HUMAN OCCUPATION AND CHANGING ENVIRONMENTS DURING THE MIDDLE TO LATER STONEAGES: SOIL MICROMORPHOLOGY AT THE HAUA FTEAH, LIBYA THIS DISSERTATIONIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DIVISION OFARCHAEOLOGY DEPARTMENT OFARCHAEOLOGY ANDANTHROPOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE SEPTEMBER 2012 ROBYN HELEN INGLIS MAGDALENE COLLEGE Human Occupation and Changing Environments During the Middle to Later Stone Ages: Soil Micromorphology at the Haua Fteah, Libya Declaration I hereby declare that this dissertation is the result of my own work and includes nothing which is the outcome of work done in collaboration except where specifically indicated in the text. No part is substantially the same as any that I have submitted or will be submitting for a degree or diploma or other qualification at any other university. Statement of Length This thesis does not exceed the word or page limit stipulated by the Degree Committee for the Faculty of Human, Social and Political Sciences. Robyn Helen Inglis September 2012 iTable of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................ vi Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................... viii List of Figures................................................................................................................................x List of Tables...............................................................................................................................xiii Chapter One: Introduction ............................................................................................... 1 1.1 Reconstructing Human-Environment Interactions ............................................................1 1.2 Modern Human Origins, Dispersals and Environments.....................................................2 1.3 The Haua Fteah, Libya ..........................................................................................................3 1.4 Cave Sediments and Environmental Reconstruction .........................................................4 1.5 Thesis Approach and Outline.................................................................................................5 Chapter Two: The North African MSA–LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context ....................................................................................................................................... 6 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................6 2.2 North African Palaeoenvironments from MIS5 to 2............................................................6 2.2.1 North African Climate ............................................................................................... 6 2.2.2 Atlantic and Mediterranean Marine Sediment Records ............................................. 7 2.2.2.1 Sapropels ....................................................................................................... 7 2.2.2.2 Dust ............................................................................................................... 8 2.2.3 Terrestrial Records ...................................................................................................... 9 2.2.3.1 Lake Cores ..................................................................................................... 9 2.2.3.2 Speleothems ................................................................................................... 9 2.2.3.3 Aeolian Records ............................................................................................10 2.2.3.4 Carbonate Lacustrine Records and Tufa Deposition .................................. 11 2.2.3.5 Alluvial Records ...........................................................................................12 2.2.3.6 Sea Level Changes .......................................................................................14 2.2.4 Summary of Palaeoenvironments MIS5–2 ................................................................ 14 2.3 The North African MSA–Early LSAArchaeological Record .......................................... 17 2.3.1 Introduction and Overview ........................................................................................ 17 2.3.2 Northern Libya ..........................................................................................................19 2.3.3 The Central Sahara ....................................................................................................20 2.3.4 The Maghreb.............................................................................................................. 21 2.3.5 The Western Desert ....................................................................................................22 2.3.6 The Nile Valley .......................................................................................................... 23 2.4 Conclusion: Palaeoenvironments and Human Occupation in the North African MSA and Early LSA ............................................................................................................................ 24 Chapter Three: Cave and Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction...................................................................................................................... 26 3.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 26 3.2 Geoarchaeology and Site Formation Processes.................................................................. 27 3.2.1 Archaeological Stratigraphy and Deposits ................................................................28 3.3 Depositional Processes in Karstic Rockshelter & Cave Mouth Environments .............. 28 3.3.1 Endogenous Sedimentation .......................................................................................28 3.3.1.1 Physical Weathering of Bedrock ...................................................................28 3.3.1.2 Chemical Precipitation .................................................................................29 ii 3.3.2 Exogenous Sedimentation .........................................................................................30 3.3.2.1 Fluvial Deposition ........................................................................................30 3.3.2.2 Colluviation ..................................................................................................30 3.3.2.3 Aeolian Sedimentation ..................................................................................30 3.3.2.4 Marine Processes .........................................................................................30 3.3.3 Biogenic Sedimentation .............................................................................................31 3.3.4 Anthropogenic Sedimentation ..................................................................................31 3.3.5 Post-Depositional Processes ......................................................................................32 3.3.6 Summary of Cave and Rockshelter Site Formation Processes ..................................33 3.4 Deposition Rates, Stratigraphic Continuity and Interpretational Resolution ............... 33 3.4.1 Rates of Deposition ...................................................................................................33 3.4.2 Site Formation Processes and Interpretational Resolution ........................................34 3.5 Conclusions – Cave Site Problems and Potentials ............................................................. 35 Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology ....................................................... 36 4.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 36 4.2 The Haua Fteah .................................................................................................................... 36 4.2.1 Geological Setting .....................................................................................................36 4.2.2 Archaeological Background ......................................................................................36 4.2.3 Dating the Haua Fteah Sequence ...............................................................................40 4.2.4 Previous Palaeoenvironmental Investigations at the Haua Fteah ..............................42 4.2.4.1 Faunal Analysis ............................................................................................42 4.2.4.2 Avifaunal Analysis – MacDonald (1997) .....................................................43 4.2.4.3 Digital Cementum Analysis – Wall-Scheffler (2007) ....................................44 4.2.4.4 Sedimentological Analyses – Sampson (1967), Moyer (2003) .....................44 4.2.4.5 Isotopic Analyses ..........................................................................................46 4.2.5 Summary: Previous Palaeoenvironmental Work and Occupation in the Haua Fteah ..........................................................................................................................46 4.3 Methodology .......................................................................................................................... 49 4.3.1 Scales of Investigation ...............................................................................................49 4.3.2 Bulk Sedimentological Analyses ...............................................................................51 4.3.2.1 Particle Size Analysis ...................................................................................53 4.3.2.2 Magnetic Susceptibility ................................................................................53 4.3.2.3 Percent Calcium Carbonate (%CaCO 3 ) .......................................................55 4.3.2.4 Percent Loss on Ignition, Organics (%LOI) ................................................55 4.3.3 Soil Micromorphology ..............................................................................................55 4.4 Summary................................................................................................................................ 56 Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses .................................................. 57 5.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 57 5.2 Sediment Sequence Overview ............................................................................................. 57 5.2.1 General Field Observations .......................................................................................57 5.2.2 The Haua Fteah Sediment Sequence .........................................................................58 5.3 The Haua Fteah Sediments in Context – Analogue Samples ........................................... 61 5.3.1 Soils on the Jebel Akhdar ..........................................................................................61 5.3.2 The Origin of Terra Rossa Soils: Saharan Dust or Weathered Limestone?...............65 5.3.2.1 The Haua Fteah Limestone Residue .............................................................66 5.3.2.2 Aeolian Analogues: The Al Mechili Palaeolake and Matmata Loess ........ 66 5.3.2.3 Aeolian Parent Material for the Jebel Akhdar Soils? ..................................70 5.3.3 Analogues and the Haua Fteah Samples ....................................................................71 iii 5.4 Bulk Sedimentology in the Haua Fteah ............................................................................. 72 5.4.1 General Overview ......................................................................................................72 5.4.1.1 Particle size ..................................................................................................72 5.4.1.2 %CaCO 3 .......................................................................................................75 5.4.1.3 Magnetic Susceptibility ................................................................................75 5.4.1.4 %LOI Organics ...........................................................................................76 5.4.1.5 Correlations Between Sedimentological Variables in the Haua Fteah ........76 5.4.1.6 Preliminary Sedimentological Hypotheses ...................................................77 5.4.2 Temporal Trends in Bulk Sedimentology ..................................................................77 5.4.2.1 % Loss on Ignition (Organics) .....................................................................78 5.4.2.2 %CaCO 3 .......................................................................................................80 5.4.2.3 Magnetic Susceptibility ................................................................................82 5.4.3 Bulk Sedimentology: Synthesis .................................................................................85 5.5 Bulk Sedimentological Analyses: Conclusions .................................................................. 88 Chapter Six: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five ............ 89 6.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 89 6.2 Key Micromorphological Features ..................................................................................... 89 6.2.1 Microstructure ...........................................................................................................89 6.2.1.1 Massive .........................................................................................................89 6.2.1.2 Granular .......................................................................................................90 6.2.1.3 Vughy ............................................................................................................90 6.2.1.4 Subangular Blocky .......................................................................................90 6.2.2 Coarse Material..........................................................................................................90 6.2.2.1 Quartz and Feldspars ...................................................................................91 6.2.2.2 Limestone and Speleothem Fragments .........................................................91 6.2.3 Fine Material..............................................................................................................91 6.2.3.1 Colour ...........................................................................................................91 6.2.3.2 Texture .........................................................................................................92 6.2.4 b-fabric.......................................................................................................................92 6.2.4.1 Speckled ........................................................................................................92 6.2.4.2 Striated ........................................................................................................93 6.2.4.3 Crystallitic ....................................................................................................93 6.2.4.4 Undifferentiated ............................................................................................93 6.2.5 Textural Pedofeatures ................................................................................................94 6.2.5.1 Fine Material Laminations ...........................................................................94 6.2.5.2 Crusts ...........................................................................................................94 6.2.5.3 Coatings and Infillings .................................................................................95 6.2.6 Crystalline Pedofeatures ............................................................................................95 6.2.6.1 Calcitic Hypocoatings ..................................................................................95 6.2.7 Amorphous and Cryptocrystalline Pedofeatures .......................................................96 6.2.7.1 Manganese/Iron Features ............................................................................ 96 6.2.8 Inclusions ..................................................................................................................96 6.2.8.1 Pedorelicts ....................................................................................................96 6.2.8.2 Dung .............................................................................................................96 6.2.8.3 Shell ..............................................................................................................97 6.2.8.4 Bone ..............................................................................................................97 6.2.8.5 Flint/Chert ....................................................................................................98 6.2.8.6 Plant Ash and Charred Organic Material ....................................................98 6.2.8.7 Vesicular Silica Aggregates ..........................................................................98 6.2.9 Micromorphological Observations from Soil Pit T – Modern Analogue ..................99 iv 6.2.10 Summary of Micromorphological Features ...........................................................100 6.3 Facies Five .......................................................................................................................... 102 6.3.1 Facies Five: Field Description and Chronology ......................................................102 6.3.2 Facies Five: Micromorphological Observations......................................................102 6.3.2.1 Contexts 528–524, North-Facing Profile ...................................................104 6.3.2.2 Contexts 523, North and West-Facing Profiles ......................................... 111 6.3.2.3 Context 522, West-Facing Profile Only ..................................................... 112 6.3.2.4 Context 521, North- and West-Facing Profiles ......................................... 113 6.3.2.5 Context 520, West-Facing Profile Only ..................................................... 116 6.3.3 Facies Five: Bulk Sedimentology ........................................................................... 118 6.3.4 Facies Five: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data. 118 6.3.5 Facies Five: Interpretation .......................................................................................120 6.4 Facies Four ......................................................................................................................... 126 6.4.1 Facies Four: Field Description and Chronology......................................................126 6.4.2 Facies Four: Micromorphological Observations .....................................................126 6.4.2.1 Contexts 517–516, West-Facing Profile ....................................................126 6.4.2.2 Contexts 567–535, North-Facing Profile ...................................................129 6.4.2.3 Context 513, North- and West-Facing Profile ............................................136 6.4.3 Facies Four: Bulk Sedimentology ...........................................................................137 6.4.4 Facies Four: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data. 137 6.4.5 Facies Four: Interpretation ......................................................................................139 6.5 Facies Four and Five: Summary Discussion ................................................................... 143 6.5.1 Facies Five ..............................................................................................................143 6.5.2 Facies Four .............................................................................................................143 6.6 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 144 Chapter Seven: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Three........................ 145 7.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 145 7.2 The Late MSALayers......................................................................................................... 147 7.2.1 The Late MSA Layers: Field Description................................................................147 7.2.2 The Late MSA Layers: Soil Micromorphology .......................................................147 7.2.3 The Late MSA Layers: Bulk Sedimentology...........................................................160 7.2.4 The Late MSA Layers: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentology and Micromorphological Data.................................................................................................160 7.2.5 The Late MSA Layers: Interpretation ......................................................................162 7.3 Layer XXV .......................................................................................................................... 168 7.3.1 Layer XXV: Field Description.................................................................................168 7.3.2 Layer XXV: Soil Micromorphology........................................................................168 7.3.2.1 Contexts 497–496, West-Facing Profile .....................................................168 7.3.2.2 Contexts 495=470 to 493=458, West- and North-Facing Profiles ...........171 7.3.2.3 Context 491, West-Facing Profile ..............................................................180 7.3.3 Layer XXV: Bulk Sedimentological Data ...............................................................182 7.3.4 Layer XXV: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data ...................................................................................................................................182 7.3.5 Layer XXV: Interpretation ......................................................................................183 7.4 The Early Dabban Layers ................................................................................................. 188 7.4.1 The Early Dabban Layers: Field Descriptions.........................................................188 7.4.2 The Early Dabban Layers: Soil Micromorphology .................................................188 7.4.2.1 Context 490, West-Facing Profile ...............................................................188 7.4.2.2 Context 457, North-Facing Profile .............................................................191 v7.4.2.3 Context 445=453+455, West- and North-Facing Profile ......................... 192 7.4.2.4 Context 442=466+430+449+461, West- and North-Facing Profiles ....... 196 7.4.3 The Early Dabban Layers: Bulk Sedimentological Data .........................................203 7.4.4 The Early Dabban Layers: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Soil Micromorphological Data.................................................................................................203 7.4.5 The Early Dabban Layers: Interpretation ............................................................... 204 7.5 Facies Three: Summary Discussion and Interpretation ................................................ 211 Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSABurning Features... 212 8.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................212 8.2 Feature 600 .........................................................................................................................212 8.2.1 Field Description ....................................................................................................212 8.2.2 Soil Micromorphology ............................................................................................213 8.2.2.1 Sample 2015 .............................................................................................. 214 8.2.2.2 Sample 2155 .............................................................................................. 219 8.2.3 Discussion and Interpretation of Feature 600 ..........................................................227 8.3 513/535 Burn Event ............................................................................................................232 8.3.1 Field Description .....................................................................................................232 8.3.2 Soil Micromorphology ............................................................................................232 8.3.3 Discussion and Interpretation of Contexts 513 and 535 ..........................................238 8.4 MSAHearth Features in the Haua Fteah ........................................................................240 Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion of the Sedimentary Sequence. 241 9.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................241 9.2 Environmental Interpretations of Site Formation Processes in the Haua Fteah Sequence..........................................................................................................................241 9.2.1 Inwash Events ..........................................................................................................241 9.2.2 Calcite Precipitation ............................................................................................... 242 9.2.3 Roof-Spall ................................................................................................................243 9.2.4 Aeolian/Dust Layers ................................................................................................244 9.2.5 Scales of Interpretations ..........................................................................................245 9.2.6 Summary ..................................................................................................................246 9.3 Sedimentological History of the Haua Fteah – Synthesis and Environmental Interpretation ............................................................................................................................246 9.3.1 Chronology ..............................................................................................................246 9.3.2 Facies Five ...............................................................................................................250 9.3.2.1 Synthesis and Discussion .......................................................................... 250 9.3.2.2 Interpretation ............................................................................................. 251 9.3.3 Facies Four ..............................................................................................................251 9.3.3.1 Synthesis and Discussion .......................................................................... 251 9.3.3.2 Interpretation ............................................................................................. 252 9.3.4 Facies Three .............................................................................................................253 9.3.4.1 Synthesis and Discussion .......................................................................... 253 9.3.4.2 Interpretation ............................................................................................. 254 9.3.5 Facies Two ...............................................................................................................255 9.3.5.1 Synthesis and Discussion .......................................................................... 255 9.3.5.2 Interpretation ............................................................................................. 256 9.3.6 Facies One ...............................................................................................................257 9.3.6.1 Synthesis and Discussion .......................................................................... 257 9.3.6.2 Interpretation ............................................................................................. 257 vi 9.4 Comparison of the Sediment Sequence with Existing Palaeoenvironmental Archives from the Haua Fteah and North Africa ................................................................................. 257 9.4.1 The Sediment Sequence and Other Environmental Proxies ....................................257 9.4.2 The Haua Fteah in a North African Environmental Context ...................................259 9.5 Implications of the Site Formation Processes for the Haua Fteah Archaeological Data ................................................................................................................. 261 9.6 Behavioural Implications of the MSABurning Events .................................................. 262 9.7 The Haua Fteah Cultural History in its Environmental Context .................................. 265 9.8 Summary.............................................................................................................................. 267 Chapter Ten: Assessment, Conclusions and Future Research .................... 268 10.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 268 10.2 Reconstructing Environments from Cave Sediments ................................................... 268 10.3 Site Formation Processes and Archaeological Sequences in Caves and Rockshelters271 10.4 The Jebel Akhdar and North African Environmental Change .................................... 272 10.5 Environment and Human Interactions During the MSA-LSA .................................... 273 10.6 Summary............................................................................................................................ 275 References ............................................................................................................................ 277 Appendix One: Procedures............................................................................................ A1 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data ........................................................ A4 Appendix Three: SEM analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ ................................................. A13 Appendix Four: Field Descriptions of Contexts Sampled for Micromorphological Analyses ................................................................................... A16 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions................................ A22 vii Abstract: Human Occupation and Changing Environments During the Middle to Later Stone Ages: Soil Micromorphology at the Haua Fteah, Libya Robyn Helen Inglis Magdalene College Dissertation submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Division of Archaeology, Department of Archaeology and Anthropology. Environmental change has been cited as a key factor in controlling dispersals throughout human evolution. Shifting environments potentially controlled movements of late Middle Stone Age (MSA) and Later Stone Age (LSA) modern human populations during Marine Isotope Stages 5–2 (MIS5–2) bothwithin, and out of,Africa. Understanding the environmental context of the occupations at the Haua Fteah rockshelter, Libya (one of the key cultural sequences in North Africa), will allow the assessment of environmental controls on the replacement of populations carryingMSA technologies by those with LSA industries, and the analysis of their relative abilities to adapt to a range of environments. Cave sediments result from the complex interplay between anthropogenic and ‘natural’ influences, and thus potentially contain high-resolution histories of environmental change which can be directly linked to the archaeology they contain. This thesis combines geoarchaeological techniques of bulk sedimentology (percent loss on ignition organics, magnetic susceptibility, particle size and percent calcium carbonate) and thin section soil micromorphology to produce a multi-scalar robust site formation history. Through field descriptions and bulk sedimentology, it traces the response of the shelter to global environmental change over the last glacial cycle. Within this long-term framework, micromorphological analysis is used to examine specifically the conditions leading up to and during the replacement of the later MSA with the early LSA Dabban. The results demonstrate the potential for integrating such analyses into rockshelter investigations, both for environmental reconstruction as well as for highlighting the major taphonomic issues integral to all on-site palaeoenvironmental analyses and archaeological excavations. The sedimentary history of the shelter appears to show that relatively high-densityMSA occupation at the Haua Fteah during the later part ofMIS5a inmesic conditionswas curtailed by the onset of cooling in the glacial conditions of MIS4. Environmental and landscape fluctuations in MIS3, reflecting rapid global climatic shifts, were accompanied by even lower occupation density for both MSA populations and the LSA Dabban, which appears during this period, indicating that this period was inhospitable to populations with both industries. Subsequently, the occupation intensity of the Dabban increases markedly with the onset of MIS2, indicating that the Jebel Akhdar acted as a refuge during full glacial conditions for LSA populations, yet not for MSA populations during MIS4. This geoarchaeological study of the Haua Fteah therefore potentially highlights a technological advantage of LSA industries which allowed modern human populations to adapt to a wider range of environments than was possible with MSA technology, an ability which may potentially have aided their global dispersal. viii Acknowledgements My supervisor and advisor, Prof. Graeme Barker and Dr Charly French, have guided, supported and encouraged me throughout the development of this thesis, from the formulation of the project to its writing and completion, and beyond. They have kept me on track, gently and kindly providing perspective and encouragement when needed, and I have benefited greatly from their experience. I am incredibly grateful for their excellent supervision and patience over the years, thankyou. I am grateful to a number of sources for providing funding to carry out this research. My thesis was primarily funded by anArts andHumanities Research Council DoctoralAward, with additional funding from a LeslieWilson Minor Scholarship from Magdalene College, Cambridge. Fieldwork and project costs were met by grants awarded to the ‘Environmental Transitions and Cultural Transformations in African Prehistory (TRANS-NAP)’ project from the European Research Council, awarded to Prof. Barker, the Society for Libyan Studies, the Leakey Foundation and the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, with additional NERC ORADS grants for radiocarbon dating. Work in Libya would have been impossible without the support of a number of colleagues; Dr Paul Bennett of the Canterbury Archaeological Trust; Dr Saleh Agrab al-Hassi and Dr Giuma Anag at the Department ofAntiquities of Libya in Tripoli; DrAhmed Buzaiain, at the Department ofArchaeology, Gar Yunis University, Benghazi; Ahmed Sabah, Controller of Antiquities for Cyrene; Ibreike Quinhe, Inspector of Antiquities, Apollonia; and Abullah Almabruk, Hamza Abdelgader al Muzeini and many others. The late Abdulgader al Mulzeini, former Controller of Antiquities for Cyrene, welcomed us to Cyrenaica with open arms, and will be very much missed. Dr Tim Reynolds bore the destructive and sometimes disruptive effects of the micromorphological and sedimentological sampling on the Haua Fteah excavations with characteristic good humour. Dr Chris Hunt was unfailingly encouraging of my work, and always enthusiastic and willing to share and discuss his ideas and research. Both have met my demands on their time with a kindly and critical eye, aiding me immensely in the development of my thesis, for which I am thankful. Drs Lucy Farr and Sacha Jones regularly went out of their way to helpme throughout the development of this thesis, with lengthy discussions and advice on everything from data collection to careers, amidst rapid responses to my ‘emergency’ requests for obscure TRANS-NAP data. Working with them has been a joy and I am very grateful for their encouragement, support, and their friendship. This thesis would not have been possible without the hard work of TRANS-NAP members both in the field and lab between 2008 and 2011. Specifically, Sara Harrop’s unfailingly cheerful organisation skills kept the project running without a hitch. Drs Nick Drake, Kevin White and Simon Armitage all aided in the collection and discussions of the aeolian analogue samples and Saharan dust. Dr Ian Candy patiently explained to me the aspects of cave sedimentation and landscape evolution. Dr Bernard Smith fielded all queries with regards to rock weathering and the development of the shelter with a smile. Dr Jacob Morales identified various mysterious plant remains in thin section, and Drs Ryan Rabett and ix Chris Stimpson responded happily to my many faunal queries. Ongoing dialogue between myself and the other TRANS-NAPPhD students has aided in the development of many research tangents, and all have willingly shared what they can of their preliminary results; Annita Antonniadou, Kate Connell, Amy Prendergast, Hazel Reade, Natalie Russell and David Simpson. Thankyou. A number of dating specialists have been kind enough to share their unpublished data with me for the purposes of developing the working chronology used in this thesis: Dr Simon Armitage, Natalie Russell, Drs Zenobia Jacobs and Richard Roberts (OSL), Dr Christine Lane (tephrochronology), Prof. Rainer Grun (ESR), and Prof. TomHigham (14C). In particular, in addition to her dating contributions (14C shell) Dr Katerina Douka freely offered her own time and expertise in resolving OxCal queries. This thesis benefited from many informal discussions with micromorphologists both within, and outside of, the Charles McBurney Laboratory for Geoarchaeology, especially Miranda Semple, Drs Mike Morley, Ruth Shack-Gross, Richard Macphail, Karen Milek, Matt Canti and the participants of the International Working Group Meeting on Soil Micromorphology 2010, Brno. Dr Matt Canti and the staff at English Heritage, Fort Cumberland, warmly welcomed me to use their SEM facilities to analyse the ‘MSA slag’, and discussions with them were incredibly useful. The majority of the bulk sedimentological data in this thesis was collected by John Davison in the School of Geography, Archaeology, and Palaeoecology, Queen’s University of Belfast - for his patient hard work I am very grateful. Dr Rhiannon Stevens, Catherine Kneale and Louise Butterworth hosted me in the George Pitt Rivers Laboratory in the McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research during my limestone dissolution, and Dr Steve Boreham and Chris Rolfe in the Physical Geography Laboratories in the Department of Geography for the sediment analysis. Julie Boreham trained and enouraged me in thin section manufacture. Dora Kemp answered multiple queries on the intricacies of Adobe InDesign. Above all, Tonko Rajkovaca has supported every aspect of my activities in the McBurney with extreme kindness, thoughtfulness and much laughter - thankyou so much. The friendship and support of those within the Department of Archaeology at Cambridge whom I was lucky enough to work alongside made the experience great: Alex, Amy, Catherine, Donna, Emma, Hazel, Hugo, Isabelle, Kate, Lauren, Lindsey, Michael, Miranda, Monique, Naomi and Tera and others too numerous to list. Franca Cole in particular has witnessed and shared the highs and lows of the PhD experience, thankyou. Others have strove to puncture the Cambridge Archaeology PhD bubble: Emma, Christianne, Hannah andDawn. JosephineMiller has picked me up and dusted me off somany times throughoutmy university career that I cannot count them all, and I am so very privileged to have her friendship. Tom Thompson was, as ever, wonderfully encouraging, providing an often refreshing perspective when needed, for which I am very grateful, thankyou. This thesis would not have seen completion without the love and support of my immediate and extended family. Above all, my parents Clive and Kristine Inglis, and my brother Karl have supported me throughout, calming me, encouraging me, and celebrating breakthroughs at any time of day or night. I could not have wished for more. This thesis is dedicated to them, with love. xTable of Figures Chapter One: Introduction ................................................................................................ 1 Figure 1.1: Location of the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya and the TRANS-NAP survey ........... 2 Figure 1.2: Vegetation reconstructions for North Africa in present, fully glacial and fully interglacial conditions. ...................................................................................................................3 Chapter Two: The North African MSA–LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context ........................................................................................................................................ 6 Figure 2.1: Summary table of global and North African palaeoenvironmental records from 150,000 BP to present . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Figure 2.2: Locations of key sites mentioned in the text ...................................................... 18 Chapter Three: Cave and Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction....................................................................................................................... 26 Figure 3.1: Summary of potential sources of rockshelter sedimentation in the Haua Fteah, Libya . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology ........................................................ 36 Figure 4.1: Location of the Jebel Akhdar and the Haua Fteah . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 Figure 4.2: The Haua Fteah. .........................................................................................................38 Figure 4.3: Stratigraphic and chronological summary for the Haua Fteah archaeological sequence showing dominant sedimentological facies ...................................................... 39 Figure 4.4: Cultural information from the McBurney excavations ..............................................41 Figure 4.5: Percentage of coarse material plotted against percentage of Ammotragus in Haua Fteah sequence ....................................................................................................... 45 Figure 4.6: Summary of palaeoenvironmental intepretations prior to the TRANS-NAP project, and their correlations with the occupation density. ......................................................................47 Figure 4.7: Location of sample columns and micromorphological samples. ...............................50 Figure 4.8: Comparison of particle size curves from four samples from the Haua Fteah sequence both decarbonated and untreated. .................................................................................................52 Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses .................................................. 57 Figure 5.1: Examples of the main sediment types observed in the Haua Fteah......................58 Figure 5.2: Sedimentological summary of the Haua Fteah sequence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59 Figure 5.3: Views of the Haua Fteah sediment sequence. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 Figure 5.4: Map of analogue sample locations around the Jebel Akhdar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 Figure 5.5: Photos of Jebel Akhdar soil pit locations and decarbonated particle size distributions. ..........................................................................................................................63 Figure 5.6: Comparison of decarbonated and untreated particle size distributions for Jebel Akhdar soil pit samples............................................................................................................65 Figure 5.7: Particle size distributions for Jebel Akhdar soil pit samples and limestone residue.66 Figure 5.8: Photos of Al Mechili fan and palaeolake system. ...................................................... 67 Figure 5.9: Particle size distribution for Matmata Loess and Soil 8 from Al Mechili. .................69 Figure 5.10: Decarbonated particle size distributions for potential parent materials for the Haua Fteah soils compared to the soil distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70 Figure 5.11: Decarbonated particle size distribution curves for all samples from the Haua Fteah sequence.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 xi Figure 5.12: % Loss on Ignition (organics) values for complete Haua Fteah sequence. ............79 Figure 5.13: % Carbonate values for complete Haua Fteah sequence. .............................. 81 Figure 5.14: Magnetic susceptibility values for Haua Fteah sequence. ......................................83 Figure 5.15 : Summary of bulk sedimentological data and field facies .................................. 86 Chapter Six: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five ............. 89 Figure 6.1: Slide scan and microphotographs from Soil Pit T ........................................................99 Figure 6.2: Photograph of North-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing Facies Five at the end of the 2008 season. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Figure 6.3 Location and sampling of Facies Five sediments for micromorphological analysis.103 Figure 6.4 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 528. ................................................104 Figure 6.5 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 568. ................................................106 Figure 6.6: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 563 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Figure 6.7: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 524 and 523. ............................. 110 Figure 6.8: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 522. ............................................. 113 Figure 6.9: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 521. ............................................. 114 Figure 6.10: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 520 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Figure 6.11: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Five contexts .................................... 119 Figure 6.12: Photo of West-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing Facies Four .................................................................................................................................126 Figure 6.13: Location and sampling of Facies Four sediments for micromorphological analysis. ......................................................................................................................................127 Figure 6.14: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 517 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128 Figure 6.15: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 537 and 567. .............................130 Figure 6.16: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 562 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133 Figure 6.17: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 536 and 561. .............................134 Figure 6.18: Slide scan and micromphotographs from Context 513, West-Facing Profile . . . . . 136 Figure 6.19: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Four . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138 Chapter Seven: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Three.........................145 Figure 7.1: Photo of North-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing the Facies Three cultural subdivisions used in this chapter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146 Figure 7.3: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 509 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148 Figure 7.4: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 508 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150 Figure 7.5: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 506 and 507. ...............................151 Figure 7.6: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 505 and 504 ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154 Figure 7.7: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 503 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156 Figure 7.8: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 499 and 498 ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158 Figure 7.9: Bulk sedimentological data for MSA contexts in Facies Three. ...............................161 Figure 7.11: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 497 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168 Figure 7.10: Location and sampling of Facies Three Layer XXV. sediments for micromorphological analysis.......................................................................................................169 Figure 7.12: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 496 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 Figure 7.13: Slide scan and microphotographs of Context 495=470. .......................................172 Figure 7.14: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 494=459 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177 Figure 7.15: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 493=458 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 Figure 7.16: Slide scan and microphotos from Context 491. .....................................................181 Figure 7.17: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Three Layer XXV contexts.................. 183 Figure 7.19: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 490 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 190 Figure 7.20 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 457. ..............................................192 xii Figure 7.21: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 445............................................. 193 Figure 7.22: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 453 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .195 Figure 7.23: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 442 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .197 Figure 7.24: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 466 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .199 Figure 7.25: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 450 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .200 Figure 7.26: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 449 and 461. ............................ 202 Figure 7.27: Bulks sedimentological data for Facies Three Early Dabban contexts .............. 204 Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSABurning Features .. 212 Figure 8.1: View of base of North Facing Profile of the Middle Trench, showing F600 ........... 212 Figure 8.2: F600 in 2009, after removal of sample <2015> in 2008/09. .................................. 213 Figure 8.3: Slide scan and microstratigraphy of 2015 with interpretations............................... 215 Figure 8.4: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2015, Micro-fabrics 2015:7-4..... . . . . 216 Figure 8.5: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2015, Micro-fabrics 2015:3-1..... . . . . 218 Figure 8.6: Slide scan and microstratigraphy of 2155 with interpretations............................... 220 Figure 8.7: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabrics 2155:12-8/9 ...... 221 Figure 8.8: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Fabrics 2155:7-5 .................... 223 Figure 8.9: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabrics 2155:4-2 ........... 225 Figure 8.10: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabric 2155:1 ............ 226 Figure 8.11: 513/535 burning event on North Facing Profile. Scale is 1m. Photo G. Barker... 232 Figure 8.12: Slide scan and microstratigraphy of 1052 with interpretations............................. 233 Figure 8.13: Microphotographs of features from Sample 1052, Fabrics 1052:8-5. ................. 234 Figure 8.14: Microphotographs of features from Sample 1052, Micro-fabrics 1052:4-1 ..... . . 236 Chapter 9: Synthesis and Discussion of the Sedimentary Sequence ........ 241 Figure 9.1: North-Facing Middle and Upper Trench Profiles showing location of dating samples. .......................................................................................................................... 247 Figure 9.2: Dates from the Haua Fteah sequence in stratigraphic order .................................. 248 Figure 9.3: Summary of facies descriptions, bulk sedimentology and field descriptions; site formation processes; and environmental interpretations by facies; and the cultural sequence.249 Figure 9.4: Summary of environmental interpretations, cultural sequence and occupation density in the Haua Fteah as developed in this thesis. ............................................................... 266 Appendix Three: SEM analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ .................................................. A13 Figure A3.1 Views of vesicular structure of ‘slag’ .............................................................. A13 Figure A3.2 Graph comparing mean % compositions of ‘slag’ samples determined through backscatter SEM. ........................................................................................................................A14 xiii List of Tables Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses ................................................... 57 Table 5.1: Location and description of analogue samples. ...........................................................62 Table 5.2: Bulk sedimentological properties of Haua Fteah and Al Marj soil pit samples ....... 64 Table 5.3: Bulk sedimentological properties of all analogue samples .........................................71 Table 5.4: Descriptive statistics for bulk sedimentological variables in the Haua Fteah sequence.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 Table 5.5: Correlations between sedimentological variables in the Haua Fteah Sequence .........77 Chapter Six: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five .............89 Table 6.1: Summary table of intepretation of micromorphological features. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 Table 6.2: Description of percentage classes used in micromorphological descriptions ......... 101 Table 6.3: Summary of Facies Five context interpretations based on micromorphological descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Table 6.4: Summary table of Facies Five micromorphologial descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 Table 6.5: Summary of Facies Four context interpretations based on micromorphological descriptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138 Table 6.6: Summary table of Facies Four micromorphological descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 140 Chapter Seven: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Three ........................145 Table 7.1: Summary of interpretations of Facies Three MSA contexts based on micromorphological descriptions. ...............................................................................................161 Table 7.2: Summary table of Facies Three MSA micromorphological descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164 Table 7.3 Summary context interpretations for Layer XXV based on micromorphological observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183 Table 7.4: Summary table of Facies Three Layer XXV micromorphological descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185 Table 7.5: Summary of context intepretations of Facies Three Early Dabban contexts based on micromorphological interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205 Table 7.6: Summary table of Facies Three Early Dabban micromorphological descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 207 Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSABurning Features .. 212 Table 8.1: Summary table of F600 micromorphological descriptions and interpretations .. . . . . 229 Table 8.2: Summary table of Context 315/535 micromorphological descriptions and interpretations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data ........................................................ A4 Figure A2.1: Raw bulk sedimentological data..................................................................... A4 Appendix Three: SEM analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ .................................................. A13 Figure A3.2 Table of results of analysis of ‘slag’ samples using back-scatter SEM .............. A15 1Chapter One: Introduction 1.1 Reconstructing Human-Environment Interactions Environmental change has often been cited as a prime driver in constraining and facilitating dispersals of human populations throughout human evolution (e.g. Ambrose 1998; Carto et al. 2009; Finlayson 2005; Hetherington and Reid 2010). Global climatic conditions influence local environments, and these environments dictate the resources available to the populations which inhabit them. Shifts in these environments therefore impact on the subsistence choices available to these populations, and sometimes render areas impossible to inhabit without major changes in subsistence strategies or technology. The narrow Mediterranean coastal strip of North Africa is crucial in debates surrounding the dispersal of Homo sapiens populations from Africa and into Europe. From 80,000 to 30,000 years ago, major climatic fluctuations impacted upon the landscape of, and resources available within, the coastal strip (McBurney 1967). An increased ability (cognitive and/or technological) to respond to these changes, potentially possessed by ‘fully behaviourally modern’ populations assumed to be responsible for Later Stone Age/Upper Palaeolithic (LSA/UP) technology, may have been vital to overcome the environmental challenges encountered, and which would have been a barrier to earlier populations (e.g. Bar-Yosef 2002). Yet the climatic and environmental conditions in which LSA industries first developed and spread in North Africa remain imprecise, hampering evaluation of the relationships between environmental and cultural change. Models of the impact of environment on population dispersals and technological development necessarily rely on regional models of environmental change and cultural chronology to trace these developments at the regional, population level. Yet, at this broad scale, local variations in the effects of global changes due to topography or other factors which may present opportunities or obstacles to different types of human occupation often go undetected. Especially in deep prehistory, the low chronological resolution of environmental and cultural models hampers the assessment of environmental impacts on populations. It is only through detailed study of sites within their local environmental context that the relationships modelled on the regional scale can be tested, evaluated and fed back into these wider paradigms. This thesis uses geoarchaeological approaches to investigate the relationships between human occupation and environmental change at the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya (Fig. 1.1), during the Middle and Later Stone Ages (MSAand LSA), between 80,000 to 30,000 years ago. Geoarchaeology, that is, the application of earth-science approaches to archaeological questions (Goldberg et al. 2001; Goldberg and Macphail 2006; Waters 1992), utilises the necessary tools to investigate the environmental context of archaeological sites by developing models of the site formation processes. These processes are driven by environmental mechanisms, as well as by human activity (Schiffer 1987), but can supply histories of both human and environmental influence on a site to look at a site’s response to environment. The Haua Fteah is the longest sequence in North Africa (McBurney 1967), Chapter One: Introduction 2 containing cultural material from the MSAto the present, and it is therefore ideally placed to examine human-environment interactions in this crucial period. 1.2 Modern Human Origins, Dispersals and Environments The earliestHomo sapiens fossils are known fromOmoKibish, EastAfrica at 195,000 BP (McDougall et al. 2005).The ageof these fossils correlateswellwith thematcheswith genetic evidence for anAfrican origin of modern populations between 100,000 and 200,000 years ago (Cann et al. 1987; Ingman et al. 2000; Pakendorf and Stoneking 2005).Yet the Late Pleistocene fossil record is fragmented, and the spread of these humans and their relationship to, and replacement of, previous populations are unclear (see Chapter Two; Foley and Lahr 1997; Lahr and Foley 2001; McBrearty and Brooks 2000). LSA/UP industries have been argued to represent the first expression of full ‘behavioural modernity’ through traits such as symbolic expression, long-distance trade networks, specialised hunting strategies and blade technology (Mellars 1996; Mellars et al. 2007). Such innovations may have represented an increased ability to adapt to new environments, thus facilitating the global dispersal of populations carrying the technology (Foley and Lahr 1997). These industries may have come about through a revolutionary change in cognition, potentially driven by a genetic mutation c.50,000 BP (Klein 1995, 1999), yet some researchers highlight instances of these traits appearing as far back as 250-300,000 years ago in theMSA(Marean andAssefa 2005; McBrearty and Brooks 2000), potentially de-coupling aspects of ‘modernity’ from being the sole reserve of H. sapiens populations. MSA populations first dispersed out ofAfrica in a short-lived, ultimately unsuccessful, dispersal into the Levant c.90-120,000 BP (Grün et al. 1991, 2005; Valladas et al. 1988). Later, the global spread of fully ‘behaviourally modern’ populations carrying LSA/UP industries occurred c.65,000–50,000 BP (Forster 2004; Forster and Matsumura 2005; Macaulay et al. 2005; Stringer 2000). These dispersals probably took place either via the Nile Corridor (van Peer 1998; van Peer and Vermeersch 2007) or the Bab el Mandab Straits and the Arabian Peninsula (Beyin 2006; Petraglia 2007; Rose 2007), with the potential for migration into North West Africa along the Mediterranean coastal strip (Bar-Yosef 2002, 2007). Survey Area 100 m 200 m 500 m 0 50 km N Mediterranean Sea Desert Littoral Haua Fteah Pre-desert Gebel AkhdarJebel Akhdar Wadi Kuf Wadi Derna 0 300 km Haua Fteah N Figure 1.1: Location of the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya and the TRANS-NAP survey. Drawing: D. Kemp. Chapter One: Introduction 3 Environmental change in North Africa has often been cited as a major controlling factor in these dispersals (e.g. Ambrose 1998; Carto et al. 2009; Finlayson 2005; Foley and Lahr 2007; Hetherington and Reid 2010). Environmental shifts during the last 130,000 years had massive impacts on the physical geography of North Africa, with the Sahara Desert expanding and contracting in response to global glacial cycles (Fig.1.2). Humid interglacials brought an increase in habitable areas in the form of ‘humid corridors’ (Armitage et al. 2007; Geyh and Thiedig 2008; Osborne et al. 2008), allowing the expansion of populations beyond those areas previously inhabited (Foley and Lahr 1997; Lahr and Foley 1998). Periods of aridity during glacial periods appear to have produced population bottlenecks by fragmenting and isolating populations in refuges (Ambrose 1998, 2003). Population expansions and dispersals were therefore dependent either on environmental change, or on an increased ability to adapt to more marginal environments, or both. The expansion of populations carrying LSA/UP industries out of Africa may represent such an increased ability, as it took place during a period characterised by aridity across Africa, effectively ‘against the grain’ of environmental change (Lahr and Foley 1998). Yet the conditions leading up to, and during, this period in North Africa remain unclear, hampering the evaluation of MSA and LSA populations’ ability to adapt to, and potentially overcome, their environment. 1.3 The Haua Fteah, Libya The Haua Fteah is one of the key deep cultural sequences in North Africa, spanning potentially from 80 to 200,000 years of sedimentation and occupation (McBurney 1967; Moyer 2003). It is located on the North coast of the Jebel Akhdar (Green Mountain) massif (Fig. 1.1), an area which at present is Figure 1.2: Vegetation reconstructions for North Africa in present, fully glacial and fully interglacial conditions. After Adams (1997) http://www.esd.ornl.gov/projects/qen/nercAFRICA.html - Accessed June 2008. Presentvegetation 20-16,000radiocarbonyearsago, full glacial 9,000radiocarbonyears ago,full interglacial Mediterranean forest Mediterranean scrub Extremedesert Semi-desert Grasslands Savanna (a fewtrees) Scrub Woodland (open canopy) Tropical rainforest Montane forest Recolonising forestmosaic Chapter One: Introduction 4 characterised by a Mediterranean environment and higher precipitation than the surrounding desert regions (McBurney and Hey 1955). The area may therefore have acted as one of a number of refuges across North Africa for populations of hominins, animals and plants during arid periods, much as it does today (Marean and Assefa 2005), yet significant climatic fluctuations did impact upon the environment of the Jebel Akhdar during this period (Higgs 1967; Klein and Scott 1986; MacDonald 1997; McBurney and Hey 1955). The Haua Fteah is located at the crossroads between both population movements through the Sahara during humid periods, and the Mediterranean coastal strip, with coastal environments potentially crucial to facilitating dispersals (e.g. Bailey 2008; Stringer 2000). Discussion of the palaeoclimatic context of occupation at the Haua Fteah is therefore integral to our understanding of the models of the emergence and dispersal of LSA populations into, and through, North Africa. Were populations forced out of the Jebel Akhdar and Libya coastal strip during periods of climatic deterioration, as they were from large swathes of NorthAfrica, or were these environmental changes not as marked within the Jebel Akhdar as they were in the rest of the region, with the area acting as a refuge? Was there a difference between the environments occupied by MSA and LSA populations, and does this reflect an increased ability possessed by LSApopulations to adapt to a wider range of environments? 1.4 Cave Sediments and Environmental Reconstruction Cave and rockshelter sites possess significant potential for investigating human-environment interactions: they afford natural shelter and thus often have deep occupation histories which often form the cornerstones of regional chronologies, as at the Haua Fteah.As well as being foci for activity, they are also natural sediment traps, collecting and protecting environmental-driven and anthropogenic sedimentation (Farrand 2001b). The influence of environmental change on cave sedimentation is mediated by the unique situation and characteristics of the cave, such as aspect, geomorphological setting and proximity to source material (Collcutt 1979). These often complex environmental histories are also altered by populations who occupied the sites, and who deposited occupation material and waste as well as disturbing ‘natural’ sediments (Goldberg et al. 2009; Petraglia 1993; Schiegl et al. 1996). The sedimentation histories of these caves are therefore the product of a complex interplay between environmental and anthropogenic influences (Bailey and Woodward 1997; Collcutt 1979; Woodward and Goldberg 2001). Whilst it can be difficult to fully unravel these influences, when this is achieved the environmental records from these sites can be linked directly to the archaeological sequences contained within them. This degree of direct correlation between environmental and cultural records is invaluable when studying human-environment interactions, and often impossible in the case of comparisons of offsite palaeoenvironmental records with archaeological chronologies. Geoarchaeological techniques are well-suited to the analysis of site formation processes, particularly crucial in complex settings such as cave sediments (Goldberg and Sherwood 2006). Bulk sedimentological analyses can develop site formation histories linked to changing depositional environments and post-depositional alteration which can be further strengthened by the application of soil micromorphology. The strength of this latter technique lies in the examination of intact sediments, Chapter One: Introduction 5 which can confirm ambiguities in bulk analyses through detailing the arrangement, character and composition of sediments. Together these techniques form a powerful analytical approach. 1.5 Thesis Approach and Outline This thesis analyses the nature and strength of the relationship between occupation and environment at the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya, during the terminal MSA and early LSA from 80,000 to 30,000 years ago. It develops a detailed characterisation of site formation processes at the Haua Fteah in the later MSA, which is characterised by Levalloiso-Mousterian technology, and the early LSA Dabban industry (see Chapters Two and Three). This is achieved through the application of soil micromorphology and bulk sedimentological analyses to the sediment sequence. This high-resolution sedimentological history is then situated within the existing palaeoenvironmental and archaeological work from the site to trace the impact of environmental change on the occupation of the cave, and its wider implications for the respective populations to adapt to different environments. This thesis begins with a summary of the existing palaeoenvironmental data from northern Africa, both from terrestrial and marine archives, followed by a review of existing archaeological knowledge for NorthAfrica during the MSAand early LSA (Chapter Two). Chapter Three reviews the potential of cave site formation processes for reconstructing environment, discussion which, along with a review of the existing palaeoenvironmental data from the site, informs the geoarchaeological approaches employed in the analysis of the Haua Fteah sequence outlined in Chapter Four. Chapters Five to Eight present the results of this geoarchaeological analysis. Chapter Five presents the bulk sedimentological data recovered from the sequence in context of its potential relationships to analogue material, temporal trends in sedimentation and the potential implications for site formation processes over the long-term. Chapters Six and Seven focus specifically on the micromorphological analysis of the later MSA and early LSA levels with the aim of reconstructing a higher-resolution record of sedimentation processes leading up to and during the replacement of the MSA Levalloiso- Mousterian with the LSA Dabban. This record is developed further with the analysis of two MSA burning events in Chapter Eight. Chapter Nine synthesises the sedimentological history of the cave, integrating the high-resolution data from Chapters Six to Eight with the wider sedimentological trends outlined in Chapter Five. It discusses the environmental implications of the changes observed within the sequence in light of existing palaeoenvironmental data from the site. This environmental framework is then compared to the site’s occupation history to develop a model of the influence of environment on occupation. Chapter Ten outlines the conclusions from this thesis regarding the methodological considerations of reconstructing environments from cave sedimentation, and the vital role that studies of site formation processes play inmultidisciplinary investigations of human-environment interactions.The implications for the Haua Fteah environmental sequence are discussed in relation to the reconstruction of North African environments, the nature of refuges within North Africa and the understanding of human- environment interactions during the MSA and LSA and their role in human dispersals. 6Chapter Two: The North African MSA–LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 2.1 Introduction Over the last 130,000 years, North Africa has undergone dramatic changes in its environment, driven by global climatic shifts. These shifts had massive impact on North African landscapes, not least in the expansion and contraction of the Sahara desert, shifts which may well have driven, and limited, population dispersals. This chapter outlines the existing palaeoenvironmental records from north east Africa and the southern Mediterranean, before reviewing the existing understanding of the North African archaeological record and the relationships between populations and environment during MIS5–2. 2.2 North African Palaeoenvironments from MIS5 to 2 The Greenland ice cores record marked shifts in global climate over the past 130,000 years. MIS5, the Last Interglacial, was subject to fluctuations in environment (Greenland Ice Core (GRIP) Members 1993). Beginning at around 130,000 BP and lasting until c. 115,000–110,000 BP, MIS5e was characterised by warm, fully interglacial conditions and sea levels between 4 to 9m higher than present (Rohling et al. 2008). Cooling in MIS5d occurred prior to warmer conditions in MIS5c and 5a (c.103,000 to 96,000 BP and 79,000 to 70,000 BP respectively) split by another period of cooling (MIS5b) centred on c.91,000 BP (Greenland Ice Core (GRIP) Members 1993). Following the end of MIS5a, the global climate began to deteriorate steadily, withMIS4marked by a global temperature drop of -10°C (Lowe &Walker 1997). MIS3, from 58,000 to 23,000 BP and which lacked the prolonged low temperatures of MIS4, was characterised by a general cooling and rapid temperature fluctuations such as the Dansgaard/Oeschger cycles and Heinrich events (Andersen et al. 2006; Bond et al. 1992, 1993; Dansgaard et al. 1993; Heinrich 1988; Hemming 2004). These were mirrored by gradually falling, but markedly fluctuating, sea levels towards the onset of MIS2 and the LGM (Lambeck and Chappell 2001; Siddall et al. 2003). The LGM, c.18,000 BP, was characterised by low temperatures and sea levels of up to -123m below present levels (Hanebuth et al. 2009). This review will first outline the present physical geography of North Africa, and the climatic systems which control its environment. The impact of these global shifts on the marine record from around North Africa will then be considered to provide an overview of regional change, prior to examination of the terrestrial record of these changes from Northeast Africa. 2.2.1 North African Climate The climate of North Africa is influenced by the interactions between the Inter Tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ), Atlantic circulation, and low-latitude monsoon systems (Almogi-Labin et al. 2004). In the Hadley Cell circulation, insolation at the equator warms air, increasing its capacity to hold moisture. This moist, warm air rises and cools, with the moisture precipitated out as cloud and rain over the equatorial regions (Williams et al. 1997). The cool, dry air then descends over the tropics, where it Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 7 warms, before being drawn back towards the equator, collecting moisture from the land it passes over. This leads to both the development of hyper-arid tropical deserts such as the Sahara and a band of thunderstorms at the ITCZ (Goudie 1996). The ITCZmigrates seasonally: in the northern hemisphere summer, it moves northwards in response to increased northern hemisphere insolation, bringing low pressure to North Africa and intense heat over the Sahara (Goudie 1996). Similarly, in the southern hemisphere summer, the ITCZmigrates south, with a high pressure cell developing over NorthAfrica. North African climates are also influenced by the Northern European and Atlantic systems which bring winter turbulence and storms to the extreme northernmost edges of the region (Gilbertson and Hunt with Smithson 1996; Harding et al. 2009). The relative influence of these systems has shifted over time in response to changes in global circulation and climates. During interglacial periods and periods of precession maxima, the Mediterranean fronts appear to have penetrated further south than at present (Almogi-Labin et al. 2004; Arz et al. 2003) and lower-latitude monsoonal systems shifted northwards and strengthened (de Noblet et al. 1996; Kutzbach and Liu 1997; Kutzbach and Street-Perrot 1985; Rohling et al. 2002), with both systems introducing moisture to the central part of North Africa, shrinking the Sahara. During glacial periods, the reverse was true, with the Sahara expanding and hyper-aridity developing across the region. 2.2.2 Atlantic and Mediterranean Marine Sediment Records Circulation and sea surface temperatures (SSTs) within the Mediterranean, reconstructed through deep sea cores, were linked strongly to global shifts in climate and North Atlantic circulation (Cita et al. 1977; Sánchez Goñi et al. 2002). In general, Mediterranean SSTs were cooler during glacials and warmer during interglacials. Yet SST gradients between the Western and Eastern Mediterranean have altered over time, indicating complexity in the responses of Mediterranean circulation to global changes (Bethoux and Gentili 1996; Hayes et al. 2005; Hayes et al. 1999). 2.2.2.1 Sapropels The marine record in the Mediterranean basin is characterised by sapropels, layers of black, organic- rich sediments (de Lange and Haven 1983; Rohling 1994; Rossignol-Strick 1985, 1995). They are formed by an increased primary productivity of marine organisms and stagnation of deep water which preserves organic matter through a lack of oxygen on the sea bed (Krom et al. 2002; Rohling and Thunell 1999; Rossignol-Strick et al. 1982; Thomson et al. 1999). A reduction in the excess of evaporation over freshwater input in the Mediterranean allows the development of a freshwater ‘cap’ over the more dense saline water (Rohling 1994), yet the mechanism of freshwater influx which this requires has been debated (Cramp and O’Sullivan 1999). One model emphasises the role of polar ice cap meltwater entering theAtlantic during deglaciations, thus altering the salinity balance between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic, and allowing less-saline Atlantic water to flow into the Mediterranean (Béthoux and Pierre 1999). Yet sapropels were not always formed during deglaciations (Cramp and O’Sullivan 1999), and were laid down in both glacial and interglacial conditions (Kallel et al. 2000) with SSTs at the time of formation varying by up to 8˚C (Emeis et al. 1998). Substantial research has Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 8 highlighted the role of the Indian Monsoon driving increased freshwater input through Nile runoff (Osborne et al. 2010; Rossignol-Strick 1983, 1985), and formation of the youngest sapropel, S1 (~9– 6000 BP), has been linked to high Nile discharge through Nd isotopic ratios (Freydier et al. 2001), and salinity levels (Sperling et al. 2003). Yet freshwater input may also be linked to an intensification of Atlantic Westerlies transporting moisture to the Mediterranean (Rohling 1994). Given variability in sapropel characteristics, it is probable that there are multiple drivers for increased freshwater input (Bethoux and Gentili 1996), with significant differences in the Eastern and Western Mediterranean sapropel records potentially indicating different freshwater sources (Cramp and O’Sullivan 1999; Martínez-Ruiz et al. 2003). Five sapropels are documented from interglacial and glacial periods in MIS5–1. Interglacial sapropels are characterised by an increase in tree pollen, and glacial sapropels by a predominance of Artemesia indicating a more open environment (Cheddaidi and Rossignol-Strick 1995). S3, S4 and S5 were all deposited during MIS5. S5 is the thickest, with a warm-water faunal assemblage indicated from microfossils (Cramp and O’Sullivan 1999) and high oak pollen percentages (Rossignol-Strick 1983), whilst S3 and S4 contain semi-arid pollen assemblages between those expected from ‘glacial’ and ‘interglacial’ sapropels (Bar-Matthews et al. 2000; Rossignol-Strick 1983). A very thin S2 was deposited during MIS3 (Rossignol-Strick 1983, 1995, 1999) potentially around 54,000 BP (Bar- Matthews et al. 2000). All of the sapropels from this period appear to show progressive establishment of humid conditions in the Mediterranean rather than abrupt environmental change (Melki et al. 2010). Although low sea levels impact greatly on the circulation of the Mediterranean, the impact of changing sea levels on conditions for sapropel formation remains poorly understood (Löwemark et al. 2006). Whilst lower sea levels may impact sea floor ventilation and produce good conditions for sapropel formation, S2, formed during a period in which sea levels were up to -50m below present, is not well-developed, probably as it correlates with only a minor insolation maxima (Capozzi et al. 2009). Sapropel formation therefore appears to be linked to periods of rainfall increase around North Africa, the Mediterranean and the Levant, driven by fluctuations in global climatic systems, both in glacial and interglacial environments. 2.2.2.2 Dust Dust deposition in marine sediments off the Atlantic coast of Africa and in theWestern Mediterranean traces changes in Saharan humidity, reflecting broad-scale changes in aeolian sediment availability driven by a loss of vegetation as well as potentially increased storminess (Bozzano et al. 2002), and recording change on both long-term and millennial scales (Jullien et al. 2007). Dust deposition in marine cores from the Alboran Sea, Western Mediterranean, between 48,000 and 28,000 BP indicates a sporadically arid Sahara, with dust transported by increased winds during cool Dansgaard/Oeschger and Heinrich events (Cacho et al. 2001, 2006; Frigola et al. 2007, 2008; Moreno et al. 2002, 2004, 2005). These short-term environmental shifts were also detected in pollen and clay mineralogy of the cores (Bout-Roumazeilles et al. 2007). Dust minima in EasternMediterranean cores Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 9 showed periods of enhanced humidity in North Africa, linked potentially to the northwards migration of the African monsoon during northern hemisphere insolation maxima (Larrasoaña et al. 2003). Atlantic cores also record dust minima linked to humid periods, with higher winter rainfall, during MIS5e (as well as millennial-scale fluctuations during MIS4-2), as well as abrupt expansions (and retreat) of Saharan grassland vegetation during MIS5a and c (Tjallingii et al. 2008). Pollen records from the Atlantic also indicate an expansion in Mediterranean-type pollen during MIS5, and a general reduction in the Mediterranean belt between 55,000 to 40,000 BP, indicating increased aridity inNorth Africa (Hooghiemstra et al. 1992). The marine records therefore show a strong influence of global climatic shifts on the circulation and temperature of the Mediterranean, as well as tracing periods of aridity and humidity within North Africa, sometimes on a millennial scale. 2.2.3 Terrestrial Records 2.2.3.1 Lake Cores Lake sediment records are very rare in the Mediterranean and North Africa, yet cores from the Lago di Monticchio, Italy, have provided a pollen record of Mediterranean vegetation over the last glacial cycle (Allen et al. 1999). Dated by varve counting, the onset of the Last Interglacial at 127,200 BP in theMediterranean is marked by an increase in forest cover (Allen and Huntley 2009), with interstadials characterised by wooded steppe biomes containing a range of temperate trees. A temperate, deciduous tree-dominated biome was reconstructed between 101,700 and 86,800 BP (potentially MIS5c), and 84,200 to 72,000 BP (potentially MIS 5a) (Allen et al. 1999, 2000), whilst MIS5b (86,800 to 84,300 BP), MIS2 and the LGM (25,900 to 14,300 BP) and other stadials were characterised by steppic environments. The Monticchio record therefore shows warmer, humid conditions across the Mediterranean during interglacials and interstadials, and general cooling during glacials and stadials. 2.2.3.2 Speleothems TheLevantinespeleothemisotopicrecordisakeyenvironmentalarchivefortheSouthernMediterranean. Speleothem records from Soreq Cave, Israel, record enhanced rainfall during MIS5 between 124,000 and 119,000 BP, 108,000 and 100,000 BP, 85,000 and 79,000 BP and during MIS3 between 55,000 and 52,000 BP (Bar-Matthews et al. 1997, 1999, 2000). The period between 60,000 and 17,000 BP is characterised by alternating cool and warm peaks which correlate with Heinrich events, yet not all Heinrich events were recorded in the speleothems (Bar-Matthews et al. 1999), indicating that the Mediterranean climate was not solely linked to global and Atlantic shifts. These trends were largely mirrored in discontinuous speleothem records from Ma’ale Efrayim Cave, Palestinian Territories, though deposition ceased during both the Last Interglacial and the LGM, indicating variable controls on speleothem formation (Vaks et al. 2003). Speleothems in the Negev Desert, Southern Israel, show humidity both in interglacial conditions during MIS5 (137,000 to 123,000 BP and 84,000 to 77,000 BP), as well as in glacial conditions in MIS4 to 2 (between 76,000 and 25,000 BP and between 23,000 and 13,000 BP) (Vaks et al. 2006). Whilst a number of these periods correlate with increased Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 10 monsoon activity, other periods of increased monsoonal activity are not recorded, indicating that local variation may have left the Negev arid during some periods of increased monsoon activity (Vaks et al. 2006). Similar periods of aridity during interglacials and humidity during glacials are also shown from speleothems in a number of caves near to the Dead Sea (Sorin et al. 2010). The Levant speleothem record therefore shows local variability in the timing and extent of speleothem deposition, indicating the moderation of wider regional trends in aridity or humidity by more localised landscape featrues such as mountains creating rain shadows. Whilst the Soreq record remains the key environmental sequence in the Levant due to its duration and resolution, it cannot be automatically correlated to environmental changes observed elsewhere in the Southwest Mediterranean without consideration of these factors due to the local nature of the controls on speleothem deposition. 2.2.3.3 Aeolian Records Aeolian records are key markers of environmental change in arid and semi-arid environments (Glennie 1987). As discussed in Section 2.2.2.2, the mobilisation of aeolian sediment fluctuated widely over glacial cycles, with major periods of mobilisation and deposition during glacials (Swezey 2001). In the Jebel Gharbi, Libya, two major phases of Pleistocene aeolian sedimentation were dated by stratigraphy, regional correlations, archaeological deposits and 14C to MIS4 and to <21,610–20,090 cal. BP but >20,140–19,510 cal. BP (MIS2) (Giraudi 2005). Fluctuating aeolian sedimentation with a Saharan source during MIS3was identified on Lampedusa Island off the Tunisian Coast from >40,840 ± 720 bp until <35,960 ± 1300 bp (Giraudi 2004) (14C, uncal.). This was followed by pedogenesis and humidity from 30,190 ± 280 bp to 28,920 ± 560 bp (14C uncal.), and resumed aeolian deposition began before 23,590 ± 110 bp (14C uncal.), and ended after 22,120–21,050 cal. BP. The Matmata Plateau loess deposits, Tunisia, have been the focus of investigation into ‘desert loess’ (Coudé-Gaussen 1987, 1990; Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1988; Dearing et al. 2001; Dearing et al. 1996). Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon (1988) posited that aeolian-transported material from the nearby Great Erg was trapped by a denseMediterranean steppe during pluvial periods (Coudé-Gaussen 1990). This mesic environment, they argued, was created through the southwards movement of European depressions during ice advances, bringing rainfall to the edges of the Sahara. Dust generation and transport were then driven by intensification of Saharan winds over the Great Erg (Coudé-Gaussen 1990). Palaeosols within the loess, dated to 22,000 to 20,000 BP and 32,000 to 27,000 BP, (Coudé- Gaussen andRognon 1988), thus indicated periods of slope stabilisationwithin awider regime of Late Pleistocene humidity, rather than substantial increases in humidity. This model has been challenged by Dearing et al. (1996, 2001), who proposed that loess deposition was indeed driven by aridity, as maximum deposition took place between 20,000 and 15,000 BP, correlating with the LGM when most of North Africa was arid. Southward migration of European depressions bringing moisture during glacials would have been buffered in the area by increased wind strength over the Sahara (Dearing et al. 1996). Utilising magnetic susceptibility as a precipitation proxy, they identified an overall wetter period between 25,000 and 40,000 BP, with two distinct humid phases c.30,000 and 25,000 BP in MIS3. Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 11 The terrestrial aeolian records in NorthAfrica broadly complement that of the sea cores and speleothem records, with aeolian transport accompanying aridity in stadials and glacials. Yet they also record smaller-scale fluctuations in humidity within these phases, and the potential variability in mechanisms which generated, transported and deposited aeolian sediments are not completely understood. 2.2.3.4 Carbonate Lacustrine Records and Tufa Deposition Considerable evidence exists for the presence of lakes and river systems within the Sahara during humid periods throughout the Pleistocene and the Holocene (Drake et al. 2008; Faure 1969; Osborne et al. 2008). Whilst Rognon identified a ‘pluvial’ period between 40,000 and 20,000 BP in the Sahara (Rognon 1987), subsequent reviews and re-dating have identified two main phases of Saharan palaeolake development during MIS5e and the early Holocene (Damnati 2000; Fontes and Gasse 1989, 1991). The Shati Cadmium Palaeolake, southern Libya, expanded at 130,000 BP during the MIS6/5e transition, pre-dating the MIS5e climatic optimum, with potentially two more limited phases of lake development around 90,000 BP and 40,000 BP (Gaven et al. 1981). MIS5 high stands were recorded from Lake Megafezzan, southern Libya, c.100,000–110,000 BP (OSL) (Armitage et al. 2007), and c. 140,000–125,000 BP (230Th/U) (Geyh and Thiedig 2008). During these periods, the lakes were more brackish and reduced in area compared with preceding expansions and subsequent Holocene expansion (Armitage et al. 2007; Geyh and Thiedig 2008). Lake Chad expanded during the Holocene into ‘Megalake Chad’ (Gumnior and Preusser 2007; Kutzbach 1980; Leblanc et al. 2006; Maley 1977, 2004), and may also have expanded during parts of MIS3 (Servant and Servant-Vildary 1980). These major hydrological shifts were mirrored in the Western Desert of Egypt. Travertines at Kurkur Oasis record rising water tables between 160,000 and 70,000 BP (U/Th), clustered around 100,000 BP (Crombie et al. 1997). Ephemeral lakes at Kharga and DakhlehOases have been dated to theMIS6–5e transition (Smith et al. 2004), and authigenic calcite silts at Wadi Midauwara, Kharga Oasis, are dated to c.125,000 BP during MIS5e (Kieniewicz and Smith 2007); these were potentially linked to periods of tufa development at Kharga Oasis associated with MSA artefacts consistent with an MIS5 date (Nicoll et al. 1999). Spring mounds and travertines at Dakhleh Oasis have been dated to MIS5 and the Holocene (Brookes 1993). A ‘semi-aquatic landscape’ was reconstructed for the West Nubian Basin, Sudan between 30,000 and 21,000 BP (14C). This is followed by a gap in lake sedimentation potentially due to hyper-aridity between 21,000 and 11,000 BP prior to the development of Holocene lakes (Hoelzmann et al. 2001; Pachur and Hoelzmann 1991, 2000). Carbonate deposits at Bir Tarfawi, Bir Sahara and other Western Desert localities identified three main phases of Late Pleistocene humidity: 155,000 to 120,000 BP (MIS5e), 90,000 to 65,000 BP (MIS5c or a) and the Holocene, with a lack of evidence for pluvial episodes between 30,000 to 10,000 BP. The oldest lakes were most extensive, with the latest carbonates restricted to depressions and buried channels (Szabo et al. 1995). At Bir Tarfawi and Bir Sahara, lakes developed during the MIS6/5e transition through rising groundwater, and persisted into MIS5e. Later increasing influence Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 12 of runoff on the lakes indicated landscape degradation, followed by a drawdown of lake levels in arid conditions (McKenzie 1993). Crombie et al. (1997), assigned a North Atlantic source of moisture to travertine development at Kurkur Oasis through oxygen isotope ratios, conclusions mirrored by Sultan et al. (1997) for carbonate deposits across the Western Desert, yet whilst isotopes indicated an Atlantic source for lakes at Kharga and Dakhleh Oases during MIS6–5e, influence from the Indian monsoon could not be discounted (Smith et al. 2004). The Bir Tarfawi and Bir Sahara lakes were attributed to monsoon strengthening during glacial-interglacial transitions (McKenzie 1993), and the isotopic composition of authigenic calcite silts at Wadi Midauwara also indicated a potential monsoon source to aquifers in MIS5 (Kieniewicz and Smith 2007). Massive tufa deposits inwadis are known from the JebelAkhdar, Cyrenaica. These deposits, including lacustrine carbonates, indicated a warm, wet period assigned to MIS5e on the basis of the MSA artefacts within them at Hajj Criem (McBurney 1967; McBurney and Hey 1955). From the studies outlined above, it is clear that the Sahara supported lakes in more humid periods during the last glacial cycle, specifically during MIS5e, and potentially beginning as early as the MIS 6/5 transition, but also potentially during MIS5a–c and MIS3. These lakes were potentially fed by increased moisture from the North Atlantic as well as strengthening of the monsoon systems. 2.2.3.5 Alluvial Records Records of alluvial fan development in NorthAfrica are restricted largely to theMediterraneanmargins of North Africa, and inland elevated areas. This is due partially to the predisposition for erosion and alluvial fan development ofMediterranean environments, driven by a seasonal concentration of rainfall and the presence of steep topography (Grove and Rackham 2001). Macklin et al. (2002) correlated periods of alluvial deposition across theMediterranean with cool, dry stadials, when steppe vegetation replaced forest or wooded environments. A period of stability during MIS5e was followed by major incision and landscape change during MIS5d (109,000 to 111,000 BP) and the MIS5b/a boundary (c.88,000 BP). A later increase in fluvial activity occurred during MIS3–2 (Macklin et al. 2002), yet well-dated evidence for alluvial activity in Northeast Africa is limited. Alluvial fan sequences in Northern Libya have been subject to considerable investigation yet they remain poorly chronologically constrained (Anketell 1989; Anketell and Ghellali 1988, 1990, 1992; Ghellali and Anketell 1991; Gilbertson and Hunt with Smithson 1996; Gilbertson et al. 1987; McBurney and Hey 1955; Rowan et al. 2000; Vita-Finzi 1969, 1971). In a synthesis of Cyrenaican and Tripolitanian alluvial sequences, McBurney and Hey identified the “Younger Gravels” facies as younger than the Last Interglacial (McBurney and Hey 1955). Deposition of the facies was linked, they argued, to increased bedrock weathering coupled with highly intermittent rainfall conditions similar to today (McBurney and Hey 1955: 80). Their deposition was dated to the early Würm through the inclusion of MSA artefacts. Similarly, Vita-Finzi outlined two main phases of Mediterranean alluviation, both visible in Cyrenaica, Tripolitania and Tunisia (Vita-Finzi 1969).Whilst his “Younger Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 13 Fill” was historical, the “Older Fill”, including the Jefara Alluvium in Tripolitania and the Kuf Alluvium in Cyrenaica, both linked to MSA occupation, was interpreted as being deposited during the beginning of the last glaciation (Vita-Finzi 1971). More Pleistocene aggradational phases were clarified by later researchers: Anketell and Ghellali (1991), for example, identified 6 stratigraphic units in an ‘event stratigraphy’ of erosion and palaeosols on the Jifara plain and across northern Libya. Accretion during Q1 (early Pleistocene), Q2 (late Riss), Q3 and Q4 (Würm) was followed by major down-cutting and Holocene terrace formation. Studies of Tripolitanian alluvial sequences by Gilbertson et al. (1996; 1987) afford some rare degree of chronological control. Twomain phases of alluviation, deposited under ‘torrential’ conditions, were correlated with MIS4 and 2; the older alluvium was capped by a calcrete formed during an arid phase c.40,000–30,000 BP, which contained two slightly more arid and two more humid phases. This aridity was followed by pedogenesis in a pluvial period c.25,000 BP, followed by aridity c.18,000 BP. In the Wadi Zewana, Cyrenaica (Rowan et al. 2000), alluvial aggradation occurred prior to stabilisation c. 138,000 ± 8000 BP (U/Th), followed by another cycle of aggradation and stabilisation before 42,510 BP (OSL), indicating humid phases at the MIS6–5e boundary and within MIS3. At Ouedd es Seffaiai, Southern Tunisia, alluvial fan deposition in an arid, sporadically humid, environment was documented between 70 and 30,000 BP (potentially centred on 47,000 BP), followed by a period of humidity and stabilisation (White et al. 1996). In the MaknassyBasin, Tunisia, calcretes in wadi terraces associated with humid phases were dated to between 50,000 and 65,000 BP (Ouda et al. 1998), indicating interruptions in fluvial activity during MIS4/3. Although complex and poorly-dated, the alluvial fan records from Northeast Africa appear to record periods of landscape change between those recorded by the aeolian and lacustrine records, particularly during MIS3. They are particularly key when considering the Mediterranean setting of the Jebel Akhdar and the Haua Fteah (see Chapter Four). Major rivers have also been traced in North Africa linked to the palaeolake systems which existed during MIS5. One such system, identified by remote sensing and isotopic records from the Gulf of Sirte (Osborne et al. 2008), potentially formed a corridor across the Sahara during the Last Interglacial. Another potential corridor for dispersals is represented by the River Nile. Fed mainly by rainfall in its tributaries, the Blue and White Niles and the Ataba river in Uganda and Kenya, flow in the Nile is heavily influence by climatic changes at its source rather than changes through North Africa and was influenced heavily by fluctuations in the Indianmonsoon (Williams andAdamson 1980). The terrestrial record of the sequence of various aggradational and downcutting phases are complex, poorly dated and subject to debate (Butzer 1980; Grove 1980; Said 1975). In Egypt and Nubia, two major phases of terrace were identified and dated to the Late Pleistocene, with the LateMiddle PalaeolithicAlluviation corresponding potentially to cooling in MIS4 and the Late Palaeolithic Alluviation corresponding to MIS2 (Schild andWendorf 1980, 1989, 2010). These were separated by periods of downcutting during MIS3 in warmer phases. This is complemented by episodes of increased Nile flow during MIS 5a and 5c as traced in marine sediments from the Nile delta (Revel et al. 2010; see sapropel discussion Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 14 in Section 2.2.2.1). These alternated with periods of increased aeolian input in the alluvial sediments during MIS2, 4 and 5b marking a reduction in flooding intensity. Wetter periods were recorded during MIS3, specifically c.58,000 BP and 38,000 BP. Therefore, whilst Nile flow was largely continuous through MIS5–2, the landscape around it appears to have been very variable. 2.2.3.6 Sea Level Changes Sea level change in the Mediterranean is influenced by both climate and tectonics, with such interplay leading to a generally poorly-constrained understanding of the position of relative sea levels during the Pleistocene (Stewart andMorhange 2009: 390). Global eustatic changes in sea level cannot necessarily be directly mapped onto the existing bathymetry of theMediterranean without additional consideration of isostasy and the active tectonics of the basin (Lambeck and Purcell 2005). Yet many locations in the Mediterranean have yielded terrestrial evidence for sea level changes against which these models can be tested, including areas of Northeast Africa, evidence which is key to reconstructing the local positions of coastlines. In Egypt, at El-Omayid-Burg El-Arab, a series of coastal ridges were dated to MIS 5a/c between 110,000 and 70,000 BP, and beach boulders correlating with a high stand at MIS5e (El-Asmar and Wood 2000), potentially linked to a fossil dune system from an MIS5e high stand (Friedman 1995; Wali et al. 1994, 1995). Fortunately for the area considered in this thesis, Benghazi in Cyrenaica has been identified as one of the few locations across the globe where sea levels would least deviate from the global eustatic sea level curve (Milne andMitrovica 2008), and therefore better-resolved records of sea level change over the last glacial cycle, such as exist from the Red Sea (Sidall et al. 2003), can be used in conjunction with the terrestrial records to develop an understanding of the position of the coast over the last glacial cycle.Anumber of studies have dated beach deposits in Cyrenaica. McBurney and Hey identified a 6m asl high stand in Cyrenaica which they assigned to the Last Interglacial, or an interstadial in the Würm (McBurney and Hey 1955: 62). An MIS 6/5e high stand recorded in the Wadi Zewana, Cyrenaica, was dated to 150,000 BP ±10,900 (U/Th), or 140,000 BP ± 18,000 (ESR) (Rowan et al. 2000). These reflect high sea stands recorded in the Red Sea during MIS5 c.123,000, c.121,500 BP, and c.119,500 BP separated by brief low stands (Rohling et al. 2008; Siddall et al. 2003).Whilst MIS5e saw high sea levels, glacial periods saw a drop in sea level. The LGM (andMIS4) saw a major drop in sea levels in the Mediterranean and globally, yet the position of the coastline immediately around Cyrenaica may not have been altered dramatically; Cyrenaica has a relatively steep offshore topography, and therefore a wide coastal plain did not appear during low sea stands, nor did large areas become submerged during interglacials (Lambeck and Purcell 2005). A wider coastal plain did appear, however, to the West and East of Cyrenaica during global low sea stands. Understanding of the evolution of the Cyrenaican coastline is limited at present but is the focus of investigation by TRANS-NAP. 2.2.4 Summary of Palaeoenvironments MIS5–2 The above review, although by no means exhaustive, provides an overview of environmental changes in Northeast Africa from MIS5–2 (Fig. 2.1). The nature of these changes and their impact on the Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 15 landscape of the region can be summarised as follows: The MIS6/5e transition was marked in the Sahara by the onset of humid conditions, allowing the development of palaeolake systems and spring activity across the region which continued during MIS5e (Armitage et al. 2007; Kleindienst et al. 2006; Osborne et al. 2008). This humidity was probably linked to the southward migration ofAtlantic Westerlies and/or a strengthening of the Asian monsoon, traced by sapropel development following increased freshwater runoff into the Mediterranean, and was accompanied by higher sea levels in MIS5e (Rohling et al. 2008). Fluctuations in temperature, aridity and sea levels occurred during MIS5d–a which were, overall, slightly cooler and drier than in MIS5e, and accompanied by shifts in regional vegetation to more open species (Allen and Huntley 2009) and fluvial incision (Macklin et al. 2002) but still comparatively warm and mesic in contrast to the following MIS4. Global cooling during MIS4 was accompanied by increased aeolian sedimentation and resumption of arid conditions in the Sahara and the expansion of the desert (Giraudi 2005; Tjallingii et al. 2008). A low sea stand occurred which resulted in the exposure of land to the West and East of Cyrenaica, but little around Cyrenaica itself (Lambeck and Purcell 2005). Cooling is shown in the Levantine speleothem record for this period, yet in the Negev, there are also cool, humid periods within MIS4 (Vaks et al. 2006), showing regional variability in precipitation during this period and difficulties in extrapolating speleothem records to inform regional patterns. The transition from MIS5 may have been accompanied in theMediterranean littoral by a period of increased fluvial deposition (Gilbertson and Hunt with Smithson 1996; Gilbertson et al. 1987), perhaps indicating a period of landscape destabilisation in the coastal areas driven by de-vegetation and alterations in rainfall patterns, as well as the dropping of groundwater levels in response to falling sea levels. Records of terrestrial sedimentation during MIS3 are more fragmented and difficult to interpret than those that were deposited under the extremely humid and arid environments of MIS5 and 4 respectively. The dated landforms from this period are dominated by cycles of alluvial fan deposition in the Mediterranean littoral with little chronological control (e.g. Anketell 1989; Rowan et al. 2000) and development of sapropel S2 (Rossignol-Strick 1983, 1985) as well as periods of stabilisation and deposition in aeolian dust records (e.g. White et al. 1996). These patchy, variable records are consistent with a global climate that varied on a millennial scale (Bond et al. 1992; Dansgaard et al. 1993) recorded in marine sediments from around Africa (Frigola et al. 2008; Moreno et al. 2004) and Levantine speleothems (Bar-Matthews et al. 1997, 1999). The present understanding of the impact of climatic changes on landscapes during MIS3 within North Africa is poor, with many of the climatic shifts acting beyond the resolution of many of the existing terrestrial sediment archives. The onset of MIS2 was accompanied by aridity across most of Northeast Africa, with dust maxima in marine cores (Cacho et al. 2006; Moreno et al. 2002) also reflected in terrestrial aeolian mobilisation (Swezey 2001). This reflected global and regional cooling (Bar-Matthews et al. 1997, 1999) which was accompanied by low sea stands, although these still did not expose large areas of land around Cyrenaica itself due to its steep offshore topography (Lambeck and Purcell 2005). As with the shift Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 16 - 4 - 6 - 8 - 1 0 -2 So re q C av eS pe le ot he m (δ 18 O ) Ba r- M at th ew s et al .( 20 03 ) 50 60 70 80 90 10 0 11 0 12 0 13 0 14 0 15 0403020100 - 8 - 6 - 4 - 2 0 2 Vo st ok Ic e Co re Te m pe ra tu re (°C re la tiv e to pr es en t) Jo uz el et al .( 19 96 ) Re d Se a se a le ve l (m et re s as l) Si da ll et al .( 20 03 ) - 1 2 0 - 8 0 - 4 0 0 4 0 Fl uv ia l Ae ol ia n de po si tio n Po lle n La go di M on iti cc hi o Al le n et al .( 20 00 ) Sa pr op el Pa la eo la ke s 50 60 70 80 90 10 0 11 0 12 0 13 0 14 0 15 0 403020100 S2 S3 S4 S5 St ep pe D ec id uo us tr ee s D ec id uo us tr ee s D ec id uo us fo re st St ep pe St ep pe St ep pe S1 Su m m ar y Te rr es tr ia lR ec or ds (s ee te xt fo rd et ai ls ) Age(Thousandsofyearsbeforepresent) NEEgypt CentralSahara Seacores Terrestrial Tunisia Tripolitania 5e5d5c5a 5b4321 OIS Figure 2.1: Summary table of global and North African palaeoenvironmental records from 150,000 BP to present. Data from Jouzel et al. 1996; Bar-Matthews et al. 2003; Siddall et al. 2003; Allen et al 2000. Terrestrial record schematics collated from references in text. Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 17 fromMIS5 to 4, this may have been preceded at theMIS3/2 transition by a period of alluvial deposition in Cyrenaica (Gilbertson and Hunt with Smithson 1996; Gilbertson et al. 1987), potentially marking landscape destabilisation following de-vegetation and sea level fall, accompanied by a move to more steppic environments across the Mediterranean region (Allen et al. 2000; Rohling et al. 2009). This review has outlined the global climatic shifts between MIS5 to 2 which substantially influenced the climate and environment of North Africa, driving major landscape changes. Yet, specifically in MIS3, the main focus of this thesis (but also throughout the periodMIS5-2), the environmental record remains patchy, and the exact nature of NorthAfrican climate, landscape and the vegetation it contained unclear. Added to this, even in the periods for which there are terrestrial records of deposition, there is potentially marked local variation in the impact of these climate scales which must be addressed in any assessment of human-environment interactions. 2.3 The North African MSA–Early LSAArchaeological Record 2.3.1 Introduction and Overview The fossil record for Northern Africa, and Africa as a whole is patchy and poorly understood, despite the area yielding a substantial proportion of the known later Middle and Late Pleistocene hominin specimens. A number of researchers have sought to group the fossils which do exist in a number of different ways, despite the fact that definition between species is exacerbated by the incremental process of evolution (Hublin 1992).McBrearty andBrooks groupedAfrican hominins into three groups (McBrearty and Brooks 2000). Group One, from 1.4 million to 200,000 years ago, encompassed H. ergaster/erectus, H. rhodensiensis and H. lousileakeyi; Group Two, between 300 and 130,000 years ago included many ‘later archaic’ H. sapiens specimens, many from North Africa, under the species name of H. helmei; Group Three, from >130,000 years ago (now potentially 195,000 years ago following the finds from Omo Kibish, East Africa (McDougall et al. 2005), contains solely H. sapiens fossils, which had largely previously been referred to as ‘fully anatomically modern humans’ although the authors dispute the use of this label (McBrearty and Brooks 2000). Other researchers have grouped H. sapiens specimens with features intermediate between H. ergaster and H. sapiens as H. heidelbergensis (Barham and Mitchell 2008: 211; Willoughby 2007: 193). A third grouping has been proposed, drawing on dating and archaeology to define the species H. helmei as ‘early archaic humans’ between c.300,000–250,000 to c.50,000 BP, and concurrent with the spread of Mode Three industries (Foley and Lahr 1997; Lahr and Foley 2001). This theory has been criticised for the lack of fossil evidence to support this grouping. Because of the ongoing nature of the debates regarding the very patchy fossil record, this thesis will refer largely to the archaeological record, and the spread of populations carrying certain industries rather than specific species dispersals. The Late Pleistocene North African archaeological record contains significant geographical and temporal variation (Marean and Assefa 2005). Distinct regional research histories and naming conventions contribute further to the difficulty of synthesising MSA and LSA records across North Africa. However, broad-scale technological affinities can be traced. The earliest North African MSA industries are similar to the European Mousterian, with classic Levallois core preparation and Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 18 flaking (Wengler 2001) and can also include a late Acheulean or ‘Mousterian of Achuelian’ tradition. Widespread across North Africa, their potentially earliest appearance at Jebel Irhoud, Morocco was dated by ESR to before 90,000 to 125,000BP (Early Uptake Model) or 105,000 to 190,000BP (Linear Uptake Model, Grün and Stringer 1991) corresponds with the arrival of ‘archaic’H. sapiens (Hublin 1992, 2001; Hublin et al. 1987) following an occupation hiatus in the area after the Acheulean. The other widespread MSA industry in North Africa is the Aterian. Named after Bir el Ater/Oued Djebbana,Algeria (Morel 1974; Reygasse 1916, 1917–18, 1919–1920), it is defined by pendunculates, unifacial and bifacial foliate points (Caton-Thompson 1946b; Clark 1993; Ferring 1975). Aterian sites have been found from the Maghreb to the Eastern Sahara (Caton-Thompson 1952), with a single site in the Nile Valley (Singleton and Close 1980) and a potential site in Arabia (McClure 1994). The Aterian has been considered as “poorly described, poorly dated and suffer[ing] in its interpretation from a number of misconceptions imposed by prehistorians” (Kleindienst 2006: 1), and its definition has been expanded by some to include technologically-similar assemblages without pendunculates or bifacial points. Considered as a potential adaptation to more open, steppic environments (Cremaschi et al. 1998, 2000), its origins have been variously traced in the Maghreb (Wengler 1997, 2001) and the Lupemban and other Central African MSA bifacial industries (Garcea 2010b; Garcea and Giraudi 2006a). The Aterian was originally dated to between 40,000 and 20,000 BP (Camps 1974, 1975; Camps et al. 1973; Debénath et al. 1986; Ferring 1975), however, recent research has dated the Central Saharan Aterian to 90,000 to 60,000 BP (Cremaschi et al. 1998, 2000; Garcea 2004; Garcea and Giraudi 2006b), dates which are mirrored in Morocco at Rhafas Cave (Mercier et al. 2007) and 1000 km © Daniel Dalet / d-maps.com 1 2 3 4 5 6,8 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 2627 Haua Fteah 28 Figure 2.2: Locations of key sites mentioned in the text. 1. Adrar Bous; 2. Bir el Ater/Oued Djebbana; 3. Bir Sahara East; 4. Bir Tarfawi; 5. Hagfet et Dabba; 6. Dar es-Soltan II; 7. Dhakleh Oasis; 8. Grotte des Contrebandiers; 9. Hajj Criem; 10. Hattab II; 11. Ifri n’Ammar; 12. Jebel Irhoud; 13. Kharga Oasis; 14. Khef el Hammar; 15. Mugharet el Aliya; 16. Nazlet Khater; 17. Ras el Wadi; 18. Rhafas; 19. Sai Island; 20. Shakshuk; 21. Sodmein Cave; 22. Station One; 23. Taforalt; 24. Taramsa 1; 25. Hagfet et Tera; 26. Uan Afuda; 27. Uan Tabu; 28. Qazfzeh/Skhul. Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 19 Mugharet elAliya (Wrinn and Rink 2003), and even earlier (110,000 BP) at Dar es-Soltan II,Morocco (Barton et al. 2009). Although originally considered as a terminal phase of the MSA, this re-dating has added weight to the possibility of a more complex relationship between the industries (Wengler 2010). The dating of tanged pieces at Ifri n’Ammar to 145,000 ± 9,000 BP(TL), and early occurrences of tanged pieces elsewhere in the region outline the complexity in the definition of the Aterian as a distinct cultural and chronological unit (Richter et al. 2010). There is little concrete evidence for the Aterian after 39,000 BP (Barton et al. 2007). Many areas of North Africa experienced a hiatus in occupation after c.60,000–50,000 BP (Barham and Mitchell 2008; Wendorf and Schild 1992), yet occupation during MIS3 was recorded in some areas e.g. the LSA Dabban in Cyrenaica c.40,000 BP (McBurney 1967). The development of these industries remains unclear, and they were later replaced in the Maghreb and Libyan coast with the LSA Iberomaurusian (Close 1986). A microlithic industry containing backed bladelets (Irish 2000; Pallary 1909), the first appearance of the Iberomaurusian is dated to 20,600 ± 500 bp (14C) at Tamar Hat, Ageria (Saxon et al. 1974), and it appears to have persisted until 8,900 ± 1100 BP (TL) at Hattab Cave, Morocco (Barton et al. 2008). The following sections examine the regional chronologies within North Africa within this wider framework of the MSAand LSA; local names for the industries will be employed for consistency with the published material. 2.3.2 Northern Libya The Jebel Akhdar, Cyrenaica, Northern Libya, may have been a refuge for populations within North Africa during periods of environmental stress, and the Haua Fteah cave, on the north coast of the Jebel Akhdar, contains one of the deepest cultural chronologies in North Africa. Containing industries from the MSAto the present (Barker et al. 2007a; McBurney 1967; Moyer 2003), the sequence may include between 80,000 to 200,000 years of sedimentation (currently under revision by TRANS-NAP, see Chapters Four and Nine). The MSAsequence contains the ‘Libyan Pre-Aurignacian’, a blade-flake industry dating to 80–65,000 BP(McBurney1967),which isoverlainbyMSAassemblagesdefinedas ‘classicLevalloiso-Mousterian’ associated with ‘archaic’ modern human remains similar to those of Jebel Irhoud (Hublin 1992, 2001; McBurney 1967; McBurney et al. 1952, 1953). Similar Mousterian artefacts were recovered from Hajj Criem, Cyrenaica, preserved within lacustrine deposits (McBurney and Hey 1955). Towards the top of the MSA, a potential Aterian influence was noted (McBurney 1967: 131; 1975), but remains contentious as no pendunculates or bi- or uni-facial points were recorded. There are no stratified Aterian assemblages in Cyrenaica, yet single tanged points were found at Ras Aamer (McBurney and Hey 1955: 144) and close to the Haua Fteah (T. Reynolds, pers. comm. 2008), and Aterian material was found on the talus of Hagfet et Tera (McBurney and Hey 1955). The Cyrenaican MSA is replaced by the LSADabban, an industry restricted to the Haua Fteah where it is dated as beginning c.40,000 and continuing to 15,000 BP (14C, McBurney 1967), and Hagfet et Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 20 Dabba (McBurney and Hey 1955). It contains chamfered blades reminiscent of the northern Levantine Upper Palaeolithic, interpreted as marking a population migration from Southwest Asia along the Mediterranean coast to Cyrenaica (McBurney 1967: 327). Yet the distinctiveness of the Dabban from the underlying layers has been the subject of debate with some arguing for simply a shift in activities driving the changes observed in the lithic assemblage (Garcea 2010b), with only the chamfered blades and burins truly representing novel tool forms (Marks 1975). The use of chamfered blades to trace population movements from the Levant is also hampered when it is considered that they are not known from the southern Levant, directly in the path of the proposed ‘dispersal’(Bar-Yosef andBelfer-Cohen 2010). Such apparent isolation of the Dabban from the Levant may be a product of a population dispersals through now-submerged coastal areas along the coast of Egypt which were present during low sea stands (Lambeck and Purcell 2005) yet a lack of data hampers the understanding of the exact nature and origin of the Dabban.At both sites, theDabban is succeeded by the ‘EasternOranian’, from c.14,000 to 10,000 BP, a regional Iberomaurusian variant also known from Hagfet et Tera, Cyrenaica (Close 1986). Whilst probably not continuous, it appears from the Haua Fteah that occupation of Cyrenaica was less disrupted than occupational histories in the rest of North Africa, and that the area may have served as a ‘refuge’ for populations in the past. The semi-arid Jebel Gharbi, Tripolitania, northwestern Libya, situated between the coast and the northern edge of the Sahara, contains Mousterian and Aterian occupations clustered around springs (Garcea and Giraudi 2006b; Giraudi 2005). The earliest Mousterian occupation, in humid conditions, has been stratigraphically dated between 128,000 and 71,000 BP at Jado (Barich et al. 2003).Aeolian sedimentation, ascribed to between 70,000 and 58,000 BPand c.20,000BP and correlatedwith aridity during MIS4 and 2, brackets the terminal MSAAterian occupations between MIS4 and >30,000 BP (Barich et al. 2006; Giraudi 2005).Aterian assemblages at Ras el Wadi are containedwithin sediments indicative of a moderately arid environment, with hyper-aridity probably eventually forcing the abandonment of the Jebel (Barich 2006). An undated Aterian assemblage was also recovered from alluvial deposits in Wadi Ghan, Tripolitania (McBurney and Hey 1955: 225–9). Re-population by LSA groups with bladelet industries occurred in the Jebel Gharbi at Ras el Wadi at 27,310 ± 320 bp, and at Shakshuk at 24,740 ± 140 bp and 30,870 ± 200 bp (14C, Barich et al. 2006; Garcea 2004). After another hiatus, these groups were later replaced by Iberomaurusian populations around 15,000 BP, during a period of climatic amelioration (Barich et al. 2006). Population of the Jebel Gharbi therefore appears strongly linked to environmental variation, but also indicates that the area was sporadically inhabitable during MIS3. 2.3.3 The Central Sahara The Tadrat Acacus, Southwest Libya, contains both Mousterian and Aterian occupation (Cremaschi and di Lernia 1995; Garcea 1995). The Aterian at Uan Tabu rockshelter was dated to 61,000±10,000 BP (OSL), whilst at Uan Afuda rockshelter, a layer containing ephemeral occupation was dated to 70,000 ± 9500 BP or 73,000 ± 1000 BP (TL), and 69,000 ± 7000 BP (OSL) (Cremaschi et al. 1998), bounded by an underlying date of 90,000 ± 1000 BP (OSL). This assemblage, stratigraphically Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 21 and typologically equivalent to the Uan Tabu Aterian (Cremaschi and di Lernia 1995: 184), lacked pendunculates or bifacial foliates usually necessary for definition asAterian.Alack of these type fossils, it was argued, potentially represented functional variation within the Aterian (Cremaschi et al. 1998). Whilst there are technological affinities between theAterian and the underlying, undated, Mousterian at Uan Tabu, the Aterian contains higher quality raw material and bone technology (Cremaschi et al. 1998). Occupation of the Tadrat Acacus appears to have been heavily climate-controlled: whilst Aterian occupation took place in a moderately arid phase, subsequent hyper-aridity resulted in the depopulation of the area until the Holocene despite the presence of aquifer-fed springs (Garcea 2004; Garcea and Giraudi 2006b). Similar occurrences of MSA industries, including Aterian assemblages, have been reported along with LSA industries from the Ubari Sand Sea and Messak Settafet, Southwest Libya, associated with palaeolake deposits that are currently undated (Lahr et al. 2008, 2009, 2010; Mattingley et al. 2007). The Adrar Bous, Aïr Massif, Central Niger documents (undated) Mousterian occupations in swampy conditions overlain by Aterian assemblages associated with a slightly drier environment (Clark 1993). Both industries were made by highly mobile populations, which may have seasonally disaggregated, aggregating again around water sources (Clark 1993). MSA quarrying sites are also known from the area (Tillet 1991), and at Seggédine, Niger there is evidence for personal ornamentation in the Aterian in the form of perforated black quartzite sandstones (Tillet 1978). Following the end of Aterian occupations, the area appears to have been abandoned until the Holocene (Williams et al. 1987). The Central Sahara MSA–LSA archaeological record therefore shows occupation during humid periods, with Aterian populations inhabiting slightly more arid environments than those occupied by Mousterian populations. Hyper-aridity throughout the Sahara caused depopulation in many areas until the Holocene. 2.3.4 The Maghreb The Maghreb contains the earliest appearance of the MSA in North Africa, with Mousterian levels at Jebel Irhoud dated to >90,000 to 190,000 BP (Grün and Stringer 1991) associated with ‘archaic’ H. sapiens remains which appear to represent an intrusive population (Hublin 1992, 2001; Hublin et al. 1987). Mousterian sites are known throughout the Maghreb, usually associated with humid conditions, and persist until c.40,000 BP. The Aterian is also widespread throughout the Maghreb, and potentially persisting until as late as 39,000 ± 4000 BP at Mugharet El ’Aliya in Morrocco (Wrinn and Rink 2003). The Maghrebian Aterian also contains the earliest known personal ornamentation, with Nassarius shell beads at Grotte de Pigeons, Taforalt, Morocco, at 82,000 BP (OSL and U-Series) similar in date to those from Oued Djebbana,Algeria (Bouzouggar et al. 2007; Morel 1974; Vanhaeren et al. 2006), and the other Morroccan sites of Rhafas, Grotte des Contrebandiers and Ifri n’Ammar (d’Errico et al. 2009; Richter et al. 2010). Some sites in the Maghreb contain sequences which suggest in situ development of the Aterian from the Mousterian (Debénath et al. 1986). At Rhafas, Morocco, for example, Mousterian levels are Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 22 overlain by ‘Proto-Aterian’ and Aterian levels (Wengler 1997, 2001), with the Proto-Aterian dated to between 80,000 and 60,000 BP (most likely between 80,000 and 70,000 BP, OSL) (Mercier et al. 2007). Continuity between the Mousterian and Aterian has also been suggested by raw material procurement studies atWadi el Hajj and Rhafas, which suggests that both populations utilised similar, nomadic lifeways (Wengler 1990, 1997). It has been suggested that theMaghreb was largely depopulated at the end of the Aterian due to hyper- aridity (Debénath 2000), yet sporadic occurrences of early LSA industries indicate a more complex history. At Grotte de Pigeons, Taforalt, Morocco, an LSA industry of unknown affinity has yielded radiocarbon dates of 26,310–25,280 cal. BP and 30,070–29,020 cal. BP (Barton et al. 2007), whilst at Khef el Hammar, another LSA industry was dated by overlying sediments to earlier than 23,400 ± 1200 BP (OSL) and 21,920 ± 110 bp (14C) (Barton et al. 2005). Both assemblages are overlain by the Iberomaurusian, radiocarbon-dated to 16,950–16,190 cal. BP and 20,410–20,000 cal. BP at Grotte des Pigeons (Barton et al. 2007) and at Khef el Hammar to between 14,100 ± 60 bp and 10,100 ± 600 bp (Barton et al. 2005). The earliest Iberomaurusian date has been obtained from Tamar Hat, Algeria, at 20,600 ± 500 bp (14C) (Saxon et al. 1974). Occupation during the latter part of MIS3 and MIS2 at these sites appears to have been associated with Heinrich events andmillennial scale cooling, either through hyper-aridity forcing populations into the coastal zone, or the coast providing a corridor for a rapid repopulation of these areas following arid events. The Iberomaurusian persists in theMaghreb until as late as 8900 ± 1100 BP (TL) at Hattab II (Barton et al. 2008). 2.3.5 The Western Desert In the Western Desert of Egypt, MSA sites are almost exclusively associated with past water sources, with many areas showing discrete occupations directly correlated with periods of palaeolake recharge, and the development of tufa spring mounds and travertines during MIS5 (Issawi 1977; Kleindienst 2001; Kleindienst et al. 1999, 2006; Miller et al. 1991; Schild andWendorf 1977;Wendorf and Schild 1980; Wendorf et al. 1990, 1993). MSA occupations are widespread, containing Mousterian and Aterian occupations as well as local variants such as the Khargan (Caton-Thompson 1946a; 1952: 30), potentially contemporaneous with the Aterian (van Peer and Vermeersch 2007), and the earliest MSA industries potential overlapped with the late Acheulean (van Peer et al. 2003). Occupation episodes at the Bir Tarfawi and Bir Sahara palaeolakes took place between 160,000 and 40,000 BP (Mandel and Simmons 2001; Miller et al. 1991; Wendorf et al. 1990, 1993). Mousterian occupations during a period of rising water tables and humidity in an otherwise relatively cool and dry Later Pleistocene, were followed by an occupational hiatus and aridity, before reoccupation by Aterian groups in resumed humid conditions (Schild and Wendorf 1975; Wendorf and Schild 1980). MSA sites showed a diverse and complex economic strategy, with specific raw material extraction sites and living sites (Wendorf et al. 1990, 1993). A similar picture is recorded at the Dakhleh and Kharga Oases, where the Dakhleh Aterians may have made up nomadic groups without significant aggregation, and focused their activities around permanent water sources (Hawkins 2004). Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 23 There is little evidence for occupation in the Western Desert between 30,000 and 11,000 BP, probably as a result of the hyper-aridity which existed in the area during this time (Mandel and Simmons 2001), with populations only returning to the desert during a period of increased Holocene humidity, as in the central Sahara. The Western Desert occupation record therefore shows marked periods of depopulation, and a major link with water sources in what was always a slightly arid environment. 2.3.6 The Nile Valley Whilst the Western Desert record is discontinuous, the Nile Valley is more continuous, however, clear understanding of the Nile Valley sequence has been hampered by ongoing re-classification and grouping of sub-divided industries (Guichard and Guichard 1965, 1968; Marks 1968a, b, c; van Peer 1986, 1991; van Peer and Vermeersch 2000; Vermeersch 2006). The MSA has been divided into through three broad temporal phases (Guichard and Guichard 1965, 1968), the Early Middle, Middle Middle and Later Middle Palaeolithic. Early Middle Palaeolithic industries appear to pre-date MIS5e, whilst Middle Middle Palaeolithic industries have been classified as Nubian Mousterian (N group, defined by the use of the Nubian Levallois flaking method) or Denticulate Mousterian (K group, lacking Nubian flaking) (van Peer 1998). The LateMiddle Palaeolithic contains a diversity of regional variations, such as the Khormusan and the Halfan, which appear to date between 70,000 and 50,000 BP (Willoughby 2007). Sodmein Cave, Eastern Egypt, contains Nubian MSA occupations from as early as 118,000 ± 8,000 BP (TL), with overlying occupation dated to >45,000 BP. The presence of an MSA industry including tanged bifacial points potentially indicates an Aterian influence at >30,000 BP (Mercier et al. 1999; Moeyersons et al. 2002). A slightly different picture of the MSA is indicated from two Sudanese sites. Although undated, the assemblage from Station One, Sudan, contains affinities in raw material utilisation and technology with East AfricanMSA industries in an assemblage geared towards hunting large game (Rose 2004a). This may represent a population expansion from East Africa, perhaps during a pluvial period, and is markedly different to the rest of the Nile Valley sequence, potentially disproving the Nile Corridor dispersal models (Rose 2004a, b). East African influences are also suggested from Sai Island, Sudan, where a Sangoan assemblage overlies aeolian silt dated to <223,000 ± 19,000 BP and >150,000 ± 10,000 BP (OSL) and is interstratified with Acheulean assemblages documenting potential use of the area by different, contemporaneous populations (van Peer et al. 2003). ‘Middle Middle Palaeolithic’ Assemblages within the Nile Valley have been grouped into two main technocomplexes: the Nubian Complex and the Lower Nile Valley Complex (LNVC) (van Peer 1998; van Peer andVermeersch 2000, 2007), although these groups remain contested (e.g. Kleindienst 2006). The Nubian complex, utilising the Nubian Levallois technique, contained bifacial foliates, Nubian endscapers, Nazlet Khater points and truncated-faceted pieces. It was found throughout the Western Desert and Nile Valley, whilst the LNVC contains only the classical Levallois method and is restricted to the Lower Nile Valley (van Peer 1998). Van Peer saw the spread of the Nubian complex from the south as accompanying a population dispersal of modern humans, with the greater antiquity and spatial restriction of the LNVC reflecting a technological tradition with deeper roots (van Peer 1998; van Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 24 Peer and Vermeersch 2000, 2007). Yet the exact relationship of the technological trends to population movements is unclear. The Nubian Complex in the Nile Valley sites exhibits specialised subsistence strategies based around quarry sites that potentially mark ‘behavioural modernity’ (Vermeersch 2002; Vermeersch and van Peer 2002), although this has been challenged by Olszewski et al. (2010). Later Middle Palaeolithic industries become increasingly more localised, with regional variants such as the Khormusan, Idfuan and Safahan all dating to between 70,000 and 40,000 BP and combining elements of Middle and Upper Palaeolithic technology (Willoughby 2007: 200). Taramsa 1, a chert quarry site, contains a long sequence of material from theEarly Middle Palaeolithic to the Late Middle Palaeolithicwhich include a ‘fully anatomicallymodern’H. sapiens burial. The entire sequence is dated from 80,400 ± 19,000 BP to 49,800 ± 12,200 BP (OSL) (Vermeersch et al. 1998). The increasingly localised industries in the Nile Valley in the later MSA may show the transition to the LSA with the shift triggered by climatic deterioration and population pressure (van Peer and Vermeersch 2007). Only periodic, localised occupation is known from between 40,000 and 25,000 BP in the Nile Valley. Nazlet Khater, dated to c.35,000–30,000 BP is a specialised quarry site associated with a ‘fully anatomically modern’ H. sapiens burial (Pinhasi and Semal 2000; Thoma 1984; Vermeersch et al. 1984), and forms part of the wider LSA ‘Khaterian’, dated to 40–32,000 BP (Vermeersch 2010). The LSA Shuwikhatian follows between 25–24,000 BP (Vermeersch 2010), prior to the spread of microlithic industries just before the LGM (van Peer 1998; Willoughby 2007: 202). The Nile Valley record, therefore, shows a marked complexity in technological variation which may or may not represent the dispersal of different groups during the MSA, but which is probably in part due to the continued expansion and contraction of populations into the desert and back into the Nile Valley, which acted as a potential refuge from increased hyper-aridity during MIS4–2 in the rest of Africa. The timing, origin and spread of LSA industries remain unclear. 2.4 Conclusion: Palaeoenvironments and Human Occupation in the North African MSA and Early LSA The above review has outlined the environmental and archaeological records from North Africa. Throughout prehistory, occupation of Northern Africa appears to have been heavily dependent on water sources and periods of humidity. During MIS5, MSA populations with Mousterian technology expanded across the region and into areas which are at present deserts, moving through ‘green corridors’ within the Sahara formed by palaeolakes and river systems (Armitage et al. 2007; Drake et al. 2008), yet were still subject to fluctuations in climate within MIS5, with areas such as the Western Desert of Egypt repeatedly abandoned and re-occupied in line with these fluctuations (Kleindienst et al. 1999; Schild and Wendorf 1977; Wendorf and Schild 1980). The MSAAterian may have allowed the expansion of these ranges further than previously, with its potential adaptation to more steppic environments (Cremaschi et al. 1998; Garcea 2004), allowing the population of areas inaccessible to Mousterian populations. With theonset ofMIS4and the accompanyingaridity,manyareas ofNorthAfrica becameuninhabitable, Chapter Two: The North African MSA-LSA in Palaeoenvironmental Context 25 and were fully abandoned by populations, with areas of the Sahara not re-populated until the Holocene (Wendorf and Schild 1992). There is evidence for occupation in some areas during this period, notably in the Nile Valley and coastal areas of the Maghreb, as well as Cyrenaica, indicating that populations were pushed into refuges where environmental change could be tempered by local humidity and local water availability (Garcea 2010b). It was probably this fragmentation of populations that led to the diversification of regional industries during the later MSAwith movement restricted to corridors such as coasts (Marean and Assefa 2005). Overall aridity in the Sahara throughoutMIS3 andMIS2was accompanied by a continued abandonment of most of the central part of NorthAfrica, yet it is during MIS3 that populations with LSAtechnology spread across North Africa. Given the potential difficulties in movement around the region during the more arid periods when there was an absence of ‘humid corridors’ to facilitate such dispersals, these population movements have been argued to be largely ‘against the grain’ of environmental change (Lahr and Foley 1998), potentially marking an increased ability for LSA populations to adapt to at least part of these new environments. Increased environmental and population stress driven by the isolation of populations within refuges, potentially, but not exclusively, along the coastal regions, may itself have stimulated technological innovation within, or leading to the development of, the LSA. MIS3 was therefore a vital period in North African prehistory, yet its archaeological and palaeoenvironmental records are the worst-documented of the periods reviewed above. Rapid global temperature fluctuations during MIS3 would have had far-reaching and very locally-specific impacts on the landscape of North Africa which are beyond the resolution of many existing geomorphological records of palaeoenvironmental change, and which are difficult to tie to the highly-regional archaeological record from this period. Therefore, it is crucial to establish long-term records of environmental change which can be linked directly to archaeological sequences, in order to begin to unravel the relationship between environment and population movements during this period. In light of this necessity, this thesis will examine the impact of climatic shifts between MIS5 and 2 on the populations of the Haua Fteah cave, Cyrenaica, Libya through the geoarchaeological study of its sediments. Containing the longest cultural sequence in North Africa, from the MSA to the present, this sequence appears to have witnessed quite marked environmental change (see Chapter Four) but is relatively uninterrupted in its sequence when compared with other sites in central North Africa. The site therefore provides a unique opportunity to study the impact of environmental changes on occupation in an areawhich may have acted as a refuge, through an environmental proxy which can be directly linked to cultural changes, thus circumventing many of the problems outlined in this review in correlating offsite palaeoenvironmental records with archaeological sites. Yet the study of cave sequences is not without its problems and caveats, as discussed in the next chapter. 26 Chapter Three: Cave and Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 3.1 Introduction Studies of caves and rockshelters have contributed to our understanding of prehistory from the very beginnings of archaeology. They are sediment traps, and the shelter they offer means that they are often focal points for groups in the landscape (Farrand 2001b). Traces of past activities are protected in caves and rockshelters, building up long archaeological stratigraphies (Bailey and Galanidou 2009; Woodward and Goldberg 2001). These sedimentary processes are driven by climatic and landscape changes outside of the cave, as well as changes within the cave micro-environment, as well as anthropogenic activity (Bailey and Woodward 1997; Collcutt 1979). Because of this ability to focus activity, and to trap and preserve sediment, rockshelters and caves are key to our understanding of prehistory and the environmental context of past occupations; climate and occupation are recorded within a single site sequence. As outlined in Chapter Two, the archaeological chronologies within rockshelters and caves are often pivotal in regional chronologies within North Africa, preserving the stratigraphic relationships between industries which are unavailable from open-air sites. The interpretation of cave and rockshelter sequences are not without problems. The processes which produce the archaeological and sedimentary records they contain are capable of destroying them, sometimes in ways which are not immediately evident in the field. Pit digging, cleaning and removal of material from the cave can have a serious impact on the archaeological deposits, whilst processes such as water movement can erode and move sediments independently of human action (Butzer 1982). Caves and rockshelters should also be viewed as very specific places for occupation and palaeoclimatic preservation (Farrand 2001b); they may be used or avoided in periods of history for very culturally specific reasons, thus skewing the artefact assemblages resulting from the activities which take place within them (Angelucci et al. 2009). Likewise, the sedimentary history of a cave is representative of very local climatic conditions, with caves responding to climatic changes in very context-specific ways (Bailey and Woodward 1997; Woodward and Goldberg 2001). Nevertheless, cave and rockshelter sequences remain repositories of a large amount of both cultural and environmental information and form the foundation for many regional chronologies. This chapter will first outline the theoretical background behind the study of site formation processes in archaeology. It will then describe the potential depositional sources and processes relevant to the Haua Fteah’s Mediterranean coastal karstic setting, divided into sources of material from inside (endogenous sources) and outside the cave (exogenous sources). Finally, it will explore the issues surrounding detecting the changing rates of sedimentation and depositional hiatuses which exist within cave sediments, and how to develop approaches which take these into consideration when reconstructing environments from cave sequences. Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 27 3.2 Geoarchaeology and Site Formation Processes Site formation processes were brought to prominence in the 1970s, and developed primarily through the work of Michael Schiffer (1976; 1987) and Karl Butzer (1971; 1982). Site formation processes are the processes by which archaeological and historic records are created (Schiffer 1987: 7). He grouped these into ‘cultural’ transforms (C-transforms), the result of human behaviour, and ‘non-cultural’ transforms (N-transforms), stemming from natural environmental processes. C-transforms define the nature and timescale of discarded or deposited material, as well as later cultural modifications to sediment, up to and including excavation (Schiffer 1987: 7). N-transforms encompass processes driven by non-human agents. These act on artefacts during their manufacture, and use, before deposition and decay in the archaeological context (Schiffer 1987: 7). Therefore both anthropogenic and non-anthropogenic processes contribute to the archaeological record and influence our understanding of the past, and must be understood in order to allow wider cultural interpretations of a site (Butzer 1982: 122). Whilst the terms N- and C-transform have largely fallen out of use, the identification of the formation processes of the sites remain vital to archaeology. The site formation history involves both sedimentary processes and post-depositional alterations, and it is in the unravelling of this history that geoarchaeological techniques have been key (Hassan 1978: Butzer 1982). By identifying the timing and extent of environmental drivers in site formation processes, geoarchaeologists derive information which informs both the taphonomic history of the sediments and the environmental history of the occupations. Geoarchaeological approaches in Palaeolithic archaeology have traditionally focused on the environmental side, as the sedimentary processes which create sites during this period are usually assumed to be primarily environmental rather than anthropogenic when compared with those of later periods. There are, however, some marked exceptions of anthropogenically-dominated cave and rockshelter sedimentary environments (e.g. Sibudu Cave, South Africa: Goldberg et al. 2009). The recognition of sediments themselves as a category of artefact has been developed recently as the potential of anthropogenic sediments is realised throughmicroscopic and high-resolutionmineralogical analyses (e.g. Goldberg 2003; Karkanas et al. 2002, 2007; Schiegl et al. 1996, 2003). Humans create andmodify stratigraphy as much as they create andmodify other natural materials to make the artefacts which are traditionally the focus of study by archaeologists. These deposits may also play active roles in culture after their deposition; repeated use of certain hearths over periods of time may be linked to ideas of identity and family, or more generally to the identity and return of certain groups to a certain site (Bailey and Galanidou 2009). Anthropogenic sediments retain markers of the behaviours which led to their deposition in the same way that non-anthropogenic layers retain markers of their depositional environment. Micro-scale geoarchaeological approaches, developed over the last decade or so, can therefore be used to develop a history of the human actions that produced and deposited the material (Mallol et al. 2007). Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 28 3.2.1 Archaeological Stratigraphy and Deposits Histories of site formation are recorded within site stratigraphies. The concept of stratigraphy is core to archaeological practice, based on the concepts of deposits and depositional events (Stein 1987), and has been used to establish human antiquity, provide relative dating, reconstruct the environment and analyse site formation processes (Stein 1987: 337). Stratigraphies are made up of units which can be related to each other through the principle of superimposition, with relationships recorded in archaeological sites through systems such as the Harris Matrix (Harris 1989). These site stratigraphies are correlated between sites through absolute dating, artefact typologies and environmental interpretations to create regional and temporal archaeological narratives. These stratigraphies are made up of a series of deposits, the limits of which are defined through observable changes in the physical properties of sediments, i.e. their colour, compaction or inclusions (Stein 2001b). Artefacts recovered from a certain unit are classed together, forming an assemblage which is interpreted as a whole because they have been recovered from what has been deemed to be a distinct layer of sediment – the artefacts are brought together through deposition (Stein 2001a). These contexts are the primary division on which archaeological analysis relies, and their nature must therefore be examined as fully as possible to inform the larger narratives which are based upon them. 3.3 Depositional Processes in Karstic Rockshelter & Cave Mouth Environments The potential depositional sources and processes relevant to the Haua Fteah’s Mediterranean coastal karstic setting are summarised in Figure 3.1. 3.3.1 Endogenous Sedimentation 3.3.1.1 Physical Weathering of Bedrock Bedrock weathers through a range of physical and chemical processes, producing clay-sized particles to massive blocks (Collcutt 1979; Farrand 1975; Laville et al. 1980). Rates of deposition vary between almost continual, fine spalling of material to rare but catastrophic shelter collapses (e.g. Mallol and Carbonell i Roura 2008). Rockfall layers in rockshelter sites were traditionally interpreted as resulting from freeze-thaw processes (Farrand 1975; Laville et al. 1980) based on research at the classic Perigordian sites in Frances, such as the Abri Pataud (Farrand 1975). Later research however has highlighted other mechanisms of physical weathering as sites such as Ksar Akil, Israel and Francthi Cave, Greece which, according to independent palaeoenvironmental proxies, have not experienced freezing conditions though contain large amounts of éboulis (Farrand 2001a). These processes include: wetting-drying cycles (Courty and Vallverdu 2001); tectonic activity (Becker et al. 2006; Kagan et al. 2005); salt weathering (Cooke and Smalley 1968; Smith andMcGreevy 1983; Smith et al. 2005); and chemical dissolution (Goldberg and Sherwood 2006). The presence and type of physical weathering are dependent on the physical properties of the bedrock and its resistance to such weathering (Collcutt 1979). Above all, the periodicity, duration and intensity of cycles that control physical weathering are moderated by the aspect and morphology of the cave, which control its micro-climate. Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 29 3.3.1.2 Chemical Precipitation Carbonate deposition within caves and rockshelters results from the percolation of water through the karstic system (Buhmann and Dreybrodt 1985; Dreybrodt 1999). Carbonate bedrock is dissolved by water passing through the systemwhich becomes saturated with carbonate.When the water reaches the cave atmosphere and the solution’s pressure drops, carbon dioxide is lost from the solution, lowering the ability of the sediment to carry dissolved carbonate and carbonate is precipitated (Sweeting 1972: 177). Such precipitates may also contain, and sometimes be comprised completely of, gypsum and other mineral salts, yet the mechamism of precipitation remains largely similar. The overriding factor for speleothem deposition is the presence of calcareous groundwater; periods of calcite deposition within caves should therefore be interpreted as periods of greater effective atmospheric precipitaiton in the immediate vicinity of the cave (Pickering et al. 2007). Whilst it is usually assumed that the increased presence of calcareous water is linked to environmental changes in the wider landscape, such as increased rainfall, it cannot be ruled out that changes in cave sediments actually reflect changes in very local, within-cave hydrology potentially driven by processes within the hydrology of the karstic system independent of climatic change, such as tectonic constraints on spring activity (Rendell 2011). Speleothems and carbonate formations contain proxy environmental isotopic records, and their high resolution provides sequences which often underpin regional environmental models (Bar-Matthews et al. 1997, 2003; Vaks et al. 2003, 2006). Carbonate-rich water may also precipitate across and through cave sediments, forming flowstones and concreting sediment (Macphail and Goldberg 1999). These carbonates and the environmental records within them can be directly dated using U-series dating (Bischoff et al. 2003, 2007). This direct dating is essential in correctly dating periods of concretion of Aeolian transportation Colluv ium& slope wash Calcite precipitation Surfacewash Rockfall Anthropogenic sedimentation Animal dung Bat & bird guano PhosphatisationBioturbation Secondary calcite precipitation Residue from limestonedissolution Figure 3.1: Summary of potential sources of rockshelter sedimentation in the Haua Fteah, Libya. Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 30 sediment, and the environments associated with them, as calcareous-rich groundwater can percolate extensively through sediments to form horizons far below the depth of the contemporary floor. 3.3.2 Exogenous Sedimentation 3.3.2.1 Fluvial Deposition Water may deposit or erode sediment in caves and rockshelters as a consequence of wider hydrological changes within a landscape. Stream action, whether from outside the cave or from tunnels within cave systems, can erode and deposit sediment. The entire cave or rockshelter may be submerged by a river, scouring or dumping deposits, e.g. at Boila Rockshelter, Greece (Bailey and Woodward 1997; Woodward et al. 2001). Significant changes in hydrological action at a site may also be linked to the changing morphology of the cave, for example, a shift from small-scale ponding of sediments to full stream action and incision was recorded in Konispol Cave, Albania, during the early Post- Glacial, signaling a shift in the intensity of flow enabled by the opening of a sinkhole in the shelter roof (Karkanas 2002; Schuldenrein 2001). The nature and energy of these fluvial processes can be recognized by the size and morphology of clasts, as well as by their sorting and arrangement which mark varying flow velocities. 3.3.2.2 Colluviation Colluvial movements can introduce material into caves and rockshelters, as well as moving it around within and out of the cave (White 2007). Such movement may be triggered by gravity and water saturation. A mass movement of guano identified by Dykes (2007) in the West Mouth of Niah Great Cave, Borneo, illustrates themassive scale on which these processes can operate. Colluvial movement of terra rossa soils is common in Mediterranean caves (Ellwood et al. 1996, 2004; Karkanas et al. 1999; Schuldenrein 1998, 2001). Episodes of inwash of soils into Konispol Cave marked periods of vegetation denudation and the release of soils from slopes surrounding the cave (Karkanas 2001). Sequences of redeposited soils have been used as archives of soil magnetic susceptibility measurements which have been used to reconstruct changes in soil characteristics over time (e.g. Ellwood et al. 2001). 3.3.2.3 Aeolian Sedimentation Aeolian sediments range from fine loess-like dust to relatively coarse dune sands (Glennie 1987). Aeolian material is typically well-sorted, and can accumulate in thick layers within shelters. Layers of loess indicate periods of aridity (Giraudi 2005) whilst coastal dunes can also trace shifting shorelines (Rhodes et al. 2006). Wind action can however also deflate and rework sediment from rockshelters or open cave mouths. Aeolian deposits are also particularly useful for OSL dating (e.g. Jacobs et al. 2003a, 2003b, 2006). 3.3.2.4 Marine Processes Coastal caves may be subject to past flooding and erosion from the sea. The Mount Carmel caves, Israel, including es Skhul and et Tabun contain potential fossil dunes, despite now being 40m above sea Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 31 level due to tectonic uplift and sea level changes. The artifacts they contain have been heavily abraded, possibly by wave action during a high sea stand in MIS5e, although this model is debated (Ronen et al. 2007; Vita-Finzi and Stringer 2007a, b). When assessing the possibility of marine influences on a particular cave or rockshelter, the tectonic history of the landscape as well as the range of the sea level change in the local area must be considered. 3.3.3 Biogenic Sedimentation Animals living within caves and rockshelters can contribute to sedimentation through the deposition of guano and dung. Deposition of guano can be on a massive in scale, e.g. in Niah Cave, Sarawak (Dykes 2007; Gilbertson et al. 2005). The scale and type of biogenic sedimentation from wild animals are linked to the morphology and attractiveness of the shelter to animals. Large quantities of animal dung can also be related to the stabling of livestock in later prehistory and the use of fire as part of cleaning practices produces thick layers of burnt dung fumiers (Brochier et al. 1992; Macphail et al. 1997). Another form of biogenic sedimentation within caves and rockshelters is the deposition of human and animal bones by humans, animals and birds. The faunal records these bones constitute can be used for long-term environmental and behavioural reconstruction (and have been in the Haua Fteah; see Section 4.2.4.1, Higgs 1967; Klein and Scott), forming the cornerstone of environmental histories in archaeological sequences, yet the vectors of their accumulation, be they animal or human activity or other taphonomic processes, must be considered in any analysis and interpretation of the species composition and faunal profile implications (Reitz and Wing 1999: 9). 3.3.4 Anthropogenic Sedimentation The range of materials brought into, and depositedwithin, cave sites by humans iswide and dependent on the activities they are carrying out. Human activity may be the dominant sedimentation mode in the cave, e.g. in the case of middens (Karkanas 2002). Material may be brought in unwittingly, such as mud trampled in on the soles of feet, or specifically imported to build structures, e.g. wooden posts and large stones (Farrand 2001a). Debris from activities such as flint knapping and butchery will also accumulate within sediments. One of the primary areas of research into anthropogenic input is the use of fire in prehistory, and the behavioural implications of different durations and intensities of burning (e.g. Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998; Goldberg et al. 2001; Karkanas et al. 2007; Schiegl et al. 1996). Hearths, and the material preserved within them, inform past human activity and behaviour, such as fuel choice, hearth preparation and maintenance, as well as being a source for palaeoenvironmental information through the plant macro and phytolith remains which they preserve (Albert et al. 1999, 2003; Karkanas et al. 2002). Another key source of anthropogenic sedimentation is the use of caves and rockshelters for burial of human remains (e.g. at Grotte des Pigeons, Taforalt, Morocco (Humphrey et al. 2012)). Human agency also accounts for the disturbance of sediments e.g. in the digging of pits, burials and site maintenance practices such as building and sweeping. The incorporation of anthropogenic material in cave sediments, such as ash or dung from stabling deposits or bones (as discussed above), may also have a long-term effect on the characteristics and diagenetic pathways of the surrounding sediments (Woodward and Goldberg 2001). Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 32 3.3.5 Post-Depositional Processes A number of post-depositional processes may affect the sedimentary records which are present within caves and rockshelters. Mechanical disturbance of sediments, through cryoturbation, colluviation, anthropogenic activity, water erosion and redeposition within a cave can distort and move sediments, as well as artefacts. (Farrand 2001b). If the cave is particularly open, pedogenic processes may operate upon sediments changing their structure, and altering the properties of the sediments through illuviation and eluviation of material between horizons and potentially ‘overprinting’ the original stratigraphy. Bioturbation is a key consideration when assessing the integrity of cave sediment sequences and the environmental and cultural information they contain. In addition to the anthropogenic ‘bioturbation’ processes outlined above, bioturbation is related to the activities of a wide range of organisms, from burrowing mammals, e.g. mole rats, to soil meso-fauna such as earthworms, ants, termites and soil micro-fauna, and as well as the action of plant roots (Butzer 1982: 110; Wilkinson et al. 2009). The activities of these organisms can have wide-ranging impacts on sediments at a number of scales, from changing the structures of sediments within a layer (Courty et al. 1989: 140; further discussion of the micromorphological features caused by bioturbation in Section 6.2) to mixing entire sedimentological layers, obliterating stratigraphy (GoldbergandMacphail 2006;Stein2001a).Bioturbation isparticularly prevalent in tropical caves (e.g. Stephens et al. 2005; Mijares and Lewis 2009), due to the often quite organic nature of the sediments and high activity and prevalence of soil meso- and micro-fauna, yet can also operate extensively in Mediterranean cave settings. Such bioturbation can cause blurring of both the archaeological and sedimentological records, severely affecting their interpretation, such as in the movement of bones between Mousterian occupation layers in Hayonim Cave, Israel (Stiner et al. 2005). The impact of bioturbation can be assessed both within the field, through the observation of burrows etc. cutting stratigraphy as well as through micromorphological techniques studying the structure and arrangement of voids within the sediments themselves (Kooistra and Pulleman 2010). There are also numerous chemical alterations which sediments may be subject to post deposition. One key agent in the chemical alteration of cave sediments is the phosphatisation of sediments linked to biogenic activity, such as the deposition of guano. This can have major implications for the archaeological record, altering or dissolving bone through changes in the geochemistry of the site (e.g. Nielsen-Marsh and Hedges 2000; Shahack-Gross et al. 2004). Sediments may also become cemented through calcite deposition as well as through the precipitation of other mineral forms which may preserve or destroy different parts of the archaeological record or obscure stratigraphy (Goldberg and Sherwood 2006). Bioturbation may also exacerbate the potential for post-depositional chemical alteration through the alteration and opening up of the sediment structure, as well as geochemical changes brought about through the activity of animas and plants themselves (Courty et al. 1989: 144). Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 33 3.3.6 Summary of Cave and Rockshelter Site Formation Processes This brief review of the processes which drive cave and rockshelter sedimentation has outlined the potential which their stratigraphies contain in terms of palaeoenvironmental and behaviour reconstruction. However, at most sites many of these processes will be active, and unravelling these sedimentary histories can be complex, even before post-depositional processes are taken into account. It is therefore crucial that detailed histories of site formation processes can be developed using geoarchaeological methods, both for the examination of environmental change through the processes outlined above, but also as these formation processes affect both the nature and resolution of the archaeological and palaeoenvironmental records they contain, as outlined in the following section. 3.4 Deposition Rates, Stratigraphic Continuity and Interpretational Resolution 3.4.1 Rates of Deposition Following the identification of the site formation processes which deposited units, the rate at which the sediments were laid down must be considered. Sediments are not deposited at a uniform, continuous rate: the deposition of a unit can occurwithin minutes, such as in amudflow or dump of anthropogenic material, or may be built up over centuries through occasional, brief episodes of deposition (Butzer 1982: 70). As well as having obvious environmental implications, these varying rates of deposition have serious implications for the interpretation of stratigraphy, through our understanding of the relative length of time a certain deposit represents. Within the layers at a site there are those which are deposited more quickly than others. By identifying these changing rates, an internal, relative chronological measure can be established for the site, one that can trace areas in which our potential archaeological and temporal resolution may be higher than in others (Bailey and Galanidou 2009). As well as examining the rates of deposition within each unit and depositional regime, the assessment of stratigraphic continuity in sediment sequences is integral to the data that are used to build histories of cultural and environmental change. There is now a growing recognition by cave archaeologists and geoarchaeologists that these sequences are likely to contain discontinuities in sedimentation in the form of sedimentary standstills or erosive surfaces (Campy and Chaline 1993; Courty 2001). Sedimentary hiatuses, erosional events and truncation by humans – effectively absences of stratigraphy – are as much a part of the sedimentary history of the site as the sedimentary units which remain (Harris 1989: 70). Integration of these discontinuities has significant implications for archaeological interpretation as regional transitions between cultural units and different populations are primarily studied through deep stratigraphies. For instance, erosional events that remove material from a unit, exposing previously buried artefacts, can create potentially abrupt transitions between occupation horizons that are not truly representative of the site’s occupation history. Bioturbation of sediments, at the surface and after burial, may mix cultural material and sediments of different ages, blurring boundaries between originally discreet deposits and transporting artefacts and sediments vertically within profiles with major implications for cultural chronologies, palaeoenvironmental analyses and dating. Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 34 Previous methods to detect breaks in sedimentation have relied largely on high-resolution dating, especiallyAMS 14C dating, (e.g. Mlekuž et al. 2008), to identify sediment discontinuities and variances in rates of deposition within sites, yet the resolution offered by other dating methods at and beyond the limit of radiocarbon in theMiddle and Early Stone Age is limited. In these periods it is often more vital that integrated geoarchaeological analysis of site sediments is carried out, as, whilst absolute dating remains crucial to the construction of any site chronology, it will remain low in resolution. By considering the nature of the sediments, the rate at which they were laid down and their relation to potential hiatuses, a relative chronology can be refined within the absolute chronological framework. Detailed stratigraphic analysis is therefore integral to the understanding of cave and rockshelter sites and the cultural sequences they contain. With high-resolution approaches to stratigraphy, as enabled by the application of soil micromorphology, units which may be identified in the field as a single deposit can actually be broken down into smaller microstratigraphic units, with the interfaces they contain providing yet more information on site formation processes (Courty 2001). Interpretations of interfaces developed at a macro-scale in the field, and the sedimentological models based upon them can be tested using thesemethods (Woodward andGoldberg 2001).Microstratigraphic traces of activity taking place on these surfaces at the interfaces between the units are identifiable through their detailed spatial examination (Matthews et al. 1997). The nature of these surfaces and the post-depositional alteration (or lack thereof) of these traces, such as trampling or weathering of bone, also indicate the conditions in which the site was occupied, and abandoned. Repeated, punctuated development of surfaces probably represents repeated reoccupation, and the recognition of the duration and condition of sediments between these surfaces can refine the occupation history of the site. This is noticeable especially in the repeated re-use and cleaning of hearths (Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998; Karkanas et al. 2007; Schiegl et al. 1996, 2003). Post-depositional alteration of occupation surfaces can also inform about processes which may skew the archaeological record, such as the fluvial movement of artefacts around a site (Butzer 1982: 100). 3.4.2 Site Formation Processes and Interpretational Resolution The issues outlined above have far-reaching implications for the archaeological record.Archaeologists are very rarely dealing with material that was deposited in a single event, yet this is often an implicit assumption in archaeological analysis and interpretation which (necessarily) groups all material from a single stratigraphic unit together (Bailey 2007). Nearly every assemblage recovered by archaeologists, save for the most ephemeral occupations such as a single kill site with associated knapping debris, is a palimpsest, that is, it is the product of more than one depositional event (Bailey 2007; Bailey and Galanidou 2009). Archaeological materials within most deposits are, to some degree, time-averaged, i.e. they contain artefacts which have been deposited in perhaps a number of discrete events over the time the surrounding sediments have been deposited (Stein 2001b). Caves and rocksheltersmorphology spatially restricts the area available to occupationwithin them, and are therefore particularly susceptible to this averaging with repeated occupation. However, the nature of the palimpsest will vary according to the sedimentation rates of the site (Bailey and Galanidou 2009). If seasonal mudflows bury the site, Chapter Three: Rockshelter Sedimentation and Environmental Reconstruction 35 the occupation material within each unit will represent a restricted period of time. If sedimentation is slow, the material could represent a longer period of occupation within a single unit. By carrying out geoarchaeological investigations of the stratigraphy we can begin to identify varying sediment rates in these contexts, and then provide a robust framework for the archaeological analyses to take these changing rates into account (Stein 1990). As well as aiding the archaeological interpretation of a site, rates of deposition and discontinuities are also of importance to the environmental interpretations of that site. The rate of deposition is linked obviously to the depositional environment, and forms part of the interpretation of the units themselves. However, different depositional environments can blur the parameters being measured. In slow, punctuated deposition, small-scale sedimentation may vary between small washes of water- lain deposition and aeolian deposition. During this slow deposition, the material may be mixed and bioturbated beyond definitive recognition as resulting from either. In the same way artefacts make up time-averaged palimpsests, as do sedimentary particles, albeit at a smaller scale. Therefore, some depositional environments may not be fully discernible through bulk sedimentological methods. Conversely, massmovements, which have been deposited relatively quickly, may be easier to interpret and assign a single origin and interpretation because of their scale and homogeneity. It is therefore vital that the methods selected to study sediments are suitable to the scales of resolution required to answer the questions posed. 3.5 Conclusions – Cave Site Problems and Potentials The preceding review has outlined the significant potential from cave and rockshelter sediments for environmental reconstruction, but has also highlighted the potential problems, including equifinality and reworking which can hamper the interpretation of sedimentary environments within a sequence. The latter half of the chapter outlined the issues which must be taken into account when considering the impact of sedimentary hiatuses and the changing rates of sedimentation driven by the processes previously outlined on both the interpretation of a cave’s sedimentary history, as well as the palaeoenvironmental and archaeological archives it contains. The examination of the sedimentary sequence within a cave must be undertaken at a series of scales in order to fully understand a site’s responses to different magnitudes of environmental change, whilst developing a robust record of the depositional context of the archaeological record it contains. The following chapter outlines the multi- scalar geoarchaeological approaches employed at the Haua Fteah in light of these discussions. 36 Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 4.1 Introduction This chapter introduces the sedimentary and archaeological sequence at the Haua Fteah in detail, and the geoarchaeological approaches taken to the research questions outlined in the previous chapters. The geographical and archaeological setting of the Haua Fteah is described, alongside the existing understanding of the stratigraphy and palaeoenvironmental context of past occupations. The geoarchaeological approaches, sampling strategies and analytical methods taken in this thesis in light of the research themes discussed in the previous chapters are then outlined. 4.2 The Haua Fteah 4.2.1 Geological Setting The Haua Fteah cave is located on the north coast of the Miocene limestone Jebel Akhdar (Green Mountain) massif, northeast Libya (Barker et al. 2007a) (Fig. 4.1). The Jebel Akhdar covers an area ~300 x 400km and rises in series of three escarpments to over 800m (McBurney and Hey 1955). These escarpments, potentially tectonic in origin, overlook a narrow coastal plain (Hey 1956). Due to this rapid rise in elevation from the coast, and its location within the path of the Mediterranean Westerlies (see Chapter Two), the JebelAkhdar receives 200-550mm precipitation per year, supporting a Mediterranean environment in an otherwise arid region (McBurney and Hey 1955). The Jebel is surrounded to the South, West and East by desert, the closest similar areas being the Nile valley to the East and the Jebel Gharbi/Nafusa in Tripolitania to the West (Gregory 1916). The Haua Fteah is located ~50m asl in the first escarpment of the Jebel Akhdar, facing North to the coast. The current opening is 20m high and 80m wide (Fig. 4.2). The cave is karstic in origin, its morphology resulting from the erosion of the escarpment into a subterranean cavern causing a partial collapse of the roofwhich exposed the present void (Smith& Meneely in Barker et al. 2010: 66). Over time, this void has become filled with colluvium, aeolian deposits and limestone weathering products. 4.2.2 Archaeological Background The Haua Fteah was excavated in 1951 and 55 by Charles McBurney of the University of Cambridge (McBurney 1967: 4). Both the cave and its environs are the subject of renewed multidisciplinary investigations by the TRANS-NAP Project (Barker et al. 2007a, 2008, 2009, 2010). McBurney excavated >14m of deposits, across three stepped trenches: the ‘Upper Trench’, 11m x 10m x 2.5m deep; the ‘Middle Trench’ 6m x 4.5m x 6.5m deep; and the ‘Deep Sounding’, 2.5m x 2m x 3m deep (terminology following Barker et al. 2007a). The stratigraphy, cultural chronology and environmental interpretations as understood at the start of this thesis are outlined in Figure 4.3. The site was excavated by McBurney in spits of variable depth, many of which crossed sedimentological boundaries. Layers were defined after excavation, it appears, with reference to stratigraphy observed in the sections, resulting in many spits covering two layers. These layers were only recorded on Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 37 the profile drawings published in the site monograph (McBurney et al. 1967), which contain small inconsistencies in numbering and layer definitions between adjacent profiles. Themonograph contains no consistent description of the sedimentology of the layers, beyond the broad trends and coarse granulometry data outlined below in Section 4.2.4.4. No plan views of the layers during excavation exist in the McBurney archive or were published in the monograph, rendering consideration of the spatial distribution of artefacts from the archive collection virtually impossible. The sequence’s regional significance has been discussed in Chapter Two, and this section will focus more closely on the site stratigraphy to provide a cultural framework for the following chapters and Figure 4.1: a) Location of the Jebel Akhdar and the Haua Fteah, showing the TRANS-NAP study area. Drawing: D. Kemp. b) View of coastal plain of Jebel Akhdar, looking east from the first escarpment, showing the staircase topography of the Jebel’s northern coast, and the location of the Haua Fteah. Photo: G. Barker. Survey Area 100 m 200 m 500 m 0 50 km N Mediterranean Sea Desert Littoral Haua Fteah Pre-desert Gebel AkhdarJebel Akhdar Wadi Kuf Wadi Derna 0 300 km Haua Fteah N Location of the Haua Fteah First escarpment Second escarpment Third escarpment Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 38 Figure 4.2: The Haua Fteah. a) Satellite photo of Haua Fteah (1), showing deeply-incised landscape, red soils and filled doline (2). Image courtesy of Google Earth. b) View into the Haua Fteah in 2007. Ringed figure for scale. c) and d) LiDAR images of internal topography of the Haua Fteah, 2010: c) plan view, showing location of excavation trench and d) cross section showing modern floor and excavation trenche. Courtesy of J. Meneeley and B Smith. N N 10m 20m 500m 1 2 a b c N d Excavation trench Excavation trench Dripline Dripline Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 39 D om in an t Se di m en to lo gi ca l Fa ci es Cu ltu ra l Se qu en ce (M cB ur ne y 19 67 ) Ch ro no lo gy M cB ur ne y (1 96 7) M oy er (2 00 3) Si lt w ith lo ca lis ed br ec ci a co nc en tr at io ns Br ec ci a w ith si lt le ns es Si lt Si lt & sa nd D ab ba n (L S A ) Ib er om au ru si an /O ra ni an (L SA ) Li by co -C ap si an (L SA ) N eo lit hi c G ra ec o- Ro m an Re ce nt Le va llo is - M ou st er ia n (M SA ) Pr e- Au rig na ci an (M SA ) 40 ,0 00 BP > 80 ,0 00 BP DEEPSOUNDING 14 ,0 00 BP 10 ,0 00 BP 7, 00 0B P 47 00 BP M ai nl y O IS 5e 13 0- 11 7, 00 0B P O IS 7 > 19 0, 00 0B P O IS 3 59 -2 4, 00 0B P O IS 4 74 -5 9, 00 0B P ? O IS 6 19 0- 13 0, 00 0B P O IS 2 24 -1 2, 00 0B P ? 1m ? ? Redacted due to lack of permission to reproduce - please refer to McBurney (1967) F ig ur e 4. 3: St ra ti gr ap hi c an d ch ro no lo gi ca ls um m ar y fo r th e H au a F te ah ar ch ae ol og ic al se qu en ce sh ow in g do m in an ts ed im en to lo gi ca lf ac ie s as ou tl in ed by M cB ur ne y (1 96 7) , cu lt ur al se qu en ce s an d pr op os ed ch ro no lo gi ca lm od el s. D ee p so un di ng co nt in ue s 6m be lo w W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e (s ho w n he re ). D ra w in g by R .I ns ke ep (M cB ur ne y 19 67 ). Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 40 analyses. The earliest MSA industry within the Haua Fteah, the Libyan Pre-Aurignacian, is restricted to the Deep Sounding. Occupation is concentrated in three layers over the ~6m sequence (McBurney 1967: 75), separated by two sterile horizons. These levels were largely inaccessible during the writing of this thesis. Directly overlying the latest Pre-Aurignacian (Spit 1955/50), at the junction of theDeep Sounding and Middle Trench, an abrupt cultural shift occurs with the appearance of the Levalloiso-Mousterian in Layer XXXV. This shift was identified by McBurney as a population replacement (McBurney 1967: 131). The counts of lithics and bones recovered from the Levalloiso-Mousterian and Dabban layers are outlined in Figure 4.4. They are relatively high in the lower Levalloiso-Mousterian layers, which yielded two archaic Homo sapiens fossil jaw fragments in Layers XXXII-XXXIII (McBurney et al. 1952, 1953; Tobias 1967; Trevor and Wells 1967). The amount of archaeological material decreases significantly above Layer XXXII/XXXI. This layer corresponds to the potential “Aterian” industry (McBurney 1967: 130) discussed in Chapter Two. The density of artefacts remains low during the remainder of the Levalloiso-Mousterian and its replacement by LSADabban industries in Layer XXV. Layer XXV was subdivided into sub-units a-e, with Levalloiso-Mousterian material in XXVc overlying the first appearances of potentially Dabban material in XXVd (McBurney 1967: 138). McBurney attributed this interstratification to erosion and reworking during this period. However, the presence of residual MSA traits or groups in Cyrenaica after the appearance of the Dabban could not be discounted (McBurney 1967: 138). The Dabban begins unequivocally in Layer XXIV, but lithics and bone remain low in number from the levels until Layer XXI at the end of the Early Dabban. In Level XV another major population replacement is marked by the Eastern Oranian (equivalent to the Iberomaurusian of the Maghreb), followed by the Capsian in Layers X to IX (McBurney 1967: 185), followed by the Neolithic. These three phases contain a major rise in numbers of lithics and bone, which again fall in the Historic period. Fluctuations in lithic and bone counts from theMcBurney archivemeasure provide only a crude gague of occupation density, given the variation in area between the trenches and the differing depth of the layers, the lack of understanding of rates of deposition, and the possibility of occupation continuing outside of the excavated area. Yet, the majority of the layers examined within this thesis (i.e. the Levalloiso-Mousterian to Capsian layers) lie within the Middle Trench, with only the Neolithic to modern layers lying within the larger area of the Upper Trench (fig. 4.3). This consistent excavation area through the layers most crucial to this thesis should therefore minimise the impact of this variation on the key periods. These counts remain the only measure of occupation intensity available before the new archaeological investigations are completed. 4.2.3 Dating the Haua Fteah Sequence McBurney obtained radiocarbon (14C) dates from the upper part of the sequence, which dated the Levalloiso-Mousterian to Dabban transition as occurring c. 40,000BP (fig. 4.3). The extrapolation of ages of levels beyond the limit of radiocarbon dating were based on sediment depth, as well as by Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 41 Historic Libyco-Capsian Iberomaurusian Dabban Levalloiso-Mousterian Neolithic 80 Pre-Aurignacian XVI XVII XVIII XIX XX XXI XXII XXIII XXIV XXV XXVI XXVII XXVIII XXIX XXX XXXI XXXII XXXIII XXXIV XXXV Ammotragus Gazella Bos 0 20 40 60 D ab ba n Le va llo is o- M ou st er ia n 0 20001000 0 2000 4000 0 10,000 20,000 Number of animal bones (Klein and Scott 1986) Number of lithics (McBurney 1967, Moyer 2003) Fauna - Number of identified specimens (Higgs 1967) Number of lithics (Moyer 2003) XXe(spit 55-93 XX/XXIInterface XXI/XXII XXII XXII-XXIV XXIV XXIV/XXV XXVa-b XXVc-d XXV-XXVII XXVII/XXVIII XXIX-XXI XXXI/XXXII XXXII/XXXIII XXXIV/XXXV MinimumNumberof Tools Total Flakes D ab ba n a b Figure 4.4: Cultural information from the McBurney excavations: a) Bone and lithic counts by cultural period (McBurney 1967). b) Number of identified specimens of fauna and lithic counts for the Levalloiso-Mousterian layers by layer. Faunal data from Higgs (1967) and lithic counts from Moyer (2003). It is unclear from the original data why the Levalloiso-Mousterian to Dabban boundary has been placed between XXVIII and XXVII in the original table of data (Higgs 1967: 32) used to construct Figure 4.4b Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 42 cross-correlating pioneering oxygen isotope studies with deep sea records (Emiliani and McBurney 1967). Using this method, McBurney estimated sedimentation of the entire sequence taking place over 80-100,000 years (McBurney 1961, 1967). The sequence chronology was re-interpreted by Moyer (2003). Using the isotopic, faunal and hominin data, and by correlating sedimentological data with Mediterranean sapropel events, he proposed a longer chronology, of 200,000 years. The entire sequence is subject to re-dating by the TRANS-NAPproject using Optically Stimulated Luminescence (OSL), Uranium-Series (U-Series) and Electron Spin Resonance (ESR) dating, tephrochronology and a renewed programme of 14C dating on charcoal and shell. The present results of these investigations will be outlined as part of the discussion in Chapter Nine. 4.2.4 Previous Palaeoenvironmental Investigations at the Haua Fteah TheHauaFteahmonographwas pioneering in itsmulti-disciplinary approaches to palaeoenvironmental reconstruction: faunal and sedimentological analyses were complemented by pioneering isotopic analyses. Since the monograph, a number of researchers have refined and revised these original models through re-analysis of the archival material. The existing environmental hypotheses are summarised in Figure 4.6 at the end of the section. 4.2.4.1 Faunal Analysis Original Analysis – Higgs (1967) Higgs (1967) identified around 5000 bones from the sequence, and used the relative abundance of three key species to trace environmental change: Bos (cattle), which he took to represent high temperatures and dry conditions; Gazella (gazelle), indicating nearby desertic environments; and Ammotragus lervia (Barbary sheep), whose tolerance to a range of environments rendered them an “insensitive yardstick”, but as tentatively useful for representing a generally cooler environment (Higgs 1967:27). Higgs interpreted the patterns as follows: • The Pre-Aurignacian levels: high frequencies of Bos and Gazella, indicating a largely warm (and dry) environment (Higgs 1967:32), which he correlated with the last interglacial. • Layers XXXII and XXXI: 100% Ammotragus (Higgs 1967:32), indicating a cooler (and wetter) period which he correlated with a stadial phase between 49-43,000BP and 46-42,000BP (Higgs 1967:33). • Layers XXVII and XXII (including the transition to the Dabban):Bos frequencies increase, indicating warmer and drier conditions between 46-42,000BP and 36,000BP (Higgs 1967:32). • Layer XXI: Decline in Bos and an increase in Ammotragus, indicating the start of a long cold/wet period c.35,000BP-11,500BP (Higgs 1967:32). • Holocene to present: Bos populations rose, indicating a warmer/drier climate (Higgs 1967:33). The faunal material from the Haua Fteah was subject to recovery bias (Klein and Scott 1987: 524) and variable preservation (Higgs 1967:16), as well as variation between spits in the sizes of the excavated Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 43 areas between the trenches (Higgs 1967:32). Problems caused by spit excavation, where spits often cross-cut discreet layers in the sequence were not taken into account in the original publications (e.g. Higgs 1967:32). Reanalysis - Klein and Scott (1986) Klein and Scott’s (1986) re-analysis identified 9068 bone fragments (part and taxon), but they deemed the resolution too low to allow interpretation beyond the cultural phase. This lumping of multiple layers is quite problematic given the large-scale faunal shifts which Higgs identified within cultural units i.e. within the Levalloiso-Mousterian. They supported the trends identified by Higgs, but posed alternative interpretations: Bos populations required moist conditions (Klein and Scott 1986: 528), not dry/hot conditions, and Ammotragus indicated cold/arid periods (Klein and Scott 1986: 537). This brought the sequence into line with newer models of warm/wet interglacials and cold/dry glacials in the lower latitudes (Klein and Scott 1986: 528-9).Their re-analysis added new species to support these interpretations. Elephant during the Pre-Aurignacian and Late Iberomaurusian indicated warm, humid interglacials (Klein and Scott Table 2: 523), whilst relatively abundant tortoise remains through the Levalloiso-Mousterian andDabban supported aridity (Klein and Scott 1986: 521). Sub-Saharan species such as elephant and long-horned buffalo indicated humid periods when the Sahara was not a barrier to the movement of animal, and presumably hominin, populations. Very small numbers of Eurasian species such as bear and Kirchberg’s Rhinoceros also indicated sporadic potential connections with the Maghreb (Klein and Scott 1986: 539). The re-analysis presents some problems – if Bos peaks represented periods of increased moisture within the area, then it is unclear why there are abundant ‘arid-indicator’ tortoise remains throughout the Levalloiso-Mousterian and early Dabban as well as relatively high Bos frequencies. This apparent contradiction may result from Klein and Scott’s lumping together of the two distinct faunal phases identified byHiggs (and in the sedimentology) within the Levalloiso-Mousterian.Asecond explanation may be linked to climatic variability duringMIS3which is beyond the resolution of the faunal analyses. 4.2.4.2 Avifaunal Analysis – MacDonald (1997) Analysis of the limited avian faunal remains by MacDonald (1997) supported Klein and Scott’s interpretations. 703 bone fragments were identified to 65 taxa, dominated by: Kestrel (Falco tinnunculus), Barbary Partridge (Alectoris Barbara), Common Quail (Coturnix Coturnix), Rock or Stock Dove (Columba livia/oenas), Turtle Dove (Streptopelia turtur), Alpine Swift (Apus melba), thrushes (Turdus sp.), and starlings (Sturnus sp.). A single Wood Pigeon (Columbus palumbus) in the Pre-Aurignacian indicated forested environments (MacDonald 1997: 89), alongside non-specialised species and an absence of arid taxa, illustrating a generally mesic, interglacial/interstadial environment (MacDonald 1997:89). Mesic conditions continued into the Early Levalloiso-Mousterian which contained both woodland and open environment taxa, as well as a Common Crossbill (Loxia Curvirostra) indicating nearby freshwater bodies (MacDonald 1997: 90). Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 44 The Later Mousterian and Early Dabban assemblage indicated a shift to more open country, with the Lesser Kestrel (Falco cf. Naumanni) the Whimbrel (Numenius cf. Phaeopus), Rock Dove, starlings and large thrushes indicative of rocky shorelines (MacDonald 1997:90), consistent with a drier environment. The relatively small Iberomaurusian bird assemblage was dominated by Rock Dove with a single marine species, the Common Greenshank (Tringa nebularia), and a Dabbling Duck (Anas sp.) indicating fresh water and a mesic environment. Freshwater and woodland indicators, along with marine species, are also present within the Capsian levels, as are sub-Saharan species in the form of the African Crake (Crex egregia) (MacDonald 1997:89). The Neolithic remains were dominated by freshwater and woodland species, mirroring the similarities in the large faunal record between the ‘interglacial” Pre-Aurignacian and the Neolithic assemblages. Sub-Saharan species such as larger Shag (Phalacrocorax aristotelis), African Cormorant (Phalacrocorax africanus) and the Woolly- Necked Stork (Ciconia episcopus) mirror the sub-Saharan faunal remains identified by Klein and Scott, indicating humid periods in the Sahara. Taxa from the Historical period were essentially the same as the present-day, with cliff or rock face-nesting taxa dominating in a non-forested landscape (MacDonald 1997: 86). 4.2.4.3 Digital CementumAnalysis – Wall-Scheffler (2007) Wall-Scheffler carried out digital cementum analysis on 187 teeth from Ammotragus lervia, through the entire sequence, to trace seasonality (Wall-Scheffler 2007). The teeth were, however, mainly concentrated in the Iberomaurusian and Neolithic layers, with only 3 and 20 from the Levalloiso- Mousterian and Dabban layers respectively. Most prehistoric specimens were killed in growth months, whilst those from the Historic periods appear to have been killed in the winter. Little can be inferred given the limited assemblage, but there did appear to be consistency in the ratio of summer to winter kills throughout the prehistoric periods, and potentially some warming from MIS3 to the present. 4.2.4.4 Sedimentological Analyses – Sampson (1967), Moyer (2003) Coarse granulometric analysis of the deposits was carried out by Sampson (1967). Samples from a column on the East-Facing Profile of the Upper and Middle Trench and the Deep Sounding were sieved at 3.353mm, 2.057mm, 1.003mm, and 0.5mm after the removal of ‘visible cultural and organic material’ (Sampson 1967: 51). The samples, taken at the end of the excavation, respected layers, which were subdivided when they contained significant variations in coarse content. The sampling was independent of the spit excavation, and these data are therefore the best-constrained from the 1950s excavations. Due to the variable stratigraphy across the trench, however, not all layers were sampled. The material was grouped into two classes: the <0.5mm fraction was, Sampson argued, derived from outside of the cave by wind and water action, and the >0.5mm fraction had weathered from the cave walls through freeze-thaw processes (Sampson 1967: 51). Sampson plotted the percentage >0.5mm fraction alongside with the percentage of Ammotragus vs. the total Bos/Gazella/Caprine count for the layers (Fig. 4.5), outlining a qualitative correlation between Ammotragus and periods of rockfall. Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 45 This he interpreted as cooler environments during the stadial and glacial periods recognised in the faunal remains. Although the correlation of coarse material solely with freeze-thaw processes may not be always true (see Chapter Two) - and autogenic fine material may also have been produced by dust spalling from the roof - the correlation between roof-spall and the Ammotragus peaks appears to suggest that in this case these cooler environments may indeed have been linked to freezing and thawing. Utilising this sedimentology, as well as field descriptions, McBurney divided the sequence into five phases (McBurney 1967: 50). From the base: • red mineral silts containing the Pre-Aurignacian and some Mousterian material (Layers XXXI to Spit 1955/179, Deep Sounding), and ascribed to Later Eemian and warm/dry conditions; • an episode of limestone scree deposition (Layers XXXII-XXXIII) marking a stadial (the Early Würm) during Mousterian occupation; Figure 4.5: Percentage of coarse material (left) plotted against percentage of Ammotragus (right) in Haua Fteah sequence. McBurney 1967, Figure III.2, page 52. Redacted due to lack of permission to reproduce - please refer to McBurney 167 Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 46 • red mineral silts (Layers XXII-XXXI) including the Mousterian-Dabban transition marking an interstadial; • a large band of limestone scree (Layers XXI-XII) towards the top of theMiddle Trench represent the Last Glacial/Würm Climax; and • the silts of the Upper Trench (Layers XI and above) deposited during the Holocene. Moyer (2003), following Woodward and Goldberg (2001), stressed the potential of the fine sediment fraction for environmental reconstruction. He correlated periods of increased fine material deposition with Mediterranean sapropel events, on the basis that pluvial episodes would wash fine soil material into the Haua Fteah. Although soil inwash no doubt contributed to fine sedimentation within the Haua Fteah, this framework ignores the potential for the role of fine aeolian deposition. Whilst Moyer acknowledged the importance of the fine material, the data available to him from the 1950s were designed to measure precisely the size classes that he dismissed as less than informative, e.g. the coarser material. The focus on the fine material championed byWoodward and Goldberg in their 2001 paper has only been made possible through high-resolution geoarchaeological techniques such as soil micromorphology which were in their infancy during the 1950s. 4.2.4.5 Isotopic Analyses Pioneering work was carried out on the oxygen isotopes frommarine shells in the Haua Fteah (Emiliani and McBurney 1967). Patella coerulea and Trocus turbinatus shells were analysed and compared with modern Mediterranean populations and deep sea isotopic records. Although limited in scope, the analysis indicated interglacial temperatures in the Pre-Aurignacian, followed by glacial temperatures in Layers XX, XXII (Dabban) and XXVIII (Levalloiso-Mousterian), and a rise in temperatures after XIII during the Ibermaurusian (Emiliani and McBurney 1967: 58). These correlated with the faunal data and sedimentological data in potentially representing the last glacial cycle. 4.2.5 Summary: Previous Palaeoenvironmental Work and Occupation in the Haua Fteah The existing palaeoenvironmental work identified and interpreted broad-scale temporal trends in the Haua Fteah environment and it is clear that the sediments contain periods of both fully glacial and interglacial conditions encompassing at least the last glacial cycle. These periods are reflected mainly in the sedimentology of the site, as well as the faunal material. The Pre-Aurignacian occupation appears to have taken place in interglacial conditions which, as has been noted by the authors outlined above, bears resemblance to the Holocene sediments and assemblages. It is during these full interglacial conditions that ‘humid corridors’ existed in the Sahara (Chapter Two; Drake et al. 2008; Osborne et al. 2008), and a number of taxa from these periods indicate trans-Saharan linkages. It is difficult to ascertain the relative density of occupation in the Pre-Aurignacian compared to the overlying layers in the Middle Trench given the reduction in size of the excavation, but there are a number of hiatuses that may indicate fluctuations in occupation Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 47 Pr e- A ur ig na ci an , D ee p So un di ng Le va llo is o- M ou st er ia n XX V- XX XV Ea rl y D ab ba n XX I- XX V La te D ab ba n XX -X VI Ib er om ar us ia n X- XV Li by co -C ap si an IX -X N eo lit hi c IV -V III H is to ric ,I -I V Ea rly to La te Ee m ia n Fi na lE em ia n/ Ea rly W ür m ?C ol d/ hu m id cl im ax ? ?O ns et of in te rs ta di al ? Th ro ug h in te rs ta di al to W ür m cl im ax Ea rly Po st -G la ci al H ig gs (1 96 7) H ig h Bo s an d G az el la 10 0% Am m ot ra gu s Bo s do m in an t Am m ot ra gu s do m in an t Co ol in g, w et Lo ng co ld pe rio d, an d/ or w et Co ol er th an Pr e- Au , bu tn ot as co ld as D ab ba n W ar m an d dr y W ar m /d rie r H ig h Bo s K le in & Sc ot t( 19 86 ) W ar m / w et te r Co ol / dr ie r W ar m -i sh , w et W ar m / w et Te m p. ris e be gi ns . Te m p. m ax . 6. 5- 4. 5k ya Te m p. m in . 4k ya Ea rly an d m ai n W ür m , 10 °C co ol er th an pr es en t. Fu lly in te rg la ci al As to da y Fr es h w at er ,w oo dl an d Su b- sa ha ra n in flu en ce Fr es h w at er ,m ar in e & w oo dl an d Ro ck y sh or el in es , fr es h w at er Ro ck y sh or el in es , op en W oo dl an d an d fr es h w at er A vi fa un a M ac D on al d (1 99 7) Sy nt he si s M cB ur ne y (1 96 7) Fa un a Is ot op es Em ill ia ni (1 96 7) O cc up at io n D en si ty M cB ur ne y (1 96 7) H ig h Ve ry lo w Lo w H ig h Lo w Ve ry hi gh M oy er (2 00 3) Sy nt he si s & C hr on ol og y > 80 ,0 00 BP 10 ,0 00 BP 7, 00 0B P 47 00 BP O IS 5e 13 0- 11 7, 00 0B P O IS 7 > 19 0, 00 0B P O IS 3 59 -2 4, 00 0B P O IS 4 74 -5 9, 00 0B P O IS 6 19 0- 13 0, 00 0B P O IS 2 24 -1 2, 00 0B P 40 ,0 00 BP 14 ,0 00 BP C ul tu ra lP ha se an d La ye r (M cB ur ne y 19 67 ) F ig ur e 4. 6: Su m m ar y of pa la eo en vi ro nm en ta l in te pr et at io ns pr io r to th e T R A N S- N A P pr oj ec t, an d th ei r co rr el at io ns w it h th e oc cu pa ti on de ns it y as re co rd ed by th e M cB ur ne y ar ch iv e. Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 48 density within the cave during MIS5, which may in turn reflect fluctuations in population density in the landscape. This interpretation remains tentative however as occupation may simply have been moving outside of the excavated area in the Haua Fteah, or to different caves in the landscape. In contrast, the Levalloiso-Mousterian levels begin in these interglacial conditions, yet encompass \ major shifts in both sedimentation and fauna. The band of limestone scree observed in the lower half of the Middle Trench, corresponding to a shift to an Ammotragus-dominated faunal assemblage, was interpreted by McBruney as cooling in a stadial, potentially MIS4 or a major fluctuation in MIS3, and is accompanied by a marked drop in amount of archaeological material. Yet, above this, density drops even further and remains low through the end of the Levalloiso- Mousterian and the Early Dabban, despite this period’s association with a drop in Ammotragus, with higherBos percentages, although, asmentioned previously, the implications of these faunal changes are contradictory at present. This period may correspond toMIS3, a period of rapid global environmental fluctuations recorded in North Africa (see Chapter Two), and the low artefact density may indicate a period inwhich theHaua Fteahwas largely unoccupied (although again it is possible for occupation to have continued outside of the area of excavation or in other caves). However, the current resolution of the palaeoenvironmental, and indeed archaeological, record is too low to detect the potentially crucial impact of these rapid changes on the occupation history of the cave. This requires higher-resolution examination to unravel the environmental changes at the site specifically within the crucial period of the MSA-LSA transition. The rise in artefact density in the Later Dabban in Layer XXI is broadly concurrent with a rise in coarse material deposition identified and interpreted by McBurney as indicating a period of rock-fall from increased physical weathering. This was correlated with the end of MIS3 and MIS2, with the faunal assemblages continuing to show cool/arid environments (Klein and Scott 1986). This rise in occupation density continues throughout the LSA layers and into the Neolithic, where a shift to siltier deposition was interpreted by warmer, more mesic environments in the Late Glacial and the Holocene (McBurney 1967), and is followed by an apparent drop in occupation density in the Historical period. It appears therefore that occupation within the Haua Fteah, from the known environmental archives, does not show a straightforward correlation with changes in the cave environment. The appearance of the Dabban does not appear to correspond with any marked difference in environment recorded in the proxy records so far studied.Also, periods of increased physicalweathering and ‘cold/arid’Ammotragus peaks in the middle of the Levalloiso-Mousterian and in the later Dabban to Iberomaurusian are accompanied by relatively high density of occupation, when in the rest of North Africa cool/arid conditions brought about the de-population of large areas (e.g. Ambrose 2003; Cremaschi et al. 1998; Kleindienst et al. 1999; Lahr and Foley 1994). MSA occupation of the cave actually drops following the amelioration of these cold/arid conditions and the resumption of what appear to be warmer, more mesic environments recorded in the fauna (although, as discussed previously, the palaeoenvironmental data from this period is contradictory). This shift to apparently mesic conditions is not accompanied by a rise in population levels, as may be expected given the earlier association of MSA industries with Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 49 earlier mesic conditions across North Africa during MIS5 e.g. in the Western Desert (Kleindienst et al. 1999; Wendorf et al. 1990, 1993); Central Libya (Garcea 2004) and Northern Libya, Barich et al. 2003). This potentially indicates that the Haua Fteah was a refuge during cooler/arid periods from which populations shifted away following wider, but still quite localised, climatic amelioration. Yet, as with all levels, it cannot be discounted that fluctuations in occupation ‘density’ as reflected in the material recovered from the excavated area do not simply reflect choices made by populations to inhabit or abandon the Haua Fteah in favour of other sites in the Jebel Akhdar, or indeed periods in which the area of main occupation in the cave shifted beyond the bounds of excavation. Added to this, evaluation of the relationship between environment and occupation at the Haua Fteah is hampered by the very broad resolution of these analyses. The geoarchaeological analysis of the sequence, as outlined in the following section, employs a far-higher resolution of investigation to develop a history of sedimentation driven by environmental changes and linked directly to the site’s cultural history. In addition, analysis of these site formation processes provides information on rates of sedimentation which allows the refinement of the record of occupation density from the archive ahead of the renewed excavations. 4.3 Methodology The following section outlines the approaches taken to examine site formation processes in the Haua Fteah sediment sequence to address questions of human-environment interactions in light of the records above, as well as the specific problems and potential of cave sediments to environmental reconstruction as outlined in Chapter Three. 4.3.1 Scales of Investigation This thesis examines the top seven metres of the sequence, the sequence accessible during four TRANS-NAP excavation seasons between 2008 and 2010 (Barker et al. 2007a, 2008, 2009, 2010. This encompasses the Middle and Upper Trenches and the cultural sequence from the base of the Levalloiso-Mousterian to the present (McBurney 1967). The TRANS-NAP excavations utilised a single-context recording system to log the stratigraphy visible on the exposed profiles of McBurney’s excavation following the removal of the 1950s backfill. These contexts broadly traced the stratigraphy recorded in McBurney’s section drawings, yet the new excavations identified many subdivisions of his stratigraphic units, often with multiple contexts within what were grouped as ‘layers’ (and which in places contained some very distinct sedimentary changes). Therefore, the TRANS-NAP contexts were used as the primary unit of stratigraphy within this thesis, and the presence of crucial cultural boundaries were extrapolated from theMcBurney section drawings onto the new stratigraphy by visual comparison. A set of nested scales of analyses and methods was employed to analyse the sediments: Field Observations (Chapter Five): The contexts within the 7m sequence from the base of the Levalloiso-Mousterian to the present were grouped into sedimentary facies on the basis of broad-scale changes in sedimentology. This was in order to provide a broad stratigraphic framework for the rest of Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 50 0 50 cm 0 1 m 20 8 M od er n H is to ric (I- III ) N eo lit hi c (V I- VI II) Ca ps ia n (IX -X ) 0 1 2m M SA (X XV -X XX V) D ab ba n (X X- XX V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) W E S E W N So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch Pr of ile W es t- Fa cin g M id dl e Tr en ch Pr of ile So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h Pr of ile W es t- Fa cin g M id dl e Tr en ch Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g M Id dl e Tr en ch Pr of ile Cu ltu ra lP ha se & M cB ur ne y La ye rs F ig ur e 4. 7: L oc at io n of sa m pl e co lu m ns (g re y) an d m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al sa m pl es (b la ck ) on th e So ut h- F ac in g U pp er Tr en ch P ro fil e (t op le ft ) an d th e W es t- an d N or th - F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch P ro fil es (b ot to m ), an d th e re la ti ve po si ti on s of th e di ff er en t tr en ch fa ce s (t op ri gh t) .I nd iv id ua l m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al sa m pl e nu m be rs di sp la ye d in fig ur es at th e be gi nn in g of ea ch an al ys is se ct io n in C ha pt er s Si x an d Se ve n Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 51 the analyses, as well as to identify broad, long-term changes in the sedimentation of the cave which, it was hoped, could be linked to global glacial cycles. Bulk Sedimentology (Chapter Five) The 7m sequence from the base of the Levalloiso-Mousterian to present was sampled for bulk sedimentological analyses to characterise the sediments. The data were used to test field observations, and again focussed on identifying broad, long-term changes in the sedimentation of the cave which, it was hoped, could be linked to global glacial cycles. Soil Micromorphology of the Middle-Upper Palaeolithic (Chapter Six and Seven) Each context in the Mousterian and the early part of the Dabban layers in the Middle Trench was sampled for micromorphological analyses. This methodology was employed to confirm the trends in bulk sedimentology, and primarily to provide information on more subtle and smaller-scale changes in sedimentation which had been missed in the bulk sedimentology with a view to tracing smaller scale and more rapid environmental change. Microstratigraphic Analysis of Anthropogenic Features (Chapter Eight) Two burning events in the Middle Palaeolithic layers were sampled for micromorphological analysis to further explore the remains of the hearths from these layers recorded by McBurney (1967). Examination of the microstratigraphy of the features was undertaken to try to elucidate the human actions and processes which built up the features, and their later diagenesis and the implications this would have for the environment within which human occupation took place. 4.3.2 Bulk Sedimentological Analyses Bulk sedimentology sampling was undertaken over the 2008 and 2009 excavation seasons. A column was sampled in three parts, on the South-Facing Upper Trench Profile (2008) and two separate sections on the West-Facing Middle Trench Profile (2008 and 2009) (shaded profiles in schematic trench diagram, Figure 4.7). This column will be referred to as the West-Facing Sample Column. In the Middle Trench, the lower half of the column was stepped to the south to avoid an area of calcite- concreted sediment. The spatial separation of the different segments of the sample column affects the ability to trace temporal trends between the different parts of the sample columns (specifically in %CaCO 3 , see discussion in Chapter Five, Section 5.4.2.2), but was unavoidable. A second column was sampled on the North-Facing Middle Trench Profile in 2009, from Context 206 to the base of the Middle Trench to assess spatial variability between the profiles in the Levalloiso-Mousterian and Early Dabban sediments, as well as the impact of the prominent anthropogenic features on the North- Facing Middle Trench Profile on the sediments. Bulk samples were taken over no more than 5cm of sediment depth from the cleaned sediment profile, respecting context boundaries. A number of sediment samples were also collected from a number of locations across the JebelAkhdar and Tunisia to provide characterisation of potential analogues for the sources of the material transported into the Haua Fteah, e.g. aeolian dust sources (Al Mechili, Libya and Matmata, Tunisia) and soil material (Haua Fteah Soil Pits T and R, andAl Marj). These analogues are fully explained in Chapter Five, Section 5.3. Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 52 024681012141618 024681012141618 024681012141618 024681012141618 Sa m pl e 24 94 Sa m pl e 24 74 Sa m pl e 25 63 Sa m pl e 25 02 %Volume %Volume Pa rt ic le si ze (μ m ) Pa rt ic le si ze (μ m ) F ig ur e 4. 8: C om pa ri so n of pa rt ic le si ze cu rv es fr om fo ur sa m pl es fr om th e H au a F te ah se qu en ce bo th de ca rb on at ed (b la ck ,s ol id ) an d un tr ea te d (g re y, do tt ed ). Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 53 4.3.2.1 Particle Size Analysis Sedimentparticlesize is influencedbyitssource,mechanismof transport,andenvironmentofdeposition. Interpretations of particle size are therefore complex, as the measured particle size distributions can be altered by any of these stages, as well as by bioturbation and mixing once deposited, a particular risk in a cave environment. Nevertheless, particle size remains potentially a powerful tool in understanding the sedimentation of a site (Boggs 2001; Folk 1966). The primary reason for the application of the technique at the Haua Fteah was to identify periods of aeolian deposition in contrast to colluvial deposition; aeolian sediments should be well-sorted, whilst colluvial sediments are often less well- sorted (e.g. Tate et al. 2007). The carbonate-rich cave environment posed difficulties in particle size analysis. Secondary precipitation of calcite, observed in the Haua Fteah, can cement fine material into larger aggregates, and therefore should be removed to obtain particle sizes representative of the original material (Catt 1985; Matthews 1991). Yet carbonate also exists in the sediments as limestone roof-spall. In addition, external sediments may include carbonate material, e.g. carbonate-rich loess (e.g. Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1993). Both of these sources would have been removed by pre-treatment. The decision to decarbonate the samples was undertaken for a number of reasons. Firstly, the focus of the particle analysis was the potentially fine-grained, externally-generated sediment and inclusion of roof-spall or concretion of the sediments, both as a result of processes of deposition within the cave, would have hampered this analysis by skewing the distributions towards coarser material. Secondly, whilst it is possible that carbonate dust and loess were removed, the aeolian analogue samples, although high in carbonate, retained their characteristic shapes after pre-treatment, therefore it was assumed that similar inputs would be visible in the pretreated distributions (see Chapter Five, Section 5.3.2.2). To assess the impact of decarbonation on the sample distributions, four samples from the Haua Fteah were processed using both methods, producing largely similar particle size curves with variation mainly confined to the coarser part of the curve consistent with the expected limestone sand and secondary concretion (Fig. 4.8). In addition, all analogue samples were analysed both with and without decarbonation so as to be comparable to the decarbonated Haua samples, whilst allowing full comparison between the analogue samples (see Chapter Five). Particle size analysis was carried out in the Physical Geography Laboratories in the Department of Geography, University of Cambridge. Material was sieved using a 2mm sieve prior to decarbonation overnight with hydrochloric acid, dispersal in sodium pyrophosphate and measurement on a Malvern Mastersizer 2000 (for full procedure seeAppendix One). The particle sizes of the coarsematerial were recorded in the field. 4.3.2.2 Magnetic Susceptibility The magnetic susceptibility of a material is a measure of its ability to become magnetised (Sternberg 2001), and can serve as a rough measure of the concentration of ferro- or ferrimagnetic minerals within a sample (Thompson and Oldfield 1986: 3). e.g. iron oxides such as magnetite and maghemite Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 54 (Dearing et al. 1985). The concentration of these minerals can be affected by a number of factors. These minerals may be inherited from the parent material of the substance (Tite 1972), but their concentration can also be raised or lowered through changes in the oxidation conditions of the site, linked to burning, waterlogging, cycles of wetting and drying, and biological activity (Dearing et al. 1985; Graham 1976; Mullins 1977; Sternberg 2001). Magnetic susceptibility has been utilised in archaeology for site prospection (Ellwood et al. 1994) and on-site analysis to detect areas of burning (Tite and Mullins 1971). In palaeoenvironmental studies, magnetic susceptibility has been used to detect weathering and pedogenesis in loess profiles (Dearing et al. 1996, 2001) and soils in landscapes (Maher et al. 2003). The magnetic susceptibility of colluvial deposits in karstic caves has also been used to trace environmental change through its ability to measure the degrees of weathering of soils washed into caves (e.g. Ellwood and Gose 2006; Ellwood et al. 1995, 1997, 1998, 2001, 2004). Although low frequency magnetic susceptibility provides a relatively crude measure of the magnetic minerals present within a sample, it is an efficient method for determining the relative concentration of ferri- and ferromagnetic minerals within large data sets. The mass susceptibility of the majority of the samples were measured at Queen’s University, Belfast following Gale and Hoare (1991), except for the two analogue sites of Al Mechili and Al Marj (see Chapter Five), which were measured in the Physical Geography Laboratories, University of Cambridge using a Bartington magnetic susceptibility meter (full procedures in Appendix One). In contrast to ferro- and ferrimagnetic minerals, calcium carbonate is diamagnetic, that is, it is weakly negatively magnetic (Thompson and Oldfield 1986: 3). Diamagnetic materials also include quartz, and in most soils and sediments can be considered to have a negligible impact on the magnetic susceptibility signal (Thompson and Oldfield 1986: 73). These minerals, however, have the effect of potentially ‘diluting’ a sample (Dearing et al. 1985); a material containing large amounts of calcium carbonate and a small amount of high magnetic susceptibility soil material will have a far lower overall magnetic susceptibility than a sample which contains identical soil material and no carbonate. This effect may be marked in the carbonate-rich environment of the Haua Fteah. In light of this, the known carbonate content, measured as %CaCO 3 was used to ‘correct’ the magnetic susceptibility by recalculating the density of the sample to reflect only its non-carbonate content, before re-calculating the mass susceptibility from this non-carbonate density. This approach is notwithout its problems, as it ignores thepresenceof other, non-carbonate, diamagnetic materials, such as quartz. However, it provides a rough measure to distinguish between samples which contain non-carbonate material genuinely low in magnetic susceptibility, and those which have been ‘diluted’ by the inclusion of carbonate. The ‘corrected’ values for magnetic susceptibility have been reported and discussed alongside the ‘uncorrected’ magnetic susceptibility values throughout. Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 55 4.3.2.3 Percent Calcium Carbonate (%CaCO 3 ) As discussed in Chapter Two, carbonate exists in a number of forms in karstic settings. Sources include weathering of the roof and walls of the cave and the precipitation of secondary calcite through water drips (Farrand 2001; Laville 1976; Laville et al. 1980; White 2007). It is also possible that exogenous material is carbonaceous, such as aeolian loess (Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1993). Analysis of the %CaCO 3 content was carried out on the <2mm fraction of the samples. This removed one of the largest components of carbonate material in the form of rockfall, but this component was recorded through field descriptions. The <2mm fraction therefore contains a potential mixture of fine roof spall, secondary calcite precipitation, aeolian carbonate dust, and anthropogenic inputs of CaCO 3 , such as ash (Canti 2003). The thin section data are therefore key to elucidating the origin of the CaCO 3 in each case. The CaCO 3 content of the majority of the samples was measured using a calcimeter, following Gale and Hoare (1991), at Queen’s University, Belfast. Some of the analogue samples (Al Mechili, AlMarj and Matmata, see Chapter Five) were analysed at the Physical Geography Laboratories, University of Cambridge by heating samples previously used for %LOI organics, to 950˚C in a muffle furnace and recording their masses (full procedures in Appendix One). Whilst it was not ideal that two methods were used for the determination of the CaCO 3 content, they should be broadly comparable. 4.3.2.4 Percent Loss on Ignition, Organics (%LOI) The organic content of sediments has been used in archaeology to indicate increased human activity within sites both spatially and temporally (e.g. Macphail et al. 2004; Marwick 2005; Sànchez Vizcaíno andCañabate 1999). In palaeoenvironmental studies, organic content has been used to detect palaeosols within sedimentary sequences (Ellis andMellor 1995: 135; Stein 1992). The determination of organics through %LOI is only a rough measure of the organic content, as other substances within the sample may decompose at high temperatures, contributing to the overall weight loss. However, it remains an efficient way of determining the organic contents of a large number of samples (Dean 1974; Grewal et al. 1991; Heiri et al. 2001). %LOI was measured at the Queen’s University, Belfast, following Gale and Hoare (1991), apart from the Al Mechili, Al Marj and Matmata analogue samples which were analysed at the Physical Geography Laboratories, University of Cambridge by heating pre-dried, weighed samples to 550˚C in a muffle furnace and recording their masses (full procedures in Appendix One). 4.3.3 Soil Micromorphology Soil micromorphology, as previously discussed, is a powerful tool for examining archaeological sediments (Courty et al. 1989; Kemp 1991). By focussing on the arrangement, composition and structure of the sediments, micromorphological analysis can examine features lost or homogenised in bulk sedimentological sampling, as well as elucidating characteristics identified in the field and bulk analyses (Courty 2001; Goldberg and Macphail 2006; Macphail and Cruise 2001). Soil Chapter Four: Approaches and Methodology 56 micromorphology is especially useful in cave environments, where the often complex sedimentation and post-depositional alteration of sediments cannot be elucidated fully at the macro-scale (Woodward and Goldberg 2001). Recent research in soil micromorphology has also examined the potential for the microstratigraphic analysis of anthropogenic features, which provides information on fuel use, hearth construction, and diagenesis of anthropogenic material (Karkanas et al. 2002, 2004; Schiegl et al. 1996, 2003). In the Haua Fteah, micromorphological sampling was focussed on the Levalloiso-Mousterian and Early Dabban layers (Fig. 4.7), primarily on the West-Facing Profile, but also on the North-Facing Profile in areas of complex stratigraphy. Sampling focussed on the context boundaries, with nearly all contexts analysed at their top and bottom contexts in order to characterise the nature of the material within each deposit as well as the nature of the contacts between contexts in order to detect potential truncations or sedimentary hiatuses. Intact blocks were removed from the profiles using Kubiena tins or foil food containers, and secured with tissue paper and parcel tape to allow drying in the field. They were later wrapped in clingfilm for transport to the Charles McBurney Laboratory for Geoarchaeology at the University of Cambridge for thin section manufacture. The blocks were air dried for around a week, before being oven-dried for 48 hours prior to impregnation with crystallitic polymer resin under a vacuum, following capillary rise. When cured, slices were cut from the blocks to fit 13x7cm or 7x5cm slides, and, after polishing, adhered to 2mm thick glass and ground to 30um using a Brot multiplate grinding machine (full procedures in Appendix One). ThesectionswereexaminedbyeyeandusingaLeicaWildM40wide-viewmicroscopeatmagnifications of x4 to x35, and a Leitz Laborlux 12 Pol microscope for magnifications from x40 to x400, under plane polarized light (PPL), crossed polarized light (XPL) and oblique incident light (OIL). Standard micromorphological description was undertaken following Courty et al. (1989), Stoops (2003) and Bullock et al. (1985). 4.4 Summary The integration of the above approaches will provide a robust characterisation of the sediments and sedimentary environments of the site at the appropriate scales with which to address the long-term response of the Haua Fteah to environmental change, and within this, the specific environments of the Levallois-Mousterian to Dabban transition which is the focus of this thesis. The bulk sedimentology and the long-term trends it contains will be outlined in Chapter Five. This framework will be used to contextualise the higher-resolution micromorphological analyses outlined in Chapters Six to Eight. These results will be synthesised and discussed in Chapter Nine in light of the existing models of environmental and cultural change at the Haua Fteah. 57 Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 5.1 Introduction To trace trends in sediment source and depositional environment, and their potential links to long- term global and regional environmental change, the upper seven metres of the Haua Fteah sediment sequence were sampled for bulk sedimentological analyses (see Chapter Four). This chapter begins by outlining the major sediment facies within the sequence, and their field interpretations. A number of samples from potential source analogues are characterised using bulk sedimentology, and these analogues are then compared with those of the sediments within the Haua Fteah to examine the variation and long-term trends in site formation processes in the sequence. 5.2 Sediment Sequence Overview 5.2.1 General Field Observations Four main sediment types were observed within the Haua Fteah sequence (Fig. 5.1): Red mineral silts/silty clays - The entire sequence is, to some extent, red in colour (Munsell colours range across sheets 2.5-7.5YR - full descriptions of contexts sampled for micromorphological analysis in Appendix Four). These layers vary from deep red to lighter orange/buff, with the darkest red layers compact and clayey. This variation indicates variability in the amount and oxidation state of the iron potentially inherited from the source material (Bridges 1997: 15; Taylor 1982). Alternatively it could result from the hydrological changes associated with the deposition and preservation of the material within the cave altering the states of the iron material (Bridges 1997; Ellis andMellor 1995; FitzPatrick 1980; Schwertmann and Taylor 1977: 61), however, the clarity of the context boundaries within the cave sequence indicate that this is unlikely. Such clarity of stratigraphy also suggests that extensive bioturbation has not taken place on the macro-scale, although a number of circular burrows are visible in the profiles suggesting disturbance in some areas. In the field the similarity in texture and colour between the cave sediments and the terra rossa in the surrounding landscape suggested that these soils were a key source of sediment throughout the sequence, either through inwash, colluviation or aeolian movement, as in many Mediterranean, karstic caves (e.g. Karkanas 2001; Schuldenrein 1998; Woodward and Goldberg 2001), yet the fine material may also have weathered directly from the limestone itself, models which are tested in this and the following chapters. Gravel/Breccia – Subangular limestone gravel, given its largely horizontal orientation, was interpreted in the field as originating from the roof and walls of the cave during periods of increased physical weathering (Bar-Yosef 1993; Barton and Clark 1993; Farrand 2001a, b; Goldberg and Sherwood 2006; Laville et al. 1980). In the Neolithic levels in the Upper Trench however, layers containing disoriented, subrounded limestone gravel and boulders were interpreted as mudflows transporting limestone clasts transported into the cave from the area in front of the cave opening (Hunt et al.2010). The clasts’ orientation and character of the fine matrix remains key to interpreting their ultimate deposition in the following chapters. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 58 Calcite layers – Secondary calcite precipitation is present in the profiles, the result of groundwater dripping from the bedrock (Sweeting 1972; White 2007), with some sediment layer well-concreted with calcite and resemble flowstone, visible in the profiles as mm- to cm-thick white encrustations. Calcite also forms skins and irregular impure stalactites on the ceiling and walls of the cave. Carbonate precipitation during or after the deposition of the units may concrete the material, appearing to mark out different sedimentological regimes when the underlying material is, in fact, consistent. Such post- depositional alteration is observable in the almost complete concretion of the central part of the South- Facing Middle Trench Profile and parts of the northeast corner next to the upper part of the West- Facing Middle Trench Sample Column. Anthropogenic sediments – Anthropogenic influence is clear in some layers, especially in a series of large ‘burnt’ events in the lower part of the North-Facing Middle Trench Profile. On the South- Facing Upper Trench Profile, contexts containing large amounts of flint,molluscs and charcoal appear to be the result of middening and/or very intense occupation. The microstratigraphy of these MSA anthropogenic features will be explored in Chapter Eight. 5.2.2 The Haua Fteah Sediment Sequence Figure 5.2 summarises the main sedimentological facies identified in the top seven metres of the Haua Fteah sediment sequence, and explored in this chapter: Figure 5.1: Examples of the main sediment types observed in the Haua Fteah. a) Red silts. b) Gravel layers. c) Burnt anthropogenic layers. d) Lines of calcite precipitation. Photos a-c G. Barker, d. R. Inglis. a b c d Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 59 The sediment sequence (also show in Figure 5.3) is as follows: Field Facies Five: -7 to -6m below ground level. Dense, reddish silts at the base of the Middle Trench. On the North-Facing Profile, these layers contain a number of potential burning events (discussed in Chapter Eight). The contact between Contexts 523 and 521 on the West-Facing Profile, when traced across the West-, South- and East-Facing Profiles contains a number of anthropogenic lenses and burning features. There are very rare circular burrows visible in the section (15-30cm) which cut the otherwise well-defined stratigraphy. Field Facies Four: -5.5 to -6m. Silty, greyish sediments and horizontally-orientated limestone gravel. Field Facies Three: -3.5m to -5.5m. Red and buff silt layers between -3.5m and -5.5m, much more variable in colour, texture and density than in Facies Five. Lenses of horizontally orientated gravel are also present, as well as layers of calcite concretion. As in Facies Five, there are rare circular burrows -1m -2m -3m -4m -5m 0m -6m -7m FaciesDescription Redsilt andsilty clay layerswith cobbles and anthropogenic material anddung Layers I-XII approx. Breccia ingreyish-redsilt matrix,with distinct redsilty clay lenses LayersXIII-XXII approx. Banded reddishand buffsiltsand silty clays with lensesof gravel concentrated to the top LayersXXIII-XXXapprox. Breccia ingreyish-redsilt matrix.LayersXXXI&XXXII Reddish siltsand silty clayswith ʻburningʼfeatures LayersXXXIII-XXXV Neolithic (VI-VIII) Capsian (IX-X) Iberomaurusian (XI-XV) Dabban (XVI-XXV) MSA (XXV-XXXV) Historic (I-III) CulturalSequence (McBurney 1967) Up pe rT re nc h M id dl e Tr en ch Facies No. 1 2 3 4 5 Figure 5.2: Sedimentological summary of the Haua Fteah sequence. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 60 G re y ʻm id de nʼ la ye r Re d so il m ud flo w s Fa ci es O ne Fa ci es Tw o Fa ci es Th re e Fa ci es Fo ur Fa ci es Tw o Fa ci es Th re e Fa ci es Fo ur Fa ci es Fi ve F ig ur e 5. 3: Vi ew s of th e H au a F te ah se di m en ts eq ue nc e. L ef tt o ri gh t: Se di m en ts in th e So ut h- F ac in g U pp er Tr en ch af te r sa m pl in g fo r flo ta ti on an d bu lk se di m en to lo gy .N ot e ‘m id de n’ la ye r’ in te rr up ti ng ot he rw is e re dd is h, si lt y po te nt ia lm ud flo w se di m en ts .P ho to : R .I ng li s. C en tr e an d ri gh t: Vi ew s of N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch P ro fil e sh ow in g fa ci es ch an ge s fr om (c en tr e) th e to p of th e se qu en ce an d (r ig ht ) th e ba se of th e tr en ch .S ca le di vi si on s ar e 50 cm .P ho to s: G . B ar ke r. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 61 (15-30cm) which cut the otherwise very well-defined stratigraphy. Field FaciesTwo: -1.5 to -3.5m. Silty, greyish sediments and horizontally-orientated limestone gravel similar to, but deeper than, Facies Four. Field Facies One: 0m to -1.5m. Red silt layers interspersed with anthropogenically-influenced sediments. In one part of the trench aGraeco-Roman structurewas excavated byMcBurney (McBurney 1967: 328), further illustrating significant anthropogenic disruption of this facies. These field facies form the framework for the investigation of the sediment sequence within this thesis. 5.3 The Haua Fteah Sediments in Context – Analogue Samples Samples were collected from around the JebelAkhdar in a range of depositional environments in order to act as modern and ancient source analogues for the sediments deposited in the Haua Fteah (Fig. 5.4 and Table 5.1). Although restricted in nature, as explained below, this programme of sampling included the main sources of material for the Haua Fteah deposits: aeolian-transported material from the edges of the Sahara (sampled at Al Mechili and Matmata, Section 5.3.1), as well as local soil material (sampled in the cave environs and further afield at Al Marj, Section 5.3.2.2). 5.3.1 Soils on the Jebel Akhdar Two soils pits were dug close to the Haua Fteah, one ~20m above and to the south of the cave (Fig. 5.5a), and one on a plateau ~600m below the Haua Fteah to the north where vegetation had preserved an island of soil in an otherwise eroded area of the landscape (Fig. 5.5b). The soil around the Haua Fteah is a terra rossa chromic luvisol (UNESCO/FAO) formed on limestone parent material, with a well-developed Bt horizon and occasional 1-2cm carbonate nodules. Another sample (referred to as “Al Marj”) was collected from a ditch near AlMarj, in the western Jebel Akhdar, where a road cutting had exposed a series of potentially colluvial valley bottom deposits of similar terra rossa soils, again on limestone parent material (Fig. 5.5c). The particle size of the soil material samples are relatively homogenous (Fig. 5.5d), containing significant proportions of medium silt to fine sand-sized material (11.05μm–125μm), as well as a fine clay peak (0.35μm–0.086μm). The distribution of the Al Marj sample is similar in character, although slightly finer and more poorly sorted than the Haua Fteah soil pits. Interpretation There are no significant variations in the sedimentological properties in depthwithin theHaua Fteah soil pit profiles, although the limited number of samples for each profile renders this observation tentative (Table 5.2). Both pits have similarly low %CaCO 3 , indicating a potentially decarbonised soil. There is substantial variation in magnetic susceptibility between the two pits, indicating significant variation in the modern landscape, which may be problematic when interpreting magnetic susceptibility changes of this magnitude in the Haua Fteah sequence. Limited variation in %LOI between the two pits may be due to variability in organic material or preservation across the landscape. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 62 Figure 5.4: Map of analogue sample locations around the Jebel Akhdar. Data from Gebco08, maps courtesy by L. Farr. HauaFteah Soil Pits AlMarj AlMechili Alluvial Fan 0 12.5 25 50 75 100 km 0-50masl 51-100masl 101-150masl 151-200masl 201-250masl 251-400masl 401-500masl 501-750masl 751-900masl 0 350 700km175 Haua Fteah Tunis TripoliMatmata Sample Location GPS Material Reason Pit R (R2-3) Below the Haua 32°54’09.1”N 22°02’58.9”E Soil ‘island’ preserved under tree. Local soil material Pit T (T2-4) Above the Haua 32°54’00.6”N 22°03’05.2”E Sediment in karstic hollow. Al Marj Near Al Marj, Jebel Akhdar 32°41’47.5”N 21°22’28.1”E Sediment from ditch cutting. Potentially re-worked loessic material Matmata Techine, Tunisia 33°33’38.2”N 09°55’21.6”E Sediment from loess section. Aeolian analogue Soil 6 Al Mechili alluvial fan/palaeolake system 32°01’44.0”N 22°27’33.3”E Mudcracks from lake. Potential Aeolian source material Soil 7 32°04’50.4”N 22°30’02.5”E Sediment from alluvial fan. Soil 8 32°03’81.2”N 22°31’94.3”E Sediment trapped under vegetation. Limestone Haua Fteah 32°54’00.6”N 22°03’05.2”E Sample from shelter wall. Residue from dissolution of rock. Table 5.1: Location and description of analogue samples. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 63 a b c 0246810121416 %Volume Pa rt ic le si ze (u m ) F ig ur e 5. 5: P ho to s of Je be lA kh da r so il pi t lo ca ti on s an d de ca rb on at ed pa rt ic le si ze di st ri bu ti on s. a) So il P it R .b ) So il P it T. P ho to s R .I ng li s. c) A lM ar jd it ch cu tt in g. Sa m pl e lo ca ti on in di ca te d. P ho to S. A rm it ag e. d) P ar ti cl e si ze di st ri bu ti on s fo r H au a F te ah so il pi ts (s ol id li ne s) an d A lM ar js oi lp it (d as he d li ne ). Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 64 The Al Marj sample contains less organic material and CaCO 3 than the Haua Fteah pits, and is lower in magnetic susceptibility. Pits T and R are modern soils and contain visible fragments of organic material, material which may have decayed from theAl Marj sediments following colluvial reworking and burial under c. 1m of further colluvial deposits, although the date of deposition of this material is unknown. The %CaCO 3 variation may be insignificant, and represents an almost completely decarbonated soil material source at Al Marj and the Haua Fteah soil pits. The much lower magnetic susceptibility for theAl Marj sample may indicate soil material formed under different environmental conditions. The particle size distributions for the soil pits and Al Marj are similar in character, perhaps showing continuity in the origin or development of the terra rossa soils across the Jebel Akhdar. The coarse silt (and in the case of the Haua Fteah soil pit samples, the coarse silt/fine sand) peak may represent a distinct input of material (potentially aeolian or originating from the limestone) from which the soil has weathered to finer material. Figure 5.6 shows the particle size distributions of the soil samples with and without decarbonation. There is a large discrepancy between the groups: the untreated distributions contain a significant proportion of clay-sized material absent from the decarbonated distributions. It was expected that the carbonate in the samples would be largely the result of secondary precipitation, either cementing material or coating grains, therefore making the material appear coarser in the untreated distributions (as can be observed in theAl Marj sample and Catt 1985;Matthews 1991) or in the form of sand-sized limestone clasts. Instead, the significant proportion of clay-sizedmaterial in the untreated distributions implies the presence of fine clay-sized carbonate in the sample - potentially the precipitation of micritic calcite (Wieder and Yaalon 1982) that has not lead to cementation of large portions of the groundmass. This explanation, however, is problematic. A large amount of coarse silt and fine sand present in the pre-treated samples is not present in the untreated sample. With only ~8% CaCO 3 by weight, the significant difference between the two curves does not appear to be explained by carbonate removal alone, despite the problems of comparing values based on weight (%CaCO 3 ) with those based on Sample Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) Corrected Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) % LOI (Organic) % CaCO 3 R2 373.4 405.0 5.3 7.8 R3 357.5 389.0 5.4 8.1 Pit R Mean 365.45 397.0 5.35 7.95 T2 584.0 636.8 8.3 8.3 T3 580.6 631.1 7.5 8.0 T4 589.8 644.6 7.8 8.5 Pit T Mean 584.8 637.5 7.87 8.27 Al Marj 108.9 112.7 3.6 3.4 Table 5.2: Bulk sedimentological properties of Haua Fteah and Al Marj soil pit samples. %CaCO 3 values for Al Marj calculated by loss on ignition, other values calculated by calcimetry (see Chapter Four). Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 65 volume (particle size). The decarbonation may be affecting the measured distribution of the particle size from the soil pits in a way which was not detected in the other samples which were run both with and without pretreatment (See the Al Marj and Al Mechili samples below, as well as Chapter Four, Section 4.3.2.1). This discrepancy remains problematic, and indicates that care should be taken with the interpretation of the decarbonated particle size distribution data in light of the methodologcial problems, and that limited interpretations can be made from the decarbonated dataset alone. 5.3.2 The Origin of Terra Rossa Soils: Saharan Dust orWeathered Limestone? The nature of the parent material for Mediterranean terra rossa soils has been subject to investigation over recent decades; although originally attributed largely to the weathering of limestone, later research highlighted the significant role of Saharan aeolian material in their development (Assallay et al. 1998; Coudé-Gaussen 1987, 1990; Jackson et al. 1982; Rapp 1984). The potential of aeolian input to the Jebel Akhdar soils, and directly into the cave itself, was investigated through the characterisation of samples from the Al Mechili palaeolake and alluvial fan system, a potential dust source just south of the Jebel Akhdar (N. Drake, pers. comm. 2009) and the Matmata plateau loess deposits in Tunisia (Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1988; Dearing et al. 2001; White et al. 2002) (Fig. 5.4). In order to assess the contribution of limestone weathering to the soils, a sample of limestone from a wall in the Haua Fteah was dissolved in 10% hydrochloric acid (see Appendix One for procedure), and the particle size of its residue measured. Figure 5.6: Comparison of decarbonated and untreated particle size distributions for Jebel Akhdar soil pit samples. Decarbonated samples in black, untreated samples in grey. Haua Fteah soil pits R and T solid lines, Al Marj distributions dashed lines. 0 5 10 15 20 25 Particle Size(um) % Vo lu m e Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 66 5.3.2.1 The Haua Fteah Limestone Residue Figure 5.7 shows the particle size distributions for the limestone residue in reference to the Haua Fteah and Al Marj soil pits. The clay peak, and trough at 0.35–0.49μm, are common to the samples, but the silt in the residue is far more poorly sorted and slightly finer than in the soil pits. There is a sand peak in the residue which is absent from the soil pit samples. The coarse peak in the residuemay therefore result from fragments of nummulite fossils, visible in the residue up to 0.5cm in size, which consist of non-carbonate components (e.g. silica). The only feature common to the soil pit samples and the residue is the peak below 0.49μm, indicating that clays and some proportion of the fine silt within the soil may originate from the weathering of the limestone. The distinct peak coarse silt/fine sand in the soil pit samples therefore does not appear to result from limestone weathering, and may be aeolian in origin. 5.3.2.2 Aeolian Analogues: The Al Mechili Palaeolake and Matmata Loess Al Mechili The Al Mechili alluvial fan and palaeolake system, just south of the Jebel Akhdar, was sampled as a potential source for the generation of dust transported to the surrounding regions (N Drake, pers. comm. 2010) as such systems may be key to the production of dust in the Sahara (Glennie 1987). Three samples were taken from different parts of the surface of the alluvial fan and playa (Fig. 5.8a–c). The particle size distribution of the material crusting on the dry surface of lake, Soil 6, is dominated by fine silt and coarse clays (~22.2μm and 0.98μm), and a fine clay peak between 0.12–0.35μm (Fig. Figure 5.7: Particle size distributions for Jebel Akhdar soil pit samples and limestone residue. Haua Fteah soil pits are solid black lines, Al Marj dashed black line, limestone residue solid grey line. 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 % Vo lu m e Particle size(um) Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 67 0 5 10 15 20 25 % Vo lu m e Particle Size(um) a b c Figure 5.8: Photos of Al Mechili fan and palaeolake system. a and b) Playa surface and location of Soil 6 Photos N. Drake. c) Location of Soil 8 sample under vegetation. Photo K. White. d) Particle size distributions for Al Mechili samples. Soil 8 (black), Soil 7 (dark grey), Soil 6 (light grey). Dashed lines indicate decarbonated distributions, solid lines untreated. d Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 68 5.8d). Their untreated and decarbonated distributions are roughly similar, indicating that the 27% CaCO 3 within the sample exists uniformly distributed across all size classes. Soil 7, the material from the surface of the alluvial fan distributions, contains the same clay peak as Soil 6 with and without pre-treatments, although this peak is completely absent from Soil 8. Soil 7 is the most poorly sorted of the Al Mechili samples, containing material throughout the range of particle size classes encompassed by the other samples. Without pre-treatment, its distribution is almost tri-modal, containing peaks shared by Soil 6 and 8. Soil 8, however, is uni-modal and very well sorted – 91% of the material lies between 44.19 and 707.1μm. The decarbonated samples of Soil 7 and Soil 8 both show a reduction in the fine sand content, indicating the presence of carbonate sand. The respective %CaCO 3 values of 46.1% and 25.8% indicate that there are significant amounts of carbonate in the samples which contribute to the particle size distributions, but in the case of Soil 8, do not alter it drastically. Interpretation The particle size distributions therefore show marked differences between different sedimentary environments within the Al Mechili system, which reflect the local reworking of alluvial fan material through wind and water. The poor sorting of Soil 7 is consistent with a continually reworked surface consistent with its interpretation in the field as an alluvial fan which may be transporting poorly sorted sediments in flash floods. Soil 7 appears to be the material from which certain components were reworked through processes with selective taphonomic fingerprints to produce the other samples. Soil 6 contains the finest material of the samples, indicating a low-energy depositional environment, in this case alluviation and crusting on the surface of a seasonal lake. Its poor sorting over a wide size class (up to ~707.1μm) probably results from the inclusion of entire 4–5mm thick crust fining sequences in each sample. Soil 8, the material trapped below vegetation, has the best sorted particle size of the samples. This mirrors the indistinct peak in Soil 7, indicating a potential source for this size class. This size class has undergone significant isolation to produce the Soil 8 distribution: either the coarse material was selectively transported from Soil 7 material by aeolian processes, or the finer material has been deflated or leached from the original material. The former explanation appears the more parsimonious: the very marked sorting of the material makes it difficult to envisage the complete in situ leaching or deflation of fine material up to a distinct size class. Instead, Soil 8 represents wind-transported material, which is either trapped by the vegetation or forms dunes which become vegetated.The smaller grains in Soils 6 and 7 are probably, are being carried further afield by the wind, towards Europe (Macleod 1980; Yaalon 1987, 1997) or westward into the Atlantic (Muhs et al. 2010; von Suchodoletz et al. 2009). This brief analysis of the Al Mechili system illustrates the processes involved in the production of aeolian material within North Africa, and provides an aeolian-transported analogue material for comparison to the Haua Fteah and soil pit samples Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 69 Matmata Loess The aeolian deposits of theMatmata Plateau in Southern Tunisia have played a key role in the definition and understanding of desert loess (see Chapter Two) (Coudé-Gaussen 1987; Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1988; Coudé-Gaussen 1990). The sample examined here was take from Techine, Tunisia. The particle size distribution of the Matmata sample is very well-sorted (Fig. 5.9), with 83% of the material lying between 44.19–353.33μm. The magnetic susceptibility is 6.1m3kg-1, and the sample contains 2.0% organics and 17.5% CaCO 3 . The distinct particle size of theMatmata sample indicates a strong aeolian taphonomic imprint in both the carbonate and the non-carbonate samples of the material. The majority of this material is quartz, as can be observed in the thin sections of the loess from Techine. This peak is similar in sorting to Soil 8, confirming Soil 8’s similar aeolian origin (Fig. 5.9). The two samples are relatively coarse for aeolian deposits, probably reflecting their proximity to their sources (Smith et al. 2002) or different wind speeds; Soil 8 shows very local transport, and the Matmata loess lying slightly further from its source. A very distinct particle size distribution shape which survives the pre-treatment applied to the analogue sediments that indicates aeolian transport should be recognisable, if present, in the Haua Fteah sediments. 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 % Vo lu m e Particle Size(um) Figure 5.9: Particle size distribution for Matmata Loess (grey) and Soil 8 from Al Mechili (black). Dashed lines indicate decarbonated distributions, solid lines untreated. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 70 5.3.2.3 Aeolian Parent Material for the Jebel Akhdar Soils? Particle Size When the Matmata loess and Soil 8 are compared to the soil pit samples (Fig. 5.10), it is clear that the modal peak in the coarse silt/fine sand distribution in the soil pit samples may represent the presence of a similar peak to the aeolian samples, but is considerably finer. The soil pits also contain finer silts and clays which are absent from the aeolian samples, but which are present in the limestone residue. The distributions therefore indicate a significant potential input of aeolian material into the Jebel Akhdar soils. The slightly finer nature of the ‘aeolian’ peak compared to the Matmata and Soil 8 samples may reflect the greater distance of the sampling point from possible aeolian sources on the edges of the Sahara, in contrast to the more proximal source locations for the AlMechili and Matmata samples. The aeolian material in the soil pits may have also been weathered to finer size classes from an originally coarse aeolian material, although given that the curve’s shape is very steeply defined at its upper limit, it is probable that the parent material contained no coarser material. The finer material in the soils may result from the weathering of the aeolian material and, especially in the case of the clays, inclusion of limestone residue. It is therefore probable that the soils around the Haua Fteahwere formed mainly through the input of aeolian material from the edge of the Sahara, in lake deposits such as Al Mechili (N. Drake, pers. comm. 2010), but also contain some finer material weathered from the limestone itself. Particle Size(um) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 % Vo lu m e Figure 5.10: Decarbonated particle size distributions for potential parent materials for the Haua Fteah soils compared to the soil distributions: Soil Pits R and T (solid black line); Matmata loess (dashed grey line); Soil 8 Al Mechili (grey line); and Haua Fteah limestone residue (black dashed line). Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 71 Bulk Sedimentology of the Analogue Materials The Al Mechili samples are characterised by low magnetic susceptibility, relatively low %LOI (aside from Soil 6) and variable %CaCO 3 (Table 5.3). The two ‘aeolian’ samples, Soil 8 and the Matmata loess, have quite different %CaCO 3 values (56.7% and 17.5% respectively). Significant aeolian input into the Haua Fteah sediments from differing sources may therefore be difficult to detect through carbonate values, and probably impossible when the multiple sources of carbonate production within the cave are considered. Similarly, although the soil pit values are very low in %CaCO 3 , indicating that weathering of carbonate aeolian material parent material involves the leaching of carbonate from the soils, with more well-developed soils containing less carbonate, the carbonate content of such material may, once it is transported into the cave, be raised by micrite precipitation or incorporation of fine limestone spall. The soil pit samples have higher magnetic susceptibility than the aeolian samples (both ‘corrected’ and ‘uncorrected’ values). This indicates that the parent material becomes more magnetically susceptible through soil development (Tite and Linington 1975). This is especially true in Mediterranean environments, where highly seasonal rainfall and high temperatures create ideal conditions for the formation of haematite and other highly magnetic iron minerals which contribute the bulk of the magnetic signal (Ellwood et al. 1995, 2001; Maher et al. 2003). Therefore periods of low magnetic susceptibility in the Haua Fteah sequence may indicate aeolian influences, either through the direct deposition of aeolian material in the cave, or from the transport of less-developed soils into the cave from the surrounding landscape. The %LOI is relatively low across the samples, with the Haua Fteah soil pit samples containing more organic material than the Al Mechili samples. The slightly higher value of Soil 6 probably results from the incorporation of desiccated organic material fragments attached to the surface of the crusts as observed in the field. 5.3.3 Analogues and the Haua Fteah Samples Based on the previous discussion, the following points can be adopted as working characterisations of different source materials within the Haua Fteah sequence: Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) Corrected Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) % CaCO 3 % LOI (Organics) Pit R Mean 365.45 397.0 5.35 7.95 Pit T Mean 584.8 637.5 7.87 8.27 Al Marj 108.9 112.7 3.4 3.6 Soil 6 53.0 72.6 27.0 8.3 Soil 7 46.1 78.4 41.2 5.1 Soil 8 25.8 25.9 56.7 4.8 Matmata 6.1 16.9 17.5 2.0 Table 5.3: Bulk sedimentological properties of all analogue samples. %CaCO 3 values for samples from Pits R and T from calcimetry, others using loss on ignition. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 72 • aeolian-deposited contain a marked coarse silt to very fine sand particle size peak; • aeolian materials, or less-weathered soil material, may contain high %CaCO 3 ; • aeolian materials or less well-developed soil materials will have lower magnetic susceptibility than well-developed redeposited soil materials; and • soil material redeposited from the surrounding hillside will have high magnetic susceptibility, low %CaCO 3 , and fairly low %LOI. These hypotheses can now be tested and refined through the consideration of the sedimentological datasets from the Middle and Upper Trench sequences. 5.4 Bulk Sedimentology in the Haua Fteah 5.4.1 General Overview In this section, the general descriptive statistics for the bulk sedimentological data are first discussed in light of the preceding discussions, and the relationships between them investigated, prior to the examination of the temporal trends in these variables to develop a working sedimentological history of the cave which will be tested and refined in the following chapters. 5.4.1.1 Particle size The descriptive statistics for the Haua Fteah sand, silt and clay fractions are outlined in Table 5.4. The samples are dominated by silt, with restricted standard deviations in all size classes indicating a tight grouping of values and little overall variance in the broad sand/silt/clay divisions. This general lack of variation is striking in the decarbonated particle size distributions (Fig. 5.11). The majority of the non-carbonate material is coarse silt to fine sand, and it is in the shape of this peak that the majority of the variation lies. This variation is, however, only a few percentage points by volume, and does not indicate any major changes in sediment size distributions, and by extraction depositional mechanism. This is unexpected given the depth of time and global environmental changes that this sequence covers. The only markedly different distributions throughout the entire sequence are from Highest Lowest Mean Standard Deviation Pit R Average Pit T average % CaCO 3 72.5 6.1 31.3 9.8 8.0 8.3 Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) 685.6 150.5 386.8 123.7 365.5 584.8 Corrected Magnetic Susceptibility (m3kg-1) 923.0 284.3 560.6 150.0 397.0 637.5 % LOI 15.86 2.13 4.55 1.76 5.4 7.8 % Clay 5.87 25.18 16.49 4.08 21.1 18.9 % Silt 2.08 32.04 9.45 4.26 79.5 78.8 % Sand 61.99 88.66 76.65 5.12 2.5 4.9 Table 5.4: Descriptive statistics for bulk sedimentological variables in the Haua Fteah sequence. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 73 F ig ur e 5. 11 : D ec ar bo na te d pa rt ic le si ze di st ri bu ti on cu rv es fo r al ls am pl es fr om th e H au a F te ah se qu en ce by se di m en tc ol um n se ct io n. N ot e ov er al l ho m og en ei ty of se di m en ts ,a nd th e di st in ct va ri at io n in C on te xt s 42 6 an d 47 2 of th e W es t- F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch U pp er Sa m pl e C ol um n w hi ch co rr es po nd to te ph ra pe ak s. 024681012141618 %Volume 024681012141618 024681012141618 024681012141618 %Volume %Volume Pa rt ic le si ze (μ m ) Pa rt ic le si ze (μ m ) So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Up pe r W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Lo w er N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch Te ph ra Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 74 the samples from Contexts 426 and 472, which are the lenses which contain large quantities of tephra (C. Lane, pers. comm. see Chapter Nine) It is possible that de-carbonation of the samples has removed variation in the form of carbonate silt loess peaks or carbonate clays. However, as previously discussed (Chapter Four, Section 4.3.2.1), significant variation was not observed in the four samples from the Haua Fteah that were measured with the different preparation methods. It is also possible that the homogeneity of the particle size curves results from bioturbation within the layers which has mixed thin layers of different sediments, in a similar way to which these layers may be homogenised in a 5cm sample. Yet given the clarity of the stratigraphy in the field it appears unlikely that bioturbation would have obliterated major changes in particle size between contexts, although this will hypothesis will be tested through soil micromorphology in the following chapters. Given the overall similarity of the curves to those of the soil pits, it appears that the non-carbonate material throughout the sequence is strikingly similar to the non-carbonate fraction of the soils surrounding the Haua Fteah. The sediments may also contain fine material weathered from the limestone, given the overlap in particle size distributions with the limestone residue curve, either into the cave sediments directly or incorporated into the soil outside of the cave as part of the soil’s formation. This may also have been incorporated into the sediment during laboratory decarbonation and dissolution of fine limestone fragments. Such a restriction of source is perhaps surprising given the relative proximity of the cave to Saharan dust sources, and observations in the field of present-day giblis and dust storms. However, the lack of distinctly aeolian material in the cave may be related to the orientation of the cave mouth away from the southerly winds which would transport material from the Sahara. Another potential source of aeolian material is a coastal plain exposed during low sea stands (Coudé-Gaussen and Rognon 1993), yet the continental shelf along this area is relatively narrow, and it appears that significant changes in sea level may not have exposed such a wide coastal plain around Cyrenaica, removing the possibility of this source’s input (Lambeck and Purcell 2005). Finally, if such aeolian material consisted of carbonate material, it could have been removed completely from the samples during pre-treatment. The particle size data, although suffering from methodological problems, appear to very tentatively show a similar non-carbonate source material to that of the local soils. However, if the soils are the source of the material, this reworking occurred too close to the source to allow the development of any distinct taphonomic imprint to distinguish aeolian depositional environments from colluvial.Added to this, the soils appear to be a mixture of aeolian material and material weathered from the limestone, a characterisation which could easily be applied to aeolian deposits within the cave which were then mixed with limestone weathering products through bioturbation and mechanical mixing. The ambiguity of the particle size distributions highlights the necessity of micromorphological analysis to elucidate depositional environments, especially in light of the methodological problems. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 75 5.4.1.2 %CaCO 3 The %CaCO 3 values (excepting the tephra samples) lie almost exclusively above that of the soil pits. This may indicate that: • the cave deposits contain a significant input of exogenous material which is not derived from the surrounding soils throughout the sequence. e.g. carbonate aeolian material; • the sediments are derived from soil material which containsmore carbonate than thosewhich exist in the area today e.g. less well-developed soils weathering from carbonate aeolian material; or • the sediments contain soil material similar to that which exists today, but internal processes have added carbonate to them e.g. roof spall and precipitation of secondary calcite. Given the field observations previously outlined, the third scenario mechanism has a potentially strong influence on sedimentation. However, all three mechanisms probably acted on the sediments, highlighting the need for micromorphological analysis to elucidate the origin of the carbonate. 5.4.1.3 Magnetic Susceptibility The Haua Fteah samples contain many magnetic susceptibility values below those of the present soil pit samples, but none which lie above them. A large number of the values lie within the range of the modern soils. When ‘corrected’ (see Chapter Four, Section 4.3.2.2), all the values rise as expected. The ‘corrected’ mean value is above the ‘corrected’ soil pit samples (whose low %CaCO 3 content means that the correction has little impact on their values), yet some values below the soil pit values. The uncorrected magnetic susceptibility may indicate the following alternative scenarios: • thematerial in the cave is not solely soil material from the surrounding area, but has beenmixed with material with a lower magnetic susceptibility, e.g. aeolian material; • the sediments are primarily soil material from the surrounding hillside, yet the magnetic susceptibility of the external soils being eroded into the cave is changing over time; or • if local soil material, with similar magnetic susceptibility values to today, is the dominant source of sedimentation within the cave, the magnetic susceptibility is being reduced by processes within the cave. In light of the magnetic susceptibility ‘correction’: • the magnetic susceptibility of the sediments within the cave appears to have been ‘diluted’ to sometimes large extents by the inclusion of carbonate material; • the ‘corrected’ values are largely within or above those of the modern day soils. This may result from the presence of soils of higher magnetic susceptibilities, or from the alteration of the magnetic susceptibility within the cave following deposition; Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 76 • corrected values lower than the ‘corrected’ values of the soil pits may result from transportation of less well-developed soils into the cave, or aeolian sedimentation. As with the %CaCO 3 , it is probable that the magnetic susceptibility of the sediments is controlled by a number of factors, including human activity, and the usefulness of magnetic susceptibility is reduced in light of the variation of the values within the present-day landscape. 5.4.1.4 %LOI Organics The %LOI values range both above and below those of the soil pits, but their mean is lower than the soil pit values, and their restricted standard deviation indicates consistently low values in the sequence. A significant proportion of the sediments in the Haua Fteah is therefore reduced in organic matter in comparison with the modern soils. This indicates that: • the source sediments consist primarily of material lower in organic matter than modern soils, i.e. aeolian material or material weathered from the bedrock of the cave; • the soil material transported into the cave has been altered post-deposition to reduce its organic content, e.g. through decay; or • the high values in %LOI result from a process other than soil organic matter input, e.g. anthropogenic or biogenic activity within the cave. The %LOI is therefore potentially a product of both natural and cultural processes, and its origin must be examined carefully through field observations and soil micromorphology. 5.4.1.5 Correlations Between Sedimentological Variables in the Haua Fteah Magnetic Susceptibility and %CaCO 3 Magnetic susceptibility and %CaCO 3 are moderately to strongly negatively correlated (-0.521, Table 5.5). This relationship may reflect mixing on a continuum between distinct sources of sedimentation, e.g. mudflows of external soil material (high magnetic susceptibility), and the internal rockshelter environment (high%CaCO 3 fromroof-spall or secondary carbonate precipitation) or aeolian-dominated sedimentation (low magnetic susceptibility, potentially high %CaCO 3 ).With the ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility, this correlation drops to weakly negative (-0.109) and is statistically insignificant. This indicates that the correlation is due to the ‘dilution’ effect; the magnetic susceptibility of the non- carbonate fraction varies independently of the amount of carbonate in the sediment, indicating that the mechanisms which raise the respective values are different. Magnetic Susceptibility and %LOI The weak positive correlation between %LOI and uncorrected magnetic susceptibility values, nearly unchanged with ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility, indicate that, if both are considered markers of human occupation, then combined magnetic susceptibility and %LOI peaks may be useful for identifying human impact on the sediments, such as burning. The correlation, however, is weak, and given the lack of variation in the majority of LOI samples, it may be being skewed by one or Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 77 two outliers. In addition, both variables are affected by non-anthropogenic influences – organic matter decays over time (Stein 1992), animal dung may also add organic matter to the sediments independent of human activty and the variation of magnetic susceptibility in the external soil pits illustrates how wide this variability can be in the potential source materials. This correlation may be linked to the transport into the cave of well developed, high-magnetic susceptibility soil material containing organic matter. %CaCO 3 and %LOI There is no statistically significant correlation between the %CaCO 3 and %LOI values, indicating that, as with the %CaCO 3 and magnetic susceptibility, the variables are influenced by different systems. %LOI may mark human or animal influence, whilst %CaCO 3 probably reflects a range of environmental and source material changes. 5.4.1.6 Preliminary Sedimentological Hypotheses From this survey of the data, along with previous discussion of the analogue samples, the following working hypotheses can be formed and tested through the field observations in the following sections: • contexts with high magnetic susceptibility or high ‘corrected’magnetic susceptibility may potentially consist of redeposited, well-developed soils from outside the cave; • contexts with low magnetic susceptibility or low ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility originate from a source other than the surrounding modern-day soils, such as aeolian material from the edge of the Sahara or soils with different properties; • contexts with high %CaCO 3 are either dominated by aeolian deposition, the product of increased physical weathering within the cave, secondary calcite precipitation, or a combination of them all; and • %LOI is raised above the levels of the soil pits through anthropogenic or faunal activity. 5.4.2 Temporal Trends in Bulk Sedimentology In the following section, the broad temporal trends in the bulk sedimentological data are discussed. Due to the major variation in some of the variables and the subsequent inherent subjectivity of the placement of boundaries of blocks of the values referred to in the following sections (especially in %CaCO 3 ), as well as the probable multiple vectors that control each variable, as discussed above, Table 5.5: Correlations between sedimentological variables in the Haua Fteah Sequence Magnetic Susceptibility Corrected Magnetic Susceptibility % LOI % CaCO 3 Magnetic Susceptibility 0.901 0.000 0.211 0.003 -0.521 0.000 Corrected Magnetic Susceptibility 0.901 0.000 0.257 0.000 -0.109 0.125 % LOI 0.211 0.003 0.257 0.000 0.013 0.853 % CaCO 3 -0.521 0.000 -0.109 0.125 0.013 0.853 Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 78 statistical tests were not carried out on the differences between these blocks. The patterns are discussed in relation to each other and to the field facies at the end of the chapter, and further in Chapter Nine. 5.4.2.1 % Loss on Ignition (Organics) Observations The %LOI values for the entire sediment sequence are outlined in Figure 5.12. The overall mean of the data set is 4.55%, with a standard deviation of 1.76% and range between 2.13% and 15.86%. The sequence can be divided visually into three broad blocks: A. Context 414 to 417 – high, marked peaks corresponding to contexts containing anthropogenic material visible in the field; B. Context 126 to 426 – less variable in values than A, but still variable with some marked peaks. The peaks correspond with observations of anthropogenic material; C. Context 184/218 to base – consistently low values ~3–4%. Peaks on the North-Facing Profile correspond to burning events and anthropogenic material identified in the field. A slight jump in values accompanies the shift between the stepped columns of the Middle Trench: the values at the base of the Upper Middle Trench Column are slightly reduced when compared to samples from the same context in the Lower Column. Discussion A significant proportion of the sediments are reduced in organic matter content in comparison with the modern soil pits. The trend towards lower values at the base of the sequence, i.e. an overall reduction of %LOI with age, is consistent with a general degradation of organic matter with time (Stein 1992). The marked peaks which occur in the top part of the sequence, and which lie above the variation in the modern soil pit samples, are associated with visibly anthropogenically influenced layers containing charcoal in Facies Two. In Block C, the smaller peaks on the West- and North-Facing Profiles lie within the boundaries of the variation exhibited bymodern soils, yet are recognisably distinct from the surrounding values. These peaks have probably been reduced over time through organic decay, and it can be assumed that other, less marked, peaks have been lost completely. Interpretation %LOI values, although reduced over time, are an effective way of identifying and confirming anthropogenic influence on the sediments. The marked %LOI peaks in the upper part of the sequence, (specifically in Block A but also, to an extent, in Block B), could be due to more intensive occupation or use of the cave, such as stabling or middening, or animal occupation. The homogeneity of the lower portion in Block C (albeit whose values were reduced over time through organic decay) would therefore record a less intensive occupation regime in the cave. This shift in use corresponds with Context 472 at the boundary between the Dabban and Iberomaurusian layers (McBurney 1967) and whilst it could mark a shift in preservation conditions, the presence of some peaks in the lower Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 79 Figure 5.12: % Loss on Ignition (organics) values for complete Haua Fteah sequence. Red lines show the mean values for the R and T soil pits. All North-Facing Middle Trench Profile values are below both mean soil pit values. W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Lo w er W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Up pe r So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch % Losson Ignition 0 5 10 15 20 0 2 4 6 Pi tR Pi tT A B C C % Losson Ignition Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 80 MSA levels indicates that significant anthropogenic input would probably still be detectable. Spatial variation in the %LOI patterns between the West- and North-Facing Lower Sample Columns indicates that anthropogenic signatures may have been localised, and that the lower portion of the West-Facing Profile could represent a largely unaltered record of environmentally-controlled sedimentation, whilst the North-Facing Middle Trench Profile has been more heavily altered by human action. 5.4.2.2 %CaCO 3 Observations The %CaCO 3 values are variable throughout the sequence (Fig. 5.13), with a growing consistency in values in the top part of the sequence. They can be visually split into five broad blocks: A. Contexts 414 to 417 – high values, with abrupt variations. The peaks correspond to anthropogenic material observed in the field; B. Contexts 126 to 136 – relatively consistent, mid-range values, with a few small, abrupt peaks; C. Context 176 to 236 – very variable with marked, sustained peaks separated by abrupt shifts which correspond to the Middle Trench West-Facing Upper Sample Column and observations of secondary carbonate concretion; D. Context 440 to 513 – very abruptly variable with reduction in values to the top of the block; E. Context 516 to base – variable with very high peaks. These peaks are smooth with increases and decreases occurring over a number of samples. Values on the North-Facing Profile are slightly higher than those on the corresponding West-Facing Middle Trench Profile, though show similar trends in peaks and troughs. Discussion %CaCO 3 values fluctuate throughout the sequence, aside from a general reduction in Block B, yet there is subtle variation in the nature and arrangement of these fluctuations. Such variation may not correspond to changes in the environment contemporaneous with deposition; firstly, in Block A it appears that anthropogenic influence has raised the %CaCO 3 of the sediments, with peaks corresponding to observations of molluscs and ash in the field. Secondly, the correlation of Block C with the part of the sequence represented by theWest-Facing Upper Sample Columnmirrors significant secondary concretion of the sediments, and the sample column was moved in the lower part to avoid the worst of this concretion. It is therefore unclear as to how much this part of the section can be seen as containing meaningful variation. Such distinct spatial variability in carbonate content across the trench and between profiles means that direct comparisons between the different sample locations may be hindered. This variation may exist from the presence of drips, or from retreat and differential weathering of the cave walls in certain areas. However, the general correlation between the trends in the North-Facing Middle Trench Sample Column and the West-Facing Middle Trench Lower Sample Column indicate that without the presence of considerable periods of secondary carbonate deposition, Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 81 Figure 5.13: % Carbonate values for complete Haua Fteah sequence. Red line shows the mean values for the R and T soil pits, which lie too close together on this scale to plot separately. So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Up pe r W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Lo w er 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 % Carbonate 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 % Carbonate N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch A B C D E E D Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 82 trends in %CaCO 3 are traceable across the trench profiles. The magnitude of variation in the samples, and the ‘noisy’ nature of the peaks throughout the profile, coupled with the lack of any obvious sustained peaks during facies which contain large amounts of gravel illustrate the polygenetic nature of the %CaCO 3 signal. The value could, as discussed at the beginning of the chapter, be recording a mixture of <2mm carbonate from a number of sources: roof spall, secondary precipitation, and external carbonate source material. The nature of the peaks must therefore be considered in light of the field observations as well as micromorphological observations to understand the origins and environmental implications of the carbonatepresent. This will be carried out in the analysis of Facies Five to Three in Chapters Six and Seven. Interpretation From the base of the Middle Trench, there appears to be a general reduction over time in %CaCO 3 (excepting the problematic Block B). It is unclear if this is due to reduced physical weathering, a reduction in carbonate precipitation, or a change in external source material from the field and sedimentological descriptions alone. This will be further tested through micromorphological analysis in Chapters Five and Six. The large peaks at the very top of the sequence show anthropogenic influence through the addition of shell and potentially ash to the material, indicating a change in use of the cave. 5.4.2.3 Magnetic Susceptibility The lowest readings in the magnetic susceptibility data set, including almost the entire Middle Trench West and North-Facing Lower sample columns are lower than the modern soil pit values (Fig. 5.14). In contrast, only ten values in the whole sequence are higher than the soil pit range.When ‘corrected’, few values are below the ‘corrected’ soil pit values, and these are, with the exception of Context 472 (the tephra context) are in theMiddle TrenchNorth andWest-Facing Lower sample columns.Many of the samples in the Upper Part of the sequence are above that of both soil pits when ‘corrected’. There ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility can be visually split into three quite distinct blocks: A. Contexts 414 to 128 – Lower magnetic susceptibility, but at the top, highly variable magnetic susceptibility values with abrupt shifts, some corresponding to observations of anthropogenic material, but others containing little anthropogenic material; B. Contexts 406 to 441 – consistently highmagnetic susceptibility values many above the modern soil pit values. A slight decrease in the upper few contexts of this block; and C. Contexts 442 to base – variable, generally lower magnetic susceptibility, with around half below the present day soil values. The strikingly higher values of BlockB dominate the sequence, and potentially indicate a quite abrupt, change in the sedimentary regime within the cave. Discussion Given the variation which exists in the modern soils, there is a limit to the significance of the variations Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 83 Figure 5.14: Magnetic susceptibility values for Haua Fteah sequence. Corrected values in blue, uncorrected values in red. Black lines show the mean corrected values for the R and T soil pits. So ut h- Fa ci ng Up pe rT re nc h W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Up pe r W es t- Fa ci ng M id dl e Tr en ch Lo w er N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 Magnetic Susceptibility (x) Magnetic Susceptibility (x) A B B C C Pi tR Pi tT Pi tR Pi tT Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 84 shown in the sequence whether ‘corrected’ or not; variation up to 200m3kg-1 may simply represent material being transported in from different parts of the landscape in the same environmental and sedimentary regime. There are, however, distinct, broad scale trends in magnetic susceptibility, indicating that that there are true variations in the types of sediments deposited over time, even if less meaningful variation may account for the ‘noise’ of short-term variation. The ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility seeks to remove one source of this noise, the ‘dilution’ effect of the carbonate. If the magnetic susceptibility values reflect a change in sediment source, the contrast between Blocks C and B can be explained by a shift from a predominantly low-magnetic susceptibility source, such as aeolian material or less-mature soils, to one of deposition dominated by soil with magnetic susceptibilities at, or higher than, themodern soils.This shift broadly corresponds to the change between Facies Two and Three.Yet the usefulness of magnetic susceptibility as a marker for an increased input of soils from this period is problematic when viewed in light of the occupation history of the cave. As discussed previously, magnetic susceptibility can be influenced by anthropogenic activity, such as burning, as well as the breakdown of organic matter (Dearing et al. 1985; Mullins 1977; Sternberg 2001; Tite and Mullins 1971). Some peaks towards the top of Block A are markedly high in magnetic susceptibility, and contain visible concentrations of anthropogenic material, with layers identified as ‘clean’ inwash actually having lower ‘corrected’ magnetic susceptibility values than these layers. The shift in magnetic susceptibility between Blocks B and C from the layers corresponds well with the increase in the number of artefacts recovered byMcBurney in Layer XXI of the Dabban. Therefore, the jump in magnetic susceptibility may not be indicating a significant sediment source jump, but instead a shift in the use of the cave, with increased occupation overriding the environmental signatures of the magnetic susceptibility in this period, or a mixture of both. Yet, whilstMcBurney’s data for the entire Mousterian phase show a relatively low artefact density, the majority of the lithics are concentrated in Layers XXXIII–XXXV at the base of the Middle Trench, indicating a period of high occupation density which is also seen in the presence of a number of burning events in the sections. It may therefore be expected that these levels would also be massively raised in magnetic susceptibility especially given the number of burning events. However, these levels, whilst they are slightly higher than those which overly them, they are not as markedly high as those in the upper part of the sequence. This perhaps indicates that dense occupation in the Haua Fteah may not necessarily give rise to high magnetic susceptibility values, or that the later phase of dense occupation was on a scale not before seen in this area of the cave. A third mechanism to raise magnetic susceptibility is that of surface weathering and oxidation of sediments during periods of exposure. This may be consistent with a slowing of deposition in Facies Two, although without good chronological control this is difficult to assess. This mechanism may act independently of, or within the same periods as, the other two mechanisms, with inwash events separated by prolonged exposure, or occupation on exposed, relatively stable surfaces during periods of slow deposition. The low values of the lower part of the sequence may therefore reflect a period of relatively higher sedimentation rate compared to those in the upper part of the sequence. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 85 Due to the absence of micromorphological sampling in these layers it is unclear which of these scenarios is correct. There is frequent anthropogenic material observed in the field throughout the upper part of the sequence, yet some of the trends observed in the section are consistent with mass flows of soil material as identified in the profile. Interpretation The variations in magnetic susceptibility in the sequence could illustrate a mixture of the following scenarios: Environmental: The presence of highly elevated values in Block B compared to the rest of the sequence could mark a period of massive landscape instability which is eroding well-developed soils from the surrounding landscape. Before, and to an extent after, this (although the upper trench samples have been subject to anthropogenic influence), the reduced magnetic susceptibility indicates an input of aeolian material and a reduction in massive inwash events and landscape stability, or merely the transport of less well developed soils and potentially aeolian material deposited in the landscape into the cave. A second environmental hypothesis for elevated magnetic susceptibility in the cave is the presence of prolonged periods of surface exposure during periods in which sedimentation was relatively low in rate. This would therefore show a marked change in sedimentation rate from the underlying layers. Occupation Density: The source material remains essentially the same throughout the sequence, as reduced in values compared to the soil material, with some variations. There is a significant increase in anthropogenic influence on the sediments during the early Dabban, accompanying the increase in finds recorded by McBurney, which has hampered the usefulness of magnetic susceptibility as an environmental indicator. in the sediments. 5.4.3 Bulk Sedimentology: Synthesis The overall sediment sequence is outlined in Figure 5.15. The sedimentological analyses have revealed a complex range of potential influences sedimentation, with different patterns emerging from each bulk sedimentological variable. Facies Five contains a number of marked peaks in %LOI on the North-Facing Profile, correlating with sporadic, marked anthropogenic influence. Variable %CaCO 3 peaks, with a slightly higher period, may show increased roof spall, an increased carbonate aeolian input to the sediments. It may also show an increased period of micritic carbonate precipitation within the sediments driven by calcareous water dripping onto, or percolating through, the sediments during deposition, yet this precipitationmay have occurred far later than the deposition of the unit. The slightly high, but variable magnetic susceptibility values in this facies may indicate variability in source material, for example in incorporation of variable amounts of highly magnetically susceptible soil material. It may also result from the more intensive occupation recorded by McBurney in these levels, and mirrored in the %LOI peaks, periods of depositional hiatuses in deposition allowing surface weathering, or a combination of all of the above. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 86 Figure 5.15 : Summary of bulk sedimentological data and field facies. West-Facing MiddleTrenchLower West-Facing MiddleTrenchUpper South-Facing UpperTrench (n ot to sc al e) F1 F2 F3 F 5 10 0 20 0 30 0 40 0 50 0 60 0 70 0 80 0 90 0 10 00 M ag ne tic Su sc ep tib ili ty (x ) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 % C ar bo na te 0 5 10 15 % Lo ss on Ig ni tit io n (O rg an ic s) F4Fa ci es Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 87 FaciesFour, a slightly greyer, gravelly series of contexts, contains relatively lowmagnetic susceptibility, at the start of a period of markedly low magnetic susceptibility, which continues into Facies Two. Its %LOI is low, but a number of peaks on the North-Facing Profile correspond to anthropogenic material observed in the field. There is slightly elevated %CaCO 3 , probably linked to the increased roof spall which produced the gravel, driven by a period of increased physical weathering or the input of aeolian carbonate material or carbonate precipitation, either during or post-deposition of the unit. FaciesThree contains generally lowmagnetic susceptibility values,which jumpmarkedly higher during the shift to Facies Two, indicating: a marked change in sediment source in the cave (potentially from aeolian material to well-developed soil material); increased anthropogenic influence on the sediments; the presence of major sedimentary hiatuses after this point allowing oxidation of the surface material or a combination of the three. The %CaCO 3 is variable throughout, probably reflecting its multiple origins: there are observations of calcite concretion in the sections as well as layers containing gravel, and paler silty layers with a potentially carbonate aeolian component. Facies Three may therefore represent a period of deposition of low magnetically susceptible material, such as aeolian material, followed by resumed, sporadic input of a higher magnetically susceptible material, potentially soil material, later accompanied by periods of physical weathering, although the nature of the finematerial requires further investigation through soil micromorphology. Periods of increased moisture within the cave marked in the carbonate-concreted horizons may have occurred during the deposition of Facies Three, yet may also have occurred far later, with concretion occurring post-deposition. Facies Two has sustained high magnetic susceptibility values, indicating either: a consistent input of highly magnetically susceptible source material such as soil material; prolonged stratigraphic hiatuses allowing periods of surface weathering of sediment; or a consistent anthropogenic influence on the sediments which accompanies a jump in occupation intensity as recorded in the artefacts. The variable %CaCO 3 in the facies may be altered by the placing of the sample column and variations in post-depositional concretion of the sediments (see above). The %LOI jumps in the top third of the facies, indicating an increased anthropogenic input following the tephra deposition, although this may equally be related to preservation conditions. This facies, with its increased physical weathering and raised magnetic susceptibility, could mark punctuated depositions of soil material in the cave separated by limited deposition and reworking of aeolian material. It may also indicate a period when there are prolonged exposures of surfaces within the cave during sedimentary hiatuses. Alternatively, the facies may simply represent a period when the anthropogenic activity in the rockshelter overrides the environmental controls on the character of the fine material within the sediments. Facies One contains further peaks in %LOI, becoming far more pronounced towards the top of the unit, a change which is also seen in the increased variability of %CaCO 3 and magnetic susceptibility. Facies One therefore contains a marked period of anthropogenic input at its top, with the whole facies marked by large soil inwash events visible in the field. Chapter Five: Bulk Sedimentological Analyses 88 5.5 Bulk Sedimentological Analyses: Conclusions Many of the changes in bulk sedimentology outlined above do not correlate with sedimentological changes as observed in the field facies, illustrating further subtlety in the site formation processes that are not evident in the field observations. All of the variables may be driven by a number of mechanisms, both related to the deposition of the sediments as well as post-depositional processes, and each variable appears to reflect different aspects of the cave environment which vary at different times, probably for different reasons, and which remain ambiguous ahead of micromorphological analyses. It is for this reason that the field facies as defined in Section 5.2.2 will not be re-defined on the basis of the sedimentological data. Instead, the field facies will remain the framework for discussing the sedimentological framework in the rest of this thesis as they remain an important data set which records long-term changes in cave sedimentation. The relationships between the bulk sedimentological and soil micromorphological and field observations will be discussed in relation to the entire sequence in Chapter Nine, and its temporal, cultural and environmental contexts. 89 Chapter Six: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 6.1 Introduction This chapter will first outline and discuss the common micromorphological features observed in the Haua Fteah sediment sequence. This discussion will form the basis of the micromorphological interpretations of Facies Four and Five in this chapter as well of Facies Three in Chapter Seven. As outlined in Chapter Four, Facies Four and Five are the lowest facies in the Middle Trench sequence examined in this thesis. Facies Five is a series of red silt layers interspersed with burning events, whilst the overlying Facies Four is distinct in character due to its marked abundance of limestone gravel and pale colour. Both facies contained abundant MSA artefacts defined as Levalloiso-Mousterian by McBurney (see Chapter Three). 6.2 Key Micromorphological Features The Haua Fteah sediments exhibit a range of micromorphological features which inform both depositional and post-depositional processes within the cave. Many of these features are undiagnostic when considered in isolation, and many are produced by a number of interrelated processes, with equifinality posing a recurrent problem. Interpretation is therefore complex, and the features were considered in relation to each other and field observations to produce robust interpretations of their depositional and post-depositional histories in the following chapters. 6.2.1 Microstructure The microstructures observed in the Haua Fteah often exhibit multiple, different structural characteristics within a single sample, reflecting an often complex depositional and post- depositional history. A combination of the following terms has therefore been employed in their description where appropriate. 6.2.1.1 Massive Massive structures contain no separated peds and few, if any, visible voids (Stoops 2003: 68). This structure usually results from the deposition of predominantly fine material which is undisturbed by the action of soil fauna or pedogenic processes. Such deposition may occur in mass movements of material, through water flow, or aeolian processes. It may also result from the compression of porous material, or infilling of porous material by illuvial processes. Loss of structure through compression is of concern in the MSA–LSA layers as they are overlain by >4m of sediment, and gradual compaction of homogenous sediments may be difficult to discern. Loss of structure through infilling of illuvial processes should be detectable micromorphologically through the presence of infillings (Goldberg and Arpin 1999). Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 90 6.2.1.2 Granular Granular microstructures contain granules separated by non-accommodating compound packing voids (Stoops 2003: 68). These granules may be formed through bioturbation of originally massive structures by soil fauna, producing excrements (Albert et al. 1999).At the Haua Fteah, the development of such granular structures may be related to the activity of enchytraeids, mites or earthworms (Davidson et al. 2002). Granular microstruturesmay also be inherited from the granular nature of thematerial when deposited. Such material may be soil peds washed into the cave, or windblown aggregates of finer material. It is also possible that granular aggregates may have formed on the cave floor by material rolling across sporadically damp surfaces, picking up coatings of fine dust (Goldberg 2000). Features of the granules themselves aid in elucidating their origins: concentric rings of silt and clay indicate granules formed under the latter conditions, whereas if the granule fabrics are homogenous in nature, they are more likely the product of bioturbation or a granular parent material. 6.2.1.3 Vughy Vughy microstructures are apedal, with non-interconnected vughs and occasional channels and chambers (Stoops 2003: 68). Vughs can form through the breakdown and reformation of initially granular material, the dissolution of components (Stoops 2003: 65), or the illuvial deposition of material in the void space by water (Wolff and Goldberg 2007). A vughy structure can also be indicative of bioturbation, with the shape and any coatings of the voids informing on the organism which produced them, although this can be difficult (Kooistra and Pulleman 2010). Termites may produce coated channels (Mando and Miedma 1997), which are not observed in the Haua Fteah. Channels however, are, and may be produced by rooting, indicating a stabilisation and vegetation of the surface (Mallol 2006), whilst a vughy, mamillate structure may be produced by earthworm activity (Davidson et al. 2002). These taphonomic pathways have very different environmental implications, and it is the relative proportions and relationships of vughy to more loosely granular areas, as well as to more massive areas, which can support the distinction and interpretation of the processes leading to the development of the vughy structure in each fabric. 6.2.1.4 Subangular Blocky A subangular blocky microstructure contains aggregates separated by short planar voids on all or most sides, with the aggregate faces largely accommodating each other (Stoops 2003:68). Planar voids are created by shrinkage or slipping within a sediment (Stoops 2003: 65) This structure indicates that a unit has been affected by physical processes such as shrinking and swelling, or freezing and thawing, and may indicate incipient pedogenic processes (Fedoroff and Courty 1999). Weakly-developed subangular blocky structures may result from the drying out of a previously wet fabric, especially clay-rich fabrics. 6.2.2 Coarse Material There is little variation in the dominant coarse mineral material in the Haua Fteah sediments – all of the sediments contain quartz and limestone, with rare occurrences of feldspars. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 91 6.2.2.1 Quartz and Feldspars Quartz (and very rare feldspar) coarse silt and fine sand, between 50-120μm, is ubiquitous in the sediments, with ~10% present in most samples. No quartz or feldspar was observed in any of the limestone fragments in the thin sections, and the quartz has therefore probably originated largely from outside the cave, although it cannot be ruled out without further investigations (e.g. granulometry) that a limited amount has weathered from the limestone. An external origin is also supported through the presence of similar quantities of quartz in the external soil pit thin section (Section 6.2.9). Quartz therefore probably entered the site as a result of reworking of local soil material, rather than direct deposition from a source further afield (see discussion on parent material in Section 5.2.2.3). Its presence will therefore not be drawn upon as an indicator of depositional environment in the micromorphological analysis. 6.2.2.2 Limestone and Speleothem Fragments The limestone sand and gravel in the sediments (sometimes accompanied by fragments of speleothems) results from the weathering of the ceiling and walls of the cave. The presence of limestone in cave sediments is long debated in sedimentological studies (see Chapter Three), with weathering linked to freeze-thaw cycles, wetting and drying of the bedrock, diurnal changes in temperature, salt weathering or simply the exposure of an easily-weathered area of bedrock (Farrand 1975; Laville 1976; Waters 1992;White 2007). Limestone content can therefore only be used on its own as an indicator of physical weathering, or a lack of deposition of fine material. The larger fragments of limestone gravel were consciously avoided during micromorphological sampling for practical reasons, but their presence, proportion, size and orientation were recorded through the field descriptions. The same characteristics of the finer limestone gravel and sand were observed in the thin sections. Horizontally oriented, angular gravel fragments indicate their deposition on flat surfaces. More disorganised arrangements of sub-rounded to rounded clasts may indicate mass movement of material, a recognition aided by the presence of imbricated clasts. Disorganisation of the coarse material may also be caused by bioturbation of the sediments, which should be detectable through the structure of the sediments (e.g. granular, see discussion in 6.2.1.2). Rounding of limestone clasts may also occur through the chemical weathering of the clasts (Laville et al. 1980), and may be accompanied by the presence of calcitic pedofeatures in the sediments where the dissolved calcite has precipitated out of solution, although such pedofeatures would be indistinguishable from those produced by the percolation of calcareous water from the karstic system. 6.2.3 Fine Material 6.2.3.1 Colour The sediments in the Haua Fteah are predominantly red, indicating a ubiquity of oxidised iron in the sediments (Schwertmann and Taylor 1977). As discussed in Chapter Five, this red character appears consistent with the terra rossa soils surrounding the cave, although may also mark the incorporation of reddish clays weathering from the limestone directly as well as in the soils themselves. Yet the Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 92 problems of interpreting layers on colour variances alone have been discussed in Chapter Five. Iron states and therefore sediment colour can be altered post-depositionally through hydrological changes within a site, remobilising under reducing wet conditions and forming iron pans on drying and oxidation (FitzPatrick 1980: 91). The presence and interpretation of iron nodules are discussed below. Leaching of iron may also result from changes in sediment chemistry driven by the deposition of material such as guano (Shahack-Gross et al. 2004a). However, patterns of significant iron leaching or deposition unrelated to the initial deposition of the unit have not been observed in the Haua Fteah, and its stratigraphy remains largely sharp, indicating a predominantly oxidised environment with a lack of prolonged wetting periods or leaching. The colour of the sediment is also linked to other components andmineralswithin the sediments: brown- coloured sediments indicate the presence of organic matter, whilst secondary calcite precipitation may result in a whitish colour (FitzPatrick 1980: 91) yet this is not always well-expressed, and a lack of secondary precipitationmust be confirmed through soil micromorphology. Guano-rich sediments may also display a range of colours, from brown to orange-red to white (Lewis 2007; Miko et al. 2002). The mutiple vectors which may influence sediment colour therefore render it a less than reliable indicator of sediment origin, and interpretations must be primarily based on micromorphological observations of other characteristics. 6.2.3.2 Texture As discussed in Chapter Five, the texture of the finematerial, specifically the proportions of clay in the material, should be linked to changes in the source material, e.g. clayey, colluvially-redeposited soil material vs. silty aeolian sediments. Given the problems with the bulk particle size data at the Haua Fteah (Section 5.3.2.1) observations of particle size in the thin sections, whilst only semi-quantitative, are a crucial measure. However, the meaning and interpretation of variances in texture and particle size remain subject to the caveats outlined in Chapter Five with regards to differential erosion of material and soil horizons. The thin section data, and their potential for identifying depositional structures, are therefore vital for robust interpretation of the fine material texture. 6.2.4 b-fabric The b-fabric describes the origin and the patterns of orientation and distribution of interference colours in the micromass (Stoops 2003: 95). Variations in the b-fabrics observed in the Haua Fteah sediments are primarily linked to the presence of oriented clays or fine crystalline calcite. 6.2.4.1 Speckled The most common b-fabrics in the Haua Fteah are speckled, with a mixture of clay and silt making up the bulk of the fine material. Speckled b-fabrics are characterised by randomly arranged domains of oriented clays smaller than the fabric units at the scale of observation (Stoops 2003: 96). They can be subdivided into stipple-speckled, consisting of isolated and individual speckles, and mosaic- speckled, where the speckles are in contact with each other, resulting in a mosaic-like fabric (Stoops 2003: 96). Stipple-speckled b-fabrics are predominant in the Haua Fteah and imply little influence of Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 93 mechanical processes to orient the clay such as shrinking and swelling (unlike striated fabrics – see below). Mosaic-speckled b-fabrics, in contrast, are representative of a limited expression of striated fabrics, perhaps primarily through the drying of previously wet sediment (Cremeens 2005). 6.2.4.2 Striated Striated b-fabrics exhibit orientation of claywithin the groundmass, either around pores (porostriation), coarse material (granostriation) or in striations within the groundmass. This orientation occurs through physical stress in the sediments, such as wetting and drying (Blockhuis et al. 1990) or cryoturbation (Solé-Benet et al. 1990). In the Haua Fteah, cross-striated b-fabrics, that is, where elongated zones or streaks in which domains show more or less simultaneous extinction and intersect (Stoops 2003: 96–97), occur solely in units which are arranged into fining sequences, and are therefore interpreted as the product of wetting and drying of inwash material. 6.2.4.3 Crystallitic Crystallitic b-fabrics contain small birefringent mineral grains that determine the interference colours of the fine mass as a whole (Stoops 2003: 95). In the Haua Fteah, b-fabrics contain both micritic and sparitic calcite. Both forms are linked to the presence and evaporation of carbonate-rich groundwater within the cave (Goldberg 1979a; Guo and Fedoroff 1990; Macphail and Goldberg 2003). Needle calcite may also be biogenic in origin, forming through the activity of bacteria or fungal hyphae (Loisy et al. 1999; Ould Mohamed and Bruand 1994; Phillips and Self 1987; Verrecchia and Verrecchia 1994) potentially linked to the past organic content of the sediments (Becze-Deák et al. 1997). The presence of micritic calcite in units withmixed b-fabrics may result from two scenarios. Scattered micritic crystals which give small pinpricks of high birefringence, may result from the precipitation of fine calcite crystals in the groundmass through limited amounts of moisture in the calcareous groundmass (Durand et al. 2010) either during or long after deposition. However, these small calcitic flecks may also show fine sand and dust weathering from the limestone, as well as silt-sized calcitic aeolian material (as discussed in Chapter Five). The context, continuity and nature of the crystals within the crystallitic groundmass and their relation to other crystallitic pedofeatures are therefore vital to elucidate their origin. 6.2.4.4 Undifferentiated Undifferentiated b-fabrics are characterised by an absence of interference colours in the fine mass and may be caused by: the dominance of short-range order clay minerals; the masking of b-fabrics by humus or sesquioxides; the presence of opaque material; or the random orientation of clay particles (Stoops 2003: 95). In the Haua Fteah these usually occur in areas associated with organic material indicating a potentially increased anthropogenic influence, as well as in areas of severe manganese staining indicating changing redox conditions at some point following deposition of the unit. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 94 6.2.5 Textural Pedofeatures 6.2.5.1 Fine Material Laminations Laminations in the fine material, often very subtle and only a few microns thick, indicate very ephemeral surfaces which existed in a punctuated, low-energy depositional environment such as may exist with aeolian deposition, or very local, small colluvial movements and trampling by animals and people (Goldberg 2000). The survival of subtle laminations indicates a lack of bioturbation, which could infer a rapidity of sedimentation. These laminations are often simply marked by slight changes in groundmass density, and are interpreted in the Haua Fteah sediments as generally indicative of a predominantly dry environment with punctuated aeolian deposition and reworking, limited sediment input and breaks in sedimentation. More distinct laminations marked by fining sequences may suggest small-scale alluvial deposition and puddling, and the formation of depositional crusts (see next section). Freeze-thaw processes may also produce laminations within fine material (van Vliet-Lanoë 1998; van Vliet-Lanoë et al. 1984), however, these are often also related to the development of a platy structure and resemble structural micro-crusts (see next section). Laminations in the fine material may therefore reflect a range of processes, yet these are usually identifiable through examination of the nature and level of development of laminations. Very fine, ephemeral laminations expressed in slight colour changes or orientation of sand grains probably reflect punctuated aeolian/dry deposition, and or trampling or dampening (Goldberg 2000), whilst more strongly-developed laminations which show sorting ofmaterial may be linked to small-scale colluvial movements, puddling or freeze-thawing, and form a continuum with the crusts discussed in the next section. 6.2.5.2 Crusts Crusts can be classified as structural or depositional, although some continuum exists between these two types (Mücher et al. 1988; Valentin 1991), and both are linked to the action of water on a surface. Structural crusts form through the in situ breakdown of material on a surface through water action, whilst depositional crusts are linked to the deposition of material, usually as a slurry of wet material on a surface or puddling and subsequent drying (Bresson and Valentin 1994; Pagliai and Stoops 2010; West et al. 1990). The thicker crusts and fining sequences in the Haua Fteah, some of which cover entire units, are primarily depositional in nature. These may show reworking of material from within the cave or transport of soil material into the cave in mudflows or sheetwash, as well as inputs from inside the karstic system. Smaller crusts represent puddling, followed by the drying and cracking of the material. These crusts sometimes have cross-striated b-fabrics (Macphail and Goldberg 2003) as a result of shrinking and swelling during the drying of wet clayey material. Some crusts contain more than one fining sequence indicating depositional events. The finer crusts are rarely found as complete layers in the Haua Fteah sediments, but crust fragments are common, and this fragmentation may take place after burial through bioturbation, as well as through the mechanical trampling of material by animals and humans prior to burial. The degree of rounding of fragments can also indicate weathering processes – water action may dissolve and round the fragments, or they can be rolled and rounded on an exposed dry surface. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 95 Crust features observed in the sediments are also sub-millimetre in size, with micro-crusts resulting from small, very localised wetting and sorting of the sediment (Goldberg 1979a). These crusts are probably more structural in nature, resulting from drips of water from the ceiling wetting surfaces and, with an effect similar to rainsplash, breaking down structure and aggregates and spreading fine material across the surface. These fine micro-crusts represent discontinuous, fine exposed surfaces (Goldberg 2000). Such crusts may also result from freeze-thaw processes within the sediment (e.g. van Vliet-Lanoë 1998). 6.2.5.3 Coatings and Infillings Textural coatings in void spaces, such as clay coatings in a silty clay groundmass, result from the transport in suspension of fine material through sediments (Stoops 2003: 108). Fine material has been mobilised in the overlying sediment, either through physical or chemical weathering, or through the addition of material which includes a suspension of fine particles. These features may indicate either movement of water down the profile within the cave (Goldberg 1992), freeze-thaw processes (van Vliet-Lanoë 1998; van Vliet-Lanoë et al. 1984) or the transport of water and wet material from outside of the cave e.g. throughmudflows or sheetwash (Goldberg and Arpin 1999). In the Haua Fteah sediments these features occur most regularly in the top few centimetres under sediments interpreted as potential mass flows of material. Their ‘dusty’ character indicates their origin in a slurry of mixed, wet material, a movement of water over a dusty, unconsolidated surface, or surface disturbance, rather than prolonged illuviation under a stable surface (which would create more oriented, cleaner clay coatings e.g. French 2003; French et al. 2009; Gebhardt 1993). It is possible that pore coatings deeper in the sediments, formed by prolonged illuviation, may have been erased by bioturbation, however, a a lack of evidence for prolonged leaching from other lines of micromorphological evidence, such as iron pedofeatures (see Section 6.2.7.1), as well as the clarity of textural context horizons in the field, and the frequent survival of fine laminations within the finematerial means that this explanation of the absence of such coatings from the sediments remains unlikely. Coatingsmay also develop around coarsematerial. Theymay form in pore spaces between the sediment aggregates, in the manner just described, but coatings can also form prior to deposition, with dusty materials becoming attached to the coarse material through rotation across dusty surfaces (Goldberg 2000). Mass slurry movements may also have the same effect, with deformation structures occurring around coarse material as they move within the material (Stephens et al. 2005). 6.2.6 Crystalline Pedofeatures 6.2.6.1 Calcitic Hypocoatings Secondary precipitation of calcite is linked to the formation of calcitic hypocoatings, which form a continuum with complete concretion of the groundmass by carbonate and the formation of incipient flowstones. Hypocoatings form in pores either through evaporation of carbonate-rich groundwater which may be related to biological activity such as root pores (Durand et al. 2010;Wieder and Yaalon 1982), or which may simply be travelling down through existing pore spaces in arid and semi-arid Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 96 environments (Courty and Fédoroff 1985; Courty et al. 1987). In karstic caves, carbonate-saturated water is available through water dripping from the ceiling (Goldberg 1979a; Macphail and Goldberg 2003). Other sources of calcite, however, include plant ash, which can be dissolved and recrystallised as calcitic pedofeatures under certain conditions (Schiegl et al. 1996). 6.2.7 Amorphous and Cryptocrystalline Pedofeatures 6.2.7.1 Manganese/Iron Features Dendritic manganese oxide nodules are ubiquitous throughout the Haua Fteah sediments. Reduced iron and manganese in the soil water oxidise following changes in redox conditions (Veneman et al. 1976), mainly the introduction of oxygen to a previously reduced environment through soil pore space. These mottles therefore indicate past changes in hydrology within the site (Ransom et al. 1987; Taylor 1982). The genesis of these features in the Haua Fteah is problematic given the excavation history of the site – they may have formed relatively recently, during the 1950s, following the burial of the 1950s excavation, or in the present excavations prior to sampling and they thus cannot act as definitive environmental indicators. Numerous iron nodules are present in the thin sections. With a similar groundmass to the surrounding sediments, these nodules have a range of boundary types, from diffuse to sharp. These nodules have formed in situ in the case of those with diffuse boundaries, or have been re-deposited either through bioturbation or other disturbance in the case of those with sharp boundaries. Such iron nodules form through redoximorphic processes similar to that of the dendritic manganese nodules, yet represent a slightly longer saturation of the groundmass, and a rapid re-entry of oxygen into the sediment following saturation (Veneman et al. 1976). The hydrology of the cave therefore appears relatively stable; significant inputs of water to the cave appear brief in duration, and only moderate amounts of moisture retained within the sediments. 6.2.8 Inclusions Inclusions of both biogenic and anthropogenic material are abundant in the Haua Fteah sediments. 6.2.8.1 Pedorelicts There are a number of iron-impregnated aggregates within the sediments which have a groundmass, internal structure and b-fabric different from the surrounding material (Macphail and McAvoy 2008), and are potentially fragments of material from outside the cave, or ‘pedorelicts’ (Boschian 1997; Goldberg 1979a). These can be transported into the cave through colluvial processes or mass movements, or trampled in by animals or people. 6.2.8.2 Dung The natural cave for animals afforded by the Haua Fteah makes it unsurprising that dung is present throughout nearly all of the slides. The dung consists of yellow-grey silt aggregates with mainly spongy structures and isotropic fine material. Faecal spherulites, formed in the gut of herbivores Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 97 (Brochier et al. 1992; Canti 1998, 1999), are common, though not always present or preserved in archaeological contexts. Ubiquity of herbivore dung is consistent with the observations of Bos and Ammotragus throughout the archaeological sequence that underlines the potential use of the shelter by animals (Higgs 1967; Klein and Scott 1986). Phytoliths are ubiquitous in the dung, both articulated and non-articulated. There are also rare diatoms within the dung, potentially transported from where the animals had been drinking. There is only one potential preserved dung pellet in the sediments (Sample 1000, Chapter Seven, Section 7.2.2), and the majority of the dung is fragmented into sub-millimetre blocks or lenses. The arrangement and composition of these dung fragments can indicate their depositional environment: lenses may develop from the trampling of dung on surfaces (as observed in stabling deposits e.g. Macphail andCruise 2001; Shahack-Gross et al. 2003), the weathering and flaking of larger fragments during exposure, or compressed and elongated through mass movements of wet sediment. Blocky fragments may result from the breakdown of larger aggregates, either on a surface or through mass movements and mechanical mixing of sediments. 6.2.8.3 Shell Small fragments of shell are present in many of the samples, and reflect a range of sources. Eggshell may be produced by nesting birds, present today as well as in the past (MacDonald 1997). Both marine and terrestrial mollusc shells are abundant throughout the 1950s archive. Marine shells would have to have been transported from the sea either intentionally or unintentionally on vegetation by people into the site. Land snails may also have been exploited by people (indeed this is indicated in the upper layers of sequence). Thus, shells may be linked to occupation, though given the relative rarity and fragmented nature of the shells in the thin sections it is difficult to infer their origin. The fossilised silica structures of nummulites weathered from the limestone are also common in the sediments, and have been observed in the external soil pits (Section 6.2.9), but are often discernible from shell fragments through their morphology and birefringence. 6.2.8.4 Bone Bone is frequently present, most commonly in the form of coarse sand-sized splinters and fragments. This indicates high levels of fracturing, either through natural weathering (Behrensmeyer 1978) by the trampling of bones exposed on a surface (Olsen and Shipman 1988), or human activities such as butchery or carnivore gnawing crushing and breaking bone (Pickering and Egeland 2006). Bones and fragments may become weathered through prolonged surface exposure causing surface cracking (Behrensmeyer 1978). Mechanical movement from processes such as freezing and thawing (Fisher 1995) may also round bone fragments, although this may also be achieved through trampling on surfaces (Lyman 1994). It is, however, also possible that raptors roosting in the Haua Fteah may have contributed to the bone assemblage with their kills and excrement, which may be indicated through evidence of partial digestion of the bones (Goldberg 1979b; Villa and Soressi 2000). Dissolution and diagenesis within sediments also impact on the preservation of bone and may indicate the movement Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 98 of phosphate-rich water through the sediments (e.g. Nielsen-Marsh and Hedges 2000; Shahack-Gross et al. 2004), although there are only limited instances of such dissolution in the Haua Fteah sediments. When burnt, bone changes in colour from pale yellowish (unburnt) to browns and blacks (charred), and finally to grey to white (calcined), although colour is only a relative measure of the degree of burning (Nicholson 1993; Shipman et al. 1984) and may also be related to staining of the bone by iron or manganese (e.g. Shahack-Gross et al. 1997). If they are burnt, the presence of burnt bone splinters in the Haua Fteah sediments may not indicate the burning of bone for fuel, but more generally the inclusion of waste materials within a fire. 6.2.8.5 Flint/Chert Flint is present within a number of layers, with many angular fragments, and in rare cases a curving edge which may represent a cross section through a bulb of percussion. These smaller fragments probably represent microdebitage from flint-knapping within the cave. There are also rare well- rounded clasts which may have weathered from the bedrock; chert sources exist in the local area of the Haua Fteah, with outcrops in the same limestone bedrock as the cave (S. Jones, pers. comm. 2010). 6.2.8.6 Plant Ash and Charred Organic Material The samples contain a range of burnt plant materials, from charcoal and charred materials to ash, indicating the presence of different temperatures and degrees of burning (Canti 2003). Plant ash is primarily composed of calcium, potassium, silica, phosphates andmagnesium, the proportions ofwhich vary with the plant type, age and organ (Wattez and Courty 1987). Whilst the cell structure preserved in charcoal can aid identification, the morphology of ash can also be diagnostic. For example, burning changes the calcium oxalate crystals present in plant fibres (in the form of druses and rhombohedral crystals) into calcium carbonate pseudomorphs, leaving their structure intact (Brochier et al. 1992). In some instances these pseudomorphs may not become fragmented, and may instead preserve an ashed cell structure as well as calcitic pseudomorphs of plant cells (Canti 2003). The degree to which calcitic pseudomorphs and these ash structures are preserved gives some indication of the past hydrological regime of the cave, as they are easily dissolved over time by water (Schiegl et al. 1996). 6.2.8.7 Vesicular Silica Aggregates In alkaline conditions, silica from phytoliths and plant skeletons can flux under relatively low temperatures, forming vesicular ‘slags’ (M. Canti, pers. comm. 2010). ‘Slag’ was recovered from the 1950s excavations (McBurney 1967) and from the present excavations. Smaller fragments were observed in a number of the thin sections, and are grey-green in PPL, and isotropic in XPL, and have vesicular internal structures. SEM analysis of the fragments within the impregnated blocks and recovered from the flotation samples confirmed the predominance of SiO 2 in the fragments (Appendix Three). The presence of this vesicular silica indicates the presence of a silica-rich fuel, e.g. grasses (Canti 2003; Macphail and Cruise 2001). Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 99 6.2.9 Micromorphological Observations from Soil Pit T – Modern Analogue Amicromorphological sample from Soil Pit T (discussed in Chapter Five, Section 5.3.1) was analysed to provide a soil analogue for the observations from the sediment sequence (Fig. 6.1). In the field, Soil Pit T shows the profile of a chromic luvisol consisiting of red (2.5YR 4/6) clayey silt with a well-developed irregular blocky structure and a weakly-developed Bt horizon, and rare 500μm 1mm 1mm Cross-striatedb-fabric,XPL Micritic calciticnodule,XPL Root,PPL a b c1cm Figure 6.1: Slide scan and microphotographs from Soil Pit T. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 100 cm-scale calcitic nodules. The sample, taken from the diffuse contact between the A and Bt horizons shows a red (PPL) clay loam with occasional quartz coarse silt to fine sand and very rare coarse sand- sized limestone/silica fossil fragments. It has a well developed subangular to sub-rounded irregular structure (30% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to grano- and cross-striated (50:10:40). There are rare roots within the channels, and very rare struck flint fragments. There are rare medium sand to gravel-sized micritic calcitic nodules, rare fragments of nummulite fossils and rare micritic and sparitic calcitic coatings to voids. Pit R has a very clay-rich fabric, with a moderate to poorly-developed ped structure and orientation of the clays within the fine material, indicating extensive pedogenic processes in the form of shrinking and swelling consistent with a warm, seasonally dry/wet environment. The micritic nodules and coatings show a continuum of carbonate nodule development, with the b-fabric becoming warped and striated around the nodules through the expansion of these nodules. The formation of these nodules is common in highly seasonal, warm environments (Bridges 1997: 11). 6.2.10 Summary of Micromorphological Features The micromorphological features observed in the Haua Fteah sequence and their interpretations are outlined in Table 6.1. In the following chapters, percentages of features from visual estimates were classified according to the ranges outlined in Table 6.2. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 101 Feature Type Feature Interpretation of Process Microstructure Massive Potential aeolian or colluvial deposition with little bioturbation. Granular Potential aeolian or colluvial deposition of granular material, or heavy bioturbation. Vughy Reformation of granular structure through mudflow deposition or partial bioturbation of massive structures. Subangular blocky Wetting/drying of massive material. Coarse material Quartz and feldspar Potential aeolian or colluvial re-deposition of soil. Limestone and speleothem fragments Physical weathering from within cave. Fine material Colour Red; potential soil material. Yellow-brown; potential aeolian silt deposition. Brown; organics. Very tentative. Texture Clayey; potential soil material or fines weathered from limestone. Silty; potential aeolian material. b-fabric Stipple-speckled Mixed slurry or aeolian deposition. Mosaic-speckled Mixed slurry, wetting and drying. Micritic calcitic crystallitic Potential aeolian carbonate dust deposition or secondary precipitation of carbonate. Cross-striated Wetting and drying of clay-rich sediment. Undifferentiated Humic staining or lack of clayey material. Textural pedofeatures Fine material laminations Punctuated, small-scale deposition on ephemeral surfaces. Crusts Wetting of the surface through drips or sheetwash. Clay coatings and infillings Wet, colluvial movements of potential soil material. Silty coatings to coarse material Rolling of coarse material on sporadically damp surfaces or movement in a slurry. Crystalline pedofeatures Calcitic hypocoatings Percolation of calcite-rich water through sediments. Amorphous and cryptocrystalline pedofeatures Manganese dendritic nodules Dampening and drying of sediments. Iron nodules Wetting and drying of sediments. Well-rounded nodules probably re-deposited, diffuse nodules in situ. Inclusions Pedorelicts Soil fragments transported by humans or animals. Dung Presence of animals within the cave. Shell Activity of humans or birds. Bone Activity of humans or animals. Flint/chert Angular: microdebitage from knapping; rounded: weathering from bedrock. Ash and Charred Organic Material Burning. Vesicular silica aggregates Burning of silica-rich fuel in alkaline environment Description Percentage Very rare <1% Rare 1-3% Few 3-5% Occasional 5-10% Common 10-25% Frequent 25-50% Dominant 50-70% Very dominant >70% Table 6.2 (Left): Description of percentage classes used in micromorphological descriptions. Table 6.1 (Above): Summary table of intepretation of micromorphological features. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 102 6.3 Facies Five 6.3.1 Facies Five: Field Description and Chronology Facies Five, at the base of the Middle Trench, consists of red silt layers (full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four) interspersed with the most marked examples of anthropogenic influence on the sediments in the MSA levels: a number of ‘burnt’ lenses on the North-Facing Profile (discussed further in Chapter Eight). A lens of dark organic matter, Context 522, runs along the contact between Contexts 523 and 521 on the West-Facing Profile for 1.5m from the centre of the section towards the north. This contact, when traced across the South and East-Facing Profiles also contains a number of burnt lenses (Fig. 6.2). The facies includes Contexts 528 to 520 on the West-Facing Profile, and 538 to 521 on the North-Facing Profile (Fig. 6.3). 6.3.2 Facies Five: Micromorphological Observations Micromorphological sampling consisted of four samples, two on the West-Facing Profile (covering Contexts 523 to 520) and two on the North-Facing Profile (covering Contexts 528 to 521) (Fig. 6.3). Some contexts can be traced between the profiles. As with each of the following sections, the micromorphological results are summarised in Table 6.4 at the end of the section, with full descriptions of each micro-fabric in Appendix Five. Figure 6.2: Photograph of North-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing Facies Five at the end of the 2008 season. Facies Five continues from the top of the lower white ranging pole division to the base of the trench. Divisions are 50cm. Note thin lenses of charcoal to bottom left of the facies. Photo: G. Barker. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 103 F ig ur e 6. 3 L oc at io n an d sa m pl in g of F ac ie s F iv e se di m en ts (g re y) fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al an al ys is .S ha de d ar ea s ex pa nd ed be lo w .D ra w in g L .F ar r. S N E W W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 20 37 22 42 20 28 20 21 57 0 69 3 52 1 52 3 52 4 56 3 52 8 56 5 52 5 D ab ba n (X VI -X XI V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) M SA (X XV -X XX V) 52 0 52 4 52 6 52 3 52 4 56 5 52 1 52 8 56 4 56 3 0 1 2m 50 cm 0 Fa ci es 1 Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 Fa ci es 5 N S E W 20 28 20 21 20 00 26 66 93 8 Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 104 6.3.2.1 Contexts 528–524, North-Facing Profile Context 528 In the field, Context 528 is a red clayey silt (2.5YR 4/8) with 5% horizontally-orientated limestone gravel. There are 5% charcoal inclusions (2–4mm) and 3% pale yellow silty lenses ~2cm long. The lower boundary is clear over 2–3mm, and the context is redder than (564) below. Micro-fabric 2021:6 contains the top of this context, a brown-yellow (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel, and a massive to vughy microstructure (10% porosity). It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20) b-fabric. There is rare burnt occupation material concentrated towards the top of the unit, including vesicular silica aggregates and few, well- rounded iron nodules (Fig. 6.4a). There are few dung lenses, which vary from pale yellow silt with phytoliths (Fig. 6.4b) and spongy structure, as well as rare lenses of silty clay with a similar spongy structure to the dung, and ashed plant structures (Fig. 6.4c). Its lower boundary was not sampled. The silty texture of the fine material suggests that the material probably did not originate from soils similar to the surrounding modern clayey soils. The dispersion of the micritic component to the b-fabric throughout the groundmass, and lack of concretion of areas or calcitic hypocoatings to voids may indicate that this calcite spalled as dust from the cave walls, or was transported into the cave as Figure 6.4 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 528. 20 21 :6 (5 28 ) (568) 2021:6Rounded iron nodules,PPL 1mm a 2021:6Dung lenses, PPL 500μm b 1mm 2021:6Dung and ash/silica structure,PPL c Sample 2021 1cm Co nt ex t Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 105 aeolian dust, rather than precipitating out into the groundmass through the percolation of carbonate- rich water through the sediments, either during deposition or far after, although this scenario is still possible. Dung lenses and the horizontal orientation of the gravel potentially demarcate ephemeral surfaces in an environment of punctuated, mainly dry, aeolian sedimentation and reworking. The low porosity of the fabric and the survival of these laminations suggest a lack of bioturbation, potentially indicating a relatively rapid (but still punctuated) depositional regime. The iron nodules contain a similar groundmass to the micro-fabric, indicating that these result from sporadic wetting of the fabric rather than their inclusion as pedorelicts from outside the cave. Their rounded nature and sharp boundaries indicate that they have been reworked, perhaps close to the surface, potentially through trampling prior to burial. The anthropogenic material towards the top of the unit may be incorporated from the overlying Micro-fabric 2021:5 (see below) through burning and deposition of material on a dry, unconsolidated surface, yet the rounded nature of the inclusions indicates reworking of the occupation material on the cave floor, potentially throughout the deposition of the unit. The fine laminations and lack of bioturbation therefore suggest that Context 528 was deposited relatively rapidly potentially through aeolian processes, whilst occupation material was reworked from around the cave on ephemeral surfaces. Context 568 Context 568 in the field is a lens of charcoal and ash which contains two micro-fabrics, 2021:5 and 4 (Fig. 6.5). Micro-fabric 2021:4 is a grey-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with common limestone fine to coarse sand and a vughy to very weakly-developed granular microstructure. It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (85:15) b-fabric. There is rare bone and shell, and few blocky fragments of charcoal. There are frequent fragments of calcitic ash in the groundmass (Fig. 6.5a), and rare fragments of vesicular silica (Fig. 6.5b and c). There is a lens of material similar to 2021:5 at the top of the unit, and few dung lenses and blocks. Its lower boundary is prominent and sharp. Micro-fabric 2021:5 is a red-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel and a vughy to weakly-developed subangular blocky structure. It has a stipple-speckled b-fabric. The groundmass is coloured by fine silt-sized organics. It contains common larger blocky charcoal fragments, potentially burnt bone and shell (Fig. 6.5b and c). Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. The diffuse lower boundary of 2021:5 indicates that the lower half of this lens is in situ, with occupation potentially taking place on an unconsolidated surface, consistent with the above intepretation of Micro-fabric 2021:6. Its sharp upper boundary indicates that it has been truncated with the deposition of Micro-fabric 2021:4. 2021:4 contains fragmented combustion material in a silty matrix, consistent with truncation and reworking by colluvial processes. There is no apparent cementation or dissolution of the ash aggregates, indicating a potentially relatively dry or rapid environment of redeposition after burning, or at least a lack of strong diagenetic processes acting on them whichmay indicate prolonged Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 106 exposure (Mallol et al. 2010; Schiegl et al.1996). The granular nature of the fine material may be due in part to the high proportion of ash aggregates within the groundmass, as well as from bioturbation resulting from an initially high organic content. Micro-fabric 2021:6 does not appear rubefied, despite underlying an in situ burning event in 2021:5 and 4. This may indicate a low temperature for the burning or a short period of time (Canti and Linford 2000). However, as the shape or extent of the feature beyond the section is unknown, it is unclear whether this represents the edge of a larger area of intense combustion, or the centre of a small, localised burning event. The presence of vesicular silica aggregates indicates a source of fuel with a high silica content, such as grasses (Canti 2003), which may have been used as kindling for a fire based mainly on the wood indicated by the presence of wood ash pseudomorphs. Context 568 therefore appears to be material from a burning event on an unconsolidated surface, which was truncated by a colluvial movement, potentially relatively rapidly after deposition as the combustion material which was reworked and buried within the colluvial sediments does not appear to be excessively weathered. 2021:4Ash, PPL 2021:5 2021:4 (5 68 ) (5 63 ) (5 28 ) a 2021:5 Generalview showing burnt bone andvesicularsilica,PPL 2mm c 1mm 1mm 2021:5and 4 Charredbone (F5) and and vesicularsilica (F4),PPL b Sample 2021 1cm Figure 6.5 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 568. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 107 20 21 :1 Im br ic at io n, PP L 20 21 :2 O rg an ic le ns ov er ly in g du ng le ns ,P PL 20 21 :1 -2 In te rfa ce cr us t, PP L 20 21 :3 Bu rn tm at er ia l, PP L (563) (568) 2021:32021:22021:1 2m m c 50 0μ m 1m m 1m m a b d c Sa m pl e 20 21 1c m Context F ig ur e 6. 6: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 56 3. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 108 Context 563 Context 563 is a yellowish-red clayey silt which becomes redder towards its top (5YR 4/6 at top, 5YR 5/6 at base). It contains 15% horizontally-orientated limestone fine and coarse gravel. Towards the base there are subtle horizontal laminations of pale yellow silt 3–4cm long. The groundmass is increasingly clayey towards the top of the unit. The lower boundary is clear but slightly interleaved with the underlying charcoal lens. Context 563 contains three micro-fabrics. 2021:1 is a yellow-orange brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone coarse silt to fine gravel. It has a vughy to moderately-developed granular microstructure with 20% porosity. The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is rare bone and shell and occasional well-rounded iron nodules/pedorelicts. Its lower boundary is distinct but sharp, with areas of potential fine sand imbrication at its base (Fig. 6.6a). Micro-fabric 2021:2 is a pale orange-yellow brown (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with a massive to weakly-developed subangular blocky structure. There is frequent limestone at its base, becoming dominant in the centre of the unit, and common at the top of the unit. The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is rare burnt occupation material. There are common dung lenses up to 5cm long in the base of the unit, one underlying a slight concentration of charred organic material, 150–250μm thick (Fig. 6.6b). A structural crust seals the top of the unit (Fig. 6.6c). The micro-fabric’s lower boundary is faint but sharp. Micro-fabric 2021:3 is a pale brown-orange (PPL) sandy silt loam with common fine limestone sand to gravel and a vughy microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There is rare burnt and unburnt occupation material (Fig. 6.6d). There are rare dung lenses, and the unit becomes less coarse towards the top, where the fine material contains strong horizontal laminations. There is a calcitic hypocoating to a large bone, with a potential depositional crust beneath it. The lower boundary is faint but sharp and marked by a lack of the occupation material (which is abundant in 2021:4). The fine material in Context 563 is largely consistent throughout the fabrics, its silty texture and partially crystallitic b-fabric component suggesting a mixture of potentially aeolian silt and limestone dust weathering from the cavewalls, although themicritic calcite could conceivably also be the result of post-depositional precipitation. The arrangements of the fine and coarse fabric components, however, mark distinct changes in sedimentation between the micro-fabrics. 2021:3 at its base shows an initially chaotic mixture of material, probably resulting from colluvial reworking or potentially bioturbation. This reworking may have incorporated occupation debris from the underlying Context 568, yet the presence of a large bone indicates continued occupation nearby. The lower boundary is clear, and the potential depositional crust preserved under the large bone (presumably protected from trampling or reworking on the surface by the position of the bone) indicates that the colluvial movement may have been initially wet. Dung lenses towards the top of 2021:3 demarcate ephemeral surfaces in an environment of punctuated small-scale, aeolian deposition and reworking. The preservation of these fine laminations indicates a relative rapidity of deposition and lack of bioturbation, despite a probable Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 109 high organic content of the sediments originating from the dung. These laminations are especially marked in 2021:2, with longer dung lenses and an increase in limestone fine sand. This may indicate a slowing of fine material deposition, a restriction of fine sediment source, an increase in physical weathering or a combination of all three. One of these lenses is overlain by a very thin layer of fine charcoal silt (Fig. 6.6b) indicating anthropogenic or natural burning and reworking of charcoal within the cave. Towards the top of 2021:2 the relative decrease in limestone sand indicates an increase in the rapidity of fine material deposition, or a reduction of physical weathering. The structural crust at the top of the unit may represent a prolonged sedimentary hiatus, during which the surface was dampened. This is overlain by the relatively disorganised 2021:1, with slight imbrication in the sand-sized material at its base indicating a wet colluvial flow that overlaid the semi-consolidated, crusted surface with no truncation. The fine material in Context 563 was therefore potentially deposited by aeolian processes, and mixed with physical weathering products. 2021:3 marked a colluvial reworking of this material, and the occupationmaterial frombelow,whichwas followed by aeolian deposition in 2021:2 and a sedimentary hiatus. This micro-fabric was then capped by another colluvial reworking of aeolian sedimentation. Occupation material is present throughout the context. Context 524 Context 524 is a yellowish-red (5YR 5/8) clayey silt with 2% coarse sand to fine limestone gravel, (1–4mm). It has a sharp lower boundary and contains a wavy lens of charcoal and ash. Micro-fabric 2028:5 contains the upper part of 524. It is a red-brown silty clay loamwith few limestone fine to coarse sand clasts and a massive/vughy microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to undifferentiated (80:20). There are occasional dung, few depositional crust and very rare ash fragments, and rare flint and shell, with rare silty coatings to the coarse components, as well as lenses of 2028:4 (Fig. 6.7a). Its lower boundary was not sampled. The red colour of the unit suggests an increased iron content relateive to the surrounding sediments, yet this may also result from the slide being thicker than 30μm in places rather than a definite change in source material of surface alteration. This thickness also hampered assessment of the b-fabric. Silty coatings to coarse components potentially indicate these components rolling around on periodically damp surfaces, picking up coatings of fine material. The depositional crust fragments indicate periods of puddling or sheetwash, followed by drier periods during which the crusts were disrupted and fragmented, possibly through trampling or bioturbation. Context 524 therefore potentially shows the punctuated deposition and reworking of material through aeolian processes, deposition which is very sporadically interrupted by sheetwash episodes and dampening of the sediments. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 110 F ig ur e 6. 7: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt s 52 4 an d 52 3. (523) (521) 2000:3 20 28 :3 20 28 :4 (524) 20 28 :5 2m m 20 28 :5 In te rle av ed le ns es of 20 28 :4 ,P PL 20 00 :3 Ch ar re d or ga ni cs ,P PL 20 28 :3 As h le ns ,P PL 20 28 :4 G en er al vi ew ,P PL 50 0μ m 2m m 2m m b c d a W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile Sa m pl e 20 00 Sa m pl e 20 28 1c m Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 111 6.3.2.2 Contexts 523, North and West-Facing Profiles On the West-Facing Profile, 523 is a yellowish-red (5YR 5/8) massive homogenous clayey silt with very rare limestone sand and gravel. It exhibits a subtle but clear lower boundary marked by a decrease in clay and a slightly lighter colour from the context below. 2000:3 contains the upper contact of 523. It is an orange-brown (PPL) clay loam/silty clay loam with occasional fine sand and gravel. It has a vughy tomassive microstructure (20% porosity) and a stipple- speckled b-fabric. There is rare partially charred organic material, with very rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone and shell (Fig. 6.7b). There are few potential pedorelicts, rare diffuse iron nodules and very rare calcitic infillings. Its lower boundary was not sampled. The reddish colour of the groundmass, although potentially due to slide thickness, may indicate an input of soil material into the fabric, but may also be linked to the decomposition of occupation material or heating accompanying the occupation debris in Context 522 oxidising iron in the underlying sediment. Dusty clay coatings to the coarse material suggest movement of material on ephemeral surfaces and punctuated dampness, inconsistent with mass colluvial movements and instead suggestive of aeolian deposition and reworking. It is possible that the anthropogenic inclusions may have been incorporated into what would have been a dry unconsolidated upper surface of the context during the occupation that formed Context 522 (described below). Calcitic infillings to the voids indicate the percolation of calcitic-rich water through the sediments following deposition through drips from the ceiling, although the precipitation may be far younger than the rest of the unit. Context 523 on the West-Facing Profile appears therefore to show the deposition and reworking of material through aeolian processes, which may have been altered during the occupation which formed Context 522. The percolation of carbonate-rich groundwater through the profile indicates drips within the cave and water percolation at a later point in time. In the field on the North-Facing Profile, Context 523 is a yellowish-red clayey silt (5YR5/6) with <5% limestone subangular fragments (1–2cm). It has a diffuse lower boundary. Micro-fabric 2028:3 is an orange-brown silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand to gravel, and a vughy/massive microstructure overlying a moderately developed granular microaggregate structure (25% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled tomicritic calcitic crystallitic (75:25). There is rare blocky charcoal, bone and flint, and occasional lensing of the coarse components. There is a concentration of crystallitic b-fabric between the lenses of burnt material similar to Micro-fabric 2028:4. There are rare ash lenses to the top of the unit (Fig. 6.7c), rare depositional crust fragments and occasional dung fragments. The lower boundary is prominent and clear. Micro-fabric 2028:4 is a dark brown-red (PPL) silt loam with few limestone medium to coarse sand clasts and a platy microstructure overlying a granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity) (Fig. 6.7d). The b-fabric is undifferentiated to stipple-speckled (70:30). There are rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone and shell fragments and very rare silt-sized charred material. Its lower boundary is Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 112 prominent but diffuse and interleaved. The micromorphological observations of 2028:4 are consistent with the burning event identified in the field, withmultiple inclusions of combustionmaterial. The lack of substantial blocks of charred organic material and the dark staining of the groundmass indicate a degradation of the material indicative of prolonged exposure, and potential hyper-fragmentation of larger fragments (Braadbaart et al. 2009). In the field, the burning event appears quite restricted in area, although it is possible that it represents one corner of a larger feature (as discussed inContext 568).The upper contact of the unit is clear,with limited mixing, potentially resulting from a truncation, possibly through colluvial processes in an otherwise relatively dry environment. Ash from this burning was probably eroded or deflated during exposure on a surface. The lenses of charred material in 2028:3 indicate either continued reworking of the material from 2028:4 or repeated burning nearby. The crystallitic component of the b-fabric of 2028:3may result from the incorporation of ash material during this reworking or subsequent bioturbation, although it could simply result from roof spalling or drips of calcite-rich groundwater. The moderately developed granular structure in 2028:3 indicates significant bioturbation, potentially of mites or enchytraeids, potentially supporting an initially high organic content consistent with reworked occupation and combustion material. Micromorphological observations of Context 523 appear consistent across the two profiles, showing a potentially primarily dry aeolian/dusty environment of deposition and reworking. There is substantial reworking of occupation material on the North-Facing Profile in a dry environment. 6.3.2.3 Context 522, West-Facing Profile Only In the field, Context 522 is a lens 75cm long and 3–4cm deep which appears to have been disrupted by a burrow in its centre. It is a dark brown silt with a friable but compact platy structure. Micro-fabric 938:3 is a red-brown silt loam with few limestone medium sand to gravel clasts and a massive to vughy structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is common, fibrous and horizontally-orientated charred organic material throughout the fabric (Fig. 6.8a), as well as larger blocks with cell structure. There are very rare inclusions of ashed plant material, rare micritic calcitic aggregates within the fabric (Fig. 6.8b), as well as very rare vesicular silica (Fig. 6.8c). There are also rare angular flint shards (Fig. 6.8d) and few potentially burnt red bone fragments. The fabric is stained extensively with iron and manganese. The lower boundary is prominent and clear. The inclusions of burnt organicmaterial, ash, bone, and flint strongly suggest that Context 522 is heavily anthropogenically-influenced. The iron and manganese staining is probably due to the decomposition of organic material in the form of both burnt and unburnt occupation material. Context 522 therefore shows occupation acitivity on the surface of Context 523. 522 is only one of a number of lenses occurring in the contact between Contexts 523 and 521 across all profiles, including a number of distinct burnt lenses on the South-Facing Profile, marking a coherent occupation surface. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 113 6.3.2.4 Context 521, North- and West-Facing Profiles On theWest-Facing Profile, Context 521 is a red (2.5YR 4/6) clayey silt with 10% horizontally oriented limestone fine gravel (2mm–2cm). The lower boundary is clear. Micro-fabric 2000:2 contains the depth of Context 521 and is an orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam. There is common very fine limestone sand to gravel, concentrated slightly towards the top of the unit, Figure 6.8: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 522. 938:3 (521) (522) (523) 2mm1mm 500μm 1mm 938:3Iron stained groundmassand fibrous charcoal blocks,OIL a b 938:3Calcitic aggregates, PPL 938:3vesicular silica, PPL 938:3-4Boundary with flint shard,PPL c d 1cmSample 938 Co nt ex t Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 114 (521) (523) 2000:2 2028:1 2028:2 W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 2m m 20 00 :2 As h le ns ,X PL 20 28 :1 -2 Bo un da ry ,P PL 2m m 20 28 :2 Cr us tf ra gm en t, XP L 1m m 20 00 :2 W ea th er ed bo ne ,X PL 1m m b Sa m pl e 20 00 Sa m pl e 20 28 a 1c m Context c d F ig ur e 6. 9: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 52 1. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 115 and a massive/vughy to weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (60:40). There is rare charred and uncharred occupation material throughout, but it is particularly concentrated at the base of the unit. There is fragmented, potentially partially-dissolved, bone close to the top part of the fabric (Fig. 6.9a). There is diffuse horizontal lensing to the fine material, and an increase in crystallitic material to the top of the unit. There are also rare crystallitic infillings to voids and manganese coatings to channels. There are few well-rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts, and rare dung and depositional crust fragments consiting of material grading from very well-sorted fine quartz sand to reddish clay. There are also two long ash lenses containing rhombohedral calcitic pseudomorphs (Fig. 6.9b). The lower boundary is faint but clear, with no trace of Context 522 at the contact between Contexts 523 and 521. The silty nature of the fabric suggests a potentially aeolian origin to the fine material, with limestone gravel marking the incorporation of roof-spall increasing to the top of the unit and ash lenses marking ephemeral surfaces. Given the presence of calcitic void infillings, the increased crystallitic groundmass towards the top of the unit may be the result of secondary calcite precipitation during a period of dripping within the cave onto the dry sediments, although the timing of this precipitation may be far after deposition. This crystallitic groundmass may also result from the incorporation of limestone weathering dust or aeolian carbonate material into the sediments. Manganese void hypocoatings also indicate wetting of the sediments after deposition potentially through dripping in the cave and potentially related to the calcite precipitation, yet may also date, as with the calcite precipitation, from long after burial. The occupation material is particularly concentrated near the base of the unit, suggesting potential reworking of the occupation material from 522, however the ash lenses at the top of the unit may indicating continuing activity nearby throughout the deposition of the context. The diffuse lower boundary of 2002:2 indicates an unconsolidated, dry surface for the deposition of 522. Deposition of Context 521 on the West-Facing Profile appears to have been punctuated and probably the result of aeolian processes reworking material from outside and within the cave. A period of post- depositional calcite precipitation followed, perhaps in a period of stability, potentially prior to its truncation by 520 (described below), although the timing of this calcite precipitation may be far later. On the North-Facing Profile, Context 521 is a yellowish-red (5YR 4/6) clayey silt, with slightly more clay and slightly redder towards the top of the context and greyer to its base. There is <5% subangular to subrounded limestone, 1–2cm, and the lower boundary is clear. Micro-fabric 2028:1 is an orange yellow-brown (PPL) silt loam/sandy silt loamwith common limestone fine sand to gravel. It has a massive/vughymicrostructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (25% porosity). It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (75:25). There are very rare blocky charcoal fragments and rare potentially burnt bone and shell. There are few iron nodules, depositional crust fragments and dung lenses. The lower boundary is distinct and diffuse, and the fabric is interleaved with 2028:2 (Fig. 6.9d). Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 116 2028:2 is a pale orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel which increases slightly to the top of the unit. It has a massive/vughy microstructure (15% porosity) overlying a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure with a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (80:20). There is rare blocky charcoal, bone and shell, and these are concentrated in the lower half of the fabric. There are rare silt micro-crusts, and a link capping which covers the lower contact of the unit. There are frequent depositional crust fragments consisting of well-sorted material and broken infillings in the top third of the unit (Fig. 6.9c), and few dung fragments. Its lower boundary is distinct and diffuse. The relatively high porosity and weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (with homogeneous aggregates) in both fabrics indicate bioturbation throughout the context. The silty nature of the fine material and the crystallitic b-fabric indicate a mixed, potentially aeolian and internal weathering origin, although the micritic b-fabric may also result from precipitation following deposition of the unit. Silty micro-crusts, which appear to be depositional, and link cappings in 2028:2 may suggest small-scale movements of clay-rich water across otherwise dry sediments or localised dripping and puddling. Dung lenses in 2028:1 indicate puctuated deposition of material on ephemeral surfaces. Further well-sorted depositional crust and infilling fragments indicate slightly more significant wetting of material, again potentially through small flows of water, or increased dripping and puddling. Both fabrics contain continued occupation material throughout in small quantities. The North-Facing Profile observations are largely consistent with those from the West-Facing Profile, with potentially aeolian silt mixed with limestone weathering products in a mainly dry, slow, depositional environment. On the North-Facing Profile the context is punctuated by brief periods of crusting, potentially driven by washes of water carrying material from outside the cave or within the karstic system, or increased puddling and dripping in the cave. The presence of secondary calcite precipitation on the West-Facing Profile indicates spatially-restricted drips of water towards the end of the deposition of the unit and prior to truncation by Context 520. 6.3.2.5 Context 520, West-Facing Profile Only Context 520 is a reddish brown clayey silt (2.5YR 4/4) which is darker towards its base (2.5YR 3/5) where it is more clayey. There is 15% fine limestone grit with 5% limestone blocks, which are platy and horizontally-oriented. Micro-fabric 2666:3 contains the upper part of Context 520. It is a brown-orange (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent fine sand to gravel, and a massive to vughy structure overlying a weakly-developed granular structure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is very rare charcoal and humified blocky material, with rare bone and very rare flint and very rare pedorelicts. There is an overall fining from the base of the unit to <10% coarse at the top of the unit. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2000:1 contains the lower part of the context. It is a dark orange-brown (PPL) silty clay loam with few limestone fine to coarse sand-sized clasts. It has a moderately developed subangular Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 117 blocky microstructure overlying a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure, becoming more vughy/massive to the top of the unit (rising from 15 to 20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- speckled. There are occasional manganese dendritic hypocoatings to organic material, and the fabric itself is stained with manganese and iron (Fig. 6.10a). There are also occasional diffuse to well-rounded iron nodules and potential pedorelicts. There is occasional blocky charcoal with cell structure, and rare potentially burnt bone. There is rare fine lensing of the groundmass, and an area of depositional crusting of well-sorted silty clay towards the top of the slide with multiple layers. There is a 15mm- wide round concentration of limestone-rich material to the left hand side of the slide, with a subtle boundary. The micro-fabric’s lower boundary is prominent and sharp (Fig. 6.10b). The micromorphological observations of the sharp nature of 2000:1’s lower boundary, range of amorphous pedofeatures and clayey nature, coupled with its lenticular shape and dense clayey texture as observed in the field, indicate that the context was an erosive, wetmovement, potentially of reworked soil material from outside of the shelter. The whole context may have been deposited rapidly, yet the depositional crusts indicate some, potentially rapid, punctuation to this deposition, or the reworking of existing depositional crust fragments, potentially deposited by smaller sheetwash events prior to this large-scale event. The lack of coarsematerial towards the top of 2000:1may also be linked to repeated 26 66 :3 20 00 :1 2000:1Manganese staining togroundmass,OIL 2000:1-2Boundary, PPL 2mm 1mm a b Sa m pl e 26 66 Sample 2000 1cm (5 21 ) (5 20 ) (5 17 ) Figure 6.10: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 520. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 118 rapid episodes of depositionwhich vary slightly in energy and content. However the finer nature of the material to the top of 2666:3 may also indicate a resumption of aeolian processes reworking material deposited by the initial event or, more probably, the settling out of a wet flow event. Context 520 is therefore intepreted as being deposited by a rapid, or series of rapid, erosive event(s) which potentially transported external soil material into the cave. 6.3.3 Facies Five: Bulk Sedimentology The Facies Five magnetic susceptibility values are all slightly higher, but more variable, than in the overlying Facies Four (see Chapter Five), and a number of peaks from both the uncorrected and corrected values are above the means of the entire sequence (386.8 and 560.6m3kg-1 respectively) (Fig. 6.11). The corrected values are largely within that of the modern soil pit variation. Significant fluctuations in values are traceable between the profiles, with the highest values on the West-Facing Profile at the base of Contexts 521 and 520, matching a peak on the North-Facing Profile in 521, as well as slightly elevated values in Context 528 on both profiles. The North-Facing Profile also contains peaks in Context 523, which is absent from the West-Facing Profile values, and Context 564 which is a lens on the North-Facing Profile. There are two %LOI peaks on the North-Facing Profile, Contexts 568 and 565, yet the rest of the values on both profiles are consistently below the mean for the entire sequence (4.55%). The %CaCO 3 values are variable, with peaks in Contexts 520, 563 and 538 lying above the sequence mean value of 31.3% and a marked low in the top of Context 570 to 565 below this value. There is also a slight rise in %CaCO 3 values around Contexts 538-526 on both profiles. 6.3.4 Facies Five: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data The micromorphological interpretations are summarised in Table 6.3. The fluctuating, relatively moderate magnetic susceptibility values in Facies Five indicate either a variable input of soil material into the cave sequence, variable extents of anthropogenic activity raising the magnetic susceptibility of material post-deposition, or the presence of prolonged surface exposure and weathering of the sediments, or a combination of all. Context 520, is highly magnetically susceptible at its base, where it was interpreted through micromorphology and in the field as the result of a mudflow which potentially incorporated soil material from outside of the mouth of the cave or material from within the karstic system (the intepretation of an inwash event is favoured through the shape of the context in the field which is consistent with a flow of material into the cave). It thus supports the former mechanisms, yet other contexts are linked to observations of anthropogenic material such as Context 521, supporting the latter. Context 523, identified as probably aeolian- deposited from the micromorphological observations, is high in magnetic susceptibility on the North- Facing Profile, where it includes indicators of burning, but not so high on the West-Facing Profile where this anthropogenic influence is not observed in thin-section. Interpretation of the magnetic susceptibility data therefore requires careful consideration of the micromorphological observations. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 119 Context Interpretation 520 Erosive, mass movement, potentially of soil material or material from within the karstic system. 521 Possible aeolian deposition and reworking and ongoing occupation, with sporadic surface washing and crusting in the North-Facing Profile. Increasing calcite precipitation during deposition of the top part of the unit, or after deposition. Truncated by 520 on the West-Facing Profile. 522 (West-Facing Only) Substantial occupation material on an unconsolidated surface. 523 Possible aeoilan/dust deposition and reworking during occupation on the North-Facing Profile. 524 Punctuated, potentially aeolian/dust deposition and reworking, with sporadic damping of the surface. 563 Potential colluvial reworking of aeolian/dust material from cave floor, followed by aeolian/ dust deposition and reworking, a depositional hiatus, and then another potential colluvial mass movement of aeolian material. Occupation material throughout. 568 Burning event truncated and reworked in a dry environment, then truncated by colluvial movement. 528 Rapid, punctuated potential aeolian/dust deposition and reworking. Limited internal weathering with sporadic wetting. Unconsolidated upper surface incorporating material from Context 568. Table 6.3: Summary of Facies Five context interpretations based on micromorphological descriptions. Figure 6.11: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Five contexts. Blue magnetic susceptibility bars are uncorrected values, red are corrected values. 520 521 523 524 526 527 528 70 0 60 0 50 0 40 0 30 0 20 0 10 0 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 0 6 0 521 523 524 563 568 528 564 565 570 538 70 0 60 0 50 0 40 0 30 0 20 0 10 0 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 0 6 0 7 0 8 0 MagneticSusceptibility(x)% LOIOrganics % Carbonate W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 80 0 Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 120 The %LOI peaks on the North-Facing Profile correspond with observations of burnt material in Contexts 568 and 565.The burning event observed in 523was notwithin the sample column, although there is a very slight rise in the %LOI in this context which may reflect reworking of the material within the context. Context 570 is only accompanied by aminor %LOI peak, surprising given the dark colour of this feature, and its potentially high former organic content (see further discussion of F600 in Chapter Eight). The lack of %LOI peaks on the West-Facing Profile reflects the lack of significant amounts of organic material observed in the thin sections. The observation of ash in Context 521 and lack of corresponding %LOI peak illustrates that occupationmaterial may not always be detectable by %LOI, as not only may the preservation of organic material at this depth be poor (See Chapter Five), but as not all anthropogenic material is carbon – ash is primarily CaCO 3 . %LOI peaks associated with burning events do not occur in contexts above peaks in magnetic susceptibility (corrected or uncorrected) indicating that burning events leaving visible traces did not have a significant impact on the magnetic susceptibility of the sediments which underlay them which can be distinguished from the ‘noise’ of potential source variability. This may be due to the fire not reaching the necessary temperature or length of burn needed to alter the magnetic susceptibility of the sediments (Canti and Linford 2000). However, a peak in Context 523 on the North-Facing Profile, absent on the West-Facing Profile and correlating to a context containing a burnt event and reworked material restricted to the North-Facing Profile, may indicate that anthropogenic influence on the sediments does alter magnetic susceptibility. This issue is complicated by the potential presence of aeolian-deposited soil material in the context which could raise the magnetic susceptibility. It also remains that if the top few centimetres of the sediment unit were raised by burning or occupation, this may have been diluted by the other, unaltered sediment contained within the 5cm sample. That is, the resolution of the sampling may not be high enough to detect anthropogenic influence if it has indeed altered the magnetic susceptibility of the sediment. The North-Facing Profile contains the highest %CaCO 3 peak in the MSA–LSA sequence in Context 538. This peak may indicate a highly calcite-cemented surface prior to the deposition of red silts in the Middle Trench yet its position at the base of the excavation and outside of the micromorphological sampling hampers interpretation. A carbonate low in the top of Context 570 and 565 is potentially related to an originally high organic source of these layers. The multiple sources of %CaCO 3 are well- illustrated in Facies Five. The high value for Context 521 on the West-Facing Profile, primarily the result of the observed secondary calcite deposition and ash, is nearly as high as that of the overlying mudflow, Context 520, which is primarily soil material, but which contains limestone grit. This indicates an equifinality which can only be clarified through micromorphological observations. 6.3.5 Facies Five: Interpretation Facies Five appears potentially to be largely a mixture of aeolian-deposited or reworked silt and limestone sand, which has, in places, been reworked through colluvial movements. This environment is interspersed by occupation episodes which have left substantial impacts on the sediments as observed in the thin sections and bulk sedimentology. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 121 The nature of the major burning feature at the base of Facies Five, Feature 600, will be discussed in detail in Chapter Eight. This feature appears to have at least two main phases of use separated by a hiatus, the second of which appears to have been interrupted repeatedly by inwash of clay- rich material. This is truncated by 564 in a wet colluvial movement, potentially incorporating soil material (Chapter Eight). Above Context 564, 528 appears to consist of sedimentation dominated by potential aeolian deposition and reworking with sporadic wetting of sediments through drips and very limited sheetwash of external soil material or flows fromwithin the karstic system through fissures in the limestone. Occupation takes place in Context 568, the upper part of which appears to have been left exposed and later reworked in dry conditions, before potential truncation by colluvial movements of in the base of Context 563. Context 563 appears to contain a shift from initial colluvial reworking of aeolian/dust material from within the cave to a slow, depositional environment dominated by aeolian reworking and deposition. This aeolian deposition potentially increases in rapidity, before a depositional hiatus, which is overlain by possible further colluvial reworking of aeolian material. Occupation material continued to be reworked throughout this context, potentially reflecting continued occupation nearby. Apotential shift back to punctuated aeolian/dust deposition and reworking occurred in Context 524. Occupation took place on the surface of Context 524, followed by further potential aeolian deposition and reworking and occupation in Context 523, with another, more marked period of occupation overlying Context 523, as represented in Context 522 as well as further observations of burning features on the South-Facing Profile at this depth. Phases of occupation may have taken place during sedimentary hiatuses, or simply marked relatively rapid anthropogenic deposition in periods of very slow aeolian deposition and reworking. Sporadic occupation appears to have continued through the aeolian deposition of Context 521, with increased roof-spalling to the top of the unit indicating a slowing of deposition and/or an increase in physical weathering, along with a period of water dripping (which could also have occurred far later). This unit was truncated by an inwash event on the West- Facing Profile, Context 520, which marked a major change in the hydrology of the cave. In summary, the depositional environment of the cave in Facies Five is dominated by aeolian/ dust deposition and reworking of fine material within the cave, with occupation taking place on unconsolidated surfaces and later subject to various degrees of reworking and truncation. It is sporadically interrupted by colluvial movements of material potentially from within and outside of the cave, and is capped by an episode of colluvial deposition of what is interpreted as soil inwash due to its similarities to the fabric of the modern soil pit (Section 6.2.9). Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 122 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e 52 0 26 66 :3 15 m m B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd fr eq ue nt li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el . M as si ve to vu gh y ov er ly in g a w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs ,c ra ck s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re ch ar re d an d hu m ifi ed bl oc ky m at er ia l. F ew sh el l, ra re bo ne an d ve ry ra re fli nt .O ve ra ll fin in g fr om th e ba se of th e un it to < 10 % co ar se m at er ia la tt he to p of th e un it .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d vo id in fil li ng s. V er y ra re pe do re li ct s. U pp er pa rt of in w as h ev en t, he av il y w ea th er ed an d po te nt ia ll y re w or ke d, in cl ud in g th ro ug h bi ot ur ba ti on . E ro si ve ,m as s m ov em en to f so il m at er ia l, la te r ex po se d an d w ea th er ed an d bi ot ur ba te d. 20 00 :1 15 -3 5m m D ar k or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m . qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne fin e to co ar se sa nd .M od er at e to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ov er ly in g vu gh y to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. M or e vu gh y/ m as si ve to to p of un it . 20 -1 5% po ro si ty :v ug hs an d ch am be rs ,c ha nn el s an d pl an ar vo id s (c on ce nt ra te d to to p of sl id e) .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic . C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 -2 5: 80 -7 5. P ro m in en t, sh ar p an d un du la ti ng lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .b lo ck y ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bu rn t bo ne .R ar e fin e le ns in g of th e gr ou nd m as s. O cc .M n de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .i ro n no du le s, bo un da ri es bo th sh ar p an d di ff us e, an d pe do re li ct s. A re a of cr us ti ng to to p of un it ,m ul ti pl e la ye rs .F ew du ng bl oc ky fr ag m en ts . C on ce nt ra ti on of li m es to ne to le ft ha nd si de of sl id e – up to 25 % . B as e of he av il y er os iv e in w as h ev en t. W es t- an d N or th -F ac in g P ro fil es 52 1 W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e 20 00 :2 80 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne ve ry fin e sa nd to gr av el (s om et im es or ga ni se d in ho ri zo nt al le ns es ). M as si ve /v ug hy to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e w it h 20 % po ro si ty :c ha nn el s, vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. F ai nt ,c le ar lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky an gu la r ch ar co al an d bu rn ta nd un bu rn t bo ne ,w it h so m e he av il y de gr ad ed fr ag m en ts to th e to p. V er y ra re sh el l. D ec re as e in bo ne ,s he ll an d or ga ni cs to to p of un it .D if fu se ho ri zo nt al le ns in g to fin e m at er ia l. In cr ea se in cr ys ta ll it ic fa br ic to to p 3c m of un it .R ar e cr ys ta ll it ic in fil li ng s to vo id s. R ar e m an ga ne se co at in g to ch an ne ls .F ew ir on no du le s – in cl ud in g pe do re li ct s. R ar e ye ll ow du ng .R ar e w el l- ro un de d cr us tf ra gm en ts . L ar ge as h le ns es co nt ai ni ng rh om bo he dr al ca lc it ic ps eu do m or ph s. O cc up at io n in ae ol ia n de po si ti on , w it h so m e po st - de po si ti on al w et ti ng of se di m en ts th ro ug h ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er of un kn ow n ti m in g. A eo li an de po si ti on an d oc cu pa ti on ,w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng an d cr us ti ng in th e N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e. In cr ea si ng ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n du ri ng de po si ti on of th e to p pa rt of th e un it ,o r af te r de po si ti on . T ru nc at ed by 52 0 on th e W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e. Ta bl e 6. 4: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F ac ie s F iv e m ic ro m or ph ol og ia ld es cr ip ti on s an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul ld es cr ip ti on s in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al ,f re q. -f re qu en t, co m m .- co m m on . Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 123 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 52 1 N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e 20 28 :1 25 m m O ra ng e- ye ll ow br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am /s an dy si lt lo am .O cc . qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve /v ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g a gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e. 25 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs ,c ha m be rs an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, (r ar e ve ge ta lv oi ds ) an d pl an ar vo id .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 5: 25 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 26 :7 4. D is ti nc t, di ff us e, in te rl ea ve d lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar co al .R ar e bo ne an d sh el l. F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, fe w ir on no du le s or cr us t fr ag m en ts .F ew du ng le ns es . P un ct ua te d, po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po st io n w it h ra re , sp or ad ic w et ti ng . (s ee ab ov e) . 20 28 :2 65 -8 0m m P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m w it h co m m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy /m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g a w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty , vu gh s an d ch am be rs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b on e, sh el l. It is in te rl ea ve d w it h 20 28 :1 to th e to p of th e un it .O cc up at io n de br is is co nc en tr at ed in th e lo w er ha lf of th e fa br ic .T he m at er ia l is co ar se r to th e to p of th e un it (l im es to ne ). R ar e si lt y m ic ro -c ru st in g. L in k ca pp in g al on g ba se of un it .R ar e m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs to vo id s. cr us tf ra gm en ts an d br ok en in fil li ng s ar e fr eq ue nt to th e to p th ir d of th e un it . F ew du ng fr ag m en ts . P un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on , sp or ad ic al ly w et te d by sm al l- sc al e sh ee tw as h an d pu dd li ng to th e to p of th e un it . 52 2 W es t- F ac in g O nl y 93 8: 3 20 m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el cl as ts . M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs , pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . F re qu en tc ha rr ed m at er ia l, fib ro us bl oc ky an d ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed .R ar e si li ca an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic w oo dy pl an ts tr uc tu re .R ar e an gu la r fli nt ,f ew fr ag m en ts of bu rn tb on e, an d ra re ve si cu la r si li ca .O cc .s ta in in g of gr ou nd m as s w it h m an ga ne se an d ir on .F ew w el l- ro un de d pe do re li ct s. R ar e m ic ri ti c as h ag gr eg at es an d cr us t fr ag m en ts . O cc up at io n m at er ia lo n un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. 52 3 W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e 20 00 :3 25 -4 0m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ; vu gh s, ch an ne ls an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic . C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar re d/ pa rt ia ll y hu m ifi ed st em st ru ct ur e. V er y ra re bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e an d sh el l. V er y ra re ca lc it ic in fil li ng s. F ew pe do re li ct s, w el lr ou nd ed sh ar p ed ge . R ar e di ff us e ir on no du le s. F ew du ng fr ag m en ts . O cc up at io n in en vi ro nm en t, of po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,s om e po st -d ep os it io na l w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . O cc up at io n in pr ed om in an tl y po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n en vi ro nm en t. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 124 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 52 3 (c on t.) N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e 20 28 :3 25 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy / m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d ch am be rs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 5: 25 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r, lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b on e an d fli nt .O cc .l en se s of co ar se co m po ne nt s. co nc en tr at io n of cr ys ta ll it ic gr ou nd m as s be tw ee n le ns es of ch ar re d m at er ia l. F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. O cc .d un g fr ag m en ts .R ar e as h le ns es to to p of un it .R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts ,l en s of 20 28 :4 .B io tu rb at io n to ba se . O cc up at io n in po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n en vi ro nm en t of de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng . R ew or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l in dr y en vi ro nm en t. O cc up at io n in po te nt ia ll y pr ed om in an tl y ae ol ia n en vi ro nm en t of de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng . 20 28 :4 3- 5m m D ar k br ow n- re d (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se sa nd an d fin e si lt ,f ew li m es to ne m ed iu m to co ar se sa nd . P la ty m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g a gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ,p la na r vo id s, vu gh s an d ch am be rs . U nd if fe re nt ia te d to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic . C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en tb ut di ff us e/ in te rl ea ve d lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e, an d sh el l. V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar re d pl an tm at er ia l, ov er al lb ro w n or ga ni c st ai ni ng to fa br ic . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed bu rn in g ev en t. N or th -F ac in g P ro fil e 52 4 20 28 :5 0- 12 m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt to fin e sa nd ,f ew li m es to ne cl as ts fin e sa nd to co ar se sa nd .M as si ve to vu gh y ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to un di ff er en ti at ed (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic , C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e fli nt an d sh el l. V ar ia ti on s in cl ay co nt en tl en se s in fil li ng s or m ic ro -c ru st s. R ar e si lt y co at in gs to co ar se co m po ne nt s. O cc .d en dr it ic m an ga ne se no du le s an d in fil li ng s. V er y ra re as h fr ag m en t. O cc .d un g fr ag m en ts . F ew cr us tf ra gm en ts .l en s of 20 28 :4 in te rl ea ve d w it h to p of un it . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,w it h sp or ad ic da m pi ng of th e su rf ac e. 56 3 20 21 :1 10 -2 8m m Y el lo w -o ra ng e br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd co m m on li m es to ne co ar se si lt to fin e gr av el .V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m ,C F ra ti o: 30 :6 5. D is ti nc t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el l, bo ne .F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. O cc . ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, in cl ud in g on e la rg e pe do re li ct , po te nt ia ll y bu rn t. S li gh ti m br ic at io n at th e ba se of th e un it . C ol lu vi al re w or ki ng of ae ol ia n m at er ia l. C ol lu vi al m ov em en t of po te nt ia l ae ol ia n m at er ia l, fo ll ow ed by ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng , a st ab il is at io n of th e su rf ac e an d th en a co ll uv ia l m as s m ov em en t of po te nt ia l ae ol ia n m at er ia l. O cc up at io n m at er ia l th ro ug ho ut . 20 21 :2 35 m m P al e or an ge -y el lo w br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m to sa nd y lo am at to p of un it .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,w it h co m m .t o do m in an tl im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el (a tt op of un it ). M as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ,p la na r vo id s an d ch am be rs .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic ,( 80 :2 0) .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5 at ba se , 60 :4 0 at to p of un it .F ai nt ,s ha rp lo w er bo un da ry L en s of sl ig ht or ga ni c co nc en tr at io n ac ro ss sl id e, 15 0μ m - 25 0μ m th ic k. R ar e ch ar re d m at er ia l, sh el l, bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e, an d fli nt .L im es to ne co ar se ns an d in cr ea se s to th e to p. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d w el l- ro un de d pe do re li ct s. O cc .d un g le ns es an d ra re bl oc ks . V er y ra re fr ag m en ts of ve si cu la r si li ca .C ru st at th e up pe r co nt ac to f th e un it . P un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h li m it ed ph ys ic al w ea th er in g. V ar ia bl e am ou nt of ph ys ic al w ea th er in g or ra te of de po si ti on . Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 125 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 56 3 (c on t.) 20 21 :3 30 -3 5m m L ig ht br ow n- or an ge (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .c oa rs e si lt an d fin e sa nd qu ar tz ,c om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e, w it h 15 % po ro si ty :c ha m be rs an d vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (1 0% ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,R ar e bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e (a nd la rg e on e) .R ar e fli ng an d sh el l. T he to p of th e un it is fin er w it h st ro ng ho ri zo nt al la m in at io ns .S il ty cr us t un de r la rg e bo ne .M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in g to la rg e bo ne .F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e ve si cu la r si li ca fr ag m en ts . R ar e du ng le ns es . C ol lu vi al m ov em en t of ae ol ia n m at er ia l, fo ll ow ed by sh if tt o pu nc tu at ed ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . (s ee ab ov e) 56 8 20 21 :4 10 m m G re y- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,C om m on li m es to ne fin e sa nd to co ar se sa nd . V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, 15 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne (i nc lu di ng to ot h) an d sh el l. F ew bl oc ks of ch ar co al .O cc .w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e m an ga ne se no du le s. L en s of fa br ic 20 21 :5 at to p of un it .F ew du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks .R ar e ve si cu la r si li ca fr ag m en ts ,f re qu en tf ra gm en ts of ca lc it ic as h. M ix ed as h m at er ia l, re w or ke d in dr y co nd it io ns . B ur nt ev en t tr un ca te d an d re w or ke d in a dr y en vi ro nm en t.. F ur th er tr un ca te d by co ll uv ia l m ov em en ti n C on te xt 56 3. 20 21 :5 5m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .F ew qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd cl as ts ,a nd co m m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty , vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic .C F li m it :6 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry C om m on bl oc ky an gu la r ch ar co al ,a nd da rk br ow n as a re su lt of si lt -s iz ed or ga ni c st ai ni ng an d fr ag m en ts of ch ar co al .O cc .b ur nt bo ne ,a nd ra re sh el l. In cr ea se in or ga ni c m at er ia lt o th e to p of th e un it .F ew ir on no du le s or bu rn tp ed or el ic ts . T ru nc at ed bu rn in g ev en to n un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. 52 8 20 21 :6 15 -3 5m m B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd .C om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b on e (b ur nt an d un bu rn t) an d sh el l. C on ce nt ra ti on of an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia lt ow ar ds to p of un it .F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s, ra re fr ag m en ts of ve si cu la r si li ca ,a nd pa le du ng le ns es an d ar ea s of sp on gy gr ou nd m as s. R ap id ,p un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on , sp or ad ic w et ti ng .a nd re w or ki ng of ne ar by oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 126 6.4 Facies Four 6.4.1 Facies Four: Field Description and Chronology Facies Four is characterised by substantial inclusions of gravel within a pale orange to grey silty matrix (Fig. 6.12; full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four). Facies Four on the North-Facing Profile is capped by a burning event (Contexts 513 and 535) which slopes downwards towards the east, potentially cutting the horizontal stratigraphy below it. The internal stratigraphy of this feature will be discussed in more detail in Chapter Eight. On the West-Facing Profile Facies Four contains Contexts 517 to 513 and on the North-Facing Profile Contexts 567 to 513 (Fig. 6.13). Only Context 513 is traceable between theWest and North-Facing Profiles, and, aside from Context 513, the micromorphological observations from the two profiles will be discussed separately. 6.4.2 Facies Four: Micromorphological Observations 6.4.2.1 Contexts 517–516, West-Facing Profile Context 517 In the field, Context 517 is a yellowish red (5YR 5/6) silt with 30% angular, horizontally oriented, limestone gravel (0.5–3cm). It is semi-concreted with a semi-platy structure in the field, and the lower boundary is clear and slightly wavy. At the base of 517 there is a 4cm-thick clayey silt layer with 5% limestone sand and gravel (2mm– 1.5cm), with some horizontal orientation to coarser limestone clasts. There are <1% pale silty yellow Figure 6.12: Photo of West-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing the paler, more gravelly Facies Four roughly corresponding to the lower white division on the ranging pole. Divisions on rangin pole are 50cm. Photo: G. Barker. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 127 26 63 26 66 20 37 22 42 0 1 2m Fa ci es 1 Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 Fa ci es 5 N S E W N S E W D ab ba n (X VI -X XI V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) M SA (X XV -X XX V) 50 cm 0 10 52 20 58 20 33 51 3 53 5 53 6 53 7 56 2 53 6 53 7 53 5 51 3 51 7 51 6 10 52 20 58 20 33 W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile F ig ur e 6. 13 : L oc at io n an d sa m pl in g of F ac ie s F ou r se di m en ts (g re y) fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al an al ys is .S ha de d ar ea s ex pa nd ed be lo w .D ra w in g: L .F ar r. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 128 laminations, and the lower boundary is diffuse to clear. The lower part of Context 517 contains Micro-fabrics 2666:2 and 2666:1. 2666:1 is a yellow-brown sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel. The structure is vughy to very weakly- developed subangular blocky (20% porosity), including vegetal voids Fig. 6.14a). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (70:30). It contains rare blocky charcoal and humified organics with few potentially burnt bone fragments. There are rare silty hypocoatings to the vegetal voids and coarsematerial. There are few verywell rounded depositional crust fragments and occasional dung lenses and blocks. There are few iron nodules and rare manganese hypocoatings and coatings to voids. Its lower boundary is faint and diffuse. The fine material and b-fabric of Micro-fabric 2666:2 is similar to 2666:1, yet contains only few limestone coarse sand to gravel clasts. It has a massive to vughy/very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). There is very rare flint, rare bone and rare charred blocky organics and rare calcitic hypocoatings to voids. There are few dung fragments, and rare areas where of spongy structure in the groundmass, similar in character to the internal structure of the dung fragments. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear (Fig. 6.14b). The band of fine material observed in the field is shown in 2666:2. Given the silty nature of the fine material, the mixed b-fabric and the lack of in situ depositional crusting which would indicate alluvial deposition, the fine material in the micro-fabric appears potentially aeolian-deposited. The 26 66 :1 26 66 :2 (5 20 ) (5 17 ) 2666:1Vegetal voids, PPL 2666:2-3Boundary, PPL 1mm 2mm a b Sample 2666 1cm Co nt ex t Figure 6.14: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 517. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 129 relative lack of limestone sand and gravel may indicate either a rapidity of deposition or a reduction of physical weathering although the sorting of this finematerial may also have resulted frombioturbation of the entire context suggested by the very weakly-developed granular structure. Calcitic hypocoatings indicate a period of carbonate precipitation linked to water dripping from the cave ceiling, potentially accompanying a sedimentary hiatus following themicro-fabric’s deposition although this may equally have occurred far later. Micro-fabric 2666:1 contains a similar fine material to 2666:2, supporting a shared aeolian/dust depositional environment which was mixed with increased amounts of limestone sand and gravel, either indicating a slowing of aeolian deposition, or an increase in physical weathering in the cave. A punctuated depositional environment is supported by the dusty coatings of the coarse material, indicating material rolling on sporadically damp surfaces, or small-scale colluvial movements. Coarse organic material, coated in the same manner but later decaying, has probably created the effect of silty hypocoatings to the vegetal voids. Yet, there are no fine laminations of material observed in the fabric, indicating bioturbation either during or after burial, consistent with a slow deposition or past increased organic content. Context 517’s pale colour and silty nature therefore probably indicates a primarily aeolian/dust depositional environment for the fine material. Relatively rapid deposition at the base of the unit giving way to more punctuated, aeolian deposition and increased physical weathering, potentially coupled with sporadic dripping of carbonate-rich water from the ceiling and small-scale colluvial movments of material, although the unit may equally have been subject to bioturbation following deposition to create the textural variation. Context 516 Context 516 was not sampled for micromorphological analysis. In the field it was a red (2.5YR 4/8) friable silt containing 30% flat, angular limestone fragments (<5cm). Its lower boundary was clear. The limestone inclusions suggest a period of increased physical weathering, although the nature of the fine material is unclear without micromorphological analysis, its silty nature indicates a potential aeolian depositional environment, with its red colour perhaps indicating the inclusion of soil material. 6.4.2.2 Contexts 567–535, North-Facing Profile Context 567 In the field, Context 567 is a strong brown (7.5YR 5/6) friable silt with rare limestone grit, and is very distinct from the underlying 521, containing less clay. Its lower boundary is clear. Micro-fabric 2033:6 contains the upper boundary of Context 567. It is a dark brown sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand and gravel. The microstructure is vughy to granular microaggregate (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is rare charcoal, shell, very rare flint and few bone fragments (potentially burnt and unburnt). There are coatings/crusts to coarse material at the unit’s base (Fig. 6.15a). Its lower boundary was not sampled. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 130 The silty nature of the material indicates an aeolian/dusty depositional environment, with the micritic crystallitic b-fabric probably linked to the physical weathering which deposited the large amounts of fine limestone gravel or the deposition of carbonate aeolian material, given the overall lack of crystallitic pedofeatures. In places, however, the crystallitic b-fabric appears concentrated, and it is unclear whether this is simply due to slide thickness or to limited secondary calcite precipitation. The horizontal orientation of the gravel indicates their deposition on ephemeral surfaces, during a period of increased physical weathering or a restriction of fine sedimentation. The clayey coatings to coarse material at the base of the slide appear to result from water moving sporadically through the relatively openmatrix, a matrix that may have been opened further by bioturbation. There is occupation 20 33 :6 2033:5 2033:4 20 33 :3 (5 67 ) (5 37 ) 2033:6Clayey crust,XPL 1mm a 2033:4/5Boundary, XPL 2mm 2033:3Reddishclay lens, PPL 2mm c Sample 2033 1cm Co nt ex t b Figure 6.15: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 537 and 567. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 131 material throughout, indicating either continued occupation or reworking of material from elsewhere in the cave. The finematerial of Context 567 appears potentially aeolian-deposited, and has been laid down during a period of significant physical weathering that has been subject to rare wetting by clay-rich water. Occupation material has been reworked throughout. Context 537 Context 537 is a brown (7.5YR 4/4) pale grey silt and grit with thin lenses of red clay. There is horizontally-orientated subangular limestone sand and gravel (20% 1–1.5mm and 2% 3cm). The lower boundary is sharp. Context 537 contains Micro-fabrics 2033:5 to 3. Micro-fabric 2033:3 is a pale brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand to coarse gravel. It has a massive to weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (60:40). There are rare humified and charred organic fragments with cell structure, along with potentially burnt and unburnt bone and shell. There is an overall coarsening of material from the base to the top of the unit, interspersedwith rare lenses of reddish clay <1mm thick (Fig. 6.15b). There is also an increase in micritic b-fabric towards the top of the unit. Its lower boundary is faint and clear. Micro-fabric 2033:4 is a red-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam which is very similar in character to 2033:5, but is slightly increased in clay content, with a slightly subangular blocky microstructure (Fig. 6.15c). Its lower boundary is faint and sharp. Micro-fabric 2033:5 is a yellow-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel and a vughy to very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (85:15). There is rare charcoal, potentially burnt and unburnt bone and shell. There are rare lenses of silty clay, and subtle horizontal lensing in the fine material. There are also very rare degraded dung lenses. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear, marked by a decrease in limestone sand. Context 537 contains some distinct changes in sedimentary environment. The fine material throughout the majority of the context, given its silty texture, semi-micritic crystallitic b-fabric and gravel inclusions, is probably a mixture of aeolian dust and the spalling of fine dust, sand and gravel from the cave walls, although the micrite may also have precipitated post-deposition. Fabric 2033:4 is more clay-rich than 2033:5, perhaps indicating the deflation of soil material from the surrounding landscape. Lenses of silty clay and micro-crusts mark the sporadic wetting of ephemeral surfaces throughout 2033:4 and 5. Micro-fabric 2033:3 contains more limestone than 2033:4 and 5, which increases towards the top of the micro-fabric, indicating a reduction in availability of fine material, or more rapid roof-spalling. Silty clay lenses marking thin sheetwash events become more frequent to the top of the unit, indicating an amplification of the processes which created the micro-crusts in 2033:4 and 5. There is occupation material throughout the context, although it is unclear whether this is through continued occupation or from continued reworking of older, nearby occupation material. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 132 Context 537 therefore shows a predominantly dry, aeolian/dusty environment which is interrupted by increasing periods of sheetwash and sporadic wetting of the sediments to the top of the context. Context 562 Context 562 in the field is a light brown (7.5YR 6/4) clayey silt with 15% sub-angular to sub-rounded limestone clasts (2mm–2cm). At its base there are clean reddish clay lenses. The lower boundary is sharp. The upper contact of Context 562 with 536 was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2033:1 is a red-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive to weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure (10% porosity). It has a stipple- speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (70:30). There is rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone and charcoal, and shell. The groundmass is more clayey in the basal 0.5cm of the unit, and there are rare calcitic hypocoatings to limestone fragments and micritic infillings to some voids. There are rare well-rounded iron nodules. Its lower boundary is prominent, sharp, and interleaved (Fig. 6.16a) Micro-fabric 2033:2 is an orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt clay loam. There is frequent limestone fine sand and gravel and a massive to weakly-developed granular/blocky microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (60:40). There are rare blocky charcoal and few potentially burnt and unburnt bone fragments. There is a layer of silty clay at the base of the unit, similar to 2033:1, and a depositional clay crust in the centre of the unit. The lower boundary of the unit is prominent and sharp, with an area of fabric similar to 2033:2, ~1cm, included in the unit below (Fig. 6.16b). Context 562 is dominated by red clayey silt which, given the red clayey nature of the external soil pit (Section 6.2.9), indicates the potential incorporation of soil material in both fabrics, although it cannot be ruled out that this may also be the result of material weathered from limestone within the karstic system. The concentration of clay to the base of both fabrics indicates fine clayey material being washed into the cave, followed by the deposition of coarse material. In the case of 2033:2, this material is deposited in an aeolian/dusty environment, and represents spalling, whilst in 2033:1 it may reflect different energies in the wash event. The micritic b-fabric may also indicate significant wetting of the sediments through calcite-rich groundwater throughout the context, potentially long after deposition, although this interpretation is hampered by the thickness of the slide. Context 562 is therefore interpreted as the product of punctuated inwash events of probably soil material, which appear to increase in volume to the top of the context. Context 536 Context 536 is a pale buff silt with 10% sub-angular to sub-rounded disorientated limestone gravel (1–6cm). There is 3% pale yellow silt lenses (1.5cm by 1mm). The lower boundary is clear to slightly diffuse. Micro-fabric 2058:4 covers the upper contact of Context 536 (its lower contact was not sampled). It is a brown-yellow (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel and a Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 133 massive/vughy structure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microstructure (10% porosity). There is a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (60:40). There is rare blocky charcoal and potentially burnt and unburnt bone, with weak horizontal lensing of coarse/medium sand. Horizontally oriented dung lenses up to 2.5cm long dominate the unit (Fig. 6.17a). There are rare red clayey silt micro-crusts between the dung lenses (Fig. 6.17b), rare areas of groundmass with structures similar to dung (Fig. 6.17c) and well-rounded iron nodules. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2058:4, given its silty texture, limestone content and semi-crystallitic b-fabric is probably a mixture of aeolian dust and roof-spall material although the micrite may have been precipitated in the unit after burial. The dung lenses and micro-crusts mark multiple ephemeral surfaces, indicating a punctuated aggradational environment which is sporadically wetted (the crusts appear structural). The relatively large amount of dung indicates either the presence of prolonged standstills in aeolian deposition, or increased use of the cave by herbivores during this period. The inclusion of occupation material in the unit suggests reworking of nearby occupation material. Context 536 therefore shows a punctuated aeolian depositional environment, which has been sporadically wetted and influenced by the deposition of significant amounts of dung. Context 561 Context 561 is a yellowish red (5YR 5/6) silt with 50% platy, angular limestone plaquettes at the top of 2033:2 2033:1 (5 37 ) (5 62 ) 2033:1-2Interleaved boundary,PPL 2mm a 2033:2General view, XPL 2mm b Sample 2033 Co nt ex t 1cm Figure 6.16: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 562. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 134 F ig ur e 6. 17 : Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt s 53 6 an d 56 1. 20 58 :1 20 58 :2 20 58 :3 20 58 :4 (536)(561) 20 58 :1 -2 -3 Bo un da rie s, PP L 2m m a 20 58 :3 Cl ay ey le ns es ,P PL 1m m 20 58 :4 D un g an d sp he ru lit es , XP L 50 0μ m 20 58 :4 D un g an d ph yt ol ith s, w ith m ic ro -c ru st ,P PL 50 0μ m d 20 58 :4 D un g, PP L 1m m e Sa m pl e 20 58 1c m Context c b Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 135 the unit (2–4cm). There are also a few very large subangular to subrounded limestone blocks (20cm). The lower boundary is clear, over 0.5cm, and marks a shift to higher gravel content. 2058:1 is an orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive to weakly-developed subangular irregular microstructure overlying a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (50:50) and there is rare blocky charcoal, bone (potentially burnt and unburnt) and shell. There are rare well-rounded iron nodules and rare iron amorphous laminations/lenses, as well as rare depositional crust fragments. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. (Fig. 6.17d) Micro-fabric 2058:2 is a red-brown silty clay loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a massive to vughy structure overlying a moderately developed subangular blocky structure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- to mosaic-speckled and micritic calcitic crystallitic (40:30:30). There are rare blocky organic fragments with cell structures and rare blocky dung fragments, along with frequent depositional crust fragments. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear (Fig. 6.17d). Micro-fabric 2058:3 is a pale orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a massive/vughy microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic crystallitic (75:25). There is very rare blocky charcoal, shell and rare bone. There are few clayey silt laminations and micro-crusts, and cappings to planar voids and limestone (Fig. 6.17e). The limestone fragments are concentrated at the top of the slide. There are well-rounded iron nodules and common depositional crust fragments, concentrated at the base. There are few dung lenses. Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. The clayey nature of the material within the micro-fabrics in Context 561 may suggest the inclusion of soil material in the sediments, although could also reflect material weathered from limestone from within the karstic system and transported into the cave. The fining sequences and depositional crusts indicate that this material has been reworked through a series of sheet wash events. Depositional crusting towards the bottom of 2058:3 marks a period of sheetwash which is overlain by silty sediment, probably the result of an aeolian depositional envirotnment. This is capped by the deposition of clayey material in 2058:2, probably the result of a second sheetwash event, prior to the deposition of a more mixed unit of red, clayey material, potentially soil, which incorporates limestone gravel, probably though another colluvial movement in 2058:1. Occupation material throughout the context indicates reworking of nearby occupation material either older than, or contemporary with, deposition. Context 561 therefore appears to contain a series of sheetwash events increasing in rapidity and volume. Context 535 Context 535 is a reddish-black silt (5YR 2.5/) silt with no blocks of charcoal. The context is compact and blocky in places, and has a diffuse boundary with Context 561 below. This context is part of the burning event discussed further in Chapter Eight, Section 8.2, but appears to contain the lower part of a heavily weathered burning event. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 136 6.4.2.3 Context 513, North and West-Facing Profile Context 513 on theWest-Facing Profile is a reddish-brown (5YR 4/4) silty clay with 20% horizontally- orientated subangular limestone gravel (1–20mm). The unit is slightly concreted to its base, and has a slight laminar structure. Its lower boundary is clear to diffuse. On the West-Facing Profile, the top of Context 513 is shown in Micro-fabric 2663:3. This is a light brown sandy silt loam with frequent limestone gravel and fine sand, and a vughy microstructure with areas of weakly-developed granular to subangular blocky microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There is very rare bone and shell. There are rare orange-brown clay coatings and infillings to voids at the top of the unit (Fig. 6.18a), and very rare calcitic hypocoatings to limestone clasts as well as rare calcitic infillings to voids. There are rare degraded dung fragments and well-rounded iron nodules along with rare depositional crust or infilling fragments, potential burnt aggregates, and rare vesicular silica fragments (Fig. 6.18b) and a single fragment of silica plant structure with a manganese coating. The silty texture of 2663:3 and inclusions of frequent limestone gravel and fine sand indicate that the fine material is a probably a product of aeolian deposition and reworking, and significant physical weathering of the bedrock. The presence of calcitic hypocoatings to some voids indicates the post- depositional movement of carbonate-rich water through the sediments. The presence of broken depositional crust and infilling fragments as well as vesicular silica in the absence of other combustion materials indicates reworking of occupation material and sediments around the cave. 26 63 :3 (5 13 ) (5 09 ) 2663:3Clayeyvoid infillings, PPL 1mm a 2663:3Vesicular silica, PPL 500μm b Sample 2663 1cm Co nt ex t a Figure 6.18: Slide scan and micromphotographs from Context 513, West-Facing Profile. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 137 On the North-Facing Profile, Context 513 is whitish-grey silt with distorted lenses of yellower, redder and greyer silt within it. There is 10% horizontally oriented, sub-rounded limestone (1–2cm). The context is indurated, forming blocks in the section which are stained at their edges with manganese. Its lower boundary with the underlying black silt (Context 535) is slightly diffuse, undulating and possibly disturbed. The internal stratigraphy of this context is discussed in Chapter Eight, but it appears to be the result of a substantial burning event which has become heavily weathered during a prolonged period of exposure, and reworked onto the West-Facing Profile. 6.4.3 Facies Four: Bulk Sedimentology In Facies Four, only Context 513 can be traced across both profiles. This stratigraphic complexity may indicate potential post-depositional reworking of exposed sediments around the cave which may have affected the bulk sedimentological data, as well as the spatial restriction of in situ units. Facies Four marks the beginning of the period of low magnetic susceptibility values discussed in Chapter Five, with all of the corrected and uncorrected values lying below the respective means of the variables for the entire sequence. The values are relatively consistent (Fig. 6.19), with the North- Facing Profile values slightly higher the West-Facing. On the North-Facing Profile minor peaks in %LOI in Context 536 and to a lesser extent in Contexts 535 and 537 correspond roughly with magnetic susceptibility lows. The%CaCO 3 values are all above or at themean for the whole sequence, and shows a peak in Context 516 on the West-Facing Profile which can be roughly correlated with a gradual peak between Contexts 537 and 562 on the North-Facing Profile. 6.4.4 Facies Four: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data The micromorphological interpretations (summarised in Table 6.5) of a probably relatively consistent aeolian depositional environment for the sediments are mirrored in the consistently low magnetic susceptibility values (corrected and uncorrected) throughout the facies. It is unlikely that the low magnetic susceptibility indicates a lack of prolonged surface exposure and weathering of the sediments as the physical weathering material appears to indicate relatively slow deposition. Yet periods of sheetwash of potentially external soil material in the North-Facing Profile in Contexts 561 and 562 are not indicated in the bulk magnetically susceptibility values. This is probably because they are lost within the bulk sampling resolution. The %LOI peaks correspond with the field observations of burning in Contexts 535 and 537 as well as the micromorphological observations of dung in Context 536, indicating a substantial original organic content to these contexts, given the general trend over time to low %LOI values at this depth. The material underlying the burning event in Contexts 535/513 does not appear to be particularly raised in magnetic susceptibility. On the West-Facing Profile, the high %CaCO 3 value in Context 516 supports the field observations of increased roof-spall, yet the context was not sampled for micromorphology, so the interpretation remains tentative and secondary calcite deposition or a carbonate aeolian contribution to the peak Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 138 cannot be ruled out. On the North-Facing Profile, the peak which encompasses Contexts 537, 532, and 562 corresponds with observations of increased limestone sand and gravel mixed with aeolian fine material (or more clayey soil material as in Context 562). Figure 6.19: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Four. Blue magnetic susceptibility bars are uncorrected values, red are corrected values. 10 0 20 0 30 0 40 0 50 0 60 0 0 513 535 561 536 562 537 537 567 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 0 6 0 7 0 513 516 517 10 0 20 0 30 0 40 0 50 0 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 5 0 6 0 Magnetic Susceptibility (x) % LOIorganics % Carbonate W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile Table 6.5: Summary of Facies Four context interpretations based on micromorphological descriptions. Context Micromorphological Interpretation West- and North-Facing Profile 513 Ash layer from burning event on North-Facing section, reworked under dry, aeolian conditions. North-Facing Profile 535 Degraded charcoal layer 561 Repeated, punctuated inwashes of clay-rich material, punctuated by potential aeolian/dust deposition and reworking. Occupation material. 536 Potential aeolian/dust reworking and deposition, with occupation material and significant quantities of dung, sporadic wetting. 562 Punctuated, increasing inwashes of clay-rich material, potentially soil, reworking limestone sand and gravel. 537 Physical weathering and aeolian/dust deposition and reworking, with sporadic sheetwash episodes becoming more frequent to the top of the unit. Occupation material throughout. 567 Potential aeolian/dust reworking and deposition and physical weathering. Bioturbation. Punctuated wash of clay-rich material. West-Facing Profile 516 Not sampled, but high degree of physical weathering in aeolian/dust environment. 517 Rapid potential aeolian deposition followed by slower, puncutated potential aeolian deposition and physical weathering, sporadic calcite precipitation from dripping. Bioturbation.. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 139 6.4.5 Facies Four: Interpretation The silty nature of the fine material in Facies Four, as well as its high gravel content points to increased physical weathering and probable overall aeolian deposition throughout this facies. In places, however, limited inwash events punctuated this dry environment. On the West-Facing Profile, Context 517 marks a period of potential aeolian and internally dominated deposition and reworking with limited secondary calcitic deposition indicating groundwater dripping in the cave, although this may be post-depositional and far later. There is an overall escalation in the influence of physical weathering on sedimentation in Context 517 and 516 as shown in the increasing roof-spall. On the North-Facing Profile the sediments appear to mirror a similarly dry environment of aeolian reworking and deposition, with limestone sand and gravel from increased physical weathering. This depositional regime was punctuated by small sheetwash events, most prominent in Contexts 562 and 537, where inwash or flows from within the karstic system increase in intensity before being covered by potential aeolian deposition. Facies Four is capped on both profiles by Context 513, which appears to be the reworked material from a burning event on theNorth-Facing Profile (Contexts 535 and 513), discussed further in Chapter Eight. It was probably exposed for a prolonged period after its deposition, consistent with the slow depositional environment suggested in the rest of Facies Four. The differences between the two profiles may result from themore limited sampling of theWest-Facing Profile; the North-Facing Profile has been more heavily sampled in this facies and therefore can show a more complex series of subtle changes in the depositional and hydrological regime within the cave. Yet the spatial complexity of the stratigraphy in the facies also illustrates the potential complexity and continual reworking of dry sediments across the cave floor, which can blur the geochemical trends between sediments. In summary, Facies Four appears to contain aeolian-deposited and reworked material and increased roof spall, with two cycles of increasing sheetwash punctuating the overall apparently dry environment on the North-Facing Profile. The internal environment of the cave was probably largely dry, with limited external input and increased physical weathering. Potentially slow deposition may have allowed reworking and deflation of unconsolidated sediment through aeolian processes as well as small-scale bioturbation by meso-fauna.There are indications that both people and animals frequented the cave throughout Facies Four, most notably in Context 513. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 140 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 51 3 W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e 26 63 :3 35 -5 0m m L ig ht br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d fr eq ue nt li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd . V ug hy w it h ar ea s of w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re si li ca pl an ts tr uc tu re w it h m an ga ne se co at in g. V er y ra re bo ne an d sh el l. R ar e or an ge cl ay co at in gs to vo id s at to p of un it .M or e m as si ve to to p 1- 2c m of un it .V er y ra re ,m m -t hi ck st al ag m it ic co at in gs to li m es to ne fr ag m en t. R ar e ca lc it ic in fil li ng s to vo id s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e de gr ad ed du ng fr ag m en ts .R ar e cr us to r in fil li ng fr ag m en ts up to 2c m .R ar e ve si cu la r si li ca fr ag m en ts P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,a nd re w or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. B ur ni ng ev en t on N or th -f ac in g pr ofi le ,e xp os ed an d re w or ke d un de r po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n/ dr y co nd it io ns w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng . 51 3 N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e 10 52 :2 to 10 52 :5 S ee C ha pt er E ig ht ,S ec ti on 8. 3. 2. B ur ni ng ev en t, re w or ke d an d he av il y w ea th er ed W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e 51 6 N ot sa m pl ed fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og y. In te ns e ph ys ic al w ea th er in g in ae ol ia n de po si ti on al en vi ro nm en t. 51 7 26 66 :1 Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se qu ar tz si lt to fin e sa nd .C om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e w it h 20 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs ,v eg et al vo id s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 32 :6 8. F ai nt ,d if fu se lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al an d hu m ifi ed or ga ni cs .F ew bu rn tb on e an .R ar e si lt y hy po -c oa ti ng s to ve ge ta l vo id s an d co ar se m at er ia l. R ar e m an ga ne se co at in g an d hy po co at in g to vo id s. R ar e ir on no du le s. V er y ra re w el l- ro un de d cr us tf ra gm en ts .o cc .d un g le ns es an d bl oc ky . P un cu ta te d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es , w it h in cr ea se in ph ys ic al w ea th er in g to to p of un it an d bi ot ur ba ti on . R ap id po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on fo ll ow ed by w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch gr ou nd w at er ,t he n sl ow er ,p un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g, w it h bi ot ur ba ti on . 26 66 :2 10 m m Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne co ar se sa nd an d gr av el cl as ts .M as si ve to vu gh y/ ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,v eg et al vo id s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m ,C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re ch ar re d bl oc ky or ga ni cs .V er y ra re fli nt ,r ar e bo ne .R ar e ar ra ng em en to f fin e m at er ia li nt o du ng ps eu do m or ph ic fa br ic s. R ar e ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs . F ew du ng fr ag m en ts . R ap id po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h la te r w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er an d bi ot ur ba ti on , po te nt ia ll y in di ca ti ng a pe ri od of ex po su re . Ta bl e 6. 6: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F ac ie s F ou r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul l de sc ri pt io ns in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al , fr eq . - fr eq ue nt ,c om m .- co m m on . Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 141 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on N or th -F ac in g P ro fil e 56 1 20 58 :1 10 -1 5m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h oc ca si on al qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d fr eq ue nt li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar ir re gu la r ov er ly in g w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 50 ). C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 37 :6 3. P ro m in en ta nd cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry R ar e: bl oc ky ce ll st ru ct ur e, bo ne bu rn ta nd un bu rn t, an d sh el l. O cc .M n de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e ir on am or ph ou s la m in at io ns /l en se s. R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts . S he et w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia l. R ep ea te d, pu nc tu at ed sh ee tw as h, pu nc tu at ed by po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng . O cc up at io n 20 58 :2 4m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h fe w qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve to vu gh y bu tm od er at el y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -, m os ai c- sp ec kl ed an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (4 0: 30 :3 0) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ce ll st ru ct ur e, ch ar re d/ m an ga ne se im pr eg na te d or ga ni c m at er ia la nd bo ne .O cc . m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e bl oc ky du ng fr ag m en ts .F re qu en tc ru st fr ag m en ts . S he et w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia l 20 58 :3 15 m m P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve -v ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic (7 5: 25 ). C F li m it 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. P ro m in en t, di ff us e an d in te rl ea ve d lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar co al an d sh el l. R ar e bo ne . F ew ho ri zo nt al le ns es of cl ay ey si lt la m in at io ns an d m ic ro cr us ts .C ap pi ng to pl an ar vo id be lo w an d ar ou nd li m es to ne at to p of un it .L im es to ne fr ag m en ts co nc en tr at ed at to p of sl id e fin er th an co ar se sa nd in co nc en tr at ed la ye r 0. 5c m .O cc .d en dr it ic m an ga ne se no du le s an w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. C om m on cr us t fr ag m en ts th ro ug ho ut bu tc on ce nt ra te d to ba se .F ew du ng le ns es . L im it ed w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia lf ol lo w ed by po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on . 53 6 20 58 :4 35 m m B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d co ar se sa nd ,c om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el . M as si ve /v ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b on e bu rn ta nd un bu rn t, an d ve ry ra re :fl in t( ro un d) an d sh el l. ra re sl ig ht ar ra ng em en to f co ar se /m ed iu m sa nd in to ho ri zo nt al le ns es .R ar e ar ea of cr us ti ng be tw ee n le ns es of du ng . so m e co nc re te d w it h ca lc it e to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it .O cc de nd ri ti c M n st ai ni ng .F ew ir on no du le s w el l- ro un de d. fr eq ue nt du ng le ns es in up pe r pa rt , do m in at e un it . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h oc cu pa ti on m at er ia la nd si gn ifi ca nt qu an ti ti es of du ng . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on , w it h oc cu pa ti on m at er ia la nd si gn ifi ca nt qu an ti ti es of du ng , sp or ad ic w et ti ng Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 142 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 56 2 20 33 :1 10 -2 0m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd .F re qu en tl im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ;v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. P ro m in en t, sh ar p an d in te rl ea ve d lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar re d bl oc ky or ga ni c ce ll st ru ct ur e; bu rn t an d un bu rn tb on e an d sh el l. M or e cl ay ey to lo w er 0. 5c m .R ar e m ic ri ti c in fil li ng to fo rm er ch an ne ls . R ar e hy po co at in gs of co ar se li m es to ne sa nd .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d ra re w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s si lt y. P un ct ua te d in w as h of cl ay -r ic h m at er ia l re w or ki ng li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el . P un ct ua te d in w as h of cl ay -r ic h m at er ia lr ew or ki ng li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el . 20 33 :2 20 -2 5m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd .F re q. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . M as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar /b lo ck y m ic ro st ru ct ur e w it h 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic (6 0: 40 ). C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 45 :5 5. P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al an d sh el l. F ew bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e. L ay er of si lt y cl ay (3 0% cl ay ) at ba se .C la ye y cr us ti n ce nt re of un it .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. P un ct ua te d in w as h of cl ay -r ic h m at er ia l re w or ki ng li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el . 53 7 20 33 :3 40 -4 5m m P al e br ow n (P P L ) S an dy si lt lo am .F ew qu ar tz an d fr eq ue nt li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 42 :5 8. F ai nt an d cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e: ce ll st ru ct ur e pa rt ia ll y hu m ifi ed pa rt ia ll y ch ar re d or ga ni cs an d fli nt .F ew bo ne bu rn ta nd un bu rn t, an d sh el l. R ar e le ns es of re dd is h si lt y cl ay < 1m m th ic k. C oa rs en in g fr om ba se of un it (2 0- 40 % ). In cr ea se in cr ys ta ll it ic im pr eg na ti on to w ar ds to p. O cc . de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e ir on no du le s w el l ro un de d. L ar ge bu rr ow in ce nt re of sl id e. In te ns e ph ys ic al w ea th er in g an d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,s po ra di c sh ee tw as h be co m in g fr eq ue nt to to p of th e un it .O cc up at io n m at er ia l th ro ug ho ut . P hy si ca l w ea th er in g an d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on , w it h sp or ad ic sh ee tw as h ep is od es be co m in g m or e fr eq ue nt to th e to p of th e un it .O cc up at io n m at er ia l th ro ug ho ut . 20 33 :4 7m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .A s w it h 20 33 :5 bu tw it h m or e cl ay an d sl ig ht ly be tt er de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. F ai nt bu ts ha rp lo w er bo un da ry . A s 20 33 :5 P hy si ca lw ea th er in g an d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on ,s po ra di c sh ee tw as h. O cc up at io n m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t. 20 33 :5 8- 12 m m Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am . O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd .C om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e w it h 15 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs ,c pv an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. D is ti nc t, sh ar p, w av y lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e, bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b ur nt an d un bu rn tb on e, sh el l. R ar e le ns es of si lt y cl ay 10 0- 20 0μ m th ic k. H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on an d le ns in g in fin e fr ac ti on . R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e di ff us e ir on no du le s to w el l- ro un de d. V er y ra re du ng le ns . P hy si ca lw ea th er in g an d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on ,s po ra di c sh ee tw as h. O cc up at io n m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t. 56 7 20 33 :6 15 -2 0m m D ar k br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h fe w qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d fr eq ue nt li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . V ug hy to gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e w it h 20 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs ,c pv an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic (8 0: 20 ). C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F R at io :5 0: 50 .N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e an d sh el l. V er y ra re fli nt an d fe w bo ne fr ag m en ts .C oa ti ng s/ cr us ta tb as e of un it ,w ar pe d, fin e sa nd to si lt .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g. B io tu rb at io n. P un ct ua te d w as h of cl ay -r ic h m at er ia l. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 143 6.5 Facies Four and Five: Summary Discussion The fine material from both Facies Four and Five appears to have been deposited predominantly by aeolian processes, however there are some distinct differences between the facies, not least in the presence of large amounts of limestone roof-spall in Facies Four, and the anthropogenic features in Facies Five. 6.5.1 Facies Five Facies Five contains far less limestone weathering material than Facies Four, indicating a period of relatively low physical weathering within the cave. There appear to be breaks in sedimentation which have left relatively dry, unconsolidated surfaces, which in places were occupied (e.g. between Contexts 523 and 521, as observed in 522), the occupations separated largely by potential aeolian deposition. The anthropogenic features in Facies Five correspond to those observed by McBurney as well as a substantially high number of artefacts from these layers (Chapter Four, Section 4.2.2). Such a density in material is unique until Facies Two. This occupation may have influenced the variable magnetic susceptibility of the sediments, however there is little evidence of significant rubefication in the thin sections, and periods of soil material deposition are also high in magnetic susceptibility. The anthropogenic material appears largely to have accumulated and been reworked in relatively dry environments, with the exception of the second phase of use of F600 (Chapter Eight). The most distinct context in Facies Five is the inwash event of potential soil material in Context 520; although limited to theWest-Facing Profile, it marks a distinct change in the hydrological regime of the cave in the colluvial movement of material intepreted as soil. 6.5.2 Facies Four FaciesFour isdominatedby increased inputof roof-spallobserved inboth thefieldandmicromorphology of the sediment. This indicates a major increase in physical weathering. Within what appears to be an environment of physcial weathering and predominantly potentially aeolian deposition and reworking, there were periods of sheetwash of clayey material on the North-Facing Profile from inwash events or flows from cracks within the karstic system. Within these sheetwash periods, deposition began as relatively small-scale, and increased in volume. These washes indicate an active hydrological system sporadically interrupting the predominantly dry cave environment. Facies Four contains little evidence for continued anthropogenic influence on the sediments in the field, yet in the thin sections, occupation material has been reworked throughout the facies, which is ultimately capped by the largest burning event in the MSA sequence. This is consistent with the high numbers of lithics from the facies from the 1950s excavations (see Chapter Four). The micromorphologically-observed anthropogenic material shows heavy weathering and reworking in predominantly dry conditions. Chapter Six: The Micromorphology of Facies Four and Five 144 6.6 Conclusion Whilst both Facies Four and Five contain apparently primarily aeolian-deposited material and largely dry conditions, there are a number of variations in the facies which may indicate wider environmental change through the changes within the cave. The predominance of physical weathering in Facies Four is one such variation, as is the lack of physical weathering and more apparent anthropogenic input in Facies Five. The micromorphological observations have expanded these wide scale trends to include more subtle, higher resolution changes in the cave sedimentary environments over time. Potential causes and implications of these sedimentary changes for periods of wider environmental change will be discussed in full in Chapter Nine. 145 Chapter Seven: The Soil Micromorphology of Facies Three 7.1 Introduction Facies Three contains both MSA and Early Dabban layers, separated by Layer XXV which contains interleaved assemblages with mixed affinities (Chapter Four). Facies Three consists of silt layers varying in the field in compactness, colour, and texture, with reddish, clayey layers of silt standing proud from the section during cleaning interspersed with friable, pale yellow and orange silt layers (Fig. 7.1; full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four). Some layers were concreted by carbonate precipitation. The layers were largely horizontal, and many could be traced between the West and North-Facing Profiles. Sporadic layers of gravel became more pronounced and frequent towards the top of the facies and the transition to Facies Two. For ease of discussion, Facies Three will be split into its three cultural units: the Late MSA layers, Contexts 509–498; Layer XXV, Contexts 497–491; and the Early Dabban layers, Contexts 497–461. Figure 7.1: Photo of North-Facing Profile at the base of the Middle Trench showing the Facies Three cultural subdivisions used in this chapter. Scale divisions are 50cm. Photo: G. Barker. Ea rly D ab ba n XX V M SA Fa ci es Th re e Fa ci es Fo ur Fa ci es Fi ve Fa ci es Tw o Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 146 F ig ur e 7. 2: L oc at io n an d sa m pl in g of F ac ie s T hr ee M SA se di m en ts (g re y) fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al an al ys is .S ha de d ar ea s ex pa nd ed be lo w .D ra w in g: L .F ar r 49 8 49 9 53 1 50 3 50 4 50 5 53 4 50 7 50 8 50 3 49 8 49 9 53 1 50 4 53 4 50 7 50 8 50 cm 0 10 00 20 10 96 1 94 0 93 9 26 63 20 37 22 42 0 1 2m Fa ci es 1 Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 Fa ci es 5 N S E W W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile D ab ba n (X VI -X XI V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) M SA (X XV -X XX V) Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 147 7.2 The Late MSALayers 7.2.1 The Late MSALayers: Field Description The lowest layers in the MSApart of Facies Three are commonly pale orange-browns and yellow silts with little gravel (full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four). There is a shift towards a higher frequency of slightly redder and more compact layers from Contexts 503 to 499. This part of the facies was sampled for micromorphological analysis on the West-Facing Profile only (Fig. 7.2). 7.2.2 The Late MSALayers: Soil Micromorphology Context 509 In the field, Context 509 is a yellowish red (5YR 4/6) clayey silt with 15% limestone gravel (2mm– 2cm), with horizontal orientation to the larger fragments. The lower boundary occurs over 2cm, and is marked by a change in colour from the underlying grey-brown Context 513 to orange, a change accompanied by a decrease in gravel content in 509. The top of Context 509 is shown in Micro-fabric 939:3 as a 55mm-thick orange-brown (PPL) clay loam/silty clay loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel clasts. It has a moderately developed granular microaggregate to vughy-massive microstructure (25% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There are occasional silty coatings to coarse material and silty clay lenses. There are rare, well-rounded, iron nodules. There are frequent depositional crust fragments and broken silty clay infillings, as well as few clay infillings at the base of the unit (Fig. 7.3a). Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2663:1 contains the lower contact of the context, and is a 35 to 45mm-thick brown- orange (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a well-developed granular microaggregate to vughy microstructure (80:20) with 40% porosity (Fig. 7.3b). Its b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There are also very rare fragments of vesicular silica and charred organic material with cell structure, rare bone and very rare flint. There are very rare silty clay link cappings to the coarse material, and rare micritic calcitic infillings and hypocoatings to voids. There are lenses of medium sand towards the top of the unit, with occasional well-rounded iron nodules. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. Micro-fabric 2663:2 (5–10mm thick) is a brown (PPL) silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel and a massive to weakly-developed vughy microstructure (10% porosity). It has a stipple- speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (80:20), and the fabric is in places humic-stained (Fig. 7.3c). There is occasional charred and humified organic material (Fig. 7.3d) and rare bone, and rare vesicular silica containing quartz grains. There are red clay silty complete void infillings, as well as few orange dusty clay void coatings. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. The density of the organic and charred material in 2663:2 indicates a significant concentration of anthropogenic debris at the base of the context. The silty texture of 2663:1 and 939:3 indicate an aeolian origin for the fine material with the partially crystallitic b-fabric probably resulting from Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 148 93 9: 3 2663:2 26 63 :1 (5 09 ) (5 08 ) (5 13 ) 939:3Crust fragments, PPL 2mm a 2663:1Granular microstructure,PPL 1mm b 2663:2General view, PPL 2mm 1mm 2663:2Stained groundmass with organics,PPL d Sample 939 Sample 2663 1cm c Co nt ex t Figure 7.3: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 509. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 149 dust weathering from the limestone, or the deposition of carbonate aeolian silt rather than micritic precipitation at a later date given the lack of other calcitic pedofeatures. The granular structure of the fabric indicates significant bioturbation, which may have reworked occupation material from the base of the context, mixing it throughout 2663:1. Alternatively, occupation material may have been reworked across a surface from nearby during the deposition of the rest of the context. The clay lenses, silty infillings and crust fragments which are present in the three micro-fabrics may show washing of clay-rich water into and around the cave and puddling - their clayey fabric appears markedly different from the largely silty matrix of the fabric. This distinction may however simply be a by-product of textural sorting without the transport of external material into the cave, simply by puddling on the surface. The increasing thickness of these features to the top of Context 509 however suggests a potential escalation of sheetwash throughout the context and the deposition of larger volumes of this wash over time. The fragmented nature of the crusts in 939:3 probably results from the trampling on a surface following drying, though may also result from mechanical processes such as bioturbation following burial, (suggested through the granular nature of the structure) or potentially cryoturbation accompanying freezing and thawing. Context 509 therefore appears to consist of a period of occupation, followed by aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, and subsequent bioturbation, which was sporadically interrupted by punctuated, increasingly larger, sheetwash episodes. Context 508 Context 508 is a red (2.5YR 4/6) clayey silt layer. There are 3% slightly horizontally-oriented limestone gravel clasts (1–2cm). The lower boundary is diffuse. The full context is covered in Micro-fabric 939:2. This is a red-brown (PPL) clay loam/silty clay loam, with is occasional limestone fine sand and gravel. The microstructure is vughy, becoming more massive to the top, with porosity between 15 and 25%. The b-fabric is stipple- to mosaic-speckled (60:40). There are clayey coatings to vegetal voids and coarse material (Fig. 7.4a), and few rounded dung fragments. There are frequent crust and infilling fragments (Fig. 7.4b). The base of the unit is slanted, containing a ‘gully’(0–1.5cm deep)with slightly coarse crust fragments and thicker infillings. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The clayey texture of the material suggests a potential external soil origin for the fine material. The mosaic-speckled component of the b-fabric may result from the reworking of well-developed striated b-fabrics as observed in the soil pits (Section 4.3.2.1). Vegetal voids indicate the past presence of organic material. The ‘coatings’ to these voids have probably resulted from coatings which developed around the organic material during deposition, potentially in a wet slurry. The high frequency of crusts indicates a series of small, rapidmovements of clay-rich water. Given that these are smaller in size and thickness comparedwith those in 939:3, and not separated by potential aeolian deposition, they appear smaller in scale but far more frequent. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 150 Context 508 therefore appears to represent at least two episodes of transport of soil material into the cave by rapid, punctuated sheetwash events, truncating the underlying sediments. Context 507 In the field Context 507 is a yellowish red (5YR 5/8) clayey silt which is slightly more grey towards the top of the context. There are 5% limestone flecks of very fine gravel 2–4mm, concentrated up to 10% in the upper half of the unit. Its lower boundary is diffuse. The top of Context 507 is shown in Micro-fabric 940:3. It is a yellow-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam, with common limestone fine sand to gravel and a weakly-developed sub-angular blocky structure overlying a weakly-developed granular microstructure (15% porosity). The granular nature becomes more pronounced in the top half of the unit where the material is coarser. The b-fabric is stipple- speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are very rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone fragments. A link capping covers the aggregates at the top of the unit (Fig. 7.5a). There are rare manganese coatings to voids, and few iron nodules, one concentric. There are rare dung lenses and blocks. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 939:1 contains the base of Context 507, and is a yellow-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam/ silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand to gravel. It has a weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). 93 9: 2 939:2Clayey infillings, PPL 939:2Crust fragment, PPL 1mm 1mm a b Sample 939 1cm (5 08 ) (5 07 ) (5 09 ) Co nt ex t Figure 7.4: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 508. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 151 93 9: 1 (5 07 ) (5 06 ) (5 08 ) 94 0: 3 940:3Link capping, PPL 939:1Bioturbated calcitic hypocoatings,XPL 2mm 1mm 94 0: 2 940:2Crust,PPL 940:2Pedorelict and potential ash,PLL. 1mm 1mm (5 05 ) a b c d Sample 940 Co nt ex t a b c d Sample 961 1cm Figure 7.5: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 506 and 507. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 152 The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). The fabric becomes slightly coarser 1.5cm from the top of the slide. There are rare micritic calcitic hypocoatings to voids which have been fragmented (Fig. 7.5b), rare dung lenses and rare well-rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts. Its lower boundary was distinct and clear to diffuse. The silty texture of thefinematerial potentially suggests an aeolian origin anddepositional environment. The micritic b-fabric potentially indicates roof-spalling, which produced the limestone inclusions, but may also reflect aeolian carbonate sedimentation. Micritic calcite may also reflect post-depositional percolation of carbonate-rich water through the sediments yet there is a lack of calcitic coatings to voids to support this interpretation above the others The pedorelicts indicate soil material being brought into the cave, potentially through the trampling of animals (indicated by the dung fragments) or humans. The similarity of the groundmass of the iron nodules and that of the micro-fabric indicates that they formed in situ, through sporadic dampening of the material, also indicated by the calcitic features, with their sharp boundaries indicating later reworking. The lower boundary of the micro-fabric is sharp and potentially erosive. The blocky, compact structure at the base of the unit may indicate a mass deposition of material. The weak granular nature of the fabric may result from bioturbation or from granular source material, but its increased expression towards the top of the unit indicates that it is linked to bioturbation, perhaps during a sedimentary hiatus. The increase in limestone sand and gravel in the upper part of 940:3 may indicate a slowing of fine-material deposition, an increase in the physical weathering of the cave, or variations within the slurry which made up a colluvial movement. The variation in coarse material may also indicate two separate colluvial movements in 940:3. A link capping at the top of the unit in 940:3 indicates a wash of clay-rich material. Based on structural changes, composition of the fine material and arrangement of the components, it is likely that Context 507 represents originally aeolian/dusty material from the floor of the shelter which has been re-worked in a mudflow within the cave. Following deposition, the top of the unit was bioturbated during a period of exposure, creating a granular structure, before being capped by a thin wash of clay-rich material. Context 506 Context 506 is a yellowish red (5 YR 4/6) compact clayey silt which increases in clay towards its base. Within the context, there are interleaved lenses of clay and limestone grit (~1–2mm). There is 15% limestone fine sand and gravel (2% 0.5–1cm). It has a clear lower boundary. The entire depth of Context 506 is shown in Micro-fabric 940:2, and is 33mm thick. It is an orange- brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel and a weakly-developed subangular blocky to massive microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There is a slight fining and reddening towards the top of the unit accompanied by a significant reduction in porosity and a silty crust at the top of the context (Fig. 7.5c). There are occasional well-rounded iron nodules/pedorelicts and dung, along with very rare vesicular Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 153 silica aggregates and potential ash aggregates (Fig. 7.5d). There is rare warping of voids around coarse material. Its lower boundary is distinct and sharp. The silty texture of the material, coupled with its limestone content and mixed b-fabric indicates a mixture of aeolian-deposited fine material and roof spall. The spatial variation in porosity and structure in the fabric is slightly problematic. Exposure of a massive structure to bioturbation, perhaps a period of little or no deposition in the cave, would leave the base of the unit massive, with a more granular structure to the top, the opposite of what is observed. The density of the fabric towards the top may indicate a breakdown of granular aggregates through water action, forming a structural crust, and the small crust at the upper contact of the fabric probably results from wetting of the surface, yet there is little evidence for the widespread translocation of fine material to form a crust at a larger scale. Instead, it may be that the granular structure at the base of the unit is the result of bioturbation concentrated through a small burrow. The massive nature of the rest of the unit, especially towards the top, therefore indicates a potential colluvial movement of originally aeolian material, potentially closely preceded by the thin sheetwash of clay-rich, external soil material in 507. The base of the unit was later bioturbated by soil micro-fauna. Context 505 Context 505 is a red (2.5YR 4/6) clayey silt with 10% limestone subangular-subrounded fine gravel (0.5–1cm), with 2% subrounded cobbles (~10cm) to the top of the context. The coarse material is generally horizontally oriented. The lower boundary is clear to diffuse. The top and base of Context 505 were sampled, leaving 20cm between the two samples. The top contact is shown in Micro-fabric 961:3, a red-orange clay loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive to channel/vughy to weakly-developed sub-angular blocky microstructure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- to mosaic-speckled (70:30). There is rare charcoal, bone and flint, and rare micro-crusts of silty clay. There are occasional manganese void coatings, few well-rounded iron nodules, and rare dung fragments (Fig. 7.6a). Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 940:1 covers the base of 505, and is an orange-brown sandy silt loam with frequent limestone sand to gravel with awell-developed granularmicroaggregate structure (up to 40%porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are up to 20% fining sequence and crusts and coarsening sequences in the top 20mm of the unit (Fig. 7.6b). There are very rare clayey silt coatings to coarse fragments, and rare micritic calcitic hypocoatings to rare fragments of vesicular silica. There are rare dung lenses and blocks which become rounder to the base of the unit and rare well-rounded iron nodules. Its lower boundary is prominent and sharp. The micro-fabrics from Context 505 have quite different characters. In 940:1, the silty texture and frequent limestone sand and gravel suggest that the fabric is a mixture of aeolian/dusty material and roof-spall. Its granular microstructure indicates heavy bioturbation. Well-rounded dung blocks with silty coatings indicate that these fragments were rolled on dusty, sporadically damp surfaces prior Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 154 (506) 940:1 (505)(504) 961:3 961:2 96 1: 2 Co ar se m at er ia l m ix in g, PP L 2m m a 96 1: 2C al ci tic b- fa br ic ,X PL 1m m 96 1: 3C oa rs e m at er ia li n (5 05 ),P PL 2m m c 94 0: 1i nf illi ng s an d cr us t fr ag m en ts ,P PL 2m m d Sa m pl e 96 1 Sa m pl e 94 0 1c m b F ig ur e 7. 6: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 50 5 an d 50 4. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 155 to burial, surfaces which are also picked out by dung lenses. The concentration of crust and infilling fragments to the top of 940:1 indicates punctuated alluvial reworking and puddling of the matrix in a largely aeolian depositional environment. In Micro-fabric 961:3, the partially mosaic b-fabric indicate that it may consist of soil material washed into the cave, with micro-crusts indicating punctuated wetting or limited alluvial deposition potentially interspersed with aeolian deposition or reworking of external soil material, although its limited depth restricts interpretation. Its channel microstructure indicates extensive bioturbation or potential rooting of an initially massive structure. Context 505 is therefore the product of potentially aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking with sporadic wetting at its base. However, the top of the context is more ambiguous due to limited sampling, and may represent reworking by punctuated small-scale alluvial and aeolian processes. The lack of samples from the depth of the context between the two slides hampers its definition. Context 504 Context 504 is a red (2.5YR 4/6) clean clayey silt with 5% limestone fine gravel (2mm–0.5cm). It has a diffuse/clear lower boundary. Micro-fabric 961:2 contains the whole depth of Context 504, and is an orange-brown (PPL) silty clay loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel. The microstructure is massive to vughy, overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is an increase in coarse material and poor sorting in the middle part of the slide (Fig. 7.6c), and rare sparitic crystallitic infillings, with an increase in crystallitic b-fabric towards the top of the unit (Fig. 7.6d). There are rare dendritic manganese nodules and void coatings along with few well-rounded iron nodules. There are rare crusts at the base of the unit and a zone of crust fragments/infillings in the mixed area at the top of the unit. There is very rare blocky charcoal and flint. Its lower boundary is faint and diffuse. The silty nature of the fine material suggests a potential aeolian depositional environment for the sediment, and the presence of limestone sand suggests physical weathering within the cave. The crust fragments suggest punctuated sheetwash and puddling of clay-richwater in a mainly dry environment, especially at the base, perhaps mirroring a prolonged shift from the underlying regime of Context 504. The increase in density of the calcitic b-fabric to the top of the unit potentially indicates a period of groundwater dripping from the ceiling of the cave; wetting which is also marked by the manganese void coatings. This may have occurred during a sedimentary hiatus following the unit’s deposition. The context is quite disturbed at its upper contact, and may have been trampled by humans or animals. The presence of an area of clayey infillings may be linked to the later disruption of the nearby sediments by the presence of a large burrow observed in the field. Context 504 therefore appears to document aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking followed by a potential slowing or break in sedimentation. This break is potentially related to a period of calcite precipitation driven by a drip within the cave, although this precipitation may be post-depositional. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 156 Context 503 Context 503 is a light red (2.5YR 6/6) clayey silt with a slightly laminar structure. It contains 10% angular to subangular limestone gravel. The lower boundary is diffuse. A circular burrow, Context 501, cuts the context close to Sample 961. The upper contact of Context 503 is covered in Micro-fabric 2010:2. It is a pale yellow-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam/silt loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive/vughy to very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to undifferentiated to micritic calcitic crystallitic (50:20:30). There are rare fine organic blocky fragments and rare bone and shell. There are orange silty coatings to voids in areas which have been bioturbated, and micritic calcite impregnating the groundmass around these areas. There are few well- rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts (Fig. 7.7a) and blocky dung fragments and lenses. Its lower (5 04 ) 96 1: 1 (5 03 ) 20 10 :2 (499) 1mm 961:1Compoundcalcitic hypocoating andclayey infilling,XPL 2010:2Pedorelict and bone,PPL 1mm a 961:1Calcitic b-fabric,XPL 1mm b c Sample 2010 Sample 961 1cm Figure 7.7: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 503. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 157 boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 961:1 is an orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel. It has a massive/vughy to very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure and 15% porosity. The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (50:50). The unit has been cemented through this calcite, especially in the bottom 10–15mm of the unit (Fig. 7.7b). Vesicular clayey infillings to voids at the top of the slide overly calcitic coatings (Fig. 7.7c). There are occasional diffuse to well-rounded iron nodules and occasional dung fragments and lenses. Its lowed boundary is faint and diffuse. The silty texture of the fine material suggests a potential aeolian origin to the sediments, with limestone inclusions resulting from roof-spall. Dung lenses indicate punctuated deposition and ephemeral surfaces, yet the mixed nature of the base of the unit suggests bioturbation. The significant calcite cementation of the groundmass indicates water moving through the profile, perhaps precipitating out with the change in porosity created by the bioturbation. It is unclear whether this represents a different phase of calcite deposition to that observed in 504, or if the two contexts were subject to one period of deposition beginning during or after the deposition of 503, or far later after burial. The presence of vesicular clayey infillings is probably linked to water moving through the groundmass through space opened up by a nearby burrow (observed in the field), disruption which is also seen in the base of 2010:2. Context 503 is therefore probably primarily aeolian in deposition, with calcite precipitation from drips within the cave potentially during and after deposition, although such precipitation may also have occurred far later after burial. Context 499 Context 499 is a yellowish red (5YR 5/6) massive clayey silt with 5% limestone gravel (3mm–6cm) with a slight horizontal orientation. The lower boundary is clear to diffuse. Micro-fabric 1000:5 is a light brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel and a very weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled and micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are very rare silty coatings to coarse material and occasional well-rounded iron nodules. There are few dung fragments and lenses and a potential coprolite (Fig. 7.8a), and rare bone and shell. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2010:1 is an orange-brown (PPL) sandy silt loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive to vughy microstructure which is more massive to the top (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (85:15). There are rare bone fragments and very rare shell and flint. There are calcitic infillings to burrows at the top of the unit, and very rare manganese dendritic void coatings and hypocoatings as well as rare, well-rounded, iron nodules. Crust and dung fragments are common towards the base of the unit (Fig. 7.8b). It has a distinct, sharp lower boundary. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 158 (498) (497) (499) 1000:2 1000:3 1000:4 1000:5 2m m 10 00 :4 -5 Er os ive bo un da ry an d la m ni na tio ns in 10 00 :4 ,P PL 2m m 10 00 :5 Po te nt ia lc op ro lit e, PP L 1m m 20 10 :1 D un g an d cr us t fr ag m en t, PP L d (503) Sa m pl e 10 00 Sa m pl e 20 10 2m m 10 00 :2 Cl ay an d iro n- ric h go un dm as s, XP L a 1c m Context c b F ig ur e 7. 8: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 49 9 an d 49 8. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 159 The silty texture of the fine material suggests a possible aeolian origin, whilst the limestone content indicates physical weathering of the bedrock. The low density of the crystallitic b-fabric probably indicates dust spalling from the bedrock, or aeolian carbonate material. The silty coatings to the coarse material may result from material rolling on dusty surfaces. The structure is quite massive, indicating a lack of bioturbation, and coupled with a lack of limestone grit, this indicates potentially rapid deposition. The dung fragments and lenses, however, also suggest the presence of ephemeral surfaces in a punctuated depositional environment. Calcitic infillings to the burrows at the top of 2010:1 indicate calcitic water moving through the profile following bioturbation, during a period of increased groundwater dripping within the cave. Context 499 therefore appears to have been deposited through aeolian action at a relatively rapid rate, and has been subject to post-depositional calcite precipitation through water percolating through the profiles, potentially soon after deposition, but this could also have occurred far after burial. Context 498 Context 498 in the field is a red (2.5YR 4/6) compact clayey silt which has weathered proud of the section, with 5% subangular to angular blocky limestone fine gravel (2–5mm). Its lower boundary is sharp. Micro-fabric 1000:2 is a red (PPL) silty clay loam (Fig. 7.8c) with occasional medium sand to gravel limestone and a vughy to massive microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is mosaic to stipple-speckled (70:30). There are rare micritic hypocoatings to the few dung fragments. There are very rare well-rounded and diffuse iron nodules, as well as frequent crust fragments. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. Micro-fabric 1000:3 is an orange-brown (PPL) clay loam/silty clay loam with common limestone fine sand to gravel with a vughy microstructure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There is a slight horizontal orientation to the coarse inclusions, and the vughs appear ‘warped’ around coarse material inclusions. There are few crust fragments and occasional dung blocks and lenses. There is rare shell. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. 1000:4 is a yellow-orange brown (PPL) clay loam with frequent limestone fine sand to gravel and a massive to vughy microstructure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled. There are few silty coatings to the coarse material and dung, with common iron nodules with diffuse-sharp boundaries. It has a sharp diagonal lower boundary, with strong laminations of the fine material mirroring the alignment of the boundary (Fig. 7.8d). Its lower boundary is distinct and sharp. The three micro-fabrics divided by sharp boundaries probably indicate three distinct periods of deposition indistinguishable in the field. The red colour and clayey texture suggests the incorporation of soil material in all fabrics (given the appearance of the external soil pit fabric observed in Section 6.2.9), most noticeably in the reddest, 1000:2, although the inclusion of material weathered from Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 160 limestone from within the karstic system cannot be ruled out. The increasing redness and clayeyness of the micro-fabrics may indicate changes in source material, potentially representing different soil horizons (see discussions in Chapters Five and Six) or reduced mixing with local aeolian/ dusty sediments. The fine laminations and dung lenses indicate deposition in a series of punctuated movements within these three episodes, a punctuation which is also mirrored by the presence of reworked crust fragments indicating an ongoing reworking of material. Calcitic deposition within the voids indicates water dripping from the roof of the cave, or later post-depositional precipitation. The slightly granular structure and increase in porosity to the top of the context may indicate bioturbation during a sedimentary hiatus following the deposition of the unit. Context 498 therefore appears to be largely the result of a series of wet, colluvial movements of material, which first rework aeolian material, before potentially incorporating soil material. 7.2.3 The Late MSALayers: Bulk Sedimentology Facies Three lies in the period of low magnetic susceptibility values which began in Facies Four and ends in the shift to Facies Two (Chapter Five) and during which both uncorrected and corrected lie below their respective means for the sequence, with the exception of Context 498 which is a marked peak (Fig. 7.9). Within these generally low values there are also fluctuations, with peaks in Contexts 508 and 505. Overall trends are consistent between the two profiles, but the North-Facing Profile peaks are more gradual and lower than those on the West-Facing. As with the entire profile, %CaCO 3 values on the North-Facing Profile are higher than those on the West-Facing, with almost all the values on theWest-Facing Profile below the sequence mean. Mirroring the magnetic susceptibility values, the peaks are more gradual on the North-Facing Profile, although there are marked peaks in Contexts 508, 503/504 and 499. Both profiles show little variation in %LOI. 7.2.4 The Late MSALayers: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentology and Micromorphological Data Thepeaks inmagnetic susceptibility inContexts508and498correlatewellwith themicromorphological observations of reworked intepreted external soil material, although the value for 498 is markedly higher than that for 508. These contexts also correspond to low %CaCO 3 values, further strengthening their interpretation as primarily soil material with little aeolian or internally generated sedimentation.A magnetic susceptibility peak in Context 505may indicate the influence of external soil material hinted at by the limited micromorphological observations at the top of the context. The overall low magnetic susceptibility throughout the period may indicate a general lack of prolonged surface weathering and oxidation of sediment in a relatively rapid depositional environment. Peaks in %CaCO 3 on the West-Facing Profile are consistent with observed periods of secondary carbonate precipitation in Contexts 503, 504 and 499, yet 503 and 504 also contain limestone sand. There is very little evidence for calcite precipitation in Context 509, and this context’s %CaCO 3 peak probably results from the limestone fine sand observed in the thin section. Although not observed in thin section, ash may have been present in the sample along with the other combustion and occupation Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 161 Context Micromorphological Interpretation 498 Multiple erosive movements beginning with the mixing and redeposition of internal and soil material and increasing in soil content. 499 Rapid, punctuated potential aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, with limited calcite precipitation. Partially truncated by Context 498. 503 Potential punctuated aeolian/dusty deposition andrewroking with later calcite precipitation. 504 Punctuated potential aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, followed by potential depositional hiatus and calcite precipitation. Heavily disrupted at the top of the unit through bioturbation or trampling. 505 At base, heavily bioturbated potential aeolian/dusty material with increasing sheetwash and depositon of clay-rich water. At top, aeolian/small-scale colluvial deposition leaving an unconsolidated surface, with sporadic wetting - interpretation difficult. 506 Mass colluvial reworking of potentially aeolian or cave floor material. 507 Mass colluvial reworking of potenaitlly aeolian or cave floor material, later heavily bioturbated during a sedimentary hiatus. Capped by thin wash of clay-rich material. 508 Rapid, punctuated inwash of potential soil material in a three main phases. Truncates (509). 509 Period of occupation, followed by deposition of potentially aeolian material, physical weathering and internal material subject to heavy bioturbation. Sporadic wetting of sediments escalating into marked sheetwash and crusting at the top of the context. Table 7.1: Summary of interpretations of Facies Three MSA contexts based on micromorphological descriptions. Figure 7.9: Bulk sedimentological data for MSA contexts in Facies Three. Blue magnetic susceptibility bars are uncorrected values, red are corrected values. 70 0 60 0 50 0 40 0 30 0 20 0 10 0 0 498 499 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 2 3 4 5 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 60 0 50 0 40 0 30 0 20 0 10 0 0 498 566 499 531 503 505 534 507 508 2 3 4 5 500 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 MagneticSusceptibility(x)% LOIorganics % Carbonate W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 162 materials observed in the context, thus explaining the peak, yet this cannot be proved. %CaCO 3 values in this part of the profile therefore appear to be polygenetic in nature. There is little variation in %LOI, which reflects a general lack of anthropogenic influence as observed in the thin sections. The lack of a%LOI peak in Context 509 correspondingwith the occupation debris observed micromorphologically may be explained by the spatial restriction of the organic material observed in thin section and the relatively coarse resolution of the bulk sampling. The variation in the bulk sedimentological variables between the profiles is partially the result of the presence of lenses which cannot be traced between the two profiles. This complexity of the stratigraphy indicates that whilst some types of depositional events affected the whole cave, others were more localised. The smoother peaks in magnetic susceptibility and %CaCO 3 on the North-Facing Profile may indicate mixing and spreading of sediments through trampling and aeolian reworking, whilst, the sediments on the West-Facing Profile may retain a more marked external taphonomic imprint and preserve discontinuities between sediments, being directly in the path of inwash events such as Contexts 498 and 508. 7.2.5 The Late MSALayers: Interpretation The low magnetic susceptibility (both before and after correction) for the Facies Three MSA layers, coupled with the micromorphological observations, potentially indicate an aeolian origin and depositional environment for the fine material within nearly all of these contexts. Yet, in a number of contexts the depositional environment is not aeolian but colluvial, reworking existing sediments from the cave floor. The fine material has beenmixed throughoutwith the fine limestonematerial weathered from the cave walls and ceiling, but there is a general lack of gravel-sized limestone weatheringwithin the sediments potentially indicating a lack of physical weathering. The variable %CaCO 3 content traces a range of different variables: limestone sand content, secondarily precipitated calcite and potentially aeolian carbonate material. At the base of the facies, Context 509 contained a period of occupation. Following this occupation, aeolian deposition and reworking and moderate fine-grained physical weathering of the bedrock occurred, with later pulses of clay-rich sheetwash increasing in volume throughout the context. This small-scale sheetwash escalated into a period of high-energy inwash in Context 508, apparently transporting external soil material into the cave in a series of rapid punctuated flows. Contexts 506 and 507 show the reworking of potential aeolian material in colluvial movements with little evidence for the incorporation of external soil material. Interpretation of Context 505 is hampered by incomplete micromorphological sampling. However, it appears to contain a shift from potentially mainly aeolian material, interspersed with sheetwash of clay-rich water, to potential small- scale reworking of saturated soil material. Context 504 marked a resumption of potential aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, followed by secondary calcite precipitation indicative of calcareous groundwater dripping potentially during a Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 163 sedimentary hiatus. This may be a separate period of precipitation or the same as that in the aeolian- deposited Context 503. Context 499 marked a period of rapid potential aeolian deposition in a potentially drier environment without significant calcite deposition. It was truncated by Context 498, deposited in a number of mass movements which, although originally containing material with an aeolian origin, became progressively richer in external soil material. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 164 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 49 8 10 00 :2 20 -2 5m m R ed (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd oc c. li m es to ne m ed iu m to co ar se sa nd an d gr av el . V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty : vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar re d or ga ni cs .R ar e bo ne .R ar e m ic ri ti c hy po co at in g to du ng fr ag m en t. F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, ve ry ra re w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s, ra re di ff us e ir on no du le s. F re qu en tc ru st fr ag m en ts .F ew du ng fr ag m en ts an d le ns es . C ol lu vi al ly - re w or ke d po te nt ia l ex te rn al so il m at er ia l. M ul ti pl e er os iv e m ov em en ts be gi nn in g w it h th e po te nt ia lm ix in g an d re de po si ti on of in te rn al an d so il m at er ia la nd in cr ea si ng in so il co nt en t. 10 00 :3 20 -2 5m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,c om m on li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el . V ug hy m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el l. H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to co ar se in cl us io ns .C om m on ir on no du le s, di ff us e to w el l- ro un de d. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. F ew cr us tf ra gm en ts .O cc .d un g bl oc ks an d le ns es . R ap id ,w et co llu vi al ly -r ew or ke d po te nt ia le xt er na l so il m at er ia l. 10 00 :4 0- 15 m m Y el lo w -o ra ng e br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am .O cc qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd ,f re q. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar . S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic ,C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. D is ti nc t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al an d sh el l. F ew si lt y co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia la nd du ng . C om m on ir on no du le s di ff us e- sh ar p. T he re ar e la m in at io ns in th e fin e m at er ia l. R ap id ,e ro si ve w et co llu vi al ly -r ew or ke d po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l. 49 9 10 00 :5 11 -2 8m m L ig ht br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m on qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd .C om m on li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V .w ea kl y de v. su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty :v ug hs , pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne an d sh el l. V er y ra re si lt y co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia l. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .w el lr ou nd ed ir on no du le s. F ew du ng fr ag m en ts an d le ns es .C op ro li te /d un g pe ll et . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on , w it h li m it ed ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n. P ar ti al ly tr un ca te d by 49 8. 20 10 :1 50 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m on qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd ,c om m on li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e, m or e m as si ve to to p. 15 % po ro si ty :c ha nn el s, vu gh s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d: m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. D is ti nc t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne an d ve ry ra re sh el la nd fli nt .M or e m as si ve to to p of un it .c al ci ti c in fil li ng s to bu rr ow s in to p of un it .V er y ra re m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c co at in gs to vo id s. ve ry ra re m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e du ng fr ag m en ts an d le ns es .C ru st fr ag m en ts to ba se of un it co m m on . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Ta bl e 7. 2: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F ac ie s T hr ee M SA m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul ld es cr ip ti on s in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al ,f re q. - fr eq ue nt ,c om m .- co m m on . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 165 C on te xt M ic ro - fa br ic F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 50 3 20 10 :2 15 m m P al e ye ll ow -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m .M as si ve / vu gh y to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e (8 0: 20 ). 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c ha nn el s. O cc .q ua rt z si lt to sa nd ,c om m on li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .s ti pp le -s pe ck le d to un di ff er en ti at ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic /s pa ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 20 :3 0) .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ve ry fin e or ga ni c bl oc ky fr ag m en ts .V er y ra re bo ne ,r ar e sh el l. O ra ng e si lt y co at in gs to vo id s in bi ot ur ba te d ar ea s. M ic ri ti c ca lc it e im pr eg na ti ng gr ou nd m as s ro un d bi ot ur ba ti on .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s ne ar di st ur ba nc e. F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. F ew du ng bl oc ks an d le ns es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,w it h so m e w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lw it h pu nc tu at ed de po si ti on an d la te r ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n 96 1: 1 32 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m on qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd .F re qu en tl im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve / vu gh y to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :c ha m be rs ,v ug hs ,c ha nn el s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d: m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 50 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. F ai nt ,d if fu se lo w er bo un da ry . C em en te d th ro ug h ca lc it e de po si ti on .V er y ra re st ra w - li ke ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne an d sh el l. V es ic ul ar cl ay ey in fil li ng s to la rg e vo id s of th e un it .C om pl et e ca rb on at e co nc re ti on of lo w er 1- 1. 5c m by ca lc it e/ R ar e m an ga ne se ro un de d no du le s, ra re de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. O cc ir on no du le s, di ff us e to w el l- ro un de d. O cc .d un g fr ag m en ts an d le ns es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n/ in te rn al de po si ti on w it h si gn ifi ca nt w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 50 4 96 1: 2 65 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,o cc .l im es to ne .fi ne sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve -v ug hy ov er ly in g v. w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c om po un d pa ck in g vo id s, ch am be rs ,v eg et al vo id s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. F ai nt ,d if fu se lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar co al an d fli nt .I nc re as e in co ar se m at er ia la nd po or so rt in g in m id dl e pa rt of sl id e. A ss oc ia te d w it h ca lc it ic in fil li ng s to po re s. R ar e sp ar it ic ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs .I nc re as e in cr ys ta ll it ic gr ou nd m as s to to p of un it .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c fe rn s an d vo id co at in gs .F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e cr us ts at ba se of un it s. Z on e of cr us t fr ag m en ts /i nfi ll in g fr ag m en ts in m ix ed ar ea at to p of un it s. R ar e de gr ad ed du ng fr ag m en ts an d le ns es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,f ol lo w ed at so m e po in tb y w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er .H ea vi ly di sr up te d at th e to p of th e un it th ro ug h bi ot ur ba ti on or tr am pl in g. 50 5 96 1: 3 10 m m R ed -o ra ng e (P P L ) cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd . F re q. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve /c ha nn el -v ug hy to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .P or os it y: 10 % ch an ne ls , vu gh s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed b- fa br ic (7 0: 30 ). C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b on e an d fli nt .R ar e m ic ro cr us ts of si lt y cl ay .O cc m an ga ne se vo id co at in gs . R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s li nk ed to ir on no du le s. F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e du ng fr ag m en ts .C ha nn el s of ex cr em en t. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng by ve ry lo ca li se d, sm al l- sc al e sh ee tw as h. A tb as e, he av il y bi ot ur ba te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n m at er ia lw it h in cr ea si ng sh ee tw as h an d de po si ti on of cl ay -r ic h w at er . A tt op ,p ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on of le av in g an un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e, w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng - in te rp re ta ti on di ffi cu lt . 94 0: 1 40 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,F re qu en tl im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y up to 40 % :c om pl ex pa ck in g vo id s, vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0 P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . L ay er of in fil li ng /c ru st in g/ le ns of co ar se sa nd . R ar e bl oc ky or ga ni c an d bo ne .V er y ra re cl ay ey si lt co at in gs to co ar se fr ag m en ts .R ar e hy po co at in gs of ca lc it e to fr ag m en ts of ve si cu la r pl an ts il ic a. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le .R ar e du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks ,r ou nd er to ba se . C ru st an d in fil li ng fr ag m en ts up to 20 % in ar ea at to p of un it .V er y ra re ve si cu la r si li ca . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lh ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d an d ro ot ed ,w it h pu nc tu at ed sh ee tw as h. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 166 C on te xt M ic ro - fa br ic F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 50 6 94 0: 2 33 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt to fin e sa nd ,f re qu en tl im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky to m as si ve st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c ha nn el s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. D is ti nc t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar co al ,s he ll an d ra re bo ne .S li gh t fin in g an d re dd en in g to to p of un it in fin e m at er ia l. S il ty cr us tb el ow co nt ac ta tt op of un it .e xc re m en ta lg ra nu la r fa br ic at ba se .L in k ca pp in g al on g lo w er co nt ac t. W ar pi ng of vo id s ar ou nd co ar se 2% .R ar e de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. R ar e du ng .v er y ra re ve si cu la r si li ca . M as s co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng of po te nt ia l ae ol ia n m at er ia l. 50 7 94 0: 3 40 μm Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd .C om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ov er vu gh y/ m as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e be co m in g gr an ul ar to th e to p. 15 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d in te rc on ne ct ed ch an ne ls /p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :6 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry V er y ra re bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e. L in k ca pp in g to to p of un it .C oa rs en in g of m at er ia lt o to p of un it .R ar e m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e m an ga ne se co at in gs .F ew ir on no du le s on io n sk in w el l- ro un de d to di ff us e. R ar e du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lr ed ep os it ed in m ud flo w . B io tu rb at ed du ri ng ex po su re . M as s flo w (p ot en ti al ly m ul ti pl e ev en ts ) of in te rn al m at er ia l, la te r he av il y bi ot ur ba te d du ri ng ap pa re nt ex po su re . C ap pe d by th in w as h of cl ay -r ic h m at er ia l 93 9: 1 30 m m Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am /s il tl oa m .C om m . qu ar ts si lt to fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g v. w ea kl y de v gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c pv ,c ha nn el s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. L ow er bo un da ry di st in ct an d cl ea r to di ff us e. 1. 5c m fr om to p of sl id e, sh if tt o le ss co ar se m at er ia lt ha n be lo w .A re a of ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs w hi ch ha ve be en di st ur be d. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. F ew ir on no du le s w el l- ro un de d. R ar e du ng ,l en se s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lr ed ep os it ed in m ud flo w . 50 8 93 9: 2 30 - 50 m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am .C om m .q ua rt z si lt to fin e sa nd .O cc .l im es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy , m or e m as si ve to to p. F ro m 5m m do w n, fu se d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e to vu gh y. 15 -2 5% po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c pv , pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne .C la ye y si lt co at in g to oc c vo id s, es pe ci al ly ve ge ta l. O cc de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. F ew du ng ro un de d fr ag m en ts .F re qu en tc ru st an d in fil li ng fr ag m en ts . D ia go na l‘ gu ll y’ at ba se of un it 0- 1. 5c m se ep . R ap id in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi lm at er ia li n at le as tt w o m ai n ph as es .T ru nc at es 50 9. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 167 C on te xt M ic ro - fa br ic F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 50 9 93 9: 3 55 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am .C om m . qu ar tz si lt an d sa nd an d co m m .. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M od er at el y w el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e to vu gh y/ m as si ve .2 5% po ro si ty :v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne .R ar e si lt y co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia l. R ar e si lt y cl ay le ns es an d fe w cl ay in fil li ng s at th e ba se of th e un it .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. F re qu en tc ru st fr ag m en ts an d br ok en in fil li ng s. R ar e du ng fr ag m en ts . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h in cr ea si ng , pu nc tu at ed sh ee tw as h an d la te r di sr up ti on . P er io d of oc cu pa ti on , fo ll ow ed by de po si ti on of po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l, ph ys ic al w ea th er in g an d in te rn al m at er ia l su bj ec tt o he av y bi ot ur ba ti on . S po ra di c w et ti ng of se di m en ts es ca la ti ng in to m ar ke d sh ee tw as h an d cr us ti ng at th e to p of th e co nt ex t. T ru nc at ed by de po si ti on of 50 8. 26 63 :1 35 - 45 m m B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z fin e si lt an d sa nd .F re qu en tl im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e (8 0: 20 ). P or os it y: 40 % ,c pv ,c ha nn el s, vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 45 :5 5. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne an d ve ry ra re fli nt . V er y ra re si lt y cl ay li nk ca pp in gs to co ar se fr ag m en ts . L en se s to m ed iu m sa nd to to p of un it .R ar e ca lc it ic in fil li ng s/ hy po co at in gs to vo id s. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .i ro n w el l- ro un de d no du le s w it h m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. V er y ra re ve si cu la r pl an t gl as s, ro un de d. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. B io tu rb at io n. 26 63 :2 5- 10 m m B ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve to w ea kl y vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e w it h 10 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs . S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .c ha rr ed an d hu m ifi ed or ga ni c m at er ia l. R ar e bo ne . F ew br ig ht or an ge du st y cl ay in fil li ng s. R ar e re dd is h si lt y cl ay in fil li ng vo id s co m pl et el y. F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c an d or ga ni c st ai ni ng to th e gr ou nd m as s. R ar e co m po un d cl ay in te rc al at io ns an d la te r hy po co at in g. R ar e ro un de d ag gr eg at e of re fo rm ed si li ca an d qu ar tz gr ai ns . O cc up at io n la ye r. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 168 7.3 Layer XXV Layer XXV contains the shift between the MSA and Dabban levels. It was subdivided into five sub- layers, XXVa–e, which represent alternating layers of potentially reworkedMSAand Dabban artefacts prior to the full manifestation of the Dabban in Layer XXIV (McBurney 1967: 131). 7.3.1 Layer XXV: Field Description Layer XXV was traced in the field from the 1950s section drawings, yet as defined in this thesis, Layer XXV probably involves more contexts than those on McBurney’s section drawings due to some discrepancies between the numbering of the layers on the original profile drawings. Layer XXV contains layers similar to the MSA part of Facies Three, with markedly red, clayey layers alternating with paler and indurated layers (Fig. 7.2; full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four). Many of these layers are traceable across the two profiles, and their observations will be discussed in relation to each other. The stratigraphy for the areas discussed is outlined in Figure 7.10. 7.3.2 Layer XXV: Soil Micromorphology 7.3.2.1 Contexts 497–496, West-Facing Profile Context 497 In the field, Context 497 is a yellow-red clayey silt (5YR 4/6) with very rare, slightly horizontally- orientated angular limestone grit (2–4mm). There are pale yellow-grey silty lenses 1–2cm long, and ~1mm thick. The lower boundary is clear. This context lenses out ~1m south of the sample (Fig. 7.10). The lower part of Context 497 in Micro-fabric 1000:1 is a brown-red (PPL) silty clay loam with occasional limestone fine sand to gravel. The structure is vughy and more massive to the base of the unit (15% porosity, including vughs and vegetal voids). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are occasional dung lenses and blocks, and occasional pedorelicts (Fig. 7.11a). There are frequent coatings to the coarse material which appear to be continuous with the 1000:1 Pedorelictwith vegetal voids,PPL 1mm (4 97 ) 10 00 :1 (4 98 ) 1cm a Sample 1014 Figure 7.11: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 497. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 169 50 cm 0 45 8 45 9 47 0 49 3 49 4 49 7 26 28 26 21 10 14 10 00 21 13 25 21 25 29 49 1 20 37 22 42 0 1 2m Fa ci es 1 Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 Fa ci es 5 N S E W W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile D ab ba n (X VI -X XI V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) M SA (X XV -X XX V) F ig ur e 7. 10 : L oc at io n an d sa m pl in g of F ac ie s T hr ee L ay er X X V. se di m en ts (g re y) fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al an al ys is .S ha de d ar ea s ex pa nd ed be lo w .D ra w in g: L .F ar r. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 170 groundmass and in places fuse together. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The fusion of the silty coatings within the micro-fabric is probably indicative of a mass movement in a damp slurry of material. The vegetal voids attest to in situ decomposition of organic material, their orientation also indicating warping during transport in a slurry. Yet this material is not particularly clay-rich, and therefore probably not primarily soil material washed into the cave, but may consist of existing aeolian-deposited sediments reworked within the cave. The pedorelicts indicate material being trampled into the cave, and the dung has been deposited by animals within the cave, both being subsequently reworked in this colluvial movement. The coated dung lenses have probably been produced from compression in the mass movement, rather than trampling on a dry surface. Context 497 may therefore indicate colluvial reworking of material already deposited in the cave in a mudflow. The contact between 497 and 496 was not sampled. Context 496 Context 496 is a yellowish red clayey silt (5YR 5/6). There are very rare limestone flecks visible in the field up to 2mm, as well as pale yellow-grey silt lenses 1mm thick and 1–2cm long. The lower boundary is clear to slightly diffuse. This context is shown in Micro-fabrics 2628:5 and 2628:6. 2628:5 is an orange-brown (PPL) silt loam with occasional limestone coarse sand and gravel and a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (10% porosity including vegetal voids). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled and micritic calcitic crystallitic (70:30), and the unit is concreted heavily with micritic calcite towards its base. Dung lenses and blocks are present, as are rare well-rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts. The boundary with 2628:6 is clear but subtle, marked by an increase in carbonate concretion in 2628:5. It has a distinct, clear lower boundary. Fabric 2628:6 is a brown-orange (PPL) silt loam with few limestone sand and gravel clasts, and a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure underlying a vughy microstructure and 20% porosity (including vegetal voids). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled and micritic calcitic crystallitic (70:30). There are occasional dung blocks and lenses. The coarsematerial becomes slightly horizontally oriented towards the top of the unit (Fig. 7.12a) and there are silty coatings to the coarse inclusions (Fig. 7.12b).There are very raremicritic calcitic infillings to vughs, and rare pedorelicts and silty clay aggregates. Its lower boundary is not sampled. Context 496 was interpreted in the field as primarily aeolian in origin, based on its relatively pale colour, and dung lenses which appeared to mark ephemeral surfaces. Both micro-fabrics from 496 are consistent with this interpretation: along with the dung laminations, the horizontal orientation of limestone gravel demarcate ephemeral surfaces formed in a punctuated environment of aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking. The weakly-developed granular structure indicates either bioturbation or dampening and aggregation of material on a dusty surface, similar to that which probably allowed the development of the silty coatings to the coarse material The slightly increased micritic b-fabric observed in 2628:5 does not coincide with a distinct fabric Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 171 source change from 2628:6. Therefore, this increase in cementation may indicate a period of increased wetness and dripping within the cave during relatively consistent deposition of material. 2628:5 may have originally been more porous, either through a change in sedimentary conditions or bioturbation, with the calcite beginning to precipitate out when it hit the more impermeable 2628:6. Such deposition of calcite may have occurred far after deposition of the unit. Context 496 appears to be primarily aeolian/dusty in character with some small-scale colluvial reworking. The timing of the drips which lead to the precipitation of the calcite remains slightly unclear, although it probably began during the deposition of 2628:5, percolating down into 2628:6. 7.3.2.2 Contexts 495=470 to 493=458, West- and North-Facing Profiles Context 495=470 On the West-Facing Profile, Context 495=470 is a yellowish red clayey silt (5YR 4/6 yellowish red), with very rare limestone flecks (1–2mm). The basal 1–2cm of the context is indurated, marking a sharp lower boundary. 495=470 is represented by Micro-fabrics 2628:4 and 2628:3 (Fig. 7.13). Micro-fabric 2628:3 is an orange-brown silt loam/sandy silt loam. It contains common limestone sand and has a vughy to weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic to stipple-speckled (50:50), with the crystallitic component existing as isolated micritic calcite crystals rather than a mass concreting the unit (as in 2628:5). Rare bone is, in 2628:6/5 Boundary between 2628:6and5 showing horizontalorientation to coarsematerial to topof fabric 2628:5,PPL 2628:6 Silty coatingsto coarsematerial,PPL 1mm 2mm a b (4 96 ) 26 28 :6 26 28 :5 (4 95 = 47 0) 1cm Sample 2628b Co nt ex t Figure 7.12: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 496. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 172 F ig ur e 7. 13 : Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s of C on te xt 49 5= 47 0. 26 28 :3 Bo ne st rin ge ra nd la rg er bo ne fr ag m en t, PP L 26 28 :4 W el l- ro un de d cr us tf ra gm en ts ,P PL 1m m 1m m 1m m 21 13 :2 In se ct bu rr ow an d di sr up tio n of gr ou nd m as s, PP L 21 13 :2 W el l- ro un de d cr us t fr ag m en tw ith m ul tip le 2m m (495=470) (494=459) (496)-(West-FacingOnly) W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 2628:3 2628:4 2113:2 a b c d Sa m pl e 26 28 a& b Sa m pl e 21 13 1c m Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 173 one place, fragmented in a horizontal ‘stringer’ (Fig. 7.13a). There are very subtle laminations in the fine material. There are also fewmanganese hypocoatings and dendritic nodules, as well as occasional iron nodules with diffuse to clear boundaries, which consist of the same fabric components as the rest of the groundmass. Its lower boundary is faint and clear. Micro-fabric 2628:4 is a yellow-brown silty clay loam with occasional limestone sand and gravel. Its microstructure is weakly-developed granular microaggregate (25% porosity). Its b-fabric is stipple- speckled, and the fine material contains fine silty laminations in places. There are rare bone and shell occurrences, and few silty coatings to coarse material. A few well-rounded crust fragments are also present (Fig. 7.13b), along with rare dung blocks and lenses. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The fine silty material and laminations in both micro-fabrics, indicate punctuated aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, and the crystallitic b-fabric component may result from an aeolian carbonate source. The fine material in 2628:4 is redder than 2628:3, which may indicate the inclusion of aeolian-reworked soil material. Dung lenses in both fabrics and the bone stringer in 2628:3 further indicate the presence of ephemeral surfaces. Silty coatings to the coarse material, particularly in 2628:4, were probably created through dampening of coarse material on these dusty surfaces. 2628:4 appears to be slightly more coarse and chaotic than the overlying micro-fabric (especially towards the top of the unit), which may indicate bioturbation, although this may also result from small-scale colluvial reworking. The crust fragments, concentrated to the base of 2628:4, indicate brief, small- scale puddling at the base of the unit, followed by drying and disruption, either through trampling or small-scale colluvial reworking. On the North-Facing Profile, Context 495=470 can, in the field, be split into two layers by a clear but subtle distinction in texture and colour. The upper part is a yellowish red clayey silt (5YR 5/6) with occasional limestone coarse sand (<2mm). There is a faintly laminar structure to the context, picked out by rare lenses of pale yellow silt, and an overall horizontal orientation to the fine gravel. The boundary with the lower half of the context is diffuse and wavy. The lower part of 495=470 is a pale yellowish red silt (5YR 4/6), with some very slight horizontal laminations in the fine material. It includes occasional subangular limestone (1mm–2cm). The lower boundary with 494 is clear and primarily textural. 495=470 is sampled in Sample 2113. The sample has also been subject to major bioturbation in the form of four large wasp burrows 2–3cm across formed during the recent exposure of the profiles (Fig. 7.13c). 2113:1 is an orange-brown clay loam/silty clay loam. It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (85:15). It contains common limestone sand and a few limestone gravel clasts in the top 6cm of the unit. There are very rare occurrences of bone and rounded flint, and few well- rounded pedorelicts and blocks of dung and crust fragments (Fig. 7.13d). Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The fabric can be split into three different areas of structure and porosity within a consistent matrix: Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 174 • 0–3cm – vughy microstructure, 25% porosity: vughs, planar voids and vegetal voids. • 3–6cm – massive-weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure overlying a very weakly granular microaggregate structure, 15% porosity: vughs and planar voids. • 6–11cm – moderately developed subangular blocky structure, 20% porosity: planar voids and vughs. Analysis has been severely hampered by the presence of the wasp burrows, yet the fine material is largely consistent, and its silty texture suggests a potentially aeolian origin and depositional environment, with the micritic calcitic b-fabric potentially resulting from the roof-spalling fromwhich produced the sand and gravel or the deposition of aeolian carbonate material. The structural changes between the micro-fabricsmay be linked to degrees of bioturbation in antiquity (the wasp burrows probably developed during the present exposure of the sections). The subangular blocky base (6–11cm) of the contextmay represent rapid deposition and little bioturbation. Theweakly- developed granular structure between 3 and 6cm suggests bioturbation, perhaps in a period of slow deposition. The vughy structure 0–3cm may indicate a different type of bioturbation, or reformation of a granular structure. The presence of crust fragments towards the base of the unit indicates some influence of punctuated waterlain sedimentation, followed by a dry period and trampling which fragmented these crusts. Overall, given the lack of bioturbation within the slide, the most robust conclusions can be drawn from the exposure of Context 495=470 on the West-Facing Profile. This appears to show punctuated aeolian deposition and reworking and potentially small-scale colluvial reworking, as well as sporadic dampening of the material by sheetwash, which is largely supported by what can be observed on the North-Facing Profile exposure Context 494=459 In the field, on the West-Facing Profile, 494=459 is a yellowish-red clayey silt (5YR 5/6) with 5% angular/subangular limestone fragments up to 2cm, with horizontal orientation. The material becomes lighter in colour to the top of the context. The base of the context is sharp, marked by induration. The West-Facing Profile exposure of 494=459 is covered by Micro-fabrics 1014:3 and 2628:1 and 2628:2 (Fig. 7.14). Micro-fabric 1014:3 shows the upper limit of context 494=459. It is a yellow-brown silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel, and a moderately developed vughy microstructure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (50:50). There are some clayey micro-pans and infillings restricted to planar voids at the top of the unit (Fig. 7.14a). There are also rare calcitic hypocoatings towards the base of the unit, as well as rare iron nodules, dung lenses and blocks. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2628:1 is separated from 2628:2 by a sharp boundary, and is more disorganised than the fabric below. It is a brown silt loam with common limestone medium sand to gravel and a massive to Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 175 vughy structure (17% porosity). There are rare inclusions of shell, bone and flint. There are abundant micritic and sparitic calcitic hypocoatings, some stained with manganese, and micritic calcite makes up 60% of the b-fabric (Fig. 7.14b). There are irregular to well-rounded iron nodules, and well-rounded fragments of dung. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. 2628:2 encompasses the lower boundary of the context. It is a brown silt loam with common limestone gravel and a massive to vughy microstructure becoming almost spongy to its base. Overall, its porosity is 30%, but this is concentrated in two bands of vughswhich run across the section, with interconnecting planar voids and channels. The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (70:30). There are lenses of coarse sand, as well as calcitic hypocoatings and frequent manganese void coatings. There are few iron nodules with sharp to irregular boundaries, as well as few dung lenses and blocks. The material becomes more massive to the top, with more distinct laminations. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The red nature of the fine material in 2628:1 and 2 indicates a potential influence of soil material mixed with aeolian sediment and the paler nature of 1014:3 may indicate a general lack of soil material to the top of the context and mixing with aeolian material, yet this interpretation is extremely tentative given that other factors can alter sediment colour. In 2628:2, the rare lenses of coarse sand demarcate a punctuated depositional environment, potentially the result of small-scale alluvial or colluvial movements interrupting the generally aeolian/dusty environment. Punctuation in deposition is also indicated by the layers of spongy structure in the micro-fabric; which may result from bioturbation during periods of slow sediment deposition, with the more dense layers more rapidly deposited. The boundary between Micro-fabrics 2628:1 and 2628:2 marks a shift from a relatively organised fabric to one which is more disorganised, perhaps as a result of increased colluvial reworking. This disorganisation is also seen in 1014:3, although dung lenses within this micro-fabric indicate some punctuated deposition towards the top of the unit. The significant micritic calcitic component of the b-fabric in 1014:3 and 2628:1 potentially indicates the presence of carbonate-rich groundwater dripping onto the cave floor. This period of deposition may also have created the calcitic hypocoatings in fabric 2628:2. The rarity of calcite precipitation in 1014:3 indicates that the precipitation of calcite may have ceased during the deposition of the context. The presence of flint, shell and bone all point to continued occupation or reworking of nearby occupation deposits. The micro-pans in Fabric 1014:3 indicate that the layer which covered 494=459 was wet, with excesswater washing into the voids below the unit. This was not a prolonged wet period as the micro-pans are quite restricted in their area, and do not continue downwards into other voids as would be expected following long-term illuviation. The West-Facing exposure of Context 494=459 therefore indicatesmaterial which has undergone a complex series of small-scale colluvial and aeolian reworking episodes, and which appears at its base to contain small amounts of potentially aeolian- deflated soil material. Context 494=459 on the North-Facing Profile is a strong brown clayey silt (7.5YR 4/6) with common subangular to angular limestone gravel (0.5–4cm), which is horizontally oriented towards the top of Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 176 the unit. There are purplish manganese coatings to large sediment blocks. There are faint horizontal laminations in the finematerial structure, and pale yellow-grey silty lenses. The lower boundary is clear (occurring over 0.5cm) and the layer below is more compact with less gravel. The upper boundary of 494=459 is shown in 2521:2 on the North-Facing Profile (Fig. 7.14). 2521:2 is a light brown silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand to gravel. It has a massive to weakly-developed subangular blocky structure which is slightly vughy at its base (10% porosity, rising to 25% at its base). It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (80:20). There is a laminar nature to the fine material towards the top of the unit (Fig. 7.14c), which marks a shift from a more general disorganised nature to the base of the unit (Fig. 7.14d). Inclusions are occasional shell, rare unburnt and potentially burnt bone. There are also calcitic hypocoatings and infillings as well as few iron nodules and pedorelicts and occasional dung lenses. There are rare orange silty clay coatings to planar voids at the top of the micro-fabric. Its lower boundary was not sampled. A potentially aeolian environment of deposition and reworking is indicated in 2521:2 by its silty texture and the presence of fine laminations in sedimentation demarcating ephemeral surfaces, and its silty texture. The limestone content indicates material generated through the physical weathering of the bedrock. However, the coarse material at the base of the Micro-fabric 2521:2 is slightly more disorganised, thus potentially indicating an initial colluvial movement of material. There may therefore be a shift from colluvial movement of aeolian material to aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking in the top part of the context. The calcitic void hypocoatings indicate secondary precipitation of calcite through the movement of carbonate-rich groundwater through the void space, which is potentially linked to the crystallitic b-fabric, probably through drips within the cave although this may have occurred long after the deposition of the unit. The North- and West-Facing Profile exposures of 494=459 are somewhat similar in their appearance at their base, with potential aeolian deposition and small-scale colluvial reworking of sediment on the West-Facing Profile mirrored by more marked colluvial deposition on the North-Facing Profile. The fine, laminated material at the top of 2521:2 is not present on the West-Facing Profile, however, it could have been eroded from this area by the deposition of the overlying context, 493=458, or may simply have been disrupted on the West-Facing Profile by bioturbation or colluvial reworking. The West-Facing Profile exposure was, at some point either during deposition or following deposition, subject to localised wetting from drips from the ceiling which precipitated calcite in the sediments. Context 493=458 On the West-Facing Profile, Context 493=458 is a red clayey silt (2.5YR 4/6), with rare, horizontally oriented blocky sub-angular to sub-rounded limestone flecks (1–2mm). The lower boundary is clear. The entire depth of the context is covered in Micro-fabric 1014:2. In thin section it is an orange-brown silty clay loam with few limestone coarse sand to gravel clasts. It has a vughy structure overlying a weakly-developed granular microstructure (25% porosity including vegetal voids). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). The vegetal voids are restricted to an area Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 177 F ig ur e 7. 14 : Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 49 4= 45 9. 10 14 :3 Cl ay ey m ic ro pa ns ,P PL 26 28 :1 M ic rii tc ca lc iti c -f ab ric an d in fil lin gs ,X PL 1m m 25 21 :2 D un g la m in at io ns ,X PL 25 21 :2 D is or ga ni sa tio n at ba se of fa br ic ,P PL 1m m (494=459) (495=470)(493=458) 1014:3 2628:1 2628:2 2521:2 2113:1 1m m 2m m 1c m 1c m Contexts W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile a b c d Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 178 2cm from the base of the unit, where the fine material appears to have coated the now-absent vegetal fragments which created the voids along with coarse material. The fine material also has mottling of finer, denser areas of material and warped fine lenses (Fig. 7.15a). There are rare bone inclusions, and relict silty clay infilling fragments. There are also rare micritic calcitic hypocoatings to the channels at the top of the unit and some coarse material (Fig. 7.15b). Both diffuse and well-rounded iron nodules are present. There are also rare crust fragments. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The silty clay nature of the fine material possibly indicates a primarily aeolian origin, although given the appearance in the field and its clay content, it may also include reworked clayey soil material. The overall poor sorting and disorientation of material within the fabric are potentially the result of a colluvial deposition of the unit, an interpretation supported by the warping of the vegetal voids and lenses of finermaterial in the groundmass as the result ofmovement in a slurry. The granular structure is weakly developed, indicating only limited bioturbaiton. The presence of diffuse iron nodules indicates that they have developed in situ from a saturated groundmass, probably during the deposition of the unit. The well-rounded iron nodules, produced in previous wetting period, are probably redeposited during this deposition. The calcitic hypocoatings towards the top of the unit indicate calcareous groundwater moving through the void space, potentially as a result of the groundmass opened up by the bioturbation in 1014:4 (see below). On the North-Facing Profile, Context 493=458 is a reddish brown clayey silt (5YR 4/4) with 5% blocky limestone flecks, and a massive structure with manganese staining to the edges of sediment blocks and visible manganese dendritic nodules ~2mm. The unit becomes more clayey and red towards the top 3–4cm of the unit. There are few angular–subangular platy limestone gravel clasts (<1mm– 1cm). The lower boundary is clear, horizontal, relatively flat, and marked by a change in structure and gravel content. On the North-Facing Profile, the upper and lower contacts of the context are shown in micro-fabrics 2529:2 and 2521:1 respectively. Micro-fabric 2529:2 is a red-brown (PPL) silty clay loam with occasional limestone very fine sand to gravel. It has a massive, almost subangular blocky structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- to mosaic-speckled (90:10). There is a band of coarser material towards the centre of the unit, below which there is an area of crust fragments and an area where the groundmass becomes denser around the voids. There are rare well-rounded iron nodules, along with rare dung lenses and blocks, and occasional crust fragments are present towards the base of the unit (Fig. 7.15c). Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2521:1 is an orange-brown (PPL) silty clay loam with common limestone sand and gravel concentrated to the lower 3cm. It has a weakly-developed microaggregate granular structure with some patches of vughy/massive structure, becoming more granular to the base (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to mosaic (90:10). There is very rare bone and shell. There are silty concentrations coatings around potential vegetal voids and some silty coatings to coarse components. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 179 F ig ur e 7. 15 : Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 49 3= 45 8. 10 14 :2 Fu se d gr ou nd m as s, PP L 10 14 :2 C al ci tic hy po co at in gs to vo id s an d co ar se m at er ia l, XP L 1m m 25 29 :2 Cr us tf ra gm en t, PP L 25 21 :1 Pe do re lic t, PP L 1m m 1m m 1m m (493=458) 1c m 2529:2 2521:1 1014:2 a b c d W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile (494=459) Sa m pl e 10 14 Sa m pl e 25 21 Sa m pl e 25 29 Context Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 180 There are also rare silty infillings to planar voids. The fabric contains rare, well-rounded pedorelicts (Fig. 7.15d), along with rare well-rounded red silt aggregates at the top and bottom of the unit which may be very weathered crust fragments. There are few dung and rare crust fragments towards the top of the unit. It has a distinct, clear lower boundary. The field description of the material on the North-Facing Profile indicated that the context was a potential mass movement of soil material, an interpretation supported by the red colour and clayey nature of the fine material in thin section, and their stipple- to mosaic-speckled b-fabrics. The coatings to the coarse material at the base of the context probably developed during the transport of this material in a slurry. Variation in structure to the top of the context on the North-Facing Profile (Micro- fabric 2529:2) may result from a number of scenarios: material settling out following a wet colluvial movement; a period of aeolian or low-velocity reworking; or the incipient formation of a structural crust through the breakdown of the initially more granular structure of the parent material. The silty infillings to some of the planar voids indicate the translocation of fine material, perhaps as a result of punctuated episodes of inwash. The presence of crust fragments in 2529:2 potentially indicates periods of sheetwash during prior to thismass movement, although theymay have simply been reworked from the cave floor from a previous event. Context 493=458 appears largely consistent in its deposition across the profiles, with colluvial reworking and mixing of varying amounts of aeolian and soil material reflected in the different textures and colour of the two exposures. The massive structure at the top of the context on both sections may be due to an incipient structural crust, or simply variations in texture within a mudflow. 7.3.2.3 Context 491, West-Facing Profile Context 491 is a layer on the West-Facing Profile, which lenses out to the south. In the field it is red clayey silt (2.5YR 4/8) with few limestone flecks, from 1–3mm and rare gravel up to 2cm. Its lower boundary is clear. The base of Context 491 is shown inMicro-fabric 1014:1 (Fig. 7.16). It is a red-brown (PPL) silty clay loam with few limestone sand and gravel. It has a weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure overlying a granular microaggregate structure (25% porosity, including vegetal voids), and a stipple- to mosaic-speckled b-fabric (80:20). There are concentrations of fine material in the groundmass around the vegetal voids, which have fused together in places. There is rare organic material, humified and charred, along with rare shell and bone. There is a large area of calcitic hypocoatings to voids close to Micro-fabric 1014:4 (see discussion below) and rare, well-rounded iron nodules. There are rare dung and occasional depositional crust fragments. The lower boundary is prominent and clear with some slight mixing with the underlying unit (Fig. 7.16a). Field observations of the clay content of 1014:1 suggested the characterisation of the context as reworked soil material, an interpretation also supported by the texture of the fine material in thin section, although it cannot be ruled out that this is material weathered from the limestone within the karstic system. The stipple- to mosaic-speckled b-fabric may result from wetting and drying of a clay- Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 181 rich slurry. The incorporation of depositional crust fragments into the material indicates punctuated sheetwash episodes prior to, and reworkedwithin, the deposition of the rest of the unit. This sheetwash may have closely preceded the deposition of the rest of the unit, or may have occurred far earlier, with crusts re-deposited alongside other inclusions from the cave floor (e.g. charcoal, bone and shell and dung fragments). As the crust material is similar to 1014:1’s groundmass, the former explanation is favoured. The lower boundary is slightly mixed, indicating that the material was probably deposited in a low-velocity slurry over an unconsolidated surface preventing a sharp, erosive cut. The increase in granular material towards the base of the unit may be linked to the incipient formation of a crust during or after deposition. Context 491 therefore can be interpreted as an inwash event of potential soil material into the cave. At the interface between Contexts 491 and 493, the layers are cut by an area of fabric 1.5cm by 2cm (Fabric 1014:4), which was not observed in the field. Fabric 1014:4 is an orange-red (PPL) silty clay loam with occasional limestone medium to coarse sand. It has a well-developed granular microaggregate structure (Fig. 7.17b), with up to 50% porosity. In 20% of the fabric there are irregular areas of the groundmass which are vughy in structure. The b-fabric is stipple-speckled, but has Figure 7.16: Slide scan and microphotos from Context 491. 1cm 1mm 2mm 2mm 1014:1/4 Boundarybetween calcite- impregnated1014:4andclay-rich 1014:1,XPL 1014:1/4 Boundary between granular microstructure of1014:4andmore densemicrostructure of1014:1,PPL (4 91 ) (4 93 = 45 8) 1014:1 10 14 :4 1014:1/2 Slightly mixedboundary showing more reddish, clay-rich1014:1,PPL b c aSample 1014 Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 182 also been influenced by the occasional calcitic hypocoatings which impregnate up to 50% of the groundmass in places (Fig. 7.16c). There are occasional iron nodules and pedorelicts, as well as rare crust fragments. Its boundaries are prominent and clear. The granular microstructure appears to be the result of severe bioturbation of parts of both Contexts 491 and 493 by microfauna. This is supported by the presence of the vughy areas, which appear to represent fragments of the un-bioturbated fabric. The almost complete concretion in places of the granules as well as the infilling of the compound packing voids indicate that the calcite has precipitated through voids after bioturbation. The cause of this bioturbation is unclear – the shape and size are too small for a rodent burrow, and the granular nature of the fabric indicates the activity of microfauna such asmites, whichmay have been attracted by the decay of a substantial root. Thiswould be unusual within the present regime of the cave. 7.3.3 Layer XXV: Bulk Sedimentological Data The bulk sedimentological data for Layer XXV is shown in Figure 7.17.As discussed in Chapter Five, Layer XXV is within a somewhat intermediate period of magnetic susceptibility values between the low susceptibility below them and the very high values above. Both the uncorrected and corrected magnetic susceptibility values vary around their respective sequence means. The pattern of peaks varies between the profiles, with a peak in Context 494=459 and 493=458 on the North-Facing Profile only observed in 493=458 on the West-Facing Profile. Context 491 and the base of 497 have elevated values, whilst 494=459 is a marked low on the West-Facing Profile and at its base on the North-Facing Profile. There is little variation in %LOI in Layer XXV, and the slight rise in values on the North-Facing Profile in 493=458 does not mark a significant change when viewed in the whole sequence (see Chapter Five), although these values are closer to the mean for the entire sequence than the underlying sediments. %CaCO 3 values are relatively restricted in their variance compared to other parts of the sequence, with most values below the mean for the entire sequence. 494=459 represents a peak on both profiles, although the peak is towards the base in the North-Facing Profile and the top of the context on the West, spatial variation which is mirrored in the magnetic susceptibility. There is also a slight peak in Context 496 on the West-Facing Profile, whilst Contexts 493=458 and 491 are particularly low in %CaCO 3. 7.3.4 Layer XXV: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Micromorphological Data The contexts high in %CaCO 3 largely correlate with the material interpreted through the micromorphology (Table 7.3) as aeolian-dominated sedimentation with secondary carbonate precipitation (e.g. Context 496 and 494=459 on the West-Facing Profile), and are low in the contexts identified as containing significant amounts of soil material (Contexts 493=458 and 491). These inwash events are high in magnetic susceptibility (both corrected and uncorrected). These events could have produced discontinuities in the record through truncation of the underlying units, which may Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 183 have produced the ‘offset’ magnetic susceptibility values for 494=459 and 493=458 between the two profiles: 494=459 on the West-Facing profile may have originally contained a shift to high magnetic susceptibility and lower %CaCO 3 in the top of the context, as shown on the North-Facing Profile, but its truncation by 493=458 may have removed this. The low, unchanging %LOI values correspond to a lack of significant anthropogenic deposition as observed micromorphologically in these layers. 7.3.5 Layer XXV: Interpretation Layer XXV is made up of contexts deposited in a range of environments. The sequence began with Contexts 497 and 496 on theWest-Facing Profile.A period of internal reworking of potentially aeolian material by wet, colluvial processes in Context 497 is followed by aeolian deposition in 496 which Context Micromorphological Interpretation 491 West-Facing only Inwash of external soil material. 493=458 Mass colluvial movements of potentially mixed possibly aeolian-deposited and soil material. 494=459 Initial, relatively high energy colluvial movement of potential aeolian/dusty material around the cave, followed by deposition of calcite from calcite-rich water dripping onto the sediemnts or moving through profiles on the West-Facing Profile and aeolian/colluvial reworking and deposition. 495=470 Predominantly potential aeolian deposition and reworking and sporadic wetting of the sediment. 496 Possible aeolian/dusty sedimentation and reworking with micro-scale colluvial reworking on ephemeral surfaces. Impregnation of calcite through calcite-rich water dripping onto or moving through the profiles. 497 Colluvial movement of possible aeolian material, potentially mixed with soil material. Table 7.3 Summary context interpretations for Layer XXV based on micromorphological observations. Figure 7.17: Bulk sedimentological data from Facies Three Layer XXV contexts. Blue magnetic susceptibility bars are uncorrected values, red are corrected values. 10 0 20 0 30 0 40 0 50 0 2 3 4 5 0 105 15 20 25 30 35 10 0 20 0 30 0 40 0 50 0 2 3 4 5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 MagneticSusceptibility(x)% LOIorganics % Carbonate W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 491 493=458 494=459 494=459 495=470 496 497 497 493=458 493=458 493=458 494=459 494=459 495=470 60 0 70 0 60 0 70 0 Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 184 was then followed by dripping in the cave precipitating calcite in the sediments. Three contexts overly this sequence which can be traced across the two profiles. Context 495=470marks a period of aeolian deposition and small-scale colluvial reworking, potentially in places including deflated soil material. Context 494=459 contains some limited colluvial reworking of aeolian sediments followed by aeolian reworking of the material and calcite precipitation on the West-Facing Profile indicating dripping within the cave. Context 493=458 consists of a series of colluvial movements of primarily soil material, followed by a further, more soil-rich inwash event in Context 491 on the West-Facing Profile. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 185 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 49 1 10 14 :1 20 m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el cl as ts .V er y w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty :v ug hs , co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, pl an ar an d ve ge ta lv oi ds . S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m os ai c (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e or ga ni c m at er ia l, hu m ifi ed /c ha rr ed ,a nd ve ry ra re sh el la nd bo ne .L ar ge ar ea of oc c. ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs to vo id s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s an d du ng bl oc ks .F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. C on ce nt ra ti on s of si lt y m at er ia la ro un d vo id s. O cc .c ru st fr ag m en ts .R ar e or an ge cl ay vo id co at in gs ne ar 10 14 :4 . M ud dy flo w of ex te rn al so il m at er ia ls ea li ng in or ga ni c m at er ia ll at er su bj ec tt o bi ot ur ba ti on . In w as h of ex te rn al so il m at er ia l. In tr us iv e bi ot ur ba ti on . 10 14 :4 15 m m by 20 m m O ra ng e- re d (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd w it h oc c. li m es to ne m ed iu m to co ar se sa nd . G ra nu la r m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 65 % po ro si ty ,c om po un d pa ci ng vo id s, ch an ne ls an d vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r bo un da ri es . V er y ra re bo ne .O cc .c ry st al li ti c hy po co at in gs to vo id s im pr eg na ti ng 50 % of gr ou nd m as s. F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .i ro n no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts . B io tu rb at io n fo ll ow ed by im pr eg na ti on w it h ca lc it e. 49 3= 45 8 10 14 :2 55 m m W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) S il ty cl ay lo am .O cc .c oa rs e si lt -s an d qu ar tz ,f ew li m es to ne co ar se sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy ov er w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs , ve ge ta lv oi ds an d pa ck in g vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m os ai c (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 16 :8 4. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne an d sh el l. R ar e re li ct si lt y cl ay in fil li ng s. In cr ea se d ve ge ta lv oi ds to ar ea ~2 cm fr om ba se of un it .R ar e m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs to ch an ne ls at to p of un it .I ro n no du le s, di ff us e to w el l- ro un de d. R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts ,a nd w el l- ro un de d or an ge si lt y ag gr eg at es .R ar e du ng fr ag m en t. C ol lu vi al ly -r ew or ke d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n m at er ia l. M as s co ll uv ia l m ov em en ts of m ix ed po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n an d so il m at er ia l 25 29 :2 70 m m N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), si lt y cl ay lo am /c la y lo am . C om m on qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne ve ry fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty , pl an ar vo id s, vu gh s an d ch am be rs .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m os ai c (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al an d ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne . B an d of co ar se r m at er ia li n ce nt re of sl id e, be lo w w hi ch in cr ea se of cr us tf ra gm en ts .R ar e de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e ir on no du le s, w el lr ou nd ed , ra re du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks .O cc .c ru st s to ba se of un it . B as al sl ur ry of m ai nl y ex te rn al m at er ia l ov er la in by po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n re de po si ti on . T ru nc at ed by ov er ly in g un it . 25 21 :1 65 m m N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .c oa rs e qu ar tz si lt an d sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne ve ry fin e sa nd to gr av el . 20 % po ro si ty :c om po un d pa ck in g vo id s, vu gh s (v eg et al vo id s) an d pl an ar vo id s. W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e, w it h pa tc he s of vu gh y/ m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e (2 0% ). S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m os ai c st ru ct ur e (1 0% ). C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bo ne an d ra re sh el l. S il ty co at in gs to st ar -s ha pe d vo id s, an d so m e co ar se co m po ne nt s e. g. li m es to ne .R ar e si lt y in fil li ng s to pl an ar vo id s, an d ra re w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. R ar e si lt y ag gr eg at es ,w el lr ou nd ed at to p an d bo tt om of un it .F ew du ng bl oc ks .R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts to w ar ds to p. M or e gr an ul ar to ba se . M as s m ov em en to f sl ur ry m at er ia la tb as e be fo re w ea th er in g an d ae ol ia n/ sm al ls ca le co ll uv ia lr ed ep os it io n at to p. Ta bl e 7. 4: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F ac ie s T hr ee L ay er X X V m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul ld es cr ip ti on s in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al , fr eq .- fr eq ue nt ,c om m .- co m m on . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 186 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 49 4= 45 9 10 14 :3 30 m m W es t- fa ci ng pr ofi le Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc qu ar tz sa nd an d co ar se si lt an d oc c li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M od er at el y de ve lo pe d vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e w it h ve ry ra re w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty : vu gh s, pl an ar an d ch an ne ls .S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 50 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el la nd ve ry ra re bo ne .R ar e m ic ro pa ns an d in fil li ng s re st ri ct ed to pl an ar vo id s at to p of un it un de r co nt ac t. R ar e m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs to vo id s at ba se of un it .R ar e de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. W el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. R ar e du ng le ns es an d bl oc ky . R ew or ki ng of ae ol ia n m at er ia lb y co ll uv ia l pr oc es se s, la te r w et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er an d tr un ca te d. In it ia l, re la ti ve ly hi gh en er gy co ll uv ia l m ov em en to f m at er ia la ro un d th e ca ve ,w it h so m e po te nt ia l in co rp or at io n of so il m at er ia l fo ll ow ed by ca lc it e im pr eg na ti on fr om in te rn al dr ip s or w at er m ov in g th ro ug h th e pr ofi le an d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n/ co ll uv ia l de po si ti on . 26 28 :1 12 m m W es t- fa ci ng pr ofi le B ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el .1 7% po ro si ty , vu gh s, ch am be rs an d pl an ar vo id s. M as si ve to vu gh y st ru ct ur e. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to sp ar it ic an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne ,s he ll an d fli nt .A bu nd an tc al ci ti c hy po co at in gs an d co at in gs ,s om e st ai ne d w it h M an ga ne se .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s F ew ir on no du le s, ir re gu la r to w el l- ro un de d. D un g bl oc ks , w el lr ou nd ed . C ol lu vi al m ov em en to f po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l ce m en te d by w et ti ng w it h ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er du ri ng an d af te r de po si ti on . 26 28 :2 3m m W es t- fa ci ng pr ofi le B ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e an d al m os ts po ng y to th e ba se .3 0% po ro si ty , vu gh s an d pl an ar vo id s. E X PA N D B A N D S .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic 70 :3 0. C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5 D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el la nd bl oc ky ch ar co al .L am in at io ns in co ar se sa nd ar ra ng em en t. V ug hs co nc en tr at ed in tw o ba nd s. R ar e ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs .O cc .m an ga ne se co at in g to vo id s an d fe w de nd ri ti c no du le s. F ew w el l- ro un de d to di ff us e ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. F ew du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks .R ar e de gr ad ed si lt y cl ay in fil li ng s. P un ct ua te d co ll uv ia l/ ae ol ia n re w or ki ng of po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l af te r in it ia lh ig he r en er gy co ll uv ia ti on . 25 21 :2 65 m m N or th - fa ci ng P ro fil e L ig ht br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se sa nd an d fin e si lt .C om m .l im es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el .M as si ve to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty : vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 27 :7 3. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el l, ve ry ra re bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e. L am in ar na tu re to fin e m at er ia lt o th e to p. O ra ng e cl ay co at in gs to pl an ar vo id s, ve ry lo ca li se d, si lt y cl ay in fil li ng s an d co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia la nd vo id s be lo w in te rf ac e. F ew ca lc it ic in fil li ng s an d hy po co at in gs . R ar e m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs an d de nd ri ti c no du le s. Ir on no du le s – cl ay ey ,p ed or el ic ts .O cc .s il ty du ng la m in at io ns .R ar e cr us tf ra gm en ts . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n/ sm al ls ca le co ll uv ia ld ep os it io n w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 49 5= 47 0 26 28 :3 20 m m W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am /s an dy si lt lo am .C om m . qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d co m m .l im es to ne .V ug hy to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :p la na r vo id s, vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic 50 :5 0. C F li m it :6 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. F ai nt ,c le ar lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne ,f ra gm en te d in on e pl ac e in a st ri ng er , ra re sh el l. G en er al ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n an d la m in at io ns to fin e m at er ia l. P ho sp ha ti c no du le .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d hy po co at in gs to vo id s. O cc .i ro n no du le s cl ea r to di ff us e bo un da ri es (s am e gr ou nd m as s) ,a lm os tl en si ng in pl ac es .F ew pe do re li ct s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es ,w it h sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng . P un cu ta te d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng an d sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia lr ew or k- in g. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 187 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 49 5= 47 0 (c on t.) 26 28 :4 35 m m W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .c oa rs e si lt to fin e sa nd qu ar tz an d oc c. li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el . W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic . C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne ,a nd sh el l. F ew si lt y co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia l. F ew w el l- ro un de d cr us tf ra gm en ts an d du ng bl oc ks an d le ns es .F in e m at er ia ll am in at io ns . D is tu rb ed ,c oa rs e. In it ia lc ol lu vi al m ov em en tf ol lo w ed by pu nc tu at ed po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng . (s ee ab ov e) 21 13 :1 N or th - F ac in g P ro fil e O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il tc la y lo am .O cc qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd oc c- co m m .l im es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el .V ar ia bl e po ro si ty an d st ru ct ur e (s ee de sc ri pt io n an d te xt ). S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. D is ti nc ta nd cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky or ga ni cs .R ar e bo ne an d sh el l. V ar ia ti on s in st ru ct ur e an d co nt en t. C om m .s il ty co at in gs to ve ge ta lv oi ds an d co ar se m at er ia l. O cc . ir on no du le s, so m e co nc en tr ic .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. F ew cr us tf ra gm en ts .O cc .d un g, w el lr ou nd ed fr ag m en ts an d ra re le ns es .M aj or w as p bu rr ow di st ur ba nc e. H ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d po te nt ia la eo li an an d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g m at er ia lw it h va ry in g ra te s of co ll uv ia l/ ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng . W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e O nl y 49 6 26 28 :5 20 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h oc c. co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne co ar se sa nd an d gr av el .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e co nc re te d in pl ac es w it h ca lc it e. 10 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs .S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el l. M or e cr ys ta ll it ic to w ar ds ba se of un it . D un g in le ns es an d bl oc ks .R ar e w el lr ou nd ed ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on on w it h ep he m er al su rf ac es . W et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er .P ud dl in g of ca lc it e at ba se ei th er du ri ng or po st de po si ti on . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n- do m in at ed w it h m ic ro - sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng on ep he m er al su rf ac es . Im pr eg na ti on of gr ou nd m as s by da m pe ni ng w it h ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 26 28 :6 50 m m B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m .c oa rs e si lt to fin e sa nd qu ar tz an d fe w li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el ,s li gh tl y ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed .V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % P or os it y: vu gh s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . C oa rs er an d m or e ho ri zo nt al ly -o ri en te d m at er ia l to w ar ds to p of un it .S il ty co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia l. R ar e m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic in fil li ng s, oc ca si on al sh el l. R ar e ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s. F ew du ng ,l en se s an d bl oc ks .R ar e si lt y cl ay ag gr eg at es ,b lo ck y, w el l- ro un de d. S in gl e so il m at er ia la gg re ga te . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n- do m in at ed de po si ti on , w it h so m e lo ca l co ll uv ia ld am p re w or ki ng at th e ba se of th e un it . S lo w in g of de po si ti on to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it . 49 7 10 00 :1 30 m m B ro w n- re d (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h oc c. co ar se qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne gr av el .V ug hy st ru ct ur e. P or os it y 20 % vu gh s, ch an ne ls ,v eg et al vo id s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (2 0% ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al an d sh el l. S il ty co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia la nd co nc en tr at io ns in gr ou nd m as s. - m ag an es e co at in gs to vo id s. O cc .d un g, ir re gu la r fr ag m en ts an d le ns es .R ar e w el lr ou nd ed ir on no du le s C ol lu vi al re w or ki ng of po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n- de po si te d an d re w or ke d ca ve -fl oo r se di m en ts in a sl ur ry . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 188 7.4 The Early Dabban Layers 7.4.1 The Early Dabban Layers: Field Descriptions Theuppermost layers sampled formicromorphological analysis inFaciesThree contain the earliest fully Dabban assemblages. The stratigraphy varies slightly between the two sections, with finer divisions visible on the North-Facing Profile that splits many of the contexts identified on the West-Facing Profile. These layers contain the beginning of the transition to Facies Two, shown in the increasing intensity of gravel lenses (most prominent on the North-Facing Profile), which interrupt reddish, more silty layers typical of the main of Facies Three (Fig. 7.1; full field context descriptions tabulated in Appendix Four). On the West-Facing Profile, this includes Contexts 490 and 236; and on the North- Facing, Contexts 455 to 206 (Fig. 7.18). Due to the difficulty of sampling gravel-rich layers, on both profiles the bulk sedimentological sampling extends higher than the micromorphological sampling up to Context 440 on the West-Facing Profile and on the North-Facing profile up to Context 206, which also covers the transition into Facies Two. 7.4.2 The Early Dabban Layers: Soil Micromorphology 7.4.2.1 Context 490, West-Facing Profile In the field, Context 490 is an indurated lens of red (2.5YR 4/6) clay and gravel. There is 20% horizontally-oriented subangular gravel (1–3cm) concentrated in the centre of the unit. The context lenses out 2m to the south of the sampling point. It has a clear lower boundary. The upper contact of Context 490 is shown inMicro-fabric 2621:2. It is an orange-brown silty clay loam with rare limestone medium to coarse sand, and a weak to moderately developed subangular blocky to massive microstructure (15% porosity). It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (65:35). There is rare angular flint, potentially burnt and unburnt bone. There are numerous calcitic pedofeatures in the form of micritic coatings and hypocoatings to large vughs and chambers, with the groundmass cemented with calcite at the base of the unit. There are occasional well-rounded iron nodules or pedorelicts, and very rare crust fragments, some associated with manganese staining (Fig. 7.19a). Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. Micro-fabric 2621:3 is a grey-brown silty clay loam with few limestone clasts (medium sand and gravel) and a moderate to well-developed platy structure (Fig. 7.19b) (30% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic/sparitic calcitic crystallitic to undifferentiated (70:30). There are sparitic coating to all planar voids, and complete impregnation of the groundmass by micritic and sparitic calcite (Fig. 7.19c). There are well-rounded iron nodules. Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. Micro-fabric 2621:4 is an orange-brown silty clay loam with occasional limestone medium sand to gravel. It has a weakly-developed subangular blocky structure over a massive to very weakly- developed granular microaggregate structure (30% porosity). Its b-fabric is stipple-speckled. There is very rare charcoal with cell structure and rare bone. The unit becomes more massive and finer to the top, and contains calcitic hypocoatings to voids and some gravel, and complete impregnation Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 189 50 cm 0 43 8 43 9 44 0 44 4 44 2 44 5 49 0 23 6 44 3 43 9 23 6 45 0 46 6 45 3 45 5 45 7 26 2126 15 26 10 25 29 76 2 76 3 75 4A W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 20 37 22 42 0 1 2m Fa ci es 1 Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 Fa ci es 5 N S E W D ab ba n (X VI -X XI V) Ib er om au ru si an (X I- XV ) M SA (X XV -X XX V) F ig ur e 7. 18 : L oc at io n an d sa m pl in g of F ac ie s T hr ee E ar ly D ab ba n (g re y) fo r m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al an al ys is .S ha de d ar ea s ex pa nd ed be lo w .. D ra w in g L .F ar r. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 190 F ig ur e 7. 19 : Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro ph ot og ra ph s fr om C on te xt 49 0. a 2621:4 2621:3 2621:2 (490) (445) 1m m 2m m 1m m 26 21 :3 /4 Sp ar iti c ca lc iti c co at in gs ,X PL 26 21 :4 Cr us tin g, PP L 26 21 :3 Pl at y m ic ro st ru ct ur e, XP L 1m m 26 21 :2 Bo ne ,c ru st fra gm en t an d m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,P PL a b c d Sa m pl e 26 21 1c m Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 191 of the granular areas with calcite. There are few pedorelicts, rare dung lenses and rare depositional crust fragments. There are also very rare depositional crusts (Fig 7.19d). Its lower boundary was not sampled. Given its clayey nature and reddish colour, and similarity to the soil material shown in Section 6.2.9, the context appears to consist of reworked soil material, although it cannot be ruled out that it contains material weathered directly from the limestone within the karstic system. As observed in the field, the centre of the context is indurated by calcite which completely cements Micro-fabric 2621:3. Whilst it cannot be ruled out that the platy structure was produced by the formation of ice crystals within the sediments during freezing and thawing, and later preserved from bioturbation by calcite cementation, it is more likely that the formation of the calcite crystals have formed the platy structure themselves in a similar manner, potentially long after deposition of the unit. The restriction of gravel to the centre of the context indicates a potential hiatus in the deposition of the unit during which roof-spalling took place, and the presence of depositional crusts in 2621:4 indicates rapid, repeated pulsing of inwash material into the cave or sporadic wetting of potentially aeolian sediments. The extent of the calcite precipitation may be due to a period of significant wetting, potentially during this depositional hiatus, however, it is also possible that the area marked by the roof-spall consists of more porous soil material reworked by aeolian processes. This may have allowed the preferential post-depositional precipitation of the calcite in 2621:3 as groundwater percolated through the profile long after deposition of the unit, as calcitic hypocoatings exist in 2621:2. The extent of the calcitic precipitation in 2621:3 and its affect on the structure suggests a prolonged period of wetting, yet whether this was during the deposition of this context, during that of the overlying context or further removed in time cannot be ascertained. The calcite precipitation has hampered the assessment of the fine material, yet Context 490 appears to be largely the result of soil inwash, with a potential hiatus in deposition in the centre of the unit, followed by concretion of the unit by carbonate-rich water at an undefined point. 7.4.2.2 Context 457, North-Facing Profile Context 457 is a strongbrownclayey silt (7.5YR4/6)with 5% limestone sand andoccasional subangular blocky to platy limestone gravel (1mm–3cm). The larger fragments of limestone are horizontally- orientated. The boundary below is very sharp, and undulating. The top of the context was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2529:1 is an orange-brown sandy silt loam with common limestone coarse silt to gravel, and has a vughy-massive structure (15% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled and micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are coatings to coarse material and concentrations of silty material around voids. There is some horizontal arrangement to the coarse material at the base of the slide and imbrication (Fig. 7.20a). There are a few well-rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts and occasional dung lenses and blocks. The lower boundary is prominent and sharp. The silty texture of finematerial suggests a potentially aeolian origin for the finematerial, yet the chaotic Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 192 arrangement of the fine material in 2529:1 indicates a potentially colluvial movement; imbrication at the base of the unit also indicates initially alluvial/colluvial deposition, and punctuations within this regime may have generated the dung lenses at the base of the unit. The loss of this laminar nature to the fabric higher up the unit indicates either post depositional mixing (through bioturbation after burial or more disorganised colluvial movements of material) or, more probably, disruption of unconsolidated material near a surface, e.g. through trampling. Context 457 is therefore the product of colluvial reworking of potentially aeolian material at its base, followed by a period of aeolian deposition. 7.4.2.3 Context 445=453+455, West- and North-Facing Profile Context 455, defined on the West-Facing Profile, encompasses on the North-Facing Profile, contexts 453 and 455. Context 445, West-Facing Profile Context 445 in the field is a yellowish red (5 YR 5/6) clayey silt with 5% platy, horizontally oriented limestone gravel, subangular-subrounded, 3–4cm. It has a clear lower boundary. Micro-fabric 2615:2 is a pale brown-red silt loam with few, slightly horizontally-orientated limestone medium sand and gravel clasts. It has a vughy/channel microstructure (30% porosity) and a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (70:30). There are calcitic infillings and hypocoatings to 80% of voids (Fig. 7.21a). There are rare well-rounded iron nodules and occasional pedorelicts and common dung blocks and lenses. There is very rare bone and shell. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2621:1 is a brown-yellow clay loam/silty clay loamwith occasional, slightly horizontally- orientated limestone medium sand and gravel. It has a vughy/channel microstructure (15% porosity), and a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (90:10). There are very rare red silt 2529:1 Imbricationat lower boundary of2529:1,PPL 1mm 25 29 :1 (4 57 ) (4 93 = 45 8) 1cm a Sample 2529 Figure 7.20 Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 457. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 193 lenses, and some warping of small dung lenses around coarse material at the top of the unit. There are micritic calcitic coatings and aggregates within all channels, and hypocoatings and coatings to voids throughout. There are occasional pedorelicts and few dung blocks and warped lenses. It has a distinct, clear lower boundary (Fig. 7.21b). The silty texture of the fine material suggests a potential aeolian origin for the material, mixed with limestone and dust spalled from the bedrock. The slightly redder colour at the base of the unit may indicate post-depositional alteration of the sediment through surface exposure, or could simply be linked to variation in the thickness of the slide. The lower boundary of the unit is clear, and therefore could be erosive, marking a potentially colluvial movement of material. However, the slight horizontal orientation of the coarse material in both fabrics, and the dung lenses in 2621:1 indicate punctuated small-scale deposition, either through aeolian processes or small-scale colluvial movements. The base of the unit may therefore have been deposited in a relatively small-scale colluvial movement, with aeolian reworking and deposition resuming soon after. Small-scale colluviation and wetting of the sediment appear to have continued into 2615:2, as indicated by potential deformation structures and red silt lenses. The high porosity of the top part of the context in 2615:2 indicates heavy bioturbation with channels potentially marking root holes, or bio-galleries (Stoops 2003: 65), potentially marking a prolonged 26 15 :2 26 21 :1 (4 45 ) (490) (4 42 ) 2mm 2621:1/2boundary, PPL 1mm 2615:2Calcitic infillings and channels,XPL a b 1cm Sample 2621 Sample 2615 Figure 7.21: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 445. Sample 2615 is manufactured from an irregularly-cut block. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 194 hiatus in deposition. The calcitic hypocoatings to these voids were produced through the percolation of carbonate-rich groundwater through the sediments, either during this hiatus or later washing of calcite-rich groundwater through the profile (see Context 422 below). Context 445 therefore appears to indicate a potentially initially colluvial depositional environment which reworked potential aeolian material, followed by punctuated aeolian deposition and reworking and bioturbation (and potential rooting). This was associated with, or later followed by, precipitation of calcite marking increased water dripping within the cave. Context 455, North-Facing Profile In the field, Context 455 is a strong brown (7.5 YR 5/6) clayey silt which is slightly paler at the top of the context, and slightly paler to its base. There is 20–10% subangular to angular, horizontally oriented, platy limestone gravel clasts (1–3cm) concentrated to its base. There are 2% pale silt lenses (0.5mm by 1cm). The lower boundary is sharp and horizontal. The context was not sampled for micromorphological analysis. From its limestone content as observed in the field, it appears to contain a significant amount of roof-spall. The dung lenses suggest the presence of ephemeral surfaces within the depositional environment. The reddish colour of the unit, particularly to its base, suggests an external soil input into the fine material, and may result from an initially colluvial movement given the sharp lower contact, followed by potential aeolian deposition. Context 453, North-Facing Profile In the field, Context 453 is a strong brown (7.5YR 4/8) clayey silt with 35% horizontally oriented subangular platy/blocky limestone gravel. There is one large limestone cobble, well rounded, 10cm across near the lower boundary. The lower boundary occurs over 2–3cm. Micro-fabric 754A:2 is an orange-brown silt loam with occasional limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a stipple-speckled to reticulate to undifferentiated b-fabric (40:20:40). There are two main areas of structure: (1) massive to very weakly subangular to irregular blocky (10% porosity, vughs, vegetal voids and planar voids); and (2) spongy (50% porosity, vughs and chambers). Structure One forms a ~1.5cm thick band in the centre of the unit, whilst Structure Two forms bands at the top and bottom of the unit (Fig. 7.22a). There is rare blocky charcoal and bone, and a horizontal orientation to coarse material and voids. There is a single, concentric iron nodule and few typic iron nodules and rare pedorelicts. There are rare partially dissolved bones which resemble phosphatic void infillings (Fig. 7.22b), and frequent dung lenses, along with occasional phytoliths loose in the groundmass and silicified plant structures (Fig. 7.22c and d). The lower boundary is faint and diffuse. Micro-fabric 754A:3 is an orange-brown sandy silt loam with common limestone sand and gravel and a massive/vughy microstructure overlying a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure, (20% porosity), and a stipple- to mosaic-speckled b-fabric (90:10). There is rare blocky charcoal, flint, bone and shell. The coarse material is slightly horizontally-orientated and there are rare to well- rounded iron nodules as well as rare pedorelicts. There are few dung lenses and blocks. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 195 The presence of coarse limestone material in Micro-fabric 754A:3 and the silty nature of the fine material (mirrored in 754A:2) indicate that it is a mixture of aeolian sedimentation and reworking and limestone roof-spall. The weakly-developed granular structure and porosity of 754A:2 indicate bioturbation following a potentially highly organic original content. Heavily degraded, partially dissolved bone indicates heavy weathering and sporadic wetting of the sediment. The partially spongy nature of the groundmass and isolated articulated phytoliths indicates a high past organic content, Figure 7.22: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 453. (4 53 ) (4 66 ) 7 54 A: 1 75 4A :2 75 4A :3 2mm 500μm 754A:2silicified plant structure,PPL 754A:2Areasof spongy and vughy structure,PPL 754A:2Degraded bone 500μm 500μm a b c d 754A:2Phytolith-rich dungand manganesenodule,PPL Sample 754A 1cm Co nt ex ts Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 196 potentially from dung which exists in lenses. The relative lack of coarse material in 754A:2 may indicate a period of reduced physical weathering or a rapidity of deposition of aeolian material, but dung lenses indicate punctuation in this deposition. Context 453 therefore contains marked shifts in sedimentary environment, with aeolian-deposited material mixed with dung subject to wetting. The base of Context 453 therefore appears to result from colluvial movement of mixed limestone and potential aeolian material on both profiles, which was then followed by potential aeolian reworking and deposition. Significant calcite precipitation on the West-Facing Profile indicates later dripping of water on to the sediments, or movement of water through the profile far later, and potential sporadic wetting of these apparently aeolian sediments is evident on the North-Facing Profile. 7.4.2.4 Context 442=466+430+449+461, West- and North-Facing Profiles Context 442, identified on the West-Facing Profile, has been split into four contexts (466, 430, 449 and 461) on the North-Facing Profile. Context 449 is a lens on the North-Facing Profile. Only the lower half of Context 442 was sampled on the West-Facing Profile. Context 442, West-Facing Profile In the field, Context 442 is a reddish yellow-yellowish red silt. There is a large plaquette of limestone in the centre of the unit (~30cm long). Above the plaquette the matrix is reddish yellow (7.5YR 6/6), and below the plaquette becomes darker towards the base of the context.A thin line of calcite is visible in the sections at the same depth in the context as the plaquette. The micromorphological sampling extends to the underside of this plaquette. Micro-fabric 2610:1 is a yellow-brown sandy silt loam with common limestone medium sand and gravel and a vughy to moderately developed microstructure overlying a granular microaggregate structure (35% porosity). The b-fabric is a mixture of stipple-speckled, micritic calcitic crystallitic and undifferentiated (60:25:15). There is very rare blocky charcoal and shell, and the unit is siltier and better sorted towards its base. There are a layer of micritic calcitic aggregates directly below the limestone plaquette (Fig. 7.23a) and calcitic infillings and hypocoatings to all channels. There are rare well-rounded iron nodules and very rare fragments of partially dissolved bone associated with neoformed fibrous calcite crystals (Fig. 7.23b). Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. Micro-fabric 2610:2 is a red-brown silty clay with few limestone fine to medium sand clasts (Fig. 7.23c). There is a subangular blocky to massivemicrostructure (15%porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- to mosaic-speckled. (80:20). There are few blocky charcoal fragments. At the base the unit is finer and more compact than the top. There are micritic calcitic coatings to voids which run through the unit, and manganese staining to two large areas which form diffuse nodules. There are rare dung blocks and rare pedorelicts. Its lower boundary is prominent and sharp. Micro-fabric 2610:3 is an orange-brown sandy silt loam/silt loam with common limestone fine to medium sand, and a vughy/massive microstructure overlying a very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic, stipple-speckled Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 197 2610:1 2610:2 2610:3 2615:1 (4 42 ) (4 45 ) 2mm 500μm 2615:1Channel microstructure andmicritic calctic infillings,XPL 2mm 2610:1-3Showing clay-rich2610:2,PPL 2610:1Dissolving bone and re-precipitationof calcite,XPL 2610:1Micritc calcitic aggregatesat top offabric,XPL 1mm a b c d Sample 2615 Sample 2610 1cm Figure 7.23: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 442. Sample 2615 is manufactured from an irregularly-cut block. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 198 and undifferentiated (50:20:30). There are common phytoliths in the groundmass. The unit is more crystallitic towards its base, and there are calcitic hypocoatings to all large voids, andmicroaggregates within the channels. There is rare dung and pedorelicts, and rare fibrous crystallitic forms similar to those in 2610:1. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Micro-fabric 2615:1 is a brown silt loam with few limestone medium sand and gravel clasts, with a channel microstructure which overlies a massive structure, with weakly-developed granular micro- aggregate areas (30% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (60:40). There is a general horizontal orientation to the coarse material and laminations of clay. There are calcitic infillings to all large vughs and channels (Fig. 7.23d). There are also hypocoatings and infillings. There are very rare, diffuse iron nodules and common dung lenses and blocks. There are a few crust fragments to the base of the unit and few pedorelicts. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. The silty nature and limestone content of the material indicate that the fine material is potentially aeolian in origin andmixed with the products of roof-spalling. The horizontal orientation to the coarse material in 2615:1 indicates deposition on ephemeral surfaces, with the small lenses of clay indicating sporadic wetting of these surfaces. Themore distinct lensing of clayey material in 2610:2may suggest localised puddling or flow of clay-rich water from outside the cave or within the karstic system. The granular nature of the fabric indicates bioturbation throughout, potentially due to a prolonged exposure of the unit, or of an originally high organic content – thismay be linked to the abundance of phytoliths in 2610:2. The extensive calcite precipitation in pores indicates post-depositional precipitation of calcite, potentially linked to the layer of incipient flowstone above the sampled area. The fibrous crystalline calcite associated with the partially-dissolved bone fragements is probably linked to the dissolution and re-precipitation of minerals through the wetting which precipitated the calcite. They are similar to those observed in the lower layers of F600 (Chapter Eight). The manganese hypocoatings also indicate wetting of the sediments. Although the context appeared homogenous in the field, it contains distinct changes in sedimentation. 2610:2 indicates a period of sheetwash of clay-rich material, either from within the karstic system or from external soil material, a marked break from the rest of the sediments which appear aeolian in origin. Extensive precipitation of calcite throughout the context, as well as the crystalline minerals and manganese hypocoatings indicate wet conditions existing for a significant period of time in the cave, either during or after the deposition of the entire context. Context 466, North-Facing Profile In the field, 466 is a strong brown (7.5YR 5/6) clayey silt with 5% fine subrounded to angular limestone gravel. There are slight horizontal laminations in the fine material and <0.5mm pale flecks (10%). The lower boundary is distinct, over 1cm. Micro-fabric 754A:1 is an orange-brown silt loam with occasional limestone fine to coarse sand. It has a weakly-developed microaggregate structure overlain by a moderately developed subangular blocky Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 199 structure (17% porosity). It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (90:10). There are rare inclusions of potentially burnt and unburnt bone, and shell, as well as few dung lenses and blocks, very rarely with silty coatings. There are also rare coarse crust fragments, few pedorelicts and occasional well-rounded iron nodules and rare manganese coatings to voids (Fig. 7.24a). Its lower boundary is distinct and clear, marked by a change in structure. Fig. 7.24b) The silty nature of the fine material suggests a potentially aeolian origin and depositional environment. The disorganisation of the coarse material may indicate a mass colluvial movement of material overlying Context 453, yet the granular nature indicates bioturbation which may have disrupted the material producing this disorganisation, although could also reflect granular material being transported in a slurry. The silty coatings to the coarse material may have developed in such a slurry, or material rolling around on dusty surfaces. Overall consideration of this context is difficult given the small area analysed. Context 450, North-Facing Profile Context 450 is a yellowish-red (5YR 5/6), clean, homogenous gritty silt with very occasional subangular to subrounded limestone clasts (2mm–1cm). Micro-fabric 763:2 is a brown-orange (PPL) silty clay loam with occasional limestone fine sand and 75 4A :1 (4 53 ) 1mm 2mm a b Boundarybetween 754A:1and2,PPL 754A:1Manganese coating andhypocoatingto void,PPL 1cmSample 754A Co nt ex t Figure 7.24: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 466. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 200 gravel (Fig. 7.25a). It has a massive to subangular blocky microstructure (20% porosity, including vegetal voids). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is rare, degraded bone (Fig. 7.25b) and angular flint and very rare blocky charcoal with cell structure. The groundmass forms denser concentrations around the vegetal voids, and rare silty coatings to bone and flint. There are occasional iron nodules throughout, and occasional dung lenses and blocks. There are very rare articulated phytoliths. The silty texture of the material suggests an aeolian origin to the fine material, with the dung lenses potentially picking out ephemeral surfaces in an environment driven by aeolian sedimentation and reworking. The silty coatings to coarse material may have resulted from material rolling around on such surfaces and although the warped vegetal voids may suggest formation within a slurry, potentially in small-scale colluvial movements, these could also have formed in a similar way to the coatings to the coarse material. The micritic crystallitic b-fabric appears to suggest either the inclusion of silt- sized roof-spall during deposition, or micritic precipitation of calcite following (potentially well after) deposition. Context 449, North-Facing Profile Context 449 is a reddish-yellow (5YR 7/6) light brown sandy silt with frequent angular clasts (10– 50mm). It has a clear but irregular lower boundary. (4 50 ) 76 3: 2 2mm 1mm763:2Degradedbone, PPL 763:1-2Slightly subangular blocky structure,PPL a b 1cmSample 763 Co nt ex t Figure 7.25: Slide scan and microphotographs from Context 450. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 201 Micro-fabric 762:2 is a pale orange-brown sandy silt loam with frequent limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a massive to vughy structure overlying a weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (25% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled tomicritic calcitic crystallitic (70:30). There is rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone (one of which appears to be semi-dissolved and calcite re- precipitated around it, Figure 7.26a, shell and well-rounded flint. There are micro-crusts and lenses interleaved with reddish silt drapes/infillings at the centre (Fig. 7.26b). There are few iron nodules and rare pedorelicts, along with rare dung lenses and blocks. Micro-fabric 763:1 is a brown silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a vughy to very weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple- speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (90:10). There is rare angular flint and rare potentially burnt and unburnt bone. There are rare stringers of clay, and an increase in calcite to the top of the unit. There are calcitic hypocoatings which have interconnected in the centre of the unit. There are also occasional iron nodules (well rounded to diffuse) and rare pedorelicts. There are rare manganese hypocoatings to channels and occasional dung blocks and lenses. It has a faint, diffuse lower boundary. The silty nature of the fine material suggests an aeolian origin, whilst the limestone was produced through physical weathering of the bedrock. The presence of clay stringers and lenses indicates a repeated wetting of the sediment surface, which becomes more pronounced in Micro-fabric 762:2. Calcitic hypocoatings in Micro-fabric 763:1 indicates post-depositional percolation of carbonate-rich water, perhaps from drips from the roof, although this precipitation may have occurred a long time after burial. This context is therefore probably a mixture of aeolian sedimentation and reworking punctuated by periods of wetting of the sediment by clay-rich water. Context 461, North-Facing Profile Context 461 is a yellowish-red (5YR 4/6) fine silt with occasional limestone sand and angular to subangular gravel (~25mm). The lower boundary is abrupt, and the context is redder andmore compact than below, and there is possible occasional manganese staining. Micro-fabric 761:1 is a red-brown silty clay loam with few limestone fine sand to gravel clasts. It has a vughy to massivemicrostructure (15% porosity) and a stipple-speckled to reticulate (50:50) b-fabric. There is rare charcoal or humified organics. There is very rare shell and rare potentially burnt bone, as well as rare clayey infillings to the pores at the top of the fabric (Fig. 7.26c) and rare silty coatings to dung fragments. There are very rare phosphatic nodules, few dung lenses and blocks and common crust fragments. At the very base of the unit there is horizontal orientation to planar voids and fine material laminations. The lower boundary is prominent and sharp (Fig. 7.26d). Given the red colour of the fine material, the sharp lower boundary the context appears to be a result of a mass movement of soil material. The clayey coatings to voids directly under the boundary probably result from the translocation of fine material into these voids during this wet depositional event, as they do not extend far into the micro-fabric. The horizontal laminations at the base of the unit may be linked to sheet washes of material prior to deposition, or the entire unit may be a series of quite rapidly Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 202 deposited wash events. Some trends can be traced in Context 442=466+430+449+461 between the two profiles. An initial colluvial movement at the base of the unit is traced in the lowest part of 442 on the West-Facing Profile, and may be present to an extent in 466 on the North-Facing Profile. Later deposition was 76 3: 1 76 2: 2 (4 49 ) (4 61 ) 762:2clay infillings /lenses,PPL 1mm 762:2Dissolved bone andcalcite,XPL 1mm 76 2: 1 1mm 762:1-2boundary, PPL a b c d 500μm 762:1Clay coating to vegetal void,XPL Sample 763 Sample 762 1cm Co nt ex t Figure 7.26: Slide scan and microphotographs from Contexts 449 and 461. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 203 potentially aeolian in character, as seen in the top part of 442 and 450. The lack of carbonate concretion on the North-Facing Profile indicates the local restriction of what was still quite a substantial period of wetness from water dripping through the ceiling in the middle of 442 on theWest-Facing Profile where it produced an incipient flowstone (not sampled). Contexts 449 and 461 on the North-Facing Profile, show a period of potential aeolian deposition and physical weathering with some sporadic wetting, followed by a mass movement of external soil material. 7.4.3 The Early Dabban Layers: Bulk Sedimentological Data This section of FaciesThree contains the marked jump inmagnetic susceptibility values in the Dabban which dominates the sequence (See Chapter Five), occurring in Context 441 on theWest-Facing Profile (Fig. 7.27). This is mirrored on the North-Facing Profile with a more gradual rise between Contexts 448 and 446 to values consistently above the corrected and uncorrected means, as well as above the corrected soil values. This is followed by a slight low in Context 246/236 on the North-Facing Profile before the high values resume. The %LOI values are consistently low on the West-Facing Profile, with slight peaks in 466 and 246/236 on the North-Facing Profile showing limited variation but not correlated with any observations of anthropogenic material. The %CaCO 3 values from this part of the sequence are highly variable, but both show a downwards trend which mirrors the increase in magnetic susceptibility values, even following ‘correction’. The highest peak on theWest-Facing Profile is seen in Context 445, which is mirrored slightly on the North-Facing Profile in 453 and 455. As with the majority of the sequence, the %CaCO 3 values on the North-Facing Profile are slightly higher than on the West-Facing, and theNorth-Facing Profile contains a peak inContext 461which is absent from the corresponding part of the sequence on the West-Facing Profile, Context 422. The North-Facing Profile also contains peaks above the micromorphological sampling in 246/236 and 235/439. 7.4.4 The Early Dabban Layers: Discussion of Bulk Sedimentological and Soil Micromorphological Data The micromorphological observations of the layers sampled within the Early Dabban are dominated by potential aeolian sedimentation, sporadically interrupted by contexts which have been reworked through wet colluvial movements (Table 7.5). This is mirrored in the initially low magnetic susceptibility of the sediments during this period. The inwash events outlined in Contexts 490 and 461 do not correspond with significant peaks in magnetic susceptibility, as may be expected given their appearance in the field and micromorphological interpretation, yet are still within the range of modern soil values (both uncorrected and corrected), indicating that there is a consistent soil material influence to the surrounding aeolian deposited contexts, or that the material was exposed for a prolonged period of reworking allowing the oxidation of the sediments. After the micromorphological sampling stops in Context 461, the magnetic susceptibility jumps to far higher values, rendering it difficult to trace the mechanism by which this took place. The %CaCO 3 appears to trace the presence of limestone sand within the sediments rather than the presence of the secondary precipitation of carbonate, as the micromorphological observations of calcite-cemented Contexts 490 and 442 on the West-Facing Profile do not correspond with significant peaks. %LOI is consistently low, throughout, reflecting a Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 204 general lack of occupation material observed micromorphologically. 7.4.5 The Early Dabban Layers: Interpretation The Early Dabban part of Facies Three was a period when, in its lower half, the main sediment input was consistently low in magnetic susceptibility compared to the overlying layers, yet raised from the underlying, and within modern soil variation. The micromorphological observations show a largely potentially aeolian depositional environment, although some contexts have been reworked by colluvial processes within the cave, and punctuated washes of clay-rich water in an otherwise dry environment. Context 490 marks a period of inwash of soil material into the cave on the West-Facing Profile. It is unclear how this relates temporally to the colluvial deposition of internal material in Context 457 on the North-Facing Profile, or indeed how robust this interpretation is for 457. Context 445=453+455 0 2 0 0 4 0 0 6 0 0 8 0 0 1 0 0 0 440 236 236/441 441 442 445 2 3 4 5 500 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 206 207 235/439 440 246/236 446 447 448 461 449 450 466 453 0 2 0 0 4 0 0 6 0 0 8 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 3 4 5 6 500 1 0 2 0 3 0 4 0 Magnetic Susceptibility (x) % LOIorganics % Carbonate W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 490 455 457 Figure 7.27: Bulks sedimentological data for Facies Three Early Dabban contexts. Blue magnetic susceptibility bars are uncorrected values, red are corrected values. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 205 poses some difficulties in interpretation due to variation between the profiles. On the West-Facing Profile, the context appears to be the result of an initial colluvial environment, followed by continued punctuated aeolian deposition, and further bioturbation, potentially indicating a prolonged exposure. On theNorth-Facing Profile the context is split, with Context 455, although not micromorphologically sampled, potentially mirroring the formation of Context 445 through a colluvial movement followed by potential aeolian/dusty deposition and roof-spall. This aeolian regime continues into the upper half of Context 445=453+455 where there are indicators of a damper period in the cave, potentially linked to the calcite precipitation in Context 445 on the West-Facing Profile. Some trends can be traced in Context 442=466+450+449+461 between the two profiles. An initial colluvial movement at the base of the unit is traced in the lowest part of 442 on the West-Facing Profile, and may be present to an extent in 466 on the North-Facing Profile. Later deposition was aeolian in character, as seen in the top part of 442 and 450. The lack of carbonate concretion on the North-Facing Profile indicates the local restriction of what was still quite a substantial period of wetness from water dripping through the ceiling in the middle of 442 on the West-Facing Profile where it produced an incipient flowstone (not sampled), although it cannot be ruled out that this was Micromorphological Interpretation Context Traceable Context Context Micromorphological Interpretation Initially colluvial movement of internal material/potential aeolian material, with some external influence followed by possible aeolian deposition interrupted by a wash event of clay-rich material. Period of increased dripping within the cave causing calcite precipitation, potentially post-depositional. (442) (4 42 = 46 6+ 45 0 + 44 9+ 46 1) (461) Mass, erosive movement of potentially soil material. (449) Mainly potentially aeolian deposition and reworking, but with wetting by clay rich water. Later calcite precipitation. (450) Potential aeolian deposition and reworking, potential small-scale colluvial reworking. (466) Potential aeolian/ deposition with bioturbation or colluvial reworking. Initial internal colluvial movement followed by period of small-scale colluvial and potential aeolian/dusty deposition and reworking, with sporadic damping. Later extensive bioturbation and calcite precipitation. (445) (445=453+455) (453) Potential aeolian deposition and reworking, followed by a period of wetting and dung deposition. (455) Not sampled for micromorphology - potentially aeolian deposition and physical weathering from field with potentially a colluvial movement of soil material at base. Punctuated inwash of soil material, interrupted by physical weathering. Major calcite precipitation either coincident with hiatus, and continuing through context, or post-depositional. (490) (457) Initially rapid, erosive, punctuated small-scale colluvial rewokring of potentially aeolian material followed by a resumption in aeolian deposition and reworking and later bioturbation. Table 7.5: Summary of context intepretations of Facies Three Early Dabban contexts based on micromorphological interpretations. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 206 significantly after the deposition of the unit. Contexts 449 and 461 on the North-Facing Profile, show a period of potential aeolian deposition and physical weathering with some sporadic wetting, followed by a mass movement of external soil material. Context 442 is more complex in interpretation. On the West-Facing Profile, the deposition appears primarily aeolian in origin (after an initial colluvial movement) but also contains puddling layers, as well as extensive evidence for secondary wetting of the sediments and indications of an originally high organic content. The initial colluvial movement may be reflected in the deposition of 466, with 450 and 449 on the North-Facing Profile representing the later aeolian phase shown on the West-Facing in 442. Washes of sheetwash in 449 may be linked to the puddling lens of clayey material in 2610:2. The calcite precipitation in Context 442 is consistent with the field observation of the incipient flowstone in the centre of the context, and although it is unclear how much of the calcite is from this period of precipitation, such a significant concretion of the sediments indicates a potentially prolonged period of precipitation during and after deposition. The colluvial deposition soil material in Context 461on the North-Facing Profile marks a major change in the sedimentological regime of the cave, one preceded to an extent by the smaller-scale sheetwash events in Contexts 449 and 442. Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 207 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 44 2= 46 1+ 44 9+ 45 0+ 46 6 46 1 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 76 2: 1 18 m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e si lt ,a nd fe w li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :p la na r vo id s, ch am be rs an d vu gh s, ve ge ta lv oi ds .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to re ti cu la te (5 0: 50 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar re d or hu m ifi ed or ga ni cs .V er y ra re sh el l, ra re bu rn tb on e. R ar e cl ay ey in fil li ng s in fil li ng po re s at to p of fa br ic 1. 3m m ar ea .R ar e si lt y co at in gs to du ng fr ag m en ts . F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. V er y ra re ph os ph at ic no du le s. F ew du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks ,w ar pe d. C om m .c ru st fr ag m en ts . C ol lu vi al m ov em en to f so il m at er ia l 44 9 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 76 2: 2 42 m m 44 9 P al e or an ge B ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d ve ry fin e sa nd ,f re q. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el . M as si ve to vu gh y ov er ly in g a w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,c ha m be rs , ve ge ta lv oi ds an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bu rn tb on e, an d bo ne pa rt ia ll y di ss ol ve d. R ar e sh el l, ra re w el l- ro un de d fli nt .M ac ro va ri at io n in gr av el , co nc en tr at io n to ce nt re .L en se s of re dd is h si lt li nk ca pp in gs to in fil li ng s of pl an ar vo id s at ce nt re of un it .S il ty in fil li ng s to pl an ar vo id s un de r an d ar ou nd la rg e bl oc ks at ba se .M ic ro cr us ts /l en se s. In te rl ea ve d w it h re dd is h si lt dr ap es /i nfi ll in gs at ce nt re .F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. F ew ir on no du le s an d ra re pe do re li ct s. R ar e du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . M ai nl y po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti no bu tw it h w et ti ng by cl ay ri ch w at er dr ip pi ng . L at er ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n. 76 3: 1 45 -5 0m m B ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .o cc .q ua rt z fin e sa nd to si lt ,c om m .. li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el .V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty : vu gh s, ch an ne l, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :6 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. F ai nt ,d if fu se lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky fli nt ,r ar e bo ne ,b ur nt an d un bu rn t. R ar e st ri ng er s of cl ay as in un it ab ov e. In cr ea se in ca lc it e to to p of un it .i nt er co nn ec te d ca lc it ic hy po co at in g si n ce nt re of un it .F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. O cc .i ro n no du le s, w el lr ou nd ed to di ff us e, ra re pe do re li ct s. R ar e m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs to ch an ne ls .O cc .d un g bl oc ks an d le ns es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on , po te nt ia lc ol lu vi al re w or ki ng . 45 0 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 76 3: 2 20 m m B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,o cc .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :v ug hs ,v eg et al vo id s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. V er y ra re bl oc ky ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne an d ve ry ra re an gu la r fli nt .S il ty sw ir le d co at in gs to ve ge ta lv oi ds .R ar e si lt y co at in gs to bo ne an d fli nt .O cc .m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .i ro n no du le s th ro ug ho ut .O cc .d un g le ns es an d bl oc ks .V er y ra re ar ti cu la te d ph yt ol it hs in st em s. C ol lu vi al m ov em en t of po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia lw it h pa st or ga ni c co m po ne nt . 46 6 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 75 4A :1 5- 15 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd oc c. li m es to ne fin e to co ar se sa nd .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e ov er la in by m od er at el y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. 17 % po ro si ty :p la na r vo id s, vu gh s an d ch an ne ls .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic (9 0: 10 ). C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne ,b ur nt an d un bu rn t, an d sh el l. V er y ra re si lt y co at in gs to fr ag m en ts of du ng .F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .i ro n no du le s w el l- ro un de d – fe w pe do re li ct s. F ew du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks .R ar e co ar se cr us tf ra gm en ts . R ar e M n co at in g to ch an ne l. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng O R co ll uv ia lm as s m ov em en t. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on , po te nt ia l re w or ki ng . Ta bl e 7. 6: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F ac ie s T hr ee E ar ly D ab ba n m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul ld es cr ip ti on s in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al ,f re q. - fr eq ue nt ,c om m .- co m m on . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 208 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 44 2 W es t- fa ci ng pr ofi le 26 10 :1 20 -3 0m m Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d sa nd ,c om m .l im es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el . V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g a gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 35 % po ro si ty :c om po un d pa ck in g vo id s, vu gh s, pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed (6 0: 25 :1 5) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bl oc ky ch ar co al an d sh el l. U ni ts il ti er an d be tt er so rt ed to w ar ds th e ba se .M ic ri ti c ag gr eg at es at to p of un it be lo w li m es to ne pl aq ue tt e. M ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic vo id co at in gs /i nfi ll in gs to al lc ha nn el s. P ar ti al ly -d is so lv ed bo ne an d ne of or m ed m in er al s. R ar e m an ga ne se vo id co at in gs , ra re w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia l si gn ifi ca nt ly w et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . In it ia ll y co ll uv ia l m ov em en to f po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l, w it h so m e ex te rn al in flu en ce fo ll ow ed by fu rt he r ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d po te nt ia l st ab il is at io ns , an d ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n. (p ot en ti al ly po st - de po si ti on ). 26 10 :2 5- 2m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay .S ub an gu la r bl oc ky to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty :c ra ck s an d pl an ar vo id s, vu gh s. C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,f ew li m es to ne fin e to m ed iu m sa nd .S ti pp le to m os ai c sp ec kl ed b- fa br ic .( 80 :2 0) . C F li m it :3 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . F ew bl oc ky ch ar co al fr ag m en ts .A tb as e un it is fin er an d m or e co m pa ct th an fu rt he r up – st il lw el ls or te d. cr ys ta ll it ic co at in gs to vo id s w hi ch ru n th ro ug h th e un it .m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to tw o ar ea s 1- 2m m ac ro ss .R ar e du ng bl oc ks ,a nd ra re pe do re li ct s. In w as h an d pu dd li ng of po te nt ia ls oi l m at er ia l. 26 10 :3 40 -6 0m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd ,c om m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd to m ed iu m sa nd .V ug hy / m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g v. w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :c ha nn el s, vu gh s/ ch am be rs .M ic ri ti c to sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed :u nd if fe re nt ia te d (5 0: 20 :3 0) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . C om m ph yt ol it hs in gr ou nd m as s. V er y ra re bo ne . R ar e sh el l. M or e cr ys ta ll it ic to ba se of un it .C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to al ll ar ge vo id s, an d m ic ro ag gr eg at es w it hi n ch an ne ls .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, R ar e du ng .R ar e pe do re li ct s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h si gn ifi ca nt su bs eq ue nt w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 26 15 :1 40 m m B ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el .C ha nn el m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. W ea kl y de v gr an ul ar in pl ac es .3 0% po ro si ty :c ha nn el s an d vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c/ sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e sh el l. G en er al ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n an d la m in at io ns of cl ay .C al ci ti c in fil li ng s to al ll ar ge vu gh s an d ch an ne ls . A ls o hy po co at in gs an d in fil li ng s. O cc .m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, ve ry ra re di ff us e ir on no du le s. C om m du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks .F ew cr us tf ra gm en ts to ba se .F ew pe do re li ct s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 209 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on 44 5= 45 3- 45 5 44 5 W es t- fa ci ng pr ofi le 26 15 :2 42 m m P al e br ow n- re d (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt fin e sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el . V ug hy / ch an ne lm ic ro st ru ct ur e. 30 % po ro si ty :c ha nn el s, vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :6 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. N o lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re bo ne ,s he ll .S li gh th or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to co ar se m at er ia l. C al ci ti c in fil li ng s an d hy po co at in gs to vo id s. F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. O cc .p ed or el ic ts .C om m .d un g le ns es an d bl oc ks . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . In it ia li nt er na l co ll uv ia l m ov em en t fo ll ow ed by pe ri od of sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia la nd po te nt il ae ol ia n de po si ti on , sp or ad ic da m pi ng . L at er ex te ns iv e bi ot ur ba ti on an d ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n. . 26 21 :1 24 -4 0m m B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am .C om m . qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd .O cc .l im es to ne m ed iu m sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy /c ha nn el m ic ro st ru ct ur e, 15 % po ro si ty : ch an ne ls ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic gr ou nd m as s (9 0: 10 ). C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . V .R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al /h um ifi ed .R ar e bo ne .V er y ra re fin e le ns es of re d si lt .W ar pe d du ng le ns es ar ou nd co ar se m at er ia la tt op of un it .C al ci ti c co at in gs an d ca lc it ic ag gr eg at es w it hi n al lc ha nn el s. H yp oc oa ti ng s to ch an ne ls th ro ug ho ut .O cc M n de nd ri ti c no du le s. O cc .p ed or el ic ts . F ew du ng bl oc ks an d w ar pe d le ns es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng . 45 3 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 75 4A :2 30 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .1 ) M as si ve to ve ry w ea kl y su ba ng ul ar to ir re gu la r bl oc ky . 10 % po ro si ty vu gh s, ve ge ta l vo id s an d pl an ar vo id s 2) sp on gy ,5 0% po ro si ty :v ug hs an d ch am be rs .C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,o cc .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to re ti cu la te to un di ff er en ti at ed (4 0: 20 :4 0) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m ,C F ra ti o: 22 :7 8. F ai nt ,d if fu se lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,r ar e bo ne .P or os it y ch an ge in co ns is te nt m at er ia l. H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to m os tc oa rs e el em en ts an d vo id s. V .r ar e co nc en tr ic ir on no du le .O cc . de nd ri ti c M n vo id s. F ew ir on no du le s, ra re pe do re li ct s. V er y ra re ph os ph at ic in fil li ng s. F re q. du ng le ns es .O cc . ph yt ol it hs in gr ou nd m as s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic ,s ig ni fic an t w et ti ng an d du ng de po si ti on to th e to p of th e un it . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on , fo ll ow ed by a pe ri od of w et ti ng an d du ng de po si ti on . 75 4A :3 60 -7 5m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,C om m .l im es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve -v ug hy ov er ly in g w ea kl y m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y 20 % , vu gh s an d ch am be rs ,p la na r vo id s, cp v. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m os ai c( 90 :1 0) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,fl in t, bo ne an d sh el l. C oa rs e m at er ia l ha s ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. F ew m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. R ar e di ff us e to w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s, ra re pe do re li ct s, fe w du ng le ns es an d bl oc ks . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d ro ck fa ll . 45 5 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le N ot sa m pl ed P ot en ti al so il in w as h fo ll ow ed by ae ol ia n de po si ti on . Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 210 C on te xt M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on C on te xt In te rp re ta ti on W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e O nl y 49 0 26 21 :2 30 -4 0m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .q ua rt s co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,R ar e li m es to ne m ed iu m to co ar se sa nd . W ea k to m od er at e de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e to m as si ve .1 5% po ro si ty :p la na r, ch am be rs an d vu gh s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic (6 5: 35 ). C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e an gu la r fli nt ,b on e (b ur nt an d un bu rn t) .C al ci ti c co at in gs an d hy po co at in gs to la rg e vu gh s an d ch am be rs . G ro un dm as s sa tu ra te d w it h ca lc it e to ba se of un it . m an ga ne se st ai ni ng co nc en tr at ed in ce nt re of fa br ic .R ar e m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs to vo id s. O cc .i ro n no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, w el l- ro un de d. V er y ra re ro un de d cr us t fr ag m en ts . C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi l m at er ia lw it h la te r w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . P un ct ua te d in w as h of so il m at er ia l, in te rr up te d by ph ys ic al w ea th er in g. M aj or ca lc it e pr ec ip it at io n ei th er co in ci de nt w it h hi at us ,a nd co nt in ui ng th ro ug h co nt ex t, or po st - de po si ti on al fr om to p of co nt ex t. 26 21 :3 15 -2 0m m G re y- br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,f ew li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el .M od er at e to w el l- de ve lo pe d pl at y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 30 % po ro si ty :p la na r vo id s an d ch am be rs .M ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re w el l- ro un de d fli nt .C al ci ti c im pr eg na ti on to al l of th e gr ou nd m as s an d sp ar it ic co at in g of pl an ar vo id s. S pa ri ti c gr ow th s of ca lc it e in pl an ar vo id s. O cc .m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le ar ea s. R ar e w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi l m at er ia lf ol lo w ed by ex te ns iv e w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 26 21 :4 50 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd ,O cc .l im es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el . W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e on m as si ve to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 30 % po ro si ty :p la na r vo id s, vu gh s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 27 :7 3. N o lo w er bo un da ry . V er y ra re ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne .G en er al fin in g an d m or e m as si ve to to p of un it .S il ty le ns in ce nt re of un it .C al ci ti c sa tu ra ti on of gr an ul ar ar ea .C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to la rg e gr av el an d in fil li ng s to vo id s. F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. fe w pe do re li ct s, R ar e du ng le ns es ,R ar e cr us t fr ag m en ts . C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi l m at er ia l. N or th -F ac in g P ro fil e O nl y 45 7 N or th - fa ci ng pr ofi le 25 29 :1 50 m m O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .C om m .c oa rs e si lt fin e sa nd qu ar tz an d co m m .l im es to ne gr av el an d sa nd . V ug hy -m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e w it h 15 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic 80 :2 0. C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, sh el la nd bo ne .‘ F us ed ’ na tu re to gr ou nd m as s, ho ri zo nt al ar ra ng em en tt o co ar se m at er ia la tb as e of sl id e. In cr ea se in co ar se m at er ia la nd im br ic at io n to w ar ds ba se .F ew w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s an d ir on -i m pr eg na te d ag gr eg at es ,w el lr ou nd ed .o cc .d un g le ns es an d bl oc ks . E ro si ve co ll uv ia l/ al lu vi al m ov em en t of in te rn al m at er ia l, fo ll ow ed by a pe ri od of sl ow in g of de po si ti on an d ep he m er al su rf ac es an d la te r re su m pt io n of co ll uv ia lr eg im e. In it ia ll y ra pi d, er os iv e, pu nc tu at ed sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia lw et in te rn al m ov em en t of po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n m at er ia l, be co m in g m or e bi ot ur ba te d to w ar ds th e to p Chapter Seven: The Micromorphology of Facies Three 211 7.5 Facies Three: Summary Discussion and Interpretation The MSA contexts in Facies Three were dominated by potential aeolian sedimentation yet also contained a number of colluvial events which reworked both aeolian and soil material. These colluvial movements maymark increased runoff and erosion of material from the surrounding landscape, either in the form of soil or aeolian/dust material from close to the mouth of the cave. The calcite-impregnated layers towards the top of the MSA levels were constrained in depth, suggesting a restriction in the duration of these periods of calcite precipitation driven by dripping of carbonate-rich water onto the sediments. This groundwater percolation represents a different hydrological regime to that represented by the colluvial movements, however the timing of the periods in which this regime was active cannot be confirmed without the direct dating of the carbonate layers themselves. Layer XXV contained the same sedimentation regimes as the MSA layers, with slightly increasing rapidity and intensity of colluvial movements of material, beginning in small-scale colluvial movement within the contexts, and culminating the inwash event of Context 493=458 which covers the entire trench, and the very clay-rich Context 491. These wash events were punctuated by potential aeolian depositional events, as well as marked periods of calcite precipitation, e.g. in Context 496 and 491. In the Early Dabban, continued soil inwash in Context 490 appears to have been followed by mainly aeolian deposition. These sediments contained an extensive period of calcite cementation, marking prolonged percolation of carbonate-rich water within the sediments in Contexts 442 and 445, although, as previously mentioned, the relationship of these periods of precipitation to the rest of the stratigraphy remains unclear without direct dating. These levels were a capped by another inwash event, Context 461. This frequent cycle between apparent aeolian deposition and reworking and inwash events is then traced above the micromorphology in the alternating layers of pale gravelly silt and reddish clayey material as observed in the field (see Chapter Five), and which mark the shift to Facies Two. The environmental implications of this site formation history and the changes in the formation processes will be discussed further in Chapter Nine in light of the bulk sedimentology and Facies Four and Five descriptions discussed in this and the preceding chapters. 212 Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSABurning Features 8.1 Introduction Facies Four and Five contained a number of lenses of anthropogenic material, interpreted in the field as burning events. A number of the smaller lenses were described and interpreted in Chapters Six and Seven, and this chapter will outline the complex microstratigraphy of two large lenses of burning. Feature 600 was recorded at the base of the Middle Trench North-Facing Profile and Facies Five, whilst a burnt lens, Contexts 535 and 513, stretched across the top of Facies Four on the North- Facing Profile. The microstratigraphy of these burning events will be outlined and their interpretations discussed in terms of the cave environment before, after, and during their deposition and associated occupation. 8.2 Feature 600 8.2.1 Field Description At the base of the Middle Trench North-Facing Profile, Layer XXXIV contains Feature 600. The feature consists of a very dark brown, bowl-shaped silty lens with a diffuse base overlain in its centre by a series of mixed ash layers, punctuated by lenses of clean red clayey silt. It was exposed over three seasons from 2008/09 to 2010, eventually measuring approximately 75cm in length and 30cm in depth. The feature’s bowl-like shape is unusual within the otherwise largely horizontal stratigraphy Figure 8.1: View of base of North Facing Profile of the Middle Trench, showing F600 (centre of the picture, base of the trench and bisected by shoring and disrupted after sampling) in 2010. Note second, similar lens above and right of F600, and large burning event (513/535) below labels which covers most of the section. Second lens is ~50cm across. Photo: R Inglis. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 213 (Figure 8.1), suggesting the feature’s deposition in a depression. The overlying Context 563 has a sharp lower boundary with the feature, potentially indicating its truncation. 8.2.2 Soil Micromorphology Sample 2015 was removed from the profile in 2008/09 at the eastern edge of the feature, and Sample 2155 in 2009 from its centre (Fig. 8.2). Given the complex stratigraphy, Sample 2015 is described first (Fig. 8.3), with 2155 described and interpreted in relation to the other sample.Micro-fabrics within the slides are considered from the base of the slide to the top. Figure 8.2: Top - F600 in 2009, after removal of sample <2015> in 2008/09 and prior to the removal of 2155 in 2009. Scale is 15cm, divisions 5cm. Photo G. Barker. Bottom: Drawing showing internal stratigraphy of F600 and position of Samples 2015 and 2155. Orange Darkbrown/red (570) (564) (569) (563) White Grey WhiteMixing Black Reddish silt Black Orange (564) (563) (525) 10cm <2015> <2155> Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 214 8.2.2.1 Sample 2015 Micro-fabric 2015:7 is a 65 to 75mm-thick medium-brown silty clay loam with occasional quartz silt and sand and rare limestone sand and gravel. It has a vughy to weakly-developed granular microstructure, becoming vughy to spongy at its base (Figure 8.4a) (15% porosity), and a stipple- to mosaic-speckled b-fabric (80:20). There are occasional dung lenses containing faecal spherulites, and the fine material exhibits subtle lamination. There are also a few, so far unidentified but potentially calcitic, randomly orientated, straw-like crystal mineral growths (Figure 8.4b) in association with heavily degraded bone fragments in horizontal, irregular voids (Figure 8.4a). Horizontally oriented, semi-charred/semi humified organic material is present in the top 1-2cm of the unit, and the entire fabric is stained brown, and includes fine silt sized organic punctuations. Its lower boundary was not sampled. The dark colour of the groundmass indicates that the micro-fabric has been influenced by the decay of organic material, decay also shown in the heavily weathered, partially-dissolved bone fragments (Karkanas and Goldberg 2010). The spongy structure at the base of the unit may reflect the structure of the decomposed organic material, with the loss of this sponginess and a weakly-developed granular microstructure towards the top of the micro-fabric potentially indicating increased bioturbation destroying this structure, consistent with exposure near to a surface. The nature of this organic material is unclear. The spongy structure is similar to that of dung fragments observed elsewhere in theHauaFteah, yet there are occasional dung lenseswith faecal spheruliteswithin this fabric, and it is possible that these lenses have been stained along with the rest of the groundmass through the leaching of humic acids from organic material decay. A further mechanism may be the hyper-fragmentation of charcoal in alkaline conditions (Braadbaart et al. 2009), which has left little or no coarse blocky organic material, with the spongy and vughy nature of the groundmass resulting from subsequent bioturbation during exposure near a surface, further aiding in this fragmentation. Given the lack of spherulites in the matrix outside of the identified fragments of dung it does not appear that dung is being burnt systematically, but was more probably simply part of the cave floor environment during combustion. Micro-fabric 2015:6 is a 3 to 4mm-thick pale orange-brown silt loam, with few quartz coarse silt to fine sand and limestone sand to gravel clasts. A vughy to weakly-developed subangular blocky microstructure overlies a granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity), with a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (60:40) b-fabric. Occasional, horizontally-oriented stringers of charred organics (Figure 8.4c) mirror fine material laminations, and a few well-rounded iron nodules are also present. The lower boundary is prominent and diffuse, mixed with the underlying unit. The micro-fabric does not contain any ash pseudomorphs, and therefore its micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (Figure 8.4c) may result from roof-spall or aeolian silt deposition, yet it may also derive from weathered ash material linked to the underlying unit which has been largely deflated from this area, which is consistent with its mixed, diffuse lower boundary. The stringers of charred material have Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 215 20 15 :7 20 15 :1 20 15 :2 20 15 :3 20 15 :4 20 15 :5 20 15 :6 Pu nc tu at ed co llu vi al de po si tio n M ix ed co llu vi um an d as h Tr un ca te d sh ee tw as h cr us ts Sh ee tw as h cr us t Co llu vi al m at er ia l m ix ed w ith bu rn tm at er ia l H ea vi ly de gr ad ed ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia l 20 15 :1 20 15 :3 20 15 :4 20 15 :7 1c m F ig ur e 8. 3: Sl id e sc an an d m ic ro st ra ti gr ap hy of 20 15 w it h in te rp re ta ti on s. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 216 either retained their horizontal orientation from in situ burning, or have been trampled or spread across a surface, although the thickness of the unit renders interpretation difficult. Micro-fabric 2015:5 is a 3mm-thick red-brown sandy silt loam with occasional quartz and frequent Figure 8.4: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2015, Micro-fabrics 2015:7-4. 1mm a 2015:7 Degraded, partially-dissolvedbone and spongystructure,PPL 500μm b 2015:7 Unidentifiedmineralcrystals,XPL 2015:6 Charredorganic stringers and pale groundmass,PPL c 1mm d 2015:5 Inclusionsof burntbone and charcoal,PPL 500μm 1mm f 2015:4 Crustwith calcite layer,PPL 500μm2015:5/6 Boundary between silt 2015:6and more clayey, heterogenous 2015:5,PPL e Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 217 limestone gravel and sand. It has a vughy/massive microstructure (15% porosity) overlying a moderately developed granular microaggregate structure, and a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (60:40). There are occasional blocky charred organic fragments and burnt bone (Fig. 8.4d). The clayey material is concentrated towards the base of the micro-fabric, and there are occasional well-rounded iron nodules. It has a prominent, clear lower boundary with the underlying unit (Fig. 8.4e). The incorporation of charred material within a reddish groundmass indicates that occupation material has become mixed with largely geogenic material. The clear lower boundary and concentration of clay to the base of the micro-fabric indicate that it was deposited in a potentially erosive wet, colluvial movement (or series of movements). The crystallitic b-fabric may derive from reworked calcitic ash. Micro-fabric 2015:4 is a red silty clay loam made up of at least three fining sequences of frequent quartz coarse silt and fine sand clasts (Fig. 9.4f). Within these sequences the structure grades from a moderately-developed granular microaggregate structure at its base to a massive/vesicular structure at the top (porosity drops from 15 to 0%). The b-fabric is mosaic to cross-striated (80:20). There are rare blocky charcoal fragments, with rare lenses of micritic calcite on top of the fining sequences (Fig. 8.4f). It has a prominent, clear lower boundary. The fining sequences in 2015:4 indicate repeated sheetwash of silty material followed by drying and crusting. The micro-fabric’s relative homogeneity indicates a geogenic and potentially external origin for the silt, i.e. soil. The cross-striated b-fabric reflects shrinking and swelling of the fabric, probably driven by wetting and drying of the clay-rich fabric, with the calcite overlying one of the crusts potentially precipitated during this drying. The charcoal inclusions indicate reworking of burnt material, potentially from within the feature, during these sheetwash events. Micro-fabric 2015:3 is a red-brown silty clay loam with common quartz and rare limestone. It has a vughy to weakly/moderately-developed granular microaggregate structure and a stipple-speckled b-fabric (20% porosity). It contains stringers of rare charred organic material, and occasional fine sand and silt-sized blocky charred fragments including a twig cross-section (J. Morales, pers. comm. 2011). There is an upwards fining of the grain size in the micro-fabric, with silty clay crusting near its top. It has a prominent, clear lower boundary. Similarities between the fining sequences and crusts in Micro-fabrics 2015:4 and 2015:3 indicate a common deposition mechanism, that of sheetwash of material. 2015:3 is however more heterogenous and contains more inclusions than 2015:4, indicating a slightly shifted source material containing more occupation material from around the cave. The crust is disrupted and truncated in places (Fig. 8.5a) indicating physical disruption during exposure or post-depositional bioturbation by soil micro- fauna which is suggested by the areas of granular microstructure. Fabric 2015:2 is a pale orange-brown silt loam with common quartz coarse silt and fine sand and rare limestone sand and gravel. It has a vughymicrostructure (10%porosity) and a stipple-speckled b-fabric. Occasional charred organic fragments, few flint flakes and rare shell and burnt bone are present. The Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 218 fine material is mixed with 50% ash aggregates containing calcitic wood ash pseudomorphs (Fig. 8.5b) and partially combusted/partially ashed cell structures (Canti 2003; Courty et al. 1989: 106) (Fig. 8.5c), There are a few crust fragments and well-rounded iron nodules. It has a prominent and diffuse lower boundary. 500μm d 2015:1 Fully ashedplant structure,PPL 2mm e 2015:1 Fining sequences/crusts,XPL 1mm c 2015:2 Partially ashed,partially carbonisedorganicmaterial,XPL 1mm c a 2015:3 Disruptedfining sequence and crust,PPL 250μm b 2015:2 Calcitic wood ash pseudomorphs,PPL Figure 8.5: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2015, Micro-fabrics 2015:3-1. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 219 The burnt inclusions and ashy nature of Micro-fabric 2015:2, coupled with its stipple-speckled b-fabric, indicate that it is a mixture of combustion material and geogenic sedimentation. The ash pseudomorphs and cell structures within the aggregates are well-preserved, indicating a lack of weathering or exposure prior to burial, yet fine horizontal lensing of ash at the edges of the large blocks fragments indicates limited weathering, potentially through punctuated wetting. Micro-fabric 2015:1 is a brown-orange silt loam with occasional quartz coarse sand and silt and limestone sand and gravel with a vughy to moderately-developed granular microstructure. It has a stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric (60:40). Common charcoal fragments are arranged in lenses and isolated fragments. There is also partially combusted organic material, and occasional fully ashed plant structures (Courty et al. 1989: 106) (Fig. 8.5d). Occasional burnt and unburnt bone, rare flint and a few well-rounded iron nodules and pedorelicts, and occasional crust fragments and rare dung lenses are also present. At the very top of the unit are a few isolated fining sequences (Fig. 8.5e). It has a distinct, clear lower boundary. The brown-orange colour of the fine material and its semi-stipple-speckled b-fabric indicate a geogenic origin for the micro-fabric. Inclusions of combustion material suggest the reworking of nearby anthropogenic sediments, and the crystallitic component of the b-fabric may derive from the calcitic ash which is also observed in larger aggregates. The sharp lower boundary of the unit and the lensing of material indicate punctuated deposition of wet colluvial movements of material. 8.2.2.2 Sample 2155 The microstratigraphy of Sample 2155 is outlined in Figure 8.6. Micro-fabric 2155:12 is a 5mm-thick pale brown silt loam with common limestone coarse sand. It has a well-developed granular microaggregate to subangular blocky/platy microstructure (Fig. 8.7a) with 20% porosity. The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic, and there are a few micritic calcitic coatings to the limestone fragments. There are also rare burnt bone fragments. Its lower boundary was not sampled. Due to the thinness of Micro-fabric 2155:12, interpretation and observation are difficult. It is unclear whether it represents Context 538, which underlies Feature 600, or if the sample has simply included a horizontal burrow. The loose and granular nature of the fabric is consistent with bioturbation and the latter, but the fine material is different to that of 2155:11 (see below) and could represent a well- bioturbated context underlying 2155:11. Micro-fabric 2155:11 is a brown sandy silt loam with frequent limestone gravel to coarse sand (Fig. 8.7b) and occasional quartz silt and fine sand. There is less limestone in the top 1-2cm of the unit. Its microstructure is massive to moderately-developed irregular granular (20% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic. There are rare fragments of charcoal, burnt bone, flint and shell. There are very rare concentric micritic calcitic nodules. It has a distinct, clear lower boundary. The fabric is dominated by frequent limestone fragments, with little orientation to indicate their Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 220 Figure 8.6: Slide scan and microstratigraphy of 2155 with interpretations. Masscolluvial deposition Ash Broken-up surface crust Mixed, dumped/spreadash and charredmaterial Sheetwash, crust Mixedash Weathered ash and silty clay andgrit Charred,redeposited material 2155:2 2155:1 2155:3 2155:4 2155:5 2155:6 2155:7 2155:8/9 2155:10 2155:11 2155:12Bioturbation Heavily degraded charred organic material Heavily degraded charred organic materialwith grit Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 221 deposition on ephemeral surfaces, yet the diffuse contact with the overlying micro-fabric does not indicate a single mass colluvial movement with a definite upper surface. Instead, the unit may have been deposited slowly through aeolian deposition and roof-spall and later stained by humic acids leaching from the overlying layers, as well as being disturbed through bioturbation. The origin of the Figure 8.7: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabrics 2155:12-8/9 2mm 500μm 250μm 1mm 1mm 1mm a b c d e f 2155:12 Granularmicrostructure,PPL 2155:11 Fabric showingfrequent limestoneclastsand calcitic nodule,XPL 2155:10 Humifiedplantmaterial,PPL 2155:10 Spongymicrostructureand degradedbone fragments,PPL 2155:8/9 Mixedashandsilt groundmass with carbonised organicmaterial 2155:8/9 Humifiedorpartially charred plant cell structure,OIL Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 222 calcitic nodules are unclear, yet thesemay have formed through the leaching of calcite-richwater from ash layers above, which has also dominated the micritic b-fabric. Micro-fabric 2155:10 is a brown silty clay loamwith occasional quartz silt and sand and few limestone sand and gravel clasts. It has a vughy to weakly-developed granular microstructure (15% porosity). There are few charcoal and rare burnt bone fragments, along with rare degraded bone fragments (Fig. 8.7c) and dung lenses. At the top of the unit, there are a few blocks of humified organic material (Fig. 8.7d). In places, the fabric has a spongy structure, although this is not well-developed. It has a distinct, diffuse lower boundary. Micro-fabric 2155:10 is equivalent to 2015:7. The colour fine material and features are similar, yet the spongy nature of the base of 2155:10 is better-developed than in 2015:7. The interpretations of these fabrics are therefore consistent with a weathered lower charcoal layer of a burning event, and an increase in blocky charcoal to the top of 2155:10 further strengthens this interpretation. Micro-fabric 2155:8/9 is an orange-grey silt loam with few quartz silt and fine sand and rare limestone sand and gravel clasts. It has a vughy to subangular blocky microstructure overlying a moderate/ weakly-developed microaggregate structure. It has a micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric containing rare humified plant structures (Fig. 8.7e), rare bone and very rare flint. There are few micritic calcitic void infillings, and rare iron nodules with diffuse boundaries. There is also frequent to dominant ash aggregates and carbonised material (Fig. 8.7f). The lower boundary is distinct and diffuse. The micro-fabric appears to consist largely of ash aggregates mixed with orange silt, potentially aeolian in origin. The granular microstructure of the micro-fabric may result from the large quantity of ash aggregates or from bioturbation which could have aided in the incorporation of silts into the micro-fabric. The diffuse lower boundary of themicro-fabric indicates that itmay have been deposited at the same time as Micro-fabric 2155:10, with both fabrics bioturbated andweathered together during a period of prolonged exposure, probably at least partially through wetting of the sediment as can be seen from the diffuse edges of the iron nodules which appear to be in situ. Micro-fabric 2155:7 is a 1-2cm thick calcitic micritic silt loam with rare quartz coarse silt and sand and few limestone sand and gravel clasts. It has a vughy to moderately-developed microaggregate microstructure (15%porosity) and a micritic calcitic crystallitic groundmass. There are a few stringers of charred organic material towards the top of the unit, and small charcoal fragments and bone (rare calcined), and rare, fully ashed, cell structures. The lower boundary is prominent and clear but mixed, with large blocks of both 2155:7 and 2155:8/9 encompassed by clayey silt infillings to planar voids (Fig. 8.8a). In the field, this layer was heavily indurated. The ashed cell structures, charcoal and wood ash pseudomorphs (Fig. 8.8b) indicate that this material is largely ash and burnt material. Calcined bone splinters indicate the presence of fragmented bone within the fire, perhaps produced through bone processing or weathering prior to combustion. The blocky mixing between Micro-fabrics 2155:7 and 2155:8/9 may indicate concretion of the material by water action, and subsequent trampling or other disruption. The clay coatings mark later translocation Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 223 of material through the micro-fabric. Micro-fabric 2155:6 is a 1mm-1cm thick lens of pale brown and grey mixed silt loam which does not cover the entire width of the slide. It contains few quartz silt and fine sand and occasional limestone coarse sand and gravel clasts, and has a vughy to weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure Figure 8.8: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Fabrics 2155:7-5 2mm a 2155:7 Disturbedfabric showingredsilty clay infillings andblockymixing,XPL 500μm b 2155:7 Calcitic wood ash pseudomorphs,PPL 1mm c 2155:6 Fully ashedplant cell structure,PPL 2mm d 2155:6and 7 Diffuse/mixedboundary between 2155:6and7,PPL 500μm e 2155:5 Weatheredbone,PPL 500μm f 2155:5 Crustwith layer ofcalcite,PPL Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 224 (15% porosity). It has a micritic calcitic crystallitic to stipple-speckled b-fabric (93:7) There are frequent fragments of blocky charcoal with cell structure and warped, horizontally-oriented charred stringers. There are rare, completely ashed, plant cell structures, as well as well-rounded iron nodules (Fig. 8.8c). Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. The micro-fabric is heterogenous, with ash, charcoal and soil material inclusions suggesting a mix of anthropogenic and geogenic sedimentation. Its diffuse lower boundary indicates mixing with 2155:6 (Fig. 8.8d). The disorganisation of the micro-fabric and its inclusions of unburnt clayey silt sediment suggest its re-deposition after combustion, perhaps through raking-out or cleaning. Micro-fabric 2155:5 is an orange-red silty clay loam, dominated by fining sequences of silty clay which form crusts. There is common quartz silt and sand and rare limestone sand. The structure is vughy to massive (2-15% porosity) with a mosaic to stipple-speckled groundmass (70:30). There are few fragments of blocky charcoal and very rare degraded, partially dissolved bone fragments (Fig. 8.8e). There is a micritic calcitic coating to the upper side of a crust at the top of the unit (Fig. 8.8f), fragmentation of these crusts and mixing with the overlying ash fabric. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. The fining sequence and silty nature of Micro-fabric 2155:5 indicate deposition through sheetwash, an event which washed silty clay material into planar voids in Micro-fabric 2155:7. The two crusts indicate two cycles of sheetwash followed by drying, cycles which may have created the partially- mosaic b-fabric, with calcite precipitation on the surface during this drying. The material is relatively clean of anthropogenic inclusions, indicating an origin from outside of the cave. Micro-fabric 2155:4 is a grey ash silt loamwith rare quartz coarse silt and fine sand and limestone fine sand to coarse gravel. It has a massive to moderately-developed microaggregate structure (10-40% porosity). There are few stringers of charred material, along with charred blockymaterial and partially carbonised/partially ashed cell structures (Fig. 8.9a). There are laminations in the fine material to the base of the unit (Fig. 8.9b), and common rounded clayey silt aggregates, one of which may be burnt. Its lower boundary is prominent and clear but mixed. The primarily ash component of the micro-fabric and its charred inclusions indicate that it is a mix of combustion material, probably re-deposited given the inclusion of burnt and unburnt clayey silt aggregates. The laminations at its base may show spreading of material on a surface prior to a dump of ash, yet ash material may also have been deposited through the raking-out of a nearby burning area. Micro-fabric 2155:3 is an orange-grey silt loam with occasional quartz silt and fine sand and limestone sand and gravel and a massive to vughy microstructure (10-25% porosity). It has a micritic calcitic crystallitic to stipple-speckled b-fabric (90:10).There are occasional blocks of charred organicmaterial, few burnt bone fragments and rare flint and rare dung (Fig. 8.9c). The top of the unit is marked by a fining sequence on one side of the slide, ~2-3mm thick (Fig. 8.9d). There are a few patches of dense micritic calcitic crystalline groundmass and common iron nodules/pedorelicts. Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 225 Figure 8.9: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabrics 2155:4-2 2mm b 2155:4 Laminations ofcharredmaterial in ash,XPL 1mm a 2155:4 Partially carbonised,partially ashedplant cell structure,PPL 250μm c 2155:3 Phytoliths in dungfragment,PPL 2mm d 2155:3 Fining sequence at topof2155:3 overlain by ashmaterial in2155:2,XPL 2mm f 2155:2 Potentially burnt inclusionsof silty clay aggregatesin ashfabric,PPL 1mm e 2155:2 Partially carbonised,Partially ashed wood cell structure,PPL Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 226 Figure 8.10: Microphotographs of features from Sample 2155, Micro-fabric 2155:1. The fining sequence and crust in 2155:3 indicate that it was deposited in an episode of sheetwash similar to 2015:4, which has reworked combustion material. Its fragmentation indicates disruption after drying, potentially through trampling. Micro-fabric 2155:2 is a grey micritic calcite silt loam with rare quartz sand. It has a granular microaggregate structure, and a micritic calcitic crystallitic b-fabric. There are a few charred and partially ashed plant cell structure fragments (Fig. 8.9e) and rare bone and flint. There are areas of more dense ash with wood ash pseudomorphs. There are rare pedorelicts and dung blocks at its base. The lower part of the fabric contains a lens of horizontal stringers of charred plant material and a concentration of blocky charcoal, with potentially burnt sediment aggregates (Fig. 8.9f). Its lower boundary is prominent and diffuse. The ash and charcoal inclusions in Micro-fabric 2155:2 indicate inclusion of combustion material, yet whilst the blocky charcoal stringers at the base of the unit may indicate in situ burning, fragments of unburnt dung indicating some degree of mixing or re-deposition, such as through hearth-maintenance activities. Micro-fabric 2155:1 is an orange-red brown clay loam/silty clay loam. It contains occasional quartz coarse silt and sand and common limestone sand and gravel which increases to the top of the unit, with a massive/vughy to weakly developed granular microaggregate structure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled although there it becomes slightly micritic calcitic crystallitic towards the lower boundary. There are few charcoal fragments and bone (both burnt and unburnt) and well-rounded iron nodules. There are also dung lenses and blocks as well as very rare fragments of vesicular silica (Fig. 8.10a).Its lower boundary is prominent, and clear but mixed (Fig. 8.10b). The clayey texture and reddish colour of the fine material indicate a potential influence of soil material in the micro-fabric, and the sharp but slightly interleaved lower boundary and fining sequences indicate deposition in a wet, potentially erosive series of colluvial movements. Deposition of the fabric may have occurred soon after the deposition of 2155:2 which contains well-preserved ash, yet it may also have eroded more weathered material from the top of the underlying micro-fabric. Incorporation of 2mm1mm 2155:1 Fragmentsof vesicularsilica,PPL ba 2155:1 Mixed lowerboundary of2155:1,PPL Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 227 combustion material indicates the reworking of anthropogenic sediments from within the cave in such a movement. 8.2.3 Discussion and Interpretation of Feature 600 The feature’s deposition began with Micro-fabrics 2155:10/2015:8, which show Context 570. The diffuse nature of the feature’s lower boundary in the field indicates a lack of preparation of a ‘hearth’ area, but instead that material was burnt on an unprepared surface. The feature’s bowl shape could indicate usage of an existing hollow, or the scooping of relatively unconsolidated, dry material out to form such a hollow. The dark brown colour of Context 570 appears to result from fine silt-sized organic material. This material potentially results from the hyperfragmentation of charcoal from a burning event degrading under alkaline conditions, such as may exist in a karstic environment with nearby ash (Braadbaart et al. 2009). Although the spongy structure of the micro-fabrics may indicate that the dark colour of the groundmass was due to the decomposition of a significant quantity of unburnt organic material and dung staining the groundmass (Polo Díaz and Fernández Eraso 2010), the restricted nature of the feature renders the explanation of the layer as being deposited by animals unlikely. This degraded charcoal layer is overlain by a potential degraded ash layer as shown in Micro-fabric 2155:8/9, which is the only part of the feature to extend nearly as far as Context 570 (see Fig. 8.2). It contains large amounts of ash mixed with orange silt, and its granular structure indicates extended exposure and bioturbation of potentially aiding the incorporating of orange aeolian silt. Micro-fabrics 2155:10 and 8/9 therefore indicate an initial, single burning event in the area, given its relatively simple stratigraphy. This material was then left exposed in a relatively slow, mainly dry depositional environment which may have included sporadic wetting of the sediments to aid in the breakdown of the organic material and weathering of the bone fragments. After this considerable period of exposure, the ashy Micro-fabrics 2155:7 and 2155:6 are probably the result of a dump or sweeping of ash from a nearby fire. The temporal relationship of this dumping to the colluvial reworking of material in 2015:5 is unclear. However, both are covered by sheetwash in Micro-fabrics 2155:5/2015:4 which may have transported soil material into the cave, probably following the abandonment of the hearth area following this second dump given the potential concretion and weathering of the re-deposited ash in 2155:7. The ash in Micro-fabric 2155:4 is not traceable to the edge of the feature in 2015, and appears to be another localised dumping of ash material similar to that in 2155:6 and 7. This is again overlain by a sheetwash event in Micro-fabric 2155:3, potentially correlated with 2015:3. This time the wash event reworked unconsolidated occupation from burning events nearby, indicating that it may have taken a different trajectory across the cave floor to that in 2155:5/2015:4, which is more ‘clean’ and was potentially passing over consolidated occupation material. The final deposition of ash in the feature occurred in Micro-fabric 2155:2. This is probably another dump of ash material due to its mixture of ash, burnt and unburnt sediment. Fragments of this material Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 228 have potentially been reworked in blocks in 2015:2 during the series of wet, colluvial events which deposited Context (563), as observed in Micro-fabrics 2015:1 and 2155:1 through the fining sequences and crust fragments. Feature 600 therefore consists of a series of burning events separated initially by an extended period of exposure of the initial burn on a surface in a sporadically wet, but mainly dry, environment. The area was then used as an ash dump during possiblemaintenance activities of burning areas nearby in at least two phases. Phases of use were separated by periods of abandonment of the feature during which sheetwash of external soil material covered the feature, before a prolonged period of wet, colluvial movements covered the entire feature, potentially obliterating any traces of the feature on the surface. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 229 M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on 20 15 :1 20 m m B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) si lt lo am ,o cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,o cc . li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .2 0% po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs /c pv .V ug hy to m od .d ev el op ed gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F R at io 17 :8 3. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry C om m .c ha rc oa la nd pa rt ia ll y ca rb on is ed m at er ia l. O cc . as h ag gr eg at es an d si li ci fie d st ru ct ur es ,u nb ur nt an d bu rn tb on e. R ar e fli nt an d fe w re de po si te d ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. O cc .c ru st fr ag m en ts ,r ar e du ng le ns es . F in in g se qu en ce at to p of un it . M ix ed oc cu pa ti on m at er ia li n m as s co ll uv ia lm ov em en ts ,i nc or po ra ti ng m at er ia lf ro m el se w he re in th e ca ve w it h lo ca ll y re w or ke d m at er ia l. 20 15 :2 5m m P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h co m m .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d ra re li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .1 0% po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s, vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. S ti pp le sp ec kl ed b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: (2 0: 80 ). P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .c ha rr ed or ga ni cs ,f ew fli nt ,r ar e sh el la nd bu rn tb on e. 50 % w oo d as h, fe w cr us tf ra gm en ts an d pe do re li ct s/ re de po si te d ir on no du le s. C ol lu vi al m ix in g of m at er ia l in co rp or at in g as h fr om ne ar by bu rn in g, po te nt ia ll y w et at po in ts . 20 15 :3 3- 4m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h co m m .q ua rt z an d ra re m ed iu m to co ar se li m es to ne sa nd .V ug hy -w ea kl y/ m od er at e de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs ,c ha m be rs co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 16 :8 4. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry R ar e ch ar re d or ga ni c ‘s tr in ge rs ’, si ng le ‘t w ig ’c ro ss se ct io n. O cc .fi ne sa nd an d si lt -s iz ed ch ar re d fr ag m en ts . F ew ch ar co al bl oc ks .C ru st in g to w ar ds to p of un it .F ew cr us tf ra gm en ts . S he et w as h of lo ca ll y- de ri ve d, fin e an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia l, pu dd li ng an d cr us ti ng ,f ol lo w ed by pe ri od of ex po su re an d di sr up ti on . 20 15 :4 8m m R ed (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h fr eq .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd . M od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e m ic ro st ru ct ur e at ba se to m as si ve /v es ic ul ar st ru ct ur e at to p. 15 -0 % po ro si ty ,c pv ,p la na r vo id s an d vu gh s. M os ai c to cr os s- st ri at ed (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 10 :9 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry R ar e bl oc ky ch ar co al ,r ar e bu rn tb on e. C ru st in g/ fin in g se qu en ce s, ra re m ic ri ti c le ns es on fin in g se qu en ce su rf ac es an d de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s in to pm os t cr us t. R ep ea te d sh ee tw as h of so il m at er ia l. 20 15 :5 3m m R ed -b ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz an d fr eq .l im es to ne gr av el an d sa nd .V ug hy /m as si ve to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e m ic ro st ru ct ur e. S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry O cc .b lo ck y ch ar re d or ga ni cs ,s om e in ‘s tr in ge rs ’a nd oc ca si on al bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e. C on ce nt ra ti on of fin e, cl ay ey m at er ia la tt he ba se of th e un it .O cc .s m oo th ir on no du le s. R ar e m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . S m al l- sc al e co ll uv ia lm ov em en t of m at er ia la nd m ix in g of ne ar by an th ro po ge ni c an d bu rn tm at er ia l. 20 15 :6 3- 4m m P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h fe w qu ar tz co ar se sa nd an d si lt an d li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .2 0% po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s, vu gh y to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g m ic ro ag gr e- ga te st ru ct ur e. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri tc cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 10 :9 0. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .c ha rr ed or ga ni c m at er ia l, si lt -s iz ed to st ri ng er s. M or e po or ly so rt ed to ri gh th an d si de of fa br ic .S li gh t la m in at io ns in fin e m at er ia l. F ew ir on /s il tn od ul es . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed ,d efl at ed up pe r la ye r of bu rn in g ev en t. 20 15 :7 65 -7 5m m P al e m ed iu m br ow n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am w it h oc c. qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd ,r ar e li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .T op 2. 5c m V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e, lo w er 4- 5c m vu gh y to sp on gy m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs .S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to re ti cu la te /g ra no st ri at ed (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm ,C F R at io :1 2: 88 .N o lo w er bo un da ry . S om e la m in at io ns in fie m at er ia l. R ar e st ra w -l ik e m in er al ,l in ke d to he av il y de gr ad ed ,p ar ti al ly di ss ol ve d bo ne fr ag m en ts .R ar e ir on no du le s. O cc .d un g le ns es . F ib ro us ,s em i- ch ar re d an d hu m ifi ed st ri ng er s in to p 1- 2c m of un it . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed ch ar co al la ye r at ba se of bu rn in g ev en t. Ta bl e 8. 1: Su m m ar y ta bl e of F 60 0 m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul l de sc ri pt io ns in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al , fr eq . - fr eq ue nt , co m m .- co m m on . Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 230 M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :1 55 m m O ra ng e- re d br ow n (P P L ) cl ay lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am .O cc as io na lq ua rt z co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d co m m on li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve /v ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le sp ec kl ed b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F R at io 25 :7 5. P ro m in en t, cl ea r bu ts li gh tl y m ix ed lo w er bo un da ry . P la ty m ic ro st ru ct ur e to p 1- 2c m .F ew ch ar co al fr ag m en ts ,b ur nt an d un bu rn tb on e an d ra re fli nt . L im es to ne in cr ea se s in si ze an d fr eq ue nc y to to p. In cr ea se in cr ys ta ll in e b- fa br ic to w ar ds lo w er bo un da ry . O cc as io na li ro n no du le s, w el lr ou nd ed ,r ar el y di ff us e. R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d cr us tf ra gm en ts . D un g le ns es an d bl oc ks .R ar e ve si cu la r si li ca ag gr eg at es . P un ct ua te d, w et co ll uv ia lm ov em en ts of m at er ia l. 21 55 :2 5- 15 m m G re y as h si lt lo am w it h ra re qu ar tz sa nd .G ra nu la r m ic ro st ru ct ur e, 20 % po ro si ty w it h co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, pl an ar vo id s an d ch am be rs an d vu gh s. M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic .C F li m it :1 00 μm .C F ra ti o: 2: 98 . P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . F ew ch ar re d an d pa rt ia ll y as he d pl an tc el ls tr uc tu re fr ag m en ts .R ar e bo ne an d fli nt .A re as of m or e de ns e as h. R ar e M n de nd ri ti c no du le s an d F e w el l- ro un de d no du le s/ pe do re li ct s. O cc .s il ty cl ay ag gr eg at es .R ar e bl oc ky du ng at ba se . R e- de po si te d as h, po te nt ia ll y as he ar th cl ea ni ng . 21 55 :3 5- 15 m m O ra ng e- gr ey (P P L ) si lt lo am w it h oc ca si on al qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el w it h m as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 -2 5% po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs an d pl an ar vo id s. M ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic /s ti pp le sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .b lo ck s of ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia l, fe w bu rn t bo ne fr ag m en ts ,a nd ra re fli nt .U ni ta rr an ge d in fin in g se qu en ce .F ew pa tc he s of cr ys ta ll in e gr ou nd m as s. C om m on ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s an d co m m on as h bl oc ks an d is ol at ed si ng le ca lc it ic w oo d as h ps eu do m or ph s in gr ou nd m as s, ra re du ng bl oc ks . S he et w as h ev en to f m at er ia l in co rp or at in g lo ca ll y de ri ve d an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia l. 21 55 :4 10 -1 5m m G re y si lt as h lo am w it h ra re qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,a nd li m es to ne fin e sa nd to co ar se gr av el .M as si ve to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, w it h 10 -4 0% po ro si ty pl an ar vo id s. M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 4: 96 .P ro m in en ta nd cl ea r bu tm ix ed lo w er bo un da ry . F ew st ri ng er s of ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia l. F ew fr ag m en ts of ch ar re d m at er ia lw it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, an d fe w pa rt ia ll y as he d an d ch ar re d m at er ia lw it h ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e bo ne .L am in at io ns to ba se of un it , co m m on ro un de d cl ay fr ag m en ts .R ar e ir on no du le s. M ix in g an d sp re ad in g of as h on a dr y su rf ac e. 21 55 :5 3- 5m m O ra ng e- re d (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .C om m on qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d ra re li m es to ne sa nd .V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e in fin in g se qu en ce , 2- 15 % po ro si ty w it h pl an ar vo id s, vu gh s an d ve ge ta lv oi ds .M os ai c to st ip pl e sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :6 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. P ro m in en ta nd cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . F ew fr ag m en ts of bl oc ky ch ar co al .F in in g se qu en ce de fin es un it .M ic ri ti c co at in g to cr us ta tt op of un it . S om e m ix in g w it h as h fa br ic fr om ab ov e de po si ti ng in vo id s. S he et w as h of ex te rn al so il m at er ia l. 21 55 :6 1- 10 m m P al e br ow n m ix ed w it h gr ey si lt lo am (P P L ). F ew qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,a nd oc ca si on al li m es to ne co ar se sa nd an d fin e gr av el .V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty ,c ha m be rs an d vu gh s an d pl an ar vo id s. M ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (9 3: 7) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o (1 2: 98 ). P ro m in en t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . F re qu en tb lo ck y ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e. R ar e ca lc ifi ed ce ll st ru ct ur e. A sh in gr ou nd m as s. V er y ra re ve si cu la r si li ca .R ar e w el l- ro un de d F e no du le s. H ea rt h ra ke ou t/ cl ea ni ng m at er ia l. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 231 M ic ro -f ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -f ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :7 10 -2 0m m G re y (P P L ) as h si lt lo am .R ar e qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 15 % po ro si ty w it h vu gh s, cp v an d pl an ar vo id s. M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic .C F li m it 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .P ro m im en ta nd cl ea r bu tm ix ed lo w er bo un da ry . F ew ch ar re d st ri ng er s of or ga ni c m at er ia lt o to p of un it ,a nd fe w sm al lc ha rc oa lf ra gm en ts an d bo ne (r ar e ca lc in ed ). A sh ed ce ll st ru ct ur es .M ix ed at ba se w it h 21 55 :8 /9 .C la ye y si lt in fil li ng s to vo id s on ri gh th an d si de .F ew fr ag m en ts of si li ca gl as s, oc c. w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s. R ar e du ng ,w el lr ou nd ed . A sh du m p. P os t- de po si ti on al ly ce m en te d an d di sr up te d. 21 55 :8 /9 25 -3 0m m O ra ng e- gr ey (P P L ) si lt lo am .F ew qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd an d ra re li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy /m as si ve w it h m od er at el y- w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 10 -2 0% po ro si ty vu gh s, cp v an d pl an ar vo id s. M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic .C F li m it :8 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .D is ti nc t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e hu m ifi ed pl an ts tr uc tu re s ir re gu la r/ bl oc ky .R ar e bo ne ,v er y ra re fli nt .F ew ca lc it ic in fil li ng s to vo id s. R ar e di ff us e ir on no du le s, de nd ri ti c m an ag an es e no du le s an d w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s. W el l- m ix ed as h an d si lt ,h ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d an d w ea th er ed . 21 55 :1 0 25 -3 5m m B ro w n (P P L ) si lt y cl ay lo am .O cc .q ua rt z si lt an d sa nd an d fe w li m es to ne gr av el an d fin e sa nd .V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, sp on gi er to ba se . 15 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs ,p la na r vo id s. S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed B -f ab ri c. C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 12 :8 8. D is ti nc t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . F ew ch ar co al fr ag m en ts .F ew hu m ifi ed fr ag m en ts at up pe r bo un da ry .R ar e bu rn tb on e. F ew ir on no du le s, R ar e he av il y de gr ad ed /p ar ti al ly di ss ol ve d bo ne fr ag m en ts ,a nd fe w du ng le ns es w it hi n di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry .‘ F ib ro us ’n at ur e to ar ea s of th e gr ou nd m as s. V er y he av il y w ea th er ed ch ar co al la ye r at ba se of bu rn in g ev en t. F ab ri c 21 55 :1 1 40 m m B ro w n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am w it h fr eq ue nt li m es to ne fin e gr av el to co ar se sa nd an d oc ca si on al qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd .M as si ve -m od er at el y de ve lo pe d ir re gu la r gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ,p la na r vo id s, ch am be rs an d vu gh s an d cp v. M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 47 :5 3. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ch ar co al fr ag m en ts ,b ur nt bo ne ,fl in ta nd sh el l. L es s gr it in to p 1- 2c m .P la ty st ru ct ur e to la st 5m m .F ew ir on no du le s an d ra re m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. P er io d of ro of -s pa ll in g fo ll ow ed by bi ot ur ba ti on an d m ix in g w it h 21 55 :1 0. F ab ri c 21 55 :1 2 5m m P al e br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m on li m es to ne sa nd an d fe w qu ar tz si lt an d fin e sa nd .W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky /p la ty m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ,c pv ,v ug hs .M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic . C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bo ne .F ew ca lc it ic co at in gs to li m es to ne fr ag m en ts . O cc .i ro n st ai ni ng .R ar e m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. H ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d an d ca lc it e im pr eg na te d. P ot en ti al ly 21 55 :1 1 re w or ke d or a se pa ra te co nt ex t. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 232 8.3 513/535 Burn Event 8.3.1 Field Description The burning event shown in Contexts 513 and 535 stretches across the entirety of the North-Facing Profile, sloping downwards to the East (Fig. 8.11). Context 513 can be traced onto the West-Facing Profile, yet its appearance shifts from a series of orange and white layers in the centre of the North- Facing Profile to a mixed pale grey silty on the West-Facing (See Chapter Six). 8.3.2 Soil Micromorphology Sample 1052 was removed from the contexts at the 2008 Western limit of exposure of the North- Facing Profile where the stratigraphy appeared most coherent and undisturbed (Fig. 8.11). Its microstratigraphy is outlined in Figure 8.12. Micro-fabric 1052:8 contains Context 535. At its base it is a red-brown silt loam, grading upwards to dark brown, and then grey-brown (Fig. 8.13a). There is occasional limestone fine sand and gravel with a slight horizontal orientation. It has a massive to vughy microstructure (10% porosity). There are rare blocks of charred organics, as well as shell and bone (some of which is burnt). There are a few pedorelicts as well as degraded, partially dissolved bone fragments (Fig. 8.13b) and occasional dung lenses. The lower boundary was not sampled. Figure 8.11: 513/535 burning event on North Facing Profile. Scale is 1m. Photo G. Barker. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 233 1052:2 1052:31052:4 1052:5 1052:6 1052:7 1052:8 1cm 1052:1 Bioturbation 1052:5 (disturbed) Heavily- weathered burning event Reworked combustion material Second burning event? Further reworking ofmaterial and subsequent bioturbation The diffuse shifts in colour within the micro-fabric indicate that the changes may result from in situ alteration of the material through weathering or leaching rather than through three different sources. The dark brown and grey-brown material towards the top of the micro-fabric is similar to the sequence observed in 2155:10/2015:7 (see section 8.2.2), with degraded, partially dissolved bone fragments and dung material present with rare charred blocky organic material towards the top of the unit, thus potentially representing an in situ, but heavily-weathered, burnt event. The reddish underlying sediment may be slightly rubefied, but it may also simply show an orange-red silt substrate for this burning event. A lack of a sharp lower boundary indicates a lack of preparation of the surface prior to this burning, which was then exposed for an extended period. Micro-fabric 1052:7 has a diffuse lower boundary with 1052:8. It is a pale brown-grey (PPL) silt loam with rare medium limestone sand and a vughy to weakly-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). It has an undifferentiated to stipple-speckled b-fabric (90:10). There are occasional fibrous charred fragments of organic material concentrated to the top of the unit (Fig. 8.13c) and rare bone fragments. There are rare very degraded, partially dissolved bone fragments and dung lenses. Its lower boundary is distinct and diffuse. The diffuse nature of the lower boundary of 1052:7 indicates that it may have been deposited along with 1052:8 as part of the same burning event. Its grey colour suggests an ashy component to the groundmass, although there is a lack of micritic calcitic groundmass to verify this. The material may therefore simply represent weathered organic material from which humic acids have been leached, or ash material deflated, with the charred fragments of organic material towards the top of the unit Figure 8.12: Slide scan and microstratigraphy of 1052 with interpretations. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 234 1052:7 Charredorganics,PPL 1mm 1052:7-8Boundary, PPL 2mm b 1052:7-5overview XPL 2mm d 1052:6phytoliths in groundmass,PPL 250μm e 1052:8Degraded, partially-dissolvedbone,PPL 250μm a c 1052:6Calcitic hypocoatings/infillings.XPL 250μm f 1052:5Calcitic ash pseudomorphs,PPL 250μm g 1052:5Sparitic coating to limestone,XPL 250μm h Figure 8.13: Microphotographs of features from Sample 1052, Fabrics 1052:8-5. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 235 potentially the only remnants of the top of the burning event which also included 1052:8. Micro-fabric 1052:6 is a very pale brown-orange (PPL) silt loam with rare limestone medium sand and a massive microstructure (7% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic to undifferentiated (60:40). There are occasional micritic calcitic hypocoatings and some complete infillings to voids (Fig. 8.13d & e). There are few iron nodules and pedorelicts, as well as frequent lenses of phytoliths and occasional dung fragments. Throughout the groundmass there are frequent phytoliths (Fig. 8.13f). Its lower boundary is distinct and diffuse. The micritic b-fabric probably derives from ash; the phytoliths lenses which are frequent in the fabric probably result from the in situ combustion of material. The presence of micritic hypocoatings and infillings indicated dissolution and re-precipitation of the ash material through percolating water, which may have contributed to the limited leaching of humic acids through the underlying layers Micro-fabric 1052:6 is therefore the uppermost layer of the in situ burning which deposited micro- fabrics 1052:8-6, and which was later heavily weathered through bioturbation as well as wetting. Micro-fabric 1052:5 is an orange-grey silt loam with occasional limestone gravel and a vughy to massive microstructure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic to undifferentiated (80:20). There are rare ashed plant cell structures and calcitic wood ash pseudomorphs in the groundmass as well as ash aggregates (Fig. 8.13g). The material is finer to the base, where it contains lenses of phytoliths. There is a large, subrounded fragment of reddened soil material, rare vesicular silica aggregates, and few pedorelicts. There is a prominent, black-grey sparitic calcitic coating to the largest limestone fragment, up to 2-3mm thick (Fig. 8.13h). There is a large (2-3cm across), separate aggregate of material identical to the micro-fabric at the left hand side of the slide. Its lower boundary is distinct and diffuse. The heavily-micritic b-fabric of the material, as well as inclusions of ashed plant structure and ash pseudomorphs, indicate that this material is primarily ash, yet its orangey colour may be a result of aeolian silt incorporation within the material, potentially through bioturbation or colluvial reworking of thematerial in a dry environment, which also incorporated the pedorelicts and reddened soil material fragments. The large aggregate of material to the edge of the slide also indicates reworking of this material. The interleaved nature of the lower boundary indicates that material may have been blown or spread on a surface. The process which formed the limestone coating is unclear, as although it may have formed in situ through the percolation of calcite-rich water produced through ash diagenesis, the outer boundary of the coating is sharp, and it is the only limestone fragment to be coated in this way, thus indicating that the coating formed prior to the fragment’s deposition. The micro-fabric therefore appears to contain heavily weathered and bioturbated ash material, reworked from the underlying burning event. Micro-fabric 1052:4 is a grey-orange silt loam with occasional quartz. The microstructure is vughy to spongy (25% porosity), and the b-fabric micritic calcitic crystallitic. The entire fabric is stained brown-red (Fig. 8.14a), and its base is mixed with 1052:5 with an otherwise prominent, clear lower Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 236 boundary. Interpretation of this micro-fabric is unclear. Its structure and micritic b-fabric are consistent with ash and ashed plant structures yet its reddish-brown, uniform potentially staining is markedly different from any of the other micro-fabrics, with little evidence of iron-staining below. Alternatively, it may result from partial ashing of porous plant material, with the reddish brown ‘staining’ actually coming from remaining organic material in the fabric. All that can be said is that this micro-fabric illustrates further complex diagenetic process acting on the sediments following the initial burning event. 1052:4Red-brown stained ʻash ,ʼPPL 1052:3Ashed plant structureand ash,PPL 1052:3Fragmentof vesicular silica,PPL F1pedorelicts 1052:1-2Boundary with claycoating,PPL 1052:2-1Boundary, ashfragment,PPL 250μm 1mm 250μm 2mm 2mm ba c f d 1mm1052:1Potential pedorelicts, PPL e Figure 8.14: Microphotographs of features from Sample 1052, Micro-fabrics 1052:4-1. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 237 Micro-fabric 1052:3 is a grey micritic calcitic silt loam with occasional quartz silt and fine sand and frequent phytoliths in the groundmass. It has a vughy to granular microaggregate microstructure (15% porosity), resembling the defined by plant/ash structure. The b-fabric is micritic calcitic crystallitic to undifferentiated (50:50). There are common, fully ashed plant cell structures (Fig. 8.14b). There are rare pale dung fragments, and a few aggregates of vesicular silica (Fig. 8.14c). Its lower boundary is prominent and clear. The structure and micritic b-fabric of 1052:3 are similar to that of 1052:4, and potentially represent a fully-ashed or unaltered facies of the same material. The preservation of plant structures within Micro-fabrics 1052:3 and 4 indicates a lack of bioturbation, in contrast to 1052:5 which underlies both micro-fabrics, and may be ash material from a second burning event, although its interpretation remains unclear. Micro-fabric 1052:2 is an orange-brown silt loam with common limestone fine sand and gravel. It has a vughy to massive microstructure (10% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There are occasional ash aggregates (Fig. 8.14d), with some brown staining. There are rare bone and flint, and an orange clay coating to a long planar void. There are occasional vesicular silica aggregates and pedorelicts and a lens of horizontally-oriented phytoliths lies just above the boundary. Its lower boundary is distinct and clear. The chaotic orientation of the coarse material indicates the deposition of this material in a (or series of) dry colluvial movement (s), as well as subsequent bioturbation. The feathered nature of the edges of the ash fragments indicates that they have been slightly weathered potentially through sporadic wetting of the exposed material during the unit’s deposition, and the incorporation of a range of combustion products indicates the continued reworking of underlying ashy layers. 1052:1 is an orange-brown sandy silt loam with common limestone gravel and fine sand. It has a vughy to moderately-developed granular microaggregate structure (20% porosity). The b-fabric is stipple-speckled to micritic calcitic crystallitic (80:20). There is rare blocky charred organic material and bone. There is an orange clay coating to a long planar void at the base of the unit which continues into 1052:2. There are occasional well-rounded dense red clayey aggregates (Fig. 8.14e), which may be pedorelicts, iron nodules or burnt sediment aggregates, although their exact nature is unclear, as well as vesicular silica aggregates. Its lower boundary is faint but clear (Fig. 8.14f). The granular nature of Micro-fabric 1052:1 indicates significant bioturbation potentially linked to that in 1052:2, and continuity of the fine material between the two micro-fabricsmay indicate that its lower boundary is simply a boundary of bioturbation.Alternatively, the sharp lower boundary may also mark an erosional lower edge of a mass colluvial movement which was later bioturbated. As with 1052:2, the arrangement of the components within the fabric is chaotic, and its interpretation is unclear, but represents continued reworking of the ashy sediments. explain pedorelicts etc. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 238 8.3.3 Discussion and Interpretation of Contexts 513 and 535 Overall, the featuremade up byContexts 513 and 535 appears to be largely the result of a single burning event represented by Fabrics 1052:8-6 (although the edge of another may be traced in 1052:4 and 3), which has become heavily degraded during a period of extended exposure and probably influenced by wetting of the sediment (consistent with that observed on the West-Facing Profile for Context 513, see Chapter Six, Section 6.4.2.3). The charred material from these layers has been heavily bioturbated and fragmented, to the point of only existing as humic staining to the groundmass except in isolated circumstances. The ashy layers at the top of the burn, e.g. 1052:6, have been affected by significant and complex diagenesis and recrystallisation of the ash material, probably through sporadic water action following reworking and deflation in dry conditions. The fuel used appears to have been mainly grasses andwood, given the abundance of phytoliths and vesicular silica aggregates and the presence of calcitic rhombohedral pseudomorphs. Micro-fabrics 1052:5-1 appear to show the continued reworking of combustion material, primarily ash, from this burning event, although the ash in 1052:3 and 4 may represent the edges of a second, nearby, burning event. This reworking took place in a mainly dry, but also sporadically damp, period of exposure and the digenetic pathways which produced the staining of 1052:4 remain unclear. Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 239 M ic ro -F ab ri c F ab ri c an d St ru ct ur e F ea tu re s an d In cl us io ns M ic ro -F ab ri c In te rp re ta ti on 10 52 :1 O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) sa nd y si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd , co m m .l im es to ne gr av el an d fin e sa nd .V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. F ai nt ,s ha rp lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ky ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia la nd bo ne .O ra ng e cl ay co at in g to lo ng pl an ar vo id at ba se of un it .O cc .p ed or el ic ts /i ro n no du le s/ bu rn ta gg re ga te s. R ar e di ff us e ir on no du le s. R ar e du ng le ns es an d ve si cu la r pl an ts il ic a fr ag m en ts . D ry co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng of co m bu st io n m at er ia l an d ae ol ia n se di m en ta ti on . B io tu rb at ed . 10 52 :2 O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd , co m m .l im es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty :v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 22 :7 8. D is ti nc t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . L ar ge bl oc k of as h, ir on im pr eg na te d in pl ac es an d oc c. as h ch un ks . R ar e bo ne an d fli nt .O ra ng e cl ay co at in g to lo ng pl an ar vo id .F ew de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. O cc .v es ic ul ar pl an ts il ic a. L en s of ph yt ol it hs ju st ab ov e bo un da ry .O cc .p ed or el ic ts . D ry co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng of co m bu st io n m at er ia la nd ae ol ia n se di m en ta ti on . 10 52 :3 G re y (P P L ) as h si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt s co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd .V ug hy to m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e de fin ed by as h/ pl an ts tr uc tu re .1 5% po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. C ry st al li ti c to un di ff er en ti at ed (5 0: 50 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 10 :9 0. P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry . C om m .c al ci fie d pl an tm at er ia l. F ew m an ga ne se no du le s. R ar e al e si lt y br ow n sp on gy m at er ia l. F ew fr ag m en ts of ve si cu la r pl an ts il ic a. W oo d as h 10 52 :4 G re y- or an ge (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc qu ar tz .V ug hy to sp on gy m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 25 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs .C ry st al li ti c B -f ab ri c, C F li m it :5 0μ m ,C F ra ti o: 7: 93 . P ro m in en t, cl ea r lo w er bo un da ry D eg ra de d li m es to ne .S ta in in g of sp on gy ar ea s. Ir on no du le s, oc c. w el l- ro un de d. M ix in g to w ar ds ba se . Ir on -s ta in ed as h, po te nt ia ll y w et te d. 10 52 :5 O ra ng e- gr ey (P P L ) si lt lo am .C om m .q ua rt z si lt an d fin e sa nd an d oc c. li m es to ne gr av el .V ug hy to m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs . M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed (8 0: 20 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5 D is ti nc t, di ff us ed lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e ca lc it ic pl an tr em ai ns .A sh in gr ou nd m as s. F in er in te xt ur e to ba se ,i nt er le av ed w it h ph yt ol it hs le ns es .C oa ti ng to li m es to ne .O cc . de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. F ra gm en to f re dd en ed so il m at er ia l. R ar e in ci pi en tv es ic ul ar si li ca ag gr eg at e. F ew pe do re li ct s. H ea vi ly w ea th er ed an d bi ot ur ba te d as h m at er ia l. 10 52 :6 V er y pa le br ow n- or an ge (P P L ) si lt lo am .F ew qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd . R ar e li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd .M as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 7% po ro si ty ,v ug hs . C ry st al li ti c to un di ff er en ti at ed (6 0: 40 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :8 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .D is ti nc t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .c al ci ti c hy po co at in gs an d co m pl et e in fil li ng s to la rg er vu gh s. O cc .m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s co nc en tr at ed to th e ba se of th e un it .F ew ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s. F re qu en tp hy to li th s le ns es 3c m lo ng ,a rt ic ul at ed ce ll st ru ct ur es in pl ac es .O cc .d un g S il ic ac eo us re si du e fr om ve ry he av il y w ea th er ed as h. 10 52 :7 P al e br ow n- gr ey (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd an d ra re li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd .V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. 20 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d ch am be rs an d pl an ar vo id s. U nd if fe re nt ia te d to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ) b- fa br ic .C F li m it :5 0μ m . C F ra ti o: 12 :8 8. D is ti nc t, di ff us e lo w er bo un da ry . O cc .fi br ou s ch ar re d fr ag m en ts of or ga ni c m at er ia lc on ce nt ra te d to to p of un it .R ar e bo ne .F ew ir on no du le s, ra re ph os ph at ic in fil li ng s to vu gh s/ de gr ad ed bo ne ,r ar e du ng le ns es . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed as h an d bu rn in g m at er ia l. 10 52 :8 B ro w n to re d- br ow n (P P L ) si lt lo am .O cc .q ua rt z co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd , oc c. li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el .M as si ve to vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. 10 % po ro si ty ,v ug hs an d pl an ar vo id s. C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 14 :8 6. N o lo w er bo un da ry . R ar e bl oc ks of ch ar re d or ga ni cs ,s he ll an d bo ne (u nb ur nt an d v. ra re bu rn t) .O cc m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. F ew pe do re li ct s an d he av il y de gr ad ed /p ar ti al ly di ss ol ve d ph os ph at ic in fil li ng s. O cc du ng le ns es an d ch un ks .O ve ra ll sh if ti n co lo ur fr om ba se of un it (r ed ) to to p, th ro ug h br ow n to gr ey er . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed lo w er pa rt of bu rn in g ev en to n un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. nd un de rl yi ng m at er ia l. Ta bl e 8. 2: Su m m ar y ta bl e of C on te xt 31 5/ 53 5 m ic ro m or ph ol og ic al de sc ri pt io ns an d in te rp re ta ti on s. F ul ld es cr ip ti on s in A pp en di x F iv e. O cc .- oc ca si on al ,f re q. - fr eq ue nt ,c om m .- co m m on . Chapter Eight: The Microstratigraphy of the MSA Burning Features 240 8.4 MSAHearth Features in the Haua Fteah The two features analysed in this chapter, the most prominent burnt features in the MSA sediments, show some distinct similarities. Both burning events took place on unconsolidated, unprepared surfaces, although Feature 600 may have been preceded by the scooping out of a shallow hollow, or merely placed in an existing hollow in the cave (Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998). Both features began as single burning events which then underwent periods of prolonged diagenesis, including bioturbation, hyperfragmentation of charcoal, dissolution and degradation of bone fragments and reformation of their constituent minerals, as well as the dissolution and recrystallisation of ash, indicating exposure in sporadically damp environments given a general lack of truncation of these initial burning events by wet colluvial processes. The presence of calcitic ash pseudomorphs in both features, especially in Feature 600, indicates that wood was the primary fuel utilised at the Haua Fteah, indicating its availability in the area during periods of occupation. The vesicular silica aggregates in both features potentially result from a silica- rich fuel within these combustion features, such as grass (Canti 2003). In other rockshelters, the presence of combusted grass has been attributed to the combustion of bedding material (Goldberg et al. 2009), and whilst Context 535/513 and its abundant phytolith lenses cover an area large enough to render this explanation a possibility, it is an unlikely explanation in Feature 600 given its limited area. McBurney’s excavations did, however, recover a number of large fragments of ‘slag’ material from these levels which may have resulted from the burning of large quantities of grassy material, although the purpose of such material must remain speculative given the absence of contextual information and the potential for grass to be used as kindling for wood fires (Albert et al. 2003), as is probable from the features investigated in this chapter. There are some differences between the two features. Feature 600 shows repeated use of the same area for the dumping of ash from nearby burning events, dumping of material which is interrupted by periods of sheetwash in the cave, whilst Context 535 and 513 appear to largely be the result of one or two burning events reworked in environments which, although damp at points, were not subject to the same influence of inwash events. Feature 600 is also relatively restricted in area, and may show the repeated reuse of a small area as a maintained hearth, although assessment of the relative sizes of the features remains speculative given the absence of plans documenting their extents. The MSA burning events in the Haua Fteah therefore exhibit the impact of complex diagenetic processes which cannot be fully resolved through the existing micromorphological observations alone. Human activity appears to have taken place in both dry, sporadically damp, cave environments, as well as prior to, but not necessarily during, periods when there was increased soil inwash into the cave. The repeated use of Feature 600 between these inwash periods indicates a repeated return to the same area by groups. The environmental context of these occupations, and the potential they hold for behavioural reconstruction, will be discussed in Chapter Nine. 241 Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion of the Sedimentary Sequence 9.1 Introduction This chapter develops a palaeoenvironmental framework for the cultural sequence at the Haua Fteah through first considering the environmental interpretations of the site formation processes identified in the cave in Chapters Five to Eight, before synthesising the bulk sedimentological and micromorphological data to create a history of site formation processes and their environmental implications. This history is then discussed in relation to the existing palaeoenvironmental data from the site to clarify ambiguities arising from the sedimentological data, before comparison with other palaeoenvironmental records from the rest of North Africa to assess the response of the Jebel Akhdar’s landscape to regional environmental changes. The implications of the behaviours observed in the burning events in Chapter Eight are discussed, before, finally, the cultural sequence from the site is placed within this newly-refined environmental context to assess the relationships between environmental change and human occupation throughout the Haua Fteah’s history. 9.2 Environmental Interpretations of Site Formation Processes in the Haua Fteah Sequence The temporal trends in site formation processes outlined in the preceding chapters indicate significant changes in the cave environment, yet not all of these processes can be related to specific conditions outside of landscape change outside of the cave. They therefore vary in the robusticity of the environmental interpretations that can be extrapolated from them. 9.2.1 Inwash Events Colluvial inwash events, as observed in the Haua Fteah, require both sediment to be transported and water to destabilise and transport the sediment (Bridge and Demicco 2008: 272). The Haua Fteah, situated within a relatively shallow cliff incline in a Mediterranean environment (see Figure 4.2) is particularly well-placed to trace periods of colluvial movement from the surrounding landscape. The susceptibility of landscapes within the Mediterranean to such colluvial erosion is dependent on the nature of the sediment, vegetation, rainfall patterns, topography and seismic activity (Bell and Boardman 1992 and papers therein; Grove and Rackham 2001; Wainwright 2009). The colluvial mobilisation of soil material and its transport into rockshelters and caves mark a ‘tipping point’ in the landscape beyond which soil structure is broken down, either through a loss of vegetation thus leaving it unable to absorb water (Karkanas 2001; Schuldenrein 1998), a variation in intensity and concentration of rainfall (Wainwright 2009), or both. The inwash events which carried reddish, clayey soil material into the Haua Fteah therefore indicate periods of landscape instability and erosion, driven through the breakdown of soil structure through de-vegetation, a change in rainfall patterns, or both. At present, bare earth is easily eroded in the landscape during rainstorms, only resisting erosion where it is trapped in hollows, behind walls, or Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 242 in the roots of trees (e.g. in the position of Soil Pit T, Figure 5.5). A large mudflow of material into the cave from the depression in front of the cave mouth occurred during the winter of 2009 during a particularly bad storm, carrying a mixture of cave-floor sediments, animal dung pellets and external soil material into the excavation trench. Salim Hussain, the owner of the cave, reported that a recent mudflow had covered a significant area of the cave floor prior to the TRANS-NAP excavations (Barker et al. 2008). It is therefore relatively easy to envisage soil material from within the depressionwashing into the cave when there is a lack of vegetation cover - the depression is cultivated for wheat, yet is left fallow over the winter, when both of these movements occurred - and suitably intense rainstorms. How widespread the impact of these inwash events were in the landscape, however, is hard to gauge from analysis of the cave sediments alone. Given the aspect of the depression within the hillside (Figure 4.2), it is possible that material may have been washed into the depression from over the dripline or sides of the feature and into the cave itself during periods of torrential rain. It is also possible that material has washed in through fissures in the cave walls in a similar response to periods of intense rainfall, although the shape of some of these contexts observed in the trench, that appear to lens out towards the back wall of the cave (e.g. Context 520), indicate material being primarily transported in through the mouth of the cave, at least in this area of the cave. Interpretation of the colluvial transport of aeolian/dust material into and around the cave is slightly less clear.Aeolian material may have been deposited in the landscape or in front of the cave in periods of aridity, and subsequently eroded and transported into the cave during periods of resumed rainfall. Alternatively, and potentially more probably, colluvial movements of soil material may also have reworked aeolian-deposited material from within the cave within the same movement. The lack of a clayey, red nature of the sediment similar to the modern soils may simply reflect variability of sediment within a mass movement. Colluvial movements of any material observed within the Haua Fteah therefore will be interpreted generally as periods of landscape instability driven by changes in rainfall patterning or de-vegetation, with periods of potential soil inwash from outside of the cave, whether through fissures in the cave or overland flow, perhaps marking periods of particularly marked erosion given the energy required to break down their structure and transport them into the cave. Given the modern observations, if large amounts of material are flowing into the Haua Fteah, no matter how localised the source of the sediment deposited in the cave is, similar erosion is probably occurring in the wider landscape. 9.2.2 Calcite Precipitation Calcite precipitation within karstic caves is linked to calcite-rich groundwater moving through the karstic system (Goldberg and Sherwood 2006; Sweeting 1972). Layers of calcite-concreted sediments therefore record periods inwhich calcite-rich groundwater was dripping or flowing onto the sediments indicating more humid conditions in the cave and karstic system, probably reflecting periods of greater external apparent precipitation in the wider environment (Pickering et al. 2007), although conditions were still warm enough to allow the drying and precipitation of calcite. It cannot be ruled out that ongoing drips were simply shifting around the cave through changes in the morphology of bedrock Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 243 fissures. Indeed, a large part of the South-Facing Profile in the Middle Trench, closer to the present drip-line than the profiles examined in this thesis and therefore more extensively wetted during periods of higher rainfall, is heavily concreted with calcite. Due to the significant scale of what are probably multiple phases of concretion, the timing of these calcite precipitation phases is unclear. Prolonged precipitation may have been mainly post-depositional, and linked to one or two periods of far greater apparent precipitation during which calcite-rich water percolated deeply down the profile. The calcite rich layers on the West- and North-Facing Profiles, far more restricted in depth, probably represent more robustly single phases of carbonate deposition (also indicated by their isotopic compositions, I. Candy, pers. comm. 2010). Whilst it is of course possible that all of the calcite horizons may have formed significantly below the surface of the cave, making their relationship to the deposition of the sediments difficult to define without direct dating, the restriction of many of these calcitic pedofeatures observed in the micromorphology to one or two overlain contexts indicate that major leaching of calcite through the cave sediments has been restricted to the South Facing Profile and the areas closer to the dripline than those examined on the West-Facing Profile through micromorphology. If calcite precipitation reflects periods of greater apparent precipitation and subsequent evaporation of this water in Mediterranean or semi-arid environments, these periods contrast with those in which increased intensity of rainfall triggeredmass colluvialmovements. Instead, they represent periodswhen water was moving through the karstic system and into the cave without accompanying major periods of erosion, potentially during largely stable environments that were vegetated and characterised by a less intensely seasonal or simply less intense rainfall regime than that which would trigger colluvial erosion. Yet given the ability of carbonate-rich water to percolate through the profile, the timing of these periods of calcite precipitation remains problematic as the multiple sources of carbonate material in the cave has rendered them undateable (I. Candy, pers. comm. 2011). 9.2.3 Roof-Spall The mechanisms which drove the weathering of bedrock within the Haua Fteah remain somewhat ambiguous given the number of factors which can influence the physical weathering of bedrock. These factors are highly dependent on the responses of the cave’s micro-climate to wider environmental changes. It is possible that freeze-thaw processes could have driven weathering in cooler periods (Bridge and Demicco 2008: 46) as at present there is often snow on the Jebel Akhdar (M. Touati, pers. comm. 2008) and current winter temperatures in Benghazi can reach 0˚C (http://www.climatetemp. info/libya/benghazi.html). Although there is a lack of independent quantitative palaeotemperature records from the Jebel Akhdar, given lower Mediterranean sea surface temperatures during glacial periods (Chapter Two, Section 2.2.2), winter temperatures may have been low enough to allow freeze- thaw weathering. Freeze-thaw mechanisms also require the presence of moisture within the bedrock for the processes to operate, therefore, periods of increased physical weathering within the cave could well reflect cooler, moist periods (or at least periods in which there were cool, wet seasons) in the cave’s history. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 244 An alternative mechanism for physical weathering may be thermal weathering driven by diurnal changes in temperature in hot, desert environments (Jenkins and Smith 1990). Yet sunlight does not penetrate directly into the cave to heat the walls to generate the rapid cycles of heating and cooling necessary for this weathering (B. Smith, pers. comm. 2010).A third mechanism, salt weathering, may occur in semi-arid to arid conditions, with salt crystals precipitating in fissures similar to the formation of ice crystals in freeze-thawing (Boggs 2001: 4; Cooke and Smalley 1968; Smith and McGreevy 1983; Smith et al. 2005), again requiring a degree of moisture to be present at least seasonally. It is probable that there was not one sole driver of physical weathering within the cave. Other factors controlling or pre-disposing the bedrock to weathering by these processes include tectonic activity (Bailey andWoodward 1997) as well as chemical weathering and dissolution of the bedrock (Goldberg and Sherwood 2006), both possible within the Haua Fteah. Periods of physical weathering within the cave will therefore be tentatively interpreted as periods of increased environmental stress, probably as a result of cooler environments which remained at least seasonally moist. During these periods it may also have been the case that a number of processes may have been weathering the bedrock at different points in seasonal and climatic cycles as the thresholds for different mechanisms were crossed (Jenkins and Smith 1990: 458). There is however no concrete soil micromorphological evidence, e.g. the development of lenticular structures (van Vliet-Lanoë, Coutard et al. 1984; van Vliet-Lanoë 1998) from the contexts described in Chapters Six and Seven to support the development of freeze-thaw structures on the floor of the cave. Yet the lack of such structures may result from removal through bioturbation, both within the sediments as well as trampling on the surface, disruption that may be specifically aided by the increased number of large coarse limestone fragments on the surface during these periods. It may also be that whilst the moisture content of the rock and the outside environment may be high enough to drive freeze-thaw, the conditions on the cave floor may never have been wet enough to allow the development of frost-heave and cryoturbated fabrics. Indeed, the micromorphological observations from the entire sequence, including Facies Four which contains increased amounts of rock-fall, appear to show a predominantly dry and dusty depositional environment on the cave floor (see Section 9.2.4). Periods of physical weathering will therefore be interpreted as periods of cooling within the local environment. 9.2.4 Aeolian/Dust Layers The majority of the fine sediments, as characterised micromorphologically, appear to have been deposited over extended periods of time by punctuated aeolian deposition, reworking and deflation within the cave, yet the interpretation of these deposits is potentially the most ambiguous. The Haua Fteah’s north-facing aspect and position on the north side of the Jebel Akhdar, in the lee of Saharan winds, mean that it is poorly placed to record significant depositional episodes of dust deposition directly within the cave, although some aeolian dust is deposited in the wider landscape during present- day dust storms. The lack of an extensive coastal plain during low sea stands (Lambeck and Purcell 2005) removes another key source of potential aeolian sedimentation during glacials. Instead, the Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 245 material deposited through these aeolian processes in the Haua Fteah probably quite local in source, and may consist of a mixture of deflating soils, wadi sediments, or reworking of aeolian deposits previously deposited elsewhere in the landscape. Yet the aeolian/dust depositional environment as observed within the Haua Fteah probably largely reflects cave conditions similar to the present day, where a dusty, unconsolidated floor is subject to continual deflation and deposition by even light winds and trampling. This dry, ‘aeolian’ cave environment is therefore not necessarily indicative of significant aridity as, at present, even during substantial rainstorms the cave floor behind the drip- line remains dry, outside of a few drips. These sediments may therefore represent more the absence of large quantities of sediment mobilised by other processes in the immediate area of the cave than a positive, diagnostic environmental indicator. Such an absence of large layers of aeolian sedimentation within the cave potentially resulted from a lack of sediment to be mobilised, either through landscape stability and vegetation or complete denudation of the local landscape, or a lack of ability of the cave to capture aeolian sediment during periods of aeolian mobilisation due to its aspect. The overall aggradation of these layers may be tentatively linked to periods of slightly increased availability or mobility of the dust in the immediate vicinity of the cave (given that the, albeit problematic, particle size appears to indicate a local source for the sedimentation – see Chapter Five, Section 5.4.1.1), linking them to periods of aridity or semi-aridity in the local landscape. Yet in the absence of thick aeolian layers within the cave, these dusty/aeolian sediments can only be said to represent very small episodes of aeolian deposition over an extended period of time, with sediment consistently reworked around the cave from a number of sources through aeolian processes. 9.2.5 Scales of Interpretations The processes outlined above therefore represent changes in the landscape that operate and are manifest at a number of different scales, and that can be used to infer different scales of environmental information. This variability affects the robusticity of the interpretations based upon them in the following sections. It is difficult to see how the large-scale colluvial events observed in the Haua Fteah could not be accompanied by erosion and instability across the landscape; they represent the movement of large quantities of sediment probably produced by a reduction in vegetation and transported by shifts in rainfall patterning into the cave, both of which would have probably have affected the entire local area. In contrast, the shifts in temperature and humidity conditions which appear to have driven drove roof-spalling or calcite precipitation were the result of the impact of wider climatic systems on the micro-environment of the cave, moderated by its aspect, morphology and connections to fissures etc. within the bedrock. Rock-fall therefore reflects environmental shifts that may not have had an immediate, direct impact on the landscape. These environmental shifts would, however, have brought about changes in vegetation and rainfall patterns that in turnwould have impacted on the susceptibility of the landscape to erosion by colluvial or aeolian processes. Similarly, increased calcite precipitation probably took place under more mesic conditions. These conditions may have been accompanied by increased vegetation cover and stabilisation of the landscape that would have reduced the amount of Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 246 sediment available to be transported into the cave. The dominant depositional mode of the immediate cave appears to have been one of local aeolian/dust deposition that cannot definitively inform the external environment in a meaningful way. This type of deposition was probably primarily driven by the reworking of material already within the cave, as well as to a lesser extent from material from the immediate area of the cave, reflecting primarily quite localised conditions. 9.2.6 Summary In light of this discussion, the following interpretations will be used to develop the environmental interpretations of the Haua Fteah sediment sequence: • periods of increased roof-spall mark periods of increased physical weathering of the bedrock, primarily through freeze-thaw processes, in a cooler, but still somewhat humid environment. • calcitic precipitation mark periods of increased dripping within the cave, driven by a more humid, stable environment; • inwash events mark periods of landscape instability and erosion, driven by reductions in vegetation cover or an increase in seasonality or intensity of rainfall; • aeolian-deposited/reworked layers remain largely ambiguous, but represent periods lacking in influence from other sediment sources due to landscape stability or complete denudation. 9.3 Sedimentological History of the Haua Fteah – Synthesis and Environmental Interpretation This section synthesises the bulk sedimentological and micromorphological results reported in the preceding chapters and the discussion above to outline the site formation history as reflected in the sedimentation of the cave, and its environmental implications, within a preliminary chronological framework. 9.3.1 Chronology The chronology of the Haua Fteah sequence is currently under re-investigation through a range of dating methods; 14C, OSL, U-Series, ESR and tephrochronology. The stratigraphic positions of the preliminary dates are outlined in Figure 9.1 and plotted in stratigraphic order in Figure 9.2. However, all of the techniques have encountered methodological difficulties which means that these preliminary dates can only be used in the broadest sense, and no U-series dates were obtained from the sequence. There are a number of stratigraphic conflicts between the methods and dates from the same methods, potentially partially a reflection of the differentways the datedmaterial accumulateswithin the sediment sequence (e.g. the direct deposition of a tephra lens vs. recycled quartz grains used for OSL) as well as methodological difficulties. The working chronology is outlined alongside the sedimentological framework in Figure 9.3, and dates the base of theMiddle Trench to c.80,000–90,000BP. As this these dates are preliminary, no statistical modelling has been undertaken for the sequence. The chronology outlined here should therefore be treated as very preliminary, and will no doubt be revised as the Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 247 F ig ur e 9. 1: N or th -F ac in g M id dl e an d U pp er Tr en ch P ro fil es sh ow in g lo ca ti on of O SL (m ar ke d on N or th -F ac in g M id dl e Tr en ch an d te ph ra sa m pl es (l at er al ly co rr el at ed on W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e) .R ad io ca rb on sa m pl es fr om al lf ou r pr ofi le s ar e su m m ar is ed by fa ci es . O SL H F0 1 19 60 0± 10 00 BP 16 90 0± 11 00 BP O SL H F0 2 20 10 0± 10 00 BP 16 50 0± 80 0B P O SL H F0 4 42 70 0± 30 00 BP 31 70 0± 26 00 BP O SL H F0 9 61 80 0± 43 00 O SL H F1 0 60 10 0± 45 00 BP or 80 00 0± 10 00 0B P (R H UL ) O SL H F1 1 69 80 0± 60 0 BP Te ph ra - Ca m pa ni an Ig ni m br ite 39 20 0± 10 0c al .B P Te ph ra -C am pi Fl eg ri 60 -7 0, 00 0 BP O SL H F0 3 32 20 0± 21 00 BP 26 50 0± 19 00 BP Te ph ra -B ia nc av illa 18 01 9- 18 56 0c al. BP Fa ci es 2 Fa ci es 3 Fa ci es 4 14 C -s in gl e da te , 46 ,7 02 -5 1, 01 2c al. BP 14 C -b et w ee n 14 ,9 42 -1 4, 01 2c al. BP to 31 ,1 39 -3 0, 49 2c al .B P 14 C -b et w ee n 37 ,8 50 -3 66 14 ca l. BP to 45 ,7 83 -4 4, 54 0c al .B P Fa ci es 5 O SL D ee p So un di ng ,- ~6 0c m be lo w ba se of M id dl e Tr en ch RH UL 90 00 0± 10 00 0B P Fa ci es 1 14 C -b et w ee n 15 34 -1 69 2c al. BP to 13 48 5- 13 84 5c al .B P W es t- Fa ci ng Pr of ile (la te ra lly co rr el at ed ) N or th -F ac in g Pr of ile 0 1 2m 0 1 2m Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 248 OxA-18710 (126) OxA-18675 (129) OxA-18676 (129) OxA-18794 (129) OxA-18673 (131) OxA-18667 (131) OxA-18674 or 764 (132) OxA-19028 (132) OxA-18678 (136) OxA-19184 (176) OxA-22161 (177) OxA-19158 (176) ESR 2568 OxA-19030 (179) OxA-22137 (180) OxA-22138 (183) OSL HF1 younger (180) OSL HF1 average (180) OxA-19185 (181) OxA-19029 (238) OxA-19186 (182) OxA-19187 (238) OxA-19188 (238) OxA-18795 (185) OxA-18769 (187) ESR 2564 ESR 2573 ESR 2565 OSL HF2 younger (185-188/189) OSL HF2 average (185-188/189) ESR 2566 Tephra (426) Biancavilla OxA-19189 (240) ESR 2571 OxA-19571 (244) ESR 2569 OSL HF3 younger (201) OSL HF3 average (201) OxA-18797 (207) OxA-22162 (113 or 443) OSL HF4 younger (513) OSL HF4 average (513) OxA-22164 (246/236) Belfast-2199 (236) Belfast-2282 (236-441) Tephra (441/442) Campanian Ignimbrite Belfast-2254 (494) Belfast-2475 (506) Tephra Campi Flegri (513) OSL HF9 average (513) Belfast-2534 (521) OSL HF10 (536/537/562) RHUL OSL HF10 (536/537/562_ OSL HF11 (528/563/564/565) RHUL OSL 2639 (665) 020000400006000080000100000120000140000160000 Calibrated date (calBP) OxCal v4.1.7 Bronk Ramsey (2010); r:5 Atmospheric data from Reimer et al (2009); FaciesOne FaciesTwo FaciesThree FaciesFour FaciesFive Figure 9.2: Dates from the Haua Fteah sequence in stratigraphic order. Due to the preliminary nature of many of the dates, they have not been modelled as a sequence. All dates are cal. 14C AMS (using OxCal4.1.7 and IntCal09) unless noted as ESR (courtesy R. Grun), tephra (courtesy C. Lane), or OSL. OSL dates are courtesy of Z. Jacobs, or if noted ‘RHUL’, courtesy S. Armitage. Samples OSL HF 1 to 3 have two dates, the youngest modelled age and average age. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 249 -1 m -2 m -3 m -4 m -5 m0m -6 m -7 m Fa ci es D es cr ip tio n Re d si lt la ye rs w ith co bb le s an d oc cu pa tio n m at er ia l. M ed iu m m ag su s, H ig h %L O Ip ea ks Br ec ci a in re d si lt m at rix ,w ith di st in ct fin e re d le ns es . H ig h m ag .s us In cr ea si ng %L O Ip ea ks Re dd is h si lts w ith le ns es of gr av el , va yi ng te xt ur es an d co lo ur . Ca lc ite la ye rs . Lo w m ag .s us . Br ec ci a in re d si lt m at rix .L ow m ag .s us . Re dd is h si lt w ith ʻb ur ni ng fʼe at ur es . Va ria bl e m ag .s us . %L O Ip ea ks . In w as h ev en ts an d an th ro po ge ni c in flu en ce ,e sp ec ia lly to w ar ds th e to p. In cr ea se d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g of be dr oc k pu nc tu at ed w ith in w as h ev en ts AN D /O R in cr ea se d an th ro po ge ni c in pu t. In cr ea se d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g ae ol ia n/ du st de po si tio n an d re w or ki ng , sp or ad ic sh ee tw as h Ae ol ia n/ du st -d om in at ed se di m en ta tio n an d re w or ki ng , sp or ad ic in w as h. An th ro po ge ni c se di m en ta tio n. Ae ol ia n/ du st -d om in at ed de po si tio n an d re w or ki ng w ith co llu vi al re w or ki ng of in te rn al m at er ia l. Pe rio ds of w at er dr ip pi ng an d so ili nw as h to w ar ds to p. N eo lit h ic La ye r IV -V III C ap si an La ye r IX -X Ib er om au ru si an La ye r X- XV D ab ba n La ye rs XX V- XV I Le va llo is o- M ou st er ia n La ye rs XX XV -X XV H is to ric al La ye r I- IV C u ltu ra lS eq u en ce (M cB ur ne y 19 67 ) Si te Fo rm at io n In te rp re ta tio n UpperTrench MiddleTrench En vi ro nm en ta l In te rp re ta tio n 0- 14 ky a La te G la ci al -H ol oc en e Un st ab le la nd sc ap e, ch an ge in us e of sh el te r. 14 -3 0k ya -~ O IS2 C oo lin g w ith m as si ve la nd sc ap e in st ab ili ty ca us in g so ile ro si on AN D /O R in cr ea se d an th ro po ge ni c in pu t 30 -6 0k ya ~O IS 3 In te rm itt en tly un st ab le -r ap id sh ift si n cl im at e, be co m in g in cr ea si ng ly co ol . In te rm itt en tly m es ic to w ar ds to p, bu ta ls o in cr ea se d pu nc tu at ed so il er os io n bo un di ng co ol pe rio ds . 60 -7 0k ya ~O IS 4 Co ol in g, sp or ad ic al ly un st ab le la nd sc ap e 70 -8 5k ya ~O IS 5a Pu nc tu at ed in st ab iii ty ,b ut la rg el y st ab le en vi ro nm en t. D en se oc cu pa tio n. F1 F2 F3 F4 F5 Figure 9.3: Summary of facies descriptions, bulk sedimentology and field descriptions; site formation processes; and environmental interpretations by facies; and the cultural sequence. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 250 chronological resolution becomes more focussed. 9.3.2 Facies Five 9.3.2.1 Synthesis and Discussion The red, silty layers of Facies Five were laid down in a primarily dry, dusty environment of aeolian deposition and reworking in the cave, interrupted by sporadic colluvial reworking of aeolian material potentially from within the cave (e.g. Context 563). Geogenic deposition was punctuated by dark, organic lenses, confirmed micromorphologically as burning events, with%LOI peaks confirming their enhancedorganic contents. FaciesFive is cappedbyacolluvialmovementof soilmaterial (Context 520), a marked shift in depositional environment within the cave. The%CaCO3 andmagnetic susceptibility data from the facies are variable, with both sets of values largely above their means for the sequence. High %CaCO3 values recorded carbonate from a range of sources, including anthropogenic activity, secondary carbonate precipitation and roof-spall, thus reflecting both increased environmental stress (driving roof-spall) or more mesic cave environments (calcite precipitation - although this could be post-depositional) aswell as human impact on the sediments. Similarly,magnetic susceptibility values reflected variability in source material e.g. the soil inwash deposits (Context 520 and 564), which have been used as an environmental indicator, as well as markers of potential anthropogenic influence (Contexts 523 and 521) or surface weathering. Both variables therefore suffer from equifinality, hampering their usefulness as sole indicators of site formation processes. The anthropogenic material examined from Facies Five (Chapters Six and Eight) shows a repeated use of this area of the cave for occupation. The environmental context of these occupations varies, with the basal layer of Feature 600 (Chapter Eight) appearing to show a burning event, exposed for an extended period after its initial use, and weathered through sporadic dampening probably by the dripping of water from the roof. The upper layers of Feature 600, along with the other lenses of burnt material, appear to have been buried more rapidly by a range of dry or wet colluvial processes and aeolian reworking. The marked interruption of the dumping in Feature 600 by inwash potentially indicates periods of abandonments of the immediate area during periods of sheetwash. Therefore, occupation of the cave may not have been solely assigned to specific environments within the facies. The implications of the behaviors observed in these combustion events are explored further in Section 9.5. The separation of the burnt lenses by periods of aeolian/dust deposition may show a periodic abandonment of this area of the cave, and perhaps the cave itself, with discontinuous occupation restricted to sedimentary hiatuses, a model which can only be resolved through further, higher- resolution, archaeological investigation. Given the overall slow rate of aggradation of the aeolian/dust layers, it is also possible that the occupations, often just a single burning event, took place without a significant break in deposition. Facies Five was therefore dominated by punctuated, aeolian/dust deposition, but also witnessed periods of colluvial reworking of material from both within and outside of the cave, with soil inwash Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 251 to the base and top of the facies. Occupation took place between or during periods of aeolian/dust deposition, with occupation material sporadically dampened and re-worked and buried by aeolian and colluvial processes. 9.3.2.2 Interpretation As discussed in Section 9.2.4, the interpretation of the external environments which resulted in aaeolian/dusty sedimentation regime within the cave remains ambiguous. They may represent periods of unknown duration during which there was only slightly increased aeolian sediment availability in the local landscape, potentially in a largely stable semi-arid environment or in a highly denuded environment. Colluvial and sheetwash events marked erosion within the immediate landscape triggered by sporadic intensifications of rainfall or changes in rainfall patterning. The lack of physical weathering within the levels indicates a lack of environmental stress through cooling, and therefore may represent a relatively warmer phase in the Haua Fteah’s history. The facies may therefore have been deposited in a largely stable, semi-arid landscape with colluvial reworking and soil erosion reflecting sporadic periods of landscape destabilisation through shifts in rainfall intensity or patterning. The clayey inwash event at the top of the facies could mark one such major destabilisation of the landscape in response to a marked climatic change. Current chronological estimates from this facies are limited, with large discrepancies in the OSL dates due to ongoing methodological problems (N. Russell, pers. comm. 2011). The 14C date from Context 521 (Belfast-2534) at the top of the facies represents an inversion from OSL dates in Facies Four, and although these are themselves inverted, the 14C date is at the limit of calibration and may be unreliable. An OSL sample from 50cm below the base of the Middle Trench, in the Deep Sounding, yielded a very preliminary date of 90,000 BP (S. Armitage, pers. comm. 2010). Therefore the facies will be considered to date roughly to between c.85,000 and c.60-70,000 BP, thus covering the shift fromMIS5b-a and toMIS4, a period characterised globally by warming duringMIS5a, prior to cooling with the onset of MIS4. 9.3.3 Facies Four 9.3.3.1 Synthesis and Discussion Facies Four was defined by its increased gravel content and the pale nature of its fine matrix. It was interpreted in thefieldas the result ofphysicalweatheringandaeolian/dust sedimentationand reworking, an interpretation largely supported by the micromorphological observations. Micromorphological analyses also identified cycles of sheetwash of clay-rich material on the North-Facing Profile, either documenting soil inwash or flows of water from within the karstic system which begin with small- scale movements and increase in volume and thickness, but still remaining quite restricted in scale. Corrected magnetic susceptibility of the fine material lies below that of the present-day soils and the mean for the sequence, suggesting an aeolian source or transport of less-developed soil into the cave. It may also show a potential lack of surface weathering during this period, although the relatively slow Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 252 deposition of the physical weathering material makes the latter explanation problematic. %CaCO3 values, which are all at or above the mean sequence value, drop to the top of the facies, potentially indicating a shift in fine material source. %LOI values were generally low with peaks corresponding to the burning event in Context 535, as well as to observations of herbivore dung in Context 536. Facies Four therefore marks a period of increased physical weathering, with aeolian deposition interrupted by two cycles of small-scale transport of soil material into the cave. It is capped by a large burning event which appears to have been heavily weathered through a prolonged period of exposure and sporadic dampening, reflected in observations by McBurney of concretion of parts of these levels by calcite precipitation (McBurney 1967: 105). 9.3.3.2 Interpretation As discussed in Section 9.2.3 the mechanism that produced the physical weathering which dominates Facies Four is unclear from the sedimentology alone, but probably results primarily from freeze-thaw processes during a relatively cooler period. The limited sheetwash cycles on the North-Facing Profile mark cycles of small-scale colluvial erosion probably driven by changes in rainfall volume or intensity in an otherwise dry environment (see discussion above). These erosional events are far smaller in scale than that of Context 520 at the top of Facies Five, potentially representing only a limited period of erosion. The facies was therefore probably deposited during a cooler period that was punctuated by variations in rainfall patterns that transported small amounts of eroded soil material into the cave or through the karstic system in limited washes. The large burning event which covered the top of the facies on the North-Facing Profile took place in on a relatively dry, unconsolidated surface, yet was exposed for an extended period of time during which it was probably sporadically wetted prior to burial. This period of wetting may be linked to observations of calcite cementation as noted by McBurney in some areas of the trench at these levels (McBurney 1967). Driven by increased dripping in the cave, this calcite marks more mesic conditions, in humid conditions potentially during the early part of Facies Three, however, it is still possible that the calcite is from a far later wetter phase, resulting from the percolation of carbonate-rich water through the stratigraphy and its precipitation in a porous layer after its burial. The burning event itself may also have taken place within the conditions of Facies Three, simply overlying the Facies Four sediments. Chronological control for this facies is particularly unclear as it contains only two dates. The OSL date of 61,800 ± 4,300 BP (Sample HF09, Z. Jacobs, pers. comm. 2010) represents an inversion from Sample HF10 in Facies Five at 60,100 ± 4,500 BP. Both of these dates are overlain by an as yet undated tephra peak at the top of the facies in Context 513, potentially from one of a number of eruptions from the Campi Flegrei between 70,000 and 60,000 BP (C. Lane, pers. comm. 2011), although all dates are subject to wide error ranges at present. The facies will therefore be considered as very broadly dating to between 70,000 to 60,000 BP. Thus, the increased physical weathering may be linked to global cooling during MIS4, with the sporadic inwash of material in the facies linked to fluctuations in rainfall within this cooler environment. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 253 9.3.4 Facies Three 9.3.4.1 Synthesis and Discussion Facies Three is characterised by a marked decrease in physical weathering relative to Facies Four. It is comprised of silt layers which vary in texture and colour and which were largely characterized through micromorphological analysis as inwash events (clayey, reddish layers) and aeolian/dustmaterial (silty, pale layers).Micromorphological observations also identified periods of colluvially reworked aeolian/ dust sediment from within the cave and local area. There is a slight increase in frequency of reddish, clayey silt inwash layers bands towards the top third of the facies, which precedes the appearance of a number of pale, silty gravel lenses which become thicker and more frequent during the transition to Facies Two, often bounded by clay-rich inwash layers. Calcite-concreted layers (identified in the field and micromorphologically) also indicate periods of calcite-rich water dripping and percolation in the cave, suggesting more humid periods, although again the timing of these cannot be pinpointed without direct dating. Some patterningwas observed in the bulk sedimentology data from the facies.Magnetic susceptibility values are consistently below the modern soil values, consistent with those from Facies Four, until they jump in Context 498. Relative peaks are correlated with the two inwash events at the base and top of the Levalloiso-Mousterian levels. Above this, in Layer XXV and the early Dabban, the values are consistently above those of the modern soil. A further, major increase in magnetic susceptibility occurs above the limit of micromorphological sampling, and high values continue into Facies Two. The low magnetic susceptibility in the Levallois-Mousterian levels appears to be largely a result of the predominantly aeolian nature of the sediment, or a lack of weathering of the sediment on exposed surfaces, potentially indicating a rapid deposition, although this is tentative. The jumps in magnetic susceptibility values beginning at the end of the Levalloiso-Mousterian are linked to sporadic inwash of soil material, with subsequent internal reworking of this material potentially accounting for the highly magnetically susceptible aeolian sediments which occur between them. The variable %CaCO3 values reflect both calcite precipitation (e.g. Contexts 504 and 503) and limestone grit (Context 509), hampering its usefulness as an environmental indicator. %LOI is low throughout the sediments, reflecting the lack of significant anthropogenic influence on the sediments observed in the field. The sediment sequence for Facies Three can be summarised as: The Levalloiso-Mousterian layers are dominated by aeolian/dust sedimentation, with soil inwash occurring close to the base of the facies (Context 508), as well as prior to Layer XXV (Context 498). This part of the facies also contains colluvially-reworked aeolian sediments from within the cave, as well as periods of calcite precipitation indicating slightly wetter cave conditions. Aeolian/dust deposition continued into Layer XXV. This also encompassed at least two major periods of (potential) soil inwash, as well as a period of calcite precipitation and resumed inwash and a single thin lens of gravel marking a period of physical weathering. The presence of major periods of calcite precipitation within the aeolian/dust sediments during the Early Dabban the West-Facing Profile may Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 254 be linked to prolongedwetter periods in the cave during this period yet it cannot be ruled out that these horizons formed long after deposition of the units. Above this concretion on the West-Facing Profile on the North-Facing Profile, another, thicker, lens of gravel and aeolian deposition was capped by probable soil inwash (Context 461) at the upper limit of micromorphological sampling. The marked red, clayey layers and roof-spall lenses became more pronounced towards the shift into Facies Two, indicating an amplification of inwash and physical weathering to the end of the facies. 9.3.4.2 Interpretation The overall aeolian/dusty depositional environment within the cave in the Levalloiso-Mousterian layers renders its environmental interpretation largely ambiguous, yet it probably indicates a semi- arid environment (see Section 9.2.4). This environment was sporadically interrupted by landscape destabilisation driven by changes in rainfall pattern and intensity, or de-vegetation. Following the inwash event at the base of the Levalloiso-Mousterian, the colluvial reworking of aeolian/dust sediment in the middle of the Facies Three Levalloiso-Mousterian levels may indicate an increase in local aeolian sediment availability in the landscape or cave following a period of aridity (either during Facies Four or the early part of Facies Three), or simply, and more probably, a reworking of existing sediments within the cave. The trend over time after this into Facies Two towards more highly-magnetically susceptible inwash layers may reflect the gradual, punctuated stripping of older, well-developed soils from the landscape (Ortiz et al. 2002) through a series of increasing cycles of instability driven by climatic fluctuationswhich began during the Levalloiso-Mousterian and continued throughout the shift to the Dabban and into Facies Two. The layers of calcite precipitation within Facies Three, most markedly evident in the Early Dabban layers, may indicate sporadic periods of increased of percolation of carbonate-rich water through the cave sediments in response to increased external precipitation in a stable, vegetated environment, although their timing cannot be linked to specific periods without direct dating. FaciesThree therefore appears todocumentfluctuations in environmentwithin anoverall predominantly semi-arid environment. The intensity of periods of landscape instability, driven potentially by shifts in rainfall pattern and volume, appears to have increased in severity to the top of the facies, and began to be accompanied by periods of physical weathering driven by episodes of more marked cooling which reached temperatures suitable for freezing and thawing. The facies also contained periods of stable, potentiallymesic landscapes from the Levalloiso-Mousterian, indicated by calcite precipitation horizons, which may have increased in duration or extent into the early Dabban. Yet the timing of these humid periods remains speculative in the absence of direct dating of the carbonate layers. This was followed by a further period of physical weathering, potentially driven by freeze-thawing, and landscape destabilisation during the shift to Facies Two, potentially indicating cooler environments, but ones which still retained enough rainfall variation to drive sporadic colluvial erosion of material from the hillsides and to allow enough moisture for freezing and thawing. Dates from Facies Three are limited, and out of the five dates, four are concentrated in the top 50cm Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 255 of the facies. These include the Campanian Ignimbrite tephra in Context 442 (C. Lane, pers. comm. 2010), dating to 39,280 ± 110 BP (Ar/Ar, De Vivo et al. 2001). This is largely consistent with the associated radiocarbon dates - a date of 44,450–45,789 cal. BP (Belfast-2254) from Context 494 in Layer XXV lies approximately 50cm below the tephra, the closest date to the earliest possible appearance of the Dabban (it is from the centre of Layer XXV and could overly Dabban material). The lowest date in the facies of 43,160–42,015 cal. BP (Belfast-2475), from Context 506, represents an inversion and is probably somehow intrusive or contaminated as it appears far too young for that depth. The facies will therefore be broadly considered as dating from after 60,000 to 70,000 BP (as it overlies Facies Four, see above) and continuing until after 37,850–36,614 cal. BP (Belfast-2199) towards the top of the facies. This is broadly consistent with deposition duringMIS3, a period of rapid global environmental change potentially indicated in the sediments as cycles of sporadic landscape destabilisation, and fluctuations in temperature and rainfall patterns. 9.3.5 Facies Two 9.3.5.1 Synthesis and Discussion Analysis of Facies Two was restricted to field descriptions and bulk sedimentology. It is characterized by large amounts of roof-spall in a silty matrix, punctuated by lenses of reddish silty clay and anthropogenic material. Magnetic susceptibility is consistently raised above that of the present modern soil values (especially following correction) and %CaCO3 is variable. Given the polygenetic nature of the %CaCO3 and magnetic susceptibility values in the underlying facies, the detail they can add to the field observations was limited, yet the marked nature and magnitude of the magnetic susceptibility shift indicate a major shift in the fine material source or post-depositional alteration processes such as anthropogenic influence or surface weathering. Facies Four is similarly dominated by roof-spall, and contains largely aeolian-deposited fine material interrupted by two limited periods of clay-rich sheetwash of soil material. Yet the magnetic susceptibility of the finematerial fromFacies Four is far lower than that of Facies Two and themodern soils, indicating a different fine material source or post-depositional pathway for Facies Two. Given the association of inwash events to raised magnetic susceptibility values in Facies Five to Three, this may indicate a soil origin for the material, supported by the presence of large silty lenses which appear to be the result of inwash events in Facies Two. Local reworking of this soil material within the cave through aeolian processes between these inwash lenses would still result in high magnetic susceptibility, as seen in Facies Three above Layer XXV and Context 498. Furthermore, the magnetic susceptibility of inwash events became higher through the deposition of Facies Three, indicating the erosion of heavily weathered, older soils. Facies Two may represent the culmination of this erosion. As the magnetic susceptibility values for Facies Two are far higher than that of the present-day soils, these values may also have been enhanced through processes within the cave, such as anthropogenic activity or pedogenesis. The jump in magnetic susceptibility appears to occur at the same time as a jump in occupation density in the cave in the Dabban (See Chapter Four). Facies Five has a relatively high density of anthropogenic material and evidence for burning, with not markedly high magnetic Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 256 susceptibilities but some tentative evidence for an anthropogenic influence on magnetic susceptibility (See Section 9.3.2.1). Yet this occupation is still less dense than that recorded during Facies Two (Chapter Four) and anthropogenic influence on the sediments may therefore be lower than in later parts of the sequence. Pedogenesis or other weathering of the sediment (which may raise the magnetic susceptibility is difficult to trace without micromorphological observations), yet may be linked to the presence of prolonged surfaces such as may exist between sporadic inwash events. 9.3.5.2 Interpretation Although themechanism bywhich the physical weathering within the cave cannot be deduced from the sedimentology alone, the major mechanism driving this weathering is probably freeze-thaw processes (with other weathering processes important to a lesser extent or at different points throughout the annual cycle). This would therefore indicate that the environment was cooler, but still moist enough to allow freeze-thaw processes to act on the bedrock. The large clayey lenses of material within this facies, marking periods of inwash into the cave, also attest to water action within the landscape, yet these were probably restricted to sporadic episodes of higher rainfall – higher rainfall spread evenly through the year and in a stable environment, even in a cooler environment, would probably be accompanied by vegetation growth and landscape stabilisation which would hinder such movement of large volumes of soil. Therefore, these inwash events mark periods of landscape denudation. Between these inwash events, fine material from the cave floor was probably reworked primarily through aeolian processes, as well as potentially through trampling by animals and humans. The influence of post-depositional alteration on the sediments cannot be tested through the available data, yet the coincidence of the very high values with the increase in occupation density indicates that they could be linked. It is also not impossible that the material may have also been raised in magnetic susceptibility through surface weathering, as inwash events were potentially separated in time. Calcite precipitation is also largely untraceable with the current data resolution and the bulk sedimentological methods employed. The interpretation of the facies is therefore tentative, and will be discussed in light of the other environmental proxies below, and its similarities to the sediments in Facies Four. Chronological control of Facies Two is provided by a relatively large number of 14C, OSL and ESR dates and a single lens of the Biancavilla tephra (C. Lane, pers. comm. 2011) dated to 18,019–18,560 cal. BP (Coltelli et al. 2000). The dates are broadly in stratigraphic order yet there are inversions both within and between the methods, probably due in part to the complex stratigraphy of the facies, and two probable modern intrusive dates (OxA-18336 and OxA-22163). The facies will therefore be considered as spanning from >32,785–31,489 cal. BP (OxA-22164) to <13,787–13,460 cal. BP (OxA-19029). The facies is therefore broadly correlated with increased landscape instability and environmental stress consistent with increased global cooling during the end of MIS3 andMIS2. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 257 9.3.6 Facies One 9.3.6.1 Synthesis and Discussion Facies One contains far less roof-spall than FaciesTwo, and is dominated by silt layers and in its upper part, anthropogenic features, such as the foundations of a building and stabling deposits which hamper environmental interpretation. The sediments are relatively un-compressed and contain soil peds and mudflow structures of cobbles allowing the identification of mass colluvial movements interspersed with anthropogenic material (Hunt et al. 2010) and potential aeolian deposition may also have taken place. On the South-Facing Profile, in a less anthropogenically disturbed area, a series of mudflows correlate with magnetic susceptibility peaks, whilst the anthropogenic deposits which they interrupt are marked by %CaCO3 and %LOI peaks. This depositional environment, dominated by large-scale inwash events and anthropogenicmaterial, indicates a period ofmajor, punctuated landscape instability. The chronological control for this facies comes from 15 14C dates, of which two dates were considered modern outliers. The dates from the facies lie between 14,000 BP and 2,000 BP, the majority of them from between 14,000 and 8,000 BP. The facies is therefore broadly consistent with the Late Glacial and Holocene. 9.3.6.2 Interpretation Facies One appears to consist largely of inwash events of soil material, marking periods of landscape instability, during a period in which the cave was utilised for a number of different practices. This instability potentially traces both environmental fluctuations during the Late Glacial, with later inwash events potentially linked to anthropogenic clearances of the landscape for agriculture, leaving the landscape more susceptible to erosion during the Graeco-Roman period (Hunt et al. 2010). 9.4 Comparison of the Sediment Sequence with Existing Palaeoenvironmental Archives from the Haua Fteah and North Africa The sediment sequence outlined above contains a number of ambiguities that can only be discussed fully through the comparison of the sequence with existing palaeoenvironmental archives from both within the Haua Fteah and in North Africa. 9.4.1 The Sediment Sequence and Other Environmental Proxies This thesis has developed amodel of cave sedimentation that has refined someof the existing hypotheses of site formation processes and environmental interpretations for the Haua Fteah sequence, but also identified some ambiguities in the drivers behind these processes that can only be answered through the comparison of the sedimentary sequence to other environmental proxies. Sampson interpreted of the periods of physical weathering in Facies Two and Four as periods of freeze- thawing, consistent with the cooler temperatures traced by isotopic work (Emiliani and McBurney 1967), as well as with the interpretation of the presence of Ammotragus peaks as marking cool, wet Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 258 environments (Higgs 1967). This interpretation is tentatively upheld by this thesis (see Section 9.2.3), yet whilst freeze-thaw could well be the dominant process, it may not be the only physical weathering process. There does however appear to be a disjuncture between the presence of freeze-thaw products and other palaeoenvironmental proxies, given that freezing and thawing (as well as salt weathering) requires moisture within fissures in the bedrock to drive these processes. Klein and Scott (1986) interpreted the Ammotragus peaks in the sequence, concurrent with Facies Four and Two, as cool/ arid indicators, (contra a cool/wet indicator as hypothesised by Higgs (1967)). This interpretation drew on global models of the impact of glacial cycles on lower latitudes and which is supported by the preliminary data from oxygen and carbon isotope work on enamel from Ammotragus teeth which, although at present limited, appears to show increased aridity during MIS2 relative to the few teeth from the MSA layers (H. Reade, pers. comm. 2011). Preliminary results from the pollen analyses from the cave (D. Simpson, pers. comm. 2011) indicate that glacial and stadial environments were characterised by poor arid steppe with pine, potentially restricted to the wadis, also consistent with overall relative landscape degradation and increased cooling and aridity. Yet with extreme, consistent high aridity during these periods of physical weathering, Facies Two and Facies Four, there would not be enough moisture to drive freeze-thaw processes within the cave. Two scenarios are therefore possible that could account for these apparent discrepancies between the proxies, depending onwhether temperature or moisture was the controlling factor for physical weathering. There may have always been enough moisture in the local environment of the Jebel Akhdar for freeze-thaw to take place, in both glacials and interglacials, yet the required temperature lows were only present during glacials and stadials to drive these processes. ‘Arid’ periods in the faunal record may therefore only have been arid compared to the wetter periods in the sequence, rather than completely desertic. Alternatively, a generally cool and arid environment maywell have prevailed during glacials and stadials, with freezing and thawing taking place only in periods when the moisture increased sufficiently to drive freeze-thaw processes and physical weathering. Such sporadic variation in moisture, driven by variation in rainfall may also be reflected in the sporadic inwash events that eroded and transported soil material into the cave, variations which may only have occurred on decadal or century scales. Further work on the other proxy records is required to further elucidate the nature of the glacial and stadial environments in the cave. The nature of the fine material, characterised in this thesis through soil micromorphology, refines Moyer’s correlation of periods of increased silt deposition within the cave with colluvial deposition during pluvial events (Moyer 2003). Whilst inwash contributed greatly to the deposition of the silty sediments of Facies One, the micromorphological observations indicate that it had only sporadic influences on the similar sediments in Facies Three and Five. Instead, the finematerial from these facies appears to have largely been deposited through potentially local aeolian reworking and deposition, with extensive sediment deflation and recycling within the cave. These siltier Facies One, Three and Five, broadly concurrent with interglacials, were associated largely with Bos-dominated assemblages, indicating relatively warmer and wetter environments (Klein and Scott 1986), supported through the lack of physical weathering in the cave during these periods. Yet, as discussed in Chapter Four, Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 259 Section 4.2.4.1, these periods were not always very warm and wet; the appearance of arid-indicator faunal species within Facies Three which is otherwise dominated by Bos may reflect semi-arid environments. Alternatively, such mixing may arise from the lumping together of faunal assemblages from discrete occupations in a number of different environments within the climatic fluctuations in MIS3. Further resolution should be offered by the ongoing analysis of faunal remains from the current TRANS-NAP excavations. Whilst Facies Three (and Two) are both characterised as an open, arid landscape during the late Levalloiso-Mousterian and Dabban through the avifauna (MacDonald 1997), Facies Five, which appears similar in sedimentology to Facies Three, has a far more mesic avifaunal assemblage with woodland indicators, illustrating that the aeolian/dusty facies may, as previously discussed (Section 9.2.4), encompass a wide range of external environments. Such variability in MIS3 is also mirrored in the preliminary pollen results, with the Facies Three sediments indicating an overall glacial environment, but with periods of maquis species indicating more humid periods (C. Hunt, pers. comm. 2011). The above discussion highlights the need for, but also complexity involved with, using multiple methods of environmental reconstruction within a site. Each of these proxies record a different aspect of the environment, and reflect different taphonomic pathways, as well as different scales of temporal resolution, and the ongoing work by the TRANS-NAP project will refine these interpretations and further elucidate the environmental context of occupation at the Haua Fteah. 9.4.2 The Haua Fteah in a North African Environmental Context The low resolution chronology for the Middle to Later Stone Age sequence in the Haua Fteah, as well as for other terrestrial archives in North Africa, hampers the direct correlation of individual events within the cave with rapid or brief fluctuations in environment as recorded through marine or speleothem records. Yet it does appear that global fluctuations in climate had a distinct bearing on the sedimentation within the Haua Fteah. Facies Five appears to be chronologically equivalent to MIS5a, and the transition to MIS4. There are indicators that the Mediterranean region and North Africa were generally warmer and more humid during MIS5a (e.g. Larrasoaña et al. 2003; Tjallingii et al. 2008), although conditions as reflected in pollen from sapropels and the Lago di Monticchio record indicate that it was slightly drier than the fully interglacial MIS5e (Allen and Huntley 2009; Bar-Matthews et al. 2000; Rossignol-Strick 1983). The sedimentological interpretation of Facies Five as reflecting a relatively stable, potentially vegetated landscape, fits within this period. Amajor destabilisation as marked by a period of soil inwash prior to the deposition of Facies Four is consistent with landscape instability in the climatic downturn to MIS4 and during MIS4 itself. Facies Four is largely chronologically correlated with MIS4. The impact of MIS4 was recorded across North Africa by widespread aridity marking major periods of aeolian sedimentation (e.g. Giraudi 2005; Tjallingii et al. 2008) and the disappearance of the Saharan lakes (Smith et al. 2004; Wendorf Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 260 et al. 1993), concurrent with cooling in both the global and Levantine speleothem records (Bar- Matthews et al. 1997, 1999). The relationship of this regional cooling and aridity to the increased physical weathering at the Haua Fteah is problematic, as has been discussed above (Section 9.4.1). Pollen and faunal records indicate cooler/arid species, whilst freeze thaw processes are also consistent with cooling, however, such increased physical weathering driven by freeze-thaw processes would have required some degree of moisture. Therefore, the environment in the JebelAkhdar must not have been consistently hyper-arid during glacials, although may have more relatively arid compared to the Jebel’s interglacial environments. There is also no increase in aeolian sedimentation recorded in the Haua Fteah to mirror the widespread mobilisation of aeolian sediments across North Africa, although this, as discussed previously (Section 9.2.4), may be related to the aspect of the cave, as well as a lack of local aridity and sediment sources. Therefore, during MIS4,whilst the JebelAkhdar appears to have been cooler, it may still have been more humid compared with the rest of North Africa through local rainfall patterning, similar to the situation at present. FaciesThree is roughly chronologically equivalent toMIS3.This eventwas characterised byfluctuating periods of aridity and humidity across North Africa (e.g. Moreno et al. 2002, 2004) and temperature fluctuations within the Levantine speleothem record (Bar-Matthews et al. 1997). These environmental fluctuations are traced in terrestrial records dominated by alluvial activity in theMediterranean coastal strip, where largely unstable landscapes were punctuated by periods of humidity and stabilisation. Alluvial fan stabilisation due to increased humidity occurred in Tripolitania at c.40,000–30,000 BP and 25,000 BP (Gilbertson and Hunt with Smithson 1996; Gilbertson et al. 1987), and in Wadi Zewana, Cyrenaica at 42,510 BP (Rowan et al. 2000), as well as throughout MIS3 in aeolian sediment stabilisation at Oued es Saffaiai (White et al. 1996). These fluctuations in environment and landscape stability can be traced in Facies Three in the Haua Fteah, with the fluctuation of sediment sources between soil inwash marking destabilisations and calcite-cemented layers and incipient flowstones developing in periods of increased humidity and stability. Lenses of roof-spall indicating periods of physical weathering produced by freezing and thawing, towards the top of the facies are concurrent with an overall cooling throughout MIS3 (Andersen et al. 2006), as well as the potential increasing degradation of the landscape with the erosion of well-developed soils into the cave through sporadic, major pluvial events. The evidence for a prolonged period of calcite precipitation during the Early Dabban in the Haua Fteah sequence c.40,000–35,000 BP may be linked to a period of humidity which was recorded in the Tripolitanian alluvial fan stabilisations as well as a potential lake phase in southern Libya (Gaven et al. 1981), although this cannot be confirmed without direct dating of the calcite. The environment of the Haua Fteah therefore appears to trace the wider North African and global rapid climatic fluctuations during MIS3, although correlation of individual global eventswith the deposition of layers within the cave is impossible given the low resolution offered by the sedimentation. Facies Two corresponds to the last part ofMIS3 andMIS2. In North Africa this period is characterised by massive aeolian deposition driven by hyper-aridity (Dearing et al. 1996; Giraudi 2004, 2005; Swezey 2001). Yet, as with MIS4, this major aeolian mobilisation and deposition is not noted in the Haua Fteah sediments (though this may be due to a lack of a local source of aeolian sedimentation or Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 261 due to the aspect of the cave). Instead, as with Facies Four, physical weathering increases, potentially driven by freeze-thaw processes, whilst the fine material appears to have been dominated by periods of soil inwash followed by aeolian reworking (although this interpretation is rendered difficult without micromorphological analysis). This indicates a regime of sporadically intense rainfall eroding material from the surrounding landscape on a far greater scale than in Facies Four, potentially indicating an increased seasonality or more concentrated rainfall during this period relative to Facies Four. Erosion in the later part of MIS3 and MIS2 is also noted from a small cave in the wadi adjacent to the Haua Fteah, CPP1595, which appears to showmudflow erosion in sporadic rainfall events in an environment with little surface water during this period (A. Antonniadou and C. Hunt, pers. comm. 2011). The periods of increased moisture that these rainfall events brought could have potentially driven discreet periods of physical weathering through sporadic activation of freeze-thaw processes.Alternatively, the environment ofweathering may have been consistent throughoutMIS2, driven by cooler temperatures and a degree of continued humidity throughout this period that was not seen in the rest of the region. Although the exact nature of the external environment of the cave is unclear from the existing data and that presented in this thesis, as with MIS4, the Jebel Akhdar appears to be responding to wider-scale environmental shifts slightly differently to the rest of North Africa, retaining a degree of at least highly seasonal or sporadic rainfall within a period of regional hyper-aridity. Facies One corresponds largely with the Holocene which contained a return to sustained humid conditions in the early part of the Holocene across North Africa (Fontes and Gasse 1989; Kuper and Kröeper 2006; Rossignol-Strick 1999) before increasing aridity to the present day. Whilst the anthropogenic influence on the layers makes it difficult to draw concrete environmental conclusions from the sediments alone, there appears to be increasing instability towards the top of the sequence, with phases of erosion potentially linked to Neolithic and Graeco-Roman farming as well as Holocene environmental change (Hunt et al. 2010). The environmental shifts as seen in the Haua Fteah therefore appear to be broadly chronologically synchronous with glacial cycles, although the environment of the Jebel Akhdar as inferred from the cave sediments does appear to vary from the impact of these cycles on North Africa at a regional scale. The lack of major aeolian sedimentation during glacial periods may be a factor of taphonomy, but may also indicate that, whilst the area was cooler, it probably did not witness the hyper-aridity experienced by many other areas in North Africa, instead subject to at least sporadic pluvial events, if not seasonal rainfall. Therefore the sequence may show a more localised response to environmental change tempered by the Jebel Akhdar’s topography, with the area probably forming a refuge for vegetation, animal and human populations during these periods. 9.5 Implications of the Site Formation Processes for the Haua Fteah Archaeological Data Before examining the relationships between human occupation and environmental change at the Haua Fteah, the existing archaeological data and its resolution must be considered in relation to the site formation processes outlined in this thesis. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 262 As discussed previously (Chapter Four, Section 4.2.2), use of the number of artefacts recovered from each layer during the 1950s excavations to trace occupation density is problematic, yet it remains the only way of measuring this ahead of the renewed excavations by TRANS-NAP. Although it remains dependent on the low-resolution, working chronology, the site formation history developed within this thesis has highlighted shifting depositional processes with potentially different sedimentation rates. These should be able to be used to assess the artefact densities recorded by McBurney. It may be expected that the roof-spall dominated sediments represent slower deposition, with aeolian aggradation potentially indicatingmore rapid deposition. Yet a roughmeasure of the sedimentation rates within the existing chronological framework illustrates a contradictory picture. Dominated by roof-spall, Facies Two spans 15,000 years and is ~2m thick, and Facies Four spans 10,000 years in ~70cm. These facies therefore have very different sedimentation rates, at 75 years/cm and 142 years/cm respectively. In contrast, Facies Three, spanning 35,000 years over 2m, has a deposition rate of 175 years/cm, with Facies Five representing potentially 15,000 years in ~1m, at a rate of 150 years/cm. The roof-spall facies therefore appear to have been deposited relatively quickly, yet the deposition of a few fragments of roof-spall in a particularly cold period could account for a higher volume of sedimentation than aeolian aggradation of finematerial over an extended period of time. The ephemeral surfaces observed micromorphologically within the aeolian contexts also appear to have been subject to reworking and deflation after deposition in the cave, thus potentially slowing the overall rate of sedimentation by removing material as well as depositing it. There are also numerous more prominent breaks in sedimentation of unknown duration, as well as truncations, as observed micromorphologically, which also mark the removal of unknown quantities of sediment, and such removals render the calculation of sediment rates tentative at very best. The sequence lacks the chronological resolution to begin to assess the impact of these on sedimentation rates, and the issue of changing densities and rates of deposition cannot be resolved further at present, although their potential to skew the record must be borne in mind when the dating models are developed further. Layer XXV contains an interstratification of industries with Levalloiso-Mousterian and Dabban affinities, which was identified as either the existence of multiple cultural groups within the area during this period, or the result of sediment reworking creating a false sequence (McBurney 1967: 138). Whilst robust correlation between the TRANS-NAP contexts and McBurney’s sub-levels within Layer XXV is not possible at present, the sediments within Layer XXV include at least one phase of major inwash, which would support the latter explanation. This reworking of sediment means that the primary environmental context of these artefacts has also been lost, potentially hampering the assessment of the exact environmental conditions at the appearance of the Dabban. 9.6 Behavioural Implications of the MSABurning Events Whilst the analysis of the artefactual record in the Haua Fteah remains low resolution ahead of the renewed excavations, the analysis of the MSA hearths in Chapter Eight can give us an insight directly into activity at the site during a period of relatively high occupation density. Given that only two features were analysed, and the lack of spatial information about these features exposed only in Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 263 profile, the robusticity of the behavioural inferences placed upon them must be tentative, yet the processes observed have striking parallels with Middle Palaeolithic and MSA hearth and burning features studied across the Mediterranean. The MSA burning features analysed in the Haua Fteah are two slightly different types of combustion feature. F600 appears to have been constructed either in a natural or excavated hollow, within which a mixture of wood and potentially grass was burnt. The residue from this initial burning event was then exposed and weathered for an extended period of time, before ash was dumped or swept over it. The feature was then covered by inwash potentially indicating a break in use. This cycle of dumping and inwash was repeated twice, with the final colluvial event sealing the feature and potentially obliterating any trace of the feature on the surface. The burning event in 513/535, covers a much larger area in profile, and appears to show one, or perhaps two, periods of in situ burning of wood and a considerable amount of grass on an unprepared surface. The feature has been heavily weathered through exposure before being ultimately sealed by a colluvial event. Evidence for the combustion of silica-rich fuels, potentially grasses, also occurs in the form of vesicular silica ‘slag’ throughout the lower MSAlayers. The Haua Fteah burning features, with dark organic-rich layers overlain by whitish ashy layers, are typical in appearance of combustion features known from Middle Palaeolithic contexts across the Mediterranean (Bar-Yosef 1993; Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998; Goldberg 2003). Most Middle Palaeolithic hearths, like that in contexts 513/535, were placed directly onto the substrate without preparation of the surface, such as at Vanguard and Gorham’s Caves in Gibraltar (Macphail et al. 2000), and Kebara, Hayonim, and Tabun caves in the Levant (Berna and Goldberg 2007). The latter three sites also contained less-frequent, but still numerous instances where, as potentially in F600, a shallow hollowwas dug out to create a space for the hearth, or where natural hollows were utilised for hearth location. No preparation of the underlying substrate was undertaken for these hearths - lining of hearths with stones or clay is only known from the Upper Palaeolithic onwards (e.g. the lining of Aurignacian hearths with clay at Klisoura Cave, Greece (Karkanas et al. 2004), although even in the Upper Palaeolithic it is not necessarily ubiquitous (Bar-Yosef 2002), and may relate to specific functional purposes or settings (Riguad et al. 1995). From the micromorphological observations, the fuel utilised in both of the Haua Fteah burning events was a mixture of mainly wood with some grass, grasses potentially being more abundant in Contexts 513/535, as well as present to form the vesicular silica aggregates which are found throughout the lower MSA layers. Phytolith and archaeobotanical analyses would be required to further explore fuel use within the Haua Fteah, yet these fuels are consistent with the range of fuel utilization seen in Middle Palaeolithic contexts in the Levant. In Kebara and Tabun, the primary fuel was wood, with a secondary component of grasses, potentially brought in attached to the wood, or utilised as kindling (Albert et al. 1999, 2000, In Press) After wood, the second most abundant fuel in Hayonim by contrast was dichotenous leaves, potentially reflecting a different vegetation surrounding the cave during occupation to that of Kebara and Tabun (Albert et al. 2003). Grasses in large quantities are also present in Tor Faraj, potentially linked to their use as bedding (Henry et al. 2004; Rosen 2003), mirorring Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 264 the use of grasses for bedding in the MSA of southern Africa at Sibudu cave, South Africa by Homo sapiens populations (Goldberg et al. 2009). Whilst analysis is necessarily limited in the Haua Fteah, the presence of apparently large amounts of grass in the vesicular silican and 513/535 may indicate bedding, however this remains speculation. The cycles of ash dumping and cleaning illustrated in F600 are mirrored across Middle Palaeolithic contexts in the Mediterranean, most spectacularly in Kebara Cave, where in the Mousterian levels, ash appears to have been removed from hearths in the centre of the cave and dumped towards the area at the back of the cave (Schiegl et al. 1996; Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998; Goldberg 2003; Meignen et al. 2007). Systematic removals of ash took place repeatedly over an extended period of time, with hearths concentrated in the centre of the cave, and the ash dumps, mixed with bone dumps against the back wall of the cave (Meignen et al. 2007). Similar hearth maintenance activities on a variety of scales have also been observed in Middle Palaeolithic contexts at sites such as Abric Romaní, Spain (Vaquero et al. 2001;Vallverdú et al. 2010)Vanguard Cave (Macphail et al. 2000), and Peche de l’Aze IV (Goldberg et al. In Press) and potentially continue into Upper Palaeolithic contexts at Üçağizli Cave in Turkey (Goldberg 2003). Such cleaning may have been related to use of embers for cooking or roasting, in Vanguard Cave potentially for cooking shellfish (Barton 2000), implying sophisticated understanding of aspects of pyrotechonology (Meignen et al. 2007). Many of the sites which contain evidence for such cleaning activities also contain multiple lines of evidence for wider spatial patterning, with site structure centred around repeated re-use of hearths, and the location of potential bedding areas around these hearths, e.g. at Tor Faraj, Jordan (Henry et al. 2004; Hietala 2003), Abric Romaní (Vaquero et al. 2001; Vallverdú et al. 2010), and Kebara (Meignen et al. 2001; Speth 2006). Such structure of sites is considered as one of the elements of the Upper Palaeolithic ‘package’ of modern behaviours (Bar-Yosef 2002) yet these sites and the features they contain indicate that site structure, and mechanisms for maintaining it such as re-use of pits for fires, are prevalent far earlier in Middle Palaeolithic contexts and are not the preserve of H. sapiens (Speth 2006). This very brief review places the MSA burning features observed in the Haua Fteah comfortably within the range of combustion features known from Middle Palaeolithic sites elsewhere across the Mediterranean region. Yet these sites are associated with Neanderthals whilst the Haua Fteah hearths are linked to H. sapiens remains. This strengthens the idea that the practices that produced these features were part of a widerMSA/Middle Palaeolithic behavioural package, along with other types of technology, across theMediterranean, further blurring the line between the two species and their hearth practices. Whether the development of these practices was due to demographic pressure (Goldberg and Bar-Yosef 1998) requires further study - all that can be said from the Haua Fteah is that F600 and its hearth maintenance activities occur during one of the periods of relatively high density occupation of the cave as expressed in the McBurney archive, yet Context 513/535 appears to have been formed during a period of more markedly lower density. The Haua Fteah remains a difficult place to study the behaviours of populations, and specifically the use of space, within the site because of its history of Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 265 excavation, recording and relatively small area of excavation, yet some tantalising glimpses of activity of groups within the MSA have been shown in the combustion events which were accessible. 9.7 The Haua Fteah Cultural History in its Environmental Context The environmental history of the Haua Fteah, as developed through the sedimentological framework outlined in this thesis, along with data from other existing palaeoenvironmental proxies can be used to situate the cultural sequence within its palaeoenvironmental context, prior to the discussion of its implications in the following chapter. A summary outline of the cultural and environmental histories is outlined in Figure 9.4. The Levalloiso-Mousterian levels encompass major climatic and demographic shifts as reflected in artefact density. Facies Five is relatively high in occupation material, which corresponds to the observations of anthropogenic influence on the sediments in the form of F600, with repeated return and use of the excavated area for burning. Whilst environmental interpretations of aeolian/ dust sedimentation in the cave remain largely ambiguous, the lack of physical weathering and the presence of relatively humid pollen (D. Simpson, pers. comm. 2011) and faunal assemblages (Klein and Scott 1986; MacDonald 1997), coupled with the evidence for humidity throughout North Africa during MIS5a, indicate that this period in the Jebel Akhdar was not particularly arid or cool. Instead, occupation may have taken place in a semi-arid or Mediterranean landscape. Facies Four marked a major drop in occupation density within the Levalloiso-Mousterian levels, concurrent with increased physical weathering, potentially driven by cooling roughly correlated with MIS4. This drop in occupation coincident with environmental change (and the development of a steppic environment as indicated by the pollen) suggests a semi-abandonment of the cave driven by environmental constraints as a result of this cooling. Yet a continued, low-density occupation during a period in which much of North Africa was de-populated (Ambrose 1998; Barham and Mitchell 2008) still indicates a persistence of groups in the Jebel Akhdar at the Haua Fteah, and the area acting as a potential refuge due to a continued presence of water, in the driven by rainfall or the presence of springs. Yet whether this occupation was consistent throughout the cooler climates of Facies Four or whether occupation was linked to periods (or one period immediately after the Facies’ deposition linked to the large burning feature of Contexts 513/535) of amelioration within this climate, is irresolvable through the available archaeological data. The shift to the fluctuating environments of FaciesThree is accompanied by a further drop in counts of lithics and bone, with low density continuing through Layer XXV until the Late Dabban in XXI near the top of the facies, where it rises sharply. This low density indicates a less intensive use of the cave by both MSA and LSA groups during MIS3. It may be that occupation was restricted to certain types of environments within this fluctuating climatic regime, yet assessment of this lies beyond the present archaeological resolution, and may be further blurred by the taphonomic impact of large mudflows on the archaeology within the cave. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 266 The lithic and bone counts remain relatively high, despite some variation, in comparison with the underlying layers throughout Facies Two, which correlates roughly to the latter part of MIS3 and MIS2. The arrival of LSA Iberomaurusian industries towards the top of the facies, potentially just following the LGM, marked a major explosion in the amount of cultural material within the cave. Later Dabban and Early Iberomaurusian occupations within Facies Two took place in a period of cooling, with sporadic variations in rainfall triggering repeated episodes of soil inwash and erosion in an unstable landscape. This is coincident with increased aridity and depopulation elsewhere across North Africa, and potentially illustrates a continued (but altered) rainfall regime within the Jebel Akhdar that was still higher than the surrounding regions, potentially allowing it to act as a refuge of populations, as in Facies Four during MIS4. The Iberomaurusian was replaced by the Capsian, and later Neolithic and Historic populations within Facies One, which appeared to be largely warmer from the faunal analyses, yet was still marked with Figure 9.4: Summary of environmental interpretations, cultural sequence and occupation density in the Haua Fteah as developed in this thesis, with cultural sequence and occupation density after McBurney (1967). -1m -2m -3m -4m -5m 0m -6m -7m Neolithic Layers IV-VIII Capsian Layers IX-X Iberomaurusian Layers X-XV Dabban Layers XXV-XVI Levalloiso- Mousterian Layers XXXV-XXV Historical Layers I-IV Cultural Sequence Environmental Interpretation 0-14kyaLate Glacial-Holocene Unstable landscape, change in useof shelter. 70-85kya~OIS5a Punctuated instablity,but largely stable. Denseoccupation. F1 F2 F3 F4 F5 Occupation Density Very low Low Moderately high Moderately High VeryHigh Low Depth belowground 14-30kya-~OIS2 Coolingwith massivelandscape instability causing soilerosion AND/OR increasedanthropogenic input 60-70kya~OIS4 Cooling,sporadically unstable landscape 30-60kya~OIS3 Intermittently unstable-rapid shiftsin climate,becoming increasingly cool. Intermittentlymesictowards top,but also increased punctuated soil erosion bounding cool periods. Chapter Nine: Synthesis and Discussion 267 periods of soil inwash linked to Holocene variations in climates as well as potentially linked to human activity and agriculture in later prehistory and the historical periods. 9.8 Summary The above discussion has outlined an environmental framework for the current cultural sequence as documented at theHaua Fteah. DuringMIS5a the cave, occupied by populationswithMSAtechnology, appears to have been in a relativelymesic landscape, with only sporadic periods of landscape instability. Occupation density dropped markedly with the onset of cooling inMIS4, yet dropped even lower with the shift to more fluctuating conditions in MIS3. This low-density occupation continued following the arrival of LSA Dabban industries, and remained low until a rise in density within the Dabban during the end of MIS3 against an overall trend of cooling. Higher density Dabban occupations continued throughout cooler conditions in MIS2, with the arrival of the Iberomaurusian, potentially following the LGM, marking a major increase in occupation density within the cave. The hyper-aridity present across North Africa during glacial periods is not evident at the Haua Fteah, and instead the impact of such regional aridity may have been tempered by the local topography of the Jebel Akhdar, making it a potential refuge for populations during glacials. 268 Chapter Ten: Assessment, Conclusions and Future Research Directions 10.1 Introduction This chapter summarises the conclusions of this thesis for reconstructing environments from cave sediments, and the implications for the study of site formation processes for archaeological and palaeoenvironmental data recovered from sites. It then considers the implications of the environmental history outlined in this thesis for reconstructing NorthAfrican palaeoenvironments, and understanding the environmental contexts of Middle and Later Stone Age populations and their ability to adapt to environmental change. 10.2 Reconstructing Environments from Cave Sediments This thesis has demonstrated the potential of cave sediments for tracing environmental change through the interpretation of site formation processes based on bulk sedimentological and micromorphological analyses, as well as some of the difficulties and ambiguities in interpreting the external environments that drove, or did not drive, cave depositional processes. As discussed in the preceding chapter (Section 9.2), the interpretation of external environments from the sediments within the Haua Fteah is complex, as the processes observed in the cave relate in different ways to changes in the landscape and local climate. Large-scale colluvial events probably directly document periods of widespread erosion, whilst roof-spall and calcite precipitation are driven by climatic processes moderated by the cave micro-environment, placing them one step removed from the impact of these changes on the landscape. Aeolian/dusty sediments, the result of potentially very localised reworking of material, were deposited during a wide range of external environments as indicated by the other proxies from the cave (see Chapter 9, Section 9.4.1) and are therefore not useful for interpreting external environments in themselves. The differing extents to which the processes within the cave can be robustly linked to changes in the landscape therefore illustrates the impact of the unique characteristics of each cave on the sediment it captures (Bailey and Woodward 1997; Farrand 2001b). The Haua Fteah, situated within a relatively shallow cliff incline in a Mediterranean environment is particularly well-placed to trace periods of colluvial movement. Mediterranean and semi-arid landscapes are particularly susceptible to colluvial erosion (Grove and Rackham 2001; Wainwright 2009), and the cave’s wide opening and the large depression at its mouth could easily catch colluvial material. On the other hand, its north-facing aspect and position on the north side of the Jebel Akhdar, in the lee of Saharan winds, mean that it is poorly placed to record aeolian mobilisation across the Sahara during glacials. Whether or not this aeolian mobilisation impacted anywhere on the Jebel Akhdar is irresolvable from the cave sediments, and remains to be clarified from landscape work by TRANS-NAP. This specificity of the cave’s sensitivity to landscape and environmental changes is also detected in the spatial variation of the sediments within the cave itself. Variation between the two profiles examined Chapter Ten: Conclusions 269 in this thesis has highlighted spatial variation in sedimentation, with a number of lenses of inwash confined to the West-Facing Profile (see Chapters Six and Seven). The same is true of a number of calcite layers in Facies Three. The location of the trench within the cave therefore has a major bearing on the types of sediments which may be preserved and observed. A trench further towards the opening (for location of trench see Figure 4.2) might include sediment from more, slightly smaller, inwash episodes, whilst nearer the dripline the sediments might also be influenced further by dripping and calcite precipitation (as can be seen in the almost complete concretion of the South-Facing Profile). Yet these processes may blur the impact of others, and a more exposed position may allow the major reworking and erosion of sediments. A trench further into the cave might not detect any influence of periods of inwash. The retreat of the dripline will also have altered the cave’s morphology over time, with the location of the dripline moving closer to the trench, although the rate, timing and impact of such retreat is unknown. However, the variability of the sediments within the cave can and should be explored further through coring and test-pitting in front of the cave where sediments may be shallower to gain a fuller understanding of the stratigraphy. Imaging of the underlying bedrock through ground penetrating radar would also allow the assessment of areas that may be sheltered from certain sedimentological processes. The thesis has also demonstrated the strength of integrating micromorphological analyses with bulk sedimentology to trace site formation processes over a wide range of temporal scales. The trends traced in the bulk sedimentology allowed the refinement of field observations, mainly through the variable magnetic susceptibility of the sediments tracing periods of potential soil and aeolian deposition. In turn, these interpretations were tested and further refined by the micromorphological observations from Facies Five to Three. Micromorphological analysis proved crucial in providing robust interpretations of the site formation processes which would otherwise have been misidentified or left ambiguous from the bulk sedimentological data, as in the interpretation of Facies Two without supportingmicromorphological data (Chapter Nine, Section 9.3.5). This highlights wider issues related to the use of bulk sedimentological analyses in caves and rockshelters where modes of sedimentation are complex and context-specific, and where the measured values for a variable can reflect a number of quite different processes, including post-depositional processes such as leaching (e.g. CaCO 3 ). Such analyses remain low resolution in cave environments, and their usefulness is limited without the support of micromorphological data and observations of the sedimentation to assess factors such as bioturbation and leaching on a sequence (the effects of which appear to be limited in the Haua Fteah). The time and cost-intensive nature of micromorphological analysis will always render it impractical for the total coverage of deep sequences, yet by integrating micromorphological data within a bulk sedimentological framework for some layers, models can be developed for areas without micromorphological coverage and then sampled and tested in a more targeted manner. In this manner, future work at the Haua Fteah should therefore focus on the targeted sampling of sediments within Facies Two for micromorphological analysis to clarify the potential sources of its high magnetic susceptibility. The bulk sedimentological data, however, is not rendered redundant by micromorphological analysis Chapter Ten: Conclusions 270 as it provides valuable, quantitative information that cannot be drawn from the micromorphological observations. For example, at the Haua Fteah, magnetic susceptibility has been shown to be influenced by sediment source, with soil inwash events correlated with magnetic susceptibility peaks (Chapter Six). Whilst these events were all identified by soil micromorphology as inwash events, the variable magnetic susceptibility of the layers potentially indicates a subtler picture, with increasingly older well-developed soils being eroded in the latter stages of Facies Three, marking escalating landscape degradation. In other caves and rockshelters, frequency-dependent magnetic susceptibility measurements have been used to trace trends in climate through the weathering states of the soils (Ellwood and Gose 2006; Ellwood et al. 1995, 1996, 1997, 2004). Whilst issues such as the time lag between soil formation and erosion make interpretation of data in this way problematic, identification of the magnetic minerals through frequency-dependent magnetic susceptibility can aid in the characterisation of source materials. This information can be linked into wider landscape models of erosion, expanding the understanding of the sedimentation of the site. Whilst the particle size measurements were potentially problematic (see Chapter Five, Section 5.3.1), the ambiguity of the micritic calcitic silt in the micromorphological observations merits further investigation. By combining the existing, non-carbonate, particle size data with future measurement of the particle size of the complete sample, the problems posed by secondary carbonate concretion and roof-spall can both be identified alongside potential carbonate loess influence. The identification of aeolian deposits within the sediments would also be strengthened through the application of granulometry. Above all, integration of bulk sedimentology and soil micromorphology, as well as adding to the robusticity of the sedimentological model, has allowed the examination of the sediment sequence at a number of scales. Whilst soil micromorphology can identify sub-millimetre episodes of deposition which may represent a single gust of wind in an aeolian/dusty environment, or confirm the character of a single inwash event, which have direct implications for the taphonomy of single layers (see below), the correlation of these events to actual climatic cycles is only achieved with the long-term trends over the whole depth at the scale of global climatic cycles, be they glacial cycles or millennial- scale variations, as traced through bulk sedimentology and field observations. With these nested approaches, the sequence can be interrogated at a number of scales that vary in relation to the level of specificity required. The limited microstratigraphic analysis of the MSA hearths has demonstrated the potential for behavioural reconstruction through the stratigraphy as highlighted by a number of authors (Goldberg 2000; Goldberg et al. 2009; Karkanas et al. 2004; Sergant et al. 2006; Shahack-Gross et al. 2004; Vallverdú et al. 2005;Wattez et al. 1990). The investigation of these hearths was only preliminary, and could be developed further through the analysis of phytoliths in thin section and in bulk samples to further discern the fuels used, to reconstruct the availability of the different vegetation around the cave (Albert et al. 2003;Madella et al. 2002; Shahack-Gross et al. 2003, 2004). More detailed geochemical work on the sediments, including Fourier-Transform Infra-Red spectroscopy (Goldberg et al. 2001, In Press; Mallol et al. 2009) would also allow the discernment of various complex diagenetic pathways that are unclear in the micromorphological analyses. Yet the stratigraphy of the MSA hearths within Chapter Ten: Conclusions 271 this cave has provided a snapshot of activity that has gone far beyond the resolution offered by the other archaeological material, documenting individual events of hearth cleaning by groups of Homo sapiens with distinct similarities to the practices of Neanderthal groups in the Levant and Southern Europe. Within a more detailed archaeological framework developed by the TRANS-NAP project, both through excavations and reanalysis of the McBurney archive, analyses such as these have the potential to contribute massively to the debates surrounding the activities and behavioural capacities of hominin populations both in North Africa, and further afield. 10.3 Site Formation Processes and Archaeological Sequences in Caves and Rockshelters As well as contributing to environmental reconstruction, the study of site formation processes has far-reaching implications for archaeological work in caves and rockshelters. These processes create the stratigraphic record which contains the archaeological material used to construct cultural chronologies, and therefore must be understood in order to provide a robust understanding of this archaeological record. The characterisation of site formation processes has identified varying rates of sedimentation.Although present chronological resolution hampers the quantification of these rates (See Chapter Nine, Section 9.5), when this is refined, these changing sedimentation rates will be linked into the new archaeological records from the TRANS-NAP excavations. This will allow a fuller understanding of the length of time represented by archaeological assemblages from each layer, and the types of questions which can therefore be asked of them with regards to individual or group behaviour (Bailey 2007; Bailey and Galanidou 2009). Furthermore, by understanding site formation processes, stratigraphy which has been subject to reworking or truncation can be identified, e.g. in the Layer XXV sediments. Without definitive recognition of these truncations and possible inversions, false cultural sequences can be developedwith far-reaching consequences for our knowledge of population histories and replacements. In the case of the Haua Fteah, the exact conditions of the replacement of theMSA by the Dabban may never be definitely knowable, due to reworking by mudflows, and interpretations instead restricted to the overall environmental trends around that time. In a similar way as the site formation history identifies the taphonomic processes linked to the burial of artefacts, it identifies the taphonomic history of various palaeoenvironmental proxy records contained within the sediments. Proxies such as pollen and phytoliths are heavily affected by these taphonomic processes (Simpson andHunt 2009). Soil inwashmay transport sediments and their pollen assemblages into the cave under conditions very different from those that first deposited the pollen. Yet these proxies provide valuable palaeoenvironmental information cannot be extracted from sedimentological analyses alone (see Chapter Nine, Section 9.4.1), further highlighting the need for multi-disciplinarity in palaeoenvironmental reconstruction. These issues of taphonomy and sediment recycling are also highly relevant to the application of dating methods.Assessing the taphonomic pathways which tephra has passed through is crucial to the assessment of the robusticity of tephrochronology dates (Morley and Woodward 2011), and the potential for deposits to have become deflated, re-deposited or only Chapter Ten: Conclusions 272 partially exposed or re-exposed to sunlight has far-reaching implications for the applicability of OSL dating (Bailey et al. 1997). Understanding the formationprocesseswithin archaeological sites is therefore vital to the understanding of the archaeological record, the environmental proxies from the sediments and their chronological controls. When these taphonomic problems are identified and integrated into interpretations of data, cave sediments can provide vital environmental information directly linked to the archaeological material, at a resolution of correlation unobtainable from off-site records. 10.4 The Jebel Akhdar and North African Environmental Change The sedimentation environments of the Haua Fteah appear to trace the impact of global glacial cycles over the past 80,000 years on NorthAfrican environments, with glacial stages characterised by cooling and landscape degradation, and warming and stabilisation accompanying interstadial and interglacial phases. Global instability during MIS3 is reflected in sediments which documenting frequent cycles of stabilisation and instability, consistent with variability in rainfall and rainfall patterning over North Africa. The environmental interpretation proposed in this thesis of cooler landscapes during stadials and glacials at the Haua Fteah, indicates that the Jebel Akhdar was not completely isolated from the global changes that affectedNorth Africa.Yet, whilst the environment cooled at the Haua Fteah during glacial periods, there is no evidence of the hyper-aridity witnessed across North Africa in the Haua Fteah sediments (although this may be a taphonomic factor, as discussed in Section 10.2). Therefore, although the JebelAkhdar was influenced by global environmental shifts, the area may still have been more attractive to populations than the rest of North Africa, similar to other potential refuges such as areas of the Nile Valley and the Maghreb. The sporadic inwash during the glacial periods identified in the cave indicate an at least sporadic regime of rainfall in the area, potentially driven by the southward migration of storms from the Atlantic and Southern Europe, although the extent of the impact of this on vegetation is, once more, unclear from the sediments alone. It remains difficult to extrapolate the environment of the Jebel Akhdar in relation to the rest of Africa from a single site, and future geomorphological work by TRANS-NAP both within the landscape and other caves will be crucial for developing models of landscape change in the Jebel Akhdar. This study has, however, provided a chronologically-controlled history of largely environmentally- driven sedimentation spanning most of the last glacial cycle. This sequence can therefore be used as a cornerstone for the wider landscape work and broad-scale shifts observed in the geomorphology, as it is far higher in resolution and more complete than many of the external palaeoenvironmental archives. Above all, understanding the depositional environments within the Haua Fteah allows the direct, robust correlation of the external environmental changes which drove changes in the cave sedimentation with the changes, or lack of changes, observed in the cultural sequence, correlation which is vital in the examination of human-environment interactions. Chapter Ten: Conclusions 273 10.5 Environment and Human Interactions During the MSA-LSA The environmental history outlined in this thesis contains major climatic shifts that appear to have impacted upon the demography of the groups that occupied the cave as inferred from the 1950s sequence. Although use of this archaeological data to assess occupation density is problematic (see Chapter Four, Section 4.2.2), it is the only cultural data available for comparison with environmental archives ahead of the results of the ongoing TRANS-NAP excavations. The environmental changes reflected in the sedimentology and other proxy data do not appear to correlate with cultural changes, yet coincide with changes in occupation density and potentially therefore demography. The relatively high density of MSA occupations in the relatively stable Facies Five (roughly equivalent to MIS5a) is consistent with the association of MSA industries across North Africa with mesic environments (Barham and Mitchell 2008; Garcea 2004). Following the end of MIS5, hyper-aridity in MIS4 appears to have forced the depopulation of large areas of North Africa, pushing populations into refugia (Ambrose 1998; Marean and Assefa 2005). This trend is observed in the major drop in occupation density in the Haua Fteah in Facies Four associated with cooler environments, yet this cooling is not associated with evidence of sustained aridity, potentially indicating that the Haua Fteah was still moister than the rest of North Africa. This buffering of the hyper-aridity seen in other areas of North Africa may have occurred through the unique topographic character of the Jebel Akhdar, such as it does today, and producing a refuge of sorts for populations. The reduced occupation density within the cave during MIS4 implies, however, that whilst aridity was potentially buffered in the area around the Haua Fteah through local factors, the environmental effects of glacial conditions were still felt. Such a massive impact on cave occupation may be related to the inability ofMSA populations to remain in the same number and density within the Jebel Akhdar during this period of cooling; subsistence strategies employed by theMSA population may have been altered due to changes in vegetation and faunal potentially requiring lower density occupation by more mobile groups. Yet it must be remembered that, due to the low archaeological resolution, it cannot be confirmed if this was a complete or partial de-population (see Chapter Nine, Section 9.6), and this will only be confirmed through the renewed excavations by TRANS-NAP. The occupation record of the cave during Facies Three, correlating broadly with MIS3, is crucial to assessing the relationships between cultural and environmental change as it contains the replacement of the MSA by the Dabban. Occupation density in Facies Three (disregarding potential changes in sedimentation rate) is even lower than in Facies Four/MIS4, and remains so throughout the facies in both the MSA and Dabban layers. This suggests that environmental constraints limited populations with both MSA and LSA technologies to a similar degree during the fluctuating environments of MIS3, and the restrictions placed on populations by this environmental context was even moremarked than in the cool environments of MIS4. The early Dabban did not necessarily therefore confer an adaptive advantage to groups occupying the Haua Fteah over those using MSA technology. This low density inMIS3 may indicate sporadic use of the cave or low-density occupation, potentially by small, Chapter Ten: Conclusions 274 quite mobile groups. Relatively rapidly fluctuating environments during this period may have left an environment and landscape which populations could not inhabit permanently, but which may have allowed seasonal population or population during briefly more mesic periods. Alternatively, the Jebel Akhdar may have been isolated by the expansion of desertic areas, only accessible from other areas of North Africa during more humid periods. In both scenarios, there is the possibility that MSAand LSA populations may have also occupied different environments within these fluctuations during MIS3, yet the assessment of this is beyond present archaeological resolution. The Dabban industry first appears at the Haua Fteah during a period when, overall, the colder phases in these environmental fluctuations appear to be getting colder in an increasingly degraded landscape during MIS3. It may therefore mark an adaptive response to the cooler environments, or may reflect occupation of the area during a humid phase by a groupwho had developed such technology elsewhere. Yet, given the presence of inwash events in Layer XXV and the unclear relationship between these wash events and the sub-layers defined by McBurney as Dabban or MSA, the exact sedimentary environments at the appearance of the Dabban are unclear. Without this archaeological resolution, it is also unclear as to if the 14C date of 44,540-45,789 cal. BP from the middle of Layer XXV is associated with the earliest Dabban levels, or if it pre-dates (or indeed post-dates) their appearance (Context 494, from which the charcoal was taken, does not appear to have been subject to colluvial reworking itself). Further resolution and understanding of the sediments will be added with the ongoing excavations carried out by the TRANS-NAP project. Whilst the dating, and indeed existence of similar LSA industries across North Africa is patchy, the date of around 44,540-45,789 cal. BP for the appearance of the Dabban places it earlier than known LSA industries from the Nile Valley c.40,000BP (van Peer and Vermeersch 2007; Vermeersch 2010), as well as far earlier than the LSA from the Mediterranean littoral in the Jebel Gharbi c. 30,000 uncal. bp (Barich et al. 2006; Garcea 2004). It is, however, later than the earliest Levantine Initial Upper Palaeolithic c. 47,000-43,000BP (Bar Yosef 2002; Belfer-Cohen and Goring-Morris 2003). It is therefore chronologically possible that the appearance of the Dabban at the Haua Fteah represents a dispersal of populations bearing early LSA technology from the Levant as proposed initially by McBurney (1967), potentially during a period in which increased humidity allowed the movement of fauna and human populations between North Africa and the Levant. Such fluctuations in humidity and temperature are recorded in the palaeoenvironmental records in the Levant during this period (see Chapter Two; Almogi-Labin et al. 2004). Yet the degree to which the Dabban represents a complete cultural break from the underlying MSA levels at the Haua Fteah has been challenged (Marks 1975; Garcea 2010; see discussion in Section 2.3.2). Instead, the situation may have been more nuanced; Garcea has argued towards the potential diffusion of technologies through populations along the wider Mediterranean coastal zone, resulting in the transmission of technologies from areas such as the Levant to the Libyan coast during MIS3 (Garcea 2010) perhaps in response to unique challenges faced by populations inhabiting the littoral and NileValley during these climatic oscillations whilst the vast majority of the interior of the region remained largely arid. Yet the lack of LSA sites from North Africa renders this largely still speculation and further research is required in order to place the timing Chapter Ten: Conclusions 275 of the Dabban in its regional context. The environmental history outlined by this thesis highlights one major difference between the environments inhabited by MSA and LSA populations within the Haua Fteah sequence. Whilst it appears that MSA occupations were significantly curtailed by cooling correlating with MIS4, the Dabban occupation rose in density with increased, prolonged cooling during sediments correlating with the end of MIS3 and MIS2. LSA technology, specifically the Later Dabban, therefore may have allowed populations to adapt to a wider range of conditions than was possible with MSA technology. Therefore, despite environmental deterioration in the area, as traced in the Haua Fteah sediments, the Jebel Akhdar appears to have been a refuge for LSA populations from the widespread aridity across much of North Africa that characterised MIS2 and the LGM. The Haua Fteah is only one of many sites frequented and occupied by populations throughout the last 80,000 years in North Africa. Periods identified through the site sequence as occupation ‘lows’ may simply represent a lack of the use of the cave by populations who were present elsewhere in the Jebel Akhdar. Archaeological survey and targeted excavation of other sites in the area are therefore sorely needed to expand understanding of the cultural chronology of the Jebel Akhdar. Yet, as with the environmental data, the Haua Fteah sequence provides a unique long-term sequence of occupation which can be linked directly to the environmental proxies outlined in this thesis, and is thus a crucial cornerstone for our understanding of the environmental context of Late Pleistocene populations in North Africa. 10.6 Summary The environmental history presented in this thesis has allowed the examination of long-term human- environment interactions with a robusticity previously unobtainable. It appears that the area was subject to major environmental fluctuations, which did impact on the populations which occupied the Haua Fteah, yet it still may have remained a refuge during glacial periods and the hyper-aridity which accompanied them in North Africa. The level of occupation during these glacial periods indicate that LSA populations were more able to adapt to long-term cooler environments in the Jebel Akhdar than MSA populations, yet both populations were constrained by fluctuating environments during MIS3. It appears therefore that the LSAmay well have represented an increased technological ability to adapt to different environments that was lacking during the MSA. This assessment of the environmental context of the cultural changes shown at the Haua Fteah was only possible through the examination of an environmental proxy (cave sedimentation) that can be directly correlated to the archaeological sequence. These sediments record environmental change at a number of scales, from global, glacial cycles, to single erosive events. Whilst sedimentation within caves is moderated by the characteristics of the cave, and each sequence must therefore be considered in its local setting and morphology, the sequence at the Haua Fteah traces environmental change in North African environments over glacial and potentially millennial scales. When high-resolution studies of site formation processes based on micromorphological analyses and bulk sedimentology are Chapter Ten: Conclusions 276 combined with other environmental proxies they provide a high-resolution record of environmental change. These site formation processes also underpin the taphonomy of all of these other proxies, and the archaeologicalmaterial. As these palaeoenvironmental and archaeological investigations continue, the sequence of site formation processes will provide a vital control on the resolution of these analyses, and the questions which can be asked of them. 277 References Albert, R.M., O. Lavi, L. Estroff, S.Weiner, A. Tsatskin, A. Ronen, and S. Lev-Yadun (1999) Mode of occupation of Tabun Cave, Mt Carmel, Israel during the Mousterian period: A study of the sediments and phytoliths. Journal of Archaeological Science 26, 1249–60. Albert, R. M. S. Weiner, O. Bar-Yosef, L. Meignen (2000) Phytoliths in the Middle Palaeolithic deposits of Kebara Cave, Mt Carmel, Israel: study of the plant materials used for fuel and other purposes. Journal of Archaeological Science 27(10), 931–47. Albert, R.M., O. Bar-Yosef, L.Meignen, and S. Weiner (2003) Quantitative phytolith study of hearths from the Natufian and Middle Palaeolithic levels of Hayonim Cave (Galilee, Israel). Journal of Archaeological Science 30, 461–80. Albert, R. M. F. Berna, P. Goldberg (In Press) Insights on Neanderthal fire use at Kebara Cave (Israel) through high resolution study of prehistoric combustion features: Evidence from phytoliths and thin sections. Quaternary International doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2010.10.016. Allen, J. R. M., and B. Huntley (2009) Last Interglacial palaeovegetation, palaeoenvironments and chronology: a new record from Lago Grande di Monticchio, southern Italy. Quaternary Science Reviews 28, 1521–38. Allen, J. R. M., U. Brandt, A. Brauer, H.-W. Hubberten, B. Huntley, J. Kellerk, M. Kramlk, A. Mackensen, J. Mingram, J. F. W. Negendank, N. R. Nowaczyk, H. Oberhänsli, W. A. Watts, S. Wulf, and B. Zolitschka (1999) Rapid environmental changes in southern Europe during the last glacial period. Nature 400, 740–43. Allen, J. R. M., W. A.Watts, and B. Huntley (2000) Weichselian palynostratigraphy, palaeovegetation and palaeoenvironment; the record from Lago Grande di Monticchio, southern Italy. Quaternary International 73/74, 91–110. Almogi-Labin, A., M. Bar-Matthews, and A. Ayalon (2004) Climate variability in the Levant and Northeast Africa during the Late Quaternary based on marine and land records. In N. Goren-Inbar and J. D. Speth, eds, Human Palaeoecology in the Levantine Corridor. Oxford: Oxbow, 117–34. Ambrose, S. H. (1998) Late Pleistocene human population bottlenecks, volcanic winter, and differentation of modern humans. Journal of Human Evolution 34, 623–51. Ambrose, S. H. (2003) Did the super-eruption of Toba cause a human population bottleneck? Reply to Gathorne-Hardy and Harcourt-Smith. Journal of Human Evolution 45, 231–37. Andersen, K. K., A. Svensson, S. J. Johnsen, S. O. Rasmussen, M. Bigler, R. Röthlisberger, U. Ruth, M.-L. Siggaard-Andersen, J. P. Steffensen, D. Dahl-Jensen, B. M. Vinther, and H. B. Clausen (2006) The Greenland ice core chronology 2005, 15–42 ka. Part 1: constructing the time scale. Quaternary Science Reviews 25, 3246–57. Angelucci, D. E., G. Boschian, M. Fontanals, A. Pedrotti, and J. M. Vergès (2009) Shepherds and karst: the use of caves and rock-shelters in the Mediterranean region during the Neolithic. World Archaeology 41:2, 191–214. Anketell, J. M. (1989) Quaternary deposits of Northern Libya: lithostratigraphy and correlation. Libyan Studies 20, 1–29. Anketell, J. M., and S. M. Ghellali (1988) Stratigraphy of the Qasr Al Haj formation, fan gravel deposits of Quaternary age, Tripolitania, SPLAJ. Libyan Studies 19, 123–131. References 278 Anketell, J. M., and S. M. Ghellali (1990) Stratigraphic relationship of basalt lava flows to the Pleistocene sedimentary sequence of the Mizdah region, Tripolitania, SPLAJ. Libyan Studies 21, 61–64. Anketell, J. M., and S. M. Ghellali (1991) Quaternary fluvio-aeolian sand/silt and alluvial gravel deposits of northern Libya – event stratigraphy and correlation. Journal of African Earth Sciences 13:3/4, 457–69. Anketell, J. M., and S. M. Ghellali (1992) The Karawak and Quarabulli members of the Jifarah Formation – Later Pleistocene aeolian and lacustrine deposits – Northwestern Libya. Libyan Studies 23, 1–6. Armitage, S. J., N. A. Drake, S. Stokes, A. El-Hawat, M. J. Salem, K. White, P. Turner, and S. J. McLaren (2007) Multiple phases of NorthAfrican humidity recorded in lacustrine sediments from the Fazzan Basin, Libyan Sahara. Quaternary Geochronology 2, 181–6. Arz, H. W., F. Lamy, J. Pätzold, P. J. Müller, and M. Prins (2003) Mediterranean moisture source for an Early Holocene humid period in the Northern Red Sea. Science 300, 118–21. Assallay, A. M., C. D. F. Rogers, I. J. Smalley, and I. F. Jefferson (1998) Silt: 2–62 mm, 9–4 Φ. Earth- Science Reviews 45, 61–88. Bailey, G. N. (2007) Time perspectives, palimpsests and the archaeology of time. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 26, 198–223. Bailey, G. N. (2008) The coastal shelf of the Mediterranean and beyond: corridor and refugium for human populations in the Pleistocene. Quaternary Science Reviews 27, 2095–99. Bailey, G. N., and N. Galanidou (2009) Caves, palimpsests and dwelling spaces: examples from the Upper Palaeolithic of south-east Europe.World Archaeology 41:2, 215–41. Bailey, G. N., and J. C. Woodward (1997) The Klithi deposits: sedimentology, stratigraphy and chronology. In G. N. Bailey, ed. Klithi: Palaeolithic Settlement and Quaternary Landscapes in Northwest Greece. Cambridge: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, 61–94. Bailey, R.M., B.W. Smith, and E. J. Rhodes (1997) Partial bleaching and the decay form characteristics of quartz OSL. Radiation Measurements 27, 123–35. Bar-Matthews, M., A. Ayalon, and A. Kaufman (1997) Late Quaternary palaeoclimates in the Eastern Mediterranean region from stable isotope analysis of spelethems at Soreq Cave, Israel. Quaternary Research 47, 155–68. Bar-Matthews, M., A. Ayalon, A. Kaufman, and G. J. Wasserburg (1999) The Eastern Mediterranean paleoclimate as a reflection of regional events: Soreq cave, Israel. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 166, 85–95. Bar-Matthews, M.,A.Ayalon, andA. Kaufman (2000) Timing and hydrological conditions of sapropel events in the Eastern Mediterranean, as evident from speleothems, Soreq cave, Israel. Chemical Geology 169, 145–56. Bar-Matthews, M., A. Ayalon, M. Gilmour, A. Matthews, and C. J. Hawkesworth (2003) Sea– land oxygen isotopic relationships from planktonic foraminifera and speleothems in the Eastern Mediterranean region and their implication for paleorainfall during interglacial intervals.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 67:17, 3181–99. References 279 Bar-Yosef, O. (1993) Site formation processes from a Levantine viewpoint. In P. Goldberg, D. T. Nash and M. D. Petraglia, eds, Formation Processes in Archaeological Context. Madison: Prehistory Press, 11–32. Bar-Yosef, O. (2002) TheUpper Palaeolithic Revolution. Annual Review of Anthropology 31, 363–93. Bar-Yosef, O. (2007)The dispersal ofmodern humans in Eurasia: a cultural interpretation. In P.Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef and C. Stringer, eds, Rethinking the Human Revolution: New Behavioural and Biological Perspectives on the Origin and Dispersal of Modern Humans. Cambridge: McDonald Institute. 207–218. Bar-Yosef, O., and A. Belfer-Cohen (2010) The Levantine Upper Palaeolithic and Epipalaeolithic. In E. A. A. Garcea, ed. South-Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 54–65. Bard, E., G. Delaygue, F. Rostek, F.Antonioli, S. Silenzi, D. P. Schrag (2002). Hydrological conditions over the western Mediterranean basin during the deposition of the cold Sapropel 6 (ca. 175 kyr BP). Earth and Planetary Science Letters 202: 481-494. Barham, L., and P. Mitchell (2008) The First Africans. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Barich, B. (2006) The archaeology of Jebel Gharbhi – contributions to the knowledge of the Pleistocene–Holocene transition in Libya. In K. Kroeper, M. Chłodnicki and M. Kobusiewicz, eds, Archaeology of Early Northeastern Africa: In Memory of Lech Krzyżaniak. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 959–70. Barich, B., E. A. A. Garcea, C. C. Barbaro, and C. Giraudi (2003) The Ras el Wadi sequence in the Jebel Gharbhi and the Late Pleistocene cultures of Northern Libya. In L. Kyzyzaniak, K. Kroeper and M. Kobusiewicz, eds, Cultural Markers in the Later Prehistory of Northeast Africa and Present Research. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 11–20. Barich, B., E. A. A. Garcea, and C. Giraudi (2006) Between the Mediterranean and the Sahara: geoarchaeological reconnaisance in the Jebel Gharbi, Libya. Antiquity 80:309, 567–82. Barker, G., C. O. Hunt, T. Reynolds, I. Brooks, and H. el-Rishi (2007a) The Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica (Northeast Libya): renewed investigations of the cave and its landscape, 2007. Libyan Studies 38, 93–114. Barker, G., H. Barton, H. Bird, P. Daly, I. Datan, A. Dykes, L. Farr, D. D. Gilbertson, B. Harrisson, C. O. Hunt, T. Higham, L. Kealhofer, J. Krigbaum, H. Lewis, S. McLaren, V. Paz, A. Pike, P. Piper, B. Pyatt, R. Rabett, T. Reynolds, J. Rose, G. Rushworth, M. Stephens, C. Stringer, J. Thompson, and C. Turney (2007b) The ‘human revolution’ in lowland tropical Southeast Asia: the antiquity and behavior of anatomically modern humans at Niah Cave (Sarawak, Borneo). Journal of Human Evolution 52, 243–61. Barker, G., L. Basell, I. Brooks, C. Cartwright, F. Cole, J. Davison, L. Farr, R. Grün, R. Hamilton, C. Hunt, R. Inglis, Z. Jacobs, T. Legge, V. Leitch, J. Morales, I. Morley, M. Morley, S. Pawley, A. Pryor, R. Roberts, T. Reynolds, H. el-Rishi, D. Simpson, M. Twati, and M. van der Veen (2008) The Cyrenaican Prehistory Project 2008: the second season of investigations of the Haua Fteah cave and its landscape, and further results from the initial (2007) fieldwork. Libyan Studies 39, 175–221. References 280 Barker, G., A. Antoniadou, H. Barton, I. Brooks, I. Candy, N. A. Drake, L. Farr, C. Hunt, A. A. Ibrahim, R. Inglis, S. Jones, J. Morales, I. Morley, G. Mutri, R. Rabett, T. Reynolds, D. Simpson, M. Twati, andK. White (2009) The Cyrenaican Prehistory Project 2009: the third season of investigations of the Haua Fteah cave and its landscape, and further results from the 2007–2008 fieldwork. Libyan Studies 40, 55–94. Barker, G., A. Antoniadou, S. Armitage, I. Brooks, I. Candy, K. Connell, K. Douka, N. Drake, L. Farr, E. Hill, C. Hunt, R. Inglis, S. Jones, C. Lane, G. Lucarini, J. Meneeley, J. Morales, G. Mutri, A. Prendergast, R. Rabett, H. Reade, T. Reynolds, N. Russell, D. Simpson, B. Smith, C. Stimpson, M. Twati, andK.White (2010) The Cyrenaican Prehistory Project 2010: the fourth season of investigations of the Haua Fteah cave and its landscape, and further results from the 2007–2009 fieldwork. Libyan Studies 41, 63–88. Barton, C. M., and G. A. Clark (1993) Cultural and natural formation processes in Late Quaternary cave and rockshelter sites of Western Europe and the Near East. In P. Goldberg, D. T. Nash and M. D. Petraglia, eds, Formation Processes in Archaeological Context.Madison: Prehistory Press, 33–52. Barton, R. N. E. (2000) Mousterian hearths and shellfish: later Neanderthal activities on Gibraltar. In C. B. Stringer, R. N. E. Barton and J. C. Finlayson, eds, Neanderthals on the Edge. Oxford: Oxbow, 211-200. Barton, R. N. E., A. Bouzouggar, S. Collcutt, R. Gale, T. Higham, L. T. Humphrey, S. Parfitt, E. Rhodes, C. Stringer, and F. Malek (2005) The Late Upper Palaeolithic occupation of the Moroccan Northwest Maghreb during the Last Glacial Maximum. African Archaeological Review 22:2, 77–100. Barton, R. N. E., A. Bouzouggar, C. Bronk-Ramsey, S. Collcutt, T. F. G. Higham, L. T. Humphrey, S. A. Parfitt, E. J. Rhodes, J.-L. Schwenninger, C. Stringer, E. Turner, and S. Ward (2007) Abrupt climatic change and chronology of the Upper Palaeolithic in Northern and Eastern Morocco. In P. Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef and C. Stringer, eds, Rethinking the Human Revolution. Cambridge: McDonald Institute, 177–86. Barton, R. N. E., A. Bouzouggar, L. T. Humphrey, P. Berridge, S. Collcutt, E. Galili, S. Parfitt, A. Parker, E. J. Rhodes, and J.-L. Schwenninger (2008) Human burial evidence from Hattab II Cave and the question of continuity in Late Pleistocene–Holocene mortuary practices in Northwest Africa. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 18:2, 195–214. Barton, R. N. E.,A. Bouzouggar, S. N. Collcutt, J.-L. Schwenninger, and L. Clark-Balzan (2009) OSL dating of the Aterian levels at Dar es-Soltan I (Rabat, Morocco) and implications for the dispersal of modern Homo sapiens. Quaternary Science Reviews 28:19–20, 1914–31. Becker, A., C. Davenport, U. Eichenberger, E. Gilli, P.-Y. Jeannin, and C. Lacave (2006) Speleoseismology: a critical perspective. Journal of Seismology 10:3, 371–88. Becze-Deák, J., R. Langohr, andE. P.Verrecchia (1997) Small scale secondaryCaCO 3 accumulations in selected sections of the European loess belt.Morphological forms and potential for paleoenvironmental reconstruction. Geoderma 76, 221–52. Behrensmeyer, A. K. (1978) Taphonomic and ecologic information from bone weathering. Paleobiology 4:2, 150–62. Belfer-Cohen, A., and A. N. Goring-Morris (2003) Current issues in Levantine Upper Palaeolithic research. In N. A. Goring-Morris and A. Belfer-Cohen, eds, More Than Meets the Eye: Studies on Upper Palaeolithic Diversity in the Near East. Oxford: Oxbow. 1–11. References 281 Bell, and J. Boardman (1992) Past and Present Soil Erosion: Archaeological and Geographical Perspectives. Oxford: Oxbow. Berna, F., and P. Goldberg (2007) Assessing Paleolithic pyrotechnology and associated hominin behavior in Israel. Israel Journal of Earth Sciences 34, 358–373. Béthoux, J. P., and B. Gentili (1996) The Mediterranean Sea, coastal and deep-sea signatures of climatic and environmental changes. Journal of Marine Systems 7, 383–94. Béthoux, J. P., and C. Pierre (1999) Mediterranean functioning and sapropel formation: respective influences of climate and hydrological changes in the Atlantic and the Mediterranean. Marine Geology 153, 29–39. Beyin, A. (2006) The Bab al Mandab vs the Nile-Levant: an appraisal of the two dispersal routes for early modern humans out of Africa. African Archaeological Review 23, 5–30. Bischoff, J. L., D. D. Shamp,A. Aramburu, J. L. Arsuaga, E. Carbonell, and J. M. B. de Castro (2003) The Sima de los Huesos hominids date to beyond U/Th equilibrium (>350 kyr) and perhaps to 400– 500 kyr: new radiometric dates. Journal of Archaeological Science 30, 275–80. Bischoff, J. L., R. W. Williams, R. J. Rosenbauer, A. Aramburu, J. L. Arsuaga, N. García, and G. Cuenca-Bescós (2007) High-resolution U-series dates from the Sima de los Huesos hominids yields 600±66 kyrs: implications for the evolution of the early Neanderthal lineage. Journal of Archaeological Science 34, 763–70. Blockhuis, W. A., M. J. Kooistra, and L. P.Wilding (1990) Micromorphology of cracking clayey soils (vertisols). In L.A. Douglas, ed. Soil Micromorphology: A Basic andApplied Science. Proceedings of the VIIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, San Antonio, Texas, July 1988. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 123–48. Boggs, S. (2001) Principles of Sedimentology and Stratigraphy. 3rd ed. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall. Bond, G., H. Heinrich,W. S. Broecker, L. Labeyrie, J. McManus, J. E.Andrews, S. Huon, R. Jantschik, S. Clasen, C. Simet, K.Tedesco,M.Klas, G. Bonani, and S. Ivy (1992) Evidence formassive discharges of icebergs into the North Atlantic ocean during the last glacial period. Nature 360, 245–49. Bond, G., W. S. Broecker, S. J. Johnsen, J. McManus, L. Labeyrie, J. Jouzel, and G. Bonani (1993) Correlations between climate records from North Atlantic sediments and Greenland ice. Nature 365:143–147. Boschian, G. (1997) Sedimentology and Soil Micromorphology of the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene Deposits of Grotta dell’Edera (Trieste Karst, NE Italy). Geoarchaeology 12:3, 227–49. Bout-Roumazeilles, V., N. Combourieu Nebout, O. Peyron, E. Cortijo, A. Landais, and V. Masson- Delmott (2007) Connection between South Mediterranean climate and North African atmospheric circulation during the last 50,000 yr BP North Atlantic cold events. Quaternary Science Reviews 26, 3197–215. Bouzouggar, A., R. N. E. Barton, M. Vanhaeren, S. Collcutt, T. Higham, E. Hodge, S. A. Parfitt, E. J. Rhodes, J.-L. Schwenninger, C. Stringer, E. Turner, S. Ward, A. Moutmir, and A. Stambouli (2007) 82,000-year-old shell beads from North Africa and implications for the origins of modern human behavior. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104:24, 9964–69. References 282 Bozzano, G., H. Kuhlmann, and B. Alonso (2002) Storminess control over African dust input to the Moroccan Atlantic margin (NWAfrica) at the time of maxima boreal summer insolation: a record of the last 220 kyr. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 183, 155–68. Braadbaart, F., I. Poole, and A. A. van Brussel (2009) Preservation potential of charcoal in alkaline environments: an experimental approach and implications for the archaeological record. Journal of Archaeological Science 36, 1672–79. Bresson, L. M., and C. Valentin (1994) Soil surface crust formation: contribution of micromorphology. InA. J. Ringrose-Voase andG. S. Humphreys, eds, Soil Micromorphology: Studies inManagement and Genesis. Proceedings of the IX International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, Townsville, Australia, July 1992. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 737–57. Bridge, J. S., and R. V. Demicco (2008) Earth Surface Processes, Landforms and Sediment Deposits. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Bridges, E. M. (1997)World Soils. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Brochier, J. E., P. Villa, and M. Giacomarra (1992) Shepherds and Sediments: geo-ethnoarchaeology of pastoral sites. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 11, 42–102. Brookes, I. A. (1993) Geomorphology and Quaternary geology of the Dakhla Oasis region, Egypt. Quaternary Science Reviews 12, 529–52. Buhmann, D., and W. Dreybrodt (1985) The kinetics of calcite dissolution and precipitation in geologically relevant situations of karst areas: 1. Open system. Chemical Geology 48:1–4, 189–211. Bullock, P., N. Fédoroff, A. Jongerius, G. Stoops, and T. Tursina (1985) Handbook for Soil Thin Section Description. Wolverhampton: Waine Research Publications. Butzer, K. W. (1971) Environment and Archeology: An Ecological Approach to Prehistory. 2nd ed. London: Meuthen. Butzer, K. W. (1980) Pleistocene history of the Nile valley in Egypt and Lower Nubia. In M. A. J. Williams and H. Faure, eds, The Sahara and the Nile. Rotterdam: Balkema, 253–280. Butzer, K.W. (1982) Archaeology as Human Ecology: Method and Theory for a Contextual Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Cacho, I., J. O. Grimalt, M. Canals, L. Sbaffi, N. J. Shackleton, J. Schönfeld, and R. Zahn (2001) Variability of the western Mediterranean Sea surface temperature during the last 25,000 years and its connection with the Northern Hemisphere climatic changes. Palaeoceanography 16:1, 40–52. Cacho, I., N. J. Shackleton, H. Elderfield, F. J. Sierro, and J. O. Grimalt (2006) Glacial rapid variability in deep-water temperature and δ18O from the Western Mediterranean Sea. Quaternary Science Reviews 25, 3294–311. Camps, G. (1974) Tableau chronologique de la préhistoire récente du Nord de l’Afrique. Deuxième synthèse des datations obtenues par le carbone 14. Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française 71:1, 261–78. Camps, G. (1975) The prehistoric cultures of NorthAfrica: radiocarbon chronology. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 181–92. Camps, G., G. Delibrias, and J. Thommeret (1973) Chronologie des civilisations préhistoriques du Nord De l’Afrique d’après le radiocarbone. Libyca 16, 9–28. References 283 Campy, M., and J. Chaline (1993) Missing records and depositional breaks in French Late Pleistocene cave sediments. Quaternary Research 40, 318–31. Cann, R. L., M. Stoneking, and A. C. Wilson (1987) Mitochondrial DNA and human evolution. Nature 325:1, 31–36. Canti, M. G. (1998) The micromorphological identification of faecal spherulites from archaeological and modern materials. Journal of Archaeological Science 25, 435–44. Canti, M. G. (1999) The production and preservation of faecal spherulites: animals, environment and taphonomy. Journal of Archaeological Science 26, 251–58. Canti, M. G. (2003) Aspects of the chemical and microscopic characteristics of plant ashes found in archaeological soils. Catena 54, 339–61. Canti, M. G., and N. Linford (2000) The effects of fire on archaeological soils and sediments: temperature and colour relationships. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 66, 385–95. Cappozi, R., and A. Negri (2009) Role of sea-level forced sedimentary processes on the distribution of organic carbon-rich marine sediments:A review of the Late Quaternary sapropels in theMediterranean Sea. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 273, 249–257. Carto, S. L., A. J. Weaver, R. Hetherington,Y. Lam, and E. C. Wiebe (2009) Out of Africa and into an ice age: on the role of global climate change in the late Pleistocene migration of early modern humans out of Africa. Journal of Human Evolution 56, 139–51. Caton-Thompson, G. (1946a) The Aterian Industry: Its place and significance in the Palaeolithic world. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 76:2, 87–130. Caton-Thompson, G. (1946b) The Levalloisian industries of Egypt. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 4, 57–120. Caton-Thompson, G. (1952) Kharga Oasis in Prehistory. London: University of London/Athlone Press. Catt, J. A. (1985) Soil particle size distribution and mineralogy as indicators of pedogenic and geomorphic history: examples from the loessical soils of England and Wales. In K. S. Richards, R. R. Arnett and S. Ellis, eds, Geomorphology and Soils. London: George Allen & Unwin, 202–18. Cheddaidi, R., and M. Rossignol-Strick (1995) Eastern Mediterranean quaternary paleoclimates from pollen and isotope records of marine cores in the Nile cone area. Palaeoceanography 10:2, 291–300. Cita, M. B., V. Vergnaud-Grazzini, C. Robert, H. Chamley, N. Ciarafni, and S. D’Onofrio (1977) Paleoclimatic record of a long deep sea core from the Eastern Mediterranean. Quaternary Research 8, 205–35. Clark, J. D. (1993) The Aterian of the Central Sahara. In L. Krzyżaniak, M. Kobusiewicz and J. Alexander, eds, Environmental Change and Human Culture in the Nile Basin and Nothern Africa Until the Second Millennium B.C. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 49–67. Close, A. E. (1986) The place of the Haua Fteah in the Late Palaeolithic of North Africa. In G. N. Bailey and P. Callow, eds, Stone Age Prehistory: Studies in Memory of Charles McBurney.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 169–80. Collcutt, S. N. (1979) The analysis of Quaternary cave sediments.World Archaeology 10:3, 290–301. References 284 Coltelli, M., P. Del Carlo, and L. Vezzoli (2000) Stratigraphic constraints for explosive activity in the past 100 ka at Etna Volcano, Italy. International Journal of Earth Sciences 89:3, 675–77. Cooke, R. U., and I. J. Smalley (1968) Salt weathering in deserts. Nature 220, 1226–7. Coudé-Gaussen,G. (1987)ThePerisaharanloess: sedimentologicalcharacterizationandpaleoclimatical significance. GeoJournal 15:2, 177–83. Coudé-Gaussen,G. (1990)The loessand loess-likedeposits along thesidesof thewesternMediterranean Sea: genetic and palaeoclimatic significance. Quaternary International 5, 1–8. Coudé-Gaussen, G., and P. Rognon (1988) The Upper Pleistocene loess of southern Tunisia: a statement. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 13:2, 137–51. Coudé-Gaussen, G., and P. Rognon (1993) Contrasting origin and character of Pleistocene and Holocene dust falls on the Canary Islands and southern Morocco: genetic and climaic significance. In K. Pye, ed. The Dynamics and Environmental Context of Aeolian Sedimentary Systems. London: The Geological Society, 277–91. Courty, M.-A. (2001) Microfacies analysis assisting archaeological stratigraphy. In P. Goldberg, V. T. Holliday and C. R. Ferring, eds, Earth Sciences and Archaeology. New York: Kluwer Academic/ Plenum Publishers, 205–40. Courty, M.-A., and N. Fédoroff (1985) Micromorphology of recent and buried soils in a semiarid region of northwestern India. Geoderma 35, 287–332. Courty, M.-A., and J. Vallverdu (2001) The microstratigraphic record of abrupt climate changes in cave sediments of the Western Mediterranean. Geoarchaeology 16:5, 467–500. Courty, M. A., R. P. Dhir, and H. Raghavan (1987) Microfabrics of calcium carbonate accumulation in arid soils of Western India (Rajasthan). In N. Fedoroff, L. M. Bresson and M. A. Courty, eds, Micromorphologie Des Sols: Soil Micromorphology, Proceedings of the Viith International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, Paris, July 1985 Plaisir: L’Association Française pour l’Étude du Sol 227–35. Courty, M.-A., P. Goldberg, and R. I. Macphail (1989) Soils and Micromorphology in Archaeology. Cambridge Manuals in Archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Cramp, A., and G. O’Sullivan (1999) Neogene sapropels in the Mediterranean: a review. Marine Geology 153, 11–28. Creemens, D. L. (2005) Micromorphology of Cotiga Mound, West Virginia. Geoarchaeology 20:6, 581–597. Cremaschi, M., and S. di Lernia (1995) The transition between Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene in the Uan Afuda cave (Tadrart Acacus, Libyan Sahara). Environmental changes and human occupation. Quaternaire 6:3–4, 173–89. Cremaschi, M., S. Di Lernia, and E. A. A. Garcea (1998) Some insights on the Aterian in the Libyan Sahara: chronology, environment, and archaeology. African Archaeological Review 15:4, 261–86. Cremaschi, M., S. Di Lernia, and E. A.A. Garcea (2000) First chronological indications on theAterian in the Libyan Sahara. In L. Krzyżaniak, K. Kroeper and M. Kobusiewicz, eds, Recent Research into the Stone Age of Northeastern Africa. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 229–37. References 285 Crombie, M. K., N. C. Sturchio, Z. El Alfy, and K. Abu Zeid (1997) Age and isotopic constraints on Pleistocene pluvial episodes in the Western Desert, Egypt. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 130, 337–55. Damnati, B. (2000) Holocene lake records in the northern hemisphere of Africa. Journal of African Earth Sciences 31:2, 253–62. Dansgaard, W., S. J. Johnsen, H. B. Clausen, D. Dahl-Jensen, N. S. Gundestrup, C. U. Hammer, C. S. Hvidberg, J. P. Steffensen,A. E. Sveinbjörnsdóttir, J. Jouzel, andG. Bond (1993) Evidence for general instability of past climate from a 250-kyr ice-core record. Nature 364, 218–20. Davidson, D. A., P. M. C. Bruneau, I. C. Grieve, I. M. Young (2002) Impacts of fauna on an upland grassland soil as determined by micromorphological analysis. Applied Soil Ecology 20, 133–143. d’Errico, F, M. Vanhaeran, N. Barton, A. Bouzouggar, H. Mienis, D. Richter, J.-J. Hublin, S. P. McPherron, P. Louzouet (2009) Additional evidence on the use of personal ornaments in the Middle Paleolithic of North Africa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106(38): 16051–56. de Lange, G., and H. L. Haven (1983) Recent sapropel formation in the eastern Mediterranean. Nature 305, 797–98. de Noblet, N., P. Braconnot, S. Joussaume, and V. Masson (1996) Sensitivity of simulated Asian and African summer monsoons to orbitally induced variations in insolation 126, 115 and 6 kBP. Climate Dynamics 12, 589–603. De Vivo, B., G. Rolandi, P. B. Gans, A. Calvert, W. A. Bohrson, F. J. Spera, and H. E. Belkin (2001) New constraints on the pyroclastic eruptive history of theCampanian volcanic Plain (Italy).Mineralogy and Petrology 73, 47–65. Dean, W. E. (1974) Determination of carbonate and organic matter in calcareous sediments and sedimentary rocks by loss on ignition; comparison with other methods. Journal of Sedimentary Research 44:1, 242–48. Dearing, J. A., B. A. Maher, and F. Oldfield (1985) Geomorphological linkages between soils and sediments: the role of magnetic measurements. In K. S. Richards, R. R. Arnett and S. Ellis, eds, Geomorphology and Soils. London: George Allen & Unwin, 245–67. Dearing, J. A., I. P. Livingstone, and L. P. Zhou (1996) A late Quaternary magnetic record of Tunisian loess and its climatic significance. Geophysical Research Letters 23:2, 189–92. Dearing, J. A., I. P. Livingstone, M. D. Bateman, and K. White (2001) Palaeoclimate records from OIS 8.0-5.4 recorded in loess-palaeosol sequences on theMatmata Plateau, southern Tunisia, based on mineral magnetism and new luminescence dating. Quaternary International 76/77, 43–56. Debénath, A. (2000) Le peuplement préhistorique du Maroc: données récentes et problèmes. L’anthropologie 104:1, 131–45. Debénath, A., J.-P. Raynal, J. Roche, J.-P. Texier, and D. Ferembach (1986) Stratigraphie, habitat, typologie et devenir de L’Atérian Marocain: données récentes. L’anthropologie 90:2, 233–46. Drake, N. D., A. S. El-Hawat, P. Turner, S. J. Armitage, M. J. Salem, K. H. White, and S. McLaren (2008) Palaeohydrology of the Fazzan Basin and surrounding regions: the last 7 million years. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 263, 131–45. Dreybrodt, W. (1999) Chemical kinetics, speleothem growth and climate. Boreas 28:3, 347–56. References 286 Durand, N., H. C. Monger, and M. G. Canti (2010) Calcium carbonate features. In G. Stoops, V. Marcelino and F. Mees, eds, Interpretation of Micromorphological Features of Soils and Regoliths. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 149–94. Dykes, A. (2007) Mass movements in cave sediments: investigation of a ~40,000-year-old guano mudflow inside the entrance of the Great Cave of Niah, Sarawak, Borneo. Landslides 4, 279–90. El-Asmar, H. M., and P. Wood (2000) Quaternary shoreline development: the northwestern coast of Egypt. Quaternary Science Reviews 19, 1137–49. Ellis, S., and A. Mellor (1995) Soils and Environment. London: Routledge. Ellwood, B. B., andW. A.Gose (2006) Heinrich H1 and 8200 yr B.P. climate events recorded inHall’s Cave, Texas. Geology 34:9, 753–56. Ellwood, B. B., F. B. Harrold , and A. E. Marks (1994) Site identification and correlation using geoarchaeological methods at the Cabeco do Porto Marinho (CPM) locality, Rio Maior, Portugal. Journal of Archaeological Science 21, 779–84. Ellwood, B. B., D. E. Peter, W. Balsam, and J. Schieber (1995) Magnetic and geochemical variations as indicators of palaeoclimate and archaeological site evolution: Examples from 41TR68, FortWorth, Texas. Journal of Archaeological Science 22, 409–15. Ellwood, B. B., K. M. Petruso, F. B. Harrold, andM. Korkuti (1996) Paleoclimate characterization and intra-site correlation using magnetic susceptibility measurements: an example from Konispol Cave, Albania. Journal of Field Archaeology 23:3, 263–71 Ellwood, B. B., K.M. Petruso, F. B. Harrold, and J. Schuldenrein (1997) High-resolution paleoclimatic trends for the Holocene identified using magnetic susceptibility data from archaeological excavations in caves. Journal of Archaeological Science 24, 569–73. Ellwood, B. B., J. Zilhão, F. B. Harrold , W. Balsam, R. Burkart, G. J. Long, A. Debenath, and A. Bouzouggar (1998) Identification of the Last Glacial Maximum in the Upper Paleolithic of Portugal using magnetic susceptibility measurements of Caldeirão Cave sediments. Geoarchaeology 13:1, 55–71. Ellwood, B. B., F. B. Harrold , S. L. Benoist, L. G. Straus, M. G. Morales, K. Petruso, N. Bicho, J. Zilhão, and N. Soler (2001) Paleoclimate and intersite correlations from Late Pleistocene/Holocene cave sites: results from Southern Europe. Geoarchaeology 16:4, 433–63. Ellwood, B. B., F. B. Harrold, B. S. L, P. Thacker, M. Otte, D. Bonjean, G. J. Long, A. M. Shahin, R. P. Hermann, and F. Grandjean (2004) Magnetic susceptibility applied as an age–depth–climate relative dating technique using sediments from Scladina Cave, a Late Pleistocene cave site in Belgium. Journal of Archaeological Science 31, 283–93. Emeis, K.-C., H.-M. Schulz, U. Struck, T. Sakamoto, H. Doose, H. Erlenkeuser,M. Howell, D. Kroon, and M. Paterne (1998) Stable isotope and alkenone temperature records of sapropels from sites 964 and 967: constraining the physical environment of sapropel formation in the Eastern Mediterranean sea. In A. H. F. Robertson, K.-C. Emeis, C. Richter and A. Camerlenghi, eds, Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results. College Station: Ocean Drilling Program, 309–31. Emiliani, C., and C. B. M. McBurney (1967) Palaeotemperature analysis by the oxygen isotope method at the Haua Fteah. In C. B. M.McBurney, ed. The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica) and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 54–59. References 287 Farrand, W. R. (1975) Sediment analysis of a prehistoric rockshelter: the Abri Pataud. Quaternary Research 5, 1–26. Farrand, W. R. (2001a) Sediments and stratigraphy in rockshelters and caves: a personal perspective on principles and pragmatics. Geoarchaeology 15:5, 537–57. Farrand, W. R. (2001b) Archaeological sediments in rockshelters and caves. In J. K. Stein, ed. Sediments in Archaelogical Context. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 29–66. Faure, J. (1969) Lacs quaternaires du Sahara. Mitteilungen der Internationale Vereinigung fur Limnologie 17, 131–46. Fedoroff, N., and M. A. Courty (1999) Soil and soil formation processes under increasing aridity. In A. Singhvi and E. Derbyshire, eds, Paleoenvironmental Reconstruction in Arid Lands. New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd. 73–108. Ferring, C. R. (1975) The Aterian in North African prehistory. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas, Texas: Southern Methodist University Press, 113–26. Finlayson, C (2005) Biogeography and evolution of the genusHomo. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 20:8, 457–463. Fisher, J. W. (1995) Bone Surface Modifications in Archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 2:1, 7–66. FitzPatrick, E. A. (1980) Soils: Their formation, classification and distribution. London: Longman. Foley, R. A., and M. M. Lahr (1997) Mode 3 technologies and the evolution of modern humans. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 7:1, 3–36. Folk, R. L. (1966) A review of grain-size parameters. Sedimentology 6, 73–93. Fontes, J.-C., and F. Gasse (1989) On the ages of humid Holocene and Late Pleistocene phases in North Africa - remarks on “Late Quaternary climatic reconstruction for the Maghreb (North Africa)” by P. Rognon. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 70, 393–98. Fontes, J.-C., and F. Gasse (1991) PALHYDAF (Palaeohydrology in Africa) program: objectives, methods, major results. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 84, 191–215. Forster, P. (2004) Ice Ages and the Mitochondrial DNAChronology of Human Dispersals: A Review. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences 359:1442, 255–64. Forster, P., and S. Matsumura (2005) Did early humans go north or south? Science 308, 965–66. French, C. A. I. (2003) Geoarchaeology in Action. London: Routledge. French, C. A. I., F. Sulas, and M. Madella (2009) New geoarchaeological investigations of the valley systems in the Aksum area of northern Ethiopia. Catena 78, 218–33. Freydier, R., A. Michard, G. De Lange, and J. Thomson (2001) Nd isotopic conditions of Eastern Meditteranean sediments: tracers of Nile influence during sapropel S1 formation? Marine Geology 177, 45–62. Friedman, G.M. (1995) The depositional and diagenetic evolution of the coastal ridges of northwestern Egypt-discussion. Sedimentary Geology 95, 133–5. References 288 Frigola, J.,A. Moreno, I. Cacho,A. Canals, F. J. Sierro, J.A. Flores, J. O. Grimalt, D.A. Hodell, and J. H. Curtis (2007) Holocene climate variability in the western Mediterranean region from a deepwater sediment record. Palaeoceanography 22. Frigola, J.,A. Moreno, I. Cacho, M. Canals, F. J. Sierro, J.A. Flores, and J. O. Grimalt (2008) Evidence of abrupt changes in Western Mediterranean Deep Water circulation during the last 50 kyr: A high- resolution marine record from the Balearic Sea. Quaternary International 181:1, 88–104. Frumkin, A. and M. Stein (2004). The Sahara-East Mediterranean dust and climate connection revealed by strontium and uranium isotopes in a Jerusalem speleothem. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 217: 451-464. Gale, S., and P. G. Hoare (1991) Quaternary Sediments: Petrographic Methods for the Study of Unlithified Rocks. London: Bellhaven. Garcea, E. A. A. (1995) New investigations in the Tadrart Acacus, Libyan Sahara. Nyame Akuma 44, 35–37. Garcea, E.A. A. (2004) Crossing deserts and avoiding seas:Aterian North African-European relations. Journal of Anthropological Research 60, 27–53. Garcea, E.A. A. (2010a) The spread ofAterian peoples in NorthAfrica. In E.A. A. Garcea, ed. South- Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 37–53. Garcea, E. A. A. (2010b) The Lower and Upper Later Stone Age of North Africa. In E. A. A. Garcea, ed. South-Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 54–65. Garcea, E.A.A. (2010c) Bridging the Gap between in and Out ofAfrica. In E.A.A. Garcea, ed. South- Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 174-181. Garcea, E. A. A., and C. Giraudi (2006a) Late Quaternary human settlement patterning in the Jebel Gharbi. Journal of Human Evolution 51:4, 411–21. Garcea, E.A.A., andC.Giraudi (2006b) Earthquakes and tectonic dynamics favouringLate Pleistocene human settlements in the Jebel Gharbhi, Libya. In K. Kroeper, M. Chłodnicki and M. Kobusiewicz, eds, Archaeology of Early Northeastern Africa: In Memory of Lech Krzyżaniak. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 971–85. Gaven, C. H., C. Hillaire-Marcel, and N. Petit-Maire (1981) A Pleistocene lacustrine episode in southeastern Libya. Nature 290, 131–33. Gebhardt, A. (1993) Micromorphological evidence of soil deterioration since the mid-Holocene at archaeological sites in Brittany, France. The Holocene 3:4, 333–41. Geyh, M. A., and F. Thiedig (2008) The Middle Pleistocene Al Mahrúqah formation in the Murzuq Basin, northern Sahara, Libya: evidence for orbitally forced humid episodes during the last 500,000 years. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 257:1, 1–21. Ghellali, S. M., and J. M. Anketell (1991) The Suq al Juma’ah palaeowadi, an example of a Plio- Quaternary palaeovalley from the Jebel Nafusah, Northwestern Libya. Libyan Studies 1991, 1–6. Gilbertson, D. D., and C. Hunt with P. A. Smithson (1996) Quaternary geomorphology and palaeoecology In G. Barker, D. D. Gilbertson, B. Jones and D. J.Mattingley, eds, Farming the Desert: the UNESCO Libyan Valleys Archaeological Survey. Volume One: Synthesis. Paris: UNESCO, 49–83. References 289 Gilbertson, D. D., C. Hunt, D. J. Briggs, G. M. Coles, and N. M. Thew (1987) ULVS XVIII: the Quaternary geomorphology and calcretes of the area around Gas Burat in the Pre-desert of Tripolitania. Libyan Studies 18:15–27. Gilbertson, D. D., M. Bird, C. Hunt, S. McLaren, R. M. Banda, B. Pyatt, J. Rose, and M. Stephens (2005) Past Human Activity and Geomorphological Change in a Guano-Rich Tropical Cave Mouth: Initial Interpretations of the Late Quaternary Succession in the Great Cave of Niah, Sarawak. Asian Perspectives 44:1, 16–41. Giraudi, C. (2004) The Upper Pleistocene to Holocene sediments on the Mediterranean island of Lampedusa (Italy). Journal of Quaternary Science 19:6, 537–45. Giraudi, C. (2005) Eolian sand in peridesert northwestern Libya and implications for Late Pleistocene and Holocene Sahara expansions. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 218, 161–73. Glennie, K. W. (1987) Desert sedimentary environments, present and past – a summary. Sedimentary Geology 50, 135–65. Goldberg, P. (1979a) Micromorphology of Pech-de-I’Azé II sediments. Journal of Archaeological Science 6, 17–47. Goldberg, P. (1979b) Micromorphology of sediments from Hayonim Cave, Israel. Catena, 167–81. Goldberg, P. (1992) Micromorphology, soils and archaeological sites. In V. T. Holliday, ed. Soils in Archaeology: Landscape Evolution and Human Occupation. Washington: Smihsonian Institution Press, 145–67. Goldberg, P. (2000) Micromorphology and site formation atDie Kelders Cave I, South Africa. Journal of Human Evolution 38, 43–90. Goldberg, P. (2003) Some observations on Middle and Upper Palaeolithic ashy cave and rockshelter deposits in the Near East. In A. N. Goring-Morris and A. Belfer-Cohen, eds, More Than Meets the Eye: Studies on Upper Palaeolithic Diversity in the Near East. Oxford: Oxbow: 19–32. Goldberg, P., and T. Arpin (1999) Micromorphological analysis of sediments from Meadowcroft Rockshelter, Pennsylvania: Implications for radiocarbon dating. Journal of Field Archaeology 26:3, 325–42. Goldberg, P., and O. Bar-Yosef (1998) Site formation processes in Kebara and Hayonim caves and their significance in Levantine prehistoric caves. In T. Akazawa, K. Aoki and O. Bar-Yosef, eds, Neanderthals and Modern Humans in Western Asia. New York: Plenum Press, 107–26. Goldberg, P., andR. I.Macphail (2006)Practical and Theoretical Geoarchaeology.Oxford: Blackwell. Goldberg, P., and S. C. Sherwood (2006) Deciphering human prehistory through the geoarcheological study of cave sediments. Evolutionary Anthropology 15, 20–36. Goldberg, P., V. T. Holliday, and C. R. Ferring (2001) Earth Sciences and Archaeology. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers. Goldberg,P., S.Weiner,O.Bar-Yosef,Q.Xu, and J.Liu (2001)Site formationprocesses atZhoukoudian, China. Journal of Human Evolution 41, 483–530. Goldberg, P., C. E. Miller, S. Schiegl, B. Ligouis, F. Berna, N. J. Conard, and L. Wadley (2009) Bedding, hearths, and site maintenance in the Middle Stone Age of Sibudu Cave, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 1, 95–122. References 290 Goldberg, P., H. Dibble, F. Berna, D. Sandgathe, S.McPherron, andA. Turq (In Press) New evidence on Neandertal use of fire: Examples from Roc deMarsal and Pech de l’Azé IV. Quaternary International. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2010.11.015. Goudie, A. S. (1996) Climate, past and present. In W. M. Adams, A. S. Goudie and A. R. Orme, eds, The Physical Geography of Africa. Oxford: Oxford Univeristy Press, 34–59. Graham, I. (1976) The Investigation of the magnetic prospection of archaeological sediments. In D.A. Davidson and M. L. Shackley, eds, Geoarchaeology. London: Duckworth, 49–63. Greenland Ice Core (GRIP) Members (1993) Climate instability during the last interglacial period recorded in the GRIP ice core. Nature 364, 203–07. Gregory, J. W. (1916) Cyrenaica. The Geographical Journal 47:5, 321–42. Grewal, K. S., G. D. Buchan, and R. R. Sherlock (1991) A comparison of three methods of organic carbon determination in some New Zealand soils. Journal of Soil Science 42:2, 251–57. Grove, A. T. (1980) Geomorphological evolution of the Sahara and the Nile. In M. A. J. Williams and H. Faure, eds, The Sahara and the Nile. Rotterdam: Balkema, 7–16. Grove, A. T., and O. Rackham (2001) The Nature of Mediterranean Europe: An Ecological History. New Haven: Yale University Press. Grün, R., and C. Stringer (1991) Electron spin resonance dating and the evolution of modern humans. Archaeometry 33:2, 153–99. Grün, R., C. Stringer, and H. P. Schwarcz (1991) ESR dating of teeth from Garrod’s Tabun cave collection. Journal of Human Evolution 20, 231–48. Grün, R., C. Stringer, F. McDermott, R. Nathan, N. Porat, S. Robertson, L. Taylor, G. E. Mortimer, S. Eggins, andM. McCulloch (2005) U-series and ESR analyses of bones and teeth relating to the human burials from Skhul. Journal of Human Evolution 49:3, 316–34. Guichard, J., and G. Guichard (1965) The Early and Middle Palaeolithic of Nubia: a preliminary report. In F. Wendorf, ed. Contributions to the Prehistory of Nubia. Dallas: Fort Burgwin Research Centre and Southern Methodist University Press, 57–117. Guichard, J., and G. Guichard (1968) Nubian complex sites. In F. Wendorf, ed. The Prehistory of Nubia. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 148–93. Gumnior, M., and F. Preusser (2007) Late Quaternary river development in the southwest Chad Basin: OSL dating of sediment from the Komadugu palaeofloodplain (northeast Nigeria). Journal of Quaternary Science 22:7, 709–19. Guo, Z. T., and N. Fedoroff (1990) Genesis of calcium carbonate in loess and in palaeosols in central China. In L. A. Douglas, ed. Soil Micromorphology: A Basic and Applied Science. Proceedings of the VIIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, San Antonio, Texas, July 1988. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 355–59. Hanebuth, T. J. J., K. Stattegger, and A. Bojanowski (2009) Termination of the Last Glacial Maximum sea-level lowstand: The Sunda-Shelf data revisited. Global and Planetary Change 66:1–2, 76–84. Harding, A., J. Palutikof, and T. Holt (2009) The climate system. In J. C. Woodward, ed. The Physical Geography of the Mediterranean. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 69–88. Harris, E. (1989) Principles of Archaeological Stratigraphy. 2nd ed. London: Academic Press. References 291 Hassan, F. A. (1978) Sediments in archaeology:methods and implications of palaeoenvironmental and cultural analysis. Journal of Field Archaeology 5:2, 197–214. Hawkins, A. L. (2004) A model for Aterian usage of Dakhleh Oasis and the surrounding region. In N. J. Conard, ed. Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age. Tübingen: Kerns Verlag, 37–64. Hayes,A., E. J. Rohling, S. De Rijk, D. Kroon, andW. J. Zachariasse (1999) Mediterranean planktonic foraminiferal faunas during the last glacial cycle.Marine Geology 153:1–4, 239–52. Hayes, A., M. Kucera, N. Kallel, L. Sbaffi, and E. J. Rohling (2005) Glacial Mediterranean sea surface temperatures based on planktonic foraminiferal assemblages. Quaternary Science Reviews 24, 999–1016. Heinrich, H. (1988) Origin and consequences of cyclic ice rafting in the Northeast Atlantic Ocean during the past 130,000 years. Quaternary Research 29, 142–52. Heiri, O., A. F. Lotter, and G. Lemcke (2001) Loss on ignition as a method for estimating organic and carbonate content in sediments: reproducibility and comparability of results. Journal of Paleolimnology 25, 101–10. Hemming, S. R. (2004) Heinrich events: massive Late Pleistocene detritus layers of the NorthAtlantic and their global climate imprint. Review of Geophysics 42, RG1005. Henry, D. O., (2003) Behavioral Organization at Tor Faraj in D. O. Henry, ed., Neanderthals in the Levant: Behavioural Organization and the Beginnings of Human Modernity. London: Continuum. 237–270. Henry, D. O., H. J. Hietala, A. M. Rosen, Y. E. Demidenko, V. I. Usik, T. L. Armagan (2004) Human behavioral organization in the Middle Paleolithic: were Neanderthals different? American Anthropologist 106(1): 17–31. Hetherington, R., and R. G. B. Reid (2010) The Climate Connection: Climate Change and Modern Human Evolution. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Hey, R. W. (1956) The geomorphology and tectonics of the Gebel Akdar (Cyrenaica). The Geological Magazine 92:1, 1–14. Hietala, H. J. (2003) Site structure and material patterning in space on the Tor Faraj living floors. InD. O. Henry, ed., Neanderthals in the Levant: Behavioural Organization and the Beginnings of Human Modernity. London: Continuum. 198–233. Higgs, E. S. (1967) Environment and chronology: The evidence from mammalian fauna. In C. B. M. McBurney, ed. The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica) and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 16–44. Hoelzmann, P., B. Keding, H. Berke, S. Kröplin, and H.-J. Kruse (2001) Environmental change and archaeology: lake evolution and human occupation in the Eastern Sahara during the Holocene. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 169, 193–217. Hooghiemstra, H., H. Stalling, C. O. C. Agwu, and L. M. Dupont (1992) Vegetational and climatic changes at the northern fringe of the Sahara 250,000–5,000 years BP. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 74, 1–53. Hu, X.-F., J. Wei, Y. Du, L.-F. Xu, H.-B. Wang, G.-L. Zhang, W. Ye, and L.-D. Zhu (2010) Regional distribution of the Quaternary Red Clay with aeolian dust characteristics in subtropical China and its paleoclimatic implications. Geoderma 159, 317–34. References 292 Hublin, J. J. (1992) Recent human evolution in northwestern Africa. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences 377:1280, 185–91. Hublin, J. J. (2001) Northwestern African Middle Pleistocene hominids and their bearing on the emergence of Homo sapiens. In L. Barham and K. Robson-Brown, eds, Human Roots: Africa and Asia in the Middle Pleistocene. Bristol: Western Academic & Specialist Press, 99–122. Hublin, J. J., A.-M. Tillier, and J. Tixier (1987) L’humérus d’enfant moustérien (Homo 4) du Djebel Irhoud (Maroc) dans son contexte archéologique. Bulletins et Mémoires de la Société d’anthropologie de Paris, XIV° Série 4:2, 115–41. Humphrey, L., S. M. Bello, E. Turner, A. Bouzouggar, N. Barton (2012) Iberomaurusian funerary behaviour: Evidence from Grotte des Pigeons, Taforalt, Morocco. Journal of Human Evolution 62:2, 261–273. Hunt, C., J. Davison, R. Inglis, L. Farr, T. Reynolds, D. Simpson, H. el-Rishi, and G. Barker (2010) Site formation processes in caves: The Holocene sediments of the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya. Journal of Archaeological Science 37, 1600–11. Ingman, M., H. Kaessmann, S. Pääbo, and U. Gyllensten (2000) Mitochondrial genome variation and the origin of modern humans. Nature 408, 708–13. Irish, J. D. (2000) The Iberomaurusian enigma: North African progenitor or dead end? Journal of Human Evolution 39, 393–410. Issawi, B. (1977) The Geology. In R. Schild and F. Wendorf, eds, The Prehistory of Dakhla Oasis and Adjacent Desert.Wroclaw: Polska. Akademia Nauk. 11–17. Jackson, M. L., R. N. Clayton, P. Violante, and A. Violante (1982) Eolian influcence on Terra Rossa soils of Italy traced by quartz oxygen isotope ratio. InH. VanOlphen and F. Veniale, eds, International Clay Conference 1981. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 293–302. Jacobs, Z., G. A. T. Duller, and A. G. Wintle (2003a) Optical dating of dune sand from Blombos Cave,South Africa: II—single grain data. Journal of Human Evolution 44, 613–25. Jacobs, Z.,A. G.Wintle, and G. A. T. Duller (2003b) Optical dating of dune sand from Blombos Cave, South Africa: I—multiple grain data. Journal of Human Evolution 44, 599–612. Jacobs, Z., G. A. T. Duller, A. G. Wintle, and C. S. Henshilwood (2006) Extending the chronology of deposits at Blombos Cave, South Africa, back to 140 ka using optical dating of single and multiple grains of quartz. Journal of Human Evolution 51, 255–73. Jenkins, K. A., and B. Smith (1990) Daytime rock surface temperature variability and its implications for mechanical rock weathering: Tenerife, Canary Islands. Catena 17, 449–59. Jouzel, J., C.Waelbroeck, B.Malaize,M. Bender, J. R. Petit,M. Stievenard, N. I. Barkov, J.M. Barnola, T. King and V. M. Kotlyakov,V. Lipenkov, C. Lorius, D. Raynaud, C. Ritz and T. Sowers. (1996) Climatic interpretation of the recently extended Vostok ice records. Climate Dynamics 12:513–521. Jullien, E., F. Grousset, B. Malaizé, J. Duprat, M. F. Sanchez-Goni, F. Frédérique Eynaud, K. Charlier, R. Schneider, A. Bory, V. Bout, and J. A. Flores (2007) Low-latitude “dusty events” vs. high-latitude “icy Heinrich events”. Quaternary Research 68, 379–86. Kagan, E. J., A. Agnon, M. Bar-Matthews, and A. Ayalon (2005) Dating large infrequent earthquakes by damaged cave deposits. Geology 33:4, 261–64. References 293 Kallel, N., J.-C. Duplessy, L. Labeyrie, M. Fontugne, M. Paterne, and M. Montacer (2000) Mediterranean pluvial periods and sapropel formation over the last 200,000 years. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 127, 45–58. Karkanas, P. (2001) Site formation processes in Theopetra Cave: a record of climatic change during the Late Pleistocene and Early Holocene in Thessaly, Greece. Geoarchaeology 16:4, 373–99. Karkanas, P. (2002) Micromorphological studies of Greek prehistoric sites: new insights in the interpretation of the archaeological record. Geoarchaeology 17:3, 237–59. Karkanas, P., and P. Goldberg (2010) Phospatic features. In G. Stoops, F. Mees and V. Marcelino, eds, Interpretation of Micromophological Features of Soils and Regoliths. Amstedam: Elsevier, 521–41. Karkanas, P., N. Kyparissi-Apostolika, O. Bar-Yosef, and S. Weiner (1999) Mineral assemblages in Theopetra, Greece: a framework for understanding diagenesis in a prehistoric cave. Journal of Archaeological Science 26, 1171–80. Karkanas, P., J.-P. Rigaud, J. F. Simek, R. M. Albert, and S. Weiner (2002) Ash, bones and guano: a study of the minerals and phytoliths in the sediments of Grotte XVI, Dordogne, France. Journal of Archaeological Science 29, 721–32. Karkanas, P., M. Koumouzelis, J. K. Kozlowski, V. Sitlivy, K. Sobczyck, F. Berna, and S. Weiner (2004) The earliest evidence for clay hearths: Aurignacian features in Klisoura Cave 1, Southern Greece. Antiquity 78, 513–25. Karkanas, P., R. Shahack-Gross, A. Ayalon,M. Bar-Matthews, R. Barkai, A. Frumkin,A. Gopher, and M. C. Stiner (2007) Evidence for habitual use of fire at the end of the Lower Paleolithic: site-formation processes at Qesem Cave, Israel. Journal of Human Evolution 53, 197–212. Kemp, R. A. (1991) Soil micromorphology as a technique for reconstructing palaeoenvironmental change. In A. Singhvi and E. Derbyshire, eds, Palaeoenvironmental Reconstruction in Arid Lands. New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing C. Pvt. Ltd, 41–72. Kieniewicz, J. M., and J. R. Smith (2007) Hydrologic and climatic implications of stable isotope and minor element analyses of authigenic calcite silts and gastropod shells from a mid-Pleistocene pluvial lake, Western Desert, Egypt. Quaternary Research 68, 431–44. Klein, R. G. (1995) Anatomy, behaviour, and modern human origins. Journal of World Prehistory 9:2, 167–98. Klein, R. G. (1999) The Human Career: Human Biological and Cultural Origins. 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Klein, R. G., and K. Scott (1986) Re-analysis of faunal assemblages from the Haua Fteah and other Late Quaternary archaeological sites in Cyrenaican Libya. Journal of Archaeological Science 13, 515–42. Kleindienst, M. R. (2001) What is the Aterian? The view from Dakhleh Oasis and the Western Desert Egypt. In C.A. Marlow andA. J. Mills, eds, The Oasis Papers: Proceedings of the First International Symposium of the Dakhleh Oasis Project. Oxford: Oxbow, 1–15. Kleindienst, M. R. (2006) On naming things: behavioural changes in the later Middle to earlier later Pleistocene, viewed from the Eastern Sahara. In E. Hovers and S. Kuhn, eds, Transitions Before the Transition: Evolutions and Stability in the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age. New York: Springer, 13–28. References 294 Kleindienst, M. R., C. S. Churcher, M. M. A. McDonald, and H. P. Schwarcz (1999) Geography, geology, geochronology and geoarchaeology of the Dakhleh Oasis Region: an interim report. In C. S. Churcher and A. J. Mills, eds, Reports from the Survey of the Dakhleh Oasis 1977–1987. Oxford: Oxbow, 1–54. Kleindienst, M. R., C. S. Churcher, B. Churcher, H. P. Schwarcz, Haldenam, J. R. Smith, and G. R. Ozinski (2006) Geoarchaeological investigations in Dakhleh Oasis, Western Desert, Egypt: Did a meteorite strike Dhakleh during the time of MSA occupation? In K. Kroeper, M. Chłodnicki and M. Kobusiewicz, eds, Archaeology of Early Northeastern Africa: In Memory of Lech Krzyżaniak. Poznań, 437–47. Kooistra, M. J. &M.M. Pulleman. 2010. Features related to faunal activity. In G. Stoops, V. Marcelino and F. Mees, eds, Interpretation of Micromorphological Features of Soils and Regoliths.Amsterdam: Elsevier, 397-418. Krom, M. D., J. D. Stanley, R. A. Cliff, and J. C. Woodward (2002) Nile River sediment fluctuations over the past 7000 yr and their key role in sapropel development. Geology 30:1, 71–74. Kutzbach, J. E. (1980) Estimates of past climate at Paleolake Chad, North Africa, based on a hydrological and energy-balance model. Quaternary Research 14:2, 210–23. Kutzbach, J. E., and N. A. Street-Perrot (1985) Milankovitch forcing of fluctuations in the level of tropical lakes from 18–0kyr BP. Nature 317:12, 130–34. Kutzbach, J. E., and J. Liu (1997) Response of the African Monsoon to orbital forcing and ocean feedbacks in the Middle Holocene. Science 278, 440–43. Kuper, R., and K. Kröeper (2006) Climate controlled Holocene occupation in the Sahara: motor of Africa’s evolution. Science 313, 803–07. Lahr, M. M., and R. A. Foley (1998) Towards a theory of modern human origins: geography, demography, and diversity in recent human evolution. Yearbook of Physical Anthropology 41, 137–76. Lahr, M. M., and R. A. Foley (2001) Mode 3, Homo helmei, and the pattern of human evolution in the Middle Pleistocene. In L. Barham and K. Robson-Brown, eds, Human Roots: Africa and Asia in the Middle Pleistocene. Bristol: Western Academic & Specialist Press, 23–40. Lahr, M. M., R. A. Foley, S. Armitage, H. Barton, F. Crivellaro, N. Drake, M. Hounslow, L. Maher, D. J. Mattingley, M. Salem, J. Stock, and K. White (2008) DMP III: Pleistocene and Holocene Palaeoenvironments and prehistoric occupation of Fazzan, Libyan Sahara. Libyan Studies 2008, 263–94. Lahr, M. M., R. A. Foley, F. Crivellaro, M. Okamura, L. Maher, T. Davies, D. Veldhuis, A. Wilshaw, and D. J. Mattingley (2009) DMPVI: Preliminary results from 2009 fieldwork on the human prehistory of the Libyan Sahara. Libyan Studies 40, 133–54. Lahr, M. M., R. A. Foley, F. Crivellaro, J. Maillo Fernandez, A. Wilshaw, A. Purdon, C. Halladay- Garrett, D. Veldhuis, and D. J. Mattingley (2010) DMP XI: Preliminary results from 2010 fieldwork on the human prehistory in the Libya Sahara. Libyan Studies 41, 133–54. Lambeck, K., and J. Chappell (2001) Sea level change through the last glacial cycle. Science 292:5517, 679–86. Lambeck, K., and A. Purcell (2005) Sea-level change in theMediterranean Sea since the LGM: model predictions for tectonically stable areas. Quaternary Science Reviews 2005, 1969–88. References 295 Larrasoaña, J. C., A. P. Roberts, E. J. Rohling, M. Winklhofer, and R.Wehausen (2003) Three million years of monsoon variability over the northern Sahara. Climate Dynamics 21, 689–98. Laville, H. (1976) Deposits in calcareous rockshelters: analytical methods and climatic interpretation. In D. A. Davidson and M. L. Shackley, eds, Geoarchaeology. London: Duckworth, 137–55. Laville, H., J.-P. Rigaud, and J. Sackett (1980) Rockshelters of the Perigord. Studies in Archaeology. London: Academic Press. Leblanc, M. J., C. Leduc, F. Stagnitti, P. J. van Oevelen, C. Jones, L. A. Mofor, M. Razack, and G. Favreau (2006) Evidence for Megalake Chad, north-central Africa, during the late Quaternary from satellite data. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 230, 230–42. Lewis, H.A. (2007) Preliminary Soil Micromorphology Studies of Landscape and Occupation History at Tabon Cave, Palawan, Philippines. Geoarchaeology 22:7, 685–708. Loisy, C., E. P. Verrecchia, and P. Dufour (1999) Microbial origin for pedogenic micrite associated with a carbonate paleosol (Champagne, France). Sedimentary Geology 126:1–4, 193–204. Löwemark, L., Y. Lin, H.-F. Chen, T.-N. Yang, C. Beier, F. Werner, C.-Y. Lee, S.-R. Song, S.-J. Kao (2006) Sapropel burn-down and ichnological response to late Quaternary sapropel formation in two ~400 ky records from the eastern Mediterranean Sea. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 239, 406–425. Lyman, R. L. (1994) Vertebrate Taphonomy. Cambridge Manuals in Archaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Macaulay, V., C. Hill, A. Achilli, C. Rengo, D. Clarke, W. Meehan, J. Blackburn, O. Semino, R. Scozzari, F. Cruciani, A. Taha, N. K. Shaari, J. M. Raja, P. Ismail, Z. Zainuddin, W. Goodwin, D. Bulbeck, H.-J. Bandelt, S. Oppenheimer, A. Torroni, and M. Richards (2005) Single, Rapid Coastal Settlement of Asia Revealed by Analysis of Complete Mitochondrial Genomes. Science 308:5724, 1034–36. MacDonald, K. C. (1997) The avifauna of the Haua Fteah (Libya). Archaeozoologia 9, 83–102. Macklin, M. G., I. C. Fuller, J. Lewin, G. S. Maas, D. G. Passmore, J. Rose, J. C. Woodward, S. Black, R. H. B. Hamlin, and J. S. Rowan (2002) Correlation of fluvial sequences in the Mediterranean basin over the last 200 ka and their relationship to climate change. Quaternary Science Reviews 21, 1633–41. Macphail, R. I., and P. Goldberg (1999) The soil micromorphological investigation of Westbury Cave. In P. Andrews, C.B. Stringer and A. Currant. eds,Westbury Cave: the Natural History Museum excavations 1976–1984. Bristol: Western Academic & Special, 59–86. Macphail, R. I., and P. Goldberg (2003) Gough’s Cave, Cheddar, Somerset: Microstratigraphy of the Late Pleistocene/Earliest Holocene Sediments. Bulletin of the Natural History Museum, London (Geology) 58 (Supplement), 51–58. Macphail, R. I., and J. M. McAvoy (2008) A micromorphological analysis of stratigraphic integrity and site formation at Cactus Hill, an early Paleoindian and hypothesized Pre-Clovis occupation in South-Central Virginia, USA. Geoarchaeology 23:5, 675–94. Macphail, R. I., and G. M. Cruise (2001) The soil micromorphologist as team player:Amultianalytical approach to the study of European microstratigraphy. In P. Goldberg, V. T. Holliday and C. R. Ferring, eds, Earth Science and Archaeology. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 241–67. References 296 Macphail, R. I., M.-A. Courty, J. Hather, and J. Wattez (1997) The soil micromorphological evidence of domestic occupation and stabling activities. In R. Maggi, ed., Arene Candide: a functional and environmental assessment of the Holocene sequence: excavations Bernabo Brea-Cardini 1940–50. Rome: Il Calamo, 53–88. Macphail, R. I., P. Goldberg, and J. Linderholm (2000) Geoarchaeological investigations of sediments from Gorham’s and Vanguard Caves, Gibraltar: microstratigraphical (soil micromorphological and chemical) signatures. In C. B. Stringer, R. N. E. Barton and J. C. Finlayson, eds, Neanderthals on the Edge. Oxford: Oxbow, 183–200. Macphail, R. I., G. M. Cruise, M. J. Allen, J. Linderholm, and P. Reynolds (2004)Archaeological soil and pollen analysis of experimental floor deposits; with special reference to Butser Ancient Farm, Hampshire, UK. Journal of Archaeological Science 31, 175–91. Macleod, D. A. (1980) The origin of the red Mediterranean soils in Epirus, Greece. Journal of Soil Science 32, 123–36. Madella, M., M. K. Jones, P. Goldberg, Y. Goren, and E. Hovers (2002) The exploitation of plant resources by Neanderthals in Amud Cave (Israel): the evidence from phytolith studies. Journal of Archaeological Science 29, 703–19. Maher, B. A., A. Alekseev, and T. Alekseev (2003) Magnetic mineralogy of soils across the Russian Steppe: climatic dependence of pedogenicmagnetite formation.Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 201, 321–41. Maley, J. (1977) Palaeoclimates of Central Sahara during the early Holocene. Nature 269, 573–77. Maley, J. (2004) Le bassin du lac Tchad au Quaternaire récent: formations sédimentaires, paléoenvironnements et préhistoire. La question des Paléotchads. In J. Renault-Miskovsky and A. M. Semah, eds, Guide de la Préhistoire Mondiale. Paris: Errance, 179–217. Mallol, C. (2006) What’s in a beach? Soil micromorphology of sediments from the Lower Paleolithic site of ‘Ubeidiya, Israel. Journal of Human Evolution 51, 185–206. Mallol, C., and E. Carbonell i Roura (2008) The collapse of Gran Dolina Cave, Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain: site formation processes of layer TD10–1. Geoarchaeology 23:1, 13–41. Mallol,C.,F.W.Marlowe,B.M.Wood,andC.C.Porter (2007)Earth,wind,andfire:ethnoarchaeological signals of Hadza fires. Journal of Archaeological Science 34, 2035–52. Mallol, C., S. M. Mentzer, and P. J. Wrinn (2009) A micromorphological and mineralogical study of site formation processes at the Late Pleistocene site of Obi-Rakhmat, Uzbekistan. Geoarchaeology 24:5, 548–75. Mandel, R. D., and A. H. Simmons (2001) Prehistoric occupation of late Quaternary landscapes near Kharga Oasis, Western Desert of Egypt. Geoarchaeology 16:1, 95–117. Mando, A. and R. Miedema (1997) Termite-induced change in soil structure after mulching degraded (crusted) soil in the Sahel. Applied Soil Ecology 6, 241-249. Marean, C. W., and Z. Assefa (2005) The Middle and Upper Pleistocene African record for the biological and behavioral origins of modern humans. InA. Stahl, ed. African Archaeology: A Critical Introduction Malden: Blackwell, 93–129. Marks, A. E. (1968a) The Halfan industry. In F. Wendorf, ed. The Prehistory of Nubia. Dallas: Fort Burgwin Research Centre and Southern Methodist University Press, 393–460. References 297 Marks, A. E. (1968b) The Khormusan: An Upper Pleistocene industry in Sudanese Nubia. In F. Wendorf, ed. The Prehistory of Nubia.Dallas: Fort Burgwin Research Centre and Southern Methodist University Press, 315–91. Marks, A. E. (1968c) TheMousterian industries of Nubia. In F. Wendorf, ed. The Prehistory of Nubia. Dallas: Fort Burgwin Research Centre and Southern Methodist University Press, 194–314. Marks, A. E. (1975) The current status of Upper Palaeolithic studies from the Maghreb to the northern Levant. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 439–54. Martínez-Ruiz, F., A. Paytan, M. Kastner, J. M. González-Donoso, D. Linares, S. M. Bernasconi, and F. J. Jiménez-Espejo (2003)A comparative study of the geochemical and mineralogical characteristics of the S1 sapropel in the western and eastern Mediterranean. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 190, 23–37. Marwick, B. (2005) Element concentrations and magnetic susceptibility of anthrosols: indicators of prehistoric human occupation in the inland Pilbara, Western Australia. Journal of Archaeological Science 32, 1357–68. Matthews, M. D. (1991) The effect of pretreatment on size analysis. In J. P. M. Syvitski, ed, Principles, Methods and Application of Particle Size Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 34–42. Matthews, W., C. A. I. French, T. Lawrence, D. F. Cutler, and M. K. Jones (1997) Microstratigraphic traces of site formation processes and human activities.World Archaeology 29:2, 281–308. Mattingley, D. J., M. M. Lahr, S. Armitage, H. Barton, J. Dore, N. A. Drake, C. Foley, S. Merlo, M. Salem, J. Stock, and K. White (2007) Desert Migrations: people, environment and culture in the Libyan Sahara. Libyan Studies 38, 115–56. McBrearty, S., and A. Brooks (2000) The revolution that wasn’t: a new interpretation of the origin of modern human behavior. Journal of Human Evolution 39, 453–563. McBurney, C. B. M. (1961) Absolute age of Pleistocene and Holocene deposits in the Haua Fteah. Nature 192:4803, 685–86. McBurney, C. B. M. (1967) The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica) and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. McBurney, C. B. M. (1975) Current status of the Lower and Middle Palaeolithic of the entire region from the Levant through North Africa. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 411–26. McBurney, C. B. M., and R. W. Hey (1955) Prehistory and Pleistocene Geology in Cyrenaican Libya. Occasional Publications of the Cambridge UniversityMuseum of Archaeology and Ethnology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. McBurney, C. B. M., J. C. Trevor, and L. H. Wells (1952) The Haua Fteah Fossil Jaw. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 83:1, 71–85. McBurney, C. B.M., J. C. Trevor, and L. H.Wells (1953)AFossil HumanMandible from a Levalloiso- Mousterian Horizon in Cyrenaica. Nature 172:4385, 889–91. McClure, H. A. (1994) A new Arabian stone tool assemblage and notes on the Aterian industry of North Africa. Arabian Archaeology and Epigraphy 5:1, 1–16. References 298 McDougall, I., F. H. Brown , and J. G. Fleagle (2005) Stratigraphic placement and age of modern humans from Kibish, Ethiopia. Nature 433, 733–63. McKenzie, J.A. (1993) Pluvial conditions in the eastern Sahara following the penultimate deglaciation: implications for changes in atmospheric circulation patterns with global warming. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 103, 95–105. Meignen, L., P. Goldberg, and O. Bar-Yosef (2007) The hearths at Kebara Cave and their role in site formation processes. In O. Bar-Yosef and L. Meignen, eds, Kebara Cave Mt. Carmel, Israel. Volume I: The Middle and Upper Paleolithic Archaeology. Cambridge, PeabodyMuseum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University. 91–122. Melki, T., N. Kallel, and M. Fontugne (2010) The nature of transitions from dry to wet condition during sapropel events in the Eastern Mediterranean Sea. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 294, 267–85. Mellars, P. (1996) The Neanderthal Legacy. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Mellars, P., K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef, and C. Stringer (2007) Rethinking the Human Revolution. McDonald Institue Monographs. Cambridge: McDonald Institute. Mercier, N., H. Valladas, L. Froget, J.-L. Joron, P. M. Vermeersch, P. van Peer, and J. Moeyersons (1999) Thermoluminescence dating of a Middle Palaeolithic occupation at Sodmein Cave, Red Sea Mountains (Egypt). Journal of Archaeological Science 26, 1339–45. Mercier, N., L. Wengler, H. Valladas, J. L. Joron, L. Froget, and J. L. Reyss (2007) The Rhafas Cave (Morocco): chronology of the Mousterian and Aterian archaeological occupations and their implications for Quaternary geochronology based on luminescence (TL/OSL) age determinations. Quaternary Geochronology 2:1–4, 309–13. Mijares,A. S. B., and H.A. Lewis (2009) Cave Sites in Northeastern Luzon, Philippines:APreliminary Soil Micromorphological Study. Asian Perspectives 48:1, 98–118. Miko, S., M. Kuhta, and S. Kapelj (2002) Environmental baseline geochemistry of sediments and percolating waters in the Modrić Cave, Croatia. Acta Carsologica 21:1, 135-149. Miller, G. H., F. Wendorf, R. Ernst, R. Schild, A. E. Close, I. Friedman, and H. P. Schwarcz (1991) Dating lacustrine episodes in the eastern Sahara by the epimerization of isoleucine in ostrich eggshells Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 84:1–4, 175–89. Mlekuž, D.,M. Budja, R. Payton, and C. Bonsall (2008) “Mind the gap”: caves, radiocarbon sequences, and theMesolithic–Neolithic transition in Europe— lessons from theMala Triglavca rockshelter site. Geoarchaeology 23:3, 398–416. Moeyersons, J., P. M. Vermeersch, and P. van Peer (2002) Dry cave deposits and their palaeoenvironmental significance during the last 115 ka, Sodmein Cave, Red Sea Mountains, Egypt. Quaternary Science Reviews 21, 837–51. Morel, J. (1974) La station eponyme de l’Oued Djebanna a Bir-el-Ater (Est Algérien): Contributions a la connaisance de son industry et de sa faune. L’anthropologie 78, 53–80. Moreno, A., I. Cacho, M. Canals, M. A. Prins, M.-F. Sánchez-Goñi, J. O. Grimalt, and G. J. Weltje (2002) Saharan dust transport and high-latitude glacial climatic variability: the Alboran Sea record. Quaternary Research 58:3, 318–28. References 299 Moreno,A., I.Cacho,M.Canals, J.O.Grimalt, andA.Sanchez-Vidal (2004)Millennial-scale variability in the productivity signal from theAlboran Sea record, WesternMediterranean Sea.Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 211, 205–19. Moreno, A., I. Cacho, M. Canals, J. O. Grimalt, M. F. Sanchez-Goni, N. J. Shackleton, and F. J. Sierro (2005) Links between marine and atmospheric processes oscillating on a millennial time- scale. A multi-proxy study of the last 50,000 yr from the Alboran Sea (Western Mediterranean Sea). Quaternary Science Reviews 24, 1623–36. Morley, M., and J. C. Woodward (2011) The Campanian Ignimbrite (Y5) tephra at Crvena Stijena Rockshelter, Montenegro. Quaternary Research 75, 683–96. Moyer, C. (2003) The Organisation of Lithic Technology in the Middle and Early Upper Palaeolithic Industries at the Haua Fteah, Libya. Unpublished PhD Thesis, Department of Archaeology, University of Cambridge. Mücher, H. J., C. J. Chartres, D. J. Tongway, and R. S. B. Greene (1988) Micromorphology and significance of the surface crusts of soils in rangelands near Cobar, Australia. Geoderma 42, 227–44. Muhs, D. R., J. Budahn, A. Avila, G. Skipp, J. Freeman, and D. Patterson (2010) The role of African dust in the formation of Quaternary soils on Mallorca, Spain and implications for the genesis of Red Mediterranean soils. Quaternary Science Reviews 29, 2518–43. Mullins, C. (1977) Magnetic susceptibility of the soil and its significance in soil science – a review. Journal of Soil Science 28, 223–46. Nicholson, R.A. (1993)AMorphological Investigation of Burnt Animal Bone and an Evaluation of its Utility in Archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Science 20:4, 411–28. Nicoll, K., R. Giegengack, and M. R. Kleindienst (1999) Petrogenesis of artifact-bearing fossil-spring tufa deposits from Kharga Oasis, Egypt. Geoarchaeology 14:8, 849–63. Nielsen-Marsh, C. M., and R. E. M. Hedges (2000) Patterns of diagenesis in bone I: The effects of site environments. Journal of Archaeological Science 27, 1139–50. Olsen, S. L., and P. Shipman (1988) Surfacemodification on bone: trampling versus butchery. Journal of Archaeological Science 15, 535–53. Olszewski, D. I., H. L. Dibble, S. P. McPherron, U. A. Schurmans, L. Chiotti, and J. R. Smith (2010) Nubian Complex strategies in the Egyptian high desert. Journal of Human Evolution 59:2, 188–201. Ortiz, I., M. Simón, C. Dorronsoro, F. Martín, and I. García (2002) Soil evolution over the Quaternary period in a Mediterranean climate (SE Spain). Catena 48:3, 131–48. Osborne, A. H., G. Marino, D. Vance, and E. J. Rohling (2010) Eastern Mediterranean surface water Nd during Eemian sapropel S5: monitoring northerly (mid-latitude) versus southerly (sub-tropical) freshwater contributions. Quaternary Science Reviews 29, 2473–83. Osborne, A. H., D. Vance, E. J. Rohling, N. Barton, M. Rogerson, and N. Fello (2008) A humid corridor across the Sahara for the migration of early modern humans out of Africa 120,000 years ago. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105:43, 16444–47. Ouda, B., K. Zouar, H. B. Ouezdou, D. Chikir, and C. Casse (1998) Nouvelles donnés paléoenvironnementales pour le Quaternaire récent enTunisie centrale (Bassin deMaknassy).Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences, Paris, Sciences de la Terre et des Planétes 326, 855–61. References 300 Ould Mohamed, S., and A. Bruand (1994) Morphology and origin of secondary calcite in soils from Beauce, France. In A. J. Ringrose-Voase and G. S. Humphreys, eds, Soil Micromorphology: Studies in Management and Genesis. Proceedings of the IX International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, Townsville, Australia, July 1992.Amsterdam: Elsevier, 27–36. Pachur, H.-J., and P. Hoelzmann (1991) Paleoclimatic implications of late Quaternary lacustrine sediments in Western Nubia, Sudan. Quaternary Research 36:3, 257–76. Pachur, H.-J., and P. Hoelzmann (2000) Late Quaternary palaeoecology and palaeoclimates of the eastern Sahara. Journal of African Earth Sciences 30:4, 929–39. Pagliai, M., and G. Stoops (2010) Physical and biological surface crusts and seals. In G. Stoops, V. Marcelino and F. Mees, eds, Interpretation of micromorphological charactersitics of soils and regoliths. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 419–40. Pallary, P. (1909) Instructions pour la recherche préhistorique dans le Nord-Ouest de l’Afrique. Mémoires de la Société Historique Algérienne 3. Algiers, 31-66. Pakendorf, B., andM. Stoneking (2005) Mitochondrial DNA and human evolution. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics 6, 165–83. Petraglia, M. D. (1993) The genesis and alteration of archaeologial patterns at the Abri Dufaure: an Upper Palaeolithic rockshelter and slope site in Southwestern France. In P. Goldberg, D. T. Nash and M. D. Petraglia, eds, Formation Processes in Archaeological Context. Madison: Prehistory Press, 97–112. Petraglia, M. D. (2007) Mind the gap: factoring the Arabian Peninsula and the Indian subcontinent into Out of Africa models. In P. Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef and C. Stringer, eds, Rethinking the Human Revolution. Cambridge: McDonald Institute, 383–94. Phillips, S. E., and P. G. Self (1987) Morphology, crystallography and origin of needle-fibre calcite in Quaternary pedogienic calcretes of Southern Australia. Australian Journal of Soil Research 25, 429–44. Pickering, R., P. J. Hancox, J. A. Lee-Thorp, R. Grün, G. E. Mortimer, M. McCulloch, and L. R. Berger (2007) Stratigraphy, U-Th chronology, and paleoenvironments at Gladysvale Cave: insights into the climatic control of South African hominin-bearing cave deposits. Journal of Human Evolution 53, 602–19. Pickering, T. R., C. P. Egeland (2006) Experimental patterns of hammerstone percussion damage on bones: implications for inferences of carcass processing by humans. Journal of Archaeological Science 33:4, 459–469 Pinhasi, R., and P. Semal (2000) The position of the Nazlet Khater specimen among prehistoric and modern African and Levantine populations. Journal of Human Evolution 39:3, 269–88. Polo Díaz, A., and J. Fernández Eraso (2010) Same anthropogenic activity, different taphonomic processes: A comparison of deposits from Los Husos I & II (Upper Ebro Basin, Spain). Quaternary International 214, 82–97. Ransom, M. D., N. E. Smeck, and J. M. Bigham (1987) Micromorphology of seasonally wet soils on the Illinoian Till Plain, U.S.A. Geoderma 40:1–2, 83–99. Rabett, R. (2010) Late Pleistocene faunal remains from the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica. Unpublished TRANS-NAP report. References 301 Rapp, G. A. (1984) Are Terra rossa soils in Europe eolian deposits from Africa? Journal of the Geological Society of Sweden 105:2, 161–68. Reitz, E. J., and E. S. Wing. (1999). Zooarchaeology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rendell, H. (2011). Tectonic Frameworks. In D. S. G. Thomas, ed. Arid Zone Geomorphology: Process, Form and Change in Drylands, 3rd Edition. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons. 17–25. Revel, M., E. Ducassou, F. Grousset, S. M. Bernasconi, S. Migeon, S. Revillon, J. Mascle, A. Murat, S. Zaragosi, and D. Bosch (2010) 100,000 Years of Africanmonsoon variability recorded in sediments of the Nile margin. Quaternary Science Reviews 29, 1342–62. Reygasse, M. (1916) Etudes de palethnologie Maghrébine. L’anthropologie, 351–69. Reygasse, M. (1917–18) Observations sur le techniques paléolithique du Nord-Africain. Recueil des notices et mémoires de la Société Archéologique de la Departement de Constantine. 8, 275–82. Reygasse, M. (1919–1920) Nouvelles études de palethnologie Maghrébine. Recueil des notices et mémoires de la Société Archéologique de la Departement de Constantine. 9, 513–70. Rhodes, E. J., J. S. Singarayer, J.-P. Raynal, K. E. Westaway, and F. Z. Sbihi-Alaoui (2006) New age estimates for the Palaeolithic assemblages and Pleistocene succession of Casablanca, Morocco. Quaternary Science Reviews 25:19–20, 2569–85. Richter, D., J. Moser, M. Nami, Einwanger, and A. Mikdad (2010) New chronometric data from Ifri n’Ammar (Morocco) and the chronostratigraphy of the Middle Palaeolithic in the Western Maghreb. Journal of Human Evolution 59, 672–79. Riguad, J.-P., J. F. Simek, and T. Ge (1995) Mousterian fires from Grotte XVI (Dordogne, France). Antiquity 69: 902–912. Rognon, P. (1987) Late Quaternary climatic reconstruction for the Maghreb (North Africa) Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 58, 11–34. Rohling, E. J. (1994) Review and new aspects concerning the formation of eastern Mediterranean sapropels. Marine Geology 122:1–2, 1–28. Rohling, E. J., and R. C. Thunell (1999) Five decades of Mediterranean palaeoclimate and sapropel studies. Marine Geology 153:1–4, 7–10. Rohling, E. J., T. R. Cane, S. Cooke, M. Sprovieri, I. Bouloubassi, K. C. Emeis, R. Schiebel, D. Kroon, F. J. Jorissen, A. Lorre, and A. E. S. Kemp (2002) African monsoon variability during the previous interglacial maximum. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 202:1, 61–75. Rohling, E. J., K. Grant, C. Hemleben, M. Siddall, B. A. A. Hoogakker, M. Bolshaw, and M. Kucera (2008) High rates of sea-level rise during the last interglacial period. Nature Geoscience 1:1, 38–42. Ronen, A., D. Zviely, and E. Galili (2007) QSR Comments – Did the Last Interglacial sea penetrate Mount Carmel caves? Comments on ‘‘The setting of the Mt. Carmel caves reassessed’’ by C. Vita- Finzi and C. Stringer. Quaternary Science Reviews 26, 2684–91. Rose, J. (2004a) New evidence for the expansion of an Upper Pleistocene population out of EastAfrica, from the site of Station One, Northern Sudan. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 14:2, 206–16. Rose, J. (2004b) The question of Upper Pleistocene connections between East Africa and South Arabia. Current Anthropology 45:4, 551–55. References 302 Rose, J. I. (2007) The Arabian corridor migration model: archaeological evidence for hominin dispersals into Oman during the Middle and Upper Pleistocene. Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies 37, 1–19. Rosen, A. M. (2003) Middle Palaeolithic plant exploutation: the microbotanical evidence. In D. O. Henry, ed., Neanderthals in the Levant: Behavioural Organization and the Beginnings of Human Modernity. London: Continuum. 156–71. Rossignol-Strick, M. (1983) African monsoon, an immediate climate response to orbital insolation. Nature 304, 46–9. Rossignol-Strick, M. (1985) Mediterranean Quaternary sapropels, an immediate response of the African Monsoon to variation of insolation. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 49, 237–63. Rossignol-Strick, M. (1995) Sea-land correlation of pollen records in the Eastern Mediterranean for the glacial-interglacial transition: biostratigraphy versus radiometric time-scale. Quaternary Science Reviews 14, 893–915. Rossignol-Strick, M. (1999) The Holocene climatic optimum and pollen records of Sapropel 1 in the Eastern Mediterranean, 9000–6000 BP. Quaternary Science Reviews 18, 515–30. Rossignol-Strick, M., W. Nesteroff, P. Olive, and C. Vergnaud-Grazzini (1982) After the deluge: Mediterranean stagnation and sapropel formation. Nature 295, 105–10. Rowan, J. S., S. Black, M. G. Macklin, B. J. Tabner, and J. Dore (2000) Quaternary environmental change in Cyrenaica evidenced by U-Th, ESR and OSL dating of coastal alluvial fan sequences. Libyan Studies 31, 5–16. Said, R. (1975) The geological evolution of the River Nile. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 7–44. Sampson, C. G. (1967) Coarse granulometric analysis of the Haua Fteah deposits. In C. B. M. McBurney, ed. The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica) and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 50–54. Saxon, E. C., Close,A., Cluzel, C.,Morse,V., and Shackleton,N. J. (1974)Results of recent excavations at Tamar Hat, Libyca 22: 49–91. Sánchez Goñi, M. F., I. Cacho, J.-L. Turon, J. Guiot, F. J. Sierro, J.-P. Peypouquet, J. O. Grimalt, and N. J. Shackleton (2002) Synchroneity between marine and terrestrial responses to millennial scale climatic variability during the last glacial period in the Mediterranean region. Climate Dynamics 19, 95–105. Sànchez Vizcaíno, A., and M. L. Cañabate (1999) Identification of activity areas by soil phosphorus and organic matter analysis in two rooms of the Iberian sanctuary “Cerro El Pajarillo”. Geoarchaeology 14, 47–62. Schiegl, S., P. Goldberg, O. Bar-Yosef, and S. Weiner (1996) Ash deposits in Hayonim and Kebara Caves, Israel: macroscopic, microscopic and mineralogical observations, and their archaeological implications. Journal of Archaeological Science 23, 763–81. Schiegl, S., P. Goldberg, H.-U. Pfretzschner, and N. J. Conard (2003) Paleolithic burnt bone horizons from the Swabian Jura: distinguishing between in situ fireplaces and dumping areas. Geoarchaeology 18:5, 541–65. References 303 Schiffer, M. B. (1976) Behavioral Archeology. New York: Academic Press. Schiffer, M. B. (1987) Formation Processes of the Archaeological Record. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press. Schild, R., and F. Wendorf (1975) New explorations in the Egyptian Sahara. In F. Wendorf and A. E. Marks, eds, Problems in Prehistory: North Africa and the Levant. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 65–112. Schild, R., and F. Wendorf (1977) The Prehistory of Dakhla Oasis and Adjacent Desert. Wroclaw: Polska. Akademia Nauk. Schild, R., and F. Wendorf (1980) The Late Pleistocene lithostratigraphy and environment of Wadi Kubbaniya. In F. Wendorf, R. Schild and A. E. Close, eds, Loaves and Fishes: The prehistory of Wadi Kubbaniya. Dallas: Department of Anthropology, Southern Methodist University., 11–48. Schild, R., and F. Wendorf (1989) The Late Pleistocene Nile in Wadi Kubbaniya. In A. E. Close, ed. The Prehistory of Wadi Kubbaniya Volume 2: Stratigraphy, Palaeoeconomy and Environment. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 15–100. Schild, R., and F. Wendorf (2010) Late Palaeolithic hunter-gatherers in the Nile Valley of Nubia and Upper Egypt. In E. A. A. Garcea, ed. South-Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 89–125. Schuldenrein, J. (1998) Konispol Cave, Southern Albania, and correlations with other Aegean caves occupied in the Late Quaternary. Geoarchaeology 13:5, 501–26. Schuldenrein, J. (2001) Site formation at Konispol Cave, Southwest Albania. Geoarchaeology 16:5, 559–602. Schwertmann, and Taylor (1977) Iron Oxides. In J. B. Dixon, S. B. Weed, J. A. Kittrick, M. H. Milford and J. L. White, eds, Minerals in Soil Environments. Madison: Soil Science Society of America, 145–80. Sergant, J., P. Crombé, andY. Perdaen (2006) The `invisible’hearths: a contribution to the discernment of Mesolithic non-structured surface hearths. Journal of Archaeological Science 33:7, 999–1007. Servant, M., and S. Servant-Vildary (1980) L’environment quaternaire du bassin du Tchad. In M.A. J. Williams and H. Faure, eds, The Sahara and the Nile. Rotterdam: Balkema, 133–62. Shahack-Gross, R., O. Bar-Yosef, and S. Weiner (1997) Black-coloured bones in Hayonim Cave, Israel: differentiating between burning and oxide staining. Journal of Archaeological Science 24:5, 439–446. Shahack-Gross, R., F. Marshall, and S. Weiner (2003) Geo-ethnoarchaeology of pastoral sites: the identification of livestock enclosures in abandoned Maasai settlements. Journal of Archaeological Science 30, 439–59. Shahack-Gross, R., F. Berna, P. Karkanas, and S. Weiner (2004a) Bat guano and preservation of archaeological remains in cave sites. Journal of Archaeological Science 31, 1259–72. Shahack-Gross, R., F. Marshall, K. Ryan, and S.Weiner (2004b) Reconstruction of spatial organization in abandoned Maasai settlements: implications for site structure in the Pastoral Neolithic of East Africa. Journal of Archaeological Science 31, 1395–411. Shipman, P., G. Foster, and M. Schoeninger (1984) Burnt bones and teeth: an experimental study of color, morphology, crystal structure and shrinkage. Journal of Archaeological Science 11:4, 307–25. References 304 Siddall, M., E. J. Rohling, A. Almogi-Labin, C. Hemleben, D. Meischner, I. Schmelzert, and D. A. Smeed (2003) Sea-level fluctuations during the last glacial cycle. Nature 423, 853–58. Singleton, W. L., and A. E. Close (1980) Report on site E-78-11. In F. Wendorf and R. Schild, eds, Loaves and Fishes: The Prehistory of Wadi Kubanniya. Dallas: Southern Methodist University Press, 229–37. Simpson, D. J., and C. O. Hunt (2009) Scoping the past human environment: a case study of pollen taphonomy at the Haua Fteah, Cyrenaica, Libya. Archaeological Review from Cambridge 24:2, 27–46. Smith, B. J., and J. P.McGreevy (1983)Asimulation study of salt weathering in hot deserts.Geografiska Annaler. Series A, Physical Geography 65:1/2, 127–33. Smith, B., D. R. Wright, and W. B. Whalley (2002) Sources of non-glacial, loess-size quartz silt and the origins of “desert loess”. Earth Science Reviews 59:1–4, 1–26. Smith, J. R., R. Giegengack, and H. P. Schwarcz (2004) Constraints on Pleistocene pluvial climates through stable-isotope analysis of fossil-spring tufas and associated gastropods, Kharga Oasis, Egypt. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 206, 157–75. Smith, B. J., P. A. Warke, J. P. McGreevy, and H. L. Kane (2005) Salt-weathering simulations under hot desert conditions: agents of enlightenment or perpetuators of preconceptions? Geomorphology 67:1–2, 211–27. Solé-Benet, A., M. A. Marques, and E. Mora (1990) Injection features in mid-altitude Mediterranean soils. Soil Micromorphology: A Basic and Applied Science. Proceedings of the VIIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, San Antonio, Texas, July 1988. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 227-33. Sorin, L., A. Vaks, M. Bar-Matthews, P. Roi, F. Amos. (2010) Late Pleistocene palaeoclimatic and palaeoenvironmental reconstruction of the Dead Sea area (Israel), based on speleothems and cave stromatolites. Quaternary Science Reviews 29: 1201-1211. Sperling, M., G. Schmiedl, C. Hemleben, K. C. Emeis, H. Erlenkeuser, and P. M. Grootes (2003) Black Sea impact on the formation of eastern Mediterranean sapropel S1? Evidence from the Marmara Sea. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 190, 9–21. Stein, J. K. (1987) Deposits for archaeologists In M. B. Schiffer, ed. Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory. San Diego: Academic Press, 337–95. Stein, J. K. (1990) Scale in Archaeology, Geosciences and Geoarchaeology. In J. K. Stein and A. R. Linse, eds, Effects of Scale on Archaeological and Geoscientific Prespectives.Boulder: The Geological Society of America, 1–10. Stein, J. K. (1992)Organicmatter in archaeological contexts. InV.T.Holliday, ed. Soils inArchaeology: Landscape Evolution and Human Occupation. Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press, 193–216. Stein, J. K. (2001a) Archaeological Sediments in Cultural Environments. In J. K. Stein and W. R. Farrand, eds, Sediments in Archaeological Context. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press. Stein, J. K. (2001b) A review of site formation processes and their relevance to geoarchaeology. In P. Goldberg, V. T. Holliday and C. R. Ferring, eds, Earth Sciences and Archaeology. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, 37–54. Stephens, M., J. Rose, D. D. Gilbertson, and M. G. Canti (2005) Micromorphology of cave sediments in the humid tropics: Niah Cave, Sarawak. Asian Perspectives 44:1, 42–55. References 305 Sternberg, R. S. (2001) Magnetic properties and archaeomagnetism. In D. R. Brothwell and A. M. Pollard, eds, Handbook of Archaeological Sciences. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 73–80. Stewart, I and C.Morhange (2009) Coastal geomorphology and sea-level change. In J. C. Woodward, ed. The Physical Geography of the Mediterranean. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 385–413. Stiner, M. C., S. L. Kuhn, T. A. Surovell, P. Goldberg, A. V. Margaris, L. Meignen, S. Weiner and O. Bar-Yosef (2005) Bone ash and shell preservation in Hayonim Cave. In M. C. Stiner, ed., The Faunas of Hayonim Cave: A 200,000 Year Old Record of Paleolithic Diet, Demography and Society. Cambridge: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Enthnology, Harvard University. 59–80. Stoops, G. (2003)Guidelines forAnalysis andDescription of Soil and Regolith Thin Sections.Madison, Wisconsin: Soil Society of America Inc. Stringer, C. (2000) Coasting out of Africa. Nature 405, 24–27. Sultan, M., N. C. Sturchio, F. Hassan, M. A. R. Hamdan, A. M. Mahmood, Z. El Alfy, and T. Stein (1997) Precipitation source inferred from stable isotopic composition of Pleistocene groundwater and carbonate deposits in the Western Desert of Egypt. Quaternary Research 48, 29–37. Sweeting, M. M. (1972) Karst Landforms. London: Macmillan. Swezey, C. (2001) Eolian sediment responses to lateQuaternary climate changes: temporal and spatial patterns in the Sahara. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 167, 119–55. Szabo, B. J., C. V. Haynes, and T.A. Maxwell (1995) Ages of Quaternary pluvial episodes determined by uranium-series and radiocarbon dating of lacustrine deposits of Eastern Sahara. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 113, 227–42. Tate, S. E., R. S. B. Greene, K.M. Scott, and K. G. McQueen (2007) Recognition and characterisation of the aeolian component in soils in the Girilambone Region, north western New South Wales, Australia. Catena 69:2, 122–33. Taylor, R. M. (1982) Colour in soils and sediments – a review. In H. Van Olphen and F. Veniale, eds, International Clay Conference 1981. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 749–61. Thoma, A. (1984) Morphology and affinities of the Nazlet Khater man. Journal of Human Evolution 13:3, 287–96. Thompson, R., and F. Oldfield (1986) Environmental Magnetism. London: Allen & Unwin. Thomson, J., D. Mercone, G. J. de Lange, and P. J. M. van Sandvoort (1999) Review of recent advances in the interpretation of eastern Mediterranean sapropel S1 from geochemical evidence. Marine Geology 153, 77–89. Tillet, T. (1978) Présence de pendeloques en milieu atérien au Niger oriental. Bulletin de la Société préhistorique française 75:9, 273–75. Tillet, T. (1991) Le massif de l’Aïr à l’époque atérienne: Source de la matière première. Revue de géographie alpine 79:1, 139–41. Tite, M. S. (1972) The influence of geology on the magnetic susceptibility of soils on archaeological sites. Archaeometry 14, 229–36. Tite,M. S., andC.Mullins (1971) Enhancement of themagnetic susceptibility of soils on archaeological sites. Archaeometry 13:2, 209–19. References 306 Tite, M. S., andR. E. Linington (1975) Effect of climate on the magnetic susceptibility of soils. Nature 256, 565–66. Tjallingii, M. Claussen, J.-B. Stuut, J. Fohlmeister, A. Jahn, T. Bickert, F. Lamy, and U. Röhl (2008) Coherent high- and low-latitude control of the northwest African hydrological balance. Nature Geoscience 1, 670–75. Tobias, P. V. (1967)Appendix 1B: The hominid skeletal remains of Haua Fteah. In C. B.M.McBurney, ed. The Haua Fteah (Cyrenaica) and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 338–52. Trevor, J. C., and L. H. Wells (1967) Appendix 1A: Preliminary report on the second mandibular fragment fromHaua Fteah, Cyrenaica. In C. B.M. McBurney, ed. TheHaua Fteah, Cyrenaica and the Stone Age of the South-East Mediterranean. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 336–37. Valentin, C. (1991) Surface crusting in two alluvial soils of northen Niger. Geoderma 48, 201–22. Valladas, H., J. L. Reyss, J. L. Joron, H. Valladas, O. Bar-Yosef, and P. Vandermeersch (1988) Thermoluminescence dating of Mousterian Proto-Cro-Magnon remains from Israel and the origin of modern man. Nature 331, 614–16. Vallverdú, J., E.Allué, J. L. Bischoff, I. Càcerens, E. Carbonell,A. Cebrià, D. García-Anto, R. Huguet, N. Ibáñez, K. Martínez, I. Pastó, J. Rosell, P. Saladié, andM. Vaquero (2005) Short human occupations in the Middle Palaeolithic Level I of the Abric Romaní rock-shelter (Capellades, Barcelona, Spain). Journal of Human Evolution 48, 157–74. Vaks, A., M. Bar-Matthews, A. Ayalon, B. Schilman, M. Gilmour, C. J. Hawkesworth, A. Frumkin, A. Kaufman, and A. Matthews (2003) Paleoclimate reconstruction based on the timing of speleothem growth and oxygen and carbon isotope composition in a cave located in the rain shadow in Israel. Quaternary Research 59, 182–93. Vaks, A., M. Bar-Matthews, A. Ayalon, A. Matthews, A. Frumkin, U. Dayan, L. Halicz, A. Almogi- Labin, and B. Schilman (2006) Palaeoclimate and location of the border between Mediterranean climate region and the Saharo-Arabian Desert as revealed by speleothems from the Northern Negev Desert, Israel. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 249:3–4, 384–99. van Peer, P. (1986) Présence de la technique Nubienne dans l’Atérian. L’anthropologie 90:2, 321–24. van Peer, P. (1991) Interassemblage variability and Levallois styles: The case of the North African Middle Palaeolithic. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 10, 107–51. van Peer, P. (1998) The Nile Corridor and the Out-of-Africa Model: An examination of the archaeological record. Current Anthropology 39:2, S115–S40. van Peer, P., and P. M. Vermeersch (2000) The Nubian Complex & the dispersal of modern humans in North Africa. In L. Krzyżaniak, K. Kroeper andM. Kobusiewicz, eds, Recent Research into the Stone Age of Northeastern Africa. Poznań: Poznań Archaeological Museum, 47–60. van Peer, P., and P. M.Vermeersch (2007) The place of NortheastAfrica in the early history of modern humans: new data and interpretations on the Middle Stone Age. In P. Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef and C. Stringer, eds, Rethinking the Human Revolution. Cambridge: McDonald Institute, 187–98. van Peer, P., R. Fullagar, S. Stokes, R. M. Bailey, J. Moeyersons, F. Steenhoudt, A. Geerts, T. Vanderbeken, M. De Dapper, and F. Geus (2003) The Early to Middle Stone Age transition and the emergence ofmodern human behaviour at site 8-B-11, Sai Island, Sudan. Journal of HumanEvolution 45:2, 187–93. References 307 van Vliet-Lanoë, B., J.-P. Coutard, A. Pissart (1984) Structures caused by repeated freezing and thawing in various loamy sediments: a comparison of active, fossil and experimental data. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms 9: 553–565. van Vliet-Lanoë, B. (1998) Frost and soils: implications for paleosols, paleoclimates and stratigraphy. Catena 34: 157–183. Vallverdú, J. M. Vaquero, I. Cáceres, E. Allué, J. Rosell, P. Saladié, G. Chacón, A. Ollé, A. Canals, R. Sala, M.-A. Courty, E. Carbonell (2010) Sleeping activity area within the site structure of archaic human groups: Evidence fromAbric Romaní Level N combustion activity area. Current Anthropology 51(1): 137–145. Vanhaeren, M., F. d’Errico, C. Stringer, S. L. James, J. A. Todd, and H. K. Mienis (2006) Middle Palaeolithic shell beads in Israel and Algeria. Science 312, 1785–88. Vaquero, M., J. Vallverdú, M. Vaquero, J. Rosell, I. Pastó, Allué, E (2001) Neanderthal behavior at the Middle Palaeolithic Site of Abric Romaní, Capellades, Spain. Journal of Field Archaeology 28(1–2): 93–114. Veneman, P. L. M., M. J. Vepraskas, and J. Bouma (1976) The physical significance of soil mottling in a Wisconsin toposequence. Geoderma 15:2, 103–18. Vermeersch, P. M. (2002) Palaeolithic Quarrying Sites in Upper and Middle Egypt. Egyptian Prehistory Monographs. Leuven: University of Leuven Press. Vermeersch, P. M. (2006) La vallée du Nil et le Sahara oriental: une population préhistorique fluctuante sous l’effet des variations climatiques. Comptes Rendus Palevol 5, 255–62. Vermeersch, P. M. (2010) Middle and Upper Palaeolithic in the Egyptian Nile Valley. In E. A. A. Garcea, ed. South-Eastern Mediterranean Peoples Between 130,000 and 10,000 Years Ago. Oxford: Oxbow, 66–88. Vermeersch, P. M., and P. van Peer (2002) Conclusions on Palaeolithic chert extraction. In P. M. Vermeersch, ed. Palaeolithic Quarrying Sites in Upper and Middle Egypt. Leuven: Leuven University Press, 353–60. Vermeersch, P. M., G. Gijselings, and E. Paulissen (1984) Discovery of the Nazlet Khater man, Upper Egypt. Journal of Human Evolution 13:3, 281–86. Vermeersch, P.M., E. Paulissen, S. Stokes, C. Charlier, P. van Peer, C. Stringer, and W.Lindsay (1998) AMiddle Palaeolithic burial of a modern human at Taramsa Hill, Egypt. Antiquity 72, 475–84. Verrecchia, E. P., and K. E. Verrecchia (1994) Needle-fiber calcite; a critical review and a proposed classification. Journal of Sedimentary Research 64:3, 650–64. Villa, P., and M. Soressi (2000) Stone tools in carnivore sites: the case of Bois Roche. Journal of Anthropological Research 56, 187–215. Vita-Finzi, C. (1969)TheMediterranean Valleys: Geological Changes inHistorical Times.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Vita-Finzi, C. (1971) Alluvial history of northern Libya since the last interglacial. In C. Gray, ed. Symposium on the Geology of Libya: Papers Presented at the Symposium Held at Tripoli, April 14–18 1969 Tripoli: University of Libya Faculty of Science, 419–30. Vita-Finzi, C., and C. Stringer (2007a) The setting of the Mt. Carmel caves reassessed. Quaternary Science Reviews 26, 436–40. References 308 von Suchodoletz, H., D. Faust, and L. Zöller (2009) Geomorphological investigations of sediment traps on Lanzarote (Canary Islands) as a key for the interpretation of a palaeoclimate archive off NW Africa. Quaternary International 196, 44–56. Vita-Finzi, C., and C. Stringer (2007b) Reply to Ronen et al. “Did the Last Interglacial sea penetrate Mount Carmel caves? Comments on ‘‘The setting of the Mt. Carmel caves reassessed’’ by C. Vita- Finzi and C. Stringer. Quaternary Science Reviews 26, 2685–86. Wainwright, J. (2009) Weathering, soils and slope processes. In J. C. Woodward, ed. The Physical Geography of the Mediterranean. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 169–202. Wali,A. M.A., M. E. Brookfield, and B. C. Schreiber (1994) The depositional and diagenetic evolution of the coastal ridges of northwestern Egypt. Sedimentary Geology 90, 113–36. Wali,A. M.A., M. E. Brookfield, and B. C. Schreiber (1995) The depositional and diagenetic evolution of the coastal ridges of northwestern Egypt–reply. Sedimentary Geology 95, 137–8. Wall-Scheffler, C.M. (2007)Digital cementum luminance analysis and the Haua Fteah hominins: how seasonality and season of use changed through time. Archaeometry 49:4, 815–26. Waters, M. R. (1992) Principles of Geoarchaeology: A North American Perspective. Tuscon: University of Arizona Press. Wattez, J., and M. A. Courty (1987) Morphology of ash of some plant materials. In N. Fedoroff, L. M. Bresson and M. A. Courty, eds, Micromorphologie Des Sols: Soil Micromorphology, Proceedings of the VIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, Paris, July 1985. Plaisir: L’Association Française pour l’Étude du Sol, 677–83. Wattez, J., M. A. Courty, R. I. Macphail, and L. A. Douglas (1990) Burnt organo-mineral deposits related to animal and human activities in prehistoric caves. In L.A.Douglas, ed. SoilMicromorphology: A Basic and Applied Science. Proceedings of the VIIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, San Antonio, Texas, July 1988.Amsterdam: Elsevier, 431–39. Wendorf, F., and R. Schild (1980) Prehistory of the Eastern Sahara. Studies in Archaeology. New York: Academic Press. Wendorf, F., and R. Schild (1992) The Middle Palaeolithic of North Africa: a status report. In F. Klees and R. Kuper, eds, New Light on the Northeast African Past: Currrent Prehistorical Research; Contribtuions to a Symposium, Cologne 1990 Cologne: Heinrich Barth Institut, 39–80. Wendorf, F., R. Schild, and A. E. Close (1993) Egypt During the Last Interglacial: The Middle Palaeolithic of Bir Tarfawi and Bir Sahara East. New York: Plenum Press. Wendorf, F., A. E. Close, R. Schild, A. Gautier, H. P. Schwarcz, G. H. Miller, K. Kowalski, H. Krolik, A. Bluszcz, D. Robins, and R. Grun (1990) Le dernier interglaciaire dans le Sahara oriental. L’anthropologie 94:2, 361–91. Wengler, L. (1990) Economie des matières premièrs et territoire dans le Moustérian et L’Atérian Maghrébins exemples du Maroc oriental. L’anthropologie 94:2, 335–60. Wengler, L. (1997) La transition du Moustérien à L’Atérien. L’anthropologie 101:3, 448–81. Wengler, L. (2001) Settlements during the Middle Palaeolithic of the Maghreb. In N. J. Conard, ed. Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age. Tübingen: Kerns Verlag, 65– 90. References 309 Wengler, L. (2010) A new relationship between Mousterian and Aterian in North Africa. In N. J. Conard, ed. Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age. Tübingen: Kerns Verlag, 67–80. West, L. T., J. M. Bradford, and L. D. Norton (1990) Crust morphology and infiltrability in surface soils from the southeast and mideast USA. In L. A. Douglas, ed. Soil Micromorphology: A Basic and Applied Science. Proceedings of the VIIIth International Working Meeting on Soil Micromorphology, San Antonio, Texas, July 1988. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 107–13. White, K., N. A. Drake, A. Millington, and S. Stokes (1996) Constraining the timing of alluvial fan response to Late Quaternary climatic changes, southern Tunisia. Geomorphology 17, 295–304. White, K., I. Livingstone, S. Gurney, J. Dearing, and M. Bateman (2002) Post-processing of mineral mixture maps for mapping surficial materials: the example of the Matmata loess, southern Tunisia. International Journal of Remote Sensing 23:15, 3091–106. White, W. B. (2007) Cave sediments and palaeoclimate. Journal of Cave and Karst Studies 69:1, 76–93. Wieder, M., and D. H. Yaalon (1982) Micromorphological fabrics and developmental stages of carbonate nodular forms related to soil characteristics. Geoderma 28, 203–20. Wilkinson, M. T., P. J. Richards, G. S. Humphreys (2009) Breaking ground: Pedological, geological, and ecological implications of soil bioturbation. Earth-Science Reviews 97, 254–269. Williams, M. A. J., and D. A. Adamson (1980) Late Quaternary depositional history of the Blue and White Nile rivers in central Sudan. In M. A. J. Williams and H. Faure, eds, The Sahara and the Nile. Rotterdam: Balkema, 281–304. Williams, M. A. J., P. I. Abell, and B. W. Sparks (1987) Quaternary landforms, sediments, depositional environments and gastropod isotope ratios at Adrar Bous, Tenere Desert of Niger, south- central Sahara. In L. E. Frostick and I. Reid, eds, Desert Sediments: Ancient and Modern. London: Geological Society, 105–25. Williams, M.A. J., D. I. Dunkerley, P. De Deckker,A. P. Kershaw, and J. Chappell (1997) Quaternary Environments. 2nd ed. London: Arnold. Willoughby, P. R. (2007) The Evolution of Modern Humans in Africa. Plymouth: AltaMira. Wolff, N., and P. Goldberg (2007)Thin Sections from theHigh Moundof TitrisHöyük: PreliminaryReport. Woodward, J. C., and P. Goldberg (2001) The sedimentary records in Mediterranean rockshelters and caves: archives of environmental change. Geoarchaeology 16:4, 327–54. Woodward, J. C., R. H. B. Hamlin, M. G. Macklin, P. Karkanas, and E. Kotjabopoulou (2001) Quantitative sourcing of slackwater deposits at Boila Rockshelter: a record of Late Glacial flooding and Palaeolithic settlement in the Pindus Mountains, Northwest Greece. Geoarchaeology 16:5, 501–36. Wrinn, P. J., and W. J. Rink (2003) ESR dating of tooth enamel from Aterian levels at Mugharet el ‘Aliya (Tangier, Morocco). Journal of Archaeological Science 30, 123–33. Yaalon, D. H. (1987) Saharan dust and desert loess: effect on surrounding soils. Journal of African Earth Sciences 6:4, 569–71. Yaalon, D. H. (1997) Soils in theMediterranean region: what makes them different?Catena 28:3–4, 157–69. A1 Appendix One: Procedures Bulk Sedimentology The majority of the bulk sedimentological analyses (%LOI, magnetic susceptibility, %CaCO 3 ) were measured by John Davison at Queen’s University, Belfast. The remainder (analysis of some of the analogue samples, See Chapter Four and all of the particle size analyses) were carried out by the author in the Physical Geography Laboratories, Department of Geography, University of Cambridge. The Belfast samples were run following procedures outlined in Gale andHoare (2001), and the Cambridge procedures are outlined below. Particle Size Analysis Approx. 1-5gwas put in a 50ml plastic tube, and topped upwith 7% hydrochloric acid and left to react overnight. During the initial stages, one or two drops of meths (IMS) were added to the samples to control frothing of the sediments. The samples were then centrifuged at 3500rpm for 13 minutes, the resulting liquid decanted off, and the tube topped up with 4.4% sodium pyrophosphate and stirred with a glass rod. The sample was then mixed on a whirlimixer to create a vortex. A few drops of the sample was added to the sample beaker of a Malvern Mastersizer 2000 with a pipette from the sample whilst in a vortex, following measurement of the background tap water. The ultrasonic probe was activated to aid deflocculation of the clays present within the samples. Analysis of the sample proceeded automatically when the correct value wasmaintained for six seconds. The sample was measured three times for ten seconds each time. The sample was re-measured until a satisfactory consistency was achieved in the curves, i.e. the material had completely deflocculated. The Malvern was then drained and rinsed with clean tap water and background levels checked once more before adding the next sample. % LOI %Organics A clean, dry empty porcelain crucible was weighed.Approximately one gramme of wet sediment was placed in the crucible, and the wet weight recorded. The sample was then placed in a muffle furnace overnight at 105°C. The sample was then removed with tongs and placed in a desiccator until it reached safe handling weight. The sample was weighed, and heated to 550°C overnight. The furnace was then reduced to ~100°C, and the samples cooled in a desiccator before weighing. %Carbonate The procedure was carried out as above for %LOI organics, on the same samples, but a third stage of heating, up to 950 ° C for at least six hours, was added. To calculate the quantity of CaCO 3 in a sample Appendix Two: Procedures A2 the weight lost between 550 - 950oC was multiplied by 2.274. Magnetic Susceptibility A 10 cm3 plastic pot was filled to the top and weighed. The sample was put in a drying oven overnight at less than 105°C. The sample was then removed from the oven, the lid fastened on and the dry weight recorded. The Bartington Magnetic Susceptibility Meter was set up and zeroed. At the first beep, the value of the empty sampled hole was noted (A). The sample was then lowered into the hole and the second beep value ignored. The third and fourth beep values are recorded (B & C) and the sample was then removed. The fifth beep was ignored and the sixth beep value recorded (D) to complete the background measurement. Magnetic susceptibility of the sample was calculated using the equation (B+C)/2 - (A+D)/2, and the mass susceptibility calculated using the known weight of the sample. Thin Section Manufacture Thin section manufacture was carried out by the author in the Charles McBurney Laboratory for Geoarchaeology, McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, University of Cambridge. Impregnation Samples from the field were unwrapped and left to air dry for around a week in the plastic containers they were to be impregnated in. Immediately prior to impregnation, the samples were placed in an oven to fully dry them at around 40°C for ~48 hours. Samples were impregnated in a fume hood with a mixture of crystic polyester resin and acetone, in the ratio of 1800ml resin to 200ml acetone. 2.0ml of MEKP catalyst was added to the mixture and stirred until the mixture turned emerald green. 2-3cm of resin was then placed in the sample boxes, and left to soak into the samples for 2-3hours. The containers were then topped up to cover the sediments, the level marked, and transferred to a vacuum chamber and slowly brought to -22 mercury vacuum or until bubbles were seen to evacuate from the blocks. The samples were then left under vacuum for 24-48 hours, after which they were removed from the vacuum chamber, topped up with resin to cover the samples once more, and returned to the vacuum chamber for 48 hours using the same vacuum pressure as before. Following this second period, the samples were removed to a ventilated cupboard, and allowed to cure over 2-3 months until they were completely hardened, and subject to a final curing in the oven at 40°C overnight. Slide Manufacture Excess resinwas trimmed from the blocks using a diamond saw. 0.5cm-thick slices were then cut from the blocks and trimmed to the size of the slide mount. The orientation of the sample was marked with a small notch at the top of the sample. These blocks were then attached to glass slides temporarily to allow polishing of the mounting face Appendix Two: Procedures A3 using a Brot multiplate grinding machine using coarse and fine grinding wheels. When flat and polished, the sample was cleaned with acetone and affixed to a pre-ground 2mm-thick glass slide (either 13x7cm or 7x5cm) using a mixture of 20ml crystic polyester resin and 0.2ml MEKP catalyst. The slides were then placed under a press overnight. When removed from the press, excess resin was removed from the slides by acetone and razors, and the sample ground to ~30μm using both coarse and fine grinding wheels. The resulting slides were cleaned using acetone, and covers slips applied using the same resin mixture as the mounting mixture. A4 A pp en di x T w o: B ul k Se di m en to lo gi ca lD at a Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty A na lo gu es R 2 11 .4 10 .0 1. 14 42 5. 7 37 3. 4 40 5. 0 5. 3 7. 8 R 3 11 .8 10 .0 1. 18 42 1. 8 35 7. 5 38 9. 0 5. 4 8. 1 T 2 12 .3 10 .0 1. 23 71 8. 3 58 4. 0 63 6. 8 8. 3 8. 3 T 3 12 .5 10 .0 1. 25 72 5. 8 58 0. 6 63 1. 1 7. 5 8. 0 T 4 12 .2 10 .0 1. 22 71 9. 6 58 9. 8 64 4. 6 7. 8 8. 5 A lM ar j 15 .3 10 .0 1. 5 16 6. 3 10 8. 9 11 2. 7 3. 6 3. 4 L ak e 11 .4 10 .0 1. 14 66 .7 58 .5 86 .3 6. 8 32 .2 L ak e (C am ) 12 .3 10 .0 1. 2 60 .2 49 .0 72 .3 8. 3 32 .3 S oi l6 12 .2 10 .0 1. 2 64 .4 53 .0 72 .6 8. 3 27 .0 S oi l7 13 .4 10 .0 1. 3 61 .6 46 .1 78 .4 5. 1 41 .2 S oi l8 1. 0 1. 0 1. 0 11 .1 25 .8 25 .9 4. 8 56 .7 M at m at a 18 .3 10 .0 1. 8 25 .5 6. 1 16 .9 2. 0 17 .5 So ut h- F ac in g U pp er T re nc h 60 6 41 4 0 - 5 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 43 1. 3 41 0. 8 66 9. 0 10 .2 3 38 .6 60 7 41 4 5 - 10 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 41 3. 6 42 6. 4 70 0. 2 11 .3 0 39 .1 60 8 41 4 10 - 15 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 42 3. 0 44 5. 3 68 6. 1 13 .1 5 35 .1 60 9 41 4 15 - 20 10 .1 10 .0 1. 01 44 4. 1 44 0. 0 74 5. 3 9. 82 41 .0 61 0 41 0 20 - 25 10 .9 10 .0 1. 09 36 2. 0 33 2. 1 55 4. 4 8. 13 40 .1 61 1 41 0 25 - 30 11 .3 10 .0 1. 13 47 7. 9 42 2. 9 62 7. 5 7. 14 32 .6 61 2 41 0 30 - 36 11 .1 10 .0 1. 11 53 4. 4 48 1. 4 62 6. 9 6. 99 23 .2 61 3 41 7 36 - 42 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 29 3. 0 29 9. 0 54 2. 6 15 .8 6 44 .9 F ig ur e A 2. 1: R aw bu lk se di m en to lo gi ca ld at a. Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A5 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 61 4 41 7 42 - 49 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 30 1. 7 30 4. 7 50 4. 5 14 .8 2 39 .6 61 5 12 6 49 - 54 10 .6 10 .0 1. 06 44 3. 1 41 8. 0 52 5. 8 5. 08 20 .5 61 6 12 6 54 - 59 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 44 2. 9 43 4. 2 54 0. 1 4. 79 19 .6 61 7 12 6 59 - 64 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 43 6. 4 44 5. 3 55 8. 7 5. 12 20 .3 61 8 67 1 12 6 64 - 69 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 43 6. 4 47 4. 3 60 5. 8 4. 83 21 .7 61 9 67 2 12 6 69 - 74 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 44 1. 8 48 0. 2 61 6. 5 5. 61 22 .1 62 0 67 3 12 6 74 - 79 9. 4 10 .0 0. 94 44 1. 5 46 9. 7 59 3. 0 5. 24 20 .8 62 1 67 4 12 8 79 - 84 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 53 1. 0 50 5. 7 62 1. 3 4. 53 18 .6 62 2 67 5 40 6 84 - 90 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 54 0. 5 60 0. 6 85 4. 3 5. 46 29 .7 62 3 67 6 40 6 90 - 97 9. 1 10 .0 0. 91 57 0. 5 62 9. 9 88 8. 0 5. 21 29 .4 62 4 67 8 40 9 97 - 10 3 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 54 0. 0 55 1. 0 77 8. 3 5. 19 29 .2 62 5 68 0 41 5/ 13 1 10 3 - 10 7 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 45 3. 9 50 4. 3 69 3. 7 9. 57 27 .3 62 6 68 1 41 5/ 13 1 10 7 - 11 1 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 49 9. 1 55 4. 6 73 2. 6 8. 01 24 .3 62 7 68 2 13 1 11 1 - 11 6 8. 5 10 .0 0. 85 51 0. 8 60 0. 9 76 2. 6 6. 80 21 .2 62 8 69 3 40 8 11 6 - 12 1 8. 6 10 .0 0. 86 48 0. 8 55 9. 1 71 0. 4 4. 84 21 .3 62 9 68 4 40 8 12 1 - 12 5 8. 9 10 .0 0. 89 47 7. 5 53 6. 5 68 2. 6 5. 12 21 .4 63 0 68 5 41 6 12 5 - 13 0 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 54 9. 4 54 9. 4 74 3. 4 6. 32 26 .1 63 1 68 5 41 6 13 0 - 13 4 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 57 7. 2 56 5. 9 76 4. 7 6. 87 26 .0 63 2 68 6 13 2 13 4 - 13 9 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 57 3. 0 59 6. 9 75 7. 5 5. 00 21 .2 63 3 68 7 13 2 13 9 - 14 4 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 57 6. 6 59 4. 4 76 5. 0 5. 15 22 .3 63 4 68 8 13 2 14 4 - 14 9 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 57 3. 5 57 9. 3 77 8. 6 5. 48 25 .6 63 5 68 9 13 2 14 9 - 15 4 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 60 4. 6 58 1. 3 76 2. 9 4. 83 23 .8 63 6 68 9 13 2 15 4 - 16 0 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 60 3. 4 57 4. 7 76 9. 3 5. 76 25 .3 63 7 69 0 13 4 16 0 - 16 5 10 .8 10 .0 1. 08 59 5. 0 55 0. 9 77 2. 7 4. 83 28 .7 63 8 69 0 13 4 16 5 - 17 0 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 54 8. 7 53 2. 7 76 1. 0 4. 79 30 .0 63 9 69 1 13 6 17 0 - 17 5 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 58 4. 3 56 1. 8 79 3. 5 5. 21 29 .2 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A6 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 64 0 69 2 13 6 17 5 - 18 0 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 53 6. 3 54 1. 7 76 7. 3 4. 79 29 .4 64 1 69 3 13 6 18 0 - 18 5 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 55 1. 6 54 0. 8 75 7. 4 3. 83 28 .6 W es t- F ac in g M id dl e T re nc h U pp er 91 4 91 5 17 6 0 - 5 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 50 1. 1 47 7. 2 70 0. 8 5. 36 31 .9 91 6 91 7 17 6 5 - 10 10 .8 10 .0 1. 08 44 3. 7 41 0. 8 70 7. 1 4. 73 41 .9 91 8 91 9 42 0 10 - 15 10 .8 10 .0 1. 08 53 2. 8 49 3. 3 72 9. 8 3. 99 32 .4 92 0 92 1 42 0 15 - 20 11 .0 10 .0 1. 10 54 7. 1 49 7. 4 73 6. 8 3. 82 32 .5 92 2 92 3 42 0 20 - 25 11 .2 10 .0 1. 12 59 2. 3 52 8. 8 73 2. 5 3. 96 27 .8 92 4 92 5 42 0 25 - 30 11 .4 10 .0 1. 14 63 8. 1 55 9. 7 73 0. 7 4. 38 23 .4 92 6 92 7 42 2 30 - 35 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 62 9. 5 62 9. 5 92 3. 0 6. 31 31 .8 92 8 92 9 42 2 35 - 40 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 60 0. 9 60 7. 0 86 0. 9 5. 63 29 .5 93 0 93 1 42 2 40 - 45 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 56 4. 8 58 2. 3 86 3. 9 3. 02 32 .6 93 4 93 5 42 2 45 - 49 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 52 5. 3 51 0. 0 73 9. 1 5. 69 31 .0 93 6 93 7 42 5 49 - 55 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 55 9. 3 53 7. 8 71 4. 2 5. 13 24 .7 94 1 94 2 42 5 55 - 62 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 52 4. 4 50 4. 2 68 9. 8 5. 57 26 .9 94 3 94 4 47 2 62 - 63 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 47 0. 9 46 1. 7 58 7. 4 7. 42 21 .4 94 5 94 6 42 6 63 - 65 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 37 5. 6 35 7. 7 38 1. 0 2. 13 6. 1 94 7 94 8 18 4/ 21 8 65 - 70 11 .8 10 .0 1. 18 65 9. 5 55 8. 9 69 0. 0 2. 90 19 .0 94 9 95 0 18 4/ 21 8 70 -7 5 11 .5 10 .0 1. 15 71 1. 8 61 9. 0 73 7. 7 3. 24 16 .1 95 1 95 2 42 8 75 - 80 10 .6 10 .0 1. 06 51 6. 0 48 6. 8 78 5. 1 3. 26 38 .0 95 3 95 4 42 8 80 - 85 10 .9 10 .0 1. 09 48 5. 8 44 5. 7 71 7. 7 3. 03 37 .9 95 5 95 6 42 8 85 - 90 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 45 5. 7 44 6. 8 69 2. 7 3. 57 35 .5 95 7 95 8 42 9 89 - 93 8. 0 10 .0 0. 80 33 8. 5 42 3. 1 57 2. 6 4. 33 26 .1 95 9 96 0 43 0 93 - 95 8. 8 10 .0 0. 88 36 6. 1 41 6. 0 57 6. 2 3. 72 27 .8 10 02 10 03 19 0 95 - 10 0 10 .6 10 .0 1. 06 54 8. 1 51 7. 1 74 8. 3 3. 28 30 .9 10 04 10 05 19 0 10 0 - 10 6 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 55 5. 8 52 9. 3 76 7. 1 4. 04 31 .0 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A7 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 10 06 10 07 43 1 10 6 - 11 0 9. 4 10 .0 0. 94 36 2. 1 38 5. 2 66 4. 2 4. 04 42 .0 10 08 10 09 19 8 11 0 - 11 6 8. 6 10 .0 0. 86 33 2. 7 38 6. 9 60 3. 5 4. 13 35 .9 10 10 10 11 43 2 11 6 - 12 0 8. 3 10 .0 0. 83 41 0. 4 49 4. 5 60 6. 0 4. 78 18 .4 10 12 10 13 43 2 12 0 - 12 5 8. 7 10 .0 0. 87 45 8. 8 52 7. 4 65 5. 1 4. 05 19 .5 10 15 10 16 43 2 12 5 - 13 0 8. 8 10 .0 0. 88 45 5. 8 51 7. 9 66 0. 7 3. 79 21 .6 10 17 10 18 43 4 13 0 - 13 4 10 .6 10 .0 1. 06 54 5. 5 51 4. 6 73 0. 0 4. 52 29 .5 10 19 10 20 43 4 13 4 - 13 9 11 .3 10 .0 1. 13 65 7. 8 58 2. 1 73 4. 1 3. 41 20 .7 10 21 10 22 20 2 13 9 - 15 0 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 36 7. 6 38 6. 9 67 1. 8 3. 78 42 .4 10 23 10 24 43 7 15 0 - 15 5 8. 9 10 .0 0. 89 30 8. 3 34 6. 4 61 5. 3 4. 36 43 .7 10 25 10 26 43 7 15 5 - 16 0 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 23 2. 0 27 6. 2 55 4. 6 4. 33 50 .2 10 27 10 28 43 8 16 0 - 16 5 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 37 9. 0 38 2. 8 69 6. 1 4. 07 45 .0 10 29 10 30 43 8 16 5 - 17 0 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 32 3. 5 33 6. 9 61 7. 2 4. 45 45 .4 10 31 10 32 43 9 17 0 - 17 8 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 43 4. 2 41 7. 5 67 1. 2 4. 46 37 .8 10 33 10 34 43 9 17 8 - 19 0 11 .1 10 .0 1. 11 46 5. 7 41 9. 5 66 7. 0 2. 95 37 .1 10 35 10 36 44 0 19 0 - 20 0 10 .8 10 .0 1. 08 42 3. 0 39 1. 7 66 6. 1 3. 58 41 .2 10 37 10 38 44 0 20 0 - 21 0 10 .7 10 .0 1. 07 43 9. 1 41 0. 4 66 3. 0 3. 65 38 .1 10 39 10 40 23 6 21 0 - 21 3 11 .6 10 .0 1. 16 60 0. 3 51 7. 5 69 1. 8 3. 42 25 .2 W es t- F ac in g M id dl e T re nc h L ow er 22 64 22 66 44 0 0 - 10 11 .5 10 .0 1. 15 75 0. 0 65 2. 2 75 1. 4 4. 1 13 .2 22 73 22 75 23 6 10 - 15 11 .0 10 .0 1. 10 59 9. 1 54 4. 6 71 0. 1 4. 7 23 .3 22 93 22 95 23 6/ 44 1 15 - 20 10 .9 10 .0 1. 09 62 6. 0 57 4. 3 84 8. 3 4. 8 32 .3 22 79 22 81 44 1 20 - 25 11 .9 10 .0 1. 19 72 4. 2 60 8. 6 68 0. 0 4. 2 10 .5 23 03 23 05 44 2 25 - 30 8. 9 10 .0 0. 89 28 9. 7 32 5. 5 42 0. 5 4. 5 22 .6 23 07 23 09 44 2 30 - 35 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 28 0. 2 29 5. 0 39 3. 3 4. 4 25 .0 23 15 23 17 44 2 35 - 40 9. 3 10 .0 0. 93 25 4. 4 27 3. 5 37 6. 3 4. 1 27 .3 23 23 23 25 44 2 40 - 49 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 28 3. 2 31 4. 7 46 1. 4 4. 2 31 .8 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A8 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 23 26 23 28 44 5 49 - 54 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 26 0. 9 27 1. 8 44 8. 5 4. 0 39 .4 23 34 23 36 44 5 54 - 59 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 28 2. 4 30 7. 0 48 5. 7 4. 1 36 .8 23 37 23 39 49 0 59 - 63 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 38 1. 3 40 1. 4 47 4. 4 4. 3 15 .4 23 40 23 42 49 1 63 - 68 10 .7 10 .0 1. 07 47 7. 0 44 5. 8 56 2. 2 4. 1 20 .7 23 43 23 45 49 3= 45 8 68 - 75 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 47 4. 9 47 4. 9 61 6. 8 4. 3 23 .0 23 67 23 69 49 4= 45 9 75 - 80 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 26 7. 0 29 0. 2 42 3. 7 4. 4 31 .5 23 70 23 72 49 4= 45 9 80 - 84 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 26 6. 2 29 5. 8 40 1. 3 4. 1 26 .3 23 73 23 75 49 5= 47 0 84 - 87 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 39 0. 3 40 6. 6 51 0. 1 4. 2 20 .3 24 00 24 02 49 6 87 - 94 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 34 2. 7 35 3. 3 50 1. 1 4. 1 29 .5 24 03 24 05 49 7 94 - 99 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 33 3. 5 36 2. 5 49 8. 6 4. 1 27 .3 24 28 24 30 49 7 99 - 10 4 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 38 1. 6 39 3. 4 53 9. 6 4. 1 27 .1 24 32 24 34 49 8 10 4 - 11 0 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 54 7. 7 53 1. 7 64 6. 9 4. 0 17 .8 24 36 24 38 49 9 11 0 - 11 5 8. 6 10 .0 0. 86 23 1. 6 26 9. 3 40 4. 4 4. 2 33 .4 24 40 24 42 49 9 11 5 -1 20 8. 2 10 .0 0. 82 23 3. 0 28 4. 1 37 7. 9 4. 2 24 .8 24 44 24 46 49 9 12 0 - 12 6 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 31 0. 3 30 4. 2 41 9. 6 3. 9 27 .5 24 48 24 50 50 3 12 6 - 13 2 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 21 0. 6 21 9. 4 35 5. 0 3. 5 38 .2 24 52 24 54 50 4 13 2 - 14 0 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 20 6. 7 21 3. 1 33 9. 9 3. 2 37 .3 24 56 24 58 50 5 14 0 - 14 5 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 28 0. 7 28 6. 4 37 3. 9 3. 3 23 .4 24 60 24 62 50 5 14 5 - 15 0 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 34 6. 6 33 3. 3 44 6. 7 3. 4 25 .4 24 64 24 66 50 5 15 0 - 15 6 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 32 7. 6 31 8. 1 43 3. 9 3. 3 26 .7 24 68 24 70 50 5 15 6 - 16 2 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 28 4. 0 28 9. 8 39 8. 6 3. 3 27 .3 24 72 24 74 50 6 16 2 - 16 6 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 31 0. 6 29 5. 8 36 4. 7 3. 4 18 .9 24 77 24 79 50 7 16 6 - 17 2 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 19 6. 6 20 6. 9 28 4. 3 3. 6 27 .2 24 81 24 83 50 8 17 2 - 17 8 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 37 2. 5 38 0. 1 47 5. 1 3. 7 20 .0 24 85 24 87 50 9 17 8 - 18 3 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 25 9. 7 26 5. 0 37 9. 1 3. 4 30 .1 25 03 25 05 50 9 18 3 - 19 1 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 25 3. 0 25 3. 0 32 6. 0 3. 4 22 .4 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A9 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 24 89 24 91 51 3 19 1 - 19 6 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 24 7. 8 24 7. 8 37 0. 4 3. 7 33 .1 24 92 24 94 51 3 19 6 - 20 5 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 22 9. 2 23 8. 8 35 4. 8 3. 6 32 .7 24 96 24 98 51 6 20 5 - 21 5 11 .4 10 .0 1. 14 20 9. 8 18 4. 0 41 0. 8 3. 4 55 .2 25 00 25 02 51 7 21 5 - 21 9 8. 6 10 .0 0. 86 19 6. 0 22 8. 0 37 4. 8 4. 1 39 .2 25 13 25 15 52 0 21 9 - 22 5 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 25 7. 7 26 5. 7 51 2. 9 3. 8 48 .2 25 18 24 20 52 0 22 5 - 22 8 11 .8 10 .0 1. 18 40 0. 6 33 9. 5 65 7. 9 3. 2 48 .4 25 26 25 28 52 1 22 8 - 23 3 9. 3 10 .0 0. 93 33 0. 2 35 5. 1 53 8. 8 4. 1 34 .1 25 37 25 39 52 1 23 3 - 23 6 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 42 3. 9 42 3. 9 59 6. 2 4. 1 28 .9 25 41 25 43 52 3 23 6 -2 39 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 35 7. 2 37 2. 1 46 6. 3 3. 8 20 .2 25 45 25 47 52 4 23 9 -2 44 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 30 4. 7 31 4. 1 41 8. 8 3. 4 25 .0 25 49 25 51 52 4 24 4 -2 49 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 30 2. 3 31 1. 6 42 8. 7 3. 3 27 .3 25 53 25 55 52 4 24 9 - 25 2 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 31 8. 3 32 8. 1 43 1. 8 3. 6 24 .0 25 57 25 59 52 6 25 2 -2 58 9. 1 10 .0 0. 91 26 7. 7 29 4. 2 44 7. 8 3. 7 34 .3 25 61 25 63 52 7 25 8 -2 63 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 30 9. 5 29 4. 8 49 1. 3 3. 3 40 .0 25 65 25 67 52 8 26 3 - 26 9 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 28 7. 4 31 2. 4 50 3. 0 3. 7 37 .9 25 72 25 74 52 8 26 9 - 27 2 8. 9 10 .0 0. 89 31 5. 7 35 4. 7 53 4. 2 3. 5 33 .6 25 76 25 78 52 8 27 2 - 27 7 8. 2 10 .0 0. 82 25 7. 1 31 3. 5 44 4. 1 2. 8 29 .4 25 80 25 82 52 8 27 7 -2 82 7. 8 10 .0 0. 78 23 1. 9 29 7. 3 34 1. 3 4. 0 12 .9 N or th -F ac in g M id dl e T re nc h 23 46 23 46 20 6 0 - 5 10 .5 10 .0 1. 05 48 7. 2 46 4. 0 68 8. 4 4. 1 32 .6 23 47 23 47 20 6 5 - 10 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 43 5. 6 42 2. 9 66 0. 8 4. 2 36 .0 23 48 23 48 20 7 10 - 13 10 .3 10 .0 1. 03 37 9. 6 36 8. 5 62 3. 6 4. 5 40 .9 23 49 23 49 23 5/ 43 9 13 - 18 9. 9 10 .0 0. 99 36 1. 5 36 5. 2 66 1. 5 4. 1 44 .8 23 50 23 50 44 0 18 - 23 10 .6 10 .0 1. 06 44 6. 9 42 1. 6 71 4. 6 4. 2 41 .0 23 51 23 51 44 0 23 - 25 11 .2 10 .0 1. 12 56 4. 1 50 3. 7 68 4. 3 4. 3 26 .4 23 52 23 52 24 6/ 23 6 25 - 30 7. 7 10 .0 0. 77 23 0. 3 29 9. 1 51 0. 4 5. 2 41 .4 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A10 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 23 53 23 53 24 6/ 23 6 30 - 33 7. 6 10 .0 0. 76 29 3. 2 38 5. 8 55 2. 7 5. 0 30 .2 23 54 23 54 44 6 33 - 36 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 67 1. 9 68 5. 6 83 0. 0 4. 7 17 .4 23 55 23 55 44 7 36 - 40 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 58 7. 3 60 5. 5 74 0. 2 4. 5 18 .2 23 56 23 56 44 8 40 - 43 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 45 2. 3 47 6. 1 63 6. 5 4. 4 25 .2 23 57 23 57 46 1 43 - 48 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 31 5. 5 34 2. 9 54 6. 1 4. 4 37 .2 23 58 23 58 46 1 48 - 50 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 28 6. 2 31 1. 1 53 3. 6 4. 6 41 .7 23 59 23 59 44 9 50 - 52 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 24 3. 0 28 9. 3 46 1. 4 4. 7 37 .3 23 60 23 60 45 0 52 - 57 7. 9 10 .0 0. 79 24 2. 2 30 6. 6 44 6. 3 4. 4 31 .3 23 61 23 61 46 6 57 - 62 7. 9 10 .0 0. 79 24 2. 6 30 7. 1 40 3. 0 5. 2 23 .8 23 62 23 62 45 3 62 - 67 8. 1 10 .0 0. 81 21 6. 6 26 7. 4 41 1. 4 4. 9 35 .0 23 63 23 63 45 3 67 - 72 8. 7 10 .0 0. 87 24 5. 3 28 1. 9 44 1. 9 4. 6 36 .2 23 64 23 64 45 3 72 - 74 8. 3 10 .0 0. 83 20 6. 4 24 8. 7 39 7. 2 4. 2 37 .4 23 65 23 65 45 5 74 - 78 8. 8 10 .0 0. 88 27 8. 6 31 6. 6 47 0. 4 4. 1 32 .7 23 66 23 66 45 7 78 - 83 8. 7 10 .0 0. 87 24 0. 8 27 6. 8 44 0. 0 4. 4 37 .1 23 77 23 77 45 8 83 - 88 9. 3 10 .0 0. 93 38 3. 5 41 2. 4 49 1. 5 5. 0 16 .1 23 78 23 78 45 8 88 - 93 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 44 0. 2 47 8. 5 60 0. 3 5. 0 20 .3 23 79 23 79 49 3= 45 8 93 - 98 8. 7 10 .0 0. 87 40 7. 0 46 7. 8 57 8. 3 4. 8 19 .1 23 80 23 80 49 4= 45 9 98 - 10 3 8. 2 10 .0 0. 82 25 6. 0 31 2. 2 42 5. 3 4. 2 26 .6 23 81 23 81 49 4= 45 9 10 3 - 10 8 9. 1 10 .0 0. 91 27 0. 7 29 7. 5 46 1. 9 4. 3 35 .6 23 82 23 82 49 5= 47 0 10 8 - 11 3 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 35 2. 8 37 1. 4 50 7. 3 4. 4 26 .8 23 83 23 83 49 8 11 4 - 12 1 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 36 0. 9 38 0. 0 56 4. 5 4. 3 32 .7 23 84 23 84 56 6 12 1 - 12 6 10 .0 10 .0 1. 00 34 7. 2 34 7. 2 53 4. 2 4. 0 35 .0 23 85 23 85 56 6 12 6 - 12 9 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 28 4. 1 29 9. 1 50 1. 8 3. 9 40 .4 23 86 23 86 49 9 12 9 - 13 4 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 28 3. 4 30 8. 0 48 2. 1 4. 2 36 .1 23 87 23 87 49 9 13 4 - 13 9 8. 8 10 .0 0. 88 25 4. 5 28 9. 2 44 5. 6 4. 3 35 .1 23 88 23 88 53 1 13 9 - 14 5 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 21 5. 1 22 1. 8 38 7. 0 3. 5 42 .7 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A11 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 23 89 23 89 50 3 14 5 - 15 0 8. 6 10 .0 0. 86 15 1. 5 15 1. 6 31 3. 5 4. 0 43 .8 23 90 23 90 50 3 15 0 - 15 3 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 16 2. 4 19 3. 3 31 9. 0 3. 9 39 .4 23 91 23 91 50 5 15 3 - 15 8 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 25 7. 6 26 8. 3 35 5. 4 4. 2 24 .5 23 92 23 92 50 5 15 8 - 16 3 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 27 5. 9 29 0. 4 39 4. 6 3. 8 26 .4 23 93 23 93 50 5 16 3 - 16 9 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 25 7. 6 26 8. 3 38 5. 0 4. 3 30 .3 23 94 23 94 53 4 16 9 - 17 4 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 17 2. 4 19 1. 6 33 3. 7 4. 0 42 .6 23 95 23 95 53 4 17 4 - 17 8 8. 9 10 .0 0. 89 16 2. 0 18 2. 0 32 0. 5 3. 8 43 .2 23 98 23 98 50 7 17 8 - 18 3 8. 0 10 .0 0. 80 16 6. 5 20 8. 1 31 7. 7 3. 7 34 .5 23 97 23 97 50 7 18 3 - 18 8 8. 0 10 .0 0. 80 16 3. 2 20 4. 0 28 5. 7 3. 7 28 .6 24 06 24 06 50 7 18 8 - 19 0 8. 2 10 .0 0. 82 19 8. 7 24 2. 3 33 2. 4 3. 6 27 .1 24 07 24 07 50 8 19 0 - 19 5 9. 0 10 .0 0. 90 23 9. 9 26 6. 6 36 4. 6 3. 5 26 .9 24 08 24 08 50 8 19 5 - 20 0 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 25 1. 9 26 2. 4 40 1. 2 3. 7 34 .6 24 09 24 09 50 8 20 0 - 20 2 9. 8 10 .0 0. 98 24 6. 4 25 1. 4 39 4. 1 3. 7 36 .2 24 10 24 10 51 3 20 2 - 20 6 9. 2 10 .0 0. 92 26 5. 6 28 8. 7 45 9. 7 3. 0 37 .2 24 11 24 11 53 5 20 6 - 20 9 6. 7 10 .0 0. 67 13 4. 9 20 1. 3 31 0. 2 4. 3 35 .1 24 12 24 12 56 1 20 9 - 21 5 9. 5 10 .0 0. 95 23 5. 5 24 7. 9 46 2. 5 3. 8 46 .4 24 13 24 13 53 6 21 5 - 22 1 6. 6 10 .0 0. 66 13 8. 5 20 9. 8 34 9. 2 5. 5 39 .9 24 14 24 14 56 2 22 1 - 22 5 10 .4 10 .0 1. 04 21 2. 8 20 4. 6 49 7. 8 3. 6 58 .9 24 15 24 15 53 2 22 5 - 23 0 11 .4 10 .0 1. 14 18 8. 1 16 5. 0 49 4. 0 3. 0 66 .6 24 16 24 16 53 7 23 0 - 23 4 9. 1 10 .0 0. 91 20 2. 6 22 2. 6 51 0. 6 4. 1 56 .4 24 17 24 17 56 7 23 4 - 23 7 9. 3 10 .0 0. 93 25 8. 9 27 8. 4 48 9. 3 3. 5 43 .1 24 18 24 18 52 1 23 7 - 24 0 9. 4 10 .0 0. 94 37 8. 7 40 2. 9 64 8. 7 4. 0 37 .9 24 19 24 19 52 1 24 0 - 24 5 9. 3 10 .0 0. 93 37 7. 2 40 5. 6 60 0. 9 3. 8 32 .5 24 20 24 20 52 3 24 5 - 24 9 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 34 5. 5 41 1. 3 57 8. 5 4. 1 28 .9 24 21 24 21 52 4 24 9 - 25 4 8. 1 10 .0 0. 81 23 9. 4 29 5. 6 40 2. 1 3. 7 26 .5 24 22 24 22 52 4 25 4 - 25 9 8. 5 10 .0 0. 85 25 9. 6 30 5. 4 42 8. 9 3. 6 28 .8 Appendix Two: Bulk Sedimentological Data A12 Sa m pl e E qu iv al en t sa m pl e C on te xt D ep th W ei gh t V ol um e M ag ne ti c Su sc ep ti bi lit y L O I O rg an ic s (% ) C aC O 3 eq ui va le nt (% ) D en si ty M et er re ad in g M as s su sc ep ti bi lit y C or re ct ed m as s su ce pt ib ili ty 24 23 24 23 52 4 25 9 - 26 5 9. 1 10 .0 0. 91 26 6. 8 29 3. 2 42 2. 5 3. 5 30 .6 24 24 24 24 56 3 26 5 - 27 0 10 .2 10 .0 1. 02 24 1. 2 23 6. 5 48 6. 6 3. 0 51 .4 24 25 24 25 56 3 27 0 - 27 4 9. 6 10 .0 0. 96 29 2. 0 30 4. 2 51 2. 1 3. 5 40 .6 24 26 24 26 56 8 27 4 - 27 5 8. 3 10 .0 0. 83 24 8. 1 29 8. 9 48 2. 1 5. 6 38 .0 25 06 25 06 52 8 27 5 - 28 0 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 31 9. 4 38 0. 2 56 3. 3 4. 2 32 .5 25 07 25 07 56 4 28 0 - 28 3 8. 4 10 .0 0. 84 29 0. 2 34 5. 5 57 7. 7 4. 0 40 .2 25 08 25 08 56 4 28 3 - 28 5 7. 5 10 .0 0. 75 34 7. 8 46 3. 7 65 2. 2 4. 2 28 .9 25 09 25 09 56 5 28 5 - 28 8 6. 5 10 .0 0. 65 19 8. 5 30 5. 4 36 5. 3 5. 1 16 .4 25 10 25 10 57 0 28 8 - 29 3 6. 5 10 .0 0. 65 18 6. 5 28 6. 9 34 8. 6 4. 1 17 .7 25 11 25 11 57 0 29 3 - 29 6 7. 9 10 .0 0. 79 21 0. 3 26 6. 2 43 6. 4 3. 4 39 .0 25 16 25 16 53 8 29 6 - 30 0 9. 7 10 .0 0. 97 14 6. 0 15 0. 5 54 7. 3 3. 1 72 .5 F or ra w pa rt ic le si ze da ta ,w hi ch ca nn ot be di sp la ye d he re du e to sp ac e re st ri ct io ns ,p le as e co nt ac tt he au th or . A13 Appendix Three: SEM analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ A greyish-green, vesicular material termed ‘slag’ was recovered by McBurney in the 1950s from the Levalloiso-Mousterian levels. Similar material was also recovered from theTRANS-NAPexcavations, and observed in a number of the thin sections from the Levalloiso-Mousterian levels, where it was isotropic in XPL and greyish-green in PPL (Fig. A3.1). In order to clarify the chemical composition and nature of this material, three samples were analyses by backscatter SEM. These samples were: a piece of ‘slag’ recovered from the excavation of the flotation sample column Sample 2570a; and two fragments embedded in the resin-impregnated blocks from which the thin sections were made (Fig. A3.2), Samples 2663a and 2021a. SEM analysis was carried out at the English Heritage Archaeological Science laboratories at Fort Cumberland. 2mm 1cm 2570 2021a 1mm 2021:4,PPL 2021a Figure A3.1 Views of vesicular structure of ‘slag’ a. Sample 2570a prior to SEM analysis. b. Microphorograph of Micro-fabric 2021:4 containing fragment of ‘slag’. c. Polished resin block showing location of ‘slag’ fragement above tuncated burning event (see Chapter Seven), and d. backscatter SEM image of aggregate in (c) showing vesicular structure. Appendix Three: SEM Analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ A14 The mean results for each sample are presented in FigureA3.2 and TableA3.1, and show a consistency between all the samples in terms of their dominance by oxygen, silica and calcium, with smaller amounts of sodium, magnesium, aluminium, potassium and iron. This is consistent with other authors’ observations of the burning of plant matter leaving a ‘vesicular glassy slag’ made from silica and alkaline salts (Canti 2003 and references therein). The presence of these ‘slags’ do not indicate heating to a particularly high temperature, as the melting point of the silica is lowered under alkaline conditions, such as exist in ash (M. Canti, pers. comm. 2010). The presence of such ‘slag’ indicates a silica-rich fuel such as grasses, being burnt in the Haua Fteah. (Macphail and Cruise 2001). Element M ea n % co m po si tio n 2021a 2570a 2663a Na Mg Al Si P S K Ca Ti Mn Fe Ni Cu Zn As Ag Sn Sb Ba Au Pb O 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Figure A3.2 Graph comparing mean % compositions of ‘slag’ samples determined through backscatter SEM. Appendix Three: SEM Analysis of MSA ‘Slag’ A15 Sp ec tr um N a M g A l Si P S K C a T i M n F e N i C u Z n A s A g Sn Sb B a A u P b O 20 21 a M ea n 4. 32 2. 51 5. 01 27 .8 8 0. 84 0. 01 2. 29 8. 21 0. 34 0. 1 2. 73 0. 02 0. 01 0. 02 0. 01 -0 .0 1 0. 15 0. 15 0. 06 -0 .0 9 0. 08 45 .3 6 S td de vi at io n 1. 17 1. 03 1. 7 2. 28 0. 45 0. 04 0. 49 2. 36 0. 22 0. 05 0. 62 0. 05 0. 05 0. 07 0. 11 0. 08 0. 1 0. 16 0. 05 0. 18 0. 11 1. 04 M ax 5. 42 4. 49 8. 02 30 .5 5 1. 52 0. 08 3. 27 12 .5 5 0. 87 0. 21 3. 79 0. 09 0. 11 0. 11 0. 18 0. 11 0. 33 0. 46 0. 12 0. 13 0. 25 47 .1 2 M in 2. 43 1 2. 87 24 .3 2 0. 21 -0 .0 4 1. 74 3. 94 0. 2 0. 04 1. 97 -0 .0 4 -0 .0 3 -0 .1 -0 .2 1 -0 .1 5 -0 .0 1 -0 .0 5 -0 .0 1 -0 .3 1 -0 .0 8 43 .6 3 25 70 a M ea n 3. 7 1. 98 4. 07 29 .3 6 0. 83 0. 1 2. 29 8. 51 0. 34 0. 07 2. 36 0. 03 0 0. 11 -0 .0 3 0. 05 0. 22 0. 15 0. 02 -0 .0 2 0. 04 45 .8 1 S td de vi at io n 0. 47 0. 64 0. 93 1. 41 0. 25 0. 18 0. 31 1. 55 0. 12 0. 03 0. 5 0. 06 0. 07 0. 2 0. 17 0. 07 0. 2 0. 17 0. 06 0. 18 0. 08 0. 56 M ax 4. 61 2. 8 6. 1 31 .4 4 1. 21 0. 51 2. 87 11 .1 2 0. 53 0. 14 3. 58 0. 14 0. 1 0. 54 0. 2 0. 16 0. 63 0. 46 0. 09 0. 32 0. 13 46 .5 6 M in 3. 13 0. 86 3. 47 27 .5 1 0. 49 -0 .0 2 1. 96 6. 73 0. 22 0. 04 2. 02 -0 .0 6 -0 .0 7 -0 .0 8 -0 .3 5 -0 .0 7 -0 .0 1 -0 .1 1 -0 .0 5 -0 .2 2 -0 .0 9 44 .9 9 26 63 a M ea n 1. 73 2. 4 6. 07 25 .9 4 0. 67 0. 03 3. 39 11 .5 6 0. 41 0. 1 2. 55 0. 03 0. 03 0 0. 01 0. 01 0. 25 0. 17 0. 09 -0 .0 5 0. 1 44 .5 3 S td de vi at io n 0. 33 0. 58 1. 1 2. 19 0. 14 0. 04 1. 05 2. 16 0. 07 0. 03 0. 39 0. 05 0. 06 0. 02 0. 22 0. 06 0. 12 0. 16 0. 09 0. 2 0. 06 0. 08 M ax 2. 12 3. 35 7. 77 28 .9 2 0. 87 0. 09 4. 42 14 .4 6 0. 51 0. 15 3. 09 0. 09 0. 09 0. 04 0. 42 0. 09 0. 37 0. 43 0. 19 0. 33 0. 2 45 .6 8 M in 1. 33 2. 01 4. 38 23 .1 8 0. 46 -0 .0 2 1. 58 9. 84 0. 33 0. 07 2. 11 -0 .0 4 -0 .0 4 -0 .0 1 -0 .2 3 -0 .0 7 0. 04 0. 01 -0 .0 2 -0 .2 2 0. 04 43 .6 4 F ig ur e A 3. 2 Ta bl e of re su lt s of an al ys is of ‘s la g’ sa m pl es us in g ba ck -s ca tt er SE M . A16 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll L ow er B ou nd ar y 44 0 V er y dr y or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el 20 % 1– 2c m an gu la r– su ba ng ul ar ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr av el w it h 5% 3– 6c m . B ur ro w s et c ev id en t, ap pr ox 3m m . 2. 5Y R 5/ 6 re d. C le ar . 44 1 & 23 6 23 6 is pa le or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . 44 1 is bu rn tl en s at ba se of 23 6. B ot h ve ry si lt y. 40 % 1– 5c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed li m es to ne bl oc ks to pl aq ue tt es . 44 1 5Y R 6/ 6 li gh t re d 23 6 5Y R 4/ 4 re dd is h br ow n S ha rp 44 2 O ra ng e si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it .V er y th ic k un it , ab ov e an d be lo w pl aq ue tt e of li m es to ne .S li gh tl y pa le r to w ar ds to p of lo w er pa rt un de rn ea th pl aq ue tt e. N o re al si gn of th e le ns yo u ca n se e in m ic ro m or ph . A bo ve pl aq ue tt e, v m uc h pa le r. 5% 1– 2m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d li m es to ne gr it . 7. 5Y R 6/ 6 re dd is h ye ll ow ab ov e 5Y R 5. 5/ 6 re dd is h ye ll ow /y el lo w is h re d 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d 44 5 P al e or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el 5% 3m m –4 cm su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt at ed ,p la ty li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 5. 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar . 49 0 ‘S an dw ic h’ of re d cl ay w it h li m es to ne gr av el la ye r in ce nt re .I nd ur at ed at ce nt re la ye r. 20 % ~1 –3 cm ,s ub an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d C le ar bu ts ub tl e. 49 1 O ra ng e– re d cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 5% 1– 3m m to 2c m (2 % ) su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it . 2. 5Y R 4/ 8 re d C le ar . 49 3 O ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 3% 1– 2m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr it . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d C le ar . 49 4 P al e or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el .S li gh tl y li gh te r to to p of un it .S li gh tl y in du ra te d at th e ba se – or ju st co nc en tr at io n of li m es to ne . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d S ha rp . 49 5 O ra ng e– re d cl ea n cl ay ey si lt it h li m es to ne gr it ,b as e m ar ke d by 1– 2c m in du ra te d se di m en t, 1– 2% 1– 2m m li m es to ne gr it . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d S ha rp . A pp en di x F ou r: F ie ld D es cr ip ti on s of C on te xt s Sa m pl ed fo r M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al A na ly se s W es t- F ac in g P ro fil e Appendix Four: Field Descriptions A17 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll L ow er B ou nd ar y 49 6 O ra ng e– re d cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 1– 2% 1– 2m m li m es to ne gr it . 2% P al e gr ey si lt y le ns es 3m m ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt ed . M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to cr ac ks in la rg e ‘p ed s’ 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d. D if fu se /c le ar . 49 7 O ra ng e– re d cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 3% 2– 4m m an gu la r, bh or iz on ta ll y– or ie nt at ed bl oc ky – to pl at y li m es to ne gr it . 1% ~3 m m . m an ga ne se co at ed ch an ne ls . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar . 49 8 R ed di sh –o ra ng e, co m pa ct cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it ,s ta nd in g pr ou d of se ct io n. 5% 2– 5m m su ba ng ul ar –a ng ul ar bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d S ha rp . 49 9 O ra ng ey cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el .M as si ve . 5% 3m m –6 cm su br ou nd ed –s ub an gu la r ,s li gh tl y ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d bl oc ky li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar /d if fu se . 50 3 P al e gr ey –o ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . P ot en ti al ly sl ig ht ly la m in ar st ru ct ur e. 10 % 2m m –3 cm an gu la r– su ba ng ul ar li m es to ne gr av el pl at y. 2. 5Y R 6/ 6 li gh t re d D if fu se . 50 4 O ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it ,v er y cl ea n. 5% 2– 5m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky li m es to ne fle ck s. 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d D if fu se /c le ar . 50 5 O ra ng ey cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it ,l ar ge , ho m og en ou s un it . 10 % 0. 5– 1c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it .2 % su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y an d ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d co bb le s to to p of un it . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d C le ar /d if fu se 50 6 T hi n cl ay ey le ns ,s li gh tl y pr ou de r of se ct io n w it h li m es to ne gr av el .C om pa ct re dd is h– or an ge cl ay ey si lt ,c la y ba se .I nt er le av ed cl ay an d gr it in th is la ye r. 15 % 1– 2m m su ba ng ul ar ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el .2 % of th is ~0 .5 –1 cm . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d 50 7 P al e or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . D if fu se co lo ur ch an ge to gr ey er at th e to p. 5% 2– 4m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el ,g ri tt ie r to w ar ds th e to p ~1 0% in to p ha lf . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d – to p 5Y R 5/ 8 ye ll ow is h re d – ba se L ow er bo un da ry cl ea r/ di ff us e 50 8 R ed di sh or an ge si lt y cl ay w it h li m es to ne gr av el . S ta nd s sl ig ht ly pr ou d of se ct io n ~3 % 1– 2c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt at ed bl oc ky li m es to ne gr av el . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d D if fu se . 50 9 O ra ng e re d– br ow n cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el 15 % 2m m –2 cm su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed (l ar ge r fr ag m en ts ) li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d. D if fu se 51 3 B ro w n– gr ey cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el .S li gh tl am in ar st ru ct ur e, M od er at e in du ra ti on to ba se of un it . 20 % 1m m –2 cm su ba ng ul ar ,h or iz on ta ll y– or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el 1m m –2 cm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky . 5Y R 4/ 4 re dd is h br ow n C le ar /d if fu se . Appendix Four: Field Descriptions A18 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll L ow er B ou nd ar y 51 7 P al e bu ff si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el ,s em i– in du ra te d, sl ig ht ly pl at y st ru ct ur e. 30 % 0. 5– 3c m an gu la r, pl at y ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar ,w av y. 51 7/ 52 0 B ro w n gr ey cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el 5% 2m m –1 .5 cm an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . < 1% pa le si lt y ye ll ow le ns es , 2c m lo ng an d 2. 5m m th ic k. D if fu se /c le ar . 52 0 R ed di sh br ow n gr it ty si lt w it h co nc en tr at io n of da rk br ow n cl ay ey m at er ia lt o ba sa l1 –2 cm an d li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 15 % ve ry fin e li m es to ne gr it ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar .5 % la rg e bl oc ks of li m es to ne ,s ub an gu la r pl at y to bl oc ky . B as e 2. 5Y R 3/ 5 da rk re dd is h br ow n U pp er 2. 5Y R 4/ 4 re dd is h br ow n 52 1 R ed di sh br ow n cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 10 % 2m m –2 cm ,s ub an gu la r– su br ou nd ed bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it an d (h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt at ed ) gr av el . 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d O ve rl ie s th e sw am py la ye r re si du al at ba se , bu tc le ar (s ub tl e) 52 3 O ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it ,a s be lo w , m as si ve ,h om og en ou s. < 1% li m es to ne gr it . 5Y R 5/ 8 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar bu td if fu se 52 4 P al e or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el , m as si ve ,h om og en ou s. 2– 3% 1– 3m m an d 2c m su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,l im es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d D if fu se 52 6 B ro w n– or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el ,m as si ve . 15 % 2– 3m m ,a nd ~6 m m ,s ub an gu la r, bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el .L ar ge r fr ag m en ts ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d. L ar ge co nt in uo us pa le si lt y le ns e ne ar up pe r bo un da ry of th e un it ov er 30 cm lo ng ,1 –3 m m th ic k D if fu se 52 7 O ra ng e br ow n cl ay ey si lt w it h gr it an d gr av el . M as si ve .S li gh ti nc re as e in cl ay to w ar ds ba se of un it , 2– 3c m . 10 % 2– 5m m to 6c m su br ou nd ed –s ub an gu la r bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 3% la rg e pa le si lt y le ns es , 4– 6c m ,~ 3m m th ic k. 2. 5Y R 4/ 6 re d m ai n, 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d, ba se . D if fu se 52 8 P al e gr ey –b ro w n cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it , cl ea n, m as si ve . < 5% 3– 4m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d B as e of ex ca va ti on s. Appendix Four: Field Descriptions A19 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll B ou nd ar y 46 6 P al e ye ll ow –g re y cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . C om pa ct ,m as si ve st ru ct ur e, w it h ve ry sl ig ht la m in at io ns .M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to la rg e cr ac ks . 5% li m es to ne fin e gr av el :3 % 2– 5m m , su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y, 2% ~2 cm an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed 7. 5Y R 5/ 6 st ro ng br ow n C le ar ,w av y 45 3 P al e or an ge cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . M as si ve st ru ct ur e. 35 % 1– 3c m su ba ng ul ar pl at y– bl oc ky ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el . 1 la rg e w el l– ro un de d li m es to ne co bb le 10 cm ac ro ss ,n ea r lo w er bo un da ry . 7. 5Y R 5/ 8 st ro ng br ow n D if fu se 45 5 P al e ye ll ow –o ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el sl ig ht ly pa le r at th e to p of th e un it ,m or e or an ge to ba se an d sl ig ht ly m or e cl ay .S li gh t ho ri zo nt al la m in at io n in pl ac es 20 –1 0% 2m m –2 .5 cm su ba ng ul ar – an gu la r pl at y li m es to ne gr av el , ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed .G ra ve l co nc en tr at ed to w ar ds ba se . 2% pa le si lt y le ns es , 1c m ,0 .5 m m th ic k 7. 5Y R 5/ 6 st ro ng br ow n S ha rp . 45 1 P al e or an ge y– ye ll ow cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el (p al er at th e to p) . 10 % 2m m –2 cm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky –p la ty li m es to ne gr av el ,( la rg er fr ag m en ts ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d) 7. 5Y R 4/ 6 st ro ng br ow n V er y sh ar p, w av y. 45 8 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it bl oc ky , m as si ve .M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to bl oc ks of se di m en t aa s w el la s ~2 m m de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. M or e cl ay ey an d re dd is h to to p 3– 4c m of un it , or an ge y be lo w . 5% < 1m m –1 cm an gu la r– su ba ng ul ar pl at y li m es to ne gr av el ,s om e ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. 5Y R 4/ 4 re dd is h br ow n C le ar . 45 9 P al e or an ge gr ey cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el , M an ga ne se co at in gs to to la rg e bl oc ks .V er y sl ig ht la m in ar st ru ct ur e. 20 % 0. 5– 4c m su ba ng ul ar –a ng ul ar pl at y li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt at ed to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it . 7. 5Y R 4/ 6 st ro ng br ow n C le ar . 47 0 O ra ng e– br ow n cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . F ai nt ly la m in ar st ru ct ur e an d or ie nt at io n to un it . S li gh tc la y in cr ea se to w ar ds th e ba se . 10 % 1m m su ba ng ul ar bl oc k li m es to ne gr it . 3% le ns es of pa le gr ey si lt ,1 –2 cm , 1m m th ic k. 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar ,s li gh tm ix in g. 47 0 (L ow er ) P al e or an ge –b ro w n si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el ., ve ry sl ig ht ho ri zo nt al la m in at io n 10 % li m es to ne :5 % gr av el 1– 2c m , su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,5 % 1– 2m m , su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar . 49 8 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el ,s li gh tl y m or e cl ay to w ar ds to p of un it .V er y co m pa ct , w ea th er ed pr ou d of se ct io n. M n st ai ni ng to bl oc ks , sm ea rs w it h a tr ow el . 10 % 1– 2. 5c m su ba ng ul ar ,p la ty –b lo ck y ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar ,s li gh tl y w av y. 56 6 P al e or an ge –y el lo w cl ay ey si lt ,w it h li m es to ne gr av el . 20 % 4m m –3 cm an gu la r– su ba ng ul ar pl at y, ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el .O ne la rg e ro un de d co bb le ~7 cm . 3% P al e gr ey si lt le ns es ,7 cm by 1c m ,u nd ul at in g, ho ri zo nt al . 7. 5Y R 4/ 6 st ro ng br ow n C le ar . N or th -F ac in g P ro fil e Appendix Four: Field Descriptions A20 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll B ou nd ar y 49 9 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el st an di ng pr ou d of se ct io n, m or e de ns e th an ov er an d un de rl yi ng ,p oo rl y so rt ed . 10 % ~1 cm su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d pl at y– bl oc ky li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d. S ub tl e, ob sc ur ed by sh or in g. 53 1 P al e or an ge y si lt w it h so m e la m in at io ns . 30 % 1– 4c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el . 7. 5Y R 5/ 8 st ro ng br ow n S ha rp ,c ut by tw o bu rr ow s. 50 3 V er y pa le gr ey –y el lo w si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el w it h sl ig ht ho ri zo nt al la m in ar st ru ct ur e. S li gh tl y m or e pa le to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it . 5% 2m m –4 cm ,s ub an gu la r– su br ou nd ed ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 2% P al e ye ll ow – gr ey si lt le ns es , 1– 2m m .l on g, 1m m th ic k. 7. 5Y R 6/ 6 re dd is h ye ll ow S ha rp ,u nd ul at in g. 50 5 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el ,s ta nd s pr ou d of se ct io n. S li gh tc on ce nt ra ti on of cl ay at th e to p an d bo tt om of un it .M as si ve –b lo ck y 10 % 0. 5– 2c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d pl at y to bl oc ky ,h or iz on ta ll y– or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr av el . 7. 5Y R 4/ 6 st ro ng br ow n V er y sh ar p. 53 4 P al e gr ey –y el lo w si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el .N o re al le ns in g w it hi n, ve ry gr it ty . M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to se di m en tb lo ck s. 25 % 1m m –1 cm an gu la r pl at y– bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el ,l ar ge r ha ve ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. 7. 5Y R 6/ 6 re dd is h ye ll ow C le ar . 50 7 V er y cl ea n bu ff si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el , la m in ar in pl ac es . 5% 1m m –1 .5 cm su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d pl at y, ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . P al e si lt y le ns es ~2 % 1– 2c m lo ng , < 1m m . 7. 5Y R 5/ 6 st ro ng br ow n C le ar 50 8 M ix ed cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el .M as si ve , bl oc ky ,b ut pr ob ab ly ju st th e w ay it ’s w ea th er in g. M n st ai ni ng an d ar ea s of po te nt ia lm ix in g w it h un de rl yi ng m at er ia l– co ul d ju st be ob sc ur ed . 30 % 0. 5– 2. 5c m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y, ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. P ot en ti al ly 1 or 2 cl ay ey le ns es w it hi n – co ul d ju st be cl ea ni ng . S ha rp ,i nt er le av ed . 51 3 A sh y pa le la ye r, in te rl ea ve d si lt w it h re dd is h la ye rs an d pa le ye ll ow –w hi te fa br ic .W hi te at th e to p, th en ye ll ow er /i nt er le av ed gr ey is h co m po ne nt s. In du ra te d, ve ry co m pa ct ed .M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to bl oc ks . 10 % 1– 2c m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky li m es to ne gr av el . C le ar ,u nd ul at in g 53 5 R ed di sh –b la ck si lt w it h li m es to ne co bb le s, al m os t bl oc ky in pl ac es ,l ik e ab ov e bu tp ro ba bl y ju st co nc re ti on br ea ks . 1% su br ou nd ed bl oc ky li m es to ne co bb le s, c. 10 cm . 5Y R 2. 5/ 2 da rk re dd is h br ow n. D if fu se . 56 1 P al e or an ge si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el .V er y ho m og en ou s, no re al la m in at io ns pr es en t. 50 % 2– 4c m an gu la r ho ri zo nt al ly – or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr av el at to p of un it , 2– 4c m ,a ng ul ar .1 % li m es to ne co bb le s ~2 0c m su br ou nd ed –s ub an gu la r in th is co nt ex t. 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar . 53 6 P al e bu ff si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . 10 % 1– 6c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, hr iz on ta ll y– or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr av el . 3% pa le ye ll ow si lt le ns es 1. 5c m lo ng , 1m m th ic k. 7. 5Y R 6/ 4 li gh tb ro w n C le ar /d if fu se . Appendix Four: Field Descriptions A21 C on te xt F ie ld de sc ri pt io n C oa rs e M at er ia l In cl us io ns M un se ll B ou nd ar y 56 2 O ra ng e bu ff cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el .A tb as e, re dd is h cl ay cl ea n le ns es (5 Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d) ,n o re al st ru ct ur e. 15 % 2m m –2 cm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . 7. 5Y R 6/ 4 li gh tb ro w n S ha rp . 53 7 S er ie s of ve ry gr it ty pa le gr ey si lt w it h le ns es of re d cl ay . 20 % 1– 1. 5m m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky ,h or iz on ta ll y– or ie nt at ed li m es to ne gr it . 7. 5Y R 4/ 4 br ow n S ha rp . 56 7 O ra ng e si lt w it h ra re li m es to ne gr it , < 1% 1– 2m m su ba ng ul ar ,b lc ky , li m es to ne gr it . 7. 5Y R 6/ 4 li gh tb ro w n C le ar 52 1 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . < 5% 1– 2c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d, bl oc ky li m es to ne gr av el . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d D if fu se 52 3 R ed di sh –g re y cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . < 1% 1– 2m m su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it . 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d C le ar 52 4 R ed –o ra ng e cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 2% 1– 4m m su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y li m es to ne gr it . 5Y R 5/ 8 ye ll ow is h re d S ha rp . 56 3 R ed di sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d li m es to ne .M as si ve .I nc re as in g cl ay to w ar ds to p of un it . 15 % su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky , li m es to ne ,1 0% 1– 2m m ,5 % 3– 4c m , ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. To w ar ds ba se pa le ye ll ow si lt le ns es 3– 4c m le ng th , 1m m –4 m m . 5Y R 4/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d to p 5Y R 5/ 6 ye ll ow is h re d ba se C le ar w it h ch ar co al le ns e, sl ig ht ly in te rl ea ve d. B ou nd ar y w it h 52 8 is cl ea r, m ar ke d by re dd is h. 56 8 C ha rc oa ll en s - m ix of pa le as h ov er ly in g da rk ch ar co al la ye r. – – D if fu se /c le ar 52 8 O ra ng e– re d cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr av el . 5% 2– 3c m su ba ng ul ar –s ub ro un de d bl oc ky ho ri zo nt al ly -o ri en ta te d li m es to ne gr av el .1 la rg e pl aq ue tt e, 15 cm hz or ie nt at io n, ov er li es bu rn in g. 5% 2– 4m m bl oc ky ch ar co al .3 % pa le ye ll ow si lt le ns es , 2c m –3 m m . 2. 5Y R 4/ 8 re d C le ar ov er 2– 3m m . 56 4 G re yi sh cl ay ey si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it . 2% 0. 5– 1c m su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y, li m es to ne gr it . 2% ch ar co al fle ck s 1– 2m m ,b lo ck y. < 2% li th ic de bi ta ge 2– 5m m . 5Y R 4/ 4 re dd is h br ow n In te rl ea ve d lo w er bo un da ry . 57 0 D ar k gr ey si lt ,d ar ke r at to p. – – 5Y R 2. 5/ 2 da rk re dd is h br ow n D if fu se 52 5 P al e gr ey si lt ,c le an . – – 7. 5Y R 4/ 6 st ro ng br ow n S ha rp V er y pa le gr ey bu ff si lt w it h li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el ,‘ flu ff y’ te xt ur e. 5% 1m m –1 cm ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky li m es to ne gr it an d gr av el . – 7. 5Y R 6/ 6 re dd is h ye ll ow . B as e of ex ca va ti on . A22 M ic ro - F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 75 4A :1 C on te xt 46 6 T hi ck ne ss :5 -1 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry :D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e ov er la in by m od er at el y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y st ru ct ur e in pl ac es .P or os it y: 17 % .7 % pl an ar vo id s 1m m lo ng ,~ 20 -6 0μ m w id e, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al le d. 2% ch an ne ls sm oo th 3- 1m m ,l on g- st ub by . 8% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, 10 0μ m -4 00 μm ,s ta r sh ap ed ir re gu la r ro ug h- is h w al ls ,n o or ie nt at io n. C oa rs e m in er al m at er ia l: 10 % qu ar tz ,4 0- 15 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to w el l- ro un de d th ro ug ho ut – w el ls or te d. 10 % li m es to ne /c al ci te 10 0μ m -2 m m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed th ro ug ho ut no or ie nt at io n, m od er at e to po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay , 70 % si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow s an d go ld s (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 2- 1% bo ne ,1 m m -7 50 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,p la ty ,h ea vi ly pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow - re d gr ey -y el lo w re d bi re fr in ge nc e (h ig h) .B ur nt an d un bu rn t. 2% sh el lp la ty ,s ub an gu la r, 50 0- 80 0μ m ,h or iz on ta lp as te lb ir ef ri ng en ce . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 1% S il ty in fil li ng to lo ng pl an ar vo id .2 ) < 1% si lt y cl ay co at in g to fr ag m en to f du ng or an ge -r ed ~5 0μ m .A m or ph ou s & C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 25 0- 50 0μ m . 2) 10 % ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, di st in ct bo un da ri es 25 0μ m - 10 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,2 0% as so ci at ed w it h m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c hy po co at in gs . F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng ,7 50 μm -1 50 0μ m w el l- ro un de d, pa le br ow n (P P L ) si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs an d sp he ru li te s. O th er s in cr ed ib ly w ar pe d an d di ff us e/ ir re gu la r, to ho ri zo nt al le ns es as w el l. 2) 1% co ar se cr us tf ra gm en t3 m m w el l- ro un de d, tw o se qu en ce s of fin er m ed iu m sa nd fr ag m en ts of bo ne ,o rg an ic ,l im es to ne ,m an ga ne se st ai ne d to o. 3) Y el lo w -o ra ng e m as si ve cl ay ey si lt se di - m en ta gg re ga te s, is ot ro pi c, w el lr ou nd ed .~ 50 0μ m C om po un d: 1) 1% m an ga ne se co at in g to ch an ne l5 0% 40 μm de ep ,b la ck re d. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng O R co ll uv ia lm as s m ov em en t. 75 4A :1 754A:2 754A:3 1c m H F 08 -7 54 A A pp en di x F iv e: F ul lM ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on s Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A23 M ic ro - F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 75 4A :2 T hi ck ne ss : 30 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: Tw o st ru ct ur es :1 ) M as si ve ,v er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y, ir re gu la r. 2) S po ng y. P or os it y: 1) 10 % .7 % vu gh s – ir re gu la r to ro un de d, 3% ve ge ta lv oi ds ,2 00 -5 00 μm .3 % pl an ar ,i nt er co nn ec ti ng ch an ne ls /v ug hs ,1 0μ m -1 m m w id e, lo ng .2 ) 50 % - vu gh s an d ch am be rs C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 40 -2 00 μm ,w el ls or te d th ro ug ho ut .7 % li m es to ne 15 0μ m -1 cm .T hr ou gh ou t, sl ig ht ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 22 :7 8. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,8 0% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), go ld to is ot ro pi c (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d: cr os s- st ri at ed :u nd if fe re nt ia te d (4 0: 20 :4 0) . R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar re d or ga ni c, ch ar co al 45 0μ m ,a ng ul ar ,b lo ck y. 1% 1. 5m m w el lr ou nd ed ,b lo ck y ch ar co al . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne 15 00 -3 00 μm ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ), m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,p oo r so rt in g, gr ey (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M as si ve po ro si ty ch an ge ,b ut m at er ia la pp ea rs co ns ta nt – de sc ri be d ab ov e. 2) H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to m os tc oa rs e el em en ts an d vo id s. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1 co nc en tr ic ir on no du le ,s ha rp ed ge d si lt y cl ay ,a nd qu ar tz ,4 00 μm ro un d. 2) 5- 10 % de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s ar ou nd so m e co ar se in cl us io ns an d in lo os er ar ea s of gr ou nd m as s 2m m -5 00 μm ,m ai n co nc en tr at io n at to p of un it 10 % .R es tt hr ou gh ou t5 % of sl id e – 10 % in lo os er bi ts .3 ) 7% ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s – 3% as so ci at ed w it h m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs ,1 50 μm ,2 -3 m m .I rr eg ul ar to ro un de d, sh ar p to sl ig ht ly di ff us e ed ge s, th ro ug ho ut .4 ) 2% m an ga ne se co at in g to pl an ar vo id s < 10 % di sc on ti nu ou s, re d bl ac k. 5) < 1% ph os ph at ic in fil li ng s to vo id s/ no du le s, 40 0- 60 0μ m ye ll ow (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), da rk or an ge (O IL ). F ab ri c: 1) 20 -3 0% du ng le ns es pa le gr ey to pa le br ow n, th ic k le ns es 60 0μ m th ic k, cm lo ng et c. A ng ul ar ,p hy to li th s sp on gy ,a rt ic ul at ed ph yt ol it hs .2 ) P hy to li th s th ro ug ho ut 5- 10 % of gr ou nd m as s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic ,s ig ni fic an t w et ti ng an d du ng de po si ti on to th e to p of th e un it . 75 4A :3 T hi ck ne ss : 60 -7 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e St ru ct ur e: M as si ve - vu gh y, ov er ly in g w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs ,i rr eg ul ar /s ta r sh ap ed , ro ug h w al le d 20 0- 75 0μ m .5 % co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, 60 -2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls m od er at el y ac co m od at ed th ro ug ho ut .5 % pl an ar – w ho le sl id e sc al e do w n to 2m m ,4 0μ m -1 m m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al m at er ia l: 10 % qu ar tz 40 -2 50 μm ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar -w el lr ou nd ed ,w el ls or te d, w el ld is tr ib ut ed .2 0% li m es to ne - 10 0μ m - 2c m po or ly so rt ed .S li gh th or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on an d di st ri bu ti on .C F li m it :4 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), (o ra ng e( O IL )) .b -f ab ri c: S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% 40 0- 60 0μ m ,b lo ck y, ro un de d, de gr ad ed ce ll st ru ct ur e, m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,c ha rc oa lb la ck -r ed di sh . A rt ef ac ts : 1% fli nt ,b lo ck y, co at ed 75 0- 50 0μ m ro un de d, si lt y cl ay .2 % bo ne 1c m -1 00 μm ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) bf w el lr ou nd ed , po or ly so rt ed .2 % sh el l, pl at y, 50 0μ m -1 25 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on c. 50 % . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C oa rs e fr ag m en ts ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n – at m an y sc al es .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no d- ul es 23 00 μm -7 00 μm ,q ui te sm al l, 1% ar ou nd ir on no du le s- sh ar p 50 0- 80 0μ m ,q ua rt z, re dd is h, w el lr ou nd ed .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s, 40 0μ m - 3m m sh ar p to ir re gu la r, po or ly so rt ed .F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng pa le gr ey le ns 1 or 2 le ns es 1c m to 2- 3m m ,p hy to li th s is ot ro pi c/ sp ar it ic ca lc it e – ve ry fe w sp he ru li te s. R es to f th e du ng is qu it e is ot ro pi c, pa le br ow n sp on gy ,p hy to li th s, st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A24 762:1 762:2 1c m M ic ro -F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 76 2: 1 C on te xt 46 1 T hi ck ne ss : 18 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m as si ve .P or os it y: 15 % .2 % pl an ar vo id s, ~7 00 μm lo ng ,2 0μ m th ic k, 1 or 2 cm lo ng cr ac ks ,p ro ba bl y dr yi ng .1 0% ir re gu la r ch am be rs an d vu gh s, 20 0– 2m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ch am be rs /v ug hs , ro ug h w al ls ,i rr eg ul ar /b lo ck y, m an y in te rc on ne ct ed .V eg et al vo id s ar e 3% .3 % ch an ne ls ,5 00 μm –1 00 μm sm oo th w al le d, ro un de d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 20 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 12 0μ m .M od er at el y so rt ed su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed , bl oc ky .5 % li m es to ne ,1 50 –7 50 μm P oo rl y so rt ed su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .V ar yi ng st ag es of co he re nc e. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F R at io : 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to cr os s- st ri at ed (5 0: 50 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1– 2% 15 00 μm ce ll st ru ct ur e, re dd is h ti ng e to ed ge s, ch ar re d or hu m ifi ed .S ec on d 2. 5m m ,b lo ck y, ca lc it e in po re s, re dd is h ti ng e to ed ge s – ch ar co al . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% sh el l6 50 μm an gu la r, pl at y. 1% bo ne ,3 00 μm ,b lo ck y su ba ng ul ar ye ll ow (P P L )- gr ey (X P L ), ye ll ow or an ge pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C la ye y si lt in fll in gs co m pl et el y in fil li ng sp on gy vo id s at th e to p of th e fa br ic . ~1 30 0μ m ac ro ss 2% of sl id e. 2) 2% si lt y cl ay co at in gs to du ng fr ag m en ts ,5 0μ m th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se /i ro n st ai ni ng in pl ac es 30 μm in ci pi en td en dr it ic no du le s – de fin it e cl us te rs bu td if fu se .M or e po ro us ,a nd or ga ni c m at er ia l. 2) P ho sp ha ti c no du le ,~ 20 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed , ye ll ow -b ro w n, ph yt ol it hs /q ua rt z, is ot ro pi c (X P L ). F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng ,p al e br ow n ye ll ow si lt y sp on gy st ru ct ur e, ph yt ol it hs ,r ou nd ed ,w ar pe d sh ap es ,s om e el on ga te d in to ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. Is ot ro pi c, (X P L ) 2m m –3 00 μm ,f ra gm en ts ,p oo rl y so rt ed .2 ) 1, 60 0μ m –1 00 μm cr us ts ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,fi ne si lt y an d cl ay ,s ub - an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,1 5% of sl id e. O ne ha s ve ry cl ay ey co m po ne nt to it ,2 –3 ep is od es ,p un ct ua te d, cl ay ev en t. ~1 00 μm li ke th is .S li gh tl y co ar se r si lt ie r on es ,5 % ,s il t, bu ts ti ll cl ay ey ,e ve n m or e. 5% .R et ic ul at e/ m as si ve .7 50 –1 00 μm .1 or 2 ha ve ca lc it ic cr us ta lo ng th e to pm os tfi ni ng se qu en ce . C ol lu vi al m ov em en to f so il m at er ia l H F 08 -7 62 76 2: 2 C on te xt 44 9 T hi ck ne ss : 42 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to fin e vu gh y, ar ea of ir re gu la r bl oc ky at to p, (p ed s 25 0μ m -1 50 μm ) ov er ly in g a w ea k to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 25 % .1 0% vu gh s, sm al le r, ir re gu la r, 10 0- 20 0μ m ,w el la cc ,2 % ve ge ta lv ug hs ,1 0% ch am - be rs 25 0μ m -1 m m ,r ou gh -s m oo th w al le d, ir re gu la r bl oc ky .5 % pl an ar vo id s ~7 00 μm ,r ou gh w al le d w el la cc om m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,e ve n di st ri bu ti on 40 -1 00 μm .2 5% li m es to ne gr av el ,1 .5 - 10 0μ m .G ra ve l, 10 % ,1 .5 -2 cm ,2 m m po or ly so rt ed .S ub an gu la r ro un de d. P oo rl y so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,3 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: M in er al ,p al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys - ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne ,1 m m ,r ed (P P L ) re ds (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, A ng ul ar ,p la ty .1 50 0μ m ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) ve ry pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, as so ci at ed w it h m an ga ne se st ai ni ng .1 or 2 ve ry de gr ad ed w it h ca lc it e. 30 0μ m pl at y ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). 2% sh el l, 30 0- 60 0μ m ,p la ty ,a ng ul ar .1 % fli nt ,w el lr ou nd ed ,3 m m bl oc ky . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A25 M ic ro - F ab ri c M ic ro m op ho lo gi ca lD es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 76 2: 2 C on te xt 44 9 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M ac ro va ri at io ns in gr av el co nt en t– co nc en tr at io n to w ar ds ce nt re of un it be lo w an d ab ov e th e le ns in g ar ea . 2) L en se s of re dd is h si lt li nk ca pp in gs to in fil li ng s of pl an ar vo id s at ce nt re of un it ,fi ni ng se qu en ce s ~1 00 μm th ic k an d 1– 2m m lo ng .3 ) L en se s of si lt y m at er ia ls am e co lo ur as gr ou nd m as s bu tw el ls or te d m as si ve an d si lt y po te nt ia ll y cr us ti ng .I nt er le av ed w it h re dd is h si lt dr ap es /i nfi ll in gs at ce nt re .U p to 1m m th ic k 3– 4m m lo ng .4 ) S il ty re d in fil li ng s to pl an ar vo id s un de r an d ar ou nd la rg e bl oc ks at ba se ~5 % ,i n pl ac es co m pl et e in fil li ng .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 2– 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s th ro ug ho ut 25 0– 30 0μ m , so m e w it h ir on nu cl eu se s th ro ug ho ut .2 ) 7% ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, ro un d to di ff us e 10 0μ m –3 m m .F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng ve ry pa le , m ic ri ti c, si lt y sp on gy ,w it h sp he ru li te s an d ph yt ol it hs – m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to o, 3m m el on ga te d le ns es to 50 0μ m w el l- ro un de d de gr ad ed , ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed . (s ee ab ov e) Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A26 M ic ro -F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on s 76 3: 1 C on te xt 45 0 T hi ck ne ss : 45 -5 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /v er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e 15 0μ m -2 00 μm .P or os it y: 20 % . 15 % vu gh s – ir re gu la r ro ug h w al le d 80 -8 00 0μ m .2 % ch an ne l– co nc en tr at io n in on e ar ea 25 0- 40 0μ m ro un d. 3% pl an ar vo id s – in te rc on ne ct in g vu gh s - < 40 μm w id e, cm lo ng . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 60 -2 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .1 5% li m es to ne 3c m -1 50 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y/ ir re gu la r. C F li m it : 60 μm .C F R at io : 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), or an ge -g ol d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en -c lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% fli nt ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar ,2 m m .2 % bo ne ,2 00 -5 00 μm pl at y, pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d sa ye ll ow or an ge -y el lo w gr ey bi re fr in ge nc e. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) < 1% st ri ng er s of cl ay as in un it ab ov e. C ry st al li ne : 1) In cr ea se in ca lc it e to to p of un it ,c al ci ti c gr ou nd m as s, up to 40 % – zo ne is 1m m .2 )A re a of in te rc on ne ct ed ca lc it e hy po co at in gs in ce nt re of un it .L in ke d to ar ea of ch an ne ls ,t o sa m e ex te nt as to p of un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) ~5 % de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 10 0μ m -5 00 μm .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s 15 0- 2m m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,s ha rp to su bt le bo un da ri es ,i rr eg ul ar to o. 3% pe do re li ct s, th e re st no du le s in va ri ou s st ag es of fo rm at io n. T hr ou gh ou t~ 10 % of al lm an ga ne se ,i rr eg ul ar ,l in ke d to ir on no du le s 3) < 1% m an ga ne se hy po co at in g to ch an ne l~ 10 μm .F ab ri c: 1) 10 % du ng ho ri zo nt al la m in at io ns .N um be r of di ff er en tf or m s: P al e ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt in la rg e ch un ks ho ri - zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed at th e to p of th e un it 30 0μ m th ic k, ot he r ch un ks ~p al e br ow n- ye ll ow ,i so tr op ic ph yt ol it hs , sp he ru li te s 1m m -8 00 μm ph yt ol it hs ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to o. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 763:1 763:2 1c m 76 3: 2 C on te xt 44 9 T hi ck ne ss : 20 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m or e bl oc ky to w ar ds th e to p. P or os it y: 20 % .1 2% vu gh s/ ve ge ta lv oi ds – 80 –9 00 μm ro ug h w al le d. 7% pl an ar – 20 μm th ic k to 20 0μ m ,i nt er co nn ec ti ng vu gh s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 15 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t. 10 % li m es to ne 15 0– 5m m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky , po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm ,C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d to is ot ro pi c (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ce ll st ru ct ur e, am or ph ou s, m an ga ne se ~6 00 μm ar ea . A rt ef ac ts :2 % bo ne 40 0– 70 0μ m pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar ,c al ci te to o. 1 or 2 bi ts .< 1% fli nt ,1 m m bl oc ky an gu la r. < 1% sh el l~ 40 0μ m pl at y, su br ou nd ed . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty cl ay hy po co at in gs to ve ge ta lv oi ds .2 ) S il ty cl ay co at in g to 1% of bo ne & fli nt < 10 μm .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc - ry st al li ne :1 ) 10 % m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, so m e m or e di ff us e th an ot he rs ,5 00 –8 00 μm .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s, sh ar p- di ff us e 1m m –1 50 μm w el l ro un de d, th ro ug ho ut .A bo ut 1/ 3 as so ci at ed w it h de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s. F ab ri c: 1) 7% du ng – va ry in g st at es of pr es er va ti on in te rm s of sh ap e – pa le br ow n si lt – so m e di ffi cu lt to se e, w it h ph yt ol it hs – is ot ro pi c. H or iz on ta ll en se s 1– 2m m ,~ 60 μm th ic k – 20 0. 2) < 1% ar ti cu la te d ph yt ol it hs , ho ri zo nt al ,~ 80 0μ m m lo ng st em . C ol lu vi al m ov em en t of po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia lw it h pa st or ga ni c co m po ne nt . H F 08 -7 63 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A27 938:1 938:2 93 8: 3 1c m 938:4 M ic ro -F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 93 8: 3 C on te xt 52 2 T hi ck ne ss : 20 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : cl ea r, m ar ke d by in cr ea se in oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. U pp er bo un da ry : in te rl ea ve d w it h ov er ly in g m or e cr ys ta ll it ic un it . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y. P or os it y: 15 % ,1 0% ir re gu la r vu gh s, 60 –1 00 μm ,r ou gh w al ls . 5% pl an ar vo id s, 10 μm th ic k to 3c m lo ng ,s m oo th to ro ug h w al ls ,m od er at el y to w el l- ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,c oa rs e si lt to fin e sa nd ,5 0μ m –1 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r- su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .5 % li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd to gr av el ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky , 20 0μ m –1 cm .C F L im it : 50 μm .C F R at io : 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 25 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,1 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge -r ed br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: C ha rr ed m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t, 20 % ‘fi br ou s’ bl oc ky ch ar re d m at er ia l, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed ,2 00 –4 00 μm .A ls o la rg er bl oc ks 20 00 –3 00 0μ m w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e. 1% si li ca an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it e w oo dy pl an ts tr uc tu re ,3 00 μm ,b lo ck y, an gu la r. A rt ef ac ts : 2% fli nt ,a ng ul ar ,s he rd y, 50 00 μm to 30 0μ m ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .5 % bu rn tb on e fr ag m en ts ,s ub ro un de d, 10 0– 40 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar .1 % ve si cu la r si li ca ag gr eg at es ,r ou nd ,3 50 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s: 1) 10 % ar ea s of m an ga ne se /i ro n st ai ni ng to gr ou nd m as s. 2) 5% pe do re li ct s/ ir on no du le s, w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p ed ge s, 30 0μ m –1 00 0μ m .F ab ri c: 1) 1% m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic ag gr eg at es w it h rh om bo he dr al cr ys ta ls (a sh ), 30 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d. In cl us io ns in gr ou nd m as s up to 3% gi vi ng sl ig ht ly gr ey co lo ur .2 ) 1% po te nt ia lc ru st fr ag m en ts ,4 00 μm , ro un de d an d cr ac ki ng .M as si ve li ke bi ts of fin in g se qu en ce . O cc up at io n m at er ia lo n un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. H F 08 -9 38 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A28 938:1 938:2 938:3 1c m M ic ro - F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 93 9: 1 C on te xt 50 7 T hi ck ne ss : 30 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r to di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e, ov er ly in g v w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, m as si ve in pl ac es .P or os it y: 20 % ov er al l. 15 % vu gh s, an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, w el ls or te d, ir re gu la r, 10 0μ m –3 00 μm ,r ou gh w al ls ,t hr ou gh ou t, w el l ac co m m od at ed ,e lo ng at ed .5 % ir re gu la r, in te rc on ne ct ed ch an ne ls .3 00 μm –4 m m ,i rr eg ul ar . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed 50 –1 20 μm ,w el ls or te d, th ro ug ho ut ,w it h so m e su bt le le ns in g. 10 % li m es to ne fr ag m en ts ,s ub ro un de d to ro un de d 80 – 15 00 μm ,m od er at el y so rt ed ,t hr ou gh ou t. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F R at io : 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay , 70 % si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ), go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d: m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic 90 :1 0. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic : < 1% ch ar co al fr ag m en ts ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,3 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d bl oc ky . A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el l, pl ay ,5 00 –6 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r th ro ug ho ut ,n o or ie nt at io n. < 1% bo ne ,p it te d, cr ac ke d, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) In ce nt re of un it ,c .1 5m m fr om to p of sl id e, sh if tt o le ss co ar se m at e- ri al th an be lo w .C ry st al li ne : 1) A re a of ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs w it h w ha ta pp ea rs to be ch an ne ls w hi ch ha ve be en di sr up te d an d re -c oa te d w it h ca lc it e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s in m or e po ro us ar ea s, 20 0– 50 0μ m ,s li gh tl y m or e in lo w er ha lf .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s, 30 0μ m –1 m m ,t hr ou gh ou t, po or ly so rt ed ,l ar ge r on es co nc en tr at ed in bo tt om ha lf ,s ha rp -b lo ck y, w el lr ou nd ed .F ab ri c: 1) 2% D un g – si ng le lo ng le ns w it h on ly sp he ru li te s le ft ,a ss oc ia te d w it h ph yt ol it hs in su rr ou nd in g gr ou nd m as s, 2. 5m m lo ng .O th er s pa le ye ll ow si lt (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ) sp he ru li te s, ph yt ol it hs ,2 50 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,i rr eg ul ar . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lr ed ep os it ed in m ud flo w . 93 9: 2 C on te xt 50 8 T hi ck ne ss : 30 –5 0m m L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ,m or e m as si ve to w ar ds to p. F ur th er do w n un it ,f ro m ~0 .5 cm on w ar ds ,i n- cr ed ib ly vu gh y, fu si ng gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at es as cl ay ey cr us tf ra gm en ts in cr ea se .P or os it y: 15 –2 5% de pe nd in g on de pt h (1 5% vu gh s at to p) .2 0% ir re gu la r vu gh s an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s 80 μm –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th w al le d, so m e st ar ry .5 % pl an ar vo id s in te rc on ne ct in g, w el l ac co m m od at ed ,~ 40 μm w id e, sm oo th w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,4 0μ m –1 00 μm ,m ai nl y su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .1 0% li m es to ne bl oc ky -i rr eg ul ar ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,1 00 μm –3 m m .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), ye ll ow to re d- go ld (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- m os ai c sp ec kl ed 60 :4 0. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic s: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,1 .5 m m ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), w el l- ro un de d m ag a- ne se st ai ni ng . R ap id in w as h of po te nt ia l so il m at er ia li n at le as tt w o m ai n ph as es . T ru nc at es 50 9. H F 08 -9 39 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A29 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 93 9: 2 C on te xt 50 8 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) ~1 0% cl ay ey si lt co at in g to vo id s. 2) 20 % In fil li ng s/ w ar pe d cr us ts of cl ay m at er ia lw it hi n gr ou nd m as s – as so ci at ed co at in gs to vo id s an d co ar se m at er ia l. C on ce nt ra te d to ba se of un it . 2) To w ar ds to p 4m m th e un it be co m es m or e si lt y w it h le ss cl ay pe do fe at ur es .C ry st al li ne : 1) 2 ra di al sp he ru le s, 20 0μ m ,r ou nd ed .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, qu it e st ub by an d fr am bo id s lo os e in fa br ic – lo os er ar ea s of gr ou nd m as s an d w it hi n. 2) 3% ir on no du le s or pe do re li ct s, w el l- ro un de d, 30 0– 40 0μ m .F ab ri c: 1) 3– 5% % du ng ,w el lr ol le d, sl ig ht si lt y cl ay co at in g, pa le ye ll ow si lt y sp on gy w it h ph yt ol it hs , fe w sp he ru li te s 30 0– 70 0μ m th ro ug ho ut .2 ) 30 % C ru st an d in fil li ng fr ag m en ts ,2 00 μm –1 00 0μ m ,q ui te di ff us e ed ge s in pl ac es fo rm in g co nt in uu m w it h fa br ic .B ec om e fin er an d m or e sp ar se fr om th e ba se of th e un it .E xc re m en ta l: G ra nu la r, al so in ch an ne ls ex cr em en ts . (s ee ab ov e) . 93 9: 3 C on te xt 50 9 T hi ck ne ss : 55 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m as si ve to m od er at e- w el ld ev el op ed gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 25 % .2 0% vu gh s – 50 μm –1 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,i rr eg u- la r w ar pe d (a nd co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s) sm al lv ug hs .V eg et al vo id s. 5% pl an ar vo id s – 2– 3c m to < 50 0μ m ,i nt er co nn ec ti ng vu gh s, w el l ac co m m od at in g si de s, ir re gu la r. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky qu ar tz ,r an do m di st ri bu ti on th ro ug ho ut 50 –1 50 μm ,w el ls or te d. 20 % li m es to ne an d ca lc it e gr av el ,r ou nd ed ,1 00 –1 cm po or ly so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), fir st -o rd er or an ge go ld s (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta l- li ti c (9 0: 10 ). O rg an ic : N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne 30 0– 75 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 10 % S il ty in cr ea se s/ co nc en tr at io ns ar ou nd m os ta gg re ga te s an d po re sp ac es – pa ck in g vo id s. ~1 0μ m .2 ) S il ty cl ay co at in gs to 1% of co ar se m at er ia l– 20 μm th ic k, br ig ht re d- or an ge .3 ) C la ye y co at in gs to 1% of vo id s – ~2 0μ m ,b ri gh to ra ng e, sl ig ht ly du st y. 4) S il ty cl ay le ns es /s m al li nfi ll in gs ~3 % of sl id e, re d, th in ,6 00 μm ~ po te nt ia ll y sm al li nfi ll in gs .C ry st al li ne : 1) 3 ra di al sp he ru le s, on e fr ag m en ta ry an d ir on -s ta in ed .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 2% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,d en dr it ic to si ng le gr ai n ~5 00 μm di ff us e, sm al le r le ss di ff us e~ 20 0μ m .2 ) ~2 % ir on no du le s 1c m –2 00 μm po or ly so rt ed ,s ha rp ,r ou nd ed ,o ne pa le gr ey bl ac k on e. F ab ri c: 1) C ru st s an d br ok en in fil li ng s de fin e th e un it – up to 25 % of sl id e 1. 5– 50 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,m ul ti pl e la ye rs ,v es ic le s, w ar pi ng ,d is or ie nt ed .2 ) 2% D un g w el l- ro un de d to di ff us e - pa le ye ll ow si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs 1. 5c m –3 00 μm .3 )A re as of co m pl et e cl ay si lt in fil li ng s to vo id ar ea s sa m e si ze cl as se s as cr us ts 5% – es pe ci al ly to w ar ds th e ba se . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h in cr ea si ng , pu nc tu at ed sh ee tw as h an d la te r di sr up ti on . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A30 940:1 940:2 940:3 1c m M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol gi ca lD es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 94 0: 1 C on te xt 50 5 T hi ck ne ss : 4c m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e 50 –8 0μ m ,p oo rl y de ve lo pe d/ sw ir ly fu se d la rg er ag gr eg at e. 70 :3 0 be tw ee n th e tw o. P or os it y: P ac ki ng vo id s in w el ld ev el op ed up to 40 % of sl id e, in po or ly de ve lo pe d ar ea s of st ru ct ur e 20 –1 0% ,8 0– 20 0μ m ,5 % vu gh s – in la rg e ag gr eg at es w it h m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e, 25 0μ m -7 00 μm ,s m oo th w al ls ,s li gh tl y ir re gu la r sh ap es C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz – 15 0μ m –5 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky , th ro ug ho ut .2 0% ca lc it e/ li m es to ne ,0 .7 5c m to 10 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ir re gu la r. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd ,s an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), du ll y or an ge -y el lo w (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic s: < 1% or ga ni c st ru ct ur e ~6 00 μm lo ng ro un de d, bl ac k. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ro un de d, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. < 1 sh el l~ 20 0μ m pl at y, an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al :1 ) L ay er of in fil li ng /c ru st in g an d co ar se ni ng se qu en ce s – 2% of al ls li de ~3 00 μm bl oc ky ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed 2) < 1% cl ay ey si lt co at in g to li m es to ne fr ag m en ts , gr an os tr ia te d b- fa br ic .C ry st al li ne : 1) 1% 10 0– 15 0μ m la rg e ra di al sp he ru le s, st ar -s ha pe d an d ro un d. 2) H yp oc oa ti ng of sp ar it ic ca lc it e to 4m m fr ag m en ts of ve si cu la r si li ca .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 3% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s as so ci at ed w it h po re sp ac e, al so ca pp in g pe ds et c. m or e de nd ri ti c ~5 00 μm ac ro ss ,t hr ou gh ou t. 2) 2% ir on no du le s, 20 0μ m –2 m m po or ly so rt ed ,w el l ro un de d, sh ar p. O th er ar ea s of ir on im pr eg na ti on (1 –2 m m ) pa le r w it h m or e di ff us e ed ge s. F ab ri c: 1) 2% D un g, le ns es 30 00 μm ,i so tr op ic (X P L ), th in < 1% pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n, no sp he ru li te s, le nt ic ul ar , un du la ti ng .7 50 μm ,r ou nd ed bl oc ky fr ag m en ts ,1 % sh ar p ed ge s – pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n w it h sp he ru li te s. R ou nd er bl oc ks to w ar ds th e ba se of un it .2 ) C ru st an d in fil li ng fr ag m en ts – up to 20 % of ar ea at to p of un it 1. 5c m by 5c m ,i nv er te d or br ok en ,2 –3 cm to 20 0μ m .V er y fin e qu ar tz sa nd an d si lt so rt ed in m ul ti pl e fin in g se qu en ce s. 3) < 1% fr ag m en to f ve si cu la r si li ca ,5 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,g re y (P P L ) is ot ro pi c (X P L ). P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lh ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d an d ro ot ed ,w it h pu nc tu at ed sh ee tw as h. 94 0: 2 C on te xt 50 6 T hi ck ne ss : 33 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e- m as si ve 80 % .2 0% at bo tt om is m od er at el y to w el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e, lo w es t0 .5 cm be fo re co nt ra ct .~ 60 μm .P or os it y: 15 % . V ug hs 10 % < 50 μm –4 00 μm ir re gu la r, ir re gu la r- sm oo th w al ls ,m od er at el y to po or ly so rt ed – sm al le r is 40 :6 0. W ar pe d. 2% ch an ne ls 70 0μ m sm oo th w al le d, al on g pl ac es .3 % P la na r vo id s – ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed ne ar to p, ot he rs di ag on al ac ro ss 1m m –c m sc al e. F ro m 60 μm w id e to 20 0μ m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,5 0– 12 0μ m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,d is tr ib ut ed th ro ug ho ut ,r an do m .2 5% li m es to ne ,1 00 μm –6 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed th ro ug h- ou t, co ul d be so m e la m in at io n/ co nc en tr at io n la ye rs .2 % gr av el ,1 5% co ar se sa nd ,5 % m ed iu m sa nd , 3% ve ry fin e sa nd .C F li m it : 50 μm ,C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. 15 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt 30 % sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . M as s co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng of po te nt ia l ae ol ia n m at er ia l. H F 08 -9 40 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A31 M ic ro - F ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 94 0: 2 C on te xt 50 6 (c on t.) F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed D is tr ib ut io n: O pe n- cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ce ll st ru ct ur e ~2 00 μm ,b lo ck y, de gr ad ed ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% sh el l, pl at y, su ba ng ul ar 70 0μ m –3 00 μm no or ie nt at io n or di st ri bu ti on . 1% bo ne ,8 00 μm –5 00 μm ,w el ls or te d, pl at y, su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). la rg e fr ag m en t2 m m ,s ub ro un de d, w it h m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,p it te d, cr ac ke d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S li gh tfi ni ng an d re dd en in g to w ar ds to p of un it in fin e m at er ia l. 2) S il ty cr us tb el ow co nt ac ta tt op of un it ,~ 20 0μ m th ic k, 1m m w id e. 3) M aj or sh if ti n m ic ro st ru ct ur e at ba se to ex cr em en ta lg ra nu la r fa br ic ,w it h ve ry lo os el y pa ck ed pe ds .4 ) L in k ca pp in g ru nn in g th e le ng th of th e lo w er co nt ac t, 25 0– 30 0μ m th ic k. 4) 2% ‘s w ir li ng ’a nd w ar pi ng of vo id s ar ou nd co ar se co m po ne nt s. C ry st al li ti c: 1) S il ty ca lc it ic co at in g to 1 la rg e ch un k of li m es to ne ~3 0μ m th ic k, ye ll ow y- gr ey at ed ge s, fin e gr ai ne d. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s in gr ou nd m as s 1m m –5 00 μm ,q ui te di ff us e. A ls o in lo os e ar ea s co nc en tr at ed ar ou nd pe ds < 2% .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s – w el lr ou nd ed 30 0μ m ,– 4m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,r ed -b ro w n, sh ar p ed ge s. F ab ri c: 1) 1% D un g – pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt ,f ew ph yt ol it hs – sp on gy -v ug hy m ic ro st ru ct ur e 70 0μ m ,r ou nd ed ,i so tr op ic , ha rd to di st in gu is h fr om gm .2 ) 1 fr ag m en to f ve si cu la r si li ca ,2 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,s ub an gu la r gr ey (P P L ) is ot ro pi c (X P L ). (s ee ab ov e) 94 0: 3 T hi ck ne ss : 40 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e su pe ri m po se d on vu gh y/ m as si ve w it h so m e ar ea s of w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e/ m as si ve .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% sm al lv ug hs /c om po un d pa ck in g vo id s, 40 0– 10 0μ m ,m od er at el y so rt ed ,t hr ou gh ou t. 15 % to w ar ds to p. 5% in te rc on ne ct ed ch an ne ls /p la na r vo id s al m os tc ha m be rs ,s m oo th -r ou gh w al ls C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,6 0– 15 0μ m ,w el ls or te d su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t. 20 % li m es to ne ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,v er y po or ly so rt ed 15 0μ m –1 cm ,l ar ge r co nc en tr at io n to w ar ds to p of sl id e. L ar ge r w it h fr ag m en ts of st al ag m it e. C F li m it : 60 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ), go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ) sp ec kl ed li m pi di ty .b -f ab ri c: S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n- cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic : N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ,b ur nt an d un bu rn t, ye ll ow pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d to or an ge (P P L ), 20 0μ m –7 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L in k ca pp in g to so il ag gr eg at es th at fo rm ab ov e en ti re to p su rf ac e of th e un it .U p to 20 0μ m th ic k. C on ti nu ou s ac ro ss se c- ti on ,c la ye y si lt ,a ss oc ia te d w it h il lu vi al co at in gs in vo id s di re ct ly be lo w .2 ) C oa rs en in g of m at er ia lt ow ar ds th e to p of th e un it ,i nc re as e in li m es to ne gr it fr om lo w es tc m .C ry st al li ne : 1) 1 la rg e ra di al sp he ru le 10 0μ m –1 50 μm .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 40 0μ m th ro ug ho ut ,1 is la rg er th an 1. 5c m .2 ) 1% m an ga ne se co at in g to vo id s, m am il la te in to gr ou nd m as s 40 0μ m lo ng .3 ) 5% ir on no du le s fr om 13 m m ,i nc ip ie nt co nc en tr ic st ru ct ur e, bu tm ai nl y ir re gu la r 10 –1 00 μm .V er y po or ly so rt ed ,w el l- ro un de d to di ff us e. F ab ri c: 1) 2– 3% du ng – pa le ca lc it e le ns es – sp on gy st ru ct ur e, pa le gr ey (P P L ) to gr ey (X P L ), tr un ca te d ph yt ol it hs ,p at ch es ap pr ox 30 0– 60 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d, pa ck ed w it h sp he ru li te s – ar ti cu la te d ph yt ol it hs . P al e ye ll ow (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), sp he ru li te s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia lr ed ep os it ed in m ud flo w . B io tu rb at ed du ri ng ex po su re . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A32 961:1 961:2 961:3 1c m M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 96 1: 1 T hi ck ne ss : 32 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d vu gh y/ m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e, ce - m en te d to ge th er th ro ug h ca lc it e de po si ti on .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% ch am be rs /v ug hs ,8 0– 1m m ,m ai nl y sm al le r, th ro ug ho ut .2 % ch an ne ls 50 0μ m –1 m m ,s m oo th w al ls 3% pl an ar ~3 0– 60 μm ,t hi ck w el la c- co m m od at ed ,j oi ni ng ch am be rs . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 40 –1 50 μm ,c oa rs e si lt ,t o ve ry fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r- su b- ro un de d bl oc ky .2 0% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el ,a lt er ed at ed ge s to ir re gu la r. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,5 2% si lt ,3 3% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic :m ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (5 0: 50 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n- cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% st ra w -l ik e lo ng it ud in al ce ll st ru ct ur e 30 0– 1μ m w id e, sh ar p, ve rt ic al . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,4 00 –8 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow -g re y (X P L ) pi tt ed an d st ai ne d. 1% sh el l, el on ga te d, 75 0– 90 0μ m ,a ng ul ar ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on < 1% fli nt ,8 00 μm ,s ub an gu - la r bl oc ky ,c la y co at in g, < 30 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) V es ic ul ar cl ay ey in fil li ng to la rg e vo id s re d, 1c m ac ro ss .W el l- co ns tr ai ne d in ar ea to th e to p of th e sl id e. C ry st al li ne : 1) A lm os tc om pl et e co nc re ti on of lo w er pa rt of m ic ro -f ab ri c 1– 1. 5c m .M or e he av il y co nc re te d th an un it be lo w .2 ) V er y th in cl ay co at in gs to vo id s ov er la in by ca lc it e co at in gs an d hy po co at in gs .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 3– 5% m an ga ne se de n- dr it ic /d if fu se no du le s in m or e po ro us ar ea s of th e gr ou nd m as s, 20 0– 75 0μ m .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s – 15 0μ m –1 m m ,v as tm aj or it y w el l- ro un de d, so m e v. sl ig ht ly di ff us e, th ro ug ho ut .F ab ri c: 1) ~1 0% du ng – ra ng in g fr om re d si lt y cl ay ag gr eg at es to th os e do m in at ed by pa le ye ll ow -g re y si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs , bo th el on ga te d le ns es an d bl oc ky ro un de d, 80 –2 50 μm w el lr ol le d bl oc ky 1– 2m m .2 -2 % ha ve < 10 μm co at in gs of re d cl ay ey si lt .S ph er ul it es . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n/ in te rn al de po si ti on w it h si gn ifi ca nt w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 96 1: 2 T hi ck ne ss : 65 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve -v ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s/ cp v/ ch am be rs – ir re gu la r, m ai nl y, 50 –2 00 μm ,5 % to 60 0μ m .I n pl ac es 3% ve ge ta lv oi ds ,1 00 –2 00 μm .5 % pl an ar –i nt er co nn ec ti ng la rg er ch am be rs ~8 0– 30 μm w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 20 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky 10 % li m es to ne 10 0μ m –1 .5 cm ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,v er y fin e sa nd to gr av el ,v ar ie s in di st ri bu ti on – lo w er % an d fin er at ba se ,h ig he r % an d la rg er at to p of un it .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge -y el lo w (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed :c ry st al li ti c (8 0: 20 ) – m or e cr ys ta ll it ic to w ar ds to p of un it (s ee pe do fe at ur es ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% bl oc ky ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,3 50 μm . A rt ef ac ts :< 1% fli nt ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar ,7 00 μm P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,f ol lo w ed at so m e po in tb y w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er .H ea vi ly di sr up te d at th e to p of th e un it th ro ug h bi ot ur ba ti on or tr am pl in g. H F 08 -9 61 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A33 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 96 1: 2 C on te xt 50 4 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) In cr ea se in co ar se m at er ia la nd po or so rt in g in m id dl e po rt io n of sl id e, di so rg an is ed ,w it h gr an ul ar an d fr ag m en te d st ru ct ur e in pl ac es .P oo re r so rt in g is pa rt of a gr ad ua lc ha ng e fr om th e ba se of un it .A ss oc ia te d w it h ca lc it ic in fil li ng s to po re s an d ot he r bi ot ur ba ti on m ar ke rs .C ry st al li ne : 1) 1c m ar ea of sp ar it ic ca lc it ic hy po co at in g to pl an ar vo id in te rs ec ti on to w ar ds ba se of un it .2 ) In cr ea se in cr ys ta ll in e gr ou nd m as s to w ar ds to p of fa br ic .U p to 40 % sp ar it ic /m ic ri ti c, gr ad ua ls hi ft fr om ba se .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1- 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 30 0– 50 0μ m to w ar ds th e to p 2) 1% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to vo id ed ge s, to w ar ds ba se of un it – br ok en up an d ~4 0μ m .3 ) 5% ir on no du le s, sh ar p bo un da ri es ,w el lr ou nd ed ,0 .5 cm –2 00 μm ,s li gh tl y di ff us e, (s m al le r) .F ab ri c: 1) 2% C ru st s ar ou nd ar ea of gr ad ua lc ha ng e at ba se of un it .7 00 –9 00 μm w id e, 30 0μ m th ic k 2) Z on e of cr us tf ra gm en ts /i nfi ll in g fr ag m en ts in m ix ed ar ea at th e to p of th e un it – up to 1c m ,c om pl ex of la ye rs of si lt y cl ay /c la ye y si lt – w ar pe d w it hi n la rg e fr ag m en t3 )2 –3 % D un g – so m e ve ry de gr ad ed an d di ff us e to ro un de d 60 0μ m –8 00 μm .N ea r to p of m ic ro –f ab ri c, la rg e ch un ks ,1 –2 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,p hy to li th s et c, pa le br ow n. M uc h m or e el on ga te in m ix ed ar ea .C on ce nt ra ti on of up to 5– 10 % co nc en tr at io n. (s ee ab ov e) 96 1: 3 C on te xt 50 5 T hi ck ne ss : 1c m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /c ha nn el -v ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .P or os it y: 10 % 2% ch an ne ls 20 0- 1m m el on ga te d, sm oo th w al le d. 5% vu gh s/ ch am be rs 15 0μ m –8 00 μm ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al ls .3 % pl an ar vo id s 20 –1 00 μm ,t hi ck ,w el la cc om m od at ed ro ug h w al le d C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t. 20 % li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el , 15 0μ m –1 cm po or ly so rt ed su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed – de fin es un it .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 25 % cl ay ,5 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .C la y lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -o ra ng e (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed :m os ai c (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n to cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% 50 0μ m bl oc ky ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,v er y ob li qu e. A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne 12 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,s ub an gu la r pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, lo w bf 2% fli nt 80 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 1% M ic ro cr us ts of si lt y cl ay at ri gh th an d si de of fa br ic ,a bo ut 60 –1 00 μm th ic k, 1– 2m m ac ro ss .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 10 % m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to vo id s – pl an ar vo id s an d op en gr ou nd ,~ 20 μm –5 0μ m ,d is co nt in uo us .2 ) < 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s li nk ed to ir on no du le s ~6 00 μm w id e. 3) 5% ir on no du le s, w el lr ou nd ed ,s ha rp ,t hr ou gh ou t, ir re gu la r- ro un d ~2 00 –7 50 μm . F ab ri c: 1) 2% D un g – pa le br ow n si lt ,i so to pi c, w el lr ou nd ed fr ag m en ts ,p hy to li th s di sa rt ic ul at ed .3 00 –1 00 0μ m .B io tu rb at io n: 1) C ha nn el s fu ll of gr an ul ar ex cr em en t, 10 0– 20 0μ m . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sp or ad ic w et ti ng by ve ry lo ca li se d, sm al l- sc al e sh ee tw as h. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A34 1000:1 1000:2 1000:4 1c m 1000:3 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 00 :1 C on te xt 49 7 T hi ck ne ss : 3c m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e. A gg re ga te s ar e po or ly so rt ed ,5 0– 20 0μ m .P or os it y: 15 % vu gh s, ir re gu la r, 80 0– 50 μm (5 % ve ge ta l, la rg er ~5 00 μm ), 3% ch an - ne ls ,5 m m –1 m m ,r ou nd ed ,e lo ng at ed ,s m oo th w al le d, 2% pl an ar vo id s, 3– 1m m ,~ 50 μm th ic k, sm oo th w al le d m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,4 0– 12 0μ m ,e ve nl y di st ri bu te d w it h so m e ve ry sl ig ht cl us te ri ng of 2 or 3 gr ai ns .1 0% li m es to ne fin e sa nd an d gr av el 3m m –2 00 μm , su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,r an do m di st ri bu ti on .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n– re d (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge -r ed (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: no ne A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,6 00 μm pl at y, ir re gu la r, pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ) ye ll ow gr ey (X P L ). 1% sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r, 30 0μ m ,s ub ro un de d, ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty co at in gs to ve ge ta lv oi ds ,2 00 –5 00 μm ,2 ) F in e m at er ia lc oa ti ng so m e co ar se co m po ne nt s an d ve ge ta lv oi ds .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 3% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, fr am bo id s an d ve ry de ns e no du le s. 30 –4 0μ m ,2 00 μm .C on ce nt ra ti on at ba se of un it .2 ) 10 % of la rg e vo id s, m an ga ne se hy po co at in g an d co at in g to vo id s – 1% fr am bo id s, 20 –6 0μ m th ic k. 3) 3% ir on no du le s, ve ry w el lr ou nd ed ,p oo rl y so rt ed fr om 4m m –2 00 μm ,a nd co nc en tr at ed to th e to p w it h m an ga ne se ,1 la rg e (3 –4 m m ) w it h ve ge ta lv oi ds w it hi n it .F ab ri c: 1) 10 % du ng – pa le br ow n si lt , sp on gy m ic ro st ru ct ur e w it h sp he ru li te s in 30 % of th e fr ag m en ts ,a pp ea ri ng in cr ed ib ly m ic ri ti c be ca us e of de ns it y. O th er w is e is ot ro pi c. U p to 3– 4m m fr om 40 0μ m .A rt ic ul at ed ,w av y st ri ng s of ph yt ol it hs , el on ga te d w av es ,a ls o in gr ou nd m as s, ir re gu la r, m os tq ui te di ff us e, po or ly so rt ed .2 ) S in gl e fr ag m en t of as he d or si li ci fie d ce ll st ru ct ur e, 50 00 μm .E xc re m en ta l: 1) L ar ge bu rr ow th ro ug h un it 3c m w id e, in cl ud in g du ng w it h ab un da nt sp he ru li te s, ro un d, sp on gy st ru ct ur e. C ol lu vi al re w or ki ng of po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n- de po si te d an d re w or ke d ca ve -fl oo r se di m en ts in a sl ur ry . 10 00 :2 C on te xt T hi ck ne ss : 20 –2 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m as si ve ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e (p ed s ro un d 50 –1 00 μm ). P or os it y: 15 % .1 3% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, sm oo th – ro ug h w al ls ,b lo ck y w ar pe d, 80 μm –1 m m . 2% pl an ar vo id s, 3– 1c m lo ng ,< 20 μm ,w id e – ot he rs sh or te r, ~5 0μ m w id e an d 30 0μ m lo ng . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed qu ar tz ,5 0– 10 0μ m w el ls or te d th ro ug ho ut . 7% li m es to ne gr av el & ca lc it e, 30 0μ m –6 –2 m m ,s ub ro un de d, m od er at el y so rt ed ,r an do m ,o pe n po rp hy ri c. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,5 8% si lt ,1 2% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed (P P L ), re d (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% or ga ni c, bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b la ck ,c el ls tr uc tu re ~4 00 μm . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne – ir re gu la r su ba ng ul ar pi tt ed & cr ac ke d, 1m m ye ll ow ,y el lo w y gr ey bi re fr in ge nc e. C ol lu vi al ly -r ew or ke d po te nt ia l ex te rn al so il m at er ia l. H F 08 -1 00 0 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A35 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 00 :2 C on te xt P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) M ic ri ti c co at in g/ hy po co at in g to up pe r si de of du ng fr ag m en tn ea r th e to p of th e sl id e ~1 60 –1 00 μm th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, ~2 00 μm ,6 0μ m fr am bo id s sc at te re d in gr ou nd m as s. A ss oc ia te d w it h cr us ts im pr eg na ti on in a fe w pl ac es an d al so du ng ,b ut al so m or e po ro us ar ea s of th e gr ou nd m as s. 2) < 1% ir on no du le s, cl ea r bo un da ri es ,d ar k re d, 30 0μ m ro un d- w el lr ou nd ed ,w el ls or te d ra nd om .3 ) 1% w ea kl y de ve lo pe d ir on no du le s, 1– 2m m ,d efi ne d by qu ar tz co nc en tr at io ns 25 % in no du le .F ab ri c: 1) 40 % C ru st fr ag m en ts .F ro m 20 0μ m –1 cm ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,a bo ut 50 % of bo tt om ha lf of sl id e, to p is ~2 0% an d m or e di ff us e, po or ly so rt ed .M ul ti pl e la ye rs of si lt y cl ay flu ct ua ti on s. 2) 5% D un g – pa le br ow n is ot ro pi c si lt .P hy to li th s, sp he ru li te s an d m ic ri te - ar ti cu la te d ph yt ol it hs ,w av y, sp on gy ,l ev id en ce of bi ot ur ba ti on .P oo rl y so rt ed ,l en ti cu la r an d sm al le r bl oc ky ,w el l- ro un de d 30 0– 60 0μ m . (s ee ab ov e) 10 00 :3 C on te xt 49 8 T hi ck ne ss : 20 –2 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy .P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s, st ar -s ha pe d, ir re gu la r ~5 0– 40 0μ m sm oo th to ro ug h w al ls (3 % po te nt ia ll y ve ge ta lv oi ds ). 5% lo ng pl an ar vo id s, 20 –1 00 μm w id e, cm sc al e lo ng ,i nt er co nn ec te d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,5 0– 10 0μ m ,b lo ck y, w el ls or te d, op en po rp hy ri c. 15 % li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,1 00 μm –2 cm ,b lo ck y- ir re gu la r, ro ug h, ro un de d- su ba ng ul ar th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F R at io : 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .c la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l, pl at y, 30 0μ m an gu la r, hz . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to 80 % of co ar se in cl us io ns .2 ) S il ty in fil li ng s et c. as M ic ro -f ab ri c 10 00 :2 in sa m e fr eq ue nc y, li gh te r in co lo ur ,c oa ti ng co ar se fr ag m en ts in so m e ar ea s ak a li gh tl y sw ir ly .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 15 % ir on no du le s po or ly so rt ed up to 1c m ,f ro m ~3 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,d if fu se to sh ar p bo un da ri es .2 ) 2% m an ga ne se co nc en tr at io ns 20 0μ m – v. sm al l, se m i- de nd ri ti c, ra re ly li nk ed to ir on no du le s. F ab ri c: 1) 5% C ru st s – m ul ti pl e fin in g se qu en ce s, si lt y cl ay ,0 .5 –2 m m ,s ub an gu la r, di st ur be d. N ea r ba se ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n an d co nc en tr at io n. 2) 7% D un g, pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt ,m an y w it h sp he ru li te s, ph yt ol it hs ,a nd un di ff er en ti at ed to -c ry st al li ti c b- fa br ic . Ir re gu la r, sh ar p bo un da ri es fr om ro un de r, bl oc ki er to m or e el on ga te d sh ap es .L ar ge r ar e el on ga te d. F ro m 40 0μ m cl us te rs to cm lo ng bi ts .P oo rl y so rt ed . R ap id ,w et co ll uv ia ll y- re w or ke d po te nt ia le xt er na l so il m at er ia l. 10 00 :4 C on te xt 49 8 T hi ck ne ss : 15 –0 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y. P or os it y: 10 % .8 % ch am be rs an d vu gh s, ir re gu la r, ro ug h- w al le d 10 0μ m –1 00 0μ m .2 % pl an ar vo id s, 10 μm –6 0μ m w id e, 30 0– cm lo ng . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,5 0μ m –1 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .2 0% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el ,6 0μ m –1 m m ,i rr eg ul ar su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .C la y lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -o ra ng e br ow n (P P L ), or an ge s an d re ds (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% bl oc ky ch ar co al ,2 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r, ce ll st ru ct ur e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l, pl at y, 2m m ,a ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty co at in gs to co ar se ag gr eg at es of du ng an d co ar se m at er ia l, 5% ,1 0μ m th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) Ir on no du le s 10 % of sl id e, ra ng e of bo un da ri es fr om sh ar p to di ff us e. R ap id ,e ro si ve w et co ll uv ia ll y- re w or ke d po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A36 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 00 :5 C on te xt 49 9 T hi ck ne ss : 28 -1 1m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g vu gh y/ m as si ve .M or e w el l- de ve lo pe d to th e to p. P or os it y: 10 % . 8% V ug hs ,r ou gh w al ls ,1 m m –1 00 μm ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s ta r- sh ap ed in pl ac es .C on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it .2 % pl an ar vo id s, ve rt ic al cr ac ki ng ,4 0– 10 0μ m th ic k, m ed iu m sm oo th w al ls ,w el l- ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,5 0– 10 0μ m ,t hr ou gh ou t. 15 % ca lc it e an d li m es to ne , 10 0μ m –5 m m ,w el ls or te d to lo w er en d, su ba ng ul ar ir re gu la r to bl oc ky .R an do m di st ri bu ti on .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay , 70 % si lt ,2 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: L ig ht br ow n (P P L ), re d- ye ll ow (X P L ), du ll or an ge -y el lo w (O IL ). b- fa br ic : St ip pl e- sp ec kl ed m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ~2 00 μm pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow ,l ow gr ey bi re fr in ge nc e, an gu la r. 1% sh el lp la ty ,a ng ul ar ~3 00 μm ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed ,P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty co at in gs to < 1% co ar se m at er ia l, du st y. B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) ~1 0– 20 μm th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s ~2 00 μm ,a ls o li ni ng co pr ol it e in te rf ac e 1% of sl id e th ro ug ho ut .2 ) 7% ir on no du le s, w el l ro un de d, 10 0μ m –3 m m .S ha rp bo un da ri es ,p oo rl y so rt ed th ro ug ho ut . F ab ri c: 1) 5% D un g – ve ry po or ly so rt ed fr ag m en ts .P al e br ow n ye ll ow si lt ,i so tr op ic w it h br ok en ph yt ol it hs ,s po ng y, ir re gu la r ed ge s – sp he ru li te s. C lu st er ed in pa le r ar ea s. L on g du ng le ns es ,m uc h m or e m ar ke d in m ac ro vi ew .1 m m w id e at w id es tp oi nt ,2 –3 cm lo ng .2 ) P ot en ti al co pr ol it e/ du ng ag gr eg at e – pe ll et w it h sp on gy st ru ct ur e, ra re bo ne ,s he ll ,c en tr e to o al so ha s st ra nd s of gr ey ,s po ng y, ph yt ol it hs .C en tr e po te nt ia ll y bi ot ur ba te d. P un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A37 1014:2 1014:3 1c m 1014:4 1014:4 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 14 :1 C on te xt 49 1 T hi ck ne ss : 2c m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e (p ed s 3– 4m m ) ov er ly in g vu gh y to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e (p ed s ~8 0μ m ). P or os it y: 25 % .1 5% V ug hs an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, po or ly so rt ed ,r ou gh to sm oo th w al le d, 10 0μ m –4 m m th ro ug ho ut (2 % ve ge ta lv oi ds ,2 00 μm ). 10 % pl an ar vo id s (s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ), ro ug h w al ls ,w el la cc om m od at ed – ho ri zo nt al an d ve rt ic al or ie nt at io ns .5 0μ m th ic k. O ne lo ng ch an ne la cr os s th e to p of th e sl id e, 1. 2c m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 10 0μ m ,w el ls or te d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,e ve nl y di st ri bu te d. 5% li m es to ne 80 μm –2 m m ,s ub -a ng ul ar to su b- ro un de d bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .N o or ie nt at io n. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F R at io : 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ) sp ec kl ed li m pi di ty ,w el ls or te d. b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1 % fib re ,1 00 μm ,b lo ck y, th in fr ag m en to f or ga ni c m at er ia l, br ow n- bl ac k, al so la rg er bl oc ky ,r ed to da rk br ow n ce ll st ru ct ur e x2 50 0μ m –8 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% sh el l, pl at y, 60 0μ m ;< 1% bo ne sh ar d – pl at y, ye ll ow ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, 1m m , an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 5% S il ty cl ay co nc en tr at io ns ar ou nd so m e. 20 0– 40 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar , th ro ug ho ut ,6 0μ m th ic k. 2) D is co nt in uo us or an ge cl ay co at in g to ar ea s ar ou nd la rg e bi ot ur ba te d ar ea ~5 0μ m th ic k. C ry st al li ti c: 1) 7% m ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic ca lc it ic im pr eg na ti on of gr ou nd m as s, 1c m ar ea ,i rr eg ul ar ,a ss oc ia te d w it h gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e an d la rg e ch an ne l. 2) 1% co nc en tr ic ca lc it e no du le s in po re ,2 00 –3 00 μm .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll it ic : 1) 3% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s ba se d ar ou nd in cl us io ns or vo id s ~5 00 μm ac ro ss ,i so la te d fr am bo id s an d in gr ou nd m as s an d ed ge s of cr us ts .2 ) 1% ty pi c ir on no du le s, 20 0μ m –6 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,r an do m di st ri bu ti on .F ab ri c: 1) 2% D un g – pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n sp on gy si lt ,i nc lu di ng ph yt ol it hs ,v er y he av il y tu rb at ed in pl ac es ,p oo rl y so rt ed fr ag m en ts .2 ) 10 % cr us ts fr ag m en ts ,1 –3 m m ,d is or ie nt at ed ,s ub -a ng ul ar to su b- ro un de d, po or ly so rt ed .3 ) 1% se di m en ta gg re ga te s w it h m or e cr ys ta ll it ic b- fa br ic ,1 –2 m m ,w el lr ou nd ed . M ud dy flo w of ex te rn al so il m at er ia l se al in g in or ga ni c m at er ia ll at er su bj ec t to bi ot ur ba ti on . 10 14 :2 C on te xt 49 3 T hi ck ne ss : 55 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ,o ve rl yi ng w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 25 % . 15 % ,v ug hs ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th up to 10 0– 60 0μ m ro ug h w al ls .1 0% el on ga te d, pa ck in g vo id s 5– 10 % ar ou nd lo os er /fi ne r gr an ul at e ar ea s. 2% ch an ne ls ,l on g m m w id e, cm th ic k. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,4 0– 10 0μ m su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar ev en ly di st ri bu te d th ro ug ho ut ,5 % li m es to ne co ar se sa nd to gr av el ,r an do m 40 0μ m –2 cm , su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,s li gh th or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to la rg er fr ac ti on .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd ,a nd gr av el .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e br ow n (P P L ), or an ge go ld (X P L ), O ra ng e- re d (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne – el on ga te ,i rr eg ul ar pl at y, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, gr ey (X P L ), bi re fr in ge nt .1 % sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r, 40 0μ m ,o dd br ac ke ti ng so m e si lt . C ol lu vi al ly - re w or ke d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n m at er ia l. H F 08 -1 01 4 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A38 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 14 :2 C on te xt 49 3 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 3% m or e si lt y, m as si ve ar ea s – co nt in uu m of in fil li ng s, co at in gs or in ci pi en tc ru st s, up to 5% in lo w er ha lf of un it . 2) F ra gm en te d si lt y cl ay in fil li ng ~1 m m in ce nt re of un it ,m ul ti pl e ph as es .3 )A re a of in cr ea se in ve ge ta lv oi ds an d co at in gs ,c on ce nt ra te d in ar ea to le ft of sl id e, ab ou t2 cm fr om ba se .C ry st al li ti c: 1) 2% C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to ch an ne ls at to p of un it .M ai nl y in up pe r ½ of un it ,a bo ut 20 0μ m ,t hi ck ,c em en ti ng ar ea s ar ou nd th em .L ow er ha s ro ck w it h it .O ne ar ea of m ic ri ti c/ sp ar it ic im pr eg na ti on up to 3– 4c m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 3% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c st ai ni ng (n ot re al ly no du le s) in m or e vu gh y ar ea s up to ~6 00 μm .2 ) 3% ty pi c ir on no du le s, da rk br ow n to re d, w el lr ou nd ed to di ff us e 20 0μ m –8 00 μm ,r an do m ,t hr ou gh ou t. S m al le r m or e di ff us e, la rg er sh ar pe r & en cl os ed by de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se st ai ni ng .F ab ri c: 1) 2% de gr ad ed du ng – pa le ye ll ow –b ro w n si lt y sp on gy ar ea s, di ff us e bo un da ri es ,~ 60 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar w ar pe d, is ot ro pi c, w it h ph yt ol it hs .2 ) 3% S il tc la y cr us tf ra gm en ts ,t hr ou gh ou t, 50 0– 30 0μ m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,s in gl e fin in g se qu en ce s. 3) 1% w el l- ro un de d ag gr eg at es of sl ig ht ly pa le r or an ge se di m en tc on ta in in g ra re qu ar tz sa nd an d li m es to ne fr ag m en ts . (s ee ab ov e) 10 14 :3 C on te xt T hi ck ne ss : 3c m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M od er at el y de ve lo pe d vu gh y m ic ro st ru ct ur e. V er y ra re po ck et s of w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al le d vu gh s, v. po or ly so rt ed fr om 60 –7 50 μm . 3% pl an ar vo id s w id th of sl id e, sm oo th w al ls ho ri zo nt al ,~ 20 0μ m w id e. 2% ch an ne ls ,s m oo th w al ls ,s om e in te rc on ne ct ed or on a ho ri zo nt al al ig nm en t~ 1m m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed w el ls or te d 50 μm –1 50 μm ,t hr ou gh ou t, ra nd om or ie nt at io n. 10 % li m es to ne – 15 0μ m –3 m m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ra nd om di st ri bu te d, po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: ye ll ow br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow an d go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys - ta ll it ic (5 0: 50 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l, pl at y, 50 0μ m ,g re y (P P L ) an gu la r ra nd om di st ri bu ti on ,w el ls or te d. < 1% bo ne ,i rr eg ul ar ,a ng ul ar pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d w it h m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), 30 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M ic ro pa ns re st ri ct ed to pl an ar vo id s at th e to p of th e un it – or an ge cl ay - 60 μm th ic k. S om e al so co at in g th e to p of th e pl an ar vo id s an d in fil li ng co m pl et el y th e vo id s im m ed ia te ly be lo w .M an ga ne se st ai ni ng at th e ed ge .C ry st al li ne :1 ) 1% ve ry fin e m ic ri ti c ca l- ci ti c co at in gs an d hy po co at in gs to pl an ar vo id s ne ar th e ba se of un it in 1 or 2 lo ng vo id s. A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 2% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng de nd ri ti c no du le s 1% ,5 00 μm ,d if fu se 2) 1% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to bo th co at in gs ou tl in ed ab ov e. 3) Ir on no du le s 5m m to 15 0μ m ,w el l ro un de d, ro un de d, sh ar p bo un da ri es .F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng – pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt y sp on gy m at er ia lw it h ph yt ol it hs an d sp he ru li te s ~1 –2 m m ir - re gu la r, w ar pe d, di ff us e- ir re gu la r bo un da ri es .E xc re m en ta l: 1) A re as of co nc en tr at ed m ic ro ag gr eg at es ~1 –2 cm ac ro ss ,a gg re ga te s 40 –8 0μ m 2% of sl id e. O ne ch an ne lfi ll ed w it h ca lc it ic ex cr em en ts of sa m e si ze . R ew or ki ng of ae ol ia n m at er ia lb y co ll uv ia l pr oc es se s, la te r w et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er an d tr un ca te d. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A39 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 14 :4 T hi ck ne ss : 15 by 20 m m ,r ou gh ly ci rc ul ar ar ea .B ou nd ar ie s: D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: G ra nu la r m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e sp he ri ca lp ed s, ro ug h, 80 –1 00 μm .1 0% m as si ve /v ug hy ch un ks of th e sa m e m at er ia l. P or os it y: 65 % .5 0% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s. 10 % sm oo th ch an ne ls in vu gh y ar ea 60 0– 10 00 μm .5 % vu gh s in vu gh y ar ea ,1 00 –3 00 μm , ir re gu la r, sm oo th w al ls ,p ot en ti al ly ve ge ta lv oi ds . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz fin e sa nd an d co ar se si lt 50 μm –2 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y, th ro ug ho ut .1 0% li m es to ne m ed iu m to co ar se sa nd 15 0μ m –1 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls ,s ub ro un de d bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e re d (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge -r ed (O IL ). S il ty cl ay lo am .b -f ab ri c: S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta l- li ti c (4 0: 60 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne 80 μm ,s ub ro un de d bl oc ky ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), gr ey -r ed (O IL ). P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to ch an ne ls ,1 0% of sl id e an d im pr eg na ti ng gr ou nd m as s up to 50 % be yo nd th es e ch an - ne ls .C om pl et el y co nc re ti ng gr an ul es to ge th er .A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s in vu gh y ar ea s ~5 00 μm .F ab ri c: 1) 10 % pe do re li ct s/ ty pi c ir on no du le s, w el lr ou nd ed ,4 00 –1 m m ,s li gh tl y cl ay ey er fin e m at er ia l, on e w it h vu gh s an d si li ci fie d pl an tm at er ia lf ra gm en t, po ss ib ly ro ot .2 ) 3% cr us tf ra gm en ts ,b lo ck y su ba ng ul ar ,s om e w it h m ul ti pl e la ye rs of fin in g, 15 00 μm – 30 0μ m . B io tu rb at io n fo ll ow ed by im pr eg na ti on w it h ca lc it e. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A40 2000:1 2000:2 2000:3 1c m M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 00 :1 C on te xt 52 0 T hi ck ne ss : 15 –3 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p an d un du la ti ng . St ru ct ur e: M od er at e to w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky (3 00 0– 40 00 μm ) ov er ly in g vu gh y to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e (r ou nd ed to ir re gu la r pe ds 80 μm ). M or e vu gh y /m as si ve to w ar ds to p of un it .P or os it y: 20 –1 5% .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 60 –7 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d, 2% ch an ne ls ro un d, sm oo th -w al le d 10 00 μm ,3 –8 % pl an ar vo id s co nc en tr at ed to w ar ds to p of th e sl id e, ro ug h to sm oo th w al ls 40 0μ m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 –2 0% qu ar tz co ar se si lt to ve ry fin e sa nd ,4 0– 80 μm ,w el l so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,l es s to w ar ds to p of un it 10 –1 5% an d m or e po or ly so rt ed ;5 % li m es to ne w el ls or te d su ba ng ul ar to an gu la r gr av el to fin e sa nd 10 0– 10 00 μm .C F li m it : 40 μm . C F ra ti o: 20 –2 5: 80 –7 5. Te xt ur e: 25 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: D ar k or an ge br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow –r ed (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ), b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 7% bl oc ky to ir re gu la r su ba ng ul ar fr ag m en ts of ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia l am or ph ou s ce ll st ru ct ur e 20 –6 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne 30 0– 70 0μ m ,a ng ul ar pl at y, br ig ht or an ge -r ed to re d, bi re fr in ge nt . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 1% fin e le ns in g of fin e gr ou nd m as s, w av y, 10 0μ m th ic k, 70 0μ m lo ng ,d if fu se bo un da ri es .C ry st al li ti c: 1) 1% co m pl et e m ic ri ti c in fil li ng to ro un d vo id 12 00 μm co m pl et el y ce m en ti ng ex cr em en ts w it hi n. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) M an ga ne se st ai ni ng 10 % ,i rr eg ul ar pa tc he s fo rm in g hy po co at in gs to or ga ni c m at te r fr ag m en ts ar ou nd 10 μm th ic k. 2) Ir on no du le s 10 % 10 00 μm –5 00 μm ro un de d to di ff us e, re d- bl ac k to re d. F ab ri c: 1) A re a of cr us ti ng to w ar ds to p of un it 20 00 –3 00 0μ m de ep ,m ul ti pl e la ye rs of co ar se -fi ne m at er ia l, w ar pe d. 2) 5% P al e or an ge -y el lo w (P P L ) bl oc ky du ng fr ag m en ts 30 0– 50 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d to di ff us e, fr eq ue nt sp he ru li te s. 3) C on ce nt ra ti on of li m es to ne to le ft ha nd si de of sl id e – up to 25 % gr av el an d co ar se sa nd in ar ea 15 m m w id e, di ff us e to su bt le ed ge s. B as e of he av il y er os iv e in w as h ev en t. 20 00 :2 C on te xt 52 1 T hi ck ne ss : 8c m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar lo w er bo un da ry . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e (r ou nd to ir re gu la r pe ds ,8 0– 10 0μ m ). P or os it y: 20 % .5 % ch an ne ls ,r ou nd ,s m oo th w al le d, 17 50 μm ;1 0% ir re gu la r vu gh s, po or ly so rt ed 25 0– 25 00 μm m od er at el y sm oo th to ro ug h w al ls ;5 % pl an ar vo id s/ el on ga te d vu gh s, in te rc on ne ct in g, w ar pe d, m od er at el y sm oo th w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd su ba ng ul ar to an gu la r bl oc ky 50 –1 20 μm th ro ug ho ut .2 0% li m es to ne ve ry fin e sa nd to gr av el 60 μm –1 cm ,p oo rl y so rt ed , th ro ug ho ut .O rg an is ed so m ew ha ti nt o ho ri zo nt al le ns es ~5 00 μm th ic k, 3m m w id e. In cr ea se s in de gr ee of so rt in g to w ar ds to p of th e un it w he re it al so co ns ti tu te s up to 25 % of th e fa br ic .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F R at io : 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e– br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow to re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge -r ed (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cy st al li ti c (6 0: 40 ), sl ig ht do m in an ce of cr ys ta ll it ic gr ou nd m as s to to p of un it an d st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to ba se .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O cc up at io n in ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,w it h so m e po st de po si ti on al w et ti ng of se di m en ts th ro ug h ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er of un kn ow n ti m in g. H F 08 /0 9- 20 00 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A41 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 00 :2 C on te xt 52 1 (c on t.) O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2– 3% bl oc ky ,a ng ul ar ch ar co al fr ag m en ts sh ow in g ce ll st ru ct ur e 10 0– 60 00 μm ,p oo rl y so rt ed . A rt ef ac ts : 2– 3% bo ne fr ag m en ts (b ur nt an d un bu rn t) ,p la ty to ir re gu la r su ba ng ul ar -a ng ul ar 40 0– 50 00 μm ,o ra ng e- ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey ,y el lo w an d re ds (X P L ), su rf ac e pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, th ro ug ho ut un it ;< 1% sh el l, an gu la r pl at y 50 0– 11 00 0μ m .P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) D ec re as e in bo ne ,s he ll an d or ga ni cs to w ar ds to p of un it .2 ) D if fu se ho ri zo nt al le ns in g to fin e m at er ia l. C ry st al li ne : 1) In cr ea se in cr ys ta ll it ic fa br ic to w ar ds to p 3c m of un it .2 ) 1% cr ys ta ll it ic in fil li ng to vo id ,p el le ts 3m m oc cu py in g 60 % of po re sp ac e. 3) < 1% la rg e ra di al sp he ru le s 20 0μ m . A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1% m an ga ne se co at in g to so m e of th e la rg e ch an ne ls ~1 0μ m .2 ) 1% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 25 0μ m , sl ig ht ly co nc en tr at ed to w ar ds to p of un it .3 ) 5% ir on no du le s, co nc en tr at ed in lo w er ha lf ,b ro w n to re d (P P L ) an d sh ar p to di ff us e bo un da ri es (3 0: 80 ). F ab ri c: 1) 3% pa le ye ll ow du ng ,s po ng y st ru ct ur e w it h ar ea s of gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e an d ph yt ol it hs .D if fu se to sh ar p bo un da ri es 60 0– 40 00 μm ,p oo rl y so rt ed bl oc ks an d le ns es (5 0: 50 ). 2) 2% w el l- ro un de d, la ye re d cr us tf ra gm en ts ,5 00 0μ m ,m ul ti pl e or ie nt at io ns .3 ) L ar ge as h le ns es 1- 2m m th ic k, ac ro ss ne ar ly th e en ti re sl id e, co nt ai ni ng rh om bo he dr al ca lc it ic ps eu do m or ph s of w oo d ce ll s. (s ee ab ov e) 20 00 :3 C on te xt 52 3 T hi ck ne ss : 25 –4 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m as si ve .P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, sm oo th to ro ug h w al le d w it h ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to so m e el on ga te d on es 25 0– 25 00 0μ m ,w el ls or te d; 5% ch an ne ls 25 0μ m –1 .5 cm lo ng ,s m oo th w al le d, m an ga ne se co at in gs ;5 % pl an ar vo id s, 56 00 μm ,w el l ac co m m od at ed w al ls ,i nt er co nn ec tv ug hs . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 50 –1 00 μm ,w el l- so rt ed bl oc ky su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,o pe n po rp hy ri c di st ri bu ti on ,r an do m ;1 0% li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd 10 0μ m –1 m m ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,p oo rl y so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re ds an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), or an ge -r ed (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar re d/ pa rt ia ll y hu m ifi ed st em st ru ct ur e, an gu la r, 1m m lo ng at ba se of un it . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ,a ng ul ar ir re gu la r 40 0– 60 0μ m ,y el lo w to re d- br ow n (P P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d su rf ac e, un bu rn ta nd bu rn t; < 1% sh el l, 20 0– 40 0μ m ,p la ty ,g re y. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) D us ty si lt co at in gs to co ar se m at er ia le .g .d un g fr ag m en ts ,< 10 μm ,5 % of sl id e. C ry st al li ne : < 1% ca lc it ic in fil li ng of vu gh ,fi ll in g 50 % of sp ac e, fin e sp ar it ic ca lc it e w it h ro un d ag gr eg at es .2 ) < 1% sp he ru le ,1 00 μm ,r ou gh ed ge s. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% di ff us e ir on no du le s 25 0– 60 0μ m ,2 ) < 1% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, 10 0μ m .3 ) M an ga ne se hy po co at in g to 50 % of ch an ne ls .4 ) 5% pe do re li ct s 25 0– 20 00 μm ,w el l- ro un de d, re d an d sh ar p- ed ge d. D is tr ib ut io n ra nd om w it h so m e cl us te ri ng .F ab ri c: 1) 2– 5% du ng ,p al e or an ge si lt w it h vu gh y/ sp on gy m ic ro st ru ct ur e. F ra gm en ts 75 0– 25 0μ m w it h sh ar p bo un da ri es ,r ou nd ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,w it h ph yt ol it hs in al lc as es an d sp he ru li te s vi si bl e in 10 % of fr ag m en ts . O cc up at io n in en vi ro nm en to f po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,s om e po st - de po si ti on al w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch gr ou nd w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A42 2010:1 2010:2 1c m M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on s 20 10 :1 C on te xt 49 9 T hi ck ne ss : 50 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y. M or e m as si ve to w ar ds th e to p of th e sl id e. B io tu rb at io n to ed ge s of sl id e. P or os it y: 15 % .2 % ch an ne ls ,r ou nd ed ,e lo ng at ed sm oo th w al ls ,3 00 μm –1 cm ,p oo rl y so rt ed in si ze .1 0% vu gh s fr om 60 μm –3 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed .I rr eg ul ar ro ug h w al ls .2 % pl an ar vo id s ~2 00 μm w id e, 80 0μ m –1 cm lo ng , in te rc on ne ct in g so m e vo id s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd 50 –1 20 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y, w el l– so rt ed .1 5% li m es to ne an d ca lc it e, 50 μm –5 m m po or ly so rt ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,b lo ck y an d ev en ly di st ri bu te d th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), or an ge -y el lo w (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) 50 0– 20 0μ m .L ar ge bo ne fr ag m en t~ 1c m ir re gu la r, pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. A lm os tc om pl et el y in fil le d w it h sp ar it ic ca lc it e ~1 0μ m lo ng co m pl et el y w it hi n bo ne st ru ct ur e. < 1% pl at y sh el l4 00 μm an gu la r, gr ey – gr ey pa st el bi re fr in ge nc e < 1% fli nt ,w el lr ou nd ed ,6 00 μm bl oc ky . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M or e m as si ve to w ar ds to p of un it .C ry st al li ne : 1) S li gh tl y m or e ca lc it ic in bu rr ow s as so ci at ed w it hi n gr an ul ar bi ot ur ba ti on es pe ci al ly at th e to p, bu ts ub tl e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) < 1% m an ga ne se co at in g to vo id s – ch an ne ls ,d en dr it ic hy po co at in g, 80 μm .2 ) < 1% sm al l, w ea kl y de ve lo pe d de nd ri ti c no du le s ~6 00 μm di ff us e cl us te rs .3 ) Ir on no du le s – 2% of sl id e, no tn ea r cr us ts ,2 00 –6 00 μm ,m od -w el l so rt ed ,w el lr ou nd ed an d sh ar p. F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng pa tc he s ~5 00 μm m an y sp he ru li te s, ir re gu la r, pa le br ow n si lt ph yt ol it hs .B lo ck y, de gr ad ed an d m ix ed .A ls o el on ga te d le ns es gr ey is ot ro pi c, no ph yt ol it hs ,1 m m lo ng ,8 0μ m th ic k. 2) Y el lo w fr ag m en t– co lo ur of du ng bu tv er y m as si ve si lt y cl ay w it h 20 % qu ar tz ,i n m id dl e of bi ot ur ba te d ar ea .3 ) C ru st fr ag m en ts – si lt y bu t1 0% of lo w es tp ar to f un it s 0. 5c m ,6 00 –2 00 μm su br ou nd ed to w el lr ou nd ed , bl oc ky ,a ll or ie nt at io ns .S om e w it h tw o la ye rs . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 20 10 :2 C on te xt 50 3 T hi ck ne ss : 15 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N o lo w er bo un da ry . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v ug hy to v w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e (8 0: 20 ) – in ci pi en tp ed s 60 μm at sm al le st .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% v. sm al lv ug hs an d co m pl ex pa ck in g vo id s, ~1 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al le d. 5% ch an ne ls an d la rg e se m i- co ll ap se d ir re gu la r ch an ne ls up to 0. 5c m lo ng 60 0μ m sm oo th -r ou gh ir re gu la r w al ls ,i nt er co nn ec te d, al ig nm en t. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd ,5 0– 10 0μ m th ro ug ho ut ,r an do m .1 5% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el ,i rr eg ul ar -d if fu se ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,1 50 μm –1 cm .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e ye ll ow -b ro w n (P P L ), ye ll ow go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, un di ff er en ti at ed an d m ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 20 :3 0) .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ve ry fin e fr ag m en ts ,b la ck ,< 50 μm bl oc ky ,v er y ra re . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne 2m m ,p la ty ,a ng ul ar ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, pa le ye ll ow gr ey bi re fr in ge nc e. 1% sh el l5 00 μm pl at y, w el ls or te d an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) O ra ng e si lt y co at in gs to vo id s in bi ot ur ba te d ar ea s ar ou nd th e ed ge s of th e sl id e. C ry st al li ne :1 ) M ic ri ti c ca lc it e im pr eg na ti ng gr ou nd m as s ar ou nd ar ea of bi ot ur ba ti on up to 1c m th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, as so ci at ed w it h di st ur ba nc e, c. ~1 m m .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s po or ly so rt ed th ro ug ho ut 20 0μ m –3 m m ro un d: bl oc ky w el lr ou nd ed ,s ha rp bo un da ri es ,c ra ck s in si de la rg er on es .F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng – pa le ye ll ow si lt ,i so tr op ic ,p hy to li th s ~5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,b lo ck y, m ix ed in .V er y w el l- m ix ed w it h m at ri x an d co m pl et el y di sa gg re ga te d. O th er le ns es ~6 00 μm lo ng ,d if fu se . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,w it h so m e w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . H F 08 /0 9- 20 10 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A43 2021:1 2021:2 2021:4 1c m 2021:3 20 21 :5 2021:6 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 21 :1 C on te xt 56 3 T hi ck ne ss : 10 –2 8m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e (r ou nd pe ds 50 –1 00 μm ). P or os it y: 20 % .1 8% vu gh s/ co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s 60 –2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls .2 % pl an ar vo id s, 75 0– 10 00 μm th in . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky 50 – 10 0μ m ,w el ls or te d, th ro ug ho ut .1 5% li m es to ne co ar se si lt to gr av el ,s ub an gu la r ir re gu la r, to ro un de d, po or ly so rt ed ,1 00 μm –8 00 μm .C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -o ra ng e br ow n (P P L ) ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l, pl at y pa st el 25 0μ m an gu la r. 2% bo ne ,p la ty ir re gu la r, 50 0– 75 0μ m , w el l- so rt ed pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey -y el lo w (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, 25 0μ m .2 % ar e li nk ed to ir on no du le s (p ot en ti al pe do re li ct s? ) at th ei r ce nt re an d ar e la rg er , up to 50 0μ m .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s 50 0– 10 00 μm ne ar to p of sl id e, cl ay -r ic h, w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p ed ge s. F ab ri c: 1) P ot en ti al bu rn tf ra gm en t, 50 00 μm si lt y re d ag gr eg at e w it h pl an tp se ud om or ph s vo id s. E xc re m en ta l: 1) L on g bi ot ur ba te d ar ea ,1 -2 cm ac ro ss w it h cy li nd ri ca le xc re m en ts 50 0μ m . C ol lu vi al re w or ki ng of ae ol ia n m at er ia l. 20 21 :2 C on te xt 56 3 T hi ck ne ss : 35 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,s ha rp . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .P or os it y: 10 % .7 % pl an ar vo id s, ra nd om or ie nt at io n, w el la cc om m od at ed w it h ro ug h w al ls .3 % ch am be rs 10 0– 30 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to ve ry fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed 50 –8 0μ m th ro ug ho ut ,w el ls or te d, ra nd om .1 5% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to co ar se sa nd po or ly so rt ed 10 0– 70 0μ m ,i n to p 1. 5c m of un it ,5 0% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el , su ba ng ul ar po or ly so rt ed 10 0μ m –2 cm in lo w er 2c m of un it .G en er al ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to fin e sa nd m at er ia l. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: To p – 25 :7 5, bo tt om – 60 :4 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd (s an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m ); 5% cl ay ,4 0% si lt 55 % sa nd (s an dy lo am ). F in e m at er ia l: P al e or an ge -y el lo w br ow n (P P L ) ye ll ow to pa le go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (2 0% ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: L en s ac ro ss en ti re sl id e w hi ch is ch ar ac te ri se d by a sl ig ht da rk en in g of th e gr ou nd m as s an d in pl ac es 40 –8 0μ m bl oc ky ch ar co al fr ag m en ts .L en s is 15 0– 25 0μ m th ic k an d sl ig ht ly un du la ti ng .2 % ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t, bl oc ky an gu la r- w el l- ro un de d w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e 40 0– 80 0μ m . P un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h li m it ed ph ys ic al w ea th er in g. V ar ia bl e am ou nt of ph ys ic al w ea th er in g or ra te of de po si ti on . H F 08 /0 9- 20 21 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A44 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 21 :2 C on te xt 56 3 (c on t.) A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el li n co ar se r la ye r, 40 0μ m ,p la ty ,s ub an gu la r ho ri zo nt al 3% bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e, < 30 0μ m ,p la ty ,y el lo w (P P L ) gr ey (X P L ) su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky fr ag m en ts .2 % fli nt ,a ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed 50 0– 10 00 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M ac ro -s ca le va ri an ce w it hi n th e li m es to ne co nt en to f th e un it fin in g an d co ar se ni ng va ri an ce .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll it ic :1 ) 3% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 25 0– 60 0μ m ,3 0% ce nt re d on co ar se m at er ia lo r pe do re li ct .2 ) 2% ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s up to 10 0– 15 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d, cl ay ey .F ab ri c: 1) 5- 10 % du ng ,l on g le ns es 2c m lo ng ,5 00 μm th ic k, ph yt ol it hs in bi re fr in ge nt m at ri x, fib ro us cl ay ey ca lc it e. A ls o sm al le r fr ag m en ts w it h sp he ru li te s, 2% of sl id e, pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt 50 0μ m lo ng ,v er y th in .5 0: 50 be tw ee n. 2) < 1% fr ag m en to f ve si cu la r si li ca ,g re y (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), 12 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,s ub an gu la r. 20 21 :3 C on te xt 56 3 T hi ck ne ss : 30 –3 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % 10 % ch am be rs an d vu gh s, 10 0– 60 0μ m .5 % pl an ar vo id s 20 μm th ic k, in te rc on ne ct in g so m e vu gh s, m m sc al e to 60 0μ m ,w el la cc om m od at ed ,m ed iu m ro ug h. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .2 0% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el 10 0μ m –2 cm , su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,p oo rl y so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: L ig ht br ow n- or an ge (P P L ), or an ge s an d go ld s (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 3% ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,b lo ck y, 15 0- 75 0μ m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,a ss oc ia te d w it h m an ga ne se st ai ni ng in pl ac es . A rt ef ac ts : A si de fr om la rg e bo ne ,3 % bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e 10 0- 20 00 μm ,a ng ul ar to w el l- ro un de d, ir re gu la r bl oc ky ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d. Y el lo w to re d- or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow -r ed (X P L ). 1% fli nt ,1 00 0μ m –2 00 0μ m su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,y el lo w is h, cl ay ey et c co at in g. 2% sh el l3 00 –6 00 μm ,p la ty , an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) F in er to p 0. 5c m of th e un it ,c on ta in in g li tt le li m es to ne an d st ro ng la m in at io ns of th e fin e m at er ia l. 2) S il ty cr us t un de rn ea th la rg e bo ne ,5 00 μm th ic k, 2c m lo ng .C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c hy po co at in g to la rg e bo ne up to 40 0μ m th ic k de po si ti on ,a ro un d an d w it hi n po re s. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 3% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 40 0– 15 00 μm .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s 80 –2 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed ,r ou nd , sh ar p bo un da ri es .F ab ri c: 1) 2% ve si cu la r si li ca fr ag m en ts up to 30 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ir re gu la r. G re y (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ). 2) 3% du ng le ns es 50 0– 10 00 μm ,p al e ye ll ow br ow n si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs an d sp he ru li te s. C ol lu vi al m ov em en to f ae ol ia n m at er ia l, fo ll ow ed by sh if tt o pu nc tu at ed ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . 20 21 :4 C on te xt 56 8 T hi ck ne ss : 10 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 3% vu gh s 10 0– 50 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h- sm oo th w al ls .2 % pl an ar vo id s ac ro ss un it ,5 0μ m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,5 0– 15 0μ m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .1 5% li m es to ne 10 0μ m –2 m m ,i rr eg ul ar -b lo ck y su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: G re y- br ow n (P P L ), or an ge s an d ye ll ow s (X P L ). O ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 4% ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, bl oc ky ,2 00 –6 50 μm . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne 20 0– 55 0μ m ,p la ty to bl oc ky ,s ub ro un de d. Y el lo w -o ra ng e (P P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (X P L ). 1% sh el l, bl oc ky to pl at y an gu la r 60 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s 10 0– 60 0μ m ,s ha rp bo un da ri es .2 ) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 10 0μ m .F ab ri c: 1) B la ck le ns at to p of un it ,s am e fa br ic as 20 21 :5 ,2 –3 cm lo ng ,3 00 μm th ic k. 2) 5% du ng ,p al e ye ll ow si lt w it h sp on gy st ru ct ur e an d ph yt ol it hs .B ot h ho ri zo nt al le ns es an d bl oc ks ,w el l- ro un de d 80 0– 10 00 μm .3 ) 3% ve si cu la r si li ca w it h bo th ve si cu la r an d fib ro us st ru ct ur es re ta in in g fib ro us na tu re ,i so tr op ic (X P L ) gr ey (P P L ), 50 0– 15 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed .4 ) C al ci ti c as h m ix ed w it h gr ou nd m as s up to 40 % in pl ac es . M ix ed as h m at er ia l, re w or ke d in dr y co nd it io ns . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A45 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 21 :5 C on te xt 56 8 T hi ck ne ss : 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s 50 –2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h to sm oo th w al ls .5 % pl an ar vo id s 50 –2 00 0μ m lo ng ,i nt er co nn ec ti ng vu gh s in pl ac es . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz 60 –2 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .2 0% li m es to ne 15 0– 50 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed , po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 60 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd ,s an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), is ot ro pi c to re d (X P L ), da rk br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 20 % bl oc ky ,a ng ul ar ch ar co al ,5 % w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, 50 –8 00 μm in ad di ti on to da rk br ow n of sl id e w hi ch ap pe ar s to be th e re su lt of or ga ni c st ai ni ng /h yp er -f ra gm en ta ti on of ch ar co al . A rt ef ac ts : 2– 10 % bu rn tb on e 15 0– 15 00 μm ir re gu la r su ba ng ul ar or an ge (P P L ), or an ge (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. 2% sh el l5 00 μm ,b lo ck y, pl at y an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : In cr ea se in or ga ni c m at er ia lt ow ar ds to p of un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll it ic : 1) 2– 5% ir on no du le s or bu rn t ag gr eg at es ,2 00 –9 00 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed w it h qu ar tz . T ru nc at ed bu rn in g ev en t on un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. 20 21 :6 C on te xt 52 8 T hi ck ne ss : 15 –3 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y. P or os it y: 10 % .2 % pl an ar vo id s 20 –5 0μ m w id e, in te rc on ne ct ed ,5 00 μm sc al e. 8% vu gh s, 10 0– 10 00 μm ir re gu la r w it h ro ug h w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz si lt to fin e sa nd 50 –2 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed th ro ug ho ut .1 5% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el 10 0μ m –1 .5 cm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed w ea th er in g ri nd s. B lo ck y to pl at y. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd ,s an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ), or an ge -r ed (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 3% ch ar co al 10 0μ m –1 .5 m m ,b lo ck y an gu la r- ro un de d. A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne ,1 00 μm –1 40 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar bl oc ky su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d. Y el lo w to re d- br ow n (P P L ), gr ey to re d- br ow n( X P L ). 2% sh el l6 00 μm ,p la ty an gu la r pa st el ye ll ow (X P L ) G re y (P P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C on ce nt ra ti on of an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia li nc re as es to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) < 1% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s < 10 0μ m .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s 15 0– 75 0μ m w el l- ro un de d th ro ug ho ut ,s ha rp bo un da ri es .F ab ri c: 1) 5% pa le ye ll ow du ng le ns w it h ve ry fe w sp he ru li te s 1– 2m m ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt at ed 60 0μ m th ic k w it h di ff us e ed ge s an d ph yt ol it hs . R ap id ,p un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,s po ra di c w et ti ng .a nd re w or ki ng of ne ar by oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A46 2028:1 2028:2 1c m 2028:3 20 28 :4 2028:5 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 28 :1 C on te xt 52 1 T hi ck ne ss : 25 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e an d in te rl ea ve d. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y, ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky in pl ac es , ov er li es w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 25 % .1 5% vu gh s, ch am be rs an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s 10 0- 10 00 μm ,2 % of th es e ar e ve ge ta l vo id s be tw ee n 10 0- 30 0μ m .1 0% pl an ar vo id s, in te rc on ne ct in g th e vu gh s fr om 50 – 10 00 μm w id e, w it h 3% sm oo th er an d 50 0μ m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky 50 –2 00 μm . 15 % li m es to ne 10 0μ m –1 cm ,i rr eg ul ar to bl oc ky ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,p oo rl y so rt ed . H ea vi ly de gr ad ed in pl ac es ,d eg re es of di ag en es is .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m /s an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- ye ll ow br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic 75 :2 5. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e ~4 00 μm an gu la r bl oc ky . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,2 00 –5 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,y el lo w (P P L ) gr ey (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d su rf ac e. 1% sh el l1 00 –7 00 μm ,p la ty su br ou nd ed gr ey (P P L ), pa st el (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) 1 la rg e ra di al sp he ru le 50 μm .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 30 0– 70 0μ m .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s/ cr us tf ra gm en ts ,1 00 –2 00 μm .F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng le ns es 50 00 μm th ic k, pa le ye ll ow br ow n si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs an d sp he ru li te s. 30 0– 40 0μ m th ic k an d de gr ad ed ed ge s. P un ct ua te d, po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po st io n w it h ra re ,s po ra di c w et ti ng . 20 28 :2 C on te xt 52 1 T hi ck ne ss : 65 –8 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /m as si ve ov er ly in g w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 2% vu gh s an d ch am be rs ir re gu la r 25 0– 10 00 μm ,m ed iu m sm oo th w al ls .3 % pl an ar vo id s 50 –4 00 μm w id e la rg e cr ac ks ac ro ss un it . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky . 10 % li m es to ne su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky w it h sl ig ht ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n 10 0– 30 00 μm .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd . S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% bl oc ky ch ar co al 25 0– 80 0μ m ce ll st ru ct ur e, m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 1– 2% bo ne su ba ng ul ar ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow -o ra ng e br ow n (P P L ), gr ey -o ra ng e (X P L ). 2% sh el l2 00 –1 00 0μ m an gu la r, pl at y, gr ey (P P L ). P un ct ua te d ae ol ia n de po si ti on ,s po ra di ca ll y w et te d by sm al l- sc al e sh ee tw as h an d pu dd li ng to th e to p of th e un it . H F 08 /0 9- 20 28 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A47 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 28 :2 C on te xt 52 1 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) F 1 in te rl ea ve d w it h to p of un it .2 ) O cc up at io n de br is co nc en tr at ed in th e lo w er ha lf of th e fa br ic .3 ) L im es to ne m ed iu m -c oa rs e sa nd co nc en tr at ed to w ar d to p of th e un it .4 ) 1% si lt y m ic ro -c ru st s. 5) L in k ca pp in g al on g ba se of th e un it 20 μm th ic k, 2c m lo ng . C ry st al li ne : 1) 1 la rg e ra di al sp he ru le 10 0μ m .A m or ph ou s: 1) < 2% m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs to vo id s 10 0μ m th ic k. 2) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 30 0– 40 0μ m .3 ) 5% ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s 20 0– 50 0μ m w el l- ro un de d, th ro ug ho ut ,s ha rp .F ab ri c: 1) C ru st fr ag m en ts in to p th ir d of un it m ak e up 25 % of th e fa br ic ,i rr eg ul ar w el l- ro un de d to an gu la r. S om e br ok en in fil li ng s to o, di ffi cu lt to te ll ap ar t. 2) 5% du ng 50 0– 80 0μ m , sl ig ht ly ca lc it ic ,p al e br ow n sp on gy si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs ,m or e ro un de d to w ar ds th e to p. F ra gm en te d an d di ff us e to w ar ds th e ba se . (s ee ab ov e) 20 28 :3 C on te xt 52 3 T hi ck ne ss : 25 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /m as si ve ov er ly in g m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 25 % .2 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 80 - 10 00 μm ,r ou gh w al ls .5 % pl an ar vo id s, in te rc on ne ct in g vu gh s 50 0– 10 00 μm m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .1 0% li m es to ne gr av el 15 0– 20 00 μm ,a ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 5: 25 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re an gu la r bl oc ky 60 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 2– 3% bo ne 50 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar su ba ng ul ar ,y el lo w (P P L ), ye ll ow s an d gr ey s (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. 1% fli nt an gu la r (m ic ro de bi ta ge ) 10 00 μm ,t ri an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) O cc as io na ll en se s of co ar se co m po ne nt s, vi si bl e on m ac ro .C ry st al li ne :1 ) C on ce nt ra ti on of cr ys ta ll it ic gr ou nd m as s be tw ee n th e le ns es of ch ar re d m at er ia l, co lo ur in g th e gr ou nd m as s m or e gr ey in (P P L ). 2% .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c/ ir re gu la r no du le s fr om 1– 2 fr am bo id s 50 –5 00 μm .2 ) 3– 5% ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s w it h sh ar p bo un da ri es 15 0μ m –6 00 μm .F ab ri c: 1) 7% du ng fr ag m en ts 40 0– 15 00 μm w el lr ou nd ed bu td if fu se bo un da ri es ,p al e br ow n- ye ll ow si lt y sp on gy st ru ct ur e w it h ph yt ol it hs .N o sp he ru li te s. 2) 1% P ot en ti al as h in th in le ns es to w ar ds to p of un it ,5 0– 20 0μ m th ic k, 3– 2c m lo ng ,p ot en ti al ca lc it ic ps eu do m or ph s. 3) C ru st fr ag m en ts 1% 15 0– 30 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed to su br ou nd ed .4 ) L en s of F ab ri c 4, P la ty st ru ct ur e, 2. 5c m lo ng ,1 –2 m m de ep .E xc re m en ta l: 1) M it e ex cr em en tc ut ti ng li nk ca pp in g at ba se of un it . O cc up at io n in po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n en vi ro nm en t of de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng .R ew or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia li n dr y en vi ro nm en t. 20 28 :4 C on te xt 52 3 T hi ck ne ss : 3– 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: P la ty ov er ly in g gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% pl an ar vo id s 30 -5 0μ m w id e 11 m m lo ng ,i nt er co nn ec te d. 10 % vu gh s an d ch am be rs ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al le d, 10 0– 50 0μ m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 20 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .5 % li m es to ne 25 0– 70 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed th ro ug ho ut w it h bl oc ky w ea th er in g ri nd s. C F li m it :5 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay , 80 % si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: D ar k br ow n- re d (P P L ), is ot ro pi c to re ds an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), du ll or an ge to da rk br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : U nd if fe re nt ia te d to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% bl oc ky ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia l, 50 μm .E nt ir e fa br ic st ai ne d da rk br ow n. A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne 20 0– 15 00 μm ,o ra ng e- ye ll ow to or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e to or an ge (X P L ) (b ur nt ). 2% sh el l, cr os s se ct io n of sp ir al ,3 m m , ro un de d. P ed of ea tu re s: N on e. H ea vi ly w ea th er ed bu rn in g ev en t. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A48 M ic ro -f ab ri c M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 20 28 :5 C on te xt 52 4 T hi ck ne ss : 0– 12 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e. P or os it y: 10 % .8 % vu gh s 10 0- 30 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar .2 % pl an ar vo id s 30 –1 00 μm w id e ac ro ss th e w ho le fa br ic . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –8 0μ m ,a ng ul ar to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .5 % li m es to ne 10 0– 10 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky . C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re ds an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), or an ge (P P L ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to un di ff er en ti at ed (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% fli nt su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed 95 0μ m bl oc ky .1 % sh el l, pl at y, el on ga te d an gu la r 80 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% si lt y co at in gs to co ar se co m po ne nt s vi si bl e in sl ig ht ly th ic ke r pa rt s of th e sl id e. C ry st al li ne : 1) 1– 2% la rg e ra di al sp he ru le s 10 0μ m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d in fil li ng s to op en gr ou nd m as s 20 0– 70 0μ m .2 ) 1% ir on no du le s 30 0– 60 0μ m ro un de d, bl oc ky to sh ar p. F ab ri c: 1) < 1% ca lc it ic as h fr ag m en ts 40 0μ m w el lr ou nd ed ,m ic ri ti c as h. 2) 5– 10 % pa le br ow n si lt du ng fr ag m en ts w it h sp on gy to m as si ve ,s li gh tl y re ti cu la te gr ou nd m as s an d si lt y co at in gs .R ou nd ed bl oc ks to ho ri zo nt al le ns es w it h ph yt ol it hs . 3) 2– 5% cr us tf ra gm en ts 20 0– 12 00 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,n o or ie nt at io n, di ff us e to sh ar p an d cr ac ke d. 4) le ns of 20 28 :4 ab ov e in te rl ea ve d ne ar th e to p of th e un it . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia l ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,w it h sp or ad ic da m pi ng of th e su rf ac e. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A49 2033:1 2033:2 1c m 2033:3 20 33 :4 2033:6 20 33 :5 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 33 :1 C on te xt 56 2 T hi ck ne ss : 10 –2 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p an d in te rl ea ve d. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,( pe ds 10 0– 15 0μ m ). P or os it y: 10 % .7 % vu gh s, ir re gu la r, ro ug h- w al le d, 15 0μ m –1 m m .3 % pl an ar vo id s, ir re gu la r, < 10 μm –8 0μ m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd 40 –1 50 μm , su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .3 0% li m es to ne gr av el 10 0μ m –1 cm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed , so m e ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay , 55 % si lt ,3 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ), b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar re d or ga ni c ce ll st ru ct ur e 30 0– 10 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar , su br ou nd ed ,m an ga ne se im pr eg na ti on . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bu rn ta nd un bu rn tb on e, 25 0– 40 0μ m ,b lo ck y, su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar ,y el lo w -o ra ng e re d (P P L ) re d- go ld (X P L ). P it te d an d cr ac ke d su rf ac es . < 1% fli nt 12 00 μm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .3 % sh el lp la ty ,s ub an gu la r, 30 0– 50 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S li gh tl y m or e cl ay ey /F e to w ar ds th e bo tt om ri gh th an d si de of un it ,l ow er 0. 5c m .C ry st al li ti c: 1) 1% m ic ri ti c in fil li ng to fo rm er ch an ne ls ne ar to p of un it .C om pl et el y in fil le d ar ou nd gr an ul es of se di m en t. 2) C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to 3% co ar se sa nd li m es to ne bl oc ks 20 0μ m th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s < 25 0μ m th ro ug ho ut an d w it h co ar se m at er ia l. Tw o ov er 1m m w id e fo rm in g hy po co at in gs in to p pa rt of un it ne ar po re sp ac e 2) 2– 3% ir on no du le s, si lt y, 10 0– 15 0μ m ,l it tl e qu ar tz .R ou nd ed ,b lo ck y fr ag m en ts up to 50 0μ m . P un ct ua te d in w as h of cl ay - ri ch m at er ia lr ew or ki ng li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el . 20 33 :2 C on te xt 53 7 T hi ck ne ss : 20 –2 5c m th ic k. L ow er B ou nd ar y: P ro m in en t, sh ar p lo w er bo un da ry . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar /b lo ck y m ic ro st ru ct ur e (p ed s 25 0μ m ,r ou nd ed ). P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s an d co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, st ar - sh ap ed 10 0– 80 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 5% pl an ar ,w el la cc om m od at ed ro ug h w al ls 40 μm th ic k. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 40 –1 00 μm ,w el ls or te d, su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .3 5% li m es to ne fin e sa nd to gr av el su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky 10 0μ m –1 cm , ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to 60 % of bl oc ks .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 45 :5 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,5 0% si lt ,4 0% sa nd an d gr av el . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), or an ge s an d go ld s (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic 70 :3 0. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ch ar co al an d se m i- hu m ifi ed ce ll st ru ct ur e ~1 m m ,o ne pi ec e he av il y im pr eg na te d w it h ca lc it e, ot he rs w it h am or ph ou s m an ga ne se im pr eg na ti on . P un ct ua te d in w as h of cl ay - ri ch m at er ia lr ew or ki ng li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el . H F 08 /0 9- 20 33 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A50 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 33 :2 C on te xt 53 7 (c on t.) . A rt ef ac ts : 4% 30 0– 20 00 μm bo ne ,a ng ul ar to su ba ng ul ar ,p la ty ,a ll pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d pa le -y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). O th er s de ep re d, an d tr an si ti on al be tw ee n th e tw o. 3% sh el l, pl at y, 20 0- 50 0μ m ,a ng ul ar ,h or iz on ta lo r di so ri en ta te d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L ay er of si lt y cl ay (u p to 30 % cl ay ) at ba se of un it ,0 .5 cm th ic k, di ff us e bo un da ry w it h ov er ly in g, le ss cl ay ey pa rt of th e fa br ic .2 ) C la ye y cr us ti n ce nt re of un it ,2 00 μm th ic k, w ar pe d, 3– 4c m lo ng .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 50 0μ m . (s ee ab ov e) 20 33 :3 C on te xt 53 7 T hi ck ne ss : 40 –4 5c m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s 80 –1 00 0μ m st ar sh ap ed ,i rr eg ul ar .5 % pl an ar vo id s, sh or t, ro ug h w al ls ,4 00 –8 00 μm ,a ls o dr yi ng ar ou nd ag gr eg at es . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz 40 –1 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .4 0% li m es to ne 10 0μ m –1 .5 cm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed , ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to 75 % .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F R at io : 42 :5 8. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,5 3% si lt ,4 2% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ce ll st ru ct ur e, pa rt ia ll y hu m ifi ed an d ch ar re d, po te nt ia li ro n re pl ac em en tt o ed ge s, 50 0– 70 0μ m ,b lo ck y, ir re gu la r an gu la r. A rt ef ac ts : 4% bo ne ,4 00 μm –2 m m ,h ea vi ly pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, w el l- ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,b ri gh tb ir ef ri ng en ce (y el lo w or gr ey ), a ra ng e of sh ad es of bu rn in g fr om or an ge to bl ac k. 1% fli nt su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky 1m m ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .5 % sh el l, 50 0– 80 0μ m ,a ng ul ar ,p la ty w it h pa st el bi re fr in ge nc e. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% le ns es of re dd is h si lt y cl ay th ro ug ho ut ,c on ce nt ra te d in a di ag on al le ns to ha lf w ay th ro ug h th e un it .< 1m m th ic k, bl oc ky ,s li gh tl y di st ur be d an d br ok en up .M an ga ne se st ai ni ng w it hi n le ns .2 ) C oa rs en in g fr om th e ba se of th e un it – lo w er 1 cm is re la ti ve ly fin e w it h on ly ab ou t2 0% co ar se m at er ia l, in cr ea si ng to > 40 % ab ov e. C ry st al li ne : 1) in cr ea se in cr ys ta ll it ic im pr eg na ti on to w ar ds th e to p th ir d of th e un it ,a lt ho ug h di ffi cu lt to se e w it h th e th in ni ng of th e sl id e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 50 0μ m , bo th ar ou nd co ar se m at er ia la nd in gr ou nd m as s. 2) 1– 2% ir on no du le s, re d cl ay ey an d qu ar tz 20 0– 60 0μ m ,s ha rp bo un da ry .E xc re m en ta l: 1) la rg e bu rr ow 12 m m ac ro ss in th e ce nt re of th e sl id e. In te ns e ph ys ic al w ea th er in g an d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on , sp or ad ic sh ee tw as h be co m in g fr eq ue nt to to p of th e un it .O cc up at io n m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t. 20 33 :4 C on te xt 53 7 T hi ck ne ss : 7m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar . A s 20 33 :5 ,b ut w it h m or e cl ay an d sl ig ht ly be tt er de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e, al th ou gh th is m ay be li nk ed to di st ur ba nc e. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el S an dy si lt lo am .F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld s (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). P hy si ca lw ea th er in g an d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on ,s po ra di c sh ee tw as h. O cc up at io n m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t. 20 33 :5 C on te xt 53 7 T hi ck ne ss : 8– 12 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ,o ve rl yi ng ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, 20 0– 80 0μ m , ir re gu la r, ro ug h- w al le d. 2% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s ir re gu la r, 20 0– 40 0μ m ,a re as of in te rc on ne ct ed ,r ar e. 3% pl an ar vo id s, 10 –2 0μ m w id e, 10 2c m lo ng .R ou gh w al le d, w el la cc om m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 40 –1 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .2 0% li m es to ne 12 0μ m to 2– 3m m ,m od er at el y to po or ly so rt ed .C F L im it : 40 μm .C F R at io : 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt 25 % sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ), go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ). O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2– 3% 50 0μ m –2 m m ,b lo ck y ch ar co al ,r ed -b la ck w it h ca lc it e im pr eg na ti on . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne ,i rr eg ul ar pl at y 40 0μ m ,o ra ng e pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d (P P L ), or an ge (X P L )o ra ng e bi re fr in ge nt .1 % sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r sl ig ht ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n 25 0– 30 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 1% le ns es of si lt y cl ay ,o ra ng ey ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on ,1 –2 m m ,1 00 –2 00 μm th ic k. 2) H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on an d le ns in g in fin e fr ac ti on ,v er y sm al l, m ic ro -c ru st s of fin e m at er ia l< 20 μm .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se no du le s 25 0– 50 0μ m ,d en dr it ic ,d en se ,a ls o as so ci at ed w it h ch ar co al .2 % ir on no du le s/ m ot tl es in gr ou nd m as s, ir re gu la r bl oc ky ,r ou nd ed di ff us e to w el l- de fin ed . 2% 60 0– 80 0μ m m or e di ff us e th an ro un de d. F ab ri c: 1) < 1% du ng le ns he av il y de gr ad ed ,p al e br ow n w it h ph yt ol it hs 2m m ho ri zo nt al ,w ar pe d. P hy si ca lw ea th er in g an d po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on ,s po ra di c sh ee tw as h. O cc up at io n m at er ia lt hr ou gh ou t. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A51 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 33 :6 C on te xt 56 7 T hi ck ne ss : 15 –2 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. (8 0: 20 % ). P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s 15 0μ m –1 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h w al le d. 3% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s in gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e ar ea s, vu gh y si ze d. 2% pl an ar vo id s, sh or t, st ub by ,1 –2 m m ,w el la cc om m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,5 0– 15 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky to su br ou nd ed .4 5% li m es to ne ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed 20 0μ m –2 cm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .P oo rl y so rt ed ,d efi ne s un it .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 50 :5 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,4 8% si lt 47 % sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: D ar k br ow n (P P L ), re d go ld -g ol d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on :c lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, 30 0μ m m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 5% bo ne ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (P P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, 20 0– 30 00 μm ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it e hy po co at in g to la rg e fr ag m en t. H or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .< 1% fli nt ,s ub an gu la r, ph os ph at ic st ai ni ng 1. 1m m .3 % sh el l, pl at y, 20 0– 70 00 μm ,a ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C oa ti ng /c ru st at ba se of un it ,w ar pe d. V er y fin e sa nd to si lt cl ay la ye rs ,i nc lu di ng 1- 2% sm al lf ra gm en ts of or ga ni c m at er ia la ng ul ar ~8 0μ m ,1 5– 20 % qu ar tz .M ay re pr es en tw he re a la rg e fr ag m en to f li m es to ne ha s be en re m ov ed in sa m pl in g. 2) S il ty cl ay ar ea s in th e gr ou nd m as s, in fil li ng s to vo id s or m ic ro -c ru st s as so ci at ed w it h co at in g. 60 μm th ic k, ho ri zo nt al ,l in k- ca pp in g in pl ac es .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) M an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s ~7 00 0μ m ,7 % th ro ug ho ut . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g. B io tu rb at io n. P un ct ua te d w as h of cl ay - ri ch m at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A52 2058:1 2058:4 1c m 20 58 :2 2058:3 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 58 :1 C on te xt 56 2 T hi ck ne ss : 10 –1 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar ir re gu la r ov er ly in g w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 50 –6 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th to ro ug h w al ls .5 % pl an ar vo id s 80 μm th ic k, ac ro ss sl id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,4 0– 12 0μ m .3 0% li m es to ne an d de gr ad ed ca lc it e 10 0– 50 00 μm ,b lo ck y to ir re gu la r. H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to 75 % of m at er ia l. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 37 :6 3. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,3 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic 50 :5 0. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on :O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ce ll st ru ct ur e, bl oc ky ,5 00 –6 00 μm ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne 25 0– 75 0μ m ,y el lo w (P P L ) ye ll ow (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d su rf ac es .A ng ul ar . 1% sh el l, su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed pl at y 50 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 50 0– 90 0μ m . 2) 2% ir on no du le s, w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p, 10 0– 25 0μ m .3 ) 1% ir on am or ph ou s la m in at io ns or le ns es . F ab ri c: 1) 2% fr ag m en ts of cr us ts ~1 00 μm /f ra gm en te d in fil li ng s, bl oc ky to w el l- ro un de d 50 0- 90 0μ m . S he et w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia l. 20 58 :2 C on te xt 56 1 T hi ck ne ss : 4m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y bu tm od er at el y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 10 % .5 % vu gh s 10 0– 60 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 5% pl an ar vo id s ~5 00 μm lo ng an d w el l ac co m m od at ed ,m od er at el y sm oo th w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz ,4 0– 20 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .1 0% li m es to ne su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,1 00 –7 00 μm . C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,5 8% si lt ,1 2% sa nd an d gr av el .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld s to go ld (X P L ), or an ge -r ed (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M os ai c- st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (4 0: 40 :3 0) O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar co al ce ll st ru ct ur e, 30 0μ m ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne 20 0μ m ,p la ty ,s ub ro un de d ye ll ow (P P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, w hi te (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 50 0– 70 0μ m th ro ug ho ut ,a ss oc ia te d w it h po re s an d co ar se fr ag m en ts .F ab ri c: 1) 2% bl oc ky du ng fr ag m en ts ,w el l ro un de d br ow n/ m as si ve w it h ca lc it e/ sp he ru li te s 70 0μ m .2 ) 30 % si lt y cl ay cr us tf ra gm en ts ,m an y or ie nt at io ns . S he et w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia l 20 58 :3 C on te xt 56 1 T hi ck ne ss : 15 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e an d in te rl ea ve d. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve -v ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s, 50 –2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,w el l- ac co m m od at ed .5 % pl an ar vo id s < 20 μm – 50 μm ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed ,1 –2 la rg e dr yi ng cr ac ks to o. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y 40 –1 50 μm .2 0% li m es to ne an d ca lc it e 10 0μ m –1 cm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el ,s an dy si lt lo am . L im it ed w as h of cl ay ey m at er ia lf ol lo w ed by po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on H F 08 /0 9- 20 58 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A53 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 58 :3 C on te xt :5 61 (c on t.) F in e m at er ia l: P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ). R ed di sh in pl ac es (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to cr ys ta ll it ic (2 5% ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar co al bl oc ky st ru ct ur e m an ga ne se -i m pr eg na te d ~4 00 μm . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,a ng ul ar ,i rr eg ul ar as so ci at ed w it h m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c st ai ni ng .Y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. 50 0– 70 0μ m . < 1% sh el l, eg g, 50 00 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 5% S m al lh or iz on ta ll en se s of re d cl ay ey si lt co nc en tr at io n in m at er ia l2 m m lo ng ,l am in at io ns an d m ic ro cr us ts ~5 0μ m th ic k, es pe ci al ly at ri gh th an d si de .2 ) C ap pi ng to pl an ar vo id be lo w an d ar ou nd li m es to ne at th e to p of th e un it .3 ) L im es to ne fr ag m en ts < co ar se sa nd ar e a co nc en tr at ed la te r at th e to p of th e sl id e 0. 5c m th ic k. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 25 0– 60 0μ m ,t hr ou gh ou ta nd co nc en tr at ed on co ar se in cl us io ns ,b ut al so in gr ou nd m as s. 2) 5% ir on no du le s, ro un de d, 14 00 0μ m ,q ua rt z, sh ar p bo un da ri es an d bl oc ky .F ab ri c: 1) 20 % cr us tf ra gm en ts th ro ug ho ut bu tc on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds th e ba se of th e un it (5 % el se w he re ) 15 0– 20 0μ m up to 1m m ,w el lr ou nd ed to an gu la r, al lo ri en ta ti on s. 2) 2– 3% du ng le ns es ,p al e br ow n si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs ,s po ng y st ru ct ur e, le ns es 1– 1. 5c m lo ng ,v er y th in ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed . (s ee ab ov e) 20 58 :4 C on te xt 53 6 T hi ck ne ss : 35 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v ug hy ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e, al m os tfi br ou s/ sp on gy in pl ac es .P or os it y: 10 % .8 % vu gh s an d ch am be rs 50 –1 00 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 2% pl an ar vo id s 50 –6 00 μm ,a nd 40 0– 1c m .L ar ge r, ho ri zo nt al -i sh or ie nt at io n. To so m e, bu t al so di ag on al an d ve rt ic al . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –8 0μ m .1 5% li m es to ne /c al ci te 10 0– 50 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar co al ,o bl iq ue ce ll st ru ct ur e, 30 0μ m ,b lo ck y, m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne ,p la ty ,e lo ng at ed ,s ub ro un de d 30 0- 10 00 μm ,y el lo w to re d( P P L ), ye ll ow s an d re ds (X P L ). R ou gh ly ho ri zo nt al .3 00 –4 00 μm , lo ng ye ll ow /p al e ye ll ow .< 1% fli nt ,w el l- ro un de d, ve ry ir on st ai ne d. < 1% sh el l7 50 μm ,p la ty ,a ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% sl ig ht ar ra ng em en to f co ar se /m ed iu m sa nd in to ho ri zo nt al le ns es 1- 2m m th ic k. 3) C oa ti ng of ca lc it e si lt y cl ay ar ou nd al lg ra ve l- si ze d li m es to ne .4 ) 1% ar ea of cr us ti ng be tw ee n le ns es of du ng ,9 00 μm lo ng ,l in k ca pp in g. C ry st al li ti c: 1) M or e co nc re te d w it h ca lc it e to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it ,m os ti n th e m id dl e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,d en dr it ic fr om 1. 5m m - 50 0μ m ,b ro ke n gr ou nd bu ta ls o in th e gr ou nd m as s. 2) 5% ir on no du le s 20 0– 60 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d th ro ug ho ut ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s li gh tl y di ff us e in so m e ar ea s. F ab ri c: 1) D un g le ns es do m in at e th e un it ,a lm os t2 5% of th e up pe r pa rt of th e fa br ic in la rg e ch un k, ra ng e of le ns es an d bl oc ks , di ff us e to sh ar p ed ge s. P un ct ua te d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h oc cu pa ti on m at er ia la nd si gn ifi ca nt qu an ti ti es of du ng . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A54 1c m 2113:1 2113:2 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 21 13 :1 C on te xt 47 0 T hi ck ne ss : 11 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e an d po ro si ty : 0– 30 m m – vu gh y, 25 % po ro si ty 15 % vu gh s (5 –3 % ve ge ta lv oi ds ), 10 0μ m –1 m m , ir re gu la r to ro ug h w al ls . 10 % pl an ar ,l ar ge sc al e pl an ar cm lo ng ,r ou gh -s m oo th w al le d, w el la cc om m od at ed , 50 –4 00 μm . 30 –6 0m m m as si ve -w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e, 15 % po ro si ty ;1 0% vu gh s, 50 –1 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al le d 5% pl an ar vo id s, 80 –2 00 μm w id e. 60 –1 10 cm – m od er at el y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,s om e pl an ar vo id s fil le d in .2 0% po ro si ty ;1 5% pl an ar vo id s, va ry in g le ng th s. 5% vu gh s, 50 μm –1 .5 m m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 25 0μ m ,w el ls or te d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky , < 1% bi g on es .1 0– 15 % li m es to ne ,0 –6 m m po or ly so rt ed 5% fin e to co ar se gr av el . S ub an gu la r bl oc ky 10 0μ m –2 .5 cm .R es to f sl id e 10 % po or ly so rt ed no gr av el -v li tt le . S am e pr op or ti on s 10 0μ m n– 2m m .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay , 60 % si lt ,2 0% sa nd .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), go ld s (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 5: 15 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en -c lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% bl oc ky ,w ar pe d ce ll st ru ct ur e, sh ar p. ~3 00 μm –5 00 μm , m an ga ne se st ai ni ng . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne 60 0μ m – 1. 5m m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,p la ty -r ou nd .P it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ) gr ey (X P L ). 3– 2% sh el l, pl at y, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed an gu la r, 1– 4c m , co nc en tr at io n ~3 00 –5 00 μm ,( el se w he re < 1% or 1% 0. < 1% fli nt ro un de d, ~4 50 μm , si lt y cl ay co at in g. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) P or os it y va ri at io ns as ab ov e. 2) S il ty co at in gs to ve ge ta l vo id s < 10 μm ,g m m ix ed .3 ) S il ty cl ay co at in gs to ~2 5% of co ar se fr ac ti on .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % ir on no du le s so m e w it h m ul ti pl e ph as es of fo rm at io n, 30 0μ m –2 m m ,q ua rt z, si lt y cl ay ,- sh ar p- di ff us e bo un da ry .W el l- ro un de d. 2) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s. 2– 3m m ac ro ss 2% ra re ou ts id e of th is .3 ) M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to vo id s – la rg e ch an ne ld oe s. D is co nt in uo us to m or e po ro us ar ea s. F ab ri c: 1) C ru st fr ag m en ts ,w el l- ro un de d 5% of sl id e ne ar er 10 % at lo w er pa rt fo r sl id e. 0. 5c m – 20 0μ m ,r ou nd -b lo ck y, si lt y cl ay ,m ul ti pl e se qu en ce s in so m e, m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to o. A re a an d zo ne s. 2) D un g – 2 or 3 la rg e cm -s ca le pa le br ow n- gr ey sp on gy si lt ,i so tr op ic (X P L ) ab un da nt ph yt ol it hs ,w el l- ro un de d fr ag m en ts th ro ug ho ut – sm al le r ha ve sp he ru li te s an d si m il ar co lo ur s. 5% co nc en tr at ed up to 15 % w it h bi g bi ts ,6 00 μm –1 - 2c m ,r ar e le ns es an gu la r/ bl oc ky .E xc re m en ta l: H ea vi ly so - pl an ar vo id s fil le d as w el l – w as p bu rr ow s. H ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d po te nt ia la eo li an an d ph ys ic al w ea th er in g m at er ia lw it h va ry in g ra te s of co ll uv ia l/ ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng . H F 08 /0 9- 21 13 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A55 1c m 2521:1 2521:2 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 25 21 :1 C on te xt 45 8 T hi ck ne ss : 65 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y- m od er at el y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e – pe ds 25 0– 10 0μ m ,r ou nd ,p ar ti al ly fu se d to ge th er .V er y w el ld ev el op ed to w ar ds th e ba se of th e un it –h ea vi ly re w or ke d – an d as so ci at ed w it h la rg er bi ot ur ba te d ar ea s w it hi n a bu rr ow cu t. V ug hy -m as si ve in so m e ar ea s, bu tn ot m or e th an 20 % .P or os it y: 20 % po ro si ty .1 0% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, 40 –2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h w al le d. 8% vu gh s, m ai nl y ve ge ta l vo id s, 5% ,1 50 μm –1 00 0μ m ,s m oo th ,s il tc ir cl ed .C on ti nu um be tw ee n th e tw o ki nd s of vo id s. N o pr ef er re d or ie nt at io n. 2% pl an ar vo id s – to w ar ds ba se of un it .5 0– 1m m w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd 40 –1 00 μm .S ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,s tr in gy ,d if fu se di st ri bu ti on .1 5% li m es to ne gr av el to ve ry fin e sa nd , 60 μm –2 cm po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt , 20 % sa nd an d gr av el . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re dd is h- go ld (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, 2m m –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), pa rt ia lm an ga ne se st ai ni ng .1 % sh el l, 75 0– 50 0μ m ,p la ty ,r an do m or ie nt at io n. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il th yp oc oa ti ng s to st ar sh ap ed vo id s th ro ug ho ut ,a nd to so m e co ar se co m po ne nt s 50 % of vo id s an d co ar se m at er ia l. 2) C oa rs er m at er ia lc on ce nt ra te d up to 20 % to lo w er 3c m – ve ry po or ly so rt ed w it h no or ie nt at io n. 3) S il ty in fil li ng s to pl an ar vo id s – ve ry ra re ,b ut on e es pe ci al ly ne ar bo un da ry in ex te nd ed pl an ar vo id s. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s up to 1c m ac ro ss ,c ir cu la r in gr ou nd m as s, m or e di ff us e an d ir re gu la r in lo w er 2c m of un it (m or e op en ). S m al le st no du le s ~1 00 μm ac ro ss .2 ) 2% ir on no du le s, sh ar p, w el lr ou nd ed ,1 50 –5 00 μm ,r ed ,q ua rt z ~2 5% . F ab ri c: 1) ~2 % F ra gm en ts of si lt y m at er ia l~ 2% re d, fin e, 15 0– 25 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed , to p an d bo tt om of un it .2 ) 5% D un g – pa le gr ey -y el lo w (P P L ) is ot ro pi c (X P L ), sp on gy st ru ct ur e, bl oc ky to w ar pe d, w el l- ro un de d, ph yt ol it hs an d sp he ru li te s 50 0μ m –3 m m . B io tu rb at ed in on e ar ea .3 ) 2% cl ay ey si lt cr us tf ra gm en ts ,c on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds to p of un it . F in in g up se qu en ce s, w ar pe d, po te nt ia ll y fr ag m en te d in fil li ng s. M as s m ov em en to f sl ur ry m at er ia la tb as e be fo re w ea th er in g an d ae ol ia n/ sm al ls ca le co ll uv ia l re de po si ti on at to p. H F 09 -2 52 1 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A56 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 25 21 :2 C on te xt 45 9 T hi ck ne ss : 65 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve /v er y w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky to sl ig ht ly vu gh y at th e ba se .W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar to p 1m m or so of un it .P or os it y: 10 % (~ 25 % at ba se ). 5% V ug hs ,2 00 –7 00 μm ,t hr ou gh ou t, ir re gu la r, ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io ns to m or e pl at y on es .A tb as e an d to p of un it 10 –1 5% .5 % pl an ar vo id s 50 0– 50 μm w id e, in te rc on ne ct ed m ai nl y. O th er s ~1 m m ,h or iz on ta lo r ve rt ic al an d di ag on al ,m ai nl y ho ri zo nt al or ga ni sa ti on ,c on ce nt ra ti on at si de s an d co nt ac t, sm al le r on es ar e no n- dr yi ng . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd 40 –1 00 μm ,v .w el l- so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed th ro ug ho ut .1 7% li m es to ne an d ca lc it e – 3c m –2 00 μm ve ry po or ly so rt ed .L ar ge r pi ec es ha ve ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 27 :7 3. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: L ig ht br ow n (P P L ), go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: no ne A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el l2 00 –8 00 μm ,p la ty ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on in ab ou t5 0% .< 1% bo ne pl at y (i n ce nt re ) an gu la r, pa le ye ll ow ,g re y bi re fr in ge nc e. 1 pi ec e bu rn ta nd w el lr ou nd ed .< 1% fli nt ~5 00 μm ,r ou nd ed ,b lo ck y. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L am in at ed fa br ic ,b as ed on th e or ie nt at io n of vo id s an d su bt le so rt in g of gr ou nd m as s. 2) In cr ea se in m ed iu m - co ar se sa nd co nc en tr at ed at ba se of un it ,a ls o as so ci at ed w it h di so rg an is at io n an d lo ss of th e la m in at io ns .3 ) O ra ng e cl ay co at in gs ,4 0μ m th ic k to la rg e pl an ar vo id s at le ft ha nd si de of fa br ic .R es tr ic te d in ar ea .4 ) S il ty cl ay in fil li ng a co m pl et e pl an ar vo id fr om lh s ju st be lo w th e bo un da ry .~ 10 0μ m th ic k. 5) C oa ti ng to la rg e gr av el ha lf w ay do w n un it – pl an ar vo id s an d in fil le d 6) C la y co at in g to 10 % qu ar tz gr ai ns .C ry st al li ne : 1) O ne ca lc it ic ‘p ed en t’ ~1 cm ac ro ss un de r la rg e gr av el fr ag m en t. 2) C al ci ti c in fil li ng s an d hy po co at in gs to 1c m ar ea at th e ve ry ba se of un it ,f ol lo w in g a m or e op en pa rt of gr ou nd m as s. Im pr eg na ti on of th e w ho le fa br ic ,i n co rn er s. A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) 1% m an ga ne se in fil li ng ,f ra m bo id s, to po re ~6 0– 80 μm ,a nd hy po co at in g to vo id s – pl an ar < 1% 2) 2% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s as so ci at ed w it h lo os er gr ou nd m as s, bu ta ls o in gr ou nd m as s. 25 0μ m –1 –2 m m ac ro ss ,d if fu se .3 ) 2% ir on no du le s 2m m –2 50 μm ,w el lr ou nd ed th ro ug ho ut ,m uc h hi gh er in cl ay th an su rr ou nd in g gr ou nd m as s. F ab ri c: 1) 1– 2% 10 0– 25 0μ m ,s il ty fr ag m en ts of cr us t– ro un de d bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t. 2) 10 % pa le br ow n si lt y du ng la m in at io ns .D eg ra de d, sp on gy ,p hy to li th s is ot ro pi c. U p to 1c m ,a ll la m in ar fr ag m en ts .D ow n to 60 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,p la ty ,w el lr ou nd ed ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .E xc re m en t: 1) L ar ge bu rr ow in ce nt re ~ 1c m . P un ct ua te d po te nt ia la eo li an /s m al l sc al e co ll uv ia ld ep os it io n w it h w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A57 1c m 2529:1 2529:2 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 25 29 :1 C on te xt 45 1 T hi ck ne ss : 50 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m as si ve in pl ac es .P or os it y: 15 % .1 2% vu gh s an d ch am be rs , ~2 00 μm ,r ou gh -s m oo th ed ge s, ir re gu la r. 3% pl an ar vo id s in te rc on ne ct in g vu gh s an d ch am be rs ,~ 20 -6 0μ m ,w id e, w el la cc om m od at ed up to cm in le ng th C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 20 % 50 –1 20 μm qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,w el ls or te d. 15 % li m es to ne ~5 0μ m –1 .5 cm su ba ng ul ar to ro un de d. V er y po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), du ll is h or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,4 00 –6 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d bl oc ky ,i nfi ll ed by si lt an d cl ay . A rt ef ac ts : < 2% sh el l2 00 –4 00 μm pl at y, an gu la r ra nd om di st ri bu ti on ,p oo rl y so rt ed . 1% bo ne ,3 00 –5 00 μm ,a ng ul ar ,p la ty ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow -g re y (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S li gh ts il ty hy po co at in gs to so m e vo id s – fil li ng in an d fu si ng ag gr eg at es < 10 μm ,~ 10 % of se ct io n, li tt le va ri at io n, th ro ug ho ut .2 ) In cr ea se in co ar se sa nd at ba se of un it sh ow in g sl ig ht im br ic at io n ju st ab ov e th e co nt ac tw it h 25 29 :2 .3 ) H or iz on ta la rr an ge m en tt o lo w er pa rt of sl id e de sp it e th e po or so rt in g. M or e a se ns e m ar ke d ou tb y th e du ng le ns es .C ry st al li ne : 1) L en se s < 1% of m ic ri ti c ca lc it e – gr ey in (X P L ), an d( P P L ), 1m m ac ro ss ,2 00 μm de ep .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 1– 2m m ac ro ss ,a ss oc ia te d w it h op aq ue no du le s – re dd is h pu rp le an d m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs .2 ) 5% ir on no du le s, 2c m –2 00 μm ,w el l ro un de d, sh ar p, ir re gu la r. F ab ri c: 7% le ns es of pa le br ow n si lt y du ng ,i so tr op ic ,2 0% ph yt ol it hs ,~ 50 μm ,l en se s 1m m –2 cm ,o ri en ta ti on .S om e ve ry ca lc it ic ~3 % . E ro si ve co ll uv ia l/ al lu vi al m ov em en to f in te rn al m at er ia l, fo ll ow ed by a pe ri od of sl ow in g of de po si ti on an d ep he m er al su rf ac es an d la te r re su m pt io n of co ll uv ia l re gi m e. H F 09 -2 52 9 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A58 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 25 29 :2 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 70 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve w it h nu m er ou s cr ac ks in pl ac es ,a lm os td ev el op in g a su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% P la na r vo id s, in te rc on ne ct ed sm oo th w al le d, m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed fr om 30 μm w id e, to 40 0μ m w id e – la rg er ar e dr yi ng cr ac ks ,b et te r ac co m m od at ed ,r ou gh w al ls .5 % vu gh s an d ch am be rs ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th -r ou gh w al ls 20 0– 60 μm . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd 50 -1 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,w el ls or te d. S li gh tl y cl us te re d. 10 % li m es to ne (3 % is gr av el > 1c m ). 15 0– 60 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,s ub ro un de d to ro un de d bl oc ky ,s li gh tl y sm oo th .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed br ow n (P P L ), re d (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: ~1 50 μm bl oc ky ch ar co al ,s ub an gu la r, ce ll st ru ct ur e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ,4 00 μm an gu la r pl at y, bl oc ky ,y el lo w (P P L ), ye ll ow -g re y (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S li gh tc oa rs en in g in ce nt re of sl id e – ba nd ab ou t2 –3 cm th ic k, w it h co nc en tr at io n of fin e gr av el /c oa rs e sa nd li m es to ne up to 15 % .2 ) B el ow th is ,a re as w it h cr us ts an d si lt y hy po co at in gs in cr ea se ,2 5% of sl id e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% w el l- de ve lo pe d m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, up to 1c m ac ro ss ,v er y he av il y im pr eg na te d in ce nt ra la re a. D ow n to 50 μm si ze cl us te rs .2 ) 3% m an ga ne se li ni ng s to pl an ar vo id s to w ar ds to p 50 % of un it ,3 ) 3% ir on no du le s 90 0– 20 0μ m w el lr ou nd ed .F ab ri c: 1) 3% du ng le ns es /c hu nk s of pa le br ow n si lt an d ph yt ol it hs ,2 00 μm –1 m m sc al e, to w ar ds to p of sl id e, so m e ve ry bl oc ky ,o th er s le ns es .2 ) S il ty cr us ts to w ar ds ba se of un it .S om e or ie nt ed ho ri zo nt al ly ,s om e w ar pe d. F ra gm en ts to 10 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,s il ty ,u p to la rg er su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar fr ag m en ts w it h m ul ti pl e la ye rs .U p to 1c m ne ar ve ry th in ar ea of th e sl id e. ~1 0% of sl id e at la st 3c m .C on ti nu um w it h po te nt ia l si lt y in fil li ng s/ co at in gs /a rr an ge m en ts of th e gr ou nd m as s. E xc re m en ta l: 1) L ar ge di st ur ba nc e in ce nt re .M ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e co m pl et el y di sa gg re ga te d 50 % . B as al sl ur ry of m ai nl y ex te rn al m at er ia lo ve rl ai n by po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n re de po si ti on .T ru nc at ed by ov er ly in g un it . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A59 1c m 2610:1 2610:3 26 10 :2 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 10 :1 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 20 –3 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. ~6 0– 12 0μ m gr an ul es ,i n pl ac es la rg er pe ds ~1 m m ac ro ss . A re as of ve ry w el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 35 % po ro si ty .2 0% C om po un d pa ck in g vo id s ar ou nd gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e. 10 % la rg e vu gh s, ir re gu la r, sm oo th w al le d 30 0– 50 0μ m .5 % C ra ck s/ pl an ar vo id s, lo ng ,r ou gh w al ls w el l ac co m m od at ed up to 1m m w id e le ng th of sl id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz – su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky , 40 –1 00 μm ,w el ls or te d. 15 % li m es to ne – 30 0– 90 0μ m ir re gu la r to bl oc ky ,d if fu se to sh ar p ed ge s, po or ly so rt ed ,a ng ul ar co ar se sa nd /fi ne gr av el co nc en tr at ed to to p, ne ar de gr ad in g li m es to ne .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt 25 % sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w br ow n (P P L ), or an ge s an d go ld s (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed ,m ic ri ti c an d sp ar it ic ca lc it ic an d un di ff er en ti at ed (6 0: 25 :1 5) .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ve ry de gr ad ed ,b lo ck y ch ar co al w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, 40 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% sh el la ng ul ar pl at y, po or ly so rt ed ,n o or ie nt at io n 80 0– 20 0μ m P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty to w ar ds ba se ,m uc h be tt er so rt in g. W el l- ro un de d fin e qu ar tz gr ai ns – 20 % he re .2 ) M as si ve in to pm os tf ew m m - co m pr es si on ? C ry st al li ne : 1) R ow of m ic ri ti c ag gr eg at es al on g th e to p of th e sa m pl e un de r th e li m es to ne fr ag m en ts ,6 0– 10 0μ m – si m il ar to th os e in vo id s. 2) 40 % of vo id s, m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic co at in gs to vo id s vo id s –a ll la rg e ch an ne ls et c 60 –1 00 μm .3 ) C al ci ti c in fil li ng s co at in gs an d hy po co at in gs to la rg e vo id ,s om et im es li nk in g. 4) 1% fib ro us ,s tr aw -l ik e rh om bo id cr ys ta ls ,c le ar in (P P L ), hi gh ly bi re fr in ge nt ,1 00 μm .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se vo id s co at in gs ca pp in g/ im pr eg na ti ng ar ea ar ou nd vo id s. 2) 3– 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, ~2 00 μm .3 ) 1– 2% ir on no du le s, w el l- ro un de d an d bl oc ky ,s ha rp bo un da ri es .1 00 –5 00 μm ,r an do m di st ri bu ti on . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n m at er ia l si gn ifi ca nt ly w et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . 26 10 :2 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 5– 2m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: S ub an gu la r bl oc ky to m as si ve .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% cr ac ks an d pl an ar vo id s 10 μm –4 0μ m w id e. 20 0μ m to cm sc al e. 5% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al ls ,5 0μ m – 30 0μ m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,3 0μ m –1 50 μm , su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .5 % li m es to ne fin e to m ed iu m sa nd ,1 00 μm –8 00 μm .C F li m it : 30 μm C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 40 % cl ay ,5 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il ty cl ay . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -m os ai c sp ec kl ed ,( 80 :2 0) .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic s: 3% bl oc ky ch ar co al .8 0μ m –1 50 μm . A rt ef ac ts : N on e. In w as h an d pu dd li ng of po te nt ia ls oi lm at er ia l. H F 09 -2 61 0 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A60 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 10 :2 C on te xt 44 2 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) A tb as e, fin er an d m or e co m pa ct be co m es co ar se bu ti s st il lw el l- so rt ed to w ar ds to p. C ry st al li ti c: 1) 10 % cr ys ta ll it ic (s pa ri ti c an d m ic ri ti c) co at in gs to vo id s w hi ch ru n th ro ug h th e un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) M an ga ne se st ai ni ng to tw o ar ea s at th e ba se of th e co nt ac t– 1– 2m m ac ro ss ,d if fu se .F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng bl oc ks ,w el lr ou nd ed ,5 00 μm .2 ) 2% pe do re li ct s, w el l- ro un de d, si lt y, 30 0– 70 0μ m . (s ee ab ov e) . 26 10 :3 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 40 –6 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e – 60 –1 00 μm . P or os it y: 20 % C ha nn el s -5 % of sl id es ,1 -2 m m ,V ug hs /c ha m be rs – 15 % of sl id e, ir re gu la r fr om 20 0– 50 0μ m ,s m oo th /i rr eg ul ar w al ls ,a ls o ar ou nd pa ck ed ag gr eg at es C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 40 –1 00 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,w el l- so rt ed .1 5% li m es to ne ,r ou nd ed -i rr eg ul ar , di ff us e ed ge s, th ro ug ho ut 10 0– 60 0μ m ,d en se m ic ri ti c, po or ly so rt ed .G ra ve l, bl oc ky ,p la ty an gu la r ra nd om di st ri bu ti on ~1 –3 m .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), ve ry du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : m ic ri ti c sp ar it ic an d m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic ,s ti pp le sp ec kl ed to un di ff er en ti at ed (5 0: 20 :3 0) .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N o or ga ni c. P hy to li th s m ak e up 15 % of th e gr ou nd m as s. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne pi tt ed ,c ra ck ed ,v er y an gu la r, bl oc ky ,6 00 μm ,g re y w it h ca lc it e. 1% sh el l, 20 0μ m pl at y an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al ,o ne ar ea 1c m fr om ba se . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) M or e cr ys ta ll it ic to ve ry ba se of un it ,u p to 70 % .2 ) M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs an d co at in gs to al l la rg e vo id s. ~1 00 –2 50 μm th ic k. S om et im es co m pl et el y im pr eg na ti ng la rg e ar ea s to w ar ds th e ba se ,o th er s on cm sc al e. 3) C al ci te m ic ro ag gr eg at es in 80 % of m am m il at e ch an ne ls .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) ~2 % m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s an d fr am bo id s in gr ou nd m as s – pa tc he s ~4 00 μm .< 1% as so ci at ed w it h pe do re li ct s. 2) 2% m an ga ne se co at in gs on so m e la rg er vo id s, la ye re d in pl ac es w it h ca lc it e, ~2 0μ m th ic k. 3) 1% pa rt ia ll y di ss ol ve d bo ne to vu gh s at ve ry to p of fa br ic ,i n pl ac es as so ci at ed w it h fib ro us ca lc it ic m in er al s ~2 0μ m ac ro ss .F ab ri c: 1) 1% D un g is ot ro pi c w it h sp he ru li te s hi gh ly ir re gu la r, ve ry ju m bl ed ,p hy to li th s, bu ti n ot he r pl ac es ar ti cu la te d. V er y pa le ,a lm os tj us tp hy to li th s le ft .P at ch es up to 1m m ,v er y de gr ad ed .2 ) 1% pe do re li ct s w el lr ou nd ed ,s ha rp 40 0– 80 0μ m ,n o or ie nt at io n, th ro ug ho ut ,p oo r so rt in g. E xc re m en ta l: 1) L ar ge ex cr em en ts in ch an ne ls ,1 –2 % ve ry sm oo th an d li nk ed to ge th er ,w el lf us ed to ge th er . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h si gn ifi ca nt w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A61 1c m 2615:22615:1 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 15 :1 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 40 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: C ha nn el m ic ro st ru ct ur e ov er ly in g m as si ve m ic ro st ru ct ur e. W ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e in pl ac es – fu si on of m ic ro ag gr eg at es w it hi n w ha tc ou ld be bi ot ur ba te d ar ea s, 10 % of sl id e, gr an ul es 50 –1 00 μm w he n fu ll y se pa ra te d, bu tm ai nl y v. de ns el y ag gr eg at ed in to la rg er pe ds ~2 00 μm ac ro ss co nc ur re nt w it h th e re st of th e gr ou nd m as s. P or os it y: 30 % .L on g sm oo th ch an ne ls ,2 0% of sl id e, 10 0μ m to 3– 4c m lo ng ,p oo rl y so rt ed .S m al li rr eg ul ar vu gh s/ ve ge ta lv oi ds , 10 0– 20 0μ m ,1 0% of sl id e, ir re gu la r, ro ug h si de s. R an do m di st ri bu ti on of sm al li rr eg ul ar vu gh s an d ch an ne ls – ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed .O pe n po rp hy ri c. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,5 0– 10 0μ m ,w el ls or te d, op en po rp hy ri c di st ri bu ti on th ro ug ho ut un it ; 5% li m es to ne /c al ci te – 25 0μ m –1 –2 cm ve ry po or ly so rt ed , ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,g ra ve ll y to w ar ds ba se of un it ,s m al le r si ze di st ri bu te d th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,8 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c to sp ar it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l– 30 0μ m an gu la r, ra nd om di st ri bu ti on ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) G en er al ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n an d la m in at io ns of cl ay – m or e a se ns e at m ac ro .C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c fil li ng s to al ll ar ge vu gh s an d ch an ne ls .1 0μ m –5 0μ m th ic k, cr ys ta ls < 5μ m .S om e al so ac co m pa ni ed by hy po co at in gs of ca lc it e in to gr ou nd m as s ar ou nd vo id s, up to 70 μm th ic k, so m et im es in te rc on ne ct in g be tw ee n ch an ne ls .2 ) C al ci te ag gr eg at io ns w it hi n th e ch an ne ls ,5 0μ m ,r ou nd ,w el lr ou nd ed .U p to 40 % of po re sp ac e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s 5- 10 % ar ou nd 25 0μ m to < 50 μm ,f ra m bo id s in gr ou nd m as s, so m et im es as so ci at ed w it h vo id s. R an do m di st ri bu ti on .3 ) 1% ve ry di ff us e ir on no du le w it h m an ga ne se ,1 50 μm .F ab ri c: 1) 20 % du ng le ns es ,p al e si lt ,v er y pa le br ow n le ns es an d ch un ks ,c on ta in in g m an y ph yt ol it hs ,s po ng y, sp he ru li te s < 10 μm .P oo rl y so rt ed .W el l- ro un de d (w it h si lt y co at in gs ) an d sh ar p bo un da ri es to su ba ng ul ar an d ir re gu la r bo un da ri es .4 00 μm –3 cm . H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on .D is ru pt ed by ch an ne ls an d bi ot ur ba ti on in pl ac es 2) C la ye y si lt cr us t fr ag m en ts ,c on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds th e ba se of th e un it w he re th ey m ak e up 5% of ar ea – ov er al l 2% of sl id e, 1c m –1 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,r ed di sh .M ul ti pl e ph as es of fin in g up , ev id en ce of cr ac ki ng on th es e sm al ls ur fa ce s, w it h so m e w hi ch m ay be w it hi n th e ch un k it se lf .3 ) 3% P ed or el ic ts – up to 25 % qu ar tz ve ry fin e sa nd .S ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y to ro un d in sh ap e, 25 0– 40 0μ m .R an do m di st ri bu ti on .S ha rp to bl ur ry ex te rn al bo un da ri es . P ot en ti al eo li an de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es . H F 09 -2 61 5 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A62 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 15 :2 C on te xt 44 5 T hi ck ne ss : 42 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /c ha nn el .P or os it y: 30 % .2 5% C ha nn el s – 25 % of sl id e, sm oo th w al le d, S om e in te rc on ne ct ed or co nn ec te d al on g a li ne by pl an ar vo id s. O pe n po rp hy ri c, ra nd om di st ri bu ti on .1 00 μm –1 cm sc al e – m ai nl y 10 0– 20 0μ m th ic k. S om e la rg er sm oo th -w al le d vu gh s in th is cl as s si ze (~ 5% ). 5% S m al li rr eg ul ar vu gh s – 50 –2 00 μm ,5 % of sl id e – ir re gu la r, ro ug h si de s. R an do m di st ri bu ti on of sm al li rr eg ul ar vu gh s an d ch an ne ls – ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ve ry to fin e sa nd 60 –1 50 μm ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed .5 % li m es to ne /c al ci te – bl oc ky su ba ng ul ar to ro un de d, 3m m –2 00 μm ve ry po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 60 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. 10 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il t lo am . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n- re d (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), D ul lo ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, sp ar it ic an d m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic (3 0: 70 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on :o pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne sh ar ds – pl at y, an gu la r ~2 00 μm th ic k, 60 0μ m lo ng .N o sp ec ifi c or ie nt at io n, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. < 1% sh el l– sp ir al st ru ct ur e ev id en t, bu ta ls o pl at y fr ag m en t. 30 0μ m su ba ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S li gh th or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on ,n ot m uc h – v sl ig ht ,n ot w el ld ev el op ed .C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci te in fil li ng s an d co at in gs to 80 % vu gh s an d ch an ne ls .A lo ng w it h gr an ul ar ca lc it ic in fll in gs ,p er ha ps ba se d on ex cr em en ts ,fi ll in g up to 30 –4 0% of th e po re sp ac e. 2) In te rc on ne ct ed hy po co at in gs ar ou nd ch an ne ls ,b ut al so in sm al le r ir re gu la r vo id s – in fil li ng .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) < 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 40 0μ m .2 ) 3% ir on no du le s w it h de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se hy po co at in gs ,w el l- ro un de d to ir re gu la r, bl oc ky .3 ) 10 % pe do re li ct s up to 25 % qu ar tz v fin e sa nd .7 00 μm -2 00 μm w el lr ou nd ed .P oo rl y so rt ed .L ar ge ex am pl e - m uc h m or e ir re gu la r/ di ff us e, bu to nl y on e si de .C ra ck st ru ct ur e. F ab ri c: 1) 15 % P al e, sp on gy du ng ,i rr eg ul ar ,v er y br ok en do w n – ph yt ol it hs ~8 00 μm ,o r le ns in g < 10 0μ m w id e an d 80 0μ m lo ng .V er y he av il y de gr ad ed . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A63 1c m 2621:1 2621:42621:2 2621:3 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 21 :1 C on te xt 44 5 T hi ck ne ss : 25 –4 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /c ha nn el st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .5 % ch an ne ls ,e lo ng at ed ,s m oo th w al ls 3– 40 0μ m w id e, up to 0. 5c m lo ng sc al e lo ng ,p oo rl y so rt ed .1 0% vu gh s – bl oc ky ,1 00 –4 00 μm , ro ug h/ sm oo th w al ls ,v po or ly so rt ed .< 2% th in ,h or iz on ta lp la na r vo id s, 10 –2 0μ m w id e, sm oo th ,w el la cc om m od at ed C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,e ve nl y di st ri bu te d, w el ls or te d 40 –1 00 μm .1 0% li m es to ne fr ag m en ts – an gu la r to su br ou nd ed 50 0μ m –1 cm po or ly so rt ed .H or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on to gr av el co m po ne nt .V er y li tt le ca lc it e, un li ke 26 10 .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .C la y lo am /s il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- ye ll ow (P P L ), or an ge -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% bl oc ky ch ar co al ,b la ck to da rk re dd is h br ow n, ir re gu la r ed ge s, ce ll st ru ct ur e, sl ig ht sp ar kl e bu tn ot to ns – hu m ifi ed ? ~6 00 –9 00 μm . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% ch ar co al ,3 m m bl oc ky ce ll ,b ut no td is ce rn ab le .1 % sh el l, pl at y, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed ,6 00 μm .1 % bo ne ,6 00 μm bl oc ky ,a ng ul ar pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) < 1% cl ay ey si lt re dd is h le ns es ,h or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on ,t ow ar ds ba se of un it ,~ 1. 5m m ac ro ss ,5 00 μm th ic k. 2) R ar e w ar pi ng of du ng le ns es ar ou nd co ar se m at er ia l at to p of un it .C ry st al ll in e: 1) C al ci ti c co at in gs an d ca lc it ic ag gr eg at es w it hi n al lc ha nn el s. 2) C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to th es e fe at ur es th ro ug ho ut ,~ 80 –1 00 μm th ic k, im pr eg na ti ng gr ou nd m as s an d fu si ng to ge th er .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s ~2 00 μm –4 00 μm in gr ou nd m as s an d ar ou nd co ar se r co m po ne nt s. 2) 10 % pe do re li ct s 2m m –2 00 μm ,r ou nd ed ,q ua rt z 25 % - w el lr ou nd ed .F ab ri c: 1) 5% du ng ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ) si lt ,s li gh tl y sp on gy ,p hy to li th ri ch le ns es ,5 0% ha ve sp he ru li te s. Ir re gu la r, al l w it h re gu la r di ff us e bo rd er s, 80 % le nt ic ul ar ~1 50 μm th ic k, 1c m lo ng ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. 20 % bl oc ky ,i rr eg ul ar an d w ar pe d ~5 00 μm . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng .. 26 21 :2 C on te zt 44 5 T hi ck ne ss : 30 –4 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y- m od er at e su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e in pl ac es ,o th er w is e m as si ve . P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% of pl an ar vo id s li nk in g ch am be rs ,d om in an tt o su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky , ho ri zo nt al in pl ac es ,5 0μ m th ic k, 1m m –1 cm lo ng an d ac ro ss en ti re un it .5 % st ar ry ,i rr eg ul ar vu gh s & ch am be rs ,s m oo th w al ls ~1 00 –2 00 μm . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 10 0μ m su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar w el ls or te d. 2% li m es to ne bl oc ky ,s ub an gu la r, ~6 00 –2 00 μm ,v po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3, 20 % cl ay 70 % si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 5: 35 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi lm at er ia l w it h la te r w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . H F 09 -2 62 1 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A64 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 21 :2 C on te xt 44 5 (c on t) A rt ef ac ts : 1% fli nt su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky 0. 5c m .1 % bo ne ,p la ty ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), an gu la r, 1m m ;2 00 μm bl oc ky re d- or an ge an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c co at in g to 50 % of al ll ar ge vu gh s an d ch am be rs w it h th ic kn es s < 5μ m to 50 μm .2 ) G ro un dm as s be co m es sa tu ra te d w it h ca lc it e to w ar ds ba se of un it ,l ow er 2– 1. 5c m .F us io n of hy po co at in gs be tw ee n vo id s in th is ar ea .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) M an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,c on ce nt ra te d in ce nt re of fa br ic (u p to 10 % he re ), de nd ri ti c, ~5 00 μm .5 % of sl id e, ca n ge tq ui te de ns e cl us te re d, bu ta ls o fr am bo id s th ro ug ho ut .A ss oc ia te d w it h co ar se m at er ia l. 2) M an ga ne se ca pp in g to so m e vo id s (~ 2% ) li nk ed to ar ea s of de nd ri ti c no du le s fo rm in g ar ou nd vo id s. 3) 10 % ir on no du le s, up to 20 0– 1m m ro un de d, sh ar p to m or e di ff us e, th ro ug ho ut ,r an do m ,p oo rl y so rt ed .P ro ba bl y pe do re li ct s. F ab ri c: 1) C la ye y si lt cr us tf ra gm en ts w el l- ro un de d ~1 % 60 0– 90 0μ m ro un de d, bl oc ky ,n ea r ba se of un it . (s ee ab ov e) 26 21 :3 C on te xt 44 2 T hi ck ne ss : 15 –2 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e St ru ct ur e: M od er at el y to w el l- de ve lo pe d pl at y m ic ro st ru ct ur e co m pl et e co nc re te d by ca lc it e. P or os it y: 30 % .2 8% pl an ar vo id s, ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt ed , w ar pe d in pl ac es fr om ~3 00 μm to ov er 2c m .P oo rl y so rt ed ,e ve nl y di st ri bu te d. 2% ch am be rs – ir re gu la r (l ar ge r pl at y) .I rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh 20 0 de ep –5 00 μm . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar ,b lo ck y 40 –1 00 μm ,w el ls or te d. 5% li m es to ne gr av el ,1 cm to 30 0μ m ,v er y po or ly so rt ed ,r an do m .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am F in e m at er ia l: G re y- br ow n (P P L ), gr ey -b ro w n (X P L ), gr ey (O IL ). b- fa br ic : m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% fli nt ,w el lr ou nd ed ,i ro n st ai ne d, 50 0μ m .1 % sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r, 20 0– 30 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c im pr eg na ti on ,c oa ti ng to al lo f th e pl an ar vo id s, cr ys ta ls 10 –3 0μ m .2 ) T hi ck cr us ts ,~ 15 0μ m ,m ul ti pl e la ye rs of cr ys ta ld ev el op m en t– bo th ne ar li m es to ne at cr ac k at ba se of un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) L ar ge ar ea s of de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 5– 10 % of fa br ic ,g ro un dm as s to o, 0. cm in si ze .2 ) 2% Ir on no du le s, 20 0– 30 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,w el ls or te d, no or ie nt at io n/ di st ri bu ti on . C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi lm at er ia l fo ll ow ed by ex te ns iv e w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er 26 21 :4 C on te xt 49 0 T hi ck ne ss : 50 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y- de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e su pe ri m po se d on m as si ve to ve ry w ea kl y- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e – m or e m as si ve to w ar ds to p of un it .P or os it y: 30 % .1 0% pl an ar vo id s, lo ng ,i nt er co nn ec te d, fr om < 10 μm to 10 0μ m ,m ac ro sc al e pe ds ar e 1- 2c m up w ar ds ,r ou gh w al ls .2 0% sm al li rr eg ul ar vu gh s, co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s – 30 0μ m –2 0μ m ,s m oo th bu ti rr eg ul ar vu gh s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 20 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,4 0– 12 0μ m ,w el l- so rt ed ,e ve n di st ri bu te d, op en po rp hy ri c. 7% li m es to ne gr av el an d ca lc it e 80 0– 20 0μ m ir re gu la r- di ff us e ca lc it e, po or ly so rt ed ,r an do m .G ra ve l1 cm –2 00 μm po or ly so rt ed su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 27 :7 3. Te xt ur e: 25 % cl ay ,5 8% si lt ,1 7% sa nd an d gr av el .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld s (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar co al ce ll st ru ct ur e ~2 00 μm ,h ex ag on al . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,p la ty /i rr eg ul ar ,r ou nd ed ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d 20 0μ m , ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) G en er al fin in g to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it – ar ra ng em en ta tb as e is m or e ch ao ti c. 2) S in gl e in si tu fin in g ne ar th is ce nt re , m uc h m or e si lt y ~2 00 μm th ic k. C ry st al li ti c: 1) A re a w it h si lt y cl ay ca lc it ic sa tu ra ti on of in cr ed ib ly gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e pe ds 60 –8 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d. C om pl et el y in fil le d. 2) A ls o in w id er gr ou nd m as s –t ow ar ds ce nt re of th e un it ,~ 1c m de ep .A ss oc ia te d w it h in cr ea se of ch am be rs an d pl an ar vo id s. H yp oc oa ti ng to la rg e gr av el .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s th ro ug ho ut - fr om ~2 0μ m sm al lt o co nc en tr at io n ar ou nd vo id s in ar ea s of 2m m .2 ) 5% ir on ag gr eg at es up to 0. 5c m ,d ow n to 40 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d 20 –3 0% qu ar tz an d cl ay ey .R an do m di st ri bu ti on . F ab ri c: 1) 1% du ng – pa le si lt ,s po ng y st ru ct ur e 1% 1– 2m m ,w ar pe d, le ns es .B io tu rb at ed ,b lo ck y ph yt ol it hs ,i rr eg ul ar ,d if fu se ,i so tr op ic w it h ca lc it e. 2) 10 2% cr us tf ra gm en ts 50 00 μm –4 00 μm ,w el l- ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar .V er y po or ly -s or te d, th ro ug ho ut bu tc on ce nt ra te d in ce nt re of un it ,q ui te di st ur be d th er e. E xc re m en ta l: L ar ge ar ea to rh s of ba se ,e xc re m en ts ro un d of fa br ic ~0 .5 –1 cm ,s ph er ic al ,o va l, in gr ou nd m as s m of sm al le r, m or e ju m bl ed ca lc it e gr an ul es .C al ci te co m pl et el y im pr eg na te s ev er yt hi ng . C ol lu vi al in w as h of po te nt ia ls oi lm at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A65 1c m 2628:2 2628:1 2628:4 a b 2628:3 2628:62628:5 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 28 :1 C on te xt 49 4 T hi ck ne ss : 8– 12 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y (t hi ck ne ss di ffi cu lt ). P or os it y: 17 % .1 0% vu gh s, 15 0– 80 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -s m oo th w al ls . 5% ch an ne ls 50 0μ m –1 cm ,s m oo th w al le d, el on ga te d, ho ri zo nt al ly –o ri en ta te d an d ve rt ic al so rt ed .~ 2% S om e vo id s jo in ed by pl an ar vo id s, ~6 0– 15 0μ m w id e, cm lo ng ne ar th e lo w er bo un da ry . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd , 50 –1 50 μm ,w el ls or te d ev en ly di st ri bu te d. 10 % su ba ng ul ar to an gu la r li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd an d gr av el ,p oo rl y so rt ed 20 0– 1c m ,d is tr ib ut ed th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am /s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), or an ge -g ol d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : H ar d to se e (t hi ck ) – sp ar it ic ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (< 10 μm ) to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (4 0: 60 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n- cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne su ba ng ul ar pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), ~4 00 μm .1 % pl at y sh el l, an gu la r ~3 00 μm ,w el ls or te d, no or ie nt at io n. 1% fli nt – al lr ou nd ,b lo ck y, 50 0μ m ,w el l- so rt ed P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c co at in gs an d hy po co at in gs to 50 % of vo id s. A m or ph ou s: 1) 1% m an ga ne se st ai ni ng to ca lc it ic co at in gs ,b ro w n- re d 1 or 2 vo id s, sh ar p ed ge s. 2) 2– 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s – up to pa tc he s of 1. 5m m ,o th er s 60 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed .3 ) 5% ir on no du le s, ir re gu la r to ro un d 1– 2m m ,t o 20 0μ m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,m os tl y w el lr ou nd ed .R an do m di st ri bu ti on th ro ug ho ut .F ab ri c: 1) D un g – ye ll ow si lt (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), w el lr ou nd ed , ir re gu la r ~7 00 μm ,p hy to li th s, no sp he ru li te s. C ol lu vi al m ov em en to f po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l ce m en te d by w et ti ng w it h ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er du ri ng an d af te r de po si ti on . 26 28 :2 C on te xt 49 4 T hi ck ne ss : 3c m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y st ru ct ur e – di ct at ed by vo id s. A lm os ts po ng y in lo w er th ir d. P or os it y: 30 % .2 0% vu gh s, co nc en tr at ed in on e or tw o ba nd s – 3m m –1 00 μm ,m od er at e to po or ly so rt ed , ir re gu la r, ir re gu la r/ ro ug h w al ls .1 –2 % ch an ne ls ,r ou nd 30 0μ m ,s m oo th w al le d. 5– 10 % pl an ar vo id s, ho ri zo nt al ,l on g, 10 0– 20 0μ m w id e, as so ci at ed w it h la ye rs of m or e vu gh yn es s – in te rc on ne ct in g. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,5 0– 12 0μ m bl oc ky , th ro ug ho ut ,b ut al so so m e le ns es .1 0% li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd an d gr av el –1 .5 cm th ro ug ho ut – lo w es ti s 25 0μ m ,p oo r so rt in g an d or ie nt at io n. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay , 65 % si lt ,2 0% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld s (X P L ), re d- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% bl oc ky ,c el ls tr uc tu re 60 0– 80 0μ m ,b la ck -r ed ,h um ifi ed ,r ou nd ed .< 1% L en se s of si li ci fie d pl an tr em ai ns – ph yt ol it hs on ly ,a rt ic ul at ed ,a bo ut 1m m lo ng . A rt ef ac ts : 1% sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r 25 0– 80 0μ m ,n o di st /o ri en ta ti on . P un ct ua te d co ll uv ia l/ ae ol ia n re w or ki ng of po te nt ia la eo li an m at er ia l af te r in it ia lh ig he r en er gy co ll uv ia ti on .. H F 09 -2 62 8 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A66 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 28 :2 C on te xt 49 4 (c on t.) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L am in at io ns in fin er m at er ia l, vi si bl e at m ac ro an d co lo ur ,b ut v th in co ar se sa nd ho ri zo nt al st ra nd s ~8 0μ m sa nd . A tt op ne ar co nt ac t– v fin e bu td is ti nc tl am in at io ns .2 ) V er y de gr ad ed si lt y cl ay in fil li ng 4m m ,c ra ck ed ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .3 ) M ic ro cr us ts at ba se of un it an d bo un da ry w it h un de rl yi ng un it – cl ay ey an d re d, 1– 2m m lo ng .C ry st al li ne : 1) C al ci ti c hy po co at in gs to so m e vo id s – br ea kd ow n of te n, cr us ty ,m ay be li nk ed to ch an ne ls an d di st ur ba nc e. A m or ph ou s aa nd cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s – 50 0μ m –1 m m ,5 % of sl id e, st ub by ,a ls o la m in at e. 2) 10 % m an ga ne se co at in g of vo id s – bl ac k- re d fr am bo id s ~5 0μ m .3 ) 5% ir on -i m pr eg na te d ag gr eg at es 75 :2 5 sh ar p: ir re gu la r 20 0μ m –3 m m .4 ) 1% ir on no du le s ir re gu la r, so m e al so as so sc ia te d w it h m an ga ne se (1 /3 ). F ab ri c: 1) 5% D un g – va ri es fr om ve ry bl oc ky an d sh ar p, ye ll ow w it h cr ac ks ,s il ta nd ph yt ol it hs .1 /5 sp he ru li te s, bl oc ky ,i rr eg ul ar 45 0μ m –2 m m . (s ee ab ov e) 26 28 :3 C on te xt 49 5 T hi ck ne ss :2 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to w ea kl y su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% pl an ar vo id s m m + sc al e, sm oo th to ro ug h w al ls ,w el la cc om m od at ed 60 - 25 0μ m w id e, ho ri zo nt al m ai nl y bu ts om e ar e ve rt ic al .5 % vu gh s, ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al le d, 30 0– 50 0μ m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d fin e sa nd ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,6 0– 15 0μ m ,t hr ou gh ou t. 15 % li m es to ne gr av el an d sa nd , 20 0μ m –2 m m ,s ub an gu la r- su br ou nd ed bl oc ky -i rr eg ul ar .C F li m it : 60 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m / sa nd y si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (5 0: 50 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne ,s ub ro un de d pl at y, 20 0– 15 00 μm ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ) - st ri ng er fr ag m en ta ti on .2 % sh el l, pl at y, 40 0– 60 0μ m , su ba ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) G en er al ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to fin e m at er ia l. A m or ph ou s an d C ry pt oc ry st al li ne : 1) P ho sp ha ti c no du le ,s ub an gu la r, 25 0μ m ,y el lo w (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), du ll ye ll ow -o ra ng e (O IL ), m an ga ne se hy po co at in g. 2) 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s an d di ff us e hy po co at in gs to vo id s. 15 0μ m de ep .3 ) 2% ir on no du le s, di ff us e to cl ea r bo un da ri es ,2 00 –8 00 μm ,s om e el on ga te d as al m os ts tr in ge rs ne ar to p of un it bo un da ry .4 ) 5% P ed or el ic ts ,3 00 –5 00 μm ,w el l- ro un de d, qu ar tz ri ch an d fa r m or e ir on th an su rr ou nd in g ar ea s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es , w it h sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng . 26 28 :4 C on te xt 49 5 T hi ck ne ss : 35 m m ov er tw o sl id es .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: W ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e 60 –1 50 μm is gr an ul ar .P or os it y: 25 % .V ug hs 20 % ir re gu la r, w ea k m od ac co m m od at in g, ~1 00 –2 00 μm ,l on ge r se t( 5% of th is ) – 40 0μ m –1 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,b lo ck y, el on ga te d. < 5% L ar ge pl an ar vo id s, ac ro ss to p of un it an d th ro ug ho ut .R ou gh w al ls ,w el la cc om m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,4 0– 10 0μ m ,w el ls or te d, th ro ug ho ut .1 0% li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el 0. 5c m –4 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,p oo r so rt in g. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 20 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt , 20 % gr av el an d sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% 20 0μ m bo ne ,v er y pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow s an d gr ey s (X P L ). 1% sh el lp la ty an gu la r, ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) S il ty ca pp in gs to co ar se m at er ia la nd le ns es ,t hr ou gh ou t, ra nd om – as so ci at ed w it h an d w it ho ut du ng .2 00 –4 00 μm lo ng & 10 0μ m th ic k w el ls or te d. 2) C oa rs e, di st ur be d ar ea ,t op ri gh t. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 3) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s in gr ou nd m as s, 10 0μ m .F ab ri c: 1) 5% cr us tf ra gm en ts 20 0μ m –0 .5 cm su ba ng ul ar ,w el l- ro un de d th ro ug ho ut re dd is h, si lt y cl ay .1 0% in pl ac es ,v ar yi ng de gr ee s of co ar se ne ss – 2% qu it e si lt y/ fin e sa nd .M ul ti pl e an d si ng le la ye rs w it hi n al ls iz e cl as se s, 1% w it h in te rn al vu gh s or m an ga ne se st ai ni ng .2 ) 3% D un g – ye ll ow pa le si lt (P P L ) w it h ph yt ol it hs ,1 0μ m sp he ru li te s, is ot ro pi c. Ir re gu la r to le nt ic ul ar ,w ar pe d, ~5 00 μm an d 1m m ac ro ss . In it ia lc ol lu vi al m ov em en t fo ll ow ed by pu nc tu at ed po te nt ia la eo li an de po si ti on an d sm al l- sc al e co ll uv ia l re w or ki ng . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A67 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 28 :5 C on te xt 49 6 T hi ck ne ss : 20 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V er y w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e pe ds ~5 0μ m –1 00 μm ,m as si ve in pl ac es ,a pp ea rs to be co nc re ti on by ca lc it e – vu gh y if no tt ak en in to ac co un tc al ci te .P or os it y: 10 % vu gh s of to ta l1 00 –3 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt an d sa nd ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,5 0– 10 0μ m ,r an do m ,b lo ck y th ro ug ho ut .1 0% li m es to ne gr av el 50 0μ m –0 .5 cm .S ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar .E ve nl y di st ri bu te d th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: no ne . A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r 1m m –2 00 μm ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) M or e cr ys ta ll it ic to ba se of un it ,c om es to m at ch cr ys ta ll in it y of 26 28 :6 ,b ut un de rl yi ng m at er ia li s de ns er th an be lo w .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s –5 00 μm ,2 % of sl id e, de nd ri ti c, eq ua ld is t. 2) Ir on no du le s 2% ~m od er at el y so rt ed ~2 50 μm ,s ha rp to m od er at el y di ff us e ed ge s, al ls ha de s of re d- br ow n, ro un de d to w el lr ou nd ed .F ab ri c: 1) D un g: pa le br ow n gr ey si lt lo ng ho ri zo nt al le ns es ~1 cm lo ng 20 0μ m w it h ph yt ol it hs .A ls o in pa le r ye ll ow m or e ir re gu la r bl oc ks .5 00 μm –2 m m , sp he ru li te s, ir re gu la r sp he ru li te s in gr ou nd m as s to o. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on on w it h ep he m er al su rf ac es .W et te d by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er .P ud dl in g of ca lc it e at ba se ei th er du ri ng or po st -d ep os it io n. 26 28 :6 C on te xt 49 6 T hi ck ne ss : 50 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : no ne . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy ,r es ul to f v w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e 60 –1 20 μm .P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s 1m m –2 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ro ug h w al ls to ve ge ta l. (i nc 7% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s in m or e m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e) .5 % P la na r vo id s – sh or ti nt er co nn ec ti ng th e vo id s ~3 0μ m th ic k (a ll a co nt in uu m ). C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % of qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,e ve n di st ri bu ti on ,5 0– 12 0μ m .5 % li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el ,p oo rl y so rt ed 4m m –4 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky .S li gh th or iz on ta lo ri en ta ti on .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n– or an ge (P P L ), re dd is h- go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: no ne A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el lp la ty an gu la r, no or ie nt at io n or di st ri bu ti on 6m m –4 00 μm ,g re y- pa st el . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C oa rs er to w ar ds to p of un it .2 ) W it hi n- fa br ic si lt y co at in gs ,f us io n be tw ee n ag gr eg at es an d co ar se m at er ia l. 3) S tr on ge r ho ri zo nt al ly -o ri en ta te d co m po ne nt to co ar se m at er ia la tt op of un it .C ry st al li ne : 1) < 1% C al ci ti c in fil li ng to bi ot ur ba te d ar ea – co m pl et e gr ou nd m as s, ve ry sp on gy st ru ct ur e. 2) 1% ve ry ra re m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs to vo id s 1% .A m or ph ou s: 1) 2% m an ga ne se th ro ug ho ut in de nd ri ti c no du le s ~2 50 μm ac ro ss .F ab ri c: 1) 5- 2% du ng – la m in at ed w it h se di m en ts in pl ac es le ns es 1. 5m m ,s ph er ul it es , ph yt ol it hs an d pa le ye ll ow .A ls o bl oc ky ir re gu la r, ro un de d to co m pl et el y di ff us e 20 :8 0, al lq ui te br ok en do w n, .2 ) 1% S il ty cl ay fr ag m en ts 75 0μ m w el lr ou nd ed ,b lo ck y th ro ug ho ut .3 ) 2% ir on im pr eg na te d se di m en ta gg re ga te s/ pe do re li ct s 80 μm –1 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed ,r ou nd ,v er y di st in ct bo un da ri es ,v eg et al vo id s an d m os ai c to st ri at ed gr ou nd m as s. P ot en ti al ae ol ia n- do m in at ed de po si ti on ,w it h so m e lo ca l co ll uv ia l, da m p re w or ki ng at th e ba se of th e un it .S lo w in g of de po si ti on to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it .. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A68 1c m 2663:1 2663:2 2663:3 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 63 :1 C on te xt 50 9 T hi ck ne ss : 35 –4 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, ro ug h to sm oo th su bs ph er oi da lp ed s (6 0– 80 μm ), 80 % to vu gh y st ru ct ur e 20 % ir re gu la r, cl us te re d, ra nd om di st ri bu ti on .P or os it y: 40 % .3 0% (u p to 40 ) co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, ir re gu la r. 10 % ch an ne ls an d vu gh s, ro ug h to sm oo th w al ls ,i rr eg ul ar to ro un de d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 20 % qu ar tz 50 –1 20 μm ,b lo ck y, su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar , w el ls or te d, in so m e ar ea s up to 40 % gr ou pi ng ,b ut on ly sl ig ht .2 5% li m es to ne fr ag m en ts 10 0μ m –2 cm ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .V er y po or ly so rt ed . C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 45 :5 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,3 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n to cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar co al ,c el ls tr uc tu re ,3 00 μm ,b lo ck y, fr ag m en te d. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,b lo ck y, pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d 40 0– 65 0μ m ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar , ir re gu la r. < 1% fli nt ,r ou nd ed ,s m oo th 50 0μ m .< 1% sh el l, bl oc ky ,2 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 1% si lt y li nk ca pp in gs ,1 or 2c m lo ng ,2 le ns es ~2 0μ m , ac ro ss ag gr eg at es ,d ia go na lo ri en ta ti on .2 ) < 1% si lt y cl ay ca pp in gs to so m e co ar se fr ag m en ts .3 ) L en se s to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it 75 0μ m th ic k, m ed iu m sa nd w el lr ou nd ed co ar se ni ng .C ry st al li ne : 1) 2% ca lc it ic in fil li ng s an d hy po co at in gs to vo id s – vu gh s, w it h m ic ro ag gr eg at es fil li ng sp ac e 5% ,s om e fr ag m en te d re de po si te d. C om pl et el y im pr eg na te ar ou nd th e vo id s to o, th ic k. 2) < 1% la rg e ra di al sp he ru le s, 20 0– 30 0μ m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) < 2% m an ga ne se ve ry sm al ld en dr it ic no du le s 20 0μ m .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s or pe do re li ct s or bu rn ta gg re ga te s, 10 0– 20 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,m or e w it h m an ga ne se ,s ha rp bo un da ry an d co ar se r, ra nd om di st ri bu ti on ,p oo rl y so rt ed .F ab ri c: 1) < 1% ve si cu la r si li ca ,g re y (P P L ) is ot ro pi c (X P L ) 40 0– 60 0μ m ,r ou nd ed . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. B io tu rb at io n. 26 63 :2 C on te xt 50 9 T hi ck ne ss : 5– 10 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to w ea kl y vu gh y. P or os it y: 10 % ,v ug hs 10 0– 20 0μ m ,s m oo th to ro ug h w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,w el ls or te d. 10 % li m es to ne fin e to fin e gr av el 10 0– 20 00 μm ,m od er at el y so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- pa le br ow n (P P L ), bl ot ch es of re d an d ye ll ow to in di ff er en ti at ed (X P L ), du ll or an ge to br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 10 % m ix tu re of ch ar re d an d hu m ifi ed or ga ni c m at er ia l2 00 -5 00 μm , am or ph ou s ce ll st ru ct ur e, ra gg ed ed ge s, bl oc ky . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,2 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d, pa le ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ). O cc up at io n la ye r. H F 09 -2 66 3 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A69 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 26 63 :2 C on te xt 50 9 (c on t) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 5% br ig ht or an ge du st y cl ay in fil li ng s in ar ea ar ou nd cu to f bu rr ow 2) 5% re dd is h si lt y cl ay co at in gs in fil li ng vo id s co m pl et el y th ro ug ho ut ,c .2 50 –4 00 μm .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) M an ga ne se an d am or ph ou s or ga ni c in la ye r 5% of gr ou nd m as s st ai ni ng 10 0μ m ,a ss oc ia te d w it h or ga ni c. F ab ri c: 1) 2% ro un de d ag gr eg at e of ve si cu la r si li ca an d qu ar tz gr ai ns ,i so tr op ic , ro un d, w el lr ou nd ed ,7 00 μm . (s ee ab ov e) 26 63 :3 C on te xt 51 3 T hi ck ne ss : 35 –5 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy w it h ar ea s of w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e (2 0% ). P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 50 –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar sm oo th w al ls ,a nd ch am be rs < 5% .5 % pl an ar vo id s 50 –1 00 μm w id e, cm lo ng ,i nt er co nn ec te d, sm oo th -w al le d, w el l ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,m od er at el y so rt ed ,s om e ro ug h cl us te rs or le ns es ; 25 % li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd 60 μm –3 cm ,s ub an gu la r to ro un de d, bl oc ky ,v er y po or ly so rt ed .S om e w it h st al ag m it e at ta ch ed .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 35 :6 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 0% si lt 30 % sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: L ig ht br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to cr ys ta ll it ic (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% si li ci fie d pl an ts tr uc tu re w it h hu m ic /m an ga ne se hy po co at in g, 30 0μ m ,b lo ck y. A rt ef ac ts : < 1% bo ne ,1 00 –5 00 μm ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey -y el lo w (X P L ) ir re gu la r, ca lc it ic co ve ri ng s. < 1% sh el l, 30 0μ m ro un de d, pl at y ho ri zo nt al . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% or an ge cl ay co at in gs to vo id s at th e to p of th e un it ,v er y pu re in 20 % of pl ac es .L oc al is ed .2 ) B ec om es m or e m as si ve to w ar ds 1- 2c m of un it .C ry st al li ne : 1) V er y ra re sp he ru le s 10 0μ m – st ar sh ap ed to o – 7. 2) < 1% ca lc it ic co at in gs to pi ec e of st al ag m it e, si lt y, 10 0μ m th ic k. 3) 2% m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs an d in fil li ng s to vo id s. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% ir on no du le ,r ed to da rk re d, w el l- ro un de d 20 0– 80 0μ m th ro ug ho ut .F ab ri c: 1) 3% du ng .P al e si lt sp on gy ar ea s, ~1 m m di ff us e, ph yt ol it hs an d so m e sp he ru li te s, ve ry de gr ad ed .2 ) 2% cr us tf ra gm en ts or in fil li ng s up to 2c m bl oc ky ,r ou nd ed ,r an do m di st ri bu ti on .M ul ti pl e la ye rs w it hi n. 3) 2% ve si cu la r si li ca ,c el lr ou nd ed ,v es ic ul ar to ir re gu la r, 20 0– 80 0μ m ,g re y (P P L ) is ot ro pi c (X P L ) w it h qu ar tz in cl us io ns . P ot en ti al ae ol ia n de po si ti on an d re w or ki ng ,a nd re w or ki ng of oc cu pa ti on m at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A70 1c m 2666:1 2666:3 2666:2 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 26 66 :1 C on te xt 51 7 T hi ck ne ss : 47 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 30 0– 30 0μ m ,l ar ge r to w ar ds to p of un it ,5 % ps eu do m or ph ic of pl an t m at er ia lw it h si lt y co at in gs .5 % pl an ar vo id s in te rc on ne ct in g th e ch am be rs 40 –2 50 μm w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd 50 –1 20 μm ,a ng ul ar ,b lo ck y. 20 % li m es to ne gr av el an d co ar se sa nd 10 0μ m –1 cm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky , in cr ea si ng to to p. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,2 5% sa nd . S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w –b ro w n (P P L ) ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ) at to p. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c to cl os e po rp hy ri c at to p of m ic ro -f ab ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1% bl oc ky ch ar re d to hu m ifi ed or ga ni c m at te r w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, ir re gu la r an d di ff us e 50 0– 80 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 2– 5% bu rn tb on e, su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky 30 0μ m –1 cm ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d w it h m an ga ne se st ai ni ng ,o ra ng e- re d (P P L ), ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% S il ty co at in g to ve ge ta lv oi ds an d so m e ot he r co ar se co m po ne nt s. 20 μm de ep .C ry st al li ti c: 1) 1% L ar ge ra di al sp he ru le s 10 0μ m ,r ou nd ed to ja gg ed ed ge s 20 0μ m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 1% m an ga ne se co at in g an d hy po co at in g to vo id 15 0μ m th ic k. 2) 5% ir on no du le s ro un de d to bl oc ky ,w el l- ro un de d, 20 0– 20 00 μm .F ab ri c: 1) < 1% ve ry w el l- ro un de d bl oc ky cr us tf ra gm en ts 75 0μ m .2 ) 10 % du ng ,p al e or an ge -y el lo w bl oc ks an d le ns es w it h a sp on gy st ru ct ur e, ph yt ol it hs ,a nd fe w sp he ru li te s. P un cu ta te d po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on on ep he m er al su rf ac es , w it h in cr ea se in ph ys ic al w ea th er in g to to p of un it an d bi ot ur ba ti on . 26 66 :2 C on te xt 51 7 T hi ck ne ss : 10 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y/ ve ry w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 0% vu gh s, ir re gu la r, ro ug h w al le d, of w hi ch 3% ve ge ta lp se ud om or ph ic vo id s, sm oo th w al le d. 5% pl an ar vo id s, li nk in g vu gh s in pl ac es .1 00 μm –1 m m w id e, w el l ac co m m od at ed ,m od er at el y sm oo th w al le d. M in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz co ar se si lt to fin e sa nd 50 –1 20 μm ,a ng ul ar ,b lo ck y. 5% li m es to ne gr av el an d co ar se sa nd 10 0μ m –1 cm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,p oo rl y so rt ed . C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,8 0% si lt ,1 0% sa nd si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: Y el lo w -b ro w n (P P L ) gr ey an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar re d bl oc ky fr ag m en ts w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, 80 –1 00 μm . A rt ef ac ts : < 1% fli nt ,b lo ck y, su br ou nd ed ,4 00 μm .1 % bo ne sp li nt er s, an gu la r, ir re gu la r, 25 0– 30 0μ m ,y el lo w (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ). P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 2% ar ra ng em en to f fin e m at er ia li nt o ps eu do m or ph s of sp on gy du ng st ru ct ur e, 1– 2m m lo ng .C ry st al li ne : 2% ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs to ci rc ul ar vo id s, up to 20 0μ m th ic k. F ab ri c: 5% D un g fr ag m en ts ,b lo ck y, di ff us e- cl ea r ed ge s 20 0– 80 0μ m ,o ri en ta ti on ra nd om . R ap id po te nt ia ll y ae ol ia n de po si ti on w it h la te r w et ti ng by ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er an d bi ot ur ba ti on , po te nt ia ll y in di ca ti ng a pe ri od of ex po su re . H F 09 -2 66 6 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A71 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 26 66 :3 C on te xt 52 0 T hi ck ne ss : 15 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y ov er ly in g a w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar st ru ct ur e 10 0μ m – w el ld ev el op ed in pl ac es (2 0% ). G ra nu la r to ri gh t ha nd si de of sl id e, ve ry br ok en up ,e na ul ic di st ri bu ti on .P or os it y: 10 % .8 % vu gh s, co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s an d ch am be rs ar ou nd in ci pi en t pe ds 50 –2 00 μm ,s ta r- sh ap ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -s m oo th w al ls .2 % cr ac ks ac ro ss th e en ti re se ct io n, w el l- ac co m m od at ed ,5 0– 10 0μ m w id e, ro ug h- w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r- su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,w el l- so rt ed 50 –1 00 μm .3 0% li m es to ne su br ou nd ed -a ng ul ar ,v er y po or ly so rt ed 10 0– 40 00 μm .V ar yi ng de gr ee s of de gr ad at io n. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,5 % si lt ,3 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ) or an ge s an d ye ll ow s (o ra ng e go ld to ye ll ow ) (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d an d m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en to cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: < 1% ch ar re d to hu m ifi ed bl oc ky m at er ia lw it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, 20 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 5% sh el l, pl at y, an gu la r, 12 00 μm ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .1 % bo ne 25 0– 20 00 μm ,a ng ul ar pl at y ye ll ow (P P L ) ye ll ow -g re y (X P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. < 1% fli nt ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,m an ga ne se st ai ni ng in pl ac es ,1 20 0– 30 00 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) O ve ra ll fin in g up fr om th e ba se to < 10 % co ar se m at er ia la tt he to p. C ry st al li ne : 1) < 1% la rg e sp he ru le s 12 0μ m , ro un de d, ra di al .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s1 00 0μ m an d 10 μm fr am bo id s in fil li ng vo id s N ot as so ci at ed w it h ir on st ai ni ng .2 ) < 1% ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, sh ar p to sl ig ht ly di ff us e. E xc re m en ta l: 1) A re a of gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e to le ft of sl id e. 2) 1 bu rr ow 1– 2c m ,d is ag gr eg at ed in th e ce nt re ,g ra nu la r. U pp er pa rt of in w as h ev en t, he av il y w ea th er ed an d po te nt ia ll y re w or ke d, in cl ud in g th ro ug h bi ot ur ba ti on . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A72 10 52 :1 10 52 :2 10 52 :3 10 52 :4 10 52 :5 10 52 :6 10 52 :7 10 52 :8 1c m M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 52 :1 T hi ck ne ss : 5– 15 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s, 10 0– 60 0μ m ,r ou gh -w al le d, ir re gu la r, so m e el on ga te d (v eg et al ?) .5 % pl an ar vo id s, w el la cc om m od at ed fr om 10 μm to 15 0μ m ,c ra ck s ac ro ss th e se ct io n. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz ,4 0– 15 0μ m ,b lo ck y an gu la r to su ba ng ul ar ,r ou nd ed .2 0% li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed 15 0μ m –2 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 30 :7 0 Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,6 5% si lt ,2 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e– br ow n (P P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% bl oc ky ch ar re d/ hu m ifi ed m at er ia l, po te nt ia ls ee d ca se , 20 0μ m -1 m m ,r ed di sh ti ng e, ce ll st ru ct ur e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ~7 00 μm bl oc ky . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) O ra ng e cl ay co at in g to lo ng pl an ar vo id w hi ch m ar ks ba se of th e un it .A m or ph ou s: 1) 13 % pe do re li ct s/ re de po si te d/ bu rn ta gg re ga te s, sh ar p bo un da ri es an d w el l- ro un de d, 10 0μ m –1 m m .2 ) 2% ir re gu la r ir on no du le s w it h di ff us e ed ge s, 10 0μ m –1 m m ,r ou nd .2 ) 5% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s, ~3 00 μm ,a ss oc ia te d w it h co ar se m at er ia li nc lu di ng ir on no du le s. F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng le ns es ,v er y pa le gr ey si lt (P P L ) w it h ph yt ol it hs ,~ 1m m ve ry di ff us e, br ok en .2 ) 5% V es ic ul ar si li ca ,~ 30 0μ m w el l- ro un de d, w el ld ev el op ed ve si cu la r st ru ct ur e to m or e di ff us e, sl ig ht ly as hy le ss de ve lo pe d st ru ct ur e. D ry co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng of co m bu st io n m at er ia l an d ae ol ia n se di m en ta ti on . B io tu rb at ed . 10 52 :2 T hi ck ne ss : 22 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m as si ve .P or os it y: 10 % .8 % vu gh s, 60 –2 00 μm ,r ou gh to sm oo th w al ls , ir re gu la r. 2% pl an ar vo id s, lo ng ,c m sc al e cr ac ks do w n to 1m m x1 0μ m .S m al l vo id s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,b lo ck y, 50 –2 00 μm ,t hr ou gh ou t. 15 % li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd ,1 m m –1 00 μm , su br ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 22 :7 8. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay , 78 % si lt ,1 7% sa nd an d gr av el ,s il tl oa m . F in e M at er ia l: O ra ng e- br ow n (P P L ), gr ey -o ra ng e (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d to m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: no ne – as hy /v es ic ul ar si li ca bl oc ks ,l ar ge ,2 –3 cm ac ro ss , le ns .I ro n- im pr eg na te d in pl ac es . D ry co ll uv ia lr ew or ki ng of co m bu st io n m at er ia la nd ae ol ia n se di m en ta ti on . H F 08 -1 05 2 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A73 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 10 52 :2 A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,b lo ck y, 50 00 μm ,y el lo w (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ). 1% fli nt ,1 00 μm –1 m m ,c la y co at in g, bl oc ky ,s ub ro un de d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) O ra ng e cl ay co at in g to lo ng pl an ar vo id ,c on ti nu es fr om F 1 ab ov e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 30 0– 40 0μ m ac ro ss ,a ro un d co ar se m at er ia l. F ab ri c: 1) 10 % ve si cu la r si li ca ag gr eg at es ,4 00 μm –1 m m .2 ) 20 % A sh ch un ks ,m ic ri ti c to sp ar it ic ,i rr eg ul ar le ns es an d bl oc k, 1– 10 m m -1 .3 ) L en s of ph yt ol it hs at lo w er bo un da ry ;p al e gr ey -y el lo w si lt (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), ph yt ol it hs ,o nl y m in er al fr ac ti on re m ai ni ng .4 ) P ed or el ic ts 7% w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p, 20 0μ m –1 m m . (s ee ab ov e) 10 52 :3 T hi ck ne ss : 2– 4m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m ic ro ag gr eg at e, de fin ed by as h/ pl an ts tr uc tu re .P or os it y: 15 % .1 3% vu gh s, 60 –1 50 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 2% pl an ar vo id s, 10 μm w id e, ir re gu la r ~5 00 μm . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut (1 % fe ld sp ar ). C F li m it : 50 μm C F ra ti o: 10 :9 0 Te xt ur e: 95 % si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: G re y (P P L ), ye ll ow -g re y to is ot ro pi c (X P L ) gr ey -w hi te to ye ll ow (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed (5 0: 50 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic s: 15 % ca lc ifi ed pl an tm at er ia l, bl oc ky ,r ou gh -e dg ed to w el l- ro un de d ~4 00 μm -1 .5 m m .A sh m ak es up th e en ti re fa br ic . A rt ef ac ts : N on e. P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s: 1) 3% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 10 0μ m ,t hr ou gh ou t, sl ig ht ly m or e am or ph ou s st ai ni ng .F ab ri c: 1) < 1% P al e si lt y br ow n sp on gy du ng ,2 m m ,w el lr ou nd ed .2 ) 5% ro un de d ve si cu la r si li ca ag gr eg at es 20 0– 50 0μ m . W oo d as h 10 52 :4 T hi ck ne ss : 2– 7m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to sp on gy .P or os it y: 25 % .V ug hs ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th to ro ug h w al le d, el on ga te d (a lm os tp la na r in pl ac es ). 50 μm to 40 0μ m . In te rc on ne ct ed in pl ac es . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz 50 –2 00 μm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 Te xt ur e: S il tl oa m . O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : N on e. F in e m at er ia l: G re y- or an ge (P P L ), gr ey s to or an ge -r ed (X P L ), gr ey -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) L ar ge ca lc it ic in cl us io n, 3m m ,r ou nd ed ,b lo ck y. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% ir on st ai ni ng of sp on gy ar ea s 2) 10 % ir on no du le s, cl ea r bo un da ri es ,5 00 –3 00 μm ,w el l- ro un de d. F ab ri c: 1) M ix in g to w ar ds ba se of un it w it h un de rl yi ng un it . Ir on -s ta in ed as h, po te nt ia ll y w et te d. 10 52 :5 T hi ck ne ss : 9– 20 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m as si ve .P or os it y: 10 % .V ug hs ,5 0– 15 0μ m .i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 50 μm –5 00 μm (< 1% is > 15 0μ m la rg e) .1 0% li m es to ne ch un ks 2. 5– 1. 5c m ,s ub an gu la r to bl oc ky . C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 25 :7 5. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,8 5% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e gr ey (P P L ), ye ll ow gr ey (X P L ), gr ey -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed (8 0: 20 ). O rg an ic m at er ia l: C al ci ti c pl an tr em ai ns ~3 % ve ry he av il y ca lc ifi ed ,b re ak in g do w n. A sh in gr ou nd m as s. A rt ef ac ts : N on e. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) F in er in te xt ur e to w ar ds th e ba se ,i nt er le av ed w it h ph yt ol it hs le ns es .C ry st al li ne : 1) C oa ti ng to li m es to ne la rg e, bl ac k, ca lc it ic ,s pa ri ti c up to 1. 5m m th ic k, la m in at ed .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s 15 0– 50 0μ m , th ro ug ho ut .F ab ri c: 1) S in gl e la rg e fr ag m en to f cl ay ey si lt re dd en ed se di m en tw it h ve ge ta lv oi ds ,1 .3 cm ,w el l– ro un de d. 2) 1% in ci pi en t ve si cu la r si li ca ,m or e de ns e sp on gy as h, w el l- ro un de d, 70 0μ m .2 ) 5% pe do re li ct s, 50 μm –1 m m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,r ou nd to bl oc ky . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed an d bi ot ur ba te d as h m at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A74 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 10 52 :6 T hi ck ne ss : 4- 6m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,c le ar . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve .P or os it y: 7% vu gh s, 5- 10 % to p to ba se ,1 00 μm -2 50 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz ,8 0- 15 0μ m su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut ,l es s to w ar ds th e to p. 2% li m es to ne m ed iu m sa nd ~3 00 0μ m -5 00 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 80 μm .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .T ex tu re : 3% cl ay ,9 0% si lt ,7 % sa nd ,s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: V er y pa le br ow n- or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow -u nd if fe re nt ia te d (X P L ), du ll gr ey -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : cr ys ta ll it ic to un di ff er en ti at ed 60 :4 0. O rg an ic s: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : N on e. P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) 10 % m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic hy po co at in gs an d co m pl et e in fil li ng s of vo id s 40 0- 70 0μ m ,r ou nd ,d if fu se to ir re gu la r. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 7% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s co nc en tr at ed to w ar ds th e ba se of th e un it ,4 00 -6 00 μm in gr ou nd m as s, no th yp o. 2) 5% ir on no du le s an d pe do re li ct s 10 0- 40 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p, bl oc ky .F ab ri c: 1) ph yt ol it hs le ns es ,3 cm x 1m m ,a lm os ta ll 50 % of fa br ic ,a rt ic ul at ed ce ll st ru ct ur e in pl ac es ,i nc re as es in si ze an d th ic kn es s to w ar ds to p. 2) 10 % du ng ,s po ng y br ow n si lt fr ag m en ts to ar ea s of gr ey is h sp on gi ne ss .6 00 μm -1 m m ,b lo ck y, su br ou nd ed ,i rr eg ul ar . S il ic ac eo us re si du e fr om ve ry he av il y w ea th er ed as h. 10 52 :7 T hi ck ne ss : 7m m .L ow er bo un da ry :D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m ic ro ag gr eg at e gr an ul ar w ea kl y de ve lo pe d. P or os it y: 20 % .2 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 10 0- 50 0μ m ,r ou gh -w al le d, st ar t- sh ap ed .2 % pl an ar vo id s ac ro ss sl id e, sm oo th w al le d. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 -1 50 μm ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,1 % fe ld sp ar ,c on ce nt ra te d in le ns es in pl ac es .2 % li m es to ne 60 0- 80 0μ m ,b lo ck y, su ba ng ul ar .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 12 :8 8. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,9 0% si lt ,5 % sa nd ,s il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n- gr ey (P P L ) is ot ro pi c/ or an ge -r ed s (X P L ), du ll or an ge an d gr ey st re ak s (O IL ). b- fa br ic : un di ff er en ti at ed to st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed (9 0: 10 ). O rg an ic s: 7% sm al lfi br ou s 60 -1 00 μm bl oc ky fr ag m en ts ,c ha rr ed ,l on g st ri ng er s to o, ho ri zo nt al la m in at io ns .C on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds to p of th e un it . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne ,a tl ow er su rf ac e, ye ll ow (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, 15 0μ m -1 m m ,s ub an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ir on no du le s or pe do re li ct s, 10 0- 70 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d, sl ig ht ly di ff us e. F ab ri c: 1) 10 % du ng le ns es 1- 1. 5m m ,~ 15 0μ m th ic k, pa le ye ll ow -b ro w n si lt (P P L ) an d ph yt ol it hs . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed as h an d bu rn in g m at er ia l. 10 52 :8 T hi ck ne ss : 12 -1 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to vu gh y. P or os it y: 10 % .8 % vu gh s, ir re gu la r 50 -2 00 μm ,r ou gh -w al le d. 2% pl an ar vo id s, 30 -5 00 μm ,i nt er co nn ec ti ng vu gh s et c, m od er at el y sm oo th w al ls to la rg er -s m al le r ro ug h w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to an gu la r 50 -1 50 μm ,t hr ou gh ou t, ev en di st ri bu ti on .7 % li m es to ne gr av el 10 0μ m -3 m m , su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,s li gh tl y ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 14 :8 6. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 0% sa nd an d gr av el si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n to re d- br ow n (P P L ) un di ff er en ti at ed to re d- ye ll ow (X P L ), da rk br ow n to da rk du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to un di ff er en ti at ed 60 :4 0. O rg an ic s: M at er ia ls ta in ed br ow n, 2% bl oc ks of ch ar re d or ga ni cs 30 -1 00 μm . A rt ef ac ts : 2% sh el l, 4m m -4 m m ,p la ty ,a ng ul ar ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt at ed ,1 % bo ne ,2 50 μm ,p la ty ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), fr ag m en te d in si tu to sm al le r fr ag m en ts .< 1% bu rn t. 5% pa rt ia ll y di ss ol ve d bo ne ,o ra ng e- ye ll ow (P P L ), is ot ro pi c (X P L ) ir re gu la r to su ba ng ul ar /s ub ro un de d, co nc en tr at ed to bo tt om 2/ 3 of un it . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) 2 or 3 sp he ru le s 15 0μ m ,r ou nd ,r ad ia l, w el l- ro un de d. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s ~4 00 μm ,1 0% th ro ug ho ut 2) 5% pe do re li ct s 5% 20 0μ m -2 m m ,w el l- ro un de d, bl oc ky .F ab ri c: 1) 10 % du ng ,l en se s at ba se , an d fr ag m en ts to to p. L en se s 10 m m ,1 00 μm th ic k, qu it e pa le ,e lo ng at ed ,s ph er ul it es . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed lo w er pa rt of bu rn in g ev en to n un co ns ol id at ed su rf ac e. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A75 20 15 :2 20 15 :5 20 15 :6 20 15 :1 20 15 :3 20 15 :4 20 15 :7 1c m M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on In te rp re ta ti on 20 15 :1 T hi ck ne ss : 20 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 10 0– 50 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 10 % co m pl ex pa ck in g vo id s, li ke in te rc on ne ct ed vu gh s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz ,5 0– 15 0μ m ,a ng ul ar to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .1 0% li m es to ne 10 0μ m –2 m m ,p oo rl y so rt ed .C F li m it : 50 μm ,C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,7 0% si lt ,1 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n- or an ge (P P L ), ye ll ow an d re d (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 17 % ca rb on is ed /p ar ti al ly ca rb on is ed or ga ni c m at er ia li n va ry in g sh ap es fr om si lt -s iz ed to 0. 5m m ,s om e ho ri zo nt al ly or ie nt at ed ,w ar pe d. A re a of le ns in g to le ft of sl id e. B lo ck y, ir re gu la r, ce ll st ru ct ur e in pl ac es .1 0% as h, fr om si ng le gr an ul es to fr ag m en ts of co m pl et el y ca lc ifi ed /s il ic ifi ed st ru ct ur es ,< 10 μm - 60 0μ m bl oc ks . A rt ef ac ts : 10 % bo ne in cl ud in g la rg e fr ag m en t, 7% w it ho ut ,v ar io us st ag es of fr ag m en ta ti on an d al lc ol ou rs fr om re d to pa le ye ll ow ,1 00 μm –2 .5 cm ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ir re gu la r, at ta ck ed .R ed de ne d ed ge s to m an y. C on ce nt ra te d to w ar ds th e to p of th e un it .2 % fli nt ,a ng ul ar ,- su ba ng ul ar ,p la ty ,4 00 -8 00 μm lo ng . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) F in in g se qu en ce ne ar to p of un it – si lt y cl ay cr us ti ng ov er 1c m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% w el l- ro un de d ir on no du le s co nc en tr at ed at bo tt om ,1 0% .5 00 –1 50 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,s ha rp -d if fu se bo un da ri es . 3/ 4s of th es e ar e pe do re li ct s w it h cr os s- st ri at ed b- fa br ic s. F ab ri c: 1) C ru st fr ag m en ts 7% of sl id e, 0. 5- 1m m ,w el l- ro un de d to ro un de d, di st ur be d, co nc en tr at ed at th e ba se of th e un it an d al so to p le ft ha nd si de ,w he re th ey ar e li nk ed to in si tu fin in g se qu en ce /c ru st in g an d ar e su ba ng ul ar .2 ) 1% du ng le ns ,p al e ye ll ow sp on gy si lt w it h ph yt ol it hs – no sp he ru li te s. M ix ed oc cu pa ti on m at er ia li n m as s co ll uv ia lm ov em en ts , in co rp or at in g m at er ia l fr om el se w he re in th e ca ve w it h lo ca ll y re w or ke d m at er ia l. 20 15 :2 T hi ck ne ss : 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, cl ea r, in te rl ea ve d. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy .P or os it y: 10 % .7 % vu gh s, 50 –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,1 % sm oo th w al ls ,r es tr ou gh .3 % pl an ar vo id s, < 10 –1 00 μm w id e, in te rc on ne ct ed ,w el l- ac co m m od at ed . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 20 % qu ar tz ,5 0– 10 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r to an gu la r, w el l so rt ed .2 % li m es to ne ,2 00 –5 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d, w el l- so rt ed . C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 22 :8 0. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- or an ge (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d. R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 10 % ch ar re d m at er ia li rr eg ul ar bl oc ky ce ll st ru ct ur e, 10 0- 30 0μ m ,b lo ck y an d st ri ng er s. C ol lu vi al m ix in g of m at er ia li nc or po ra ti ng as h fr om ne ar by bu rn in g, po te nt ia ll y w et at po in ts . H F 08 /0 9- 20 15 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A76 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 20 15 :2 (c on t) A rt ef ac ts : 5% fli nt ,u p to 2m m bl oc ky pl at y- an gu la r, st ru ck ? 1% sh el l, an gu la r, pl at y ~5 00 μm .1 % bo ne ,o ra ng e bo th pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, w el l- ro un de d ~2 00 μm . P ed of ea tu re s: F ab ri c: 1) 50 % as h fa br ic gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e fr om ps eu do m or ph s. C on ta in s fu ll y an d pa rt ia ll y ch ar re d/ pa rt ia ll y as he d m at er ia l, 5% .2 ) 5% C ru st fr ag m en ts ,b lo ck y su ba ng ul ar to w el l- ro un de d 50 0μ m –3 m m ac ro ss ,s im il ar to 20 15 :3 .3 ) Ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s 5% w el lr ou nd ed 20 0– 60 0μ m ,d is ti nc te dg es ,s om e ve ry m uc h br ow ne r fr om ou ts id e – ar ou nd ha lf . (s ee ab ov e) 20 15 :3 T hi ck ne ss : 3– 4m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -w ea kl y/ m od er at e de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 0% vu gh s/ ch am be rs ,5 0– 30 0μ m ,r ou gh - w al le d, ir re gu la r to ho ri zo nt al .5 % co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, li nk ed vu gh s et c, 50 –1 00 μm ap ar t, ro ug h, po or ly ac co m m od at ed .5 % pl an ar vo id s - w el la cc om m od at ed ,r ou gh w al ls ,< 20 μm to 10 0μ m . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz 50 –1 00 μm ,w el ls or te d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky .1 % li m es to ne w el l- ro un de d 10 00 –2 00 μm bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 16 :8 4. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,6 3% si lt ,7 % sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: M in er al /o rg an ic .R ed -b ro w n( P P L ), re d( X P L ), du ll br ow n- or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% or ga ni c st ri ng er s, ch ar re d an d ca lc it e al on g w it h si li ca st ru ct ur es ,w ar pe d, fib ro us ,1 μm .H or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed .S in gl e cr os s- se ct io n th ro ug h tw ig or se ed ch ar re d, w it h ca lc it ic co nc re ti on s w it hi n th e vo id s. 10 % F in e sa nd si lt -s iz ed fr ag m en ts of ch ar re d or ga ni c th ro ug ho ut gi ve s m ac ro co lo ur .5 % L ar ge r fr ag m en ts of ch ar co al 5% 10 0– 30 00 μm ,a ng ul ar ,b lo ck y th ro ug ho ut po or ly so rt ed . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C ru st in g to w ar ds to p of un it – fin in g up ju st be lo w in te rf ac e. F ab ri c: 1) C ru st fr ag m en t5 % fr om un it be lo w ,1 m m , 20 0μ m w el l- ro un de d. S he et w as h of lo ca ll y- de ri ve d, fin e an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia l, pu dd li ng an d cr us ti ng ,f ol lo w ed by pe ri od of ex po su re an d di sr up ti on . 20 15 :4 T hi ck ne ss : 0. 8c m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: F in es fr om m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e to m as si ve /v es ic ul ar .P or os it y: 15 –0 % .1 0% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, 50 μm pe ds sm oo th ,i nt er co nn ec te d. 2% pl an ar vo id s w el la cc om m od at ed ,r ou gh -s m oo th ,1 0– 50 μm .3 % vu gh s in m or e m as si ve 10 0– 15 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,s m oo th . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 30 % qu ar tz ,1 00 μm ,t o fin e si lt si ze d, w el ls or te d in ar ea s, an gu la r/ bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 10 :9 0. 30 % cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,1 5% sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: M in er al ,r ed (P P L ), or an ge s an d re ds (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, gr an o- to cr os s- st ri at ed at ba se (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% fin e sa nd /s il ts iz ed bl oc ky ch ar co al 40 –1 00 μm .L ar ge r ch un ks 2% ,c el ls tr uc tu re am or ph ou s ch ar co al ,i rr eg ul ar de gr ad ed . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne ,1 la rg e fr ag m en t~ 3m m ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d, ye ll ow -o ra ng e (P P L ), ye ll ow s an d or an ge s (X P L ), ot he rs 40 0μ m ,w el l ro un de d. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L ar ge cr us ti ng /fi ni ng se qu en ce s, th in ne r at ba se ,3 -4 la ye rs in to ta l1 –2 m m th ic k. D efi ne s un it .C ry st al li ne : 1) L en se s of m ic ri ti c ca lc it e in pl an ar vo id s, 3% ,l ay in g on to p of fin in g se qu en ce ,1 –2 m m .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c st ai ni ng to to p pa rt s of cr us ts ,2 % ,1 00 μm . R ep ea te d sh ee tw as h of so il m at er ia l. 20 15 :5 T hi ck ne ss : 3m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di ff us e St ru ct ur e: V ug hy /m as si ve to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e. P or os it y: 15 % .7 % vu gh y 60 –2 00 μm ir re gu la r, ro ug h- sm oo th . 5% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, co nt in uu m fr om vu gh s. 10 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,p ed s ~8 0μ m ,3 % pl an ar vo id s, 10 μm –1 00 μm ,s m oo th w al ls , m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed . S m al l- sc al e co ll uv ia lm ov em en t of m at er ia la nd m ix in g of ne ar by an th ro po ge ni c an d bu rn tm at er ia l. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A77 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 20 15 :5 (c on t) C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –1 50 μm ,b lo ck y, an gu la r, w el l- so rt ed .3 0% li m es to ne sa nd an d gr av el 10 0μ m –1 m m .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 40 :6 0. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,6 0% si lt ,3 5% sa nd .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: R ed -b ro w n (P P L ), re d- go ld (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 7% ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia lw it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, an gu la r, bl oc ky w it h w ar pe d pr op or ti on – ‘s tr in ge rs of m at er ia l1 –2 m m lo ng ,b lo ck y, do w n to 40 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 5% bo ne or an ge to ye ll ow (P P L ), ye ll ow (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, su ba ng ul ar -s ub ro un de d, 25 0μ m –1 m m ,i rr eg ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C on ce nt ra ti on of fin e, cl ay ey m at er ia ls at ba se of un it .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) Ir on no du le s, di ff us e, sm oo th ed ge d 50 0– 12 00 μm ,1 0% .2 ) 2– 3% m an ga ne se ge ne ra ld en dr it ic st ai ni ng ,s om et im es as so ci at ed w it h or ga ni c m at te r, 15 0– 20 0μ m . 20 15 :6 T hi ck ne ss : 3– 4m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky m ic ro st ru ct ur e/ m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% vu gh s, so m e el on ga te d, ir re gu la r- ro ug h, 50 –5 00 μm ,5 % pl an ar vo id s ro ug h- sm oo th ,i rr eg ul ar ,i nt er co nn ec te d. 60 0μ m lo ng ,1 0– 30 μm w id e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz ,s ub an gu la r to an gu la r bl oc ky 50 –1 50 μm ,a ng ul ar .L im es to ne 3% 5m m –1 00 μm ,s ub ro un de d- su ba ng ul ar ,i rr eg ul ar sm oo th ne ss .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F li m it : 8: 92 .T ex tu re : 5% cl ay ,9 0% si lt ,5 % sa nd an d gr av el .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e or an ge -b ro w n (P P L ), pa le ye ll ow -g ol d (X P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le -s pe ck le d, m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic (6 0: 40 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 10 % fin e or ga ni c m at er ia ls il t– st ri ng er s, hz ,~ 10 μm th ic k, to 22 00 μm .l on g. F ib ro us ,c ha nn el .A ls o bl oc ky up to 10 0μ m an gu la r. A rt ef ac ts : N on e. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M or e po or ly so rt ed to ri gh to f sl id e. 2) S li gh tl am in at io ns in m at er ia l– le ns in g? C ol ou r an d te xt ur e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ir on -i m pr eg na te d si lt ag gr eg at es ,w el l- ro un de d, pa le or an ge 15 0– 50 0μ m . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed ,d efl at ed up pe r la ye r of bu rn in g ev en t. 20 15 :7 T hi ck ne ss : 65 –7 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: To p 2. 5c m ,v ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. B ot to m 4– 5c m ,v ug hy to sp on gy st ru ct ur e, do m in at ed by fib ro us / sp on gy st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % vu gh s. 15 % 50 –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh w al ls .2 0% vu gh s an d ch am be rs 50 –7 00 μm ,e lo ng at ed ,i rr eg ul ar ,p ar t of sp on gi ne ss . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz 50 –2 00 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t, w el l- so rt ed .2 % li m es to ne gr av el -fi ne sa nd 10 0μ m -2 .5 cm po or ly so rt ed ,s ub an gu la r- ro un de d bl oc ky .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 12 :8 8. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,6 3% si lt ,7 % sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: D ar ke r to w ar ds ba se ,p al e- m ed iu m br ow n (P P L ), ve ry da rk re d to un di ff er en ti at ed (X P L ), du ll br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - sp ec kl ed to al m os tc ro ss - to gr an os tr ia te d (8 0: 20 ). R el at ed di st ri bu it io n: O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 1) E nt ir e fa br ic is or ga ni c- hu m ic st ai ne d – br ow ni sh co lo ur .2 ) F ib ro us se m i- ch ar re d, se m i- hu m ifi ed m at er ia lo rg an ic in to p 1- 2c m ,o f fa br ic ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt ed ,a ll st ru ct ur e vi si bl e fr om 20 μm –3 30 0μ m th ic k, 1– 2m m lo ng . A rt ef ac ts : 5% di ss ol ve d bo ne 30 0μ m ,d ot te d w it h bl ac k ci rc le s. L en se s up to 2– 3m m lo ng ,c on ce nt ra te d in ce nt re of un it . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al :1 ) F ib ro us na tu re to gr ou nd m as s, m or e sp on gy to w ar ds th e ba se .2 ) S li gh tl am in at io n/ or ga ni sa ti on to th e fin e m at er ia l. C ry st al li ne : 1) 5% m ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll in e co nc en tr at io ns /v oi d in fil li ng s, 50 0– 60 0μ m .2 ) 3% st ra w -l ik e, fib ro us ca lc it e m in er al ,l in ke d to di ss ol ve d bo ne fr ag m en ts .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ir on no du le s/ pe do re li ct s, 5% w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p 20 0– 60 0μ m . F ab ri c: 10 % du ng le ns es ,s am e co lo ur as gr ou nd m as s, sp on gy ,v er y cl ay ey st ru ct ur e, ph yt ol it hs .1 –2 m m lo ng . H ea vi ly w ea th er ed ch ar co al la ye r at ba se of bu rn in g ev en t. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A78 2155:2 2155:1 2155:3 2155:4 2155:5 2155:6 2155:7 2155:8/9 2155:10 2155:11 2155:12 1cm Micro-fabric Micromorphological Description 2155:1 Thickness: 55m. Lower boundary: Prominent, sharp, interleaved Structure:Massive-vughy to weakly developed microaggregate granular structure. Platy area near top of unit – bioturbation and compaction. Porosity: 10%. 7% vughs/chambers 100μm–1mm, rough-walled, irregular. 3% planar voids ~1mm long, ~60μm, moderately accommodated semi-rough. Long drying cracks across slide. Coarse mineral components: 10% quartz, 50–150μm, subangular to subrounded, blocky, throughout. 15% limestone 100μm-32mm moderately sorted, mainly coarser at the top, fine sand at base of unit. Subrounded to subangular. CF limit: 50μm CF ratio: 25:75. 20% clay, 60% silt, 20% sand and gravel. Clay loam/silty clay loam. Fine material: Orange-red brown (PPL), red-gold (XPL), orange (OIL). b-fabric: Stipple-speckled. Related distribution: open porphyric Organic material: 5% charcoal, with micritic calcite infilling, blocky 1-6mm, small fragments, 300μm, angular, cell structure, some amorphous. Larger concentration towards base. Artefacts: 3–5% bone, orange to yellow (PPL), yellow (XPL), blocky-irregular, pitted and cracked 5mm–2500μm, larger mainly in finer base of unit. 1% flint, subrounded, platy, 2mm. 3% shell, subrounded to subangular, platy/irregular 1mm–500μm. Pedofeatures: Crystalline: 1) Micritic crystallitic groundmass towards the interface of F2, mixing. Amorphous and cryptocrystalline.: 1) 3% iron micro pans 50μm–1mm. 2) 10% iron well-rounded to diffuse, 150–700μm, well-rounded. 2) 3% manganese dendritic nodules 300μm, loose/ coarse. Fabric: 1) 2% vesicular silica, 1mm- 500μm, well-rounded fragments. 2) 1% crust fragments, warped-angular, 1.5mm– 500μm. 4) 3% dung pale yellow-grey silt , phytoliths, 2–3mm blocky/lenses elongated, horizontal orientation, 700μm –1mm. Interpretation Punctuated, wet colluvial movements of material. HF09-2155 Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A79 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :2 T hi ck ne ss : 25 –3 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r w it h so m e m ix in g. St ru ct ur e: G ra nu la r – as h, in pl ac es ce m en te d to ge th er .P or os it y: 20 % .5 % pl an ar vo id s 10 –5 0μ m w id e, ro ug h, w el la cc om m od at ed .1 0% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s < 10 μm be tw ee n gr an ul es ,i nt er co nn ec te d. 5% ch am be rs an d vu gh 10 0μ m –1 m m ,r ou gh -w al le d ir re gu la r. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 2% qu ar tz 10 0μ m bl oc ky ,s ub an gu la r. C F li m it : 10 0μ m .C F ra ti o: 2: 98 .T ex tu re : 98 % ca lc it ic si lt ,2 % fin e sa nd . S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: gr ey (P P L ), gr ey (X P L ), gr ey (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 5% ch ar re d an d pa rt ia ll y as he d m at er ia lr et ai ni ng ce ll st ru ct ur e, 1– 2m m . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,p al e ye ll ow (P P L ), gr ey s (X P L ), pl at y, pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, su ba ng ul ar 50 0– 70 0μ m ,n ea r to p of un it .1 % fli nt ,1 .5 m m , an gu la r, pl at y. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) 5% A re as of m or e de ns e m ic ri te .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 2% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, ~5 00 μm , ir re gu la r, li nk ed to in cl us io ns ,s ec on da ry .F ab ri c: 1) 10 % at ba se ,l es s at th e to p of th e un it ,c hu nk s of si lt y cl ay m at er ia l, ir re gu la r, w el l- de fin ed to sh ar p. 2) 2– 3% ir on no du le s/ bu rn ta gg re ga te s/ pe do re li ct s. 3) 2% du ng ,a tb as e of un it ir re gu la r, bl oc ky ,d if fu se ,n ea r co nt ac t 70 0– 12 00 μm ,a rt ic ul at e ph yt ol it hs w it hi n. S he et w as h ev en to f m at er ia l in co rp or at in g lo ca ll y de ri ve d an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia l. 21 55 :3 T hi ck ne ss : 5– 15 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, cl ea r, m ix ed . St ru ct ur e: M as si ve in ta ct fin in g se qu en ce ,v ug hy in ot he r pl ac es .P or os it y: 10 –2 5% .V ug hs an d ch am be rs 8– 20 % ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d, sl ig ht ly el on ga te d, 25 0μ m –1 m m .P la na r vo id s 2– 5% 30 μm –7 50 μm w id e, sm al le r ar e 0. 5– 1m m lo ng ,l ay er at ta ch ed to dr yi ng . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 10 % qu ar tz si lt si ze d 40 –2 00 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,s or te d in fin in g se qu en ce .5 % li m es to ne su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed ,3 00 –5 00 μm ,w el ls or te d. C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 15 :8 5. Te xt ur e: 15 % cl ay ,7 5% si lt ,1 0% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- gr ey (P P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (X P L ), ye ll ow -o ra ng e (O IL ). b- fa br ic : m ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic ,s ti pp le -s pe ck le d (9 0: 10 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 7% ch ar re d m at er ia l– ce ll st ru ct ur es et c, ot he r bi ts co ul d be pa rt ia ll y hu m ifi ed in st ea d/ as w el l, 50 μm –2 m m ,i rr eg ul ar ,s om e an gu la r, so m e ro un de d et c. fib re s an d ch un ks . A rt ef ac ts : 5% bo ne bu rn to ra ng e to ye ll ow 15 0μ m – 0. 7c m su ba ng ul ar ir re gu la r bl oc ky .1 % fli nt ,s ub ro un de d 60 0μ m ,p la ty . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M aj or fin in g se qu en ce to to p of un it ,d is tu rb ed in pl ac es .C ry st al li ne : 1) V ar yi ng am ou nt s of cr ys ta ll it ic m ic ri ti c gr ou nd m as s, sl ig ht ly ag gr eg at ed 5% bu ta ls o im pr eg na ti ng it in pl ac es .C on cr et io n to ge th er ,r ef or m in g w et /c om pr es si on .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 12 % ir on no du le s 50 μm –1 m m ,w el l- ro un de d, to w ar ds ba se 1 or 2 w hi ch ar e si m pl y th ic ke r ar ea s in -s it u. 10 % w el l- ro un de d. F ab ri c: 1) 1- 2m m as h di ff us e pa tc he s w it h cr ys ta ll it ic ps eu do m or ph s, li nk in to ca lc it e gr ou nd m as s. 10 % as so ci at ed w it h di st ur ba nc e. 2) 2% du ng 1m m ,p hy to li th s an d sp he ru li te s, di ff us e. B io tu rb at io n – bu rr ow cu tt in g un it . S he et w as h ev en to f m at er ia l in co rp or at in g lo ca ll y de ri ve d an th ro po ge ni c m at er ia l. 21 55 :4 T hi ck ne ss : 10 –1 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve to m od er at el y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e, ba se d on as h co nc re ti ng or no t. P or os it y: V ar ia bl e, 10 –4 0% . 10 –1 5% pl an ar vo id s, la rg e, co ve ri ng w ho le th in g, ho ri zo nt al or ie nt at io n to so m e in pl ac es fr om 10 –2 0μ m by 1m m ,t o 10 0μ m an d w id e cr ac ks . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 2% qu ar tz ,4 0– 25 0μ m su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky ,r ou nd ed is la rg er .2 % li m es to ne fin e gr av el -c oa rs e sa nd 30 0– 20 00 μm , su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 4: 96 .T ex tu re : 97 % si lt ,3 % sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: G re y (P P L ), gr ey s an d w hi te s (X P L ), gr ey (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 5% st ri ng er s of ch ar re d or ga ni c m at er ia lt o ba se of un it ,5 00 –1 50 0μ m lo ng ,h or iz on ta l. 5% ch ar re d m at er ia l, la rg e ch un k w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e in ce nt re of un it ,3 m m ,b lo ck y, re st is sm al le r, 20 0– 40 0μ m ,b lo ck y ce ll st ru ct ur e. 5% pa rt ia ll y as he d an d ch ar re d m at er ia l w it h ce ll st ru ct ur e, br ow n- bl ac k w it hi n fr ag m en ts of as h, 30 0– 80 0μ m . M ix in g an d sp re ad in g of as h on a dr y su rf ac e. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A80 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :4 (c on t.) A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne ,s ub an gu la r to su br ou nd ed ,b ur nt or an ge to ye ll ow ,p it te d an d cr ac ke d 30 0– 75 0μ m . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) L am in at io ns to ba se of un it .F ab ri c: 1) 15 % si lt y cl ay fr ag m en ts si m il ar to ir on no du le s bu tt he y ar e fr ag m en ts of a di ff er en tf ab ri c. 10 0μ m –0 .6 cm ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky to ro un de d- ir re gu la r. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) < 1% Ir on /m an ga ne se no du le , 50 0μ m ,r ou nd ,d if fu se . (s ee ab ov e) 21 55 :5 T hi ck ne ss : 3– 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : P ro m in en t, di st in ct . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m as si ve de pe nd in g on w he re yo u ar e in th e fin in g se qu en ce .P or os it y: 2– 15 % on fin in g se qu en ce . 2% pl an ar vo id s, < 10 μm , pe rp en di cu la r to su rf ac e cr us t. 0– 13 % vu gh y, 50 0– 80 0μ m ,h ol es fo r lo ts of th in gs ,1 % ve ge ta lv oi d sh ap e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % qu ar tz ,v er y fin e si lt si ze d 10 0μ m an gu la r to ro un de d bl oc ky .S or te d in to fin in g se qu en ce .2 % li m es to ne , 30 0– 60 0μ m ,w el lr ou nd ed ,b lo ck y ro un d. C F li m it : 60 μm .C F ra ti o: 17 :8 3. Te xt ur e: 30 % cl ay ,6 3% si lt ,7 % sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: O ra ng e- re d (P P L ), or an ge s an d re ds (X P L ), or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : S ti pp le - to m os ai c- sp ec kl ed (7 0: 30 ). R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 5% fr ag m en te d ch ar co al ,1 lo ng st ri ng er 1– 2m m ,6 0μ m th ic k, an gu la r, ot he rs sm al le r, 15 0μ m ,b lo ck y th ro ug ho ut . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) F in in g se qu en ce s de fin e un it ,h ea vi ly di st ur be d. C ry st al li ne : 1) M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic co at in g to ar ea of cr us ta tt he to p ~1 0μ m th ic k. F ab ri c: 1) A sh in vo id sp ac es . S he et w as h of ex te rn al so il m at er ia l. 21 55 :6 T hi ck ne ss : 1– 10 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : F ai nt ,d if fu se . St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e. P or os it y: 15 % .1 2% ch am be rs an d vu gh s, in te rc on ne ct ed ,8 0μ m – 1m m ,r ou gh w al ls .3 % pl an ar vo id s, sm oo th w al ls ,m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed ot he rs ro ug h. 10 –2 00 μm th ic k. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz 40 –1 20 μm su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky ,t hr ou gh ou t, 7% li m es to ne co ar se sa nd /v er y fin e gr av el , w el l- ro un de d- su br ou nd ed .2 50 μm –9 00 μm .N o or ie nt at io n, po or ly so rt ed .C F li m it : 40 μm .C F ra ti o: 12 :9 8. Te xt ur e: 10 % cl ay ,8 0% si lt 10 % sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n m ix ed w it h gr ey (P P L ), gr ey w it h br ow n ar ea s (X P L ), br ow n- gr ey (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic w it h so m e ir on st ai ni ng 5– 10 % .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 30 % ch ar re d bl oc ky m at er ia l, ce ll st ru ct ur es fr om di ff er en tp ar ts of th e pl an t, st ri ng er s, ho ri zo nt al ,s om e pa rt ia ll y as he d to o. A sh w it hi n gr ou nd m as s. 2% fu ll y as he d ce ll st ru ct ur e 75 0μ m ,b lo ck y. A rt ef ac ts : N on e. P ed of ea tu re s: F ab ri c: 1) 1% ir on no du le s 50 0μ m ,w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p. M ix ed as h, he ar th ra ke ou t/ cl ea ni ng m at er ia l. 21 55 :7 T hi ck ne ss : 10 –2 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy -m ic ro ag gr eg at e (m od er at el y de ve lo pe d) .P or os it y: 15 % .5 % vu gh s, 50 μm –5 00 μm ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 5% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, in te rc on ne ct ed ar ou nd as h cr ys ta ls .5 % pl an ar 30 μm –1 m m in te rc on ne ct in g, fr ag m en ta ti on of m at er ia l. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 2% qu ar tz 50 –1 20 μm su ba ng ul ar to ro un de d bl oc ky .5 % li m es to ne 25 0– 60 0μ m su ba ng ul ar -s ub ro un de d, no t in cl ud in g lo ad s of st uf f w hi ch lo ok s li ke as h m at er ia l. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .T ex tu re : 94 % si lt ,6 % sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: A sh .G re y (P P L ), gr ey s an d w hi te s (X P L ), gr ey (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: 3% C el ls tr uc tu re s, si li ca et c. S tr in ge rs of ch ar re d m at er ia la cr os s to p of un it li e in 21 55 :6 .5 % sm al lc ha rc oa lf ra gm en ts , bl oc ky 10 0< um . A rt ef ac ts : 3% bo ne 40 0– 60 0μ m ,y el lo w (P P L ), fr st or de r gr ey s (X P L ), su br ou nd ed ,i rr eg ul ar . O ne ca lc in ed fr ag m en t2 00 μm ,w el l- ro un de d. R e- de po si te d as h, po st - de po si ti on al ly ce m en te d by w et ti ng an d di sr up te d. Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A81 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :7 (c on t) P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) M ix in g w it h fa br ic be lo w to w ar ds ba se .2 ) In fil li ng cl ay ey si lt to vo id s on ri gh th an d si de ,s am e m at er ia la s 21 55 :5 ab ov e. A lm os tc om pl et e in fil li ng . A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ve si cu la r si li ca ag gr eg at e, w el l- ro un de d, qu an ti ty ,i so tr op ic / gr ey 60 0– 70 0μ m ,v es ic ul ar .2 ) 10 % ir on no du le s w el l- ro un de d. 50 μm -1 m m .F ab ri c: 1) 2% du ng ,p al e gr ey ye ll ow (P P L ), ph yt ol it hs ~4 m m , ir re gu la r, w el l- ro un de d. (s ee ab ov e) 21 55 :8 /9 T hi ck ne ss : 25 –3 0m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: U nd er ly in g m od er at el y- w ea kl y de ve lo pe d m ic ro ag gr eg at e to vu gh y/ m as si ve .S ub an gu la r bl oc ky in pl ac es /p la ty .P or os it y: 10 –2 0% . 7– 12 % vu gh s, 10 0– 50 0μ m ir re gu la r to ro ug h. C om po un d pa ck in g vo id s in m or e op en ar ea s, 5% on to p of th es e an d ch am be rs .3 % pl an ar vo id s up to la rg e dr yi ng cr ac ks fr om 20 μm x1 m m in te rc on ne ct ed /e lo ng at ed in vu gh s. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 5% qu ar tz 80 –1 50 μm su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .2 % li m es to ne gr av el -c oa rs e sa nd 1– 2m m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky .C F li m it : 80 μm .C F ra ti o: 7: 93 .T ex tu re : 5% cl ay ,8 8% si lt ,7 % sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: m in er al /a sh y. O ra ng e- gr ey (P P L ), or an ge s an d gr ey s (X P L ), or an ge -g re y (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : op en po rp hy ri c O rg an ic m at er ia l: A sh ca lc it e in th e w ho le th in g. 2% hu m ifi ed pl an ts tr uc tu re ,i rr eg ul ar /b lo ck y – ce ll st ru ct ur e ne ar to p of un it ,m ix ed in . A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,u nb ur nt ,1 00 μm ,b lo ck y, ye ll ow (P P L ) pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, an gu la r- su ba ng ul ar . P ed of ea tu re s: C ry st al li ne : 1) 5% M ic ri ti c cr ys ta ll it ic in fil li ng s to vo id s or si m pl y a th in ne r ar ea of th e sl id e. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) Tw o la rg e ir on an d ca lc it e no du le s, ro un d, pr ob ab ly in si tu ,1 –1 50 0μ m .2 ) 2% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le s al on g cr ac k/ lo os e gr av el , ~3 00 μm el on ga te d. 3) 3% ir on no du le s, w el l- ro un de d 10 0μ m –1 m m . W el l- m ix ed as h an d si lt fr om he av il y bi ot ur ba te d an d w ea th er ed bu rn in g ev en t. 21 55 :1 0 T hi ck ne ss : 25 –3 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, di ff us e. St ru ct ur e: V ug hy to w ea kl y de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e – vu gh y/ fib ro us to ba se .S po ng ie r to ba se m ic ro ag gr eg at e to w ar ds th e to p. P or os it y: 15 % .1 2% vu gh s, 10 0– 75 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar ,r ou gh -w al le d. 3% pl an ar vo id s, in te rc on ne ct in g fr om 60 00 μm to cm sc al e. C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 7% qu ar tz (c .1 % fe ld sp ar ) su ba ng ul ar to su br ou nd ed bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut ,5 0μ m –1 00 μm .5 % li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd 2m m -5 0μ m ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar co nc en tr at io n to w ar ds ba se of un it ,l in ke d to gr ad ua ls hi ft .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 12 :8 8. Te xt ur e: 25 % cl ay ,6 8% si lt ,7 % sa nd .S il ty cl ay lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), da rk re d- br ow n (X P L ), du ll da rk re d- br ow n (O IL ). b- fa br ic : st ip pl e- sp ec kl ed .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : O pe n po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: F ab ri c se em s or ga ni c st ai ne d – to w ar ds ba se sp on gy .A ti nt er fa ce ,5 % fib ro us ch ar re d or ga ni cs . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bo ne ,c on ce nt ra te d to up pe r th ir d, 45 0μ m –1 m m ,s ub an gu la r bl oc ky ,o ra ng e- ye ll ow (P P L ), or an ge s an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), bu rn t. 2) 2% pa rt ia ll y di ss ol ve d bo ne ,5 00 0μ m in fil li ng vo id s 2% ir re gu la r, m an ga ne se do tt in g. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) C ha ng e in m ic ro st ru ct ur e, vu gh y/ sw ir ly to ba se ,m ic ro ag gr eg at e to w ar ds th e to p. A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ir on no du le s, w el l- ro un de d, 10 0μ m .F ab ri c: 1) du ng /p al e si lt y le ns es ,n o ph yt ol it hs ,2 –3 m m w id e, 10 0μ m th ic k, 3% m ai n co nc re ti on at to p of lo w er ha lf . V er y he av il y w ea th er ed ch ar co al la ye r at ba se of bu rn in g ev en t. 21 55 :1 1 T hi ck ne ss : 40 m m .L ow er bo un da ry : D is ti nc t, sh ar p. St ru ct ur e: M as si ve -m od er at el y de ve lo pe d ir re gu la r gr an ul ar m ic ro st ru ct ur e. A lm os tp la ty in pl ac es ,c om pr es si on .P or os it y: 20 % 7% pl an ar vo id s 10 μm –1 00 μm cm sc al e to vu gh s, ro ug h w al le d, w el l- ac co m m od at ed .7 % ch am be rs /v ug hs 10 0μ m –5 00 μm ir re gu la r, ro ug h- w al le d. 5% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, co nt in uu m w it h vu gh s, sa m e si ze cl as s, ir re gu la r. P er io d of ro of -s pa ll in g fo ll ow ed by bi ot ur ba ti on an d m ix in g w it h 21 55 :1 0. L at er w ea th er ed by pe rc ol at io n of ca rb on at e- ri ch w at er . Appendix Five: Full Micromorphological Descriptions A82 M ic ro - fa br ic M ic ro m or ph ol og ic al D es cr ip ti on C om m en ts an d In te rp re ta ti on 21 55 :1 1 (c on t) C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 40 % li m es to ne gr av el to fin e sa nd .5 0μ m –3 m m ir re gu la r an gu la r to su br ou nd ed .P oo rl y so rt ed ,n o or ie nt at io n. M ai nl y co ar se si lt . 7% qu ar tz su ba ng ul ar to an gu la r bl oc ky ,5 0– 15 0μ m ,t hr ou gh ou t. C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 47 :5 3. Te xt ur e: 5% cl ay ,5 5% si lt ,4 5% sa nd an d gr av el .S an dy si lt lo am . F in e m at er ia l: B ro w n (P P L ), ye ll ow s (X P L ), du ll gr ey -b ro w n (O IL ). b- fa br ic :M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : cl os e po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: 2% ch ar re d/ bl ac k, ce ll st ru ct ur e 2m m ,o bl iq ue ,a ng ul ar .T ow ar ds to p of un it ,5 % hu m ifi ed /i ro n re pl ac ed ,p ar ti al ly ch ar re d m at er ia l. 20 0– 50 0μ m . A rt ef ac ts : 2% bu rn tb on e 10 0– 80 0μ m ,i rr eg ul ar to su ba ng ul ar ,o ra ng e- re d pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d. 2% fli nt ,r ou nd ed to su ba ng ul ar .2 –1 m m .2 % sh el l, an gu la r to pl at y, 30 00 μm –1 m m ,h or iz on ta ll y or ie nt at ed . P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) to p 1– 2c m is co ns id er ab ly le ss gr it ty th an th e re st of th e un it .C oa rs er th an ab ov e th ou gh .2 ) S tr uc tu re be co m es al m os tp la ty to w ar ds ba se .C ry st al li ne : 1) 1% he av il y de gr ad ed li m es to ne fr ag m en t/ co nc en tr ic cm ic ri ti c ca lc it ic no du le ,1 –2 m m ,r ou nd ed . A m or ph ou s & cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 5% ir on no du le s, 10 0– 20 0μ m ,v er y da rk ,w el l- ro un de d, sh ar p. 2) 2% de nd ri ti c m an ga ne se no du le s, 25 0μ m ,o rg an ic m at er ia la nd lo os e ar ea s. (s ee ab ov e) 21 55 :1 2 T hi ck ne ss : 5m m .L ow er bo un da ry : N on e. St ru ct ur e: W el l- de ve lo pe d gr an ul ar m ic ro ag gr eg at e st ru ct ur e to su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky /p la ty .P or os it y: 20 % .1 5% co m po un d pa ck in g vo id s, 40 –1 00 iu m w id e, in te rl in ki ng ,r ou gh w al ls m od er at el y ac co m m od at ed .5 % vu gh s 15 00 μm –2 00 μm ,r ou gh w al ls . C oa rs e m in er al co m po ne nt s: 15 % li m es to ne co ar se sa nd 10 0– 80 0μ m ,s ub ro un de d to su ba ng ul ar .5 % qu ar tz ,5 0– 10 0μ m su ba ng ul ar bl oc ky th ro ug ho ut .C F li m it : 50 μm .C F ra ti o: 20 :8 0. Te xt ur e 10 % cl ay ,7 3% si lt ,1 7% sa nd .S il tl oa m . F in e m at er ia l: P al e br ow n (P P L ), re ds an d ye ll ow s (X P L ), du ll or an ge (O IL ). b- fa br ic : M ic ri ti c ca lc it ic cr ys ta ll it ic .R el at ed di st ri bu ti on : C lo se po rp hy ri c. O rg an ic m at er ia l: N on e. A rt ef ac ts : 1% bo ne ,y el lo w (P P L ), gr ey s (X P L ), pi tt ed an d cr ac ke d, 20 0μ m ,s ub an gu la r. P ed of ea tu re s: Te xt ur al : 1) ‘c ut s’ th ro ug h bl oc ky pa rt s of fa br ic ,i s th is al lc om pl et el y bi ot ur ba te d? C ry st al li ti c: 1) 5% ca lc it ic co at in gs ~8 0μ m ar ou nd li m es to ne fr ag m en ts .A m or ph ou s an d cr yp to cr ys ta ll in e: 1) 10 % Ir on st ai ni ng ,m ic ro pa ns /s tr in ge rs ov er pr in ti ng C aC O 3 gr ou nd m as s in le ss bi ot ur ba te d ar ea 1– 2m m lo ng .2 ) 1% m an ga ne se de nd ri ti c no du le 60 0μ m ,l oo se fa br ic . H ea vi ly bi ot ur ba te d an d ca lc it e- im pr eg na te d th ro ug h w et ti ng . P ot en ti al ly 21 55 :1 1 re w or ke d or a se pa ra te co nt ex t.